To Eun Woo: We have not forgotten about Moonbin. There are still people out there that remember. However, the honest truth is that we did not know him personally, but you did. He was your friend, in your group, in your life daily. We will not feel his loss like you feel his loss. I know the hole is never quite filled, but I hope you find your peace in living, and live the life that Moon Bin was not able to live.
noone forgot Moonbin. His fans aroung the globe are still craving justice for Moonbin eager to know what happened to him and why it had happened. It's Astro and the company try to ride Moonbin's popularity once again to push their agenda on the one hand and pretend nothing weird and unexplained happened on the other. But the worst of them is Eunwoo who is not only using Binnie again but tries to convert the tragedy into his own very private sorrow bragging his tears everywhere. Everyone can see Eunwoo pushed Sanha's career through Moonbin while Binnie was alive. Where were his tears at that time and why was he indifferrent to Binnie's tears?
Das einzige was ich sehe ,ist das Eun woo um Moonbin weint und er nicht will das er vergessen wird. Was auch nicht passieren wird. Moonbin war glücklich in seiner Gruppe aber auch sehr traurig innerlich man hat es in bestimmten Videos gesehen ,kein Lächeln und hat versucht sich zurück zu ziehen ,er wollte nicht gefilmt werden aber er musste mit machen und so tun als wäre alles in Ordnung. Ich kann verstehen das @semidash so denkt ,den nur Eunwoo sieht man in Videos das er um Moonbin weint und die anderen nicht und ja es ist wahr das sie weiterhin ausgenutzt werden und das nicht auf ihre Gesundheit geachtet wird .Denkt mal darüber nach wieviele Stunden Sie täglich arbeiten und wenig Schlaf sie bekommen das geht auf Dauer nicht man geht seelisch und körperlich kappt daran . Sie sind/waren noch jung aber auch sie werden älter und bekommen es zu spüren und nur sie können es ändern .
@@semidashпочти год ребята молчали. Вы все обвиняли в этом их что они не переживают и молчат, что им все равно на смерть друга. Сейчас ребята наконец то нашли в себе силы говорить о Мунбине вы опять обвиняете их. Оказывается слезы фальшивые и горе тоже фальшивое. Ну конечно, вы же больше переживаете за смерть незнакомого по сути человека, чем ребята которые прожили вместе с ним 8 лет. 24 часа в сутки, 7 дней в неделю! Вам не угодить, хейтеры они везде одинаковые. Не плачешь - плохо, плачешь - ещё хуже.
Only sleep 3 hours per week??!!! 😮😮 my love.. its not good at all! Be careful for your health! We already lost Moonbin for the stress and loss of sleep! So it's true what I read about Korea, that they work too much, are overstressed and the rate of heart attacks is the highest in the world! Please take care of your health dear Eun Woo.❤
Moonbin was "forgotten" by the agency, on which Eunwoo works by the way, but not by his fans. The agency did everything people forgot asap how they neglected Bin's wishes, talent and health, and for some time only fans reminded the world about Moonbin.
Eunwoo, this takes courage. Astro is still healing and MoonBin will never be forgotten. I know Astro members will remember Bin forever since you lived together for 7-8 years; 24/7 days and you've been through a lot together as a group. Hopefully one day, you'll be okay. We miss you Bin....we miss you Astro. Love and Aloha from Hawaii.
