BTOB WEEK (PART2) | (BTOB) KILLING VOICE REACTION | WIND AND WISH, 의 킬링보이스를 라이브로! - 그리워하다, 너 없인 안 된다 

The third song is called Second Confession! Peniel probably stumbled over the lyrics at the beginning because that rap part was originally Ilhoon’s

4:27 - that's Sungjae, our maknae😊He has a beautiful performance with Gummy called "Memory Loss"

Finally, someone shows excitement toward Peniel's voice while reacting to this!! This killing voice video made me fall in love with BTOB

It has been a long held belief that BTOB and Mamamoo are the vocal kings and queens of K-pop.

My fav song is HIGHER. You definitely need to check this song. Is a rock genre. I know is not tittle track. But absolutely masterpiece 💙

14:59 - in white shirt and a tie is Hyunsik , main vocalist too, compose and write many Btob songs, really crazy range he has

As for Eunkwang and Changsub duo… You have to watch their gold ax silver ax performances. SO GOOD!!

eunkwang aka silverlight is the official main vocalist, but he wish people would not categorize the orther members as sub vocalist etc and just called them vocalist bcs he knows all his members are amazing vocalists

Also the three vocalists besides Eunkwang (silver light) are (L-R) Sungjae (he’s acted in several popular dramas as well), Hyunsik, and Changsub (he was on Kingdom with the three you already know)

The last song, "Finale: Our Concert" is a fan favorite since it is epic and the lyrics are quite personal between BTOB and Melody. As you have guessed, this song is iconic because it usually wraps up BTOB concerts. But recently, there was a cute incident where they sang this at a university festival to a general audience which made Melodies burn with jealousy (jokingly) and BTOB didn't hesitate to tease us for it.

Not even title tracks but I looove Someday and Finale (Our Concert) ❤

From theLeft : HUTA "MINHYUK" ,, SUNGJAE ,, EUNKWANG "SILVERLIGHT" ,, HYUNSIK ,, CHANGSUB ,, PENIEL.. AND Main and Lead Rapper is HUTA "Minhyuk" and PENIEL.. For the other is a MAIN VOCALIST,, which Know as BTOB BLUE.. you can check Them song too and BTOB BLUE on IMMORTAL SONG... Actually BTOB known for 7 RAPPER, 7 VOCALIST, 7 DANCER... Coz They all Multi talented💙

from left to right: minhyuk (huta), sungjae, eunkwang (silverlight), hyunsik, changsub, peniel. if you watch Kingdom, minhyuk(huta), eunkwang(silverlight), changsub, peniel were there as BTOB4U, a sub-unit since the other members were in the military. ig that's why you recognize those three

Hey. Back so soon. Loving it🎉. For BTOB and Mamamoo collab check out Solarsido with Changsub and Solar exchanging tracks. You've beem melody-schooled hehehe ( judging by the comments) The song that stood out for you was Someday. An awesome song and their best live performance of this track was at the This is Us Concert. BTOB's live performances are always legendary and this is where they take the chance to play vocal musical chairs especially with adlibs. They change it up as they see fit. Another masterpiece is Eunkwangs recent duet with Ki Tae on Immortal Songs. Prepare to be amazed. Each member has a solo album, both Eunkwang and Changsub are musical actors, Peniel is a presenter and dj plus photographer while Sungjae and Minhyuk are both actors. FAVE songs from Killing Voice would be Finale and Be Together. All time faves though are L.U.V. , Thank you, Dreamers, Fly Away, Red Lie and many more. Thank you for this awesome reaction. 🍀💚

BTOB ATE and left no crumbs!!

I'm on 11:47 mark but I feel like I need to comment asap before I forget (so sorry if you actually had talked abt it after 11:47 mark lol). Did you know that Changsub (the guy beside Peniel) guested on Solar's youtube channel and they did that part change kinda thing? The way both of them slayed so hard on doing the songs... If you haven't watched it already, please do. You don't have to make a video reaction tho, you can just do it on your own time

Btob is the killing voice 🎤🥰

Thanks for the reaction Their name in order from the left : 1. Minhyuk 2. Sungjae 3. Eungkwang / silverlight 4. Hyunsik 5. Changsub 6. Peniel

