Camping Potti REVOLUTION! - The Thetford iNDUS System

Подписаться 80 тыс.

Просмотров 55 тыс.

50% 1

To be able to talk about a motorhome toilet for nearly 40 minutes non-stop is a skill few people have, but it's one I have managed to hone.
However, if you wish to skip straight to a certain section:
00:00 - Introduction and titles
00:45 - Overview of the Thetford iNDUS system - the Revolution of the portable toilet
02:32 - How the Thetford iNDUS System works - Cartridges A, B, & C
03:52 - The Thetford iNDUS App
08:30 - A look at the loo itself, the short flush, the long flush, pulsating flush
12:27 - How to Empty the iNDUS system - both grey and black tanks
15:15 - How to stow the Outlet Handle of the Thetford iNDUS system
16:36 - FAQs, the pros and cons of the Thetford iNDUS system
30:49 - Real life Emptying / Discharging the Thetford iNDUS system
34:24 - Final thoughts - What do YOU think about the Thetford iNDUS System?
One of the most distinctive features of the Luxury Motorhome Bürstner Elegance I 910 G is its inclusion of the Thetford iNDUS system. Thetford iNDUS is more than the just the toilet - it is the entire plumbing system including fresh water, black water, and grey water.
The Bürstner Elegance I 910G has a 140 litre fresh tank, 110 litre grey tank, and a 50 litre black tank.
We put the iNDUS system through its paces for a week and give you a REAL LIFE review on actually using the system in anger.
A huge THANK YOU to Bürstner UK for sponsoring this vlog without interfering with or influencing the content.
Please check out the Bürstner UK Website at:
www.buerstner.com/gb/en
Build your own dream Elegance I 910G using the Bürstner configurator at:
www.buerstner.com/gb/en/confi...
To keep up to date with our trip in Real Time, and for further details of the UK Bürstner Roadshow in October 2021, please follow Bürstner UK on social media:
/ burstneruk
/ burstneruk
/ burstneruk
=======================================================
MY VIDEO EQUIPMENT
You can read all about the camera and video equipment I use here:
andrewditton.substack.com/p/m...
MUSIC
The music used in this vlog is from Artist. Get TWO MONTHS FREE when you sign up using this link: artlist.io/Andrew-613983
======================================================
Thanks for tuning in!

Опубликовано:

2 авг 2024

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 292

@CaraVanOlogywithBecky 2 года назад

Very, very clever indeed. Whether it's too clever depends on the quality of the engineering... one point about chemicals that everyone seems to forget is concentration i.e. the bottles may be the same size but that doesn't mean they have the same amount of nasties in, unless we have a full chemical analysis (unlikely if there's a patent) then we just don't know. I suspect that was Thetford's point about having the same impact over 4 weeks compared to domestic loo chemicals i.e. the volume of indus chemicals may indeed be much more but if they contain less nasties per ml then it could be comparable to the volumes of loo cleaner, rim blocks, etc. used domestically by the average (likely not septic tank owning, environmentally conscious) person. Non green chemicals are a major, major issue though as lots of us have switched to formaldehyde free, green only, 100% of the time, septic tanks or not. My own feeling is that we're about to see the options diverge massively. Blades, cassettes, etc. are a minor innovation really from bucket and chuck it but feels like we're about to see revolution via a split to super hi-tech i.e. indus type systems vs super low tech - composting or waste burning dry toilets and hyper water saving e.g. some really clever grey water recycling/filtering for showers ideas out there amongst makers :) very few low tech solutions out there commercially at the moment though; I guess it's a low profit margin game at that end of the market... As to being tied to Thetford for refills, really annoying for the consumer but who can blame them given how much investment must have gone into inventing this system, all the development work THEN convincing manufacturers to try it. They've got to be assured a return somehow otherwise they don't have a business; it's Rolls Royce's power by the hour concept or printers and ink cartridges all over again, mind you it's easy to replace your printer to a new system if the manufacturer starts taking he micky... not so much for jet engines or indus systems ;-)

@ianmason8713 2 года назад

I think that the most impressive thing about the indus system is, that finally, Thetford have managed to create a toilet that has a flush that goes all the way around the bowl. Instead of going half way and then dying out :)

@iainathairydog 2 года назад

The secret to a good flush is to clear (or remove) the mesh filter in front of the flush solenoid, and to turn a tap on just a tiny bit before flushing, so that the water pump is already at full pressure.

@davidmbell 2 года назад

What loo do you have Ian? If it's a manual flush C200 then there's a plastic clip that can break off the bottom of the pump that means it still flushes but is very weak. Let me know and I'll reply with more info.

@susanneward7029 2 года назад

This system seems to be closer to the holding tank system in most US RVs. One hose to empty both gray and black, black first with a rinse from the grey tank, except it’s more complicated and more expensive with the proprietary chemicals. And it eliminates the main convenience of a cassette, which you can empty in a number of different places, including a regular toilet.

