Тёмный
No video :(

Blonde 

Georg Rockall-Schmidt
Подписаться 305 тыс.
Просмотров 41 тыс.
50% 1

The only reason I got around to finally watching "Blonde" was because it was panned by audiences, and because it was written and directed by Andrew Dominik, who directed "Chopper," which is a film that I really like. If you go back and you read articles from before "Blonde" came out, about "Blonde," they all say that it's going to be a Marilyn Monroe biopic, and it's also going to be Netflix's first NC 17 rated film, and will therefore be full of sexy simulated sexiness. FWAHHH. Sex! By its frosty reception I thought "Blonde" would be a sexploitation cash-in full of misogyny. Here, in this video, I am arguing that "Blonde" is actually a masterpiece, and is not unlike "Chopper" in what it is doing. And, like "Chopper," is easily misinterpreted as celebrating what it is, in fact, criticizing.
Patreon: / georgrockallschmidt
Twitter: / grockallschmidt

Опубликовано:

 

27 авг 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 398   
@edwardhannah8507
@edwardhannah8507 Год назад
I'm surprised nobody has made a proper documentary or movie about Louise Brooks. She was going to be the next IT girl of Hollywood in the 1920's but after making a hand full of movies for them, she quit. When asked years later why she quit, she basically said "they're perverts and a**holes." The casting couch has been around for 100 years.
@iamcasihart
@iamcasihart Год назад
As long as men have existed they have preyed upon women, sought to oppress, control, manipulate, and use women. It’s repugnant.
@adampeters7947
@adampeters7947 10 месяцев назад
Yes, Brooks deserves a film. But not a crap one. Something really special
@casbyness
@casbyness 4 месяца назад
Ditto for Ally Sheedy, who after Breakfast Club and Short Circuit had a genuine 'invite to the big leagues' but turned it down the instant she learned what said invite entailed. Contrast with Eva Green, who resisted Hollywood for roughly a decade due to full knowledge of what joining it would mean, but then went ahead anyway.
@cjc2010
@cjc2010 Год назад
You convinced me to watch Blonde when you said it wasn’t a biopic.
@ashkuigp
@ashkuigp Год назад
Fuck m8. Between Blonde and the Road, i would rewatch the Road. Be warned.
@EstebanGunn
@EstebanGunn Год назад
To me, Blonde is one of those cases where I admire it a lot more than I like it.
@droopy_eyes
@droopy_eyes 5 месяцев назад
Thought provoking. Films used to be that.
@MrJfairbrother
@MrJfairbrother Год назад
I didn't love Blonde as much as Georg does, though I have to admire that someone took as big and bold a swing as Dominik does. I personally wish it were shorter, as the extended run-time meant I eventually became numb to the suffering, which diluted the final impact and tested my patience. But I must agree that a lot of the criticism felt naïve or disingenuous. Accusations of pretension are, I say, a matter of taste; the cries of exploitation aren't necessarily invalid but do often feel misguided and reductive; and the hate for de Armas' lead performance, in particular, felt unfair; some of these attacks even seemed to affirm many ideas the movie touched upon (like how female actors end up becoming targets for projected prejudices, or mere symbols/objects for the work of men).
@SpongeBobaFett
@SpongeBobaFett Год назад
This has to be one of the most eloquently put RU-vid comments I've ever read. It's refreshing to see people with more than a dozen brain cells perusing this website
@alexp.4270
@alexp.4270 Год назад
​@@SpongeBobaFett the video and the whole comment section are refreshing.
@Happytrooper6
@Happytrooper6 Год назад
I agree with a lot of the points made previously. I agree with becoming numb to the violence. If the intended effect was to crete empathy apathy was achieved. The idea to drive home the point that hollywood indeedly does exploit women, by exploiting one on screen seems like a really juvenile strategy at best. My personal biggest peeve with this film is that it tries to convey exploitation by exploiting this womans story trough the selective use of facts when it suits the films needs. And some film bros will say: "grow up this is what it is" or "dont hide the fact your IQ isnt high enough to get it, behind moralizing" or even worst of all: "she is dead while this problem is very much alive and well so it is permissible". Those arguments just reek of "to make great art everything goes." This is how you get a Kubrik for example traumatizing his actress, which while a different kind of exploitation is also very alive and well. And yes dead people can and are exploited for their name and recognition. I just dont see why it had to be about this real person in particular other than brand recognition. I think that a lot of the vitriol comes from this aspect.
