Тёмный

Compare the Heipi 3-in-1 Carbon Tripod with PD Carbon Tripod 

PlanIt Photo
Подписаться 7 тыс.
Просмотров 11 тыс.
50% 1

I found a great tripod - Heipi 3-in-1 tripod. I haven't done any product review videos before but I love this tripod so much that I can't resist from giving it a try (without pay). So I compared the Heipi tripod with the PD tripod I had for more than two years and here is the video.
I don't normally make a video that is this long. But if you want to spend $300 on a brand new product/design, I assume you would like to know more about it before purchasing. If so, this video will fit you well. You can also click a chapter below to jump to a certain topic which will save you some time.
Timeline:
00:00 Categories of Tripods
01:06 The Design of Central Column
04:52 Compare the Heipi with PD
05:08 Portability
06:42 Max load
08:25 Stability
13:34 Features
13:51 Platform for the Plate
15:06 Ball Head
16:57 Mobile Phone Support
19:11 Flip Locks
20:49 Leg Feet
21:39 Price
22:05 Extra from Heipi
22:28 Dual Tripod
25:27 Panorama Support
29:55 Weight
30:38 Final Thoughts

Хобби

Опубликовано:

 

30 июл 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 88   
@edwood1090
@edwood1090 2 месяца назад
Extremely detailed and informative. No life stories and rambling eating up half the video. Just straight to the point. Thank you..
@user-em2we5gy6t
@user-em2we5gy6t Год назад
Great tripod comparison! I've never seen a video like this that compares some of the most important tripod perspectives. I'm in the market for a new tripod and this was a great help. Thanks for the great video.
@PlanItPhoto
@PlanItPhoto Год назад
Thank you. HEIPI Also listened to the feedbacks provided by me and other users so in the next revision of this tripod, it will be even better
@moshesalama
@moshesalama Год назад
Fantastic in depth review!
@Ghatbkk
@Ghatbkk 9 месяцев назад
Excellent comparison and review of the Heipi 3 in 1 and the PD. I've been considering a Heipi 3 in 1 and this really helped.
@PlanItPhoto
@PlanItPhoto 9 месяцев назад
Thank you. It is on sales right now.
@stephenelderphoto
@stephenelderphoto Год назад
I already backed the Heipe tripod but I want to thank you for this superb video. You provided a lot of information that makes me glad I backed the product. I’ve subscribed to your channel to see what other interesting content you have. Thanks again!
@PlanItPhoto
@PlanItPhoto Год назад
You're very welcome! Making this kind of review videos is not my main effort but it was fun to make it as I really like this tripod.
@edselharrison
@edselharrison Год назад
Excellent review and comparison. Best I've seen yet!
@PlanItPhoto
@PlanItPhoto Год назад
Thank you, Ed!
@newtonsantos_photo963
@newtonsantos_photo963 Год назад
Awesome review, congratulations!!! I am just waiting for mine to be delivered as soon as the final adjustments of the prototype design have finished later this year 🙌🏻
@PlanItPhoto
@PlanItPhoto Год назад
Thank you, You will like it.
@RyanHardKnockDC
@RyanHardKnockDC Год назад
Great review. I'm not for one to watch 30 minutes video however I thoroughly enjoyed how you compared the Heipi and the PD tripod. That kept me engaged. Your review pretty much sold me and I'm about to back Heipi. After finishing that video I was curious to see what else you've reviewed and didn't find much. I hope down the road you will review more things. You got a new follower =) Looking forward to more videos by you.
@PlanItPhoto
@PlanItPhoto Год назад
Thanks for taking the time to watch the video. I am the author of a photo planning app called Planit Pro so my videos were mainly teaching people how to use the app. This is actually the first time I review a photography equipment, which shows I like this product so much. So yes, I did use a lot of equipment when I worked on the app, so when I got a chance I will review more products that I like.
@thomasshi8863
@thomasshi8863 Год назад
This is the BEST tripod comparison video I have ever watched! I was looking for a light but sturdy travel tripod a few months back and saw nice reviews on the Heipi (prototypes). As you pointed out, there are lots of smart but critical designs from the Heipi. I missed the earliest $299 price but $329 is still not bad. A few weeks ago Heipi started delivery. Hope I can get it before my April trip.
@PlanItPhoto
@PlanItPhoto Год назад
Thank you. Hope you will enjoy the tripod as I do.
@tinamcbridephotographyllc9364
Wow. This was extremely helpful. Thank you!!
@danasuechilds
@danasuechilds Год назад
Excellent video and details on the comparison. I especially liked the comparison of the different legs and stability as they are extended. Even that alone along with all the other features and price difference gives Heipi a leg up with the current competition.
@PlanItPhoto
@PlanItPhoto Год назад
My pleasure! Glad that you like the way I compare.
@letmebereal