@namespacetoosmall 2 года назад

Interesting system, but I’ll stick with my composting toilet. It uses only a little bit of vinegar, and I can go 6 to 8 weeks before emptying the solids… 🙂 Thanks for the video!

@onthefly4711 2 года назад

Exactly, probably everybody who has a composting toilet will never go back.

@ThreeFineWonders 2 года назад

What a fantastic system Thetford have devised for helping us part with guaranteed, regular payments for consumables. Well done..

@rclancey 2 года назад

Thanks for the comprehensive video. We've always put paper down for the larger jobs - we refer to it as the green cross code.

@petebird7171 2 года назад

Very good system, probably going to become an industry standard, nice work Andrew, 👍👍👍👍👍👍

@andrewseamaster 2 года назад

Absolutely fantastic. Should open lots of options in other areas and vehicles like yachts. Once the support and accessories come online we should be off an running. The emptying hose and unit is the 'Jobby Cannon' !

@stephenwills1986 2 года назад

Hello, hello, hello and hello 👋!! Been really looking forward to watching this one and learning more about the Indus system. You were very thorough as always Andrew, good work and thank you, it was very interesting to see. 👍👍👍

@GaetanHobby 2 года назад

Thank you Andrew for the review 🙂 Good tip for the toilet paper in the bowl 👍 I love the way you say "élégance" Andrew .your french accent is very good 👍 Big kisses from France 🇨🇵

@bill8784 2 года назад

Thumbs up for your placing loo roll in loo trick. I learnt same trick from my parent’s carers when using a commode.

@andrewlittle250 2 года назад

Very impressive and as a disabled person I can see the advantages. I only hope in future they might be able to design something similar for towing caravans.

@grahamjones4888 2 года назад

I can see the advantage for you but unless you’re on a super pitch, you would only be able to stay at a MH friendly site with the MH emptying point, unless you use what Andy said was available, a wheeled container, which would put you back to square one with a cassette? Emptying a mixed waste system would require quite a few trips?

@simonmansbridge1271 2 года назад

Thanks for a very informative video as always, as a plumber I have an absolute hate of macerators and as such would not want to take one on holiday with me, This is far to complicated and as your van ages will cause no end of heartache Remember KISS keep it simple Many thanks

@G-ra-ha-m 2 года назад

My thoughts too. The cassette is VERY versatile when in need, and very little to go wrong: also I trust my mechanical sympathy more than all that electric flap nonsense. Also my cassette works even with 0 power.

@chrisborgmotorhome 2 года назад

A very informative and good video. I will recommend people to watch it when I make a video of a motorhome that has the Indus system.

@andrewjditton 2 года назад

Cool, thanks!

@frankwbeveridge 2 года назад

Andrew, thanks for the shoutout. A very informative "bog vlog". It looks like a great system removing the walk of shame....well almost, you said there was a wheelie bin to come. By my reckoning it will need to huge, or maybe they are in talks with colapz. Maybe they can make it smaller if you/we can interrupt the "download" mode. I still love. If I didn't then I wouldn't buy a motorhome with one fitted. 👍🖖🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿

@yurydvukraev9385 2 года назад

Your show was so useful for me because I didn't know before how it work. Thank you very much.

@andrewjditton 2 года назад

You're welcome!

@norbertvannoesel 2 года назад

Happy days Andrew! Thanks 🙏

@andrewjditton 2 года назад

Glad you liked it Norbert! I did the best I could :)

@jaynehook2520 2 года назад

Very informative vlog, thank you so much xx

@lifeisagift.cherisheverymoment 2 года назад

Intelligent and diplomatic review. Very informative, thank you.

@k.j.hulander2204 2 года назад

Andrew, I very much enjoy the presentation in your videos. Your videos are a fantastic resource for prospective motorhome buyers. That said, and please do not take offence, these informational videos are just too long. Reviewing a product like this shouldn’t have to take over a half-hour. I still watch your videos because they are good but if I were to come across an interesting topic from an unknown youtuber, I’d be very hesitant to even play the video if it’s so long. 15 minutes is a more reasonable time. Just something you may wish to consider in the future. Best wishes!

@namespacetoosmall 2 года назад

I like the longer videos. Andrew is thorough, and that’s partly why he has his loyal subscribers, I bet.

@nabarnes 2 года назад

Andrew, I very much enjoy the presentation in your videos. Your videos are a fantastic resource for prospective motorhome buyers. These informational videos are just the right length. Reviewing a product like this needs a considered and detailed video which may well take over a half-hour. I watch your videos because they are good but if I were to come across an interesting topic from an unknown youtuber, I’d be very hesitant to even play the video if it’s so long since they don't have your depth of knowledge, repartee or bonhomie. Best Wishes!

