Usted es un estúpido sin criterio, que mamera esta oleada actual de relativistas incapaces de decirle a alguien que lo hace bien o mal, y peor aún esos inbéciles que no saben aceptar que les hagan una crítica.
Los dos son buenos cantantes, muy aparte de que blaze haya cantado en vivo con maiden the trooper, two minutes for midnigjt, Hallowed the name entre otras canciones que Bruce dickinson les sale mejor cantarla en vivo que blaze.
I love operatic vocals with a broad range. So for the longest time I turned my nose up at Blaze. Especially since I have been a fan and first started listening to Iron Maiden around 1983. I love Bruce's vocals and stopped listening to Iron Maiden when he left. Several years after the come back I wanted to catch up and bought all the albums including Blazes. At first I wasn't that interested but heard songs like Lord of the flies sung live by Bruce. Started listening to other songs by both singers and like them both. Bruce is still the best Maiden singer ever, but Blaze is an excellent singer too and to be honest I cant think of anyone else that could front Iron Maiden in Dickinsons place. I always enjoy hearing Bayley sing in Iron Maiden when he pops up on the stereo while I'm working. The Clansman, Lord of the flies, Sign of the cross etc They are great songs that both sing really well.
I hate comparisons like this. They are not fair. These guys probably make a hundred performances a year, some of them awesome other just okay. I have seen Blaze live 2 times and both where way over my expectations. I have listened to Iron maiden since 1999 and seen them live 6 times. And I have seen a ton of live videos of both bands here at youtube. According to my experience most of there live performance are great but sometimes they fail, they are humans to. The problem is that if you making a video like this and you don't like one of them you could easily just pick a video from where the singer performs the song bad and then compare it to another video where the other singer performs the same song better. Like for instance, its not fair to compare a song with any song from the 'Rock in Rio' live DVD, as that is a premium recorded show which most likely have been edited and remixed a lot more. Also, to all of those trolls keep saying that Blaze is retarded and forget the lyrics. I Never heard him do, but Bruce does it at 3:28. The lyrics: "Do you believe, what you hear", Bruce sings: "Do you believe, what you feel". Its 'here', 'see' and 'feel'. Not 'feel', 'see', 'feel'. They are both great singers in my opinion. "If you don't enjoy us anymore then go see someone you do like instead." //Steve Harris
Escucho a Maiden desde la época de Di Anno, cuando se integro Dickinson en Piece of Mind, Maiden paso a otro nivel, sin duda, posteriormente cuando se integro Bayley personalmente creí que Maiden ya no seria lo mismo, pero Bayley mostró su calidad como compositor, ejemplo, "Como estais Amigos" un clásico y también un aporte a Maiden, mientras Dickinson hacia su carrera de Solista magistralmente, ambos como Vocalistas son excelentes, distintos, pero cada uno en su estilo, lo que no entiendo, cual es la idea de ponerlos en un Ring, es como enfrentar a Ronie James Dio con Ian Gillian, 1983dickinson, son solo tonteras de fanático adolescente, las voces tanto de Dickinson como Bayley al igual que otras son sobresalientes y no se pueden comparar tan básicamente.
si "Como estáis amigos" es un clásico como es que nadie la pide jajaja, nunca la escuchado en un concierto ni en el tiempo de virttual xi ............que por cierto fue en esa gira que regresó Dickinson a salvar la banda .
+1983dickinson entiendo que prefieras a bruce pero sinceramente debemos respetar a todos los gustos, prefieran a bruce, a blaze o a paul hay que respetar sus opiniones, sinceramente siento que blaze no hizo ningun clasico pero sus canciones son buenas y en mi opinion el disco x factores de mis favoritos y no me gusta como bruce canta las canciones de blaze ya que no estan hechas para el. el publico de la epoca de blaze en iron maiden no lo respetaba para nada, ellos querian a bruce y lo entiendo, el es el mejor cantante que iron maiden a tenido pero hay que respetarlos
Para mi sin duda Dickinson es el mejor vocalista de heavy metal de todos los tiempos, nadie puede igualarse a su capacidad vocal y sello característico. Up The Irons....
Os dois vocalista são fantásticos ,cada um tem um estilo diferente e alcances de vocal totalmente diferente ,pra quem é fã admira os dois são fantásticos.
PERSONALMENTE X FACTOR Y VIRTUAL FUERON LOS MEJORES CDS DE MAIDEN EN LOS 90!! BRAVE NEW WORLD FUE LO ULTIMO BUENO Q MAIDEN HIZO COMO DISCO....EL RESTO UN PAR DE TEMAS DE CADA ALBUM! THE X FACTOR ES UNA OBRA MAESTRA!!!
Creo que Blaze Bayley es un extraordinario vocalista, pero no para Iron Maiden. Desde mi punto de vista, el mejor vocalista que ha tenido (no en espectáculo, pero sí en voz) ha sido Paul Di'Anno. En cuanto a Blaze, sus discos de solista y con Wolfsbane son realmente muy buenos, pues canta como él, y no se le forzó a cantar como si fuera Bruce (y en el tono de Bruce). ¿Has oído los discos de Blaze? Escucha "Watching The Night Sky" (búscalo en RU-vid), entre otros.
Vi a los 2 sobre el escenario y me gustan los dos... cada uno tiene su voz pero Dickinson sobresale por encima por voz y por Showman encima del escenario que eso también cuenta muchísimo en un live
personalmente escucho a Maiden desde los 13 años y hermanos Dickinson es sin dudas el mejor de echo los mejores discos los grabó él es mi opinión como fan que soy de ellos sin omitir que ha influenciado a muchas bandas que salieron luego es una mezcla de agresividad con pases melódicos sin omitir que en el escenario se engrandece largar vida para ti Bruce y que Dios bendiga tu vos
la comparación no es la mejor hecha aunque dickinson es mejor pero no le gana por paliza como muchos piensan son dos tipos distintos con diferentes voces uno mas agudo el otro mas bajo si ocupara bayley un falsete o algo parecido también el panorama seria diferente y los movimientos en el escenario creo que no es muy importante
Ambos son buenos pero en estas canciones esta mejor blaze, me encanta su voz, bruce sin duda es tambien el mejor, pero escuche mas a blaze con estas canciones y me encantan
En lo personal no hay que negarle crédito a blaze canta bien lo que pasa es que estamos acostumbrados a bruce como también el buen paúl es un buen cantante para mi los tres son muy buenos representantes de los fabulosos Iron Maiden pues su música vivirá por siempre en mi corazón hasta el fin de mis días viva iron Maiden por siempre
Cada quien tiene un modo peculiar de interpretar sus propias canciones. Porque no es igual escuchar a Blaze cantando running free ni a Bruce cantando Lord of they Flies.
Gosto dos três cantores. Em especial do Bruce e do Blaze. Acho que cada um teve seu papel na história e trajetória do iron Maiden. Não é à toa que a banda tá aí firme e forte nesses 42 anos de existência. Parabéns a todos pelo sucesso.
A voz do bruce tem mais alcance e altura, mas é bem mais miuda e usa menos ar. O timbre do Blaze á mais encorpado, porém mais baixo. Dai é questão de gosto e preferencia, apenas isso.
Both have an important role in Maiden's history, and both have done amazing things outside of Maiden as well. This debate has been going on for over 20 years. I think it's time to let it go and appreciate them both for their contribution to the world of heavy metal.
Siendo justos un empate esta bien, "man on the edge" y "lord of the flies" mucho mejor con Blaze, " Futureal" la dejo en empate, "sign of the cross" y "the clansman" para Bruce reconociendo que el Rock in Rio es un concierto a toda raja ; si he visto mejores versiones en Blaze de estas últimos temas..... en todo caso no es necesario hacer este tipo de comparaciones, yo diría que el x factor y el virtual son mejores discos que los últimos 2 o 3 de Maiden con Dickinson ...
UN MILLÓN DE VECES CON MAYÚSCULAS BRUCE DICKINSON. VIVA IRON MAIDEN DE AQUI A LA ETERNIDAD.PAUL DIANNO FUE BUEN CANTANTE PERO DICKINSON FUE LO MAS SU VIDA LO DEMUESTRA APARTE DE SER CANTANTE DE IRON MAIDEN
Claramente Bruce Dickinson se convirtió en LA VOZ de Maiden. Pero hay que decir las cosas como son: Blaze Bayley es un GRAN cantante. Entrar a Iron Maiden para reemplazar a un consagradísimo Bruce Dickinson (que llevaba ya 11 años con Maiden) no era tarea fácil eh! Yendo al punto, no desvaloricen el trabajo de Bayley.