@letmebereal 2 месяца назад
Nice review, well done.
@KanakiGrl
@KanakiGrl Год назад
Thank you so much for this! Excellent review, so much helpful information.
@PlanItPhoto
@PlanItPhoto Год назад
Thanks. I am glad that you find it helpful.
@eViperRabbit
@eViperRabbit Год назад
Thank you for the excellent review. This is the best review and comparison of tripods that I have ever seen. 3 years ago when PD launched their tripod on Kickstarter, I did not go for it because I was concerned that the legs are not stable enough for my needs although the small form factor was very attractive. After watching many YT videos over the past few years, my concerns are confirmed and your demo from 11:50 nailed it. Although this is my first time on your channel, your clear presentation and arguments in the video have won me over to buy the Heipi tripod on Kickstarter. I believe that my wait for a good travel tripod is now finally over!!!
@PlanItPhoto
@PlanItPhoto Год назад
Thanks Edmund. The first time doing this so I am glad you find it useful. You will love the tripod. I consider this tripod to be the next generation of the tripods.
@denisng7423
@denisng7423 Год назад
Very comprehensive review. Thanks!
@PlanItPhoto
@PlanItPhoto Год назад
Glad you like it!
@bernym4047
@bernym4047 Год назад
Excellent review. Thank you.
@robertdouglas9345
@robertdouglas9345 Год назад
Excellent video my friend! Very helpful. I already own the PD as well as the Ulanzi, but it looks like I will be adding the Heipi as well. God bless!
@PlanItPhoto
@PlanItPhoto Год назад
Thank you, Robert, I'm glad you like it.
@muleyg
@muleyg Год назад
Great video and very informative.
@PlanItPhoto
@PlanItPhoto Год назад
Thank you. Glad it was helpful!
@hishamosman4341
@hishamosman4341 Год назад
Think HEIPI has hit a home run with their 3 in 1 creation. By designing that centre piece into a 3 legged small tripod is very innovative indeed. Those doing macro and food shots will welcome this thought process. The legs on the main tripod is more sturdy then PD.
@rphandler
@rphandler Год назад
Wonderful technical review. I have now backed it via Kickstarter. Wish the panning swivel were above the ball as it is in my heavier Arca Swiss p0 head, but I gather that feature is patent protected.
@PlanItPhoto
@PlanItPhoto Год назад
Thanks. You will like the tripod. Hope they will release a separate ball head with the top panning.
@LeicaCat
@LeicaCat Год назад
Thank you for this video
@PlanItPhoto
@PlanItPhoto Год назад
My pleasure
@d3bz875
@d3bz875 Год назад
great comparison video. I almost bought the PD tripod for my next trip in April. Looks like the Heipi tripod would be much better for my needs. I hope I can put my Star Adventurer astro tracker on it. Btw. the panoramic clamps aren't patented everywhere. In Europe they're readily available.
@PlanItPhoto
@PlanItPhoto Год назад
Thanks. Hope Heipi can release a separate ball head that has the top panning feature, at least in non-US market.
@wandererstraining
@wandererstraining Год назад
Thanks for the comparison! I have the PD one already, but I'm thinking I wouldn't mind getting the Heipi tripod as well. Speaking of the PD tripod, the phone clamp is flimsy. I broke it, replaced it, then broke it again, and I wasn't reckless with it. Love the feature, but unfortunately it wasn't made of all metal, which should have been the case for such a small accessory.
@PlanItPhoto
@PlanItPhoto Год назад
Thanks. That's true. I heard my friend also broke the phone holder a couple of times. At least PD lifetime warranty is good.
@wandererstraining
@wandererstraining Год назад
@@PlanItPhoto It is good! And PD's tripod is very good. I'll happily use both tripods.
@danhiggins8733
@danhiggins8733 Год назад
Very good comparison. I have also seen the one by Mads. Strong, safe, solid compatibility with the Peak Design Capture plates (v3) and with any Arca Swiss style plate or brackets such as the RRS L brackets need to be proven/demonstrated to me before I would invest in this tripod. I have the PD and a Ulanzi imitation. But the leg design on this is very compelling. It just needs to be safely and solidly compatible with these very common plates.
@PlanItPhoto
@PlanItPhoto Год назад
They listened to us and other kickstarters' feedback and made it compatible with almost all plates. See a video at ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-Jke2Ef_JChg.html
@rs779
@rs779 Год назад
Great review - detailed and helpful. I was looking at the Ulanzi Zero Y but this seems more versatile. Have you reviewed the Ulanzi? Couple of questions 1) can you mount a leveling base (like the Leofoto LB-60) between the tripod and the head, and/or do you expect Heipi to have one available and 2) it looks like your L-bracket has a tilt feature. If yes - can you advise make, and if not how did you tilt at 27:31
@PlanItPhoto
@PlanItPhoto Год назад