@MrJfairbrother
@MrJfairbrother Год назад
@@Happytrooper6 - this gave me pause as well. Watching Blonde, I knew full-well that it was fiction built on scraps of reality - and I'm OK with that, generally. But I also had enough pre-existing knowledge of the historical figures shown here, and the context of their times, to pick many instances where the movie lies about them (and, usually, to understand the creative reasoning behind the lie, too). Not everyone will have that same context and, at the risk of sounding like a pompous snob, there'll always be uncritical viewers who just believe what they're shown to be true. While I'd be loathe to argue that storytellers should always play down to the hypothetical ignorance of That Idiot in the Crowd, it makes me wonder where that line of responsibility truly lays. Monroe herself isn't alive to be hurt by the film; her iconography is so ubiquitous already that I don't think it will be hurt by Blonde, either. The point of the movie is to juxtapose our collective image of Marilyn, a nostalgic-comedic-romantic-sexual fantasy (and a product designed, manufactured, and sold to us by rich white men for their own gain), against our denied collective knowledge of how she died. Whether this is truly deep or not is eye-of-the-beholder stuff. Ditto whether it's morally justifiable: if it's a tragedy that a real person named Norma Jean was crushed by the enormity of the invented Monroe persona (and the men who benefited from it), then is it right for the movie Blonde to do the same thing, and add outright untruths on top of that? Even if this perspective is born of compassionate empathy, genuinely attempting to "take her side" from an expressionistic point of view rather than a factual one? In a nutshell: Blonde does exploit the hell out of Monroe, but her iconography is big enough to stand it - no harm, no foul, I wanna say. But I also have to admit that's a flimsy moral defence. What annoyed me most was how much of the criticism came off as simplistic "no, a Monroe movie should be cute and fun," or "any movie that depicts exploitation is exploitation" toss, when (as you've shown) there's a much more nuanced debate to be had.
@whodatboi2567
@whodatboi2567 Год назад
From what I gather, your hypothesis is that a large reason why this film was panned is that it refused to romanticize Marilyn Monroe and present her as the iconic figure that she is seen as today. That's quite a bold take and this video has presented an interesting perspective of this film that I haven't heard from anyone else.
@TheFlash-rh2el
@TheFlash-rh2el Год назад
Apparently it scared a high number of men but not so many women. It’s a strange film. It’s a film that dares the audience to look away from the atrocities shown, to the point where the final shot refuses to end despite Marilyn being gone.
@YourBlackLocal
@YourBlackLocal Год назад
@@TheFlash-rh2el Huh? Tons of woman panned it too. Their criticism was that it was exploitative, especially when many of these things didn’t happen to her.
@TheFlash-rh2el
@TheFlash-rh2el Год назад
@@YourBlackLocal No, as I’m scared like a horror film should. Whereas a lot of female audience members didn’t hear the language and saw it as exploitative.
@WobblesandBean
@WobblesandBean Год назад
​​@@YourBlackLocal That's what my issue is with the film. It's just uncomfortable, like Dominic was getting off on seeing this icon getting tortured over and over. I get that her life was not glamorous and it needs to be known, but he didn't need to invent things that didn't happen. Her life was plenty full of pain on its own. To make stuff up just seems unfair, and tarnishes Monroe's life and memory. The film was supposed to fight back against the fictional image of Monroe and to stop exploiting her, but fails to do so because it does the exact same thing, just in the opposite extreme.
@Roberta-my7qr
@Roberta-my7qr 11 месяцев назад
I thought it was just another disgusting commodificattion of a severely victimized person. I see it differently now.
@AtunSheiFilms
@AtunSheiFilms Год назад
Nice to hear you talk about this movie, Georg. I loved it too and found a lot of the criticism of it kinda baffling. It reminded me of “Inside” by Bo Burnham, a raw representation of what it means to be on display… the audience sees a performer on stage bathed in angelic light - it looks amazing up there on stage, it’s something to aspire to, never realizing that the performer’s view is a thousand dark, inscrutable faces, hungrily appraising, demanding to be sated. there’s something deeply sinister about that.
@GeorgRockallSchmidt
@GeorgRockallSchmidt Год назад
Word. Cheers mate
@frenchguitarguy1091
@frenchguitarguy1091 Год назад
Holy cheese two of my favourites
@frenchguitarguy1091
@frenchguitarguy1091 Год назад
Also bush did fort Sumter, it's all in the papers OPEN YOUR EYES LINCOLNITE
@gavinmillar816
@gavinmillar816 Год назад
What a lovely surprise you two are friends and both like Blonde too.
@CivilDefenceCanada
@CivilDefenceCanada Год назад
I love Georg's assessments. You've said what I couldn't. This was a dirty, gross movie about a dirty, gross time and the horror of living with psychological damage while being the focus of attention. I think in time this will be viewed very much like others that weren't well understood at the time.
@iain2080
@iain2080 Год назад
Fair play for giving it a fair shake. I like Andrew Dominik, Killing Them Softly is also great. I hope like S Craig Zahler's "Dragged Across Concrete" that Blonde doesn't put a pause on his career.