@paulefc1971 2 года назад

I like the long videos, I guess people have different opinions - which is good, what I would say though is that Andrew has thoughtfully created and named chapters, so one could quite easily skip those that aren’t (in somebody’s opinion) relevant.

@andrewjditton 2 года назад

Thanks. To be fair to you, had I not had the trouble with breakages and failures, and had I had the motorhome for a longer time, I might have been able to make a more concise video. But shorter and more concise needs a lot of planning and scripting - two things I just did not have the time to do on this occasion. This is why I put chapters in the description. Thanks for watching.

@andrewjditton 2 года назад

Thanks Nick! Sadly I did not have the luxury of time with this one to be more planned and succinct.

@lindaelizabethcole3675 2 года назад

Very interesting Andrew , gosh haven't we come a long way from the yellow bucket and blue lid , we started with in our first 10ft Perle , an educational and informative video Andrew , happy travels

@peterwalton1502 2 года назад

Excellent Andrew 👍

@fulltimetonex438 2 года назад

Brilliant idea

@LisaMarli 2 года назад

Not septic tank friendly would be a big problem here in the US. Many rural camp grounds use septic tanks. In fact, they are restrictive on the waste water from some portable systems we have here. And the fact that you can't just do a grey water dump to extend your time in that case. The first thing I would do is order a spare set of chemicals. Those bottles don't look too big. But the No Septic Tanks is a deal breaker for me.

@whisthpo 2 года назад

Very unbiased product report! It's a marvellous marketing decision for Thetford..... We are getting too reliant on 'Smart' phones viewers

@bobfrost123 2 года назад

Tks. Fascinating. Continuous Cruiser on canals. Sticking with pump-out. 👍

@marcusoutdoors4999 2 года назад

That’s genius. Feels like work in progress, but great never the less.

@emiliehohner2531 2 года назад

excellent review. great t-shirt. it all seems a bit cumbersome and expensive (on the other hand, if one can afford this motorhome ...) but it is an innovative system and it will either develop or flop. also, it kind of makes me appreciate the simplicity of my 'porta potti' (Fiamma Bi-Pot 30) under the dinette-bed of my completely toiletless Freedom Caravan. ;o) ... but yeah, apples an pears, obviously.

@raibeart1955 2 года назад

Hi Andrew, There is also the extra cost to factor in. I suppose it could be said that if you can afford the rig you can afford to run it. However if you have spent your “life savings” on the motor home and you’ve the extra cost of the fluid , postage and packing if you are abroad could be a dealbreaker if you have no other way of sanitising your setup. All the best to you and yours.Rab

@richardcope3850 2 года назад

All great stuff and excellent video. For me the downside is when we get home that final cassette goes down the loo. I’d have no drain to empty the Indus system into so I’d have to leave it to ‘stew’ until my next visit to a site!

@michaelburt620 2 года назад

nice of Thetford to overly complicate whats already a nice simple process. No need

@Snedstige 2 года назад

I'm going the third path of bogs...: incineration. No cassette, no chemicals - just a bit more LPG... But this was really interesting. Thank you!

@marcindomik8975 2 года назад

I like it. Like any new idea I needs time to develop. I hope they will work their green way to it.

@Mads_1313 2 года назад

Hmm 🤔 I like the idea of going longer without having to empty, but not sure about the chemicals. Like you, I only eco or home-made products. As usual, very informative and balanced review 👍🏻

@paulrixon1644 2 года назад

Andrew. I have been following you for a very long time. You are very honest and extremely fair in your surveys. However the point I wish to make is in no way criticising you. But the toilet system! 1. Far to complicated.2. Very expensive to run.3.macerators are very unreliable! I cannot imagine the problems that users will have when abroad ! I can imagine the owners carrying a porta potti in case of trouble! It would be interesting to see a price list for parts and a guarantee?

@andrewjditton 2 года назад

Thanks for the kind words Paul. I imagine it's covered under the manufacturer's warranty, just as all the components are.

@peterhobbs7609 2 года назад

Great rounded and balanced Andrew, jury’s still out for me at the moment

@ManxAndy 2 года назад

Loving the fact that you need to “log” on to the app……how apt….👍🇮🇲😂. Thetford missed a trick, , their advert for the app, should be “ Swipe to wipe” ……lol 😂😂😂

@andrewjditton 2 года назад

I've just sprayed yogurt out of my nose reading that! Thanks for the best laugh I've had all day, Andy!