Assalamualaikum insyaallah Jodoh punya alasan cantik ngk orang lain ya Allah kasih kan alasan masik sendiri belum nikah dulu kasih kan alasan pernah nangiss cariii kakak cocok jodoh baik Alhamdulillah 😂😂❤❤❤Jangan putus asa cinta baik tuhan makasih😢nama pinter
Quiero mandarle un mensaje a Cha eun woo... porfavor sé feliz,no te sientas culpable, Bin..lo quisiste todo lo que pudiste en vida y aun ahora lo Amas con toda tus fuerzas. Eres muy valiente y tienes mucha fuerza y te admiro por eso. Bin no quisisera que tú NUNU estés triste y menos quisiera verte mal. A Bin siempre lo tendremos presente pero también quiero ver bien,sano y fuerte. Porfavor sé muy feliz con todo lo que hagas. Como me gustaría poder consolarte. Te mando un gran abrazo desde CHILE 🇨🇱
I didn't know who Astro was until Moon Bin´s dead. I was learning about it through Eun Woo´s acting career and that memorable performance of the Moons siblings just a month ago. I knew him through random idol´s videos and I used to think how handsome Binnie was. But in that performance with Moon Sua he has just stunning. Suddenly one day I opened twitter and saw the news. I cried so hard because I felt his death so close to me. I am a 44 years old woman who has lost his own son 2 years prior. At the time of Binnie´s dead my own boy would've been 22. And I thought: oh no Lord please don't . I mourned him as a mother cause I was thinking about his own mom and his little sister. It hit me so hard that from that day till now I pray for him during the mass. So no my dear EunWoo, honey we won't´forget him. I'll pray for him like I pray for my own boy. He was so young and he will be always missed. Keep working but take care of your health first. We've had enough of losses for the time being.
Jamas será olvidados x su fans y arohas ,fue olvidado x su empresa y manager x su público nunca será olvidado el era GRANDIOSAMENTE UN GRAN ARTISTA UN GENIO Y BELLO Mi ANGEL BINNIE ❤🫶🍀🪻🇦🇷🌙
I remember Moonbin, R.I.P. It is still so sad to me that he is gone. I remember when I heard the news about his passing and was in shock. I don't even know him personally, so I can't begin to know how hard it is for his family and friends. Losing people you love is a painful process that never really heal, because when you think you have a handle on it, it hits you out of nowhere. I hope that his family and friends will whole tightly to the good memories they shared with him and know that it's ok that they are sad whenever they are.
Don’t bury yourself with work. You need to grieve in order to heal. There is nothing wrong with that. You are a human being after all. You maybe an artist on stage or on cam, but you are still entitled to feel your own emotions. Cry if you feel like it. Get angry if that helps. Feel sad if you need to. Just let it out of your chest. You lost a friend & that will never be easy. But he would want you to make the first step in healing yourself. You don’t need fame, nor money to heal. You just need peace. I hope you find it. Just give yourself some time to breathe.
cha eunwoo when i saw this tvn i cried it was very sad 😢 but trust me it's hard to forget our Moonbin he was a great personality and a great person he loved you and he deserves to be remembered with respect and I will pray that you feel a little better, take care ❤❤😢😢💔🕊🕊
Quando ele aparecer em seu sonho faça uma oração ao acordar com isso você vai se sentir bem melhor e então saberá que ele está bem mais quer você fique bem também e o guarde no coração pois do coração não se apaga lembra se só de coisas e momentos que nos deixam felizes Deus é contigo sempre ❤️
What I want to say to Cha Eun Woo it’s: “ Hold on through the storm, for the sun will shine again and bring new hope and possibilities”. Suicide doesn’t make it okay for the other person, it just makes the other people sad, then they might commit sucide. I haven’t forgotten about Moonbin. I miss him so much, the group just isn’t the same without him, he brought so much Joy, Moonbim was always trying to make others happy that deep inside, he didn’t make himself happy and just couldn’t share his feelings, when you share your feelings, it opens a sense of peace, because that’s all you feel like you needed to go on. I miss Moonbin so much, the suicide really damaged Cha Eun Woo’s health, I wish I could hug him and tell him it’s okay, but this suicide didn’t make anything better, it just made people that loved Moonbin go through deeper pain, I feel sad everyday, because I remember when Astr0 was in Love revenge” the show on Viki Rakuten. And if hurts to see that Moonbin isn’t here anymore.😢 as fans we are all damaged, but Cha Eun Woo is damaged more because he’s known him for more then us fans did. I am so sorry Astro, I hope to see Moonbin someday as well.
Oh mas foi suicídio mesmo? Mesmo que tenha sido ele não pode se culpar pois isso pode prejudicar física e mentalmente. Infelizmente foi uma escolha do amigo fazer isso..