@Aivottaja
@Aivottaja Год назад
I'm all right with his career freezing completely.
@iain2080
@iain2080 Год назад
@Aivottaja this new puritan crowd you're a part of that thinks representing something negative on screen is as bad as actually committing that act is wild. It's a mentality that's strangling the arts, people were filming more outré stuff in the 70s ffs.
@Aivottaja
@Aivottaja Год назад
@@iain2080 Cool story bro.
@MitchellHammond
@MitchellHammond Год назад
@@Aivottaja Helluva rebuttal.
@GeorgRockallSchmidt
@GeorgRockallSchmidt Год назад
Banning Mark Twain. Nuff said.
@DThron
@DThron Год назад
Oh my god it's so refreshing to see this; easily my favorite film from last year. Stunning and heartbreaking, and not about Marylin - but about us. A film about how we smother our true selves under a fictional self? Anyone on social media should be familiar with this problem, but it's not surprising we hated it. Thanks very much for this terrific breakdown.
@daltonbedore8396
@daltonbedore8396 Год назад
yes the egos initiial reaction to an honest mirror is often to dismiss or demonize the mirror. And much of humanity is guided purely by their ego
@DThron
@DThron Год назад
@@daltonbedore8396 100%
@iamcasihart
@iamcasihart Год назад
I show all my real self online, just as I do in “real life.” I do not curate a jolly, perfect online persona. I’ve never felt compelled to do that. In fact, I feel called to reveal as much of my suffering and adversities as I do my pleasure and triumphs.
@KalelSonOfDurel
@KalelSonOfDurel Год назад
From the marketing, I'd have never guessed this film was so deep.
@t.z2359
@t.z2359 Год назад
"Want to make an audience scared, talking fetuses is always the way to do it" Vivid flash backs to "Looks Who's Taking".
@NetanyahooWarCriminal
@NetanyahooWarCriminal Год назад
Is that the one where the family goes on vacation but they leave the fetus at home and he has to fend off the burglars with traps?
@kennethc2466
@kennethc2466 Год назад
M'ber the 'sperm race' scene in the beginning?
@Craxin01
@Craxin01 Год назад
@@kennethc2466 I M'ber! I also m'ber my then 8 months pregnant aunt saying, "kill them, kill them all," at the CGI sperm.
@BradLancaster86
@BradLancaster86 Год назад
That movie traumatized me when I realised John Travolta was up in the sky flying planes around. He actually has a pilots license.
@BradLancaster86
@BradLancaster86 Год назад
@@kennethc2466 I was first the day I was conceived. Your ether first or your last.
@lizhasasthma
@lizhasasthma Год назад
I feel like this film would've gotten a lot less criticism if it had been purely fictional. Making a movie where the main character is a real person and is about their life gives at least some expectation that it's going to be an accurate portrayal. Obviously a lot of straight biopics have inaccuracies for the sake of storytelling, but Blonde makes up a some major events (the tub drowning, the throuple). While people who knew her speculated that she had multiple abortions, there's zero evidence that Marilyn Monroe ever had one, while there is evidence that she had fertility problems. On its own the story is good, and I do like the idea of a movie exploring they way old hollywood exploited actors, but the fact that it makes up portions of a real person's life cheapens it to me. It feels like Marilyn Monroe's name is only attached to the whole thing because they knew it would make them more money than to tell an original story (which they're basically doing anyway).
@carly7522
@carly7522 Год назад
Thats exactly why i wont watch it. I already avoid biopics like the plague because they are barely trying to tell a true story. Whyvtell a story about the exploitation of a woman, about the trauma it inflicts and tell it about Monroe without her side or even basic facts? Nah, glad Georg had a good time but this just Lampshading: The Movie.
@nuance9000
@nuance9000 Год назад
Comment first, ask questions later?
@rixx46
@rixx46 Год назад
Georg's perspective of BLONDE is far more interesting and entertaining than the movie. I wish I had seen the same movie he did. I saw a self-indulgent mess. But now I have to watch it again -- damn it!
@fredbloggs5902
@fredbloggs5902 Год назад
The real tragedy of this film is that many who see it will think it IS a biopic.
@barrie5224
@barrie5224 Год назад
Nice to see an analysis of a film I only heard terrible reviews of, some of the best videos essays I've watched are about films that failed. I probably won't watch as I'm not good with this type of film and would find it too upsetting.
@raquetdude
@raquetdude Год назад
HIGHLY recommend Caleb Gammans video on it. He had a great coverage piece on it from an incredibly underrated channel. Different approach than this video
@kennethc2466
@kennethc2466 Год назад
It was pure anguish porn, save your time and happiness.
@jackdeath
@jackdeath Год назад
The problem with Blonde is that it's a complete work of fiction that clashes with the real life of Marilyn Monroe too much. Not only is the main protagonist unreliable, so is the film, playing loose with facts and popular conspiracy theories about her life, image, and death. All the usual nonsense to sensationalize a former icon to make another buck.