@ManxAndy 2 года назад

@@andrewjditton your welcome , sorry about the yogurt 👍💕🇮🇲😂

@darrenwilson8042 2 года назад

Early days - I am sure with feedback and experience Thetford will continually refine and tweek the system too

@scottwilson5426 2 года назад

Think this going to be a marmite situation.. but 2 things that worry me..1.. that plunger moved under pressure when emptying.. what if it toppled over? 2. As you said you can get a wheeled tank if you don't want to move the motor home.. can you imagine the size that would be( you can't just syphon a little off) so the whole system needs emptying.. try carting that to the chemical waste lol.. another "Wilheim Crapper" vid that super interesting and informative.. cheers guys!! Looking forward to the next.

@ericsassaalders1079 2 года назад

Let me first give compliments for those who try to make water systems in the campervan industry more efficient. So what Thetford is doing, is much appreciated. And i do love the idea of saving freshwater, by flushing toilet with grey water. And i also do like the idea of emptying the grey and black at the same time. But with the toilet you simply do not save that much water to stay longer off grid. Bigger black, grey, and fresh tanks do make you stay longer off grid. Showers are using the most amount of water and energy (warm water), and the toilet is using the least amount of water. Thetford or other manufacturers could better focus on a filtration system that makes from grey water, freshwater, so you can use the same water multiple times. These system exist on sailing yachts, so its not something that doesn’t exist. Its just still to big for a small campervan. Thanks for the video

@HiruS22 2 года назад

Can see this system falling by the wayside and being forgotten about in 5 years time. Loving your pronunciation of Burstner though 😁

@andrewbarker6991 2 года назад

I like it 👍👍👍👍

@Jungheinrick 2 года назад

Comprehensive and informative as always Andrew. Excellent review. I do think the system is too complicated and will probably be limited to a few high end motorhome and caravan builders like Burstner. I doubt many van conversion companies will buy in to the extra work needed to install it. I did think about the Thetford cassette cleaning machines (remember them?) which were the 'next revolution' in motorhome toilets a few years ago.....complicated and unreliable....wonder if Indus will be the same?

@andrewjditton 2 года назад

Thanks Chris. It's still early days for indus, only time will tell...

@I_Was_Chrispy_Kreme 2 года назад

This is almost a classic MBA business case. How to tie your customers into a premium product. For me the reuse of water is excellent, would be good to see something in the caravan line similar. But to be tied to one supplier given they could stop providing the chemicals at any point or double the price is risky.

@G-ra-ha-m 2 года назад

Reuse of water? I use my water showering and washing up, washing veg. Very very little gets used in the loo, the whole cassette is about 1 10L watering can - not a problem.

@I_Was_Chrispy_Kreme 2 года назад

@@G-ra-ha-m Hey Graham, what I meant was that in a normal caravan, you take potable water through your aquaroll into the shower & sink and back into a wastemaster. My comment wouldn't it be good if the waste water in the wastermaster could somehow feed the loo. I take your point about being only a small capacity for the loo, but if we are to attack climate change and be more green reuse of grey water I think is something to be looked into. Best wishes

@G-ra-ha-m 2 года назад

@@I_Was_Chrispy_Kreme Climate is dictated by the Sun, I doubt using 10L of extra water will affect that :D. But I agree about being green, I always use bio safe products in the loo, and of course avoid fluoride toothpaste, which is highly toxic and ends up on grey water. Overall, I think the huge number of things to go wrong with this system render it unfeasible: when you press a button and nothing happens... all the problems suddenly become very real :))

@hayard61 2 года назад

Thanks for that Mr D. I'm one of those on the fence about the whole system. I get the civilization bit and for that a big plus. But, to me, it seems rather faffy. We don't have an issue emptying our loo. It's much better than lugging the old Elsan bucket over to the toilet block. I get that some peeps don't like handling the waste and this idea stops that. Also, it's putting extra cost on leisure vehicles and it's more to go wrong. Does this rely on an app? It seems, these days, more and more things are shoved to our phones. What if my mobile phone is lost or stolen? Just a few thoughts of my own. In all, a good idea, but, maybe, not for me. 👍

@ErmittlerTV 2 года назад

I do buy my wife a cheap phone, so that we do have a back-up phone. 🙃

@davidhender1657 2 года назад

A very interesting video; thank you. Like you, I have a septic tank and so that is a "no" option for emptying. Wanting to travel in the UK, I am concerned about the emptying but as I intend converting a Mercedes Sitcar Beluga 2, there is plenty of locker space for the three tanks and they can be much bigger than on your RV. However, I am not sure as to why you cannot empty it into a septic tank, as when the tank is emptied, the tanker goes to the sewage works to unload the waste. I plan to go away for two weeks at a time so the tanks would have to be at least double the size of those on your RV. The other problem is that I do not have a smart phone. More research needed.

@rogerstarkey5390 2 года назад

Andrew. At 33:25 you lifted "the unit" and water dribbled. I think you should squeeze the blue button at that point, which would lower the silver bar and close the valve. (As you did later) Then, when you put "the unit" in the receptacle, there won't be any dribble. So, I think the order is: At the dump point Black carry handle up Blue button (seal the valve) Lift the unit Place it in the receptacle and spin to retract the hose. Lower the black handle. Push the tray in. Close the door! Flush with success (sorry)

@andrewjditton 2 года назад

Yep, I think you're right there Roger. This was my first time with a working unit...

