I would of skipped the Scotty and built out a complete set. Scotty's are nice don't get me wrong but I would have atleast went with a 54,58 and a nice milled Cleveland putter.
I’d always go for the ‘never compromise’ putters if they have them. For some reason they resell super cheap but are just as good as any odyssey or Scotty Cameron. Probably could’ve found a used one for under $50, which would’ve left him with $50 for a really good used Cleveland wedge (56+60) especially if going back to the cg series or 588/797/900(possibly 2) and possibly a Titliest/Srixon utility 3iron for under $100.