@EggBastion
@EggBastion Год назад
22:37
@meursault7030
@meursault7030 Год назад
I went from being reluctant to watch Blonde because I heard it was bad, to being reluctant to watch Blonde because it sounds fucking terrifying. Psychedelic horror really gets to me.
@warlock12uk
@warlock12uk Год назад
I haven't seen (or indeed even heard of) Blonde, but from your description it seems to share thematic similarities with Nicolas Roeg's Insignificance (1985). The central conceit of that film is the meeting of Monroe, Albert Einstein, Joe DiMaggio and Joseph McCarthy in a New York hotel, all presented in a slightly surreal manner with excellent performances from Tony Curtis, Gary Busey and Theresa Russell. Like Blonde, it is not your typical popcorn munching Hollywood movie and expects audiences to have a little more cognitive ability than usual. Thank you for bringing Blonde to my attention. I shall seek it out.
@GeorgRockallSchmidt
@GeorgRockallSchmidt Год назад
That sounds familiar, I’ll check it out. Thanks.
@sigspearthumb3249
@sigspearthumb3249 Год назад
Expecting an audience to have some cognitive ability... What was he thinking?!
@billhawkins5633
@billhawkins5633 Год назад
It’s quite interesting to watch Georg’s take on this movie and then immediately turn around and watch BeKindRewind’s review. You can tell that for the former, the surrealist nightmare and refusal to externalize the mythology of Monroe is the point and the appeal. For the latter, it’s the downfall.
@NaliniKluth
@NaliniKluth Год назад
Blonde is a masterpiece. The novel by Joyce Carol Oates on which it is based is even better. In contrast to Dominic's statement, the movie follows the book closely.
@Luraldir_Original
@Luraldir_Original Год назад
I'd not heard about this film but sounds very interesting, I'll give it a watch when I'm feeling too happy for my own good
@ScowlieMeerkat
@ScowlieMeerkat Год назад
Thank you, your soulful analysis of this deep and challenging film has really put me in the mood for some G Fuel.
@stankythecat6735
@stankythecat6735 Год назад
I just moved to NYC. That opening shot of Hollywood at night…was disturbing. Before I lived in nyc I lived in the Hollywood hills and had almost the same view. Hollywood haunts me
@wingflanagan
@wingflanagan Год назад
My first reaction to _Blonde_ was to dismiss it as suffer-porn. Watching it, I felt like I was in hell. Didn't like it; turned it off after an hour or so. The sex scenes weren't even slightly sexy, even when fairly graphic, so I couldn't even put my conscience on hold and just enjoy it for prurient reasons (don't judge me; it _is_ just a movie). But you have convinced me to give it another shot. After all, I had to give _Blue Velvet_ a second chance, too, as it initially repelled me. I'll give it another go. Thanks for the thoughtful review! EDIT: Oh, the irony! I just re-read my comment and it's unintentionally meta. Makes me feel slimy, because it seems I'm among those the film is critiquing - thinking of it as "just a movie" and the possibility of enjoying it for "prurient" reasons with my conscience shut off. That attitude is exactly the problem. That attitude, both as a consumer and a maker of films, is what fosters the environment that creates the Marilyn Monroes of the world. Yeah, I'll definitely be putting myself through a second watch.
@GeorgRockallSchmidt
@GeorgRockallSchmidt Год назад
I still haven’t gotten through Blue Velvet. I’ll give it another shot as well. And thanks for the comment- give it another go. Cheers.
@AnthonyFlack
@AnthonyFlack Год назад
@@GeorgRockallSchmidt - I can't imagine bailing part way through Blue Velvet; what did it?
@fredbloggs5902
@fredbloggs5902 Год назад
Blonde is like Schindler’s List, in that everyone should see it, but once will probably be enough for most people.
@sebs-shenanigans
@sebs-shenanigans Год назад
Well, I never cared for that film Now I wanna watch it
@YourBlackLocal
@YourBlackLocal Год назад
I feel like nobody in the comments is comprehending that many of these things didn’t happen. Don’t use a popular figure and then be shocked when people are upset it’s not actually about that popular figure and is instead an overly generalised look at exploitation.
@dontbefatuousjeffrey2494
@dontbefatuousjeffrey2494 Год назад
There's also a a fine line between looking at exploitation, and being exploitative. I'm not talking about Ana de Armas. Obviously, this is about Monroe - and about depictions of women in film in general. Personally, I was really disappointed in Dominik (having already struggled through Carol Oates's book some years ago). This felt out of date and less Blonde than blind. Times have changed. Dominik should stick to movies about blokes, if this is what he does with one about a woman. He's superb at films.... about blokes.