I had a separate video comparing five travel tripods side by side. The conclusion for zero y is at ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-TlYMNzo-1AY.html. 1) Yes, you can use any leveling bases. What I don't like about all existing leveling bases is that they are all too thick, which will decrease the stability. Heipi will release a new leveling base with a new design which will be much thinner. 2) It is an OEM brand and I don't think it is there on Amazon. You can think it as a L bracket with a panning platform. But instead of using L bracket, I simplified it to only using a nodal slide for multiple row panorama which I showed later in this video. You may consider it as an option. Of course, you need to level the tripod first.
@marklaurendet1861
@marklaurendet1861 Год назад
An interesting tripod, and a good comparison. Unless I missed it what materials are the legs of the centre tripod and lever locks made from? Wonder if you can buy spare parts from them. I guess warranty would be easier with Peak Designs as well. But it certainly looks like one to keep a watch on to see how it goes long term and if the final model gets around the earlier problem of not fitting a wide range of arca swiss plates.
@PlanItPhoto
@PlanItPhoto Год назад
Both CC and level locks were made of aluminum. Plate compatibility will be fixed in the final release.
@rphandler
@rphandler Год назад
Thanks for a very informative review! I purchased mine through Kickstarter. I may sell it. There are three components: the main legs, the sub tripod, and the head. I like the sub tripod. It's useful for wildflower photography close to the ground. The more I use the head, the less I like it. Using a 600 g lens such as my Sony 90mm macro, the camera is front heavy. Making fine adjustments in the ball position is too difficult because friction and locking are governed by a tiny short throw lever with little mechanical advantage. Loosen it slightly and the camera moves too easily and too far. When the tilting notch faces away from the photographer, as it will when aiming downwards, this tiny lever is on the left side of the head. My non-dominant left thumb is not powerful enough to clamp the ball firmly enough to prevent camera drift. So this head may have a large ball, but for me it's less stable than heads I own with smaller balls. Even with the collar around the sub tripod forcefully tightened there is some give and horizontal motion when the camera is handled, disconcerting and detrimental. The main legs are sufficiently stable. The flintlock clamps were initially very stiff but are breaking in (will they loosen too much with normal wear?). The tripod with its sub tripod and head weights 1.05 kg My Sirui AM 284 legs + my Arca p0 ballhead + Novoflex Q-Mount clamp also weighs exactly 1.05 kg. Its maximum height is about that of the Heipi with its sub tripod 25% extended. It can go low, within 20mm as low as does the Heipi sub tripod, and works just as well (or better) for those tiny flowers. It is more stable, much easier and faster to set up and take down, and when the legs are extended and splayed, as would be used over a brook, it is far more rigid than is the Heipi. (If someone wished less weight they could use the Sirui AM 254 legs instead of the 284.) And the Arca p0 has a wonderful friction control + an ovoid ball which gets tighter as the camera is tilted. So what is the advantage of the Heipi? It does have a center column which taller photographers might wish and which is useful to clear high obstructing railings. The Heipi takes less room in my carry on bag, but my Sirui AM 284 also fits. Both tripods are of equal weight when added to my camera backpack, and if I mount my Arca p0 head the Heipi becomes heavier than the Sirui. So when I am going to travel and and walk with 1.05 kg of tripod, I'll choose my Sirui AM 284 with the Arca p0.
@PlanItPhoto
@PlanItPhoto Год назад
Thanks for the detailed comment. It is a personal preference end of the day. I took Heipi where i go nowadays. You can certainly choose something else as long as you like it.
@harats1
@harats1 Год назад
hi, thank you for good and profesional review, is the head is arca swiss compatible for L-Plate mount?
@PlanItPhoto
@PlanItPhoto Год назад
Thanks. Yes, it is. Most people only noticed the innovative tri-pillar central column, but its quick release clamp is also an invention. Most other quick release systems require a custom plate and no L-plate. Other systems require two hands to operate. But Heipi's quick release works with any PD-like square plates or L-plates, and can be put it on using just one hand.
@jungjingogo
@jungjingogo Год назад
Thank you for good comparison. I already have a lot of Peak Design Camera Gear. So I wonder I can use Peak Design Plate with Heipi Tripod. Is it possible? and safe?
@PlanItPhoto
@PlanItPhoto Год назад
Yes, absolutely
@Sustainavore
@Sustainavore Год назад
