But...whodunnit? - SHERLOCK HOLMES: CRIMES AND PUNISHMENTS - Part 24 

"Use, the Force, Harry"-Gandalf

Unity looks fine. It's the performance that needs fixing. In that regard, this is way better. ^^

It may look fine, but it doesn't excuse that Sherlock looks better than Unity.

I don't quite understand your thought process on why she's not naive. She only saw the side of him that was kind and optimistic, and as such fell into the trap of his showering of frivolities.

calling it now it was miss white and albert together *cough*dontlistentome*cough*

I suppose that she may have been naively unaware of how men react to her, but it seems more likely that she knows that she's beautiful and is willing to act upon to beauty and manipulate people into doing what she wants. Albert doesn't seem a very likely candidate. Holmes didn't even come to investigate the murder, why would the murderer bring it up? And he hates botany, why would he kill his father knowing that he'd inherit the Gardens? I still think it's Hamish. Of the three he seems the most likely, maybe Miss White was tired of his advances, or he went too far and she poisoned him and is simply saying such flattering things about Dunne to make it seem as though she had no motive. Who knows.

Blueeyesthewarrior but what if miss white manipulated albert into poisoning his father through some means (like the plants or ventilation) and he didnt know what he was doing but when he found out he was all broken up which is why he told her not to disturb him and he was upset even though his dad was a jerk to him... still, dont listen to me XD

So much spoilage right now. I feel like we should stop because Dodger might read the comments and have the end of this mystery ruined.

+AfflicXIon a patron, methinks.

I'd guess it was her based on her concern that Sherlock was on a case, and her relief when he said that he was investigating the plants as opposed to the murder.

Also, the whole poor family / going to college / wearing expensive perfume / deputy thinks she's naive while she is milking a rich guy / so she is good at acting / also the deputy guy is dumb / etc, raises so many red flags, she has "ruthless manipulative sociopath" written all over her. And remember that poison is a womans weapon. And she's supposedly knowledgeable about plants. But what would be the motive? Maybe the son who has good chances at taking over is easier/less gross to manipulate?

Really? Dodger has almost finished the game. Its not worth playing yourself at this point IMO. It's not a game that can be played multiple ways.

StabStabStabStabby i know that, doesnt stop me from buying it though