I met Bruce one day after the Concertin Bremen - The No Prayer for the Dying Album in Bremen - Germany On the Train Station in Bremen - Germany... He was in full alert... I said Hello Bruce... But he only looked weired left and right and passed me fast, no response. Well.. This Match goes to Blaze, only because he was the one who sings and composed the songs first, everything after him is simply imitation. Iam a BIG Bruce Dickinson fan, but this round goes to the original of course!
Para mim iron nos vocais segue assim....bruce, bruce, bruce e bruce, depois vem paul diano e logo atrás blaze...simples....se o iron ficasse insistindo com blaze ia acabar, e so ver como o bruce ia muito bem na carreia solo com adrian e i iron estava decaindo
Bruce's always been THE Maiden singer ! Blaze's been a substitute that's it... sorry for him but that's the fuckin truth for me !! Peace for everyone !
de hecho la gira de "Ed Hunter" 1999 , Blaze no la alcanzó a vivir porque trajeron a Dickinson y a Adrian Smith....así que Blaze Sorry...pa la casa no más (=
La verdad es que en cuanto a futureal y man on the edge no hay más que esas, pero vamos Dickinson aún así deja mordiendo el polvo a Bayley, te fijaste al final el alto que hace en "man on the edge"? ....Bruce la lleva!!
i'll always like bruces vocal more in most cases (blaze always sounded better on afraid to shoot strangers imo). but there was something special about the blaze albums to me that goes deeper than just who is a better singer. Especially with the Xfactor. you got to look at what was going on in 1995. I was 16 . Grunge had moved in and took over the scene . Metal heads like me and my friends were starved for ...well... METAL. poeple we had been friend's with just a few years back started mocking us for still liking things like a well crafted guitar solos, or for liking some one that could actually play their instrument masterfully. and then metallica just released load and it was soul crushing to every freind of mine. it was a metallica grunge album. Bruce leaving maiden in 93 had already broken our little meatal heads , so metallica's "betrayal" was like a slap on the face. then comes the X factor. it wasn't bruce , but what we got was the darkest IM album ever , with a dark lower voiced vocalist it just fit our moods pefectly and spoke to what we were feeling at that time. it was also HANDS down the BEST IM album of the 90's then and in hind sight. the songs were more powerful and emotional moving than IM's two preivous efforts. and we didn't care that Bruce was not on it. blaze delivered good enough. and IM delivered great metal in one of metal's darkest times. So yeah the xfactor holds a place in my heart to this day. it was also the first time i got to see IM live as well.
I am an Iron Maiden fan and first heard piece of mind in 83 when I was 13 and was blown away, I love the number of the beast with Bruce and every other album with Bruce, I also liked Paul Diano on the first two albums and I also like blaze and what he contributed and I know you can't compare them but I think it's what we grew up on and what we are use to and our personal preference, my favorite vocalist is Bruce but I remember growing up with number of the beast, piece of mind, power slave, live after death, somewhere in time, seventh son of a seventh son, matter of life and death, it just brings back so many good memories growing up with friends . It's a dream come true for Diano and blaze to have been a part of the greatest metal band on earth!
This video is so unfair. Where's blazes version of afraid to shoot strangers? Wrathchild? Fear of the dark? The evil that men do? He even done hallowed be thy name good a couple of times. Yes he doesn't match every maiden song, but damn does he try to fit that bill, he does excellent in performing those songs I mentioned above and perhaps even better but you don't bother in showing them? Plus if any of you blaze hating fuckwits had any sense about you then you'd see that Bruce left to extend his horizons in his solo career, and that would leave iron maiden for 7 years without a vocalist and who came to save the band? Blaze did. He should be respected for the horizons he helped maiden explore in the darker toned 'x factor' and trying to satisfy the nagging "fans"in 'virtual xi' for not sounding enough like Bruce. Just enjoy them both ok? We still have Bruce in iron maiden and blaze bayley is doing great on his own with infinite entanglement. Blaze and Bruce are truly heavy metal gods in their own right.
totally agreed, songs like lord of the flies are absolutely brilliant, he filled the bang in at the perfect time and gave us very good variety. I much so appreciate the blaze era, and some of blaze's latest work has been really good.