It's it possible to insert the top tripod upside down into the main tripod (while extended) to allow an underslung camera mount?
@PlanItPhoto
@PlanItPhoto Год назад
Yes
@bluwasabi7635
@bluwasabi7635 8 месяцев назад
Do you think the new lanyard could support a 10 pound pack below the tripod, or would the PD's hook be better?
@PlanItPhoto
@PlanItPhoto 8 месяцев назад
10 or even 20 lb is absolutely fine. There is no space for a bigger hook so it is not a choice.
@PlanItPhoto
@PlanItPhoto 8 месяцев назад
I asked HEIPI and they told me it is rated 30kg😂 i guess the tripod couldn't even hold that weight.
@bluwasabi7635
@bluwasabi7635 8 месяцев назад
good to know. Thank you. @@PlanItPhoto
@zachrohe
@zachrohe Год назад
Could i use a L bracket with the Heipi tripod? My L bracket is about 1-2mm wider than the peak design plate. Looks like there is zero adjustment with the Heipi's plate retention system.
@PlanItPhoto
@PlanItPhoto Год назад
1-2mm wider is too much. Most plates that I know are within 1mm if they claim them to be arca-swiss compatible. Which brand is it? Some L brackets work with Hepi as long as the bottom is hollow at certain location so that it will not be conflict with the two stopper screws.
@zachrohe
@zachrohe Год назад
@planitphoto the L bracket is Mefoto and it matches the arca Swiss plate on my 70-200 but both are a bit larger than my peak design plate. It just seems like there is no wiggle room on the heipi's mount and I would hate to order it and it doesn't work.
@PlanItPhoto
@PlanItPhoto Год назад
By wider, do u mean width or length? If the length is wide, you can workaround it by removing the two stopper screws.
@ThePilotSports
@ThePilotSports 2 месяца назад
Will the Peak Design plate fit on the Heipi ball head?
@PlanItPhoto
@PlanItPhoto 20 дней назад
Kinda of yes, work but not perfect.
@cudackedees3327
@cudackedees3327 Год назад
There is no way to break the Heipi down for cleaning?
@PlanItPhoto
@PlanItPhoto Год назад
You can but need some skills. Not meant for average people. Watch ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-fvIFKG39bfU.html where I disassembled it. The video is in Chinese but you can choose auto-translate to see the English subtitle.
@jcoelhofoto
@jcoelhofoto Год назад
Where i can Buy the Heipi tripod please
@PlanItPhoto
@PlanItPhoto Год назад
Right now in US, the only way to pre-order this tripod is at www.indiegogo.com/projects/heipi-the-most-compact-3-in-1-travel-tripod#/. But just so you know, it is $339 right now, unless you get two at $638.
@rkefacebook9956
@rkefacebook9956 Год назад
BEWARE. Most of us who paid for this tripod on Indiegogo have not received our tripods, which are now three months late. We were supposed to receive our tripods in March, but the shipping date has been pushed back two or three times. We were promised that we would receive our tripods in May. As of May 31, we have no tripod (at least those of in the US and Europe). HEIPI has stopped responding to requests for updated shipping information. However, backers of HEIPI's Kickstarter campaign for this tripod have received their tripods as of early May. HEIPI is responding to backers on their Kickstarter campaign. This is very disconcerting to say the least for those of us who are backers of the Indiegogo campaign.
@PlanItPhoto
@PlanItPhoto Год назад
They are working on a new production line, making an improved model after accepting feedbacks from us early adapters. I understand it is hard to wait but you will receive it sooner or later.
@bunchastuff5355
@bunchastuff5355 Год назад
@@PlanItPhoto Do I order now or wait? Current price on their site is at 349, thanks
@PlanItPhoto
@PlanItPhoto Год назад
$349 is a good price.
@skywalkerfeng1734
@skywalkerfeng1734 Год назад
I have been using the Peak Design tripod for 2+ years. IMO, its biggest weakness is the ball head. I just can't get it to lock to a precise position. Every time I fully locked the ball head, the lens would "sink" a bit to a slightly lower position, which affect the photo composition I have planed for. I guess it is due to the rather small diameter of the ball, so it can't be locked precisely. I wonder what is your personal experience with the Heipi tripod? Can you firmly lock its ball head to a precise position without any further movement?
@PlanItPhoto
@PlanItPhoto Год назад
I just tried PD using a long lens. The "nodding head" problem exists but not that bad in my opinion. You can just push your camera up and down to see the movement. The problem may not be from the ball head but from the legs. Travel tripod legs are all "weak" due to its size.
@skywalkerfeng1734
@skywalkerfeng1734 Год назад
@@PlanItPhoto I just compared the PD tripod with Gitzo GT1555T with the same camera/lens setup. Both are lightweight travel tripods, with similar weight and packed size. PD tripod has oval legs, much thinner center column. Gitzo has traditional round legs, center column twice as thick. