BMW M2 vs Cayman GTS - Budget Supercars - TV Season 1 Ep. 4 | Everyday Driver 

Porsche all day everyday. M2 if you didn't have another practical car but for a dedicated sports car? mid engine NA flat six every time.

I've owned an M2C for two days and I'm truly blown away with what BMW has accomplished. Excellent vehicle 10/10.

These guys need so many more subscribers. Their content is so well done. Their cinematography is up there with the pros!

For you people that love these guys, you gotta share their videos! Paul and Todd are more down to earth and mature than most other channels, but they still know how to have fun. Other channels just list facts about the car that take up a huge amount of time when we could have easily Googled it ourselves. Paul and Todd give us so much more in every single one of their videos. They deserve to be more popular than they already are. The more support that they get, the more awesome videos they get to bring out for us! Thanks for the awesome videos guys!

Just got out of the new Motor Trend best drivers car, watched this and thought, Everyday Driver just did a better version of best drivers car. Well done as always! Two cars that are also affordable for a regular person, & both sound like amazing machines, though I personally would take the Porsche. Cheers!

Love them both. As a Bmw owner I find the M2 to be the best car in Bmw's current lineup. But...Man I don't think I would pass up on that Porsche. In a world where cars are getting so bloated with weight, this beauty comes in at just a tick over 3000 lbs. Incredible.

I wanna thank you guys for putting the weight of the car not only in pounds, but also in kilograms. It helps people who are not from the US to understand some characteristic of the car.

The Cayman driving experience is on another level - as long as you don't need passenger seats

GTS no question

I’ve driven, tracked, and raced so many Caymans (from the 987S through the phenomenal 981 GT4), I think I could do it in my sleep. So the fact that I have more fun tracking an M2 maybe is colored by the relative newness. I just love the way it tip-toes through corners, as you guys said. The chassis and brakes are phenomenal, it’s more knife-edged but in a good way. I love the Cayman, it’s as ridiculously Porsche (that is, awesome) as they get. But the M2 is more alive in my hands. Great review, guys.

I'm going with the M2 if it was my only car. Cayman for a weekend/toy/date car.

I made a comment on one of your MX-5 videos (can't remember which one), about the sound when you two step outside the cars to have your discussion. This one is absolutely stellar in comparison. Whatever you guys did worked really well. It's really amazing to see how much you guys continue to improve your quality. Keep up the great work!

The GTS is so underrated, shadowed by the great but pretty over the top looking GT4. Plus the engine and sound is so much better than the new 718

I'm new to your reviews but I gotta say it's really very high quality. You both clearly have a deep passion and knowledge about cars and are able to accurately describe what your thinking in a way that gives the viewer great insight into the products your testing. also your video editing and shooting really keeps you engaged.... great job👍

As a Cayman gt4 owner considering an m2 daily driver, I appreciate this video.

A Porsche will always feel more special than a BMW

I picked watching this over Motortrend's best drivers car. Unmatched quality and perspective from these guys 👍

This channel gives some of the best reviews on RU-vid. I appreciate this channel very much. Thank you!

was waiting for this. great video

I have a gt4 and a 1m, and this review really spoke to me. But, if/when the wife pushes for one to go, I won't hesitate cutting the 1m. The two are brilliant, modern hot-rod underdogs, but the gt4 is a pure driving experience directly connecting me to the wheels. I completely support its title as ECOTY.

This is the best heads up video I've ever seen. You two are more interested in the debate than in being broadly entertaining or staying on script. I feel like I've driven both of them now, thank you. Liked and subscribed.

Great video guys! I'm biased so it's the GTS for me. The M2 is cool and the best BMW but the GTS is a proper sports car you can use daily. I commute, run errands and even use it in the Swiss winter. And as soon as I'm on a Swiss mountain pass, the GTS just wants to be thrown around, it's so much fun.

you guys have the best intro in the business, makes me really happy to be a long term subscriber

two amazing cars. I currently own an M2 just like it, Long Beach Blue, manual trans and I use to own a 2008 Cayman S.

Great video. I just took delivery of my Cayman GTS with a 6 speed and X73 suspension, and plan to keep it forever!

Have watched over 20 M2 reviews. You two are the most enjoyable watch. Love the switch-back-and-forth format. You guys don't try and "act". Just a relaxing conversation tone. Discovered the channel today.

Best review you guys have ever done. Todd, wonderful work on the editing. I adore the music at the 2:34 and the cuts that go along with the melody. Paul, what a great problem to have choosing between those two. I loved the video; it really grabs attention in the first couple minutes. And Paul, Todd is right. It's not an "and." hahaha

Incredible job as always. Astounding quality.