@billhicks8
@billhicks8 Год назад
oh believe me, we're not shocked...
@keyser9537
@keyser9537 Год назад
No, you are not comprehending that using this specific popular figure is the whole point of the film. It is about the fact that she is a popular figure and the very dark side of what this meant for her. And most of those things did happen, just not in the way they are shown, because they are shown through a sub-conscious and surrealistic lens. The film does not deny reality, it's exploring what's behind it.
@halsinden
@halsinden Год назад
not a single offer of a can of hiptang.
@Felix_Schmitz
@Felix_Schmitz Год назад
I thank you for your take! I was conflicted about how much I liked or disliked the film because every scene had an impact on me but I didn't go out satisfied with the film. This perspective puts my feelings more or less in order. I am happy to have watched the full length but I think rewatching it would need a good reason.
@kyledelabear7091
@kyledelabear7091 Год назад
This is refreshing after seeing YMS just mock the movie repeatedly for his whole watch along because "movie bad". I didn't come away with nearly as much to think about as I did here
@lebadass
@lebadass Год назад
Damnit George are you seriously gonna make me watch Blonde! 😂
@bennygerow
@bennygerow Год назад
Adrien and Denzel are my favorite actors, and I'll watch anything they do. Thanks for including the Chopper background. That got my interest.
@unsungscandal9576
@unsungscandal9576 Год назад
What did you think of the Assassination of Jesse James by the Coward Robert Ford? Personally, it’s among my absolute favorite movies ever made.
@thedudeabides3138
@thedudeabides3138 Год назад
Terrific essay Georg, well done. You gave me a compelling enough reason to check this out, even though I know I won’t enjoy it in a conventional sense.
@chuckliquor3663
@chuckliquor3663 Год назад
Poor Norma Jean.
@anthonymcken6050
@anthonymcken6050 Год назад
I bought a lava lamp because of you.
@djobnoxious6407
@djobnoxious6407 Год назад
As always, great, outstanding content. Does Georg have an IMDB watchlist or a Letterboxd? I find it difficult to find interesting movies, and I bet he has a nice selection, his taste being what it is.
@-xirx-
@-xirx- Год назад
Ive always found his 12 films for Christmas lists a good place for inspiration
@Crispman_777
@Crispman_777 Год назад
Just make a playlist here on YT
@GeorgRockallSchmidt
@GeorgRockallSchmidt Год назад
Yeah, The Twelve Days is a good place for that. But you know what? This is a great idea for my Patreon. I’ll consider this.
@jobojoe1
@jobojoe1 Год назад
I read the book about 5 years ago and absolutely loved it, becoming a little obsessed with Monroe for a few months myself. It’s quite a gruelling book in its own right. The film looks like it does follow the book quite closely (plot wise) and thematically it seems like it catches the complexity of the novel too. Looks like it’d be good to watch it in the cinema.
@neptuneteletron2998
@neptuneteletron2998 Год назад
Great job. Wish you had mentioned the texture of the images, depth of field, etc beyond aspect ratio, but I get what you're doing. Most viewers aren't geeking out that hard. But to fail to mention the Nick Cave/Warren Ellis score is unforgivable. God bless, Georg
@ileanamuntean7338
@ileanamuntean7338 Год назад
"more pathological than deceitful", now I can start to understand my mother.
@ross4814
@ross4814 Год назад
I'm so glad you reviewed the film. I have not had the mental capacity to watch the film as of yet. I defiantly will give it a chance now.
@mrs.wontkins9294
@mrs.wontkins9294 Год назад
I enjoyed it but I am very fond of the book. However I prefer the Minseries version better it just felt more sincere overall.
@StevenSeagull123
@StevenSeagull123 Год назад
Ana de armas nailed it as Monroe though. How the hell she ended up the in the movie "Ghosted" is beyond me..
@vladgina
@vladgina Год назад
What?
@sunsetman22
@sunsetman22 Год назад
@@vladgina the movie Ghosted with Chris Evans and her, a recent dud according to what I've heard
@buttercxpdraws8101
@buttercxpdraws8101 Год назад
You’ve seen Chopper? What did you like so much about it? 🇦🇺
@mrcoatsworth429
@mrcoatsworth429 Год назад
He has a short video about it. Check it out!
@BraxtonSwine
@BraxtonSwine Год назад
'The assassination of Jesse James by the coward John Ford' sounds like one hell of a film, will John be directing as well as starring?
@eldorados_lost_searcher
@eldorados_lost_searcher Год назад
It's already been made, unless they're doing a remake. Great, if slow, film.
@UltimateKyuubiFox
@UltimateKyuubiFox Год назад
@@eldorados_lost_searcher Robert Ford is the real one.
