Carly Smithson Without You Studio Version - video 

Carly is truly a gift from above. Love this voice. So pure and so powerful...amazing.

wow oh wow! That range! wow!

She has an awesome voice!

I was sucha big fan of hers and so mad that she did not make it farther...when i do my idol list of the best she is in the top 3

Thanx for making/posting this video...I LOVE Miss Carly!! ps. love the way that the only part that was in sync with her singing was that last note! Nice Touch :) SO extremely happy that she's safe!!!! I think she would sing "MEMORY" from cats AMAZINGLY for ALW night! :) GO CARLY!!! i love the full length version...can't get enough of it!

So brilliant! So far my favourite version! Last favourite was Clay Aiken's!

Carly Smithson... Need I say more? She is amazingly talented, comedic, and witty. Thanks So Much voters for kicking her off! Not. Carly is awesome and she did not deserve to be Voted off. At all.

I LOVE YOUR STUFF! you ROCK! Bummed about Carly... VOTING for David COOK. The guy is amazing!

Nice video and clips. Needs more views.

Mariah liked Carly and so do I.

If you're still around you got no thumbs down :P