@trevorclarke5203 2 года назад

Thanks for such an informative review of the indus system Andrew...my concern ,given that we are more concious about spreading germs (Covid -19), is related to the app on the phone; surely this is an ideal place for germs to congregate I know that not all will be as hygiene aware as others and as we generally carry our phones around with us I am not convinced about the wisdom of pairing with a phone! Thetford should just leave it to a panel sited in the van.

@andrewjditton 2 года назад

Good point, but to be fair, phones are generally personal items and we only use our own.

@andywass3196 2 года назад

I am old enough to admit that I used to rail against innovation electric windows, central locking etc.. bound to go wrong, not needed etc etc, and of course am now a happy user of all of this and more!!! But I can't help but think this system as presented at present has not enough advantages .... I think the exclusiveness of the cartridges and their 'un green' content are a distinct problem and the fact that you can't operate it without the app rule it out for me! Also the cost of the system, the installation costs and its complexity of installation and maintenance might be issues. It needs Thetford to underwrite its longevity in the market and invest in technician training, parts supply etc...... I'm not convinced at this stage! Thanks for highlighting and reviewing, onwards with great content Andrew!

@nothere7198 2 года назад

Seems like a simple update to the system to allow running some volume of the gray tank water into the black tank to better manage total capacity would be an idea. A function of the flush action logically. Of course, that will use more of the product, so I'm sure Thetford can get behind the idea lol. For myself, pass, no questions, easy decision. It's just more technology to break down and pricey limiting chemicals to restrict options. Thanks for the thorough review though !

@motorhomequest 2 года назад

How much does the Indus system add weight wise to the MH as oppose to a normal cassette toilet. I do go on extended 2 month plus trips so having to carry all the extra chemicals is going take a huuuge (matron) chunks out of my payload. Does this also mean I have carry grey waste all the time instead of doing the normal emptying before setting off.

@G-ra-ha-m 2 года назад

140L = 140kg

@paula.jackson5463 2 года назад

oh ya, Dougal Smirked on this one!!!!!!!

@mikeshacklock6208 2 года назад

Andrew I’d be interested to hear about 2 aspects not mentioned on this; 1-dealer service costs & schedule (annual/seasonal) 2-mechanical failsafes/backup for when the electrics die, due to batteries not charging/LB failure/no sun WRT solar & no mains hook-up, or simple fuse/breaker tripping in the middle of the night. Also if the system is ‘constantly on’ agitating even when not pumping what is the systems average daily electrical power consumption vs leisure battery capacity🤔❓

@andrewjditton 2 года назад

Good points, but not ones I was able to measure in my short time with the motorhome. I'd need a week JUST to do this one vlog for that... maybe I'll get a second go? ;)

@mick2d2 2 года назад

Certainly one big advantage is weight, or rather the lack thereof! My van has a C400 (19.3L) which is pretty heavy to move around and empty.

@colinrimmer789 2 года назад

Very clever piece of kit, I don’t like Apps for everything I try to avoid my phone on holiday could Thetford include an information panel in the van, or am I a Dinosaur? 😂😂

@iainathairydog 2 года назад

How about buying an old phone secondhand and sticking it to the wall?

@andrewjditton 2 года назад

A very valid point Colin. I also don't want screens on holiday because I look at screens all day every day!

@kimdeabill8540 2 года назад

Good call. Perhaps like our Truma iNet we could have both options.

@dangerdaveofdevon 2 года назад

Hi Andrew. Good stuff!. 1) what happens to food waste which gets drained with the grey water? Is their a filter which requires maintenance? 2) Frost protection. Any issues there?. Think the cassette will continue at the lower end of the market!

@andrewjditton 2 года назад

Good questions Dave. Not sure about a filter - there is none I came across. As for frost protection, the tanks are all inboard and the Alde heating should take care of that. Cheers!

@raymondpiper4792 2 года назад

Thanks for that Andrew, one thing I wasn’t clear on was how do you empty your fresh tank excess before setting off, does it drain through the Indus system or is there a separate fresh drain.

@andrewjditton 2 года назад

Hi Raymond, there are separate fresh tank valves which I show in the full review.

@rickyard11 2 года назад

Great review Andrew. I wonder if they will do a version for caravans hooked up to a “serviced pitch”?

@kimdeabill8540 2 года назад

Guessing they wouldn't need to unless it's septic or green. Interested in how the major clubs feel about it.

@richardarnold3812 2 года назад

Will the waste unit and the cupboard it resides in need sanitising from time to time to keep it "sweet"?

