@@theodorocapeletti3372 even with double damage, the Giga loses 60% of its life to Carcha (both wild) and loses even more when both tamed(there is no tie, the giga wins with even more difficulty than a wild)
i fell like they should not change it much its way too iconic at this point just minor changes in texture and apperence and if there is a tlc they should 100% add mechanics ,for arguably the most iconic creature in ark its too barebones and basic and new and better animations too would be really nice.
I’m glad we have the carc even if it isnt as strong, I don’t fuck with gigas if I can help it, it’s nice to have something that’s at least in the same region of power
Giga still gives me nightmares because the first time I met one it emerged from the forest and evicted me from my base. I had to give up on everything.
@@AaaaNinjaFirst time i thought it was a rex and tryed taming it and it destroyed my base killed my trike and carno and chased my raft down and destroyed it back in 2016
@@thestorm5526 recently had a giga kill 5 of my rexes and my own giga because it woke up instantly at half consciousness. Learned my lesson to never take it out of the trap untill its tamed
It's simple, if the Carcha has max bloodrage stats it wipes the giga with a prim saddle and similar stats to the Carcha, without it's bloodrage the giga wipes the Carcha, personally I choose the Carcha because it doesn't rage when taking alot of damage but that's just my preference tho
A long tome ago. Someone lured a giga to my base. Since I basically lived underneath giga spawn. It killed a few of my dinos. But luckily I had my top stat giga. He was able to save some dinos. Then I moved into higher ground further away from giga spawn.
the carcha would not beat the giga despite being in a frenzy, don't forget that the giganotosaurus causes bleeding, with that it would kill the carcha very quickly
Spinonya kena 1 hit sama giga soalnya spino itu kalo wild darahnya 700 (kalo lvl 1) Dan wild giga darahnya 80k dan bisa ngedamage 500 + bleeding damage
Well yeah. Looking up their base stats would tell you that despite having equal hp, a Carcharodon with no kill stacks deals exactly half the damage a Giga of the same lvl does. The Carcharodon would need to have TWICE the melee stats just to have the same dps as a Giga without stacks.
If both are high lvl the carch is better if the points are out right, that could maybe only be true for tamed carches and gigas but i think its true for both
I dont think its really a faie fight, especially using wild stats, wild gigas have insane dmg even at low level, the carcha needs to build up stacks to be at its full potential when tamed
TBH I like Carcha better bc its faster, easier to tame, more fun, doesnt rage, its easier to tame and more fun too and it has a great turning radius, maybe not as strong as giga but still incredibly powerful and i think it balances out
Это не до конца честная битва, ведь кархо может быть и сильнее, но механика Гиги в том что чем он слабее, тем сильнее он бьет. А кархо динозавр который любит убивать, и поэтому он становится сильнее только после убийства
He tamed the carchar and maybe not the giga. They both get ridiculously nerfed after they’re tamed. Plus the carchar needs to be on a killing spree for its damage to be decent. Not saying it would win but it would be much closer.