@pissqueendanniella4688
@pissqueendanniella4688 Год назад
I will NOT take it easy, sir. Thank you very much lol
@caulkins69
@caulkins69 Год назад
Why do some people insist on pronouncing "biopic" to rhyme with "myopic"? How do you pronounce "bio"? How do you pronounce "pic"? Now put them together. It's _by-oh-pick._
@irenemax3574
@irenemax3574 Год назад
Yes! "By-opp-ick" = blech!
@Nationalfrontdisco71
@Nationalfrontdisco71 Год назад
David Lynch was going to do a Marilyn Monroe film in the 80's, I wonder if would have been similar to this since I get Mulholland Drive and maybe some Fire Walk With Me vibes from this (maybe some Eraserhead)
@crayvun2196
@crayvun2196 Год назад
Why did I leave this comment? I like you Georg, you're a cool person.
@Masiap
@Masiap Год назад
This really is Complex PTSD from repeated and complex trauma in a film. So incredibly sad. The director did a good job in making the audience confused as to what was happening; what had just happened; and what had happened as longer term recall too. So confused. So sad.
@hookedonphoenix3112
@hookedonphoenix3112 4 месяца назад
Monroe, Elvis, Judy Garland; all considered the peaks of stardom and celebrity who each had their lives destroyed by exploiters in the industry and cut short by the substance dependency that came as a result. While not bad people, I’m glad their stories are now being seen as tragedies rather than successes to be strived for, with hopes stories like them never happen again.
@technologic21
@technologic21 Год назад
There were many parts of this movie that reminded me of Day of the Locust, the flames, the surreal elements of horror spliced with personal trauma, rape. Faye's character in that one was very much like Marylin's, father issues, and bad things just seemed to happen around her, as if she was a magnet for darkness, _the evil within._
@odnamsrazor2364
@odnamsrazor2364 Год назад
until the *men and children* on the casting couch get confronted, there will be no repentance from Hollywood.
@MarquisdeSuave
@MarquisdeSuave Год назад
Andrew Dominick is the king of subtext. Killing Them Softly is a masterwork that people wrote off as being a dull heist film. Blonde is basically on the same level, a "biopic" that subtly tells a much different story if you look closer.
@Glookos
@Glookos Год назад
Love these videos where you’re being sarcastic the whole time.
@camhamster3891
@camhamster3891 Год назад
I had the same trepidation toward this as I do for seeing Beau is Afraid. Just not sure I have the fortitude.
@ShadyPlatinum777
@ShadyPlatinum777 Год назад
It’s fascinating to me that this film was panned for not being a by the numbers biopic. I’ve not seen it myself yet so can’t come to my own conclusions but it was great to hear your perspective and I’ll definitely watch it.
@glenncanning8189
@glenncanning8189 Год назад
I usually agree with Georg, but definitely not here. I fully understood that Dominik wanted to make a film about trauma, but I found Blonde to be a deeply flawed exercise. I also (usually) don’t care for films that use a real person’s name, image, and history to tell a partially fictionalized version of their life story. Either go factual or fully fantasized- mixing in nonfactual elements as convenient always strikes me as lazy, disrespectful, dishonest, and exploitative. Especially when those fictionalized elements prove critical to the point a film is trying to make- for example, Darryl Zanuck did not, in fact, ever rape Marilyn. There are a hundred different ways to show how she was instantly exploited & commoditized that are true to her story, but we have to go with rape because……it’s even MORE traumatizing? We’ve just seen Marilyn’s mother try to drown her, what more do we need? Anyway, I found the whole film to be needlessly torturous, and not insightful or emotionally engaging enough to justify it.
@johnpelosi4117
@johnpelosi4117 Год назад
I love this examination, thanks Georg !
@Spudcore
@Spudcore Год назад
I didn't realise it was the same director as Chopper. I fucking love that film.
@itzybitzyspyder
@itzybitzyspyder Год назад
In the end we all want acceptance.
@Paulinhox88
@Paulinhox88 Год назад
I don’t think I can watch this film. I don’t think I could take the pain.
@fredbloggs5902
@fredbloggs5902 Год назад
I only made it halfway, it’s not a ‘feel good’ film.
@kennethc2466
@kennethc2466 Год назад
I can't disagree more. It was pure anguish porn, and deeply unappealing. It's 'message' was nothing more than, 'people get exploited, and more easily so when they're mentally ill'. Wide as a creek, deep as water drop. Still, I always enjoy your content, and thanks for the video.
@SimGunther
@SimGunther Год назад
Surely we got the whole point after 15 minutes. No need to pontificate on it for 3 hours.