You guys have a fantastic channel. Every new video gets me excited and fuels my passion!

always enjoy your guy's perspective on cars. Been following your channel for years and its awesome to see the quality of your videos getting better and better.

So I've been through your exact dilemma, with a PDK Cayman GTS at that. I sold the Cayman because it was "too good" and "too easy". I got a Boxster Spyder, despite living in Boston (we get at least as much snow as Utah, and 9 feet just two years ago). Where the Spyder is where I want it is A) the manual makes me feel much more involved B) losing the roof adds a bit of necessary discomfort and anxiety (particularly top down in winter in sub-freezing weather) and C) it has the same section width as a base Boxster despite the 3.8L, so it moves around rather easily when you want it to (which is why I passed on TWO Cayman GT4 allocations -- wider, stickier tires and aero grip).

DAMN YOU 96 DEGREE LATTE!!! In all due honesty, what people need to take away is that you guys are literally dancing on the razor's edge with this comparison. The depth and application of your knowledge to a video like this should be awe inspiring to everyone that watches. It is to me, and I thank you for that.

As the prior owner of 6 BMW's and 3 Porsches, I can say the Porsches always felt like solid blocks of granite while the BMW's always felt like solid blocks of plastic.

Currently drive the E92 M3 with full suspension. I drive an M4 and drove the M2 at Thermal club race track, everything about the M2 was amazing in stock form, can only imagine the potential with upgrades.

Great video. I bought one of the last Cayman GTS allocations in June and picked up the car about a month ago. Sapphire Blue -6 speed manual - X73 suspension, PTV, etc. I sold my Ferrari 360 Spider as the prices were just nuts for a gated Ferrari. Was not sure what to expect from the Porsche. The car is phenomenal. I won't go into details comparing the two, but the after putting the first 1600 km on the car, the Porsche has not disappointed.

Love your channel guys, thanks for the great videos!

You guys are as good as it gets, period. This comparison was even more useful to me now than it was two years ago. I'm confounded that the comments are from 2-3 years ago. Every red blooded sport car fanatic should be curious about this face off / battle. This is a relevant must comparison for anyone that loves handling and lives near twisty roads. You have adeptly put into video and words how I feel and what I think about Porsche vs BMW reviews. So well done.

You guys always deliver, please never stop making these great videos 👍🏼

THis is my favorite channel along with savageese and driveopolis, PERIOD. NO other youtube car channels can compare.

Another great video guys! I always enjoy your channel!

I would probably choose the Cayman. It's just so beautiful, and the build quality is so insanely good. The M2 may be more practical, and I love practical cars, but the Cayman just seems like such a more high-end product.

I swear every time I watch this channel I like it even more. This is like that incredibly good restaurant that's only visited by people who truly enjoy great cuisine, this channel is made by true car guys for true car guys.

I literally could not think of two other cars that i would rather own today. These are real driver's cars that place balance and enjoyment above raw power output. I currently drive a 370z with 6mt and while it is no Cayman gts, it was the closest I could get at this point in life with a wife and 2 kids. Viva la driver's car & viva la car dreams

Found your channel today. I’ve been considering the Cayman GTS, and your reviews and candor have all been extremely helpful. Keep up the good work guys!

First time watching you guys (I was linked here from Bimmerpost) and I've got to say - mega video. Nice camera work and commentary. By the way, I didn't know Utah was so beautiful.

Digging the new music tracks--cool series of shots/music at 2:32...well done as always guys!

Great review guys. Interesting about the power delivery. I found the DCT to be just the opposite in my review. Immediate power everywhere. I also couldn't help but compare it to a Cayman. Both great cars! BTW, you guys were my inspiration back with your original Cayman review. keep up the good work.

I love this channel. Thanks for putting out all these quality videos.

Excellent comparison. You guys deserve a lot more subs !

I really enjoy your videos, your down to earth reviews and your approach and everything.

I need people to stop saying get the PDK on the basis of how impressed they are with the engineering. The goal is maximum fun.....manuals are more fun.

Well done. Worthy questions and well reasoned conclusions, unlike so many comparison tests.

Thanks for another great video. My M2 just made it on to the boat so this helps prime me for that experience. Had I not been able to get an M2 allocation my plan was to look for a Cayman S. Have a great time in Europe

as much as I love the M2..... to my eyes the GTS is and will remain one of the best sportscars/ drivers'cars ever!! maybe a real future classic !!

todd makes the best metaphors and analogies. simply wonderful

Todd & Paul, you fellas are great hosts! Entertaining & full of information. Great video! I'm a fan! Keep both!

Such a Great Vid Guys!! "Win-win" is the perfect description of these two honey's.