OMG I didn't realize I'd get so lucky and see TWO BTOB reactions on your channel - especially after I finished watching SDC on Patreon! Today's a good day, indeed. Minhyuk is my bias and Hyunsik (the guy you kept replaying) is my bias wrecker, and as a Cassiopeia I love the Changmin mention (he's my bias in TVXQ) so you definitely have TASTE. 😊 So glad to see you diving deeper into the BTOB discography! *To help you out, in KILLING VOICE here are the members from left to right:* MINHYUK aka HUTA (blue button-up shirt, dark necktie) - lead rapper, lead dancer SUNGJAE (white sweater vest, navy lining) - vocalist, maknae EUNKWANG aka silverlight (navy blue sweater) - leader, main vocalist HYUNSIK (white button-up shirt, dark necktie) - lead vocalist CHANGSUB (white sweater vest, orange lining) - lead vocalist PENIEL (gray sweater) - lead rapper Note that they like to switch positions (especially when playing Spin The Wheel) so when Eunkwang went into the military they had different leaders at times 😂 ILHOON used to be the main rapper before he left the group, so the rap line was Minhyuk-Peniel-Ilhoon (in age order). *The four vocalists actually have a sub-unit called BTOB BLUE.* If you want to be blown away by their vocals, this is probably my all-time favorite live stage of theirs on the show "Immortal Songs": ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-a6DNkLvHxZ8.html *Oh, by the way the English titles beneath the Hangul are actually the album names! Here are the songs' English titles in order of when they sung them:* 1. Missing You 2. Remember That 3. 2nd Confession 4. Only One For Me - *MELODY (the fandom) are also known to be long-suffering fans because the boys love to make complicated fan chants.* For this song, half the fans sing the "haAHahAHahAHHH" part then the other half chants "let's get it on let's get it on/why don't you be my girl" Fan chant guide (BTOB almost always makes one so you can search the song on their channel and find it): ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-xOAdPZ8Z4ek.html Actual fan chants during their live stage: ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-FwWuFn0nGec.html 5. Beautiful Pain - Eunkwang saluted because he was in the military when the song came out 😅 6. Someday 7. It's Okay 8. I'll Be Your Man - I remember watching their live stages when this came out and thinking the rap at the end was just INSANE ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-P1TEAmMeT58.html 9. Higher 10. Blue Moon 11. The Song 12. Be Together 13. Wind And Wish 14. Finale: Our Concert *BTOB ATE AND LEFT NO CRUMBS*

Thanks for the reaction. A lot of the questions for example regarding the rap line question will be answered in the guide by ilhoon squad. Since you enjoyed them on kingdom and said that peniel seems like a main rapper. Peniel at the beginning of his career wasn't really fluent in Korean and isn't really a singer so he had one line a song. He showed growth after 3 to 4 years but for me personally his time in btob4u (the guys that were on kingdom) made him grow the most since he had the chance to do longer parts. My favorites out of the songs they sang are probably its okay and blue moon. Ps. Btob ate and left no crumbs

Thank you for appreciating BTOB, and thank you for your genuine and sincere reactions! :) Killing Voice is really turning out to be their calling card - it showcases and encapsulates that BTOB is all about: fantastic singers who love their craft, and who are also one of the goofiest and craziest Kpop groups out there. Both of these characteristics - being great singers and being crazy - are acknowledged by the industry, not just the fans. :)

tracklist: 1. Missing you (Prod. by Hyunsik) 2:42 2. Remember that 4:46 3. Second confession 6:33 4. Only one for me (Prod. by Hyunsik) 9:04 5. Beautiful pain (Prod. by Hyunsik) 10:52 6. Someday (Prod. by Hyunsik) 13:08 7. It's okay 16:34 8. Pray(I'll be your man) (Prod. by Hyunsik) 18:11 9. Higher (Prod. by Minhyuk) 19:24 10. Blue moon (Prod. by Minhyuk) 20:20 (Cinema version is the one they rearranged for kingdom) 11. The song (Prod. by Hyunsik) 22:37 12. Be together (Prod. by Hyunsik) 24:26 13. Wind and wish (Prod. by Hyunsik) 27:15 14. Finale: Our concert 28:48

