she sung alto in her choir which would be mostly mezzo sopranos in classical music terms. mezzos/altos tend to sound better in their middle voice, like jisoo from blackpink.
@@arriek.1375Giselle is not a mezzo, she has a very light timbre, the closest to a mezzo would be Karina, who sounds the fullest out of all of them, but even Karina is just a chesty soprano.
I really love how Giselle is not just good as a rapper but also a good lyricist. Synk, Zoo, and then this. Waiting for more masterpieces from her, I just hope that SM utilize her talent in writing her own rap verse
and up to now we have Keep Going, Lips (rap part), especially DOPAMINE (her newest concert solo stage) that she composed and co-composed .... We never stop being proud of our talented Gigi
@@re2ema well, if you read the lyrics of the song, it's simply about taking a second to relax and enjoy life and the people around you... Then Bibi's lyrics start talking about how koreans have to work all the time, like working bees... Giselle's lyrics just continue on the same vibe of the song, light and positive, that's why they make more sense to me But it's ok if you disagree
@@GhostCatFromHell My question was because I read the lyrics. You didn't get Bibi's part right. Korean lifestyle is so exhausting. The priority is always to work or study. You must've heard about students suicide because of exams! So Hyoyeon's message here for them is to slow down and take a break "second". She's literally talking to Koreans, and that's why Bibi mentioned the stereotype of their lifestyle. I actually didn't read the lyrics until I saw a Korean comment thanking Hyo for the song saying it has a great message. However Giselle did a great job too. I'm impressed of the fact that she wrote it herself.
@@re2ema I did get Bibi's part, hence my previous comment. But the song doesn't mention korean lifestyle explicitly... It could be about the lifestyle of people in a lot of countries, or just about a specific person. That's why Bibi's part seems kinda out of place for me, while Giselle's part seems more coherent with the rest of the song.
@@re2ema i mean maybe giselle took it in another explanation coz bibi already did the deeper version. And i love both but giselle made it refreshing plus her tone and rap suits the vibe of the song more to me.
you can tell that she's a good rapper because even when you thought that the original version was better,you couldn't believe that there's more better than the original and giselle wrote it and sang it
small vocals are magical... I herd different vocals frm idol group but SM Hits different . It's eargasm vibes one thing I like frm the rest was SM vocals uses different sounds and technique that's probably why you.
See SM, how good she is. Give my girl more chances. She deserves more lines and opportunities. She always gets overshadowed for no reason at all. She is gifted af. Don't waste it.
I love my girl Bibi but Gigis ver. is just more smooth and relaxing! Giselle is super talented, when i found out that she not only sang, danced, rapped but also wrote and produced i was just so shocked, how can a new idol in the industry be so talented?! SM needs to give her a chance to show her true skills, not only short verses, she still ate tho! QUEEN!
She showed her talent in Synk, but sm doesn't let her show her lyric and rap skills as the song producing has been withheld from sm artists, which is sth sm has been doing w other artists as well. This is why Giselle said in the daebak show that she has lost the feeling of doing music, she misses that enthusiasm SM should do better for creative and talented artists like Giselle and allow them to show their skills
Okk woww it just giselle low notes and the lyric are just RICH!!!! I like giselle better,this is not biases...i like bibi first and she is my fav solo artist before i know giselle😌so yeah giselle own this