The Cayman is an amazing drivers car. I had this very decision to make, albeit a few years later, as I am not rich enough to afford brand new cars of this quality. I love the Cayman, but I can only afford one car, and the OG M2 was my choice. It's 95% of the driving ability of the Porsche, it really is not very far behind, but I needed rear seats, a bit of luggage space, and it is so much fun at normal speeds.

I love this show ! You guys are the best at showcasing cars, hands down. No B.S. just driving and telling it like it is!

Great video and worth the wait. It's interesting to hear how there was no clear winner. The production value of these videos is some of the best around! I'd watch this with the audio off simply to take in the sites.

Great assessment! Keep it coming, guys!

FANTASTIC video! Love you channel. Thank you.

Great review! In the market for a 718 S and love these reviews. Keep up the good work!

I had Todd's impression when I test-drove a base Cayman, vs. later taking one out on Porsche's test track in Atlanta: it is a bland, muted experience at normal speeds. So I got an S2000 :) I imagine the GT4 might solve that problem.

Guys, I really appreciated the detailed review for these cars. Honest, personal and insightful. I too like the M2, and BMWs in general. However, I know the feeling of the driving "experience" one enjoys from the Cayman. Both great cars, but I'd go with the Cayman. Based on your passionate reviews, I just subscribed.

I loved the sequence with music and detailed views of the cars. Great editing Todd! I'm a little surprised by the brake comment on Porsche. I've always felt they're truly progressive so the more pedal effort the more brake. Whereas BMW M cars have great initial bite but doesn't feel as firm when standing on them. If I had to DD one of them the choice is M2 but with a JGC as your DD I have to agree the CGTS is an event, looks better and arguably better balanced. Lastly Porsche has better built quality and it isn't immediately apparent until one spends time in one.

Every Porsche will become a classic in a 10 or 20 years. BMW just has been churning out family cars with body kits recently. Not that much soul compared to Porsches.

Nice video! I have the Cayman GTS, and a good friend is considering the M2. Although now he's leaning toward the TTRS which is no good because I already have a friend with a TTRS, I need a shot at a M2 :) All three are great cars that go about their business very differently. I wouldn't fault anyone who picked differently, but I think I'll stick with my Cayman. I came from a STI and I think I'm done with turbos for a while. Mid-engine balance is joy and that flat six sounds better (to me) than anything cheaper than a Huracan. But yeah that M2 is sweet and I sure would love to try one out.

Very important. I've seen all types of car reports and by far, you guys are the best. You're been honest and I can tell. Thanks to you guys, in getting BMW M2 2018. thank you guys!

Love you guys! keep up the great work

the gts is the easy choice for me! the way the car gets out of a corner is just pure for a driver

I love your show!!! I look forward to every Thursday!!! .. M2!!! PS. You have to drive the JCW GP2 before winter...2500lbs,6pods, Kv700 tires..track chasi!!! 218 HP! (only comes in manual) drive it on your back roads!

Very good channel! I like the direct interaction between the hosts. When the BMW M2 was announced I thought I would go for one but I have changed my mind... Both are very cool cars but between these two I would have the Porsche Cayman GTS everyday not only for driving experience but also for quality and selling prices.

For me, 17:45 nails it. I owned a Cayman S - ridiculously competent, poised car, but you had to push it so hard to feel any thrill, that as a daily driver, it was boring. There was no drama at normal speeds on normal roads. My BMW has amenities I can enjoy every day. The Cayman was a better car, no doubt, but it was not satisfying on a daily basis.

The tone of your videos is great. I like it much more than the path Motor Trend has chosen to go down.

I'm not a needy person, but I want your roads...

great vid guys keep it up and keep the vids coming

Excellent video guys! I just bought a 997 and am looking forward to adding an M2 (will never let go of this 911) when my kids outgrow the back seats. Looking at those 2 cars together as a potential garage makes me look forward to having the problem of choosing between a Porsche sports car and an M2 everyday!

wow. another great review guys. I wish I had your job. you two are living the dream.

I love the details you guys talk about ... which is why i look forward to every video you guys make! Well done as always... P.S. I would keep the Porsche its kinda hard to beat that amazing sound of a naturally aspirated flat six, it just feels so much more "Motorsport" ... just go for a nice aftermarket exhaust and save your money and keep the Cayman GTS .. thats my opinion at least, buy do what you feel is best...Good luck!

It's such a shame that you can't order a new 981 anymore. Truly an amazing car.

I had 60k and I was ready to get myself an M2. Then I realized, where I live, they were charging 110k for it (base)

One of your best guys. Really well done.

