China batteries vs. Canon original: The good, the bad and the ugly

Подписаться 22 тыс.

Просмотров 45 тыс.

50% 1

We perform a few tests to see which China battery is best, and if the Canon original part lives up to its spec and price.
NOTE: The quality of cheap knockoff batteries varies. Even if you purchase the test winner of this video, there's NO TELLING whether or not it'll actually be good. I would not stick ANY of these batteries in my expensive camera without doing these tests first, on each individual battery.
Help me survive: / ffcossag
--
THIS VIDEO IS RELEASED TO THE PUBLIC DOMAIN
To the extent possible under law, I have waived all copyright and related or neighbouring rights to this work, according to the Creative Commons CC0 affirmer. This means that anyone is free to use this content in any manner they see fit, without my objection. However, the video may still contain copyrighted content (images, video, audio, software, etc.) that does not belong to me. WHILE I DO NOT RESERVE THE RIGHTS OF ANY PART OF THIS VIDEO, THE COPYRIGHT OF THIRD-PARTY CONTENT STILL BELONGS TO ITS RESPECTIVE OWNERS. THE COPYRIGHT OF THIRD-PARTY CONTENT IS NOT WAIVED. THE VIDEO IS PROVIDED AS-IS, AND I DO NOT PROVIDE ANY GUARANTEE OF ITS QUALITY.

Опубликовано:

13 окт 2024

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 70

@FFcossag 7 лет назад

ERRATA: I calculated the ESR wrong, the actual numbers should be DOUBLED to be correct. To calculate the ESR of a battery, I connect it to an 8-ohm load, let it stabilise, and then switch to a 4-ohm load and measure the difference in cell voltage under the higher load. If you enter the ΔV and ΔI into Ohm's law, you can solve for battery ESR. For instance, 0,37 ΔV / 0,807 ΔA = 0,458 Ohm. I accidentally calculated the ESR using the full current, not the current differential, which in this case (since the ESR of the batteries is relatively low) results in a calculated ESR that is roughly half of what it actually is. My comment about what is an appropriate ESR should also be doubled, as I was just going by the measured values.

@set3777 9 месяцев назад

I bought my Original LP-E17 for 52% of thr RRP (about $30) for my 760D. But that is still about 300% of some Made in China batteries but the later cannot be charged with the Orginal Canon Charger. I did buy 2 3rd party batteries for my 550D. which could be charged but when charged by Canon's charger will drain very quickly. I think many Made in China batteries just had falsely labelled capacity (mAHs) or some were just recycled from used batteries and relabelled. (Same experience with mobile phone batteries).

@BubblesPothowari 6 лет назад

Jesus of Batteries, I could grasp less than 30%, but discharge rate, time to cut off Volts, and internal resistance are my take aways. "Sterling pounds per kg" was another blunt great trigger. Many Thanks !!!

@twocvbloke 7 лет назад

Simple case of "buyer beware", cheaper alternatives are cheap for a reason, they're usually not made that well... :)

@argilaga 6 лет назад

Really nice video, thanks! I agree with you, the problem with cheap batteries is the quality control, you never know if it will be good or not.

@YoIomaster 3 года назад

Great Video! Liked and subscribed! Can you please give me an advice? I want to power my bmpcc6k camera via the LP-E6 battery while using a gimbal. I Found these "BONACELL 3200mAh" batteries on ebay. The Problem is, that i don't know much about Battery technology and I'm not sure whether I should buy those or not. Can you tell whether those are good or not? Is there a softcap for battery capacity? Like 2600mAh is the highest, most likely to work properly battery, everything above is unrealistic to work reliably for a longer period of time? Appreciate your time!

@FFcossag 3 года назад

Basically, all claims on Ebay of capacities bigger than the original battery's capacity are lies.

@YoIomaster 3 года назад

@@FFcossag Thanks! So the 2600mAh on Amazon are not good either?

@doctorcosta 9 месяцев назад

Can you use cheap batteries to record video?

@Tsebish 5 лет назад

Thanks for putting out this video, was really very helpful!! GREAT VIDEO!

@kaziulaz 6 лет назад

some producers still tell about few full charge and discharge to build full capacity in cells. Try to check how they behave after few charging.

@kvstrickland 6 лет назад

Thanks for posting....I just ordered 2 Cheapy batteries for a cheapy grip to fit my T6i....the battery warnings and the fact that no charge % shows on the screen...first scared me and then irritated me. Lol I’ll probably order Canon batteries for that ridiculous price...and use the cheapy ones as a back up.

@Sertao2013 Год назад

The big differences in the battery's is how many times they can take a charge and keep the same time of operation . Do your test after 50 cycles and watch how fast the cheaper ones lose power .

@ITTFami 7 лет назад

FF, I told you not to make battery capacity formulas in English class! No recess for you!

@FFcossag 7 лет назад

I fighted the urge but I failed. ;)

@tbbw 7 лет назад

Ah so that's how you measure ESR :) Never needed to do it myself but sounds like something usefull to play with during a rainy weekend and an arduino :)

@FFcossag 7 лет назад

You can probably figure out all kinds of clever tricks to do it more accurately than I do. My figures are like +/-20%.

@kokakoalak 6 лет назад

Hi mate, great chanel! Photo, audio and ghetto-planet-saving-diy-stuff. All I love in one. I want all youtube to be like this! So, I'm looking for chepo replacement batteries for my mirrorless canon, is there some good knockoff brand here in europe, or should I give the GOLD to canon? Greets from Poland

@FFcossag 6 лет назад

You don't know what you get with any of the cheap brands. I'd never run a knockoff battery in an expensive camera without thoroughly testing it first.

@kokakoalak 6 лет назад

FFcossag So gold will go to Canon unfortunately. Thanks.

