Charlie Kirk Debate College Girl Who Believes ID Cards are Racist & Affirmative Action is Great! 

She had no actual argument, she just spews out what her college professors tell her to think.

My parents were dirt poor and never considered crime and murder a way of life.

She is what is wrong with America.

I'm black, patriot, vet and MAGA....The problem with black homes today is rightly pointed out by Charlie...mother's married to government for social welfare. They family needs the father at home, and more importantly the Heavenly Father. Blacks like me grew up God fearing and that was the Cornerstone of the family unit. Today it's a shambles because the father's role has been hijacked by God hating politicians, government you name it to keep the suppression of blacks intact and drive ungodly political motives. When up Black America, find your heavenly Father again. ENUFF said

Whether you believe with the charlie kirk’s or not, this girl is more of a problem.

Remember this folks, the same people that are against voter ID, wanted you to have to show your vaccine passport, to go out to dinner.

This woman is a professional gaslighter.

I would feel beyond disrespected if someone said I was too dumb to know how to get an ID card

I’ll bet that girl has to show ID to purchase alcohol, get on a plane, purchase an IPhone, & the list goes on!!

Something tells me this girl is offended by a LOT of things.

He's offering her a chance to think independently for herself, but instead, she keeps repeating mantras she has been told over and over. She doesn't seem to be able to think for herself.

She doesn't know that black people are fully capable of making free choices and taking responsibility for the outcomes. She thinks they're inferior

Her thinking is exactly what is wrong with this country.

I am a Singaporean, a multiracial country, where all citizens carry an identity card and do all official and legal activities require this card. ID is needed for voting. This is a stupid girl! ID is not racists!

She knows vocabulary and theory. She understands NOTHING about reality and practicalities.

Charlie, you couldn’t have explained it better. Thank you!

Came in the country with $2000 in pocket as a student. No relatives or friends. As an Asian, never thought I had any privilege over anyone.

Her biggest problem is she believes she is smarter than she actually is.

This gal's parents are wasting their money for her education

That makes drivers licenses racist too.

Wait- Asians were brought here in the 1800’s to build railroads.

She was insufferable, when she was dead wrong which was 99% of that exchange, she laughed and said "I don't care". Kirk won hands down

This generation can’t decide what restroom to use….parents, what are you teaching your children????

I hate when someone already lost the argument and they try to save it but makes it worse

My family was very poor and of 2 parents and 5 children.. no trouble with the law, the school nor neighbors. All 5 kids went to college and it TICKS ME OFF when people say people commit crime because they are poor. Poor does NOT equal criminality!

Charlie might hurt your feelings but he aint lying.

If she can't answer or explain it, "It's complicated." a.k.a _I have no answer._

Gosh , this 'liberal' young woman was the most reasonable liberal I've heard from in 10 + years . And yet she was Still very largely wrong about conclusions and solutions . I guess i should be a bit grateful for SOME kind of 'progress' ! 🙄

Call me crazy but it looks like the crowd disagrees with her.

Black women have been rewarded for not having a black man in the house. It’s nobody’s fault but ours and we need to have the balls to say the ish out loud and unapologetically!

She is a reflection of a successful Liberal Education.

When people say “really great question” it’s so condescending.

College produces people like this woman.

Its funny that everything is a “great question” for her, but she had no answer

These little kids haven't lived long enough to have a relevant or valid opinion. Such a narrow scope of reality and close minded.

I am white, I grew up poor, my grandmas and grampas on both sides were pickers. None of my family have ever been racist. When you live on the poor side of town, then you live in very Diversified neighborhoods. And we were all happy. No matter what your job is, you do your best. That is how I was raised.

Another obnoxious know-it-all college student who dismisses everything Charlie says. She is not interested in learning, only accusation.

Watching that girl talk is like watching someone on the deck of the Titanic saying the ship isn't sinking, when 80% of the passengers are already in the drink...

The next time someone cash a check , book a hotel room, or rent a car just says, “ that’s racist.” SMH.