@andrewjditton 2 года назад

I'd imagine so!

@philipbrown4602 2 года назад

Wonderful idea, I do wonder about the serviceability and the fact it seems to have 3 motors. How easy is it to change the pump and service the system?

@tagoooU 2 года назад

Could you just flush a lot to move gray water into the black tank when the gray gets too full?

@flybyairplane3528 2 года назад

ANDREW,,, HALOOOO, long time, THETFORD, I know of but not this system, The best ‘PORTO POTTY. there is someone I follow, was comparing toilets., so there he sat out in the OPEN SITTING ON IT,showing how it works , prior , had a HYMER AKTIV 2.0 with a cassette . Stay well, take care, cheers 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿🇬🇧🏴󠁧󠁢󠁷󠁬󠁳󠁿🇺🇸

@chrisdenison6550 2 года назад

Another brilliant Video Andrew - my negatives are as follows: (1) Availability of product - whilst in the road? (2) What happens when there's a problem with the operation? Currently my cassette is fixable by me 😉 (3) as you suggested grey water tank would need to be bigger! 👌 My positives: Great system for off grid! You mentioned a movable tank for use onsite if you didn't want to he moving your MH every 5-7 days? In addition I've recently purchased “Bob” and they also gave an app ordering system which is directly linked to Bob. I organised this to be delivered to our site in Carnac no problems. (however they are based in Paris Fr 😉. Cheers Chris “The Aussie living in the Netherlands “ 🇦🇺 btw looking seriously at family trip to the Hebrides next Summer 2022!!

@andrewjditton 2 года назад

That's right Chris, you CAN buy a wheeled tank if you want to remain in situ. But it's North of £300... Maybe see you next summer!

@kimdeabill8540 2 года назад

@@andrewjditton Jeez second mortgage time.

@MakeDoAndMend1 2 года назад

Just wondering. If you cannot use sceptic tanks . Where do you empty it. I've never been on a site that toilet waste is allowed down grey waste disposal. But I must admit the system looks good and easy to use.

@eddiedownes9084 2 года назад

Andrew, have you had any feedback from sites, especially the two major UK clubs, as to whether they will accept Indus waste down the grey disposal drains? Also, did you notice ant tissue residue on the grid you used for disposal, or is the macerator and final rinse really that good?

@andrewjditton 2 года назад

Hi Eddie, I've not had the opportunity to ask the Clubs. There was a tiny bit of tissue residue on the grille, but that was easily sloshed off with one pass of the treated grey water.

@eddiedownes9084 2 года назад

@@andrewjditton Thanks Andrew

@geoffconway8077 2 года назад

An excellent review. Thanks . I've just visited a CAMC site. Upon booking in the Warden was quite specific with their instruction that the motorhome service point was for the emptying of grey water only and not black. As an alternative I think an Indus user could on that occasion have parked near an outside Chemical disposal point as the hose would probably have reached. Because of that sort of issue I think that whilst the system may be ready for use, there is presently not an adequate infrastructure available in UK campsites to make it a viable option.

@eddiedownes9084 2 года назад

If that means Indus cannot be discharged other than black waste points, as a gravity drain system it would need to go into another container before depositing in the CDP. That does seem to make the system less efficient. Thetford need to do more research and negotiation with the clubs to make this useable on both sets of club sites.

@sprucelodge 2 года назад

Hi Andrew , after spending time in both the Hymer and the burstner , which Motorhome do you prefer, or giving a choice which one would you keep.

@andrewjditton 2 года назад

Both! Well, the best of both :)

@leannearnold8326 2 года назад

Great for drive over disposal points...will it still work in a "raised disposal point" like we have in the UK?? ..... assuming you can drive close enough to the emptying point 🤔

@andrewjditton 2 года назад

I would imagine so Leanne, as the waste is pumped rather than relying on gravity.

@birdingbilly 2 года назад

Far to complex - last thing you want is the bog conking out - I'll stick with the cassette thanks

@davidmbell 2 года назад

Some of the plastics on the “dooowhatsit” depositing thang (with the blue handle) seem brittle or at least by the sound they made as you were discussing how the handle folds. Maybe the handle could do with some bright yellow arrows for folding etc.

@matcharlie2379 9 месяцев назад

Did you empty in to the grey waste disposal point?