@lazkennedy
@lazkennedy Год назад
I'll admit, I attempted to watch the movie and while I didn't hate it at all (in fact, I thought it was brilliant work), the emotional and mental intensity was just too much for me to finish it. I have trouble getting through movies that are so visceral and agonising. It's why I have no desire to re-watch the film Shame that Michael Fassbender starred in. It's all so deeply uncomfortable and miserable to watch, that by the time the story is done you feel like you've been passed through a wringer a few dozen times. All that said, I appreciate that it doesn't glamourise or hold up the legacy of Norma Jean's life as Marilyn as some beautiful and amazing ride. It really wasn't that. And the more that people understand how truly awful the industry was for her and for women in general, the better.
@tttm99
@tttm99 Год назад
12:00 🤣 it's lines like that which can really help lift some otherwise very dark material. Understated hilariousness at a dramatic moment... Signature Georg.
@mrpandabites
@mrpandabites Год назад
I found the film gorgeous and horrific, a masterpiece of the marriage of cinematography and theme. I felt crazy for liking it after the backlash. Your take is vindicating for all those who loved this film.
@SomePotato
@SomePotato Год назад
Ana de Armas was excellent in this film, and it looked great. I struggled with the runtime though. After a while, the cycle of suffering became quite repetitive.
@megyskermike
@megyskermike Год назад
Thank you for this
@ethanboyd6885
@ethanboyd6885 Год назад
As George said, great looking movie. Hard to watch though, but not in a bad way. Very heavy. Ana Celia de Armas portrail of Marilyn Munroe is simply captivating and flawless, to the point where I forgot who I was watching. Hollywood looks like another circle of hell, both back then and now.
@liaminwales
@liaminwales Год назад
The Last Tycoon is also worth a go for the main stream look at the 1930's with some depictions of the dark side, still keeps it fairly clean.
@wasneeplus
@wasneeplus Год назад
This video made me realise something: I don't actually give a crap about Marilyn Monroe. She's another in a long line of celebrities I don't get why people obsess over. So thanks, very illuminating indeed!
@NeonDarkShadow
@NeonDarkShadow Год назад
Spot on review Georg and strongly agree with you that the film is a Masterpiece. I think general audiences may have been miss-marketed but I also reckon most probably wanted the predictable safe and satisfying emotionally manipulative dramatic tragedy about Marilyn. Instead, the film, it seems to me, is the black dream of a traumatised damaged woman lost in her own identity disassociation. What was very gratifying tho was watching a real film made by a real filmmaker and not a piece of fucking content.
@darrengordon-hill
@darrengordon-hill Год назад
Misread corner banner as "Film WIG" 😂🤷🏾‍♂️
@weeningproductions945
@weeningproductions945 Год назад
Having yet seen the video, and having been very excited too. I will say that the worst crime this film committed was being utterly mind-numbing, and nowhere near as edgy and disturbing as its early detractors tried to claim. Not that I watched it because of that, I just wanted to see Ana De Armas as Monroe.
@ChristopherDraws
@ChristopherDraws Год назад
I always enjoy hearing your thoughts Georg: I originally had no intention of watching Blonde, aside from really enjoying Ana de Armas in every role I've seen her play making me a little curious, and then the overwhelmingly negative criticism of it cemented that. Now I've heard your thoughts, I'm going to give it a go. Much appreciated.
@acrosspeacesouthernbecame5200
Wow, Caleb Gamman had very similar take on Blonde. It looks like I'll have to watch it.
@EveryFairyDies
@EveryFairyDies Год назад
You've convinced me! I'm gonna go watch it! ...eventually.
@TiffyVella1
@TiffyVella1 Год назад
Thankyou. Am Aussie, never watched "Chopper"...for a score of cultural reasons and nothing against Erik Bana who I believe would have done really well. Would never have picked "Blonde" from the Netfix menu because would have assumed it was a cheap bit of Netflix titillation. "Something for the dads" as they say. Will give them a go.
@adampeters7947
@adampeters7947 10 месяцев назад
Well done Dominic, well done
@ndsmith7119
@ndsmith7119 Год назад
I agree with all your evidence and yet completely disagree with your suggestion as it being a masterpiece. It's not a fun film, it's also a dull film. Which Chopper isn't. I love that film. And I found Chopper to be great company. Monroe isn't great company. Whatever positives about her as a person is hidden behind the message of the trauma of Marilyn. And one more 'Daddy'...! I would have liked a dual film. More of the image of her as we want her to be and then the inner experience of her. Compare and contrast. Explore, find lightness and darkness. This felt like a thunderous hammer blow over and over again. And I love my Artaud and Requiem of a Dream, but she is such damaged company through the eyes of someone wanting us to feel that trauma, it just gets tedious. It should have been what I think he was more interested in, a piece of performance art, an experiential piece you can wander through. Have cinematice representations with theatricial immersive moments and twisted warhol explorations in a radical museum piece. Not for cinema.