left to right: Lee Minhyuk (Huta for solo stuff) - main rapper, main harmonizer, main stripper, one of the songwriters/producers - Higher and Blue Moon are his songs Yook Sungjae - vocals (goes lower as a baritone), spoiled baby forever, the sun of his hyungs' world, actor (Goblin, Golden Spoon) Seo Eunkwang (Silverlight) - leader, main vocal, does all those super high ad libs, is strangely competent at the weirdest things but do NOT let him cook Lim Hyunsik - vocals, legendary Pokemon, he never leaves the studio, loves his guitars, the main songwriter and producer, the father of BTOB's music, does the super low notes since he's the only one that can reliably hit them, range for fucking days and a ^^ smile, also has a Master's degree in practical music Lee Changsub - vocals, the emotional powerhouse puncher so he often opens or ends a song, super expressive face, gremlin laugh, famous for voice cracks lol Peniel - save him pls, rap line, adept at translating BTOB into Korean and English, good vibes, raunchiest lyrics in the fucking group, is an Actual Wall BTOB definitely ate and left nothing behind and then went off looking for seconds lol My personal faves are Higher and IBYM - I love Hyunsik's songs, but Minhyuk seems to have a direct line into my head to know what I love in a song so Higher definitely wins out and the entire last 3rd of that song makes my brain do happy brrs and gives the good brain juice, but that ending part in IBYM is also just chef's kiss, definitely also a favorite.

BTOB covered MAMAMOO's - YOU'RE THE BEST. You can check it out too ☺️💙

10:45 actually there has been a few collabs between mamamoo and btob they exchange song (btob singing mamamoo song vice versa) for show music core 500th episode changsub btob and solar mamamoo are best friends, they did a few videos together on solar's channel and they also starred in a musical together

BTOB ate and left no crumbs…absolutely! Edit: my favorite two songs in this medley are Remember That (my fav BTOB ballad) and Finale: Our Concert…although Wind and Wish is climbing that favorite list quickly.

Thank you, as always for reacting to BtoB! "Who is that" - Chris to EVERY MEMBER 🤣😂🤣 Okay lets just go in the order they're standing: - So Minhyuk aka Huta, you already know 💪 Buff BtoB Bae - Sungjae our Maknae & Face of the group (my bias 🫣) - Leader and main vocal Eunkwang, you know him as DJ Silverlight. - Hyunsik, Lead vocal, he's such a cutie patootie! - Changsub, another lead vocal...no one is surprised! He has a fire solo from last year called Surrender 10/10 recommend! - And of last but not least Peniel! Regarding Rappers, both Minhyuk and Peniel are Lead Rappers. The Main Rapper was Illhoon who is no longer in the group. But as I said before they ALL sing. #BtoBAlwaysEats #BtoBStaysEating #BtoBLeavesNoCrumbs 😂 Can't wait for the guide! Favorite: ALL OF THEM. How can you pick just 2 😢?!

BTOB ate and left no crumbs

BTOB ate, left no crumbs and even washed the dishes

Someday is the best song (only for me) T_T

I don't know if you like it or not, maybe you can watch Recording Day of BTOB "The Song" (produce by Hyunsik), "Blooming Day" (produce by Minhyuk), or "Wind And Wish" (produce by Hyunsik).

THANK YOU FOR REACTING TO BTOB'S SONGS!! 💙ps: I just came from pt.1 3 mins after this video uploaded and I'm enjoying your reaction so much !

Thank you for reacting to BTOB💙 I enjoyed your reaction as well🥰 From left to right: Lee Minhyuk (HUTA) Yook Sungjae Seo Eunkwang (Silver Light) Lim (Im) Hyunsik Lee Changsub Peniel (Shin Donggeun)

Yesss I am super excited for this series!! Thank you for reacting to them and I hope you enjoy the 6 (though I hope they become 7 again) of these guys’ lovely voices and personalities!

BTOB left no crumbs💅

thanks for reacting to BTOB ..their song and voice touches heart..

I wish you all the very best in finding a bias in BTOB.... 😂😂😂 they wreak you every moment... See their Official shorts... you will hear some harmonies...

BTOT ate and left no crumbs!!!

Someday, the song, 2nd confession, I’ll be your man, and etc. All of their discography hits differently!love them thanks for your reactions ❤

Your fav song 'Someday' is produced by Hyunsik 💓 fourth member who wore white shirt & tie😊 He is real genius! Thank you for your reaction! I really enjoyed it :)

BtoB ate and left no crumbs ❤

BTOB ate no crumbs

역시 우리 비투비!!!!멜뿌듯하네 예지앞사

Someday is my fave song by btob. Sungjae next to huta is my fave singer. It hits differently for me. But btob is the only kpop groups where ever single members solos are on my play list.

I love beautiful pain so so much!💙 Song recommendation: Missing you, Beautiful pain, It's Okay(Dance ver.), Pray, Stand by me, When it rains Funny videos: Quiet & reserved idols btob(there's 10 of them) Thank you so much for reacting to btob.