@rafo6577 4 года назад

Would be intresting to get a few of the Bluemax batteries and tested them for constancy. Great job 👍

@hookedtofilms 4 года назад

Soon there is gonna be a prize in your name. You r the best 👍

@ВладимирСидоренко-ы3е 3 года назад

did u try Duracell batteries ?

@majorpayne0195 Год назад

Just bought two LP-E17 batteries for my incoming EOS R8. I will never use these chinese batteries to my camera. Like in PC, using not good PSU or power source might damaged components.

@jakeclark1402 5 лет назад

Bro I just wanna Know if I can use a cheap battery and it not mess up my camera. Get to the point. Your super smart and I wouldn't ever be able to be like you or have the knowledge to do what you do BUT get to the POinnnTtTtt.

@FFcossag 5 лет назад

"Some cheap batteries are good, others aren't, and you can't tell which is which by looking online"

@stevec5000 7 лет назад

Can you explain again how you measured the ESR so I can do it too?

@FFcossag 7 лет назад

I load the battery down until it stabilises, then I switch in a known resistive load and measure how much the voltage instantly drops. That voltage drop will be the drop across the battery's ESR, so you can derive the ESR through Ohm's law.

@stevec5000 7 лет назад

How much do you load it down initially and if you have an 8 volt battery and put a 10 ohm load across it and it drops to 7 volts how can you figure the ESR? I think there is a step missing here, don't we need to know the current?

@FFcossag 7 лет назад

I use my switchable 4/8 ohm load. Since both the voltage of the battery and the resistance of the load are known, we know the current (or we can just measure it). Since we also know that the voltage is X under an 8 ohm load and drops to Y under a 4 ohm load, the difference in battery voltage becomes the voltage drop across the ESR. Think of it as a system with a voltage source, a series resistor (ESR) and a load resistor.

@FFcossag 7 лет назад

I put a more detailed answer pinned at the top, since I actually did it slightly wrong in the video. Look at that for a proper explanation.

@stevec5000 7 лет назад

Thanks, I'll try that.

@912582 4 года назад

Canon BG-R10 Battery Grip fits ?

@sarkybugger5009 7 лет назад

Welcome back! 3 = Fought. 8 = Did. :o)

@FFcossag 7 лет назад

Thank you, it's good to be back.

@zx8401ztv 7 лет назад

The bluemax is a good substitute for the real thing, as long as the quality stays the same. Shame the camera had a problem, we can't even say it's cheap crap :-D.

@qwe980315 6 лет назад

anybody know name of the battery? For 800d cheapy battery. I wanna buy one but i couldn't find exact name of it. Thanks.

@FFcossag 6 лет назад

Doesn't matter, since you never know where they come from anyway. I generally just use WHBV batteries since they seem to have reasonably good standards for their stock.

@qwe980315 6 лет назад

@@FFcossag Oh thanks.

@109eh 5 лет назад

Do you know the durapro battery quality?

@FFcossag 5 лет назад

Never tried one.

@felixcat4346 7 лет назад

Excellent as always. Thanks

@JETNEWS-US 5 лет назад

Great Video!!!, even though i am American and it is Actually hard to understand British!

@wonderwoman8380 2 года назад

Maybe Yorkshire man, or somewhere north of there. 😀

@msbrownbeast 5 лет назад

Original Canon batteries are also made in China

@sexysilversurfer 4 года назад

msbrownbeast but using Chinese cells or Japanese cells?

@hardeepsinghbhai7609 4 года назад

How to buy.. Today... Battery lp e12. Brand.. Canon.. Vs... Etc.. Please reply massage

@execrucify 4 года назад

6.5v before sharply dropping off, not 7.0 ;-)

@Whigu 7 лет назад

Jesus battery :-D

@FFcossag 7 лет назад

Given the price, it bloody well better be the saviour.

@Whigu 7 лет назад

I understand that =) Before latest Africa trip I had to buy 4 Canon battery and when I noticed the price...

@oneeyedphotographer 6 лет назад

My Canon cameras use LP-E6 batteries. Made in China.

@steveone 7 лет назад

3 : Fight Fighting Fought ( not fighted )

@bonjour88-x7u Год назад

good info

@shreyassalian3955 6 лет назад

wanted this battery video fr 800d thank you

@YOitsJohnDough 3 года назад

Fast forward 1.75x damn bro

@ForTheWin2007 5 лет назад

Could anyone give a quick TL;DR? Thanks!

@FFcossag 5 лет назад

"You don't know what you get on Ebay"

@D-Rodriguez777 5 лет назад

So it is true that Einstein actually did have a child😉..... Get it?

@gamerguypvppvp7347 7 лет назад

the bateries only last that short because the camera rekognisesthem as fake and tries to burn their power quicker. In the original ones there is a small chip telling the camera to save power. So the fake ones are exactly as good as the original ones, only the Kamera us kinda racistic against them.

@FFcossag 7 лет назад

No. I didn't even stick any of these IN my camera, lol. I just benched them.

@TheHonestTruth 3 года назад

Well ok then lol

@DasMrOSi 7 лет назад

@Ludwig have you been practicing English lately? ;-)

@FFcossag 7 лет назад

No, I definitely have not.

@simontay4851 7 лет назад

He speaks English very well anyway.

@DasMrOSi 7 лет назад

He does. I was referring to his notes in 1:38 - they must have been back from school

@FFcossag 7 лет назад

I have a lot of these half-filled notepads that I got from a school clearout. I'm too cheap to buy new ones when I can just write beside all the silly gradeschool English. For dignity's sake, I should point out that they're not my school books. ;)

@DasMrOSi 7 лет назад

Got it :D I'd do the same thing, if I'd have such old notepads. By the way: Great video