I’ve never NOT had to show ID to vote or do anything official. If someone acted like I’m too dumb to get an ID I’d be really insulted

There are about 22 million poor whites and 9 million poor blacks in the USA. Now tell me how poverty explains the 13% / 55% split?

She is a prime example of higher indoctrination.

Oh my gosh, that young woman was so disrespectful, arrogant, and dismissive. I don't know how Charlie keeps his composure. And the laughing mockery of these students speaks volumes of that generation.

There is something spectacularly ugly about someone who is both ignorant and mocking at the same time.

He didn’t say genetic he said cultural!!! The culture changed.

😭😭😭;OMG, the reason this lady keeps chuckling is because she realizes how intellitually dishonest her argument is!

She hit all the Buzzwords.

I was a lot like this girl once, then I had a moment of clarity… I don’t know crap, I don’t care, I have zero reason to do so, and I don’t plan to change this. Now I feel much better about myself and can go into the world and enjoy life. I recommend accepting this to all people, it’s quite euphoric.

The core issue is Fatherhood

She's supposed to be at college to learn. Charlie's trying to teach her but she's not able to comprehend she could be wrong

I am an Italian American I grew up in a predominantly black community. I witnessed first hand what changed with the black culture. In the 70’s the welfare laws changed where a woman received more money if they didn’t have a man living in the home. The father then was sleeping in a different household which took away intimacy , that bonding that takes place with couples and the men then would have other women in their lives. The government incentivized the break up of the black family unity . Men usual take on the role of discipline so no discipline no role model and it became the norm not to have a dad in the house and they followed their dad’s footsteps. The girls also seen the lack of commitment and their mothers being okay with it and getting more money in the household with no man in the house. Keep in mind I seen it my friends home first hand. Thanks for reading my comments my opinion. God bless everyone!

Maybe these people need to use the word ‘prejudiced’ rather than racist, as she’s using the word ‘racist’ as many do, in the wrong context.

This girls answer is ridiculous. I grew up in the Bronx and had to fight my way through by being stalked and attacked by blacks and Hispanics. My parents migrated here from Ireland and believe me they were poor. Blacks sold blacks.

Charlie Kirk is absolutely right. I am old enough to remember when most black households were made up of a mother and a father. You are absolutely wrong about black fathers being in prisons and that is why they were not around. In late 1960's and beyond, welfare made it more profitable for black women with children to NOT have a man in the house. The carrot being dangled was to offer more money to single mothers alone. If a man entered the household, or the father was present, the benefits were reduced or stopped. That is when single black motherhood spiked. Welfare is a trap. It offers false security, but just enough to keep you from stepping out from under it and making more money (we still do this with older citizens now and collecting Social Security checks. The government raised the age of retirement based on the expectation of length of life and when the average death age is. The longer you wait to collect, the higher the paycheck, but the better chances you have of never collecting because you will be dead, whereas if young people were encouraged to set up their own strong retirement plans in the prime of their lives, they could afford to retire whenever they felt it was right, not because without working until they are good and old will assure they can maybe live in controlled, low-income housing and need food stamps). When men have no families they feel encouraged to provide for, they turn to other appetites that are not healthy ones. And it is PROVEN that without a man's influence in young men's lives, most will begin adopting things like street gangs to provide that relationship. (An interesting study was done with male elephants that became more aggressive and abusive when there were no older male elephants around to steer them in the right direction). Older men teach younger men how to be a true man who handles his responsibilities with family and to provide and raise his children. Another thing is education. Black people FOUGHT for education in slavery when it was forbidden. It was against the law for slaves to learn to read and write. More blacks did more with elementary school education than they do today graduating from high school. Part of this has to do with the deterioration of education. Schools in mostly black neighborhoods have abysmal grades. Schools actually graduate seniors who still read at elementary school levels! This was NOT the case 60 years ago with blacks, who understood the value of an education and had to fight to get it. Now they will keep passing them on. My mother was from the Dominican Republic, and i remember when public schools decided it was unfair for immigrant children to have lessons in English, so they began bilingual classes. To the white liberal, this sounds so wonderful. It's not! My mother stated that they used to put children behind a year when they immigrated here. The reason was so that they could become fluent in English and then continue with the level they left off with in their native country. They could continue their education stronger. Having children who grew up and graduated and still did not have a handle on English meant we had lots more low-income earners like janitors, maids and fast food workers. The need for immigrant children is to command the language so they can continue on to higher education, higher paying jobs, pursuing their dreams and goals. Please do yourself a favor and read some of the black economists and authors Charlie Kirk mentions, like Thomas Sowell. Even Denzel Washington has spoken many times on the need for black fathers in the home. And MOST black men 60 years ago were NOT in jail. They were working to support themselves and their families.

She will end up being a librarian living alone in a pile of cat litter.

Boldly displaying her lack of good education and then mocks Charlie when she’s proven wrong.

I was retired before I was 40 . Racism has never held me back, Because I never let it. If Cry that you are a victim from the time you wake up till you go to bed. Then you are holding yourself back!

She thought she was smart and understood more than she truly did. She made herself look foolish.

She can’t keep from laughing because she knows she’s wrong

I grew up in the 50’s and 60’s, I grew up in Alabama. I remember when I worked alongside blacks in the cotton fields, in the hayfields, etc. my family was much poorer than many of my black friends. I used to go to some black friends home and play football and hang out. Those same guys, once we were grown, 30-40 years old, I became a police officer, after my time in the military, and after all government give-away programs for blacks kicked in, along with affirmative action, which would have kept me from being hired, had it not been for an officer I knew from high school spoke up for me. These same guys I grew up with and played at their home, became criminals and I had to arrest one, and he threatened my life after just being arrested for murder. It was the Democrats that ran the KKK, started the Jim Crowe Laws, segregation, and everything else that was bad in the south. They later, in the 60’s, after Lyndon Johnson became president, figured out how to clean-up the parties reputation, and use the blacks to their advantage, but the Civil Rights Act would never have been passed had it not been for the Republican Party. This young lady is brainwashed and doesn’t have a clue. THIS COMMENT IS FOR EDUCATIONAL PURPOSES ONLY, PER RU-vid USAGE POLICY.

The government has been trying to fix this community for 60 years and after 60 years of work. The community is worse off than they were before To suggest that the government is the solution to the problem that they created is ludicrous.

That poor girl is so lost. I feel bad for her.🙁

Purchasing alcohol and tobacco is racist. Boarding an airplane is racist. Getting credit cards is racist. Literally everything is racist.

Charlie was spot on and facts. She has no argument and is lost. And what funny is how she thinks has been way folks think for decades and because of that they not got out of that norm! If they would face facts and think like Charlie then it would finally fix 90% of the problem!

Sowell is a genius.

Two of the dots that cannot be connected are those of ID cards and racism.

Ask her if she need ID for college

Economic status? There are roughly 7,695,000 million black Americans versus 21,328,000 million white Americans considered to live in poverty. So if the violent crime is based on those in poverty, then how does her stance square with violent crime being related to poverty?

Debating the stupid is inequitable.

Does she not realize that the Chinese were brought here as slaves and were subject to the same discrimination as black slaves? Who does she think built the railroads?

Doesn't all college students has to have student ID

Amusing everything as racist is racist.

Institutuonal racism INCREASED? she has never read a history book

She just wasn’t arguing in good faith, she kept making false equivalencies and trapping Charlie into banal this or that’s it’s your only choice.

That poor little girl is so brainwashed it’s pitiful.

Using big words doesn't make you smart. She is proof of that.

Hey white college girl, I know a lot Asian on very friendly terms. 1. A Vietnamese man who arrived in town as a broke 16 years old orphan after the Vietnam War. With the aid of a local benefactor, he was able to start a "hole the wall" seamstress shop, sewing on buttons, hemming up pants sand skirts, replacing broken zippers. Average customer paid $3.00. He put his daughter to college in Chapel Hill. She's now a surgeon. 2. A family of friends who fled Hong Kong before the CCP took over. Carrying everything they own on their backs. They are doing very well now. The son earns a four digit weekly paycheck. The daughter married an ABC who built his own business up; she put herself thru college and and became an accountant. Working awhile for the city of Wilmington. They then put their daught thru collge. She's a doctor. 3. A pare of brother I know who fled the CCP during the early sixties. The had to be smuggled out with only the clothes on their backs. Both served in the USN. Vietnam war fighting Communism. Both retired USN. One then went on to serve and retire from Balitmore police department. 4. My closest friends are also from China. Fuzhou. The immigrated (legally). By now means wealthy upon arrival. Now between they and their children, they own a restuarant in North Carolina, one in Miami, a Chinese Restaurant and a Japanese restaurant in Wrightsville Beach and Chesaeake, Va. A Chasino in NYC, and one of their daughters is a licensed CPA. They are also related to the two brothers who served in Vietnam which I mentioned earlier. 5. A Korean man who fought for the ROK in th Korean war. I worked with son. His son was my boss. When the father died the son gave me his father's leather jacket. The father's statis ipon arrival to our shores i do not know. 6. And finally, my wife. From Lang Qi Island near Fuzho. A delapidated spraling little community. When my wife arrived in America she had one bag of belongings. Now a suitcase, clothe bag. Her sister, and her sister's husband also arrived with Spartan bellongings. 7. Allow me also to mention the little old lady who arrived here after WW2 from Hiroshima, japan. She had married US Marine. She bore physical the scares of the A-Bomb. She ran a laundromat on Railroad st. Her son now owns a restarunt on Main St. Finale: Sure all Asians come over here rich. It's a blantant racist statement to claim that Asians all arrive here wealthy. That's stereotyping and racist.

There are no locks on those chains that she chooses to cling to.

So she believes I should be able to walk into a lending place, give her name, and get a loan under her identity for her to pay back? Cool.

As a black man he is 100% right! Look at hip hop...Baby Mama: By Three 6 Mafia, Ms. Jackson: By OutKast, ect....Our culture is toxic!

She is using big words that she was taught in college, but she is all talk ,no substance

And not demanding ID cards is totally ignorant.

25 years from now, she'll look back and say what was i thinking 🤔

She's wedded to everyone accepting her implicit of assumption of "it's a fact...it's well known" without citing the proof.

Thankyou for putting this out there Dumsy Brown.---- It brought me to a new point of view. Mr Kirk talked a lot of sense.

No wisdom behind her, she is so condescending

Want to drive? Need an ID card. Want to buy cigarettes and alcohol? Need an ID card. Want to travel by plane? Need an ID card. Any adult who doesn’t have identification and has an excuse is pathetic.

Charlie Kirk gives me the shivers. He's so composed and so well read. I really admire him. We need more people like him, Ben Shapiro and Douglas Murray.

Got my girlfriend pregnant at 20 thought it was the right thing to do to get married I'm 40 now and I have two beautiful children together forever

I can't believe how patient Charlie is day after day after day!

We have a national id card in the Philippines. Guess what, life still goes on while its in my wallet

She doesn't sound as ceazy as most liberals. She is smart just getting her information from the wrong people

Her responses are typical of narcissistic chaos/word-salad.

Give her 20 years or so, when she isn’t just out of her childhood.

I have to give cudos to this young lady for standing in there and actually discussing issues instead of using talking points insults.

Mr. Brown, Thank you for your video. You are a Class Act.

People have fought hard to remove segregation in this country since Plessy v. Ferguson. Why are we now trying to bring it back?

Where do these kids learn this foolishness? Must be foolish teachers.

That constant nervous giggle says enough. No confidence in what she says, because she knows she's just repeating slogans without substance.

The Vietnamese kid didn’t understand the question 😂😂 he was too excited.