Brock & Nellie Boyts' "Great Big Rollin' Railroad" Remake 

When will people learn that locomotives DONT. HAVE. STEERING WHEELS!

Six years later and I still don't understand how this was the winner.

Dear people who think this is unrealistic, it's a toy train.

So a wooden train with a steering wheel and a whistle instead of a horn while the people are just shaps with balls for hands...... *yes yes i belive that a train can go off road now this is the most realistic thing I have ever seen in my life wow props man Jesus crist* . . *please shoot me*

the train has a steering wheel

The train has a steering wheel... What happened: Nothing What should have happened: *train derails because of that idiotic driver

ARE YOU KIDDING ME?

Why is a freackin F unit have a whistle and chugging sounds???

At the top of the hill the train bends like it’s made of rubber or literally anything else malleable

I think I see how this won, probably for the kids who watch it so they will want to work for them

Trains don’t have steering wheels.

They are freaking trespassing on the railcar

0:13 steering wheel for a TRAIN!?

this is what won *this?*

For a diesel engine it sure sounds a lot like a steam engine. To me at least. Still, great video.

0:30 Steam engine sounds. Yet no steam engine ...... WTF is going on?

UP would fire him on the spot for havin a dog in the cab.

This is a great video. Yes, there are some things wrong, but it's meant to resemble a wooden toy train! I swear, 2/3 of these people in the comment section never had a childhood. You have to know that the people who made this put time and effort into making this! You know a train doesn't have a steering wheel, but you don't know that an animation like this can take months! This video is unique in it's own way.

Just wow.

how was this the winner

0:41 They say my name use captions

I just noticed that ladder positioning is so awkward. Do they climb throught the window

Why is it chugging? Most importantly WHY IS THERE A STEERING WHEEL?!

i love this song :)

Music: love it. Prototypicality: Wot dat?

NOW YOU'VE DONE IT! YOU MADE ME 1930S WORK WHISTLE ANGRY! *Caledonian Railway no. 812's whistle intensifies*

Why did it need to curve tho💀 0:32

HOW?!?!?!

The Canadian Pacific Railway (French: Chemin de fer Canadien Pacifique) (reporting marks CP, CPAA, MILW, SOO), also known simply as CPR or Canadian Pacific and formerly as CP Rail (1968-1996), was a Canadian Class I railway incorporated in 1881. The railway was owned by Canadian Pacific Railway Limited, which began operations as legal owner in a corporate restructuring in 2001

The lens flare effects and animated water are mesmerizing. They did SUCH a great job!

How did a wooden train animated win?

Good for little kids to inspire them to becom a railroader😊

I like UP 844

Great Big Wooden Railroad

Nothing beats the original that's a fact

Wow.A whistle. Sad.

Everyone please i dont Care if the Horn is replacing by a Steam whistle, is just a cute video not the "this is wrong here "railfans video...jeez we cant live our imagination with fans like this.

how much for that model?

00:00:10 Sodor Has A Great Big North Western Railway.

This was the grand winner

Since when do emd f units have steering wheels

Great video, love the wooden railway look!

Everyone in the comments section must be fun at parties. Come on, a couple made this, I don’t care about the inconsistencies, they clearly put their best work and effort into it. While yes, I much prefer Toonsmyth’s entry, this is still good, and it was made with passion.

Make official wooden train toys UP, you will make millions on wooden Bigboys and more

Sweet

All you haters give him credit he tried and it’s not half bad and this is made to be more for kids anyway so just try to look at the good

I would like an sd70ace engine but still great video.🚂🚂🚂🚃🚃🚃🚃🚃🚃🚃🚃🚃🚃🚃🚃🚃🚃

THE DIESEL HAS A WHISTLE A STEERING WHEEL AND IT SOUNDS LIKE A STEAM ENGINE #TRIGGERED

Fis song is beautiful🤤

Up. I like your big boy steam engine🚂

8 years later this is still great and should have aired on TV as a commericial!

Why does the train have a steering wheel? They use throttles, and not to mention, they use a whistle and not a horn!

I would rank this 4th place Cons: 1. Some pegman are missing painted legs. 2. Some pegman do not have arms. 3. Human pegman did not have feet but the chickens and cows do. 4. Cities are just roads & roller coasters. Edit: I am aware of the leg outline at 0:38, I do not count it because it seems improper.

0:22 is that the big Apple coaster at the New York New York hotel

Your trains don't even do 90. Were lucky if we even see them do forty.

Ah yes a steering wheel on the conductorers side of the locomotive because that makes sense

I now work at Union Pacific now this time I’m in a America

If this was a train set id buy it

Why does the train bend like that

HOW DID THIS WIN

There is people riding in the freight cars...

1862!? that's 1,000 years ago

From the green fields of the prairies “Wrong with heals all the ponies” Nice Auto-Generated subtitles EDIT- time stamp is 0:35

Why does the steam train have a steering wheel

Since when did train locomotives have a wheel

hey guys the union pacific can be a passenger train?

It that a f7 or was it a f9 or a e9

There are so many things wrong with this train Like why does it sound like a steam locomotive? Plus who brings there dog in the cab of a train!

Has anybody got a portable derailed I can borrow?

What is this

why is Los Angeles and Los Vegas nest to their each other?

I dont understand how this won first

The train has a steering whell Me:

I dont like that these stupid people think a diesel locomotive has a whistle and a STEERING WHEEL when they just follow the track

*COUGH* west network *COUGH COUGH*

why does a diesel have a whistle cord?-

Who made this? A five year old?

Ayyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy It's Link at 0:36

Weird

Dooododoodododooo*fart*

Great song, beautiful video, but a diesel locomotive with a steering wheel? And sounds like a steam engine? Come on!

Where is his railroad uniform

The best one except the train had a steering wheel, which is unprototypical and sounds like a steam train

Why does the train bend >:(

It pisses me off how people just criticize the little things like how the train has a steering wheel. Just enjoy the damn video, not everyone knows a locomotive inside and out. Plus, IT'S A CARTOON!

Wow toy train

Train has sterling wheel Dog in cab F7 unit has a whistle instead of a horn. And yet this won

Em why? Is a diesel engine sounds like steam train and why is linkon on a train

I like that alco pa-1

It looks like wii characters

Love this!! Great job, guys!

Why would a F Unit have steam engine sounds and steering wheel, why on gods earth would there be a railway line right next to a beach, I would Abe be riding on a diesel locomotive holding up “1862” even though was was before the diesel era??? And this was the winner???

make this an actual wooden train set.

This is for kids.

The orignal was way better.

Darrin shouldve won 100%

I'm going to make it in Grand theft Auto v

WOOD WOOD WOOD WOOD WOOD WOOD WOOD

Train doesn't have steering wheel 0:11

despite the issues this is AWSOME. congrats on "the grand prize". for the people that point out stuff that they think should be REAL.Is everyone thinking this is real,if so ITS TOYS.