Brilliant video & channel! Totally agree as a current M2 owner, last month I spent a few days spanking a Cayman GT4 through Europe's best roads and it made my M2 feel very ordinary... I'm looking at used Cayman GTS's now (GT4 is way out of my price range) Subbed :-)

Got goosebumps at 2:37 when you synced the violins to images of the cars. Bravo.

Good stuff guys keep up the good work!

Starting at 11:17. Dude.... Your crazy to not want to FEEL what the tires are doing. Go to the track in a car with hydraulic steering like an E36 M3 and get to the limit. You can FEEL when the grip starts to go away in the steering wheel. You can feel everything the car is doing through the wheel. It's amazing and the way ALL sports cars should be. So sad the EPA stepped in and now we have crap electric steering. Bottom line is I have lost some respect for you after that comment.

A year ago, I decided to upgrade from my RX-8 R3. After extensive research, I narrowed down my final list to the 987.2 Cayman S and M2 (other cars that I originally shortlisted were the C7 Corvette and 997.2 911 CS). At the time, I had driven several Caymans and loved them, but had to make a decision without getting a chance to drive the M2 as they weren't out yet. Since this is not my daily driver, I went with the Cayman and have no regrets. That said, if this my only car, I'd likely go with the M2 as it has the extra seats for the kids. I'm in total agreement that these are two of the best driver's cars available today. Thanks for the great video!

The guys in top gear (as always) hit the nail on the head: it's not just about what a car can do, but how it makes you feel. To me I'd have to say the GTS gives me the fizz. Whenever I see it, hear it, I want it; even if the bimmer is better.

you guys ROCK LOVE YOUR WORK AND VIDEOS🔥🔥💛💛💛

loved this vid, with lovingful lovettitude lol, for me the no-brainer would be the Porsche for the sound, engineering, PDK, uniqueness, induction and brandname (initial quality, sale price, etc.) but I see your points of view and respect them. dreams happen, and come in a first world problem package.

I just wanted to express my appreciation for both this channel, which is wonderful, and this episode in particular, which was especially poignant for me. Like Todd, I was, and remain, a big fan of the FRS. I bought mine new in 2013 and over the last four years it's evolved into a dedicated track machine with racing seats, a quick release steering wheel and a six point harness. It's really a giant killer at the track and I've been as far north as Mont-Tremblant Quebec and as far south as Road Atlanta. But the car is just not practical, or for that matter, livable on the street anymore. It travels between track events on an open trailer. And I'm stuck with my daily commuter when I'm not on track. (When you drive a Honda Fit every day, let's just say the FRS feels plenty fast.) The car I really wanted as a weekend car was a Boxster S. In fact, I've wanted one since first seeing a preproduction prototype on the road in Germany back in 1996. But a mortgage, kids, a college fund, etc, it was just out of reach without making too many other practical sacrifices. And just when I thought I was getting close to a 2-3 year old 981 being a possibility, the 718 arrived and drove the prices of 981s (and even 987s) skyward. Thanks Porsche. So about a year ago I gave up and decided if things went well this year, I would order an M2 in the fall. And I watched this review at least a dozen times. I almost felt as if I was sitting and living vicariously through the two of you, trying to figure out what to do. Over the last 2 months it started to bother me. As nice as the M2 is, and it's infinitely more practical [than the Boxster], I realized it wasn't exactly the car I wanted. And it would be crazy to spend almost $60K on what was basically my second choice, and for a 'weekend' car at that. But I'm thankful in that it made me realize that perhaps the car I really wanted was the Cayman. And by pure chance, I found a 2016 Cayman S for sale, sport chrono package, sport suspension, manual transmission, and only 3500 miles on the odometer. And it was expensive. But still workable. (I suppose it's to my benefit that my first color choice was yellow and transmission choice was manual, and this particular car sat for a while with no takers, as most people in the market for one, would walk right on by that combination) But it was exactly what I was looking for. So after 22+ years of dreaming, I am now a Porsche owner. And I want to thank you both for helping me make this decision by essentially presenting this exact question and debating it with precisely the balance of reason and emotion that I would myself. For what it's worth, up until a few years ago, my first choice would have been a Lotus Elise, and I think it was a brilliant car to replace the FRS. But I just don't think I could live with it every day or put up with it's idiosyncrasies as a road car. Consider me a loyal fan for life.

You guys do quality work. Good luck with your channel.

Great channel, excellent work!

Easily the GTS

Great video. I also like Glenns Car Collection videos on his Long Beach Blue manual M2

Great video guys keep it up!

GREAT COMPARISON guys!!!

Great review men. Of the 2 I'd get the GTS but in a manual. Currently I have an Stronic GTI, Stronic S3 and a manual Boxster S. If I had to choose 1 car it would be my manual Boxster. Long live the manual.

Was just thinking I haven't seen an everyday driver video in a while.