@iainathairydog 2 года назад

I would certainly not buy a motorhome with this system. Here's why: 1. Too much to go wrong. Macerators are notoriously unreliable in buildings. I can't image they're better in a motorhome. Even the ISS has macerator issues! 2. I don't go to places where there is a black waste disposal point within reach of a short hose. Grey waste, rarely. Black waste: only on Aires in Europe. 3. There's no need. A toilet cassette lasts us four days with two people using it (tip: flush the absolute minimum). A 48 litre Really Useful box in the boot holds the spare cassette. So we can manage 8 days between empties. And the water and grew waste tank are both good for a fortnight. 4. All those chemicals! One sachet of bio laundry liquid is good for a cassette. That's the only chemical we use, apart from a couple of 2-litre bottles of cheap diet coke to rinse out the grey waste tank once a year. So we can empty the grey waste down any drain, empty the black waste down any toilet or sewerage manhole. 5. It's all too much to go wrong, more stuff using precious power, more unnecessary weight. The whole concept reminds me of the con of inkjet printer cartridges where you pay eye-watering prices for miniscule amounts of ink. With this, you're locked in to buying Thetford bottle of chemicals. Though I suspect that adding a "top up" hole (with a screw lid) to each of those cartridges will be one of the first things some people will do. This system seems to be a step in the wrong direction for me.

@CliffordDive 2 года назад

It's designed to drain into grey water waste points, not black waste points.

@iainathairydog 2 года назад

@@CliffordDive tipping dilute sewage into a grey waste drain is not going to be acceptable. I'm sure Thetford claim that it is treated waste, but the precautionary principle applies.

@CliffordDive 2 года назад

@@iainathairydog - I'm inclined to agree. I can't see the Caravan Club feeling easy about it!

@iainathairydog 2 года назад

@@CliffordDive oh, I suspect that if they get a good share of the £30 per month (a pound a day!) it's reputed to cost, I expect they'll overcome their scruples.

@G-ra-ha-m 2 года назад

@@iainathairydog Agreed, esp. as it's not septic tank safe (= very nasty chemicals). Way too much to go wrong, even the flap is electric. Also impossible to empty without moving the van. It's a complex disaster, and what's with the smart phone?!?! A small LCD would be cheap and easy.

@markpullinger7324 2 года назад

Hi Andrew how do you change the 3x bottles Great idea Thank you 😊

@andrewjditton 2 года назад

You just release the blue clip, and switch them over. I can't believe how much I missed when so many people are complaining that the video is way too long and detailed!

@sekainiheiwa3650 Год назад

i didnt get it what is these septic not septic tanks friendly?

@keithfry9620 2 года назад

We use Happy Bowl in our toilet it's so clean and easy.

@jenrai8312 2 года назад

So if I don't have a pitch with waste emptying on it then I have to move the motorhome every time I need to empty the system?

@andrewjditton 2 года назад

No, you can get a wheeled tank which I mention at the end. But it's over €300!!!!

@Lucy_Bayard_John 2 года назад

Nice, I haven’t find the cost of the system and for the cartridges?

@richardfisher4202 Год назад

How long between emptying for how many people? One? Two? I'm intending to travel with 4 people, so how long can I go before emptying?

@anneshirley1748 2 года назад

Bog Vlog!! Very apt! That was quite funny in parts, I had to laugh at your descriptive perception of the most natural thing (well that & a couple of other things which we won't go into!) that we have to do!! The 3 Ps made me snigger! Honest and truthful again! You're very sincere which is why you have such a big following! Oh and Dougal is a big attraction too! Coming to an end?! Looking forward to the full review! Then you are back towing the Airstream and taking her home finally! Safe travels, see you in the next one! Hugs xxx 🐕🇩🇪😘

@kimdeabill8540 2 года назад

We had a split second... What's the third p? moment.

@steveb1856 2 года назад

Never mind the bog, Andrew where can I get one of those wonderful tee shirts?

@andrewjditton 2 года назад

From the lovely people at Culla Creative in Benbecula! www.cullacreative.com/

@onthetracks 2 года назад

Am I correct in saying that your grey tank was almost full but that there was plenty of space in the black tank? If so as you were flushing with grey water couldn't you just flush the toilet a few times to free up grey storage? Obviously this would use some chemicals but it would release some capacity.

@andrewjditton 2 года назад

I did try that, but it doesn't seem to do it in sufficient quantity to make a difference.

@victoriabergner 2 года назад

We have the car and just love the Elegance and particularly the Indus system. Ps. By the way… u can actually empty the greywater seperately if u like. Ds.

@andrewjditton 2 года назад

Interesting! I spoke to the guy who actually designed it, and he told me that you can't! What's the secret?

@ecyfoto 2 года назад

Does the Thetford rinse the black water tank and if not can you do so manually? Also you should wear gloves regardless.

@anitajohannadrost 2 года назад

Interesting 👍😁🇳🇱🍃🍂🍄

@swdman1234 2 года назад

I'll quote something I saw on Simon Jefferson's channel, Powerfuluk, where he says we are early adopters of new technology . Somebody has to take the first step towards a new way of doing things.

@keithwelton 2 года назад

There should be a way of, partly or fully, emptying the grey water to give greater flexibility in using the system. How does this system compare to having a “marine “ toilet with a macerator?

