I hate Lily for this because she said she was losing a war so she kidnapped children and brainwashed them to fight for them and when Clementine heard that she killed everyone on that ship and she's pissed off because of it. The kids don't even care about the war even Clementine never went back to Richmond because of it and Lilly forced them to
If you play season one choosing lily over Kenny early on, she is decent and kind behind her tough shell. Shes probably lost that by now, but clem was right when she says lily wasn't evil before.
Honestly I'd love a remake of S1. Longer, much more complex (extension of Doug/Carley story for example) and most importantly - two paths. Either siding with Lilly or with Kenny. Would be awesome tbh
Honestly I still don't like Lilly I still think she's not a good person, she was such an ass to everyone for no actual reason. She got pissed at people because they gave their opinions and suggestions to her and she just wouldn't hear it, all she wanted was for people to work the way she wanted and I understand it was because she wanted everyone to survive but going they way she did was not ok. She killed Carly (or Doug depending on who you choose) simply based on an assumption of who stole supplies and petty dislike in Carly's case. Lee is right to leave her on the side of the road if he chooses and then she comes back later, kidnaps children for some fucking war that doesn't involve them, tortures them if they step out of line, makes them fight for them against their will. One of them was even killed during it and once again it was because she wanted to protect people but the way she did it was fucking disgusting. I hold no sympathy for someone like Lilly
It’s true in S1 Lily and the first group in TWD was family only for a short while, though Lily wanted to be more with Lee but he liked Carly and she followed her father’s advise.