Yeah berrynose was just like oh he’s dead let’s not talk about it. Same with bumblestripe and I didn’t even REMEMBER that rosepetal was dead until I saw this. Veil of shadows did NOT do a very good job in that regard.
Tbh it’d be nice actually if Mistystar retired for her last life and was an elder for a couple of books. Like, 1-3 books at max, then she dies peacefully. She’s been kicking for a really, really long time, and I think she deserves a bit of rest before she goes.
@@beginnersweater [Spoilers for people who haven't read TBC] And then Berrynose dies without any attention given to it whatsoever other than one word, which is his name, when Bristlefrost is looking at the dead cats after a battle
Moonkitti would definitely be the Hussie of Warriors and I am rooting for her to write to the Erins to continue the series to either kill off or revive or do whatever with who she wants after it ends
Emysry same. Personal headcanon that there’s something funky in the star clan air since almost all non medicine cats who go there for major events get new personality d20 rolls. Be if for nine loves or dying.
Moonkitti: don’t kill Stemleaf Erins: :kills Stemleaf: Moonkitti: kill Berrynose, but special Erins: :kills Berrynose, but not too special I don’t think:
@@cateraderer6435 Someone killed him in the Veil of Shadows series. I can't remember how or who, I just remember him dying and me about to burst into tears b/c he was one of my favourite characters . 😢
@@grub4750 Same, I think he was killed by Fakestar (fake Bramblestar) along with Conefoot and Dapletuft when they tried to kill him in a surprise attack
“She’s a cat that resembles someone who basically died twice. Either make her immortal or kill her brutally, nothing in between.” That caught me off guard so much lol
She means the original cats as in the cats that became known in the very, very beginning of Into The Wild, like Ravenpaw, Firepaw, Bluestar, Longtail, Tigerclaw, Lionheart, etc.
@@Moonkitti yea but...but.....IT STILL SUCKED. Like it's up there with Stonefur in terms of harshness. Ohhhhh IT IS-Firestar was just too late to save Stonefur and his daughters were JUST too late to save Larksong. Oh God.
Susan Crotchfelt the Wolf-Chalk but how could a seagull pick up a dog xD. Think of the size of a owl and then the size of an owl, how the hell could an owl pick up Ambermoon
How about my list :> Bramblestar Bramblestar Bramblestar Bramblestar Bramblestar Bramblestar Bramblestar Bramblestar Bramblestar Mistystar Mistystar Mistystar Mistystar Mistystar Mistystar Mistystar Mistystar Leader of Windclan x9 Leader of Shadowclan x9 Me x9. (Wait... Waht?)
My list Kill Bramblestar Kill Thornclaw Kill Harestar Kill Tigerheartstar Kill Mistystar Kill Leafstar Kill Reedwhisker Kill Graystripe because he has nothing better to do Kill someone else from WindClan Kill someone else from ShadowClan Please kill Berrynose
Moonkitti: I have a list of cats to end The List: Bramblestar Bramble star Bramblestar Bramble star Bramble star Bramblestar Bramble star Bramble star Bramblestar Bramble star Bramble star Bramblestar Bramble star Bramble star Bramblestar Bramble star Bramble star Bramblestar Bramble star
I swear if HollyLeaf was alive I’d put her on the “do not kill” list I like her character so much! I was kinda pissed when they killed her of just to add Dovewing. I liked her because I’ve never seen a character more bound to the warrior code than HollyLeaf! And her heart literally broke when she found out her birth was against the warrior code and it was so sad! HollyLeaf is my favourite cat!