Thank youuuu

Huta Lee Minhyuk OMG

My favorite two songs are probably someday and i'll be your man 😊

5:25 he is lee changsub 😁

I enjoyed this reaction sooo much i love how you take time to appreciate each members vocals 😭

The emotion in BtoB's music really transcends language. There has been so many times when tears just comes to my eyes without paying attention to the lyrics

It's no real surprise to say BtoB might be the most versatile group ever given all their ballad-y songs (and vocal talent), their typical kpop dance tracks, their talent as producers (Minhyuk/Hyunsik have produced a LOT of their songs), their entertainment side (they are CRAZY on variety shows), Sungjae was on probably one of the top 3 most popular kdramas EVER (Goblin), even their whole drag/cosplay performances are on another level (I highly recommend looking up golden axe-silver axe, and Minhyuk doing Girls Day 'Something')....they do EVERYTHING (even Minhyuk is/was a radio host). There's literally TOO much that they do. Changsub right now has a super fun YT channel where he visits various colleges and highlights different departments by taking classes for the day

We crave for MAMAMOO and BTOB collab as well. Both have mentioned they wanted to do it. We just hope in the near future it would be possible.

Loved your reaction… I can’t pick a favorite… Everytime I’m ready to pick one, one of the other guys does something to remind me, he‘s there too… 😆

I enjoyed your reaction. I need part 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, .... of btob reaction 😁🙏

Thank you for these BTOB reactions! 💙

Thank you so much for reacting to our beats💙

My idol Btob..

FYI, Changsub & Solar both starred in a musical. They even kissed on that musical. Oh!! And they're also friends 🤭

TY for reacting, spread the love for BtoB

love this series so much!! 💙💙 Thank you!!

Thank you for the reaction to Btob

Just give up on having a particular Bias and just Bias the whole group. All of them are great, so don't bother to choose just one, choose them all.

this is what people must know🎉🎉

아 무슨말인지 모르겠는데 몸짓으로 다 이해된다능~~비투비 사랑한다 비투비없인 안된다능

apink killing voice reaction please

Someday and Finale

no surprise changsub (orange collar/angelic voice) is super good friends with Solar from Mamamoo bc ultra talented people like that are greedy AF

New subbie!! Love your insights and genuine reactions! You focus on talent, on small yet significant details in the production, their skills, and music. Love that you liked how raw this Killing Voice is. 😀 You said you’re a dancer but wow, I got a lot of vocal insignts from you! Btw. I saw you’re reacting to Treasure too! Will defnitely check those out!! ♥️

Thank you 💙💙💙

screeching up for this one before work omg

뭐라는겨... 암튼 고맙다

i LOVE watching BtoB’s killing voice over and over again! and like you, i wish BtoB and TVXQ had a collab or even just a special performance. i also wish they can perform with either Jaejoong or Junsu (or both!) as well. eunkwang (silver_light) is their main vocalist and leader. from there it’s minyuk (huta), changsub, hyunsik, peniel and sungjae. their former member ilhoon was their main rapper. for now it’s both minhyuk and peniel as lead rappers. all members of BtoB can sing AND rap. they all have solos with eunkwang, changsub and hyunsik active in musicals, minhyuk and sungjae in acting and peniel with his podcast with Ashley (Ladies Code) and BM (KARD). if you watch kdramas, sungjae might be familiar to you cause he’s acted in School 2015: Who Are You, The Village: Achiara’s Secret and Guardian: The Lonely and Great God - Goblin.

The best kpop group for me ❤🎉

14:13 he's sungjae..

From left - rapper (Blue Shirt) - Minhyuk - Vocalist ( white sweater) - Sungjae - Vocalist (Blue Sweater) - Eunkwang (Leader) - Vocalist ( White Shirt)- Hyunsik - Vocalist (white/ line orange sweater) - Changsub - Lead Rapper - Peniel

people should appreciate BTOB more and more

I love for ur reaction to BTOB ❤

A talent tornado in the area

MAMAMOO 🤝 BTOB

💙💙💙

Did you know that when there were 5 TVXQ members, there were 2 members who sang better than Changmin...😏 They still have excellent vocal skills and are famous in Korea.

💙

Members left to right : minhyuk, sungjae, eunkwang, hyunsik, changsub, peniel Songs in order: Missing You, Remember That, 2nd Confession, Only one for me, Beautiful Pain, Someday, Its okay, Ill be your man, Higher, Blue moon, The song, Be together, Wind and wish, Finale

BTOB ATE & LEFT NO CRUMBS 😂😂😂😂 VOCAL KINGS W/ PRICELESS PERSONALITIES!!! ❤

Omg how to choose two fav songs... someday and only one for me maybe?! But I love the rap in Higher