@AJandH_Wanderings 2 года назад

Interesting and informative review - thank you. With regards to emptying the system, I noticed you looked for locations through the App - am I right in assuming that Thetford have "signed up" sites that will accept emptying of this system? - presumably they are in negotiations for more or will it be left to organisations like C&CC and C&MC to accept it do you know?

@andrewjditton 2 года назад

Like the donut that I am, I forgot to check the app for locations in the UK. I'm sure Thetford will be able to give you an answer though. Thanks for watching.

@vrugtmanable 2 года назад

Thetford could have incorperated a "bidet" function! 😁

@susanneward7029 2 года назад

Great idea, as long as they don’t use the grey water for it.

@kimdeabill8540 2 года назад

@@susanneward7029 Yep I don't fancy yesterday's curry washing up water cleaning my bits. Mr D said, after spitting his tea out when I read your comment out loud, "goodness gracious great balls of fire". 🤣🤣

@richardfisher4202 Год назад

Is it possible to order bigger holding tanks?

@andrewjditton Год назад

Hi Richard, this will depend on the motorhome manufacturer. I believe that Thetford can make different sizes of tank.

@yayasdt2738 2 года назад

👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍

@helenanderson6874 2 года назад

Love it!! Just wish the chemicals were green, until they are I wouldn’t consider it 😢 such a shame as it looks a really good system.

@kimdeabill8540 2 года назад

Asked Andrew the same about the cartridges, are they recyclable, or even better could we send them back and get a cheaper refilled one back? But like the ink cartridge tech. I'm not going back to blue either.

@rhinogooner 2 года назад

I was thinking this could not be fitted to caravans because of moving to an emptying point. We don’t tour but stay on a site for full trip. But you mentioned a wheeled tank so in theory, baring in mind you would probably need extra tanks in the van, it would be possible to fit in a caravan in the future. Are Thetford looking at this because I would say there are more caravans on the road than motorhomes so from a business point of view it be in there interest to look at this.

@doug1olson 2 года назад

Interesting system. It would have been nice to have some indication of the cost of the system. Since that wasn’t mentioned I can only assume that it is quite expensive.

@juttapelzer6632 2 года назад

Still not sure what to think of it. You cleary showed the pros and cons. At the end of the video when you emptied the system successfully the pros where quite obvious and I found myself smiling, the idea of a quick and non smelly release of (black/grey) wastewater is very tempting. We'll see if the system becomes more spread and long term users can share their experiences. 1 question (I may have missed it): did you mention/do you know how long the cartridges last until they need to be changed/refilled? And thanks for your commitment. Jutta

@andrewjditton 2 года назад

Hi Jutta, yes, the emptying process really is the future. The cartridges last about a month in 'normal' use, which I'd bear out with my experience.

@davidmbell 2 года назад

We buy Andrex wipes that say they’re ‘certified for flushing’. Would they not be ok in this either?

@andrewjditton 2 года назад

I would very much think not. But then I don't believe a word about 'certified for flushing'! Certified by whom? Their mother?

@JeffInDFW 2 года назад

In the USA, the dump stations have an actual connector. You pull your sewer hose out of your RV, and connect it to the dump station with a locking connector. When the presenter turned on the system and the end of the dump hose jerked and twisted slightly as the fluids came down the hose, all I could think was "OH MY GOD IT IS GOING TO TIP OVER AND SPRAY THE ENTIRE AREA IN POO!". Also, if you do not have a system that grinds up the black tank contents, don't you end up with poo logs and toilet paper all over the grate openings when you dump it?

@philipbrown4602 2 года назад

Second comment. Will it still work in 10 years? Having said that, well done Thetford for developing the system.

@jeanne_margaret 2 года назад

Oop to early in the am for this lol be back after breakfast xo

@MakeDoAndMend1 2 года назад

Is it legal to put masserated human waste down the grey water waste system pipes etc. I don't know the answer. Eg Would you put masserated waste down the same drain as house roof gutter system. Cheers from old George

@andrewjditton 2 года назад

In about 80% of cases George, once those drains go under the ground, the waste ends up in exactly the same sewer pipe.

@MakeDoAndMend1 2 года назад

@@andrewjditton Thanks Andrew for replying. You must have lots of questions. Happy motorhoming and kisses to Dougal. Cheers from old George and Jane 🇬🇧👫

@nomadnotmad6196 2 года назад

Was that you who just drove past me getting on the ferry at Uig? 🙂🤔 - We just got back onto Skye after a 3 week tour of Uist, Harris & Lewis, inspired by your videos.

@andrewjditton 2 года назад

Yes it was... nearly home :)

@Kenta59 2 года назад

First, there must be leftovers under the handle that soils the shelf were it is between emptying, and I saw it was dripping on the hose when you lifted it Second, in Sweden we have different places for gray and blackwater, how do I solve that?