I’m late but I honestly would think its hilarious if there was a new prophecy dream with jayfeather in it being like “so water will rush and idiots will grow, but if you don’t do what Starclan says you’re not only an imbecile but you will also die in a very dramatic way for pure sheer because honestly the prophecy is all that makes you special”
Honestly, Thunderclan has been the main clan for ages now. It’d be great to have a series from a different clan’s perspective. Preferably RiverClan. Although they may be completely forgotten by Erin Hunter soon enough 😐
Spoilers for the two newest books: Well, with Frostpaw and Sunbeam both outside of ThunderClan, and Nightheart smack in the middle of moving clans...let's just say, I hope your hope is right.
keyaq yes on a patrol. But make it epic. Attacked on a patrol? He’s been training his whole life for this. They are ambushed, he tried to tell one of the apprentices to warn the clan but there are to many enemies. He manages to lead his patrol out of the fight together, one couldn’t escape on their own. They try to get away but the enemy is right on their heels. Thornclaw stops in a choke point, in between to large thorn bushes or something and takes them all on while telling the patrol to keep running. He fights them with the strength of Lionclan using the space to his advantage only fighting a few at a time and buying enough time for his clan mates to get away. But eventually he is overwhelmed and killed, he dies surrounded by wounded enemies, knowing he did his duty... his duty to this patr- Thunderclan.
“Bramblestar needs to die. I don’t care how or why, he just needs to die.” Lets have him get murdered to death by all the annoying cats in the series such as... Bumblestripe.. Berrynose... and we can’t ever forget the cat that was only mentioned once in a special edition, Pickle.
unfortunately your condition about Berrynose's death was not granted. BUT GREAT STARCLAN I'm so glad the Erins had the sense to kill him regardless of the details of his death
I kinda wanted Stormcloud to do...something. Either have kits or have a more productive role like when he helped Sparkpelt. Maybe he might have kits with a she cat (Cherryfall or Hollytuft whoever) he visits the nursery and eventually decides he wants to be like Daisy. Or maybe one day there's something only he can help the clan with cuz he was a kittypet.
Moonkitti: **lists background characters who mean nothing to anyone** Me: *lmao who's that again* Edit: I read Squirrelflight's Hope and I still don't know who anyone is
I kinda wish they would, in a way, hit "the reset button" on warriors. New readers might have a hard time reading the eternal number of books. They could have some foreign enemy come in and kill/drive out the clans. Maybe have the next arc have the pov from a loner/kitty pet. They could somehow meet an old clan cat (who managed to survive) or a descendant of a clan cat who explains the clans and maybe help them rebuild the clans. You would still need some prexistitiing knowledge but not nearly as much.
I second this. It’d also be an opportunity to re-ground the series after all of the reincarnation, powers, and heaven vs. hell stuff. I, personally, really didn’t like those plots and I ended up dropping the series after I read Dark River. Part of what I liked about the books were how it really felt like what an actual colony of feral cats could be like if they were sapient with a small pinch of mysticism. Resetting the clans could help with that problem, though there could be an argument that it’d be too much like Dawn of the Clans.
Firestar and Bramblestars personality is "Main Character" , which consists of: *Almost always having mercy on anyone *Being Generically Kind *Help anyone with anything *Be powerful, attractive, and highly respected
Except Bramblestar in Squirrelflight's Hope, who wanted to let a cat die really badly and only used the 'starclan must approve' excuse to not be a murderer
@@legrandliseurtri7495 He is. But he got possessed in Lost Stars, Squirrelflight's Hope takes place before Lost Stars, so he's just a jerk in that one before the new arc
"either of bristlefrost's siblings can be killed off at any time for character development" bristlefrost: *dies for rootspring's character development*
Dovewing should also die proving how much ShadowClan means to her now. Preferably, I'd like to see her die defending another ShadowClan cat, or a few from say a badger, and not an important one like one of her kits, Tigerstar, Puddleshine or Cloverfoot. She should die protecting Snaketooth, Hollowspring, Stonewing, Sparrowtail or someone like that!
or maybe she could go on a mission to climb a beanstalk to save her clan from a giant! (prefferably with cinnamon tail, the best cat ever by her side.)
This name is still funny. Also, yes, I'd love to get rid of Dove. Well, to be fair, I haven't read anything post-dawn of the clans (order of release I mean), so I can't really judge Dovewing I guess.
“Make breezepelt kill crow star” This is Raggedstar and Brokenstar all over again..... Thanks for the likes!!! Edit: ahhhhh 500 likes thanks so much!!!