Moonbin is not forgotten. I miss him soooo much and cry every time I see him in a video. He was an amazing humang being. He will never be forgotten!!!😢
In his very busy life, he admitted that he had experienced it, but that doesn't mean it was often. But during this time he also lacked sleep, it was evident under his eyes.
Sanha tette túl magàt a leg hamarabb.Ő fêltékeny volt Binura mert szerelmes Nunuba .Most boldog,hogy Nunu csak az Övé úgy hogy nem kell nagyon sajnálni.😢
Espero que a medida que verbalice su dolor y sentimientos, Lee DongMin pueda sentir que su corazón va sanando. Binnie está y estará por siempre en el corazón de quienes lo conocimos, pero ciertamente nuestro dolor por su partida tan temprana no puede compararse con lo que siente DongMin, los miembros de Astro, amigos y su propia familia. Lee DongMin sigue trabajando duro como el artista Cha Eunwoo, para mantenerse de pie. Es su forma de enfrentar el dolor. Pero creo que ya sabe que debe cuidar su salud para mantenerse bien por él y para los demás. Prometió a su amigo hacerse cargo de lo que dejó atrás y lo hizo de corazón porque amaba a su hermano. No es una carga para él, creo que así también lo siente más cerca. Admiro su capacidad y madurez para enfrentar su dolor y ayudar en este proceso a aroha y miembros con el propio. Definitivamente todos debemos vivir de mejor manera, llevar nuestras vidas por un mejor camino. Trabajar en ello. Así es como a Bin le gustaría vernos. Fuerza y ánimo CHA EUNWOO/ LEE DONGMIN. Desde Chile 🇨🇱 te seguiremos apoyando a ti a los chicos. Gracias a ti conocí a ASTRO, su talento grupal e individual. A otras 5 personitas con una personalidad tan bella como la tuya y aprendí que el amor, respeto, admiración y apoyo pueden darse entre personas que eligieron ser familia. Que el lazo de hermandad que los une es hermoso, fuerte y maravilloso. Todo mi amor y respeto para ti y para ellos. #CHAEUNWOO #ASTRO #kpopidol #kactir #kmodel #MC #ASTRO4EVER
Lieber Eun Woo ,ehrlich gesagt mochte ich dich zuerst ,dann war ich sehr wütend auf dich .Ich hatte soviele Fragen und die Antworten waren alle verschieden. Das sind die Medien ! Jetzt hasse ich mich selbst dafür ,das ich schlecht über gedacht habe . Es tut mir sehr leid! Nach diesem kurz film ist alles anders und ich bin froh darüber. Ich sah wie sehr du Moonbin geliebt hast ,ob Freundschaftlich oder liebschaft ihr hättest es beide so verdient glücklich zu sein . Ich habe mir nach diesem Lied: Love wins all by sorgen um dich gemacht . Ich werde mir auch jetzt keine Videos mehr von euch ansehen, da ich selbst an Depressionen leide und gemerkt habe das es mir das Herz zerreißt, das Moonbin so gelitten hat bis er starb und du jetzt auch sehr leidest Eun Woo. Bitte pass auf dich auf, iss und schlaf genug . Ich werde Moonbin und dich nicht vergessen 😊
Eun Woo might not be as expressive, but he always has deep thoughts and cares a lot. His heart is in the right place. I hope he keeps healthy in mind and heart. Sometimes I feel he breaks and as a fan, I want to protect him. Be strong Eun Woo!
Ay eun woo si supieras que yo también lo extraño muchísimo😢 a pesar de que ya tiene 1 año aun me duele ,pero hay que ser fuertes y recordarlo como si todavía estuviera con nosotros💜💜💜(por favor cuida te mucho maten té❤ sano tu y los demás💜💜
Привет красавчик, я ничего не забыла ,я помню ,я понимаю что это для тебя очень болезнено ,я бы хотела тебе сказать ,больше ,береги себя и буть счастлив❤
It has been a year since Binnie death. Binnie was the best of Astro. I love him and miss him deeply. I am so glad, Cha, you made a tribute to our Binnie. He will always be deeply missed. He is deep in my heart. I see him in my dreams, and I know he is always by my sides. He just wants you to be happy and healthy. Live a long life with your family and Astro💜
@Chaeunwoo716 no disrespect to you, Cha, but I am Moonbin's fan. He was the heartbeat of Astro. Now he is gone, my love for Astro die with him. Take care of yourself, your family, and Astro members. Be happy😊
I can personally share Eun Woo and his emptiness in his life with the loss of Moonbin. Three years ago, this past March, I lost my oldest son and ten days later my only grandson. I keep you and my two sons in my thoughts and prayers.
