Commander Game - Phyrexia All Will Be One - Solphim, Ixhel, Ezuri, Vishgraz - EDH Format 

Agreed! Thanks for the comment :)

Right though!?

He is. He is.

Thank you! You too! Your feedback really means a lot :)

Same. Same.

www.moxfield.com/decks/9h0KWxxf-U6hufWeqsOmYw just got it! Here you go

@@mostlycasualcommander lol! Thank you

Hey friend, glad you like the content. We definitely notice your regular commenting and appreciate it! I don’t think your war of the spark reference is accurate though. Proliferate states that a player may choose any number of permanents and/or players and then give each another counter of each they already have. We joked about Scott choosing the stonecoil serpent, but he didn’t. Therefore no counter is added. Scott did choose to give a counter to J man, but that does not require Scott to give a counter to the stonecoil. I think you may be thinking of a permanent having two different kinds of counters on it. If that were true, the proliferation would require that a counter of each type be put onto the thing. But in this case, all appears to be in order. If we are wrong, please share a source or link so we can review it too! Thanks buddy

that's simply not true

Fraid not: 701.26a To proliferate means to choose any number of permanents and/or players that have a counter, then give each one additional counter of each kind that permanent or player already has. So if you have an energy counter & - 1/-1 on a creature, it gets one of each, but you don't need to target that creature when you proliferate, even if you target its controller.

@@Lewbee you don't target when you proliferate

@@antonchichona6700 yep sorry mb

You should ask that in our Discord and see what people have to say too. I vote Plamp. Plamp is strictly better than Swains.

Oh that's easy. The answer is: Yes.

We're working on getting an initial order that we will put up for sale. If interested let us know and we will loop back when we are able to sell them :)