@DingbatToast
@DingbatToast Год назад
Fair comment
@danielx555
@danielx555 9 месяцев назад
Joyce Carol Oates is one of those writers who destroyed their career by writing too much. She puts out so many books and short stories that no critic or reviewer has read more than 1% of her material. No one takes her seriously as a writer because she basically publishes an endless series of rough drafts. I tried getting into her 20 years ago, and I was immediately baffled by her writing. Some of the stuff is interesting, but almost every book she produces is the kind of book that you would imagine an amateur writer producing. I might look for this novel just to see what it's like.
@Tizzle1888
@Tizzle1888 Год назад
Beautiful insight and analysis, more of this good sir, whenever you can be arsed 👍🏻😂
@doriangraye1971
@doriangraye1971 Год назад
Well, now I have to watch it.
@caulkins69
@caulkins69 Год назад
Charles Chaplin Jr died six years after Marilyn did. How could she have heard of his death?
@fredbloggs5902
@fredbloggs5902 Год назад
It’s NOT a biopic.
@caulkins69
@caulkins69 Год назад
@@fredbloggs5902 I understand that. The problem is, the fictional elements aren't simply a speculative filling in of the blanks. Rather, they completely contradict facts which are known.
@jamesabernethy7896
@jamesabernethy7896 Год назад
I haven't seen this and it's not the type of film I would watch. I've seen a few people really trash this, viewing it heavily from the 'Me Too' perspective. Your analysis is very compelling. You are very funny, but you can be thought-provoking too.
@pmp3446
@pmp3446 Год назад
I'm going to pause this.
@wayneeast405
@wayneeast405 Год назад
Look, I remember watching the film sometime late last year. It blew me away. Felt different from all the other biopics coming out at the time because it wasn't sugarcoating any hard and serious topics. I respected this take and I really thought audiences missed the point of the film. Whereas by the books biopics gets all the praise.
@bobohobo7652
@bobohobo7652 Год назад
Not a biopic
@cookiemonstera9218
@cookiemonstera9218 Год назад
You're the best. Excellent as always
@polus2494
@polus2494 Год назад
We love you, Georg!
@GeorgRockallSchmidt
@GeorgRockallSchmidt Год назад
Love you too
@mattgilbert7347
@mattgilbert7347 Год назад
A remarkable film.
@idontbelonghereanymore6834
@idontbelonghereanymore6834 Год назад
Thank you I totally thought It was a bio pick from the advertising! I’ll definitely give it a go.
@AntoineMatuttisMusic
@AntoineMatuttisMusic Год назад
I agree - Blonde is a fantastic film that is widely misunderstood
@zzulm
@zzulm Год назад
Norma Jeanne wanted to have children the most but couldn't because of endometriosis, the abortion added to this narrative is so far away from her and it seems like she was used for her fame once again in this film.
@jonhillman871
@jonhillman871 Год назад
i think watching this critique will help me enjoy blonde more than if i just watched it without getting some context.
@aonghusofaolain8686
@aonghusofaolain8686 Год назад
Whew...heavy is right Maybe some other time. Sounds good but not right now
@Sodacake
@Sodacake Год назад
The Assassination of Jesse James by the Coward ROBERT Ford, not John Ford 😂
@4-a-e
@4-a-e Год назад
It's amazing to me how people didn't catch the chopper connection with Dominik's refusal to let Mark Read lionise himself like he does in the books.
@jadedspades
@jadedspades Год назад
The problem with this film is that it is just not as good or clever as it thinks it is.
@billhicks8
@billhicks8 11 месяцев назад
the film doesn't think, it's you thinking for it
@keyser9537
@keyser9537 10 месяцев назад
Not sure what the film thinks of itself, but it's basically as good as films can get.
@ostsan8598
@ostsan8598 Год назад
Patreon: for when the Hiptang money dries up.
@Burningwithecstasy
@Burningwithecstasy Год назад
I am looking forward to watching Blonde, now. Because I think I will enjoy it...and probably never watch it, again. Chopper sounds interesting, also. do I need to watch Atomic Blonde first to know what's going on in Blonde?
Далее
The Flash: What Went Wrong?
20:43
Просмотров 98 тыс.
The Ultimate Ancient Roman Iceberg Explained
3:49:37
Просмотров 607 тыс.
Can You Bend This Bar?
01:00
Просмотров 3,9 млн
The circle of light is yours (Blonde)
1:59
Просмотров 24 тыс.
Georg Complains: Jobs
24:45
Просмотров 90 тыс.
5 movies every filmmaker should watch
7:08
Просмотров 9 тыс.
Nevermind The Source Material
13:59
Просмотров 76 тыс.
How Wealth Influences Health
20:30
Просмотров 82 тыс.
Andrew Tate and the Lost Boys
44:19
Просмотров 157 тыс.
How Marvel's Cinematic Universe Changed Over Time
26:57
Private Equity: Apex Predator
29:15
Просмотров 40 тыс.