No Nunu, I have not forgotten Moonbin. I am a fan of ASTRO, so every time I see a member of the group, especially you, I think of Moombin. Thanks for loving Binnie and talking about him. I know you speak from the heart and that means a world to me! Love you both!
Its very hard i can relate eunwoo. My mom comes in my dreams always but i can't sleep well at all. Why do our loved ones leave regrets. Eunwoo regretted about moonbin shows his honesty love towards him.
I've been praying for you. Your important too, we Love You. Stay Healthy in your Body, Soul and Mind. Moonbin will always be in our HEARTS 💕, and in Your precious heart. Please STAY You, C.E.W. I will keep you Always in My Prayers. BE BLESSED, PRESSED DOWN, SHAKEN TOGETHER AND RUNNING OVER. LOVE YOU ALWAYS, SHALOM.....🙏🙏🙏
Те кто знал не забыли! Возможно просто боятся трогать,ведь это всё ещё "открытая рана" для его близких.Тоже много дорогих и близких мне людей умерли совсем молодыми,это очень тяжело.Те кто умер из дорогих нам людей явно не хотели бы видеть наши слёзы.Дядя,брат,3 друга,одноклассник и один очень хороший знакомый умерли очень рано.И все они были бы очень расстроены если бы видели наши слёзы.Мой младший двоюродный братик который тоже умер рано,ему было тяжело видеть меня грустную всегда спрашивал кто меня обидел ,чтобы побить обидчика.Поэтому мы должны стараться жить так как этого бы хотели для нас умершие дорогие нам люди,долго и счастливо.И обязательно поддерживать нужно их матерей,им тяжелее всего перенести утрату 💔.Сил всем кто потерял дорогих людей и постарайтесь жить так чтобы за вас радовались с небес и не переживали.
Lee Dong-mi es un gran ser humano, lo demuestra en su ser con sus hermanos. Profesionalmente es increíble su capacidad actoral a dejado muestra de ello y su capacidad vocal es tan distintiva su dulzura es inefable. Gracias Nunu por todo lo que has compartido en tu proyecto que deja ver tu esencia, te amamos. 💝💙💙💙💙😍
He is someone that can never be forgotten 😢we all felt his loss but you probably felt it much more than we did 😢😢. Be strong 💪💪 Eun woo, Moon Bin would have wanted you to be happy and living an extremely good life ❤❤😢
🙏😊☺️ Dios 🙏 té bendiga siempre ☺️ mí niño hermoso,me encantó verte y sí debemos luchar por estar bien,mí moonbin está súper orgulloso de ti y de los chicos, cada uno tiene su potencial,no lo dudes, MJ entusiasta, jinjin súper genial líder, sahna está claro en la vida y tendrán sus momentos, porque astro está más fortalecido y el potencial es demasiado genial ✌️ lo máximo 👍, pero queremos que se mantengan sanos y sobretodo felices, ése será el mejor éxito, sé les quiere mucho mucho mucho mucho mucho ❤️ ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️ no lo dudes 😊🇻🇪 vzla
Eu simplesmente comecei amar esse garoto. Vejo nele um ser muito sensível e compassivo e muito amoroso e que precisa também ser amado muito mais agora. Forca Nunu !! Fique bem por favor! Se cuide durma bem e se alimente . Bin não ia querer vê _lo triste ou se culpando. Procure ajuda e fique perto de pessoas boas que possam te apoiar. Com amor Rosana do Brasil ❤❤❤❤
Moonbin loved Cha Eun Woo more than anyone else, had it been Cha Eun Woo who died Moonbin would have followed him immediately, so somehow Moonbin knew that Cha Eun Woo is stronger than he thinks he is. Moonbin's love for you was unmatched Nunu....please be strong.
On ne peut oublier Moonbin, mais la vie continue, son passage parmi nous aura été de courte durée mais marquante en cela restera de beaux souvenirs.❤ (soit rassuré ChaEunwoo😊)
I would have appreciated it if you had just used only English subtitle without adding your voice to the video, the hurt in his voice isn't in yours so the feeling isn't the same.. please who knows where I can get the English subtitles of the video?
My sister was died at tree years in 2017. I can't cry because the pain was very stronger but After this drama, I know now the death IS not fatality, it's a RDV that our dears beings give us towards heaven.
Quando os arohas vão acordar e parar de romantizar essa exploração absurda q a fantagio comete com seus artistas? Eunwoo dormi apenas 3 hrs por dia? Vcs acham isso legal? Acham q eunwoo é de ferro? Pq os arohas não fazem igual aos armys protestar na frente da fantagio um tratamento mais humano e respeitoso pelos meninos do astro? Não consigo aceitar essa omissão do fandom em achar que tudo está bem e q na vdd não está, sinto muito pelo eunwoo por toda carga emocional e pela responsabilidade de manter sozinho essa dura missão em sustentar essa empresa q pra mim é uma criminosa 😡
I can't comment on the things that CEW said because is his story but one thing he said is a lie , is that moonbin has been forgotten , just to show he knows nothing about bin , we have been out here voting for bin, he won 3 consecutive months of boy ranking, he has been posted on RU-vid and Instagram everyday , and i am sure other social media, i just have those two 😂, but the name moonbin will never be forgotten, if his fans have anything to do with it . When i personally think about Astro i think of moonbin , i am just happy he was smart enough to video most of his life and left for us to see . Love you bin , you did well
Ыну спасибо огромное за откровения, но хочу сказать, что Мунбина помнят и любят все. Он ангел который оберегает тебя и всю вашу группу. Как только вспоминаю про него сразу слезы на глазах. Мунбин звёздочка которая светит нам всем❤❤❤ Ыну побольше отдыхай, конечно все рады и ждут твоих выступлений, но береги себя❤❤❤ Ты у нас такой один)))
@@МаринаМедведева-м2б жалко когда я ишо не смотрела видео там было написано на русском начинаю смотреть а там на Английском и на корейских языке только надеялся что будет на русском 😥
Obrigado? Até quando vcs vão continuar romantizabdo essa exploração absurda q a fantagio mais uma vez está cometendo contra seus artistas? Eunwoo dormi apenas 3hrs por dia e acha q isso é normal pra quem já carrega tanto peso de emoções e responsabilidade ? Ou esse fandom acorda pra realidade e protestar contra uma empresa q foi capaz de explorar até o último sopro de vida q foi do moonbin, ou vamos ter q assistir de braços cruzados mais uma exploração desumano dessa lixo da fantagio q pra mim não passa de uma empresa ass@ssin@.
It's sad that they just forgot him like that. I know that sometimes to keep yourself healthy you have to kinda move past the things that hurt or are complicated to understand and move on... But what about the people there, the idols, the staff, hell the managers that stood with them all as they grew. You still have to keep a healthy reminder in your company's status of someone to help those that are still struggling to be able to do the same. For some it's not that easy to just set aside and forget their presence. Especially for the members that are left behind. Me I'll never forget and I don't want to. I spent so many years supporting moonbin as an actor and later as an idol. He was one of the few idols I held so much love and respect for cause in my years struggling and growing up he was what I had to look back on and set as my goal to bettering myself. I have a yearly calendar notification set to give prayers and remembrance to the idol who I loved with all my heart and showed that love back in return with his hard work and good will. His smile is widely loved and I never want to forget those smiles, I miss his presence in the world and hope his family is well and his fans are getting through the days okay. We will never forget so we will continue to stand with them as 6, cause Astro will always be 6 😊
@Chaeunwoo716 I'll be at your show here in Brazil. I want to see him in person even if it's just from the stage. I hope everything works out at your show here in Brazil