I love Bruce. Blaze has a good voice and is a good singer but not for Maiden at all. Very boring voice for Maiden. Maiden could've picked a dozen better voices for the band and Blaze certainly did NOT "save the band" (that's simply laughable). Bruce and Adrian back with the band SAVED THEM; provenly.
@@chadeagleton3141 be fair with Blaze. After all, Maiden is Steve Harris’s, since 1993, Steve was in a depression when he no longer had Adrian then Bruce, and he got divorce. What could be happended when a band did not have a singer, and a leader lost motivation. Some could say Maiden could rest, rather than disband. But could Nikko, Dave, Janick stop doing music and rest with Steve for 7 years before Bruce and Adrian came back? I don’t think so, they would find other ways like solo stuff or join other bands, Steve would be struggling to at least make a full reunion rather than keeping Maiden until today You can dislike Blaze-era, it’s your opinion, but I think we should put ourselves in Steve’s position. Steve chose Blaze when he wanted to explore darker tones, which fitted his depressing time, we can question why Blaze but after all, it’s Steve’s decision and it at least kept the band in process for even 6 and 7 years before reuniting with Bruce and Adrian. I’m not claiming who was the saviours when it is Steve Harris and manager Rod Smallwood who truly save and keep the band in process. Every member, even the formers contributed to help Steve in saving the band and make Maiden music be diverse, so that they all deserve respect and credit
Te has tomado el trabajo de leer la letra de "The King Of Metal"? Sabes que es un álbum muy personal? La portada, las letras... Y dices que no tienes nada en contra de Blaze? En serio???
Son 2 voces diferentes. La de Bruce tiene fuerza y se luce en las notas altas y sostenidas, pero en las notas graves de blaze es como que le falta aliento y se muere un poco. Y Blaze es lo contrario, tiene medios graves muy potentes y sostenidos, que aportan mucho sentimiento, pero los agudos cuestan, y forzado a llegar a las notas altas de dickinson, por incapacidad desafina.
My answer resides on professional ability because I do respect both vocalists. Bruce has better pitch control and his vocal performances are more consistent. Blaze only does well by his Maiden songs, but Bruce owns every Maiden song he sings from every album. Bruce wins!
I really Love How Blaze do the studio version and of course the live version.but Bruce make a Great Job doing the Live Version but is my humble opinion I give to Balze rounds 1 and 3 and to Bruce 2 4 5 Bruce Wins ane Why Not Both of them Wins "Frienship'' and We Win Variety and Style ... Up the Irons
Cualquiera con medio oído y con todo el respeto para blaze, diría que Bruce Dickinson se lo come en todos los aspectos tanto vocales como interpretativos, Blaze hizo lo que pudo pero Bruce es mucho Bruce
They are both phenomenal singers but Bruce takes it. I grew up listening to Iron Maiden/Bruce. Some changes are hard to accept I guess lol. Blaze is just as amazing though....ugh why even compare these 2 crazy awesome vocalists?
I think Blaze wins, he does Man on the Edge, Futureal, and Sign of the Cross better. Bruce does the Clansman better, and i can't decide who sang Lord of the Flies better
Max Durk Yeah you're right. And then bruce does every song from The Number of the Beast, Peace of Mind, Iron Maiden, Powerslave, Fear of the Dark, Seventh son of a seventh son, and Somewhere in time better lol. the only albums that matter
White Temple well, let i know, i cant defend that. I realized later that he was flat on man on the edge, the clansman, and sign of the cross, i had the studio versions in my head too much. I think it has something to do with the fact that he doesnt do well with touring at higher registers, too taxing on his voice. But in studio he sounds great, and the x factor and virtual xi are actually quite good, especally the x factor. give them a chance, and try not think about bruce
Max Durk these things should not be compared. Period. But if you want to compare, one should try to put, as possible, the same conditions on the table. And, there is one huge difference... while dickinson is singing for the usual maiden audience, blaze is playing for like... a quarter of that. and that includes production works. i just think this is an unfair duel. each one of them has their place on maiden's history, as well as Paul Dianno, and the band made great albuns and great songs with all of them. hands down for dickinson, for he is one of the bands faces, and the most influent singer of them all. so it shall be written, and so it shall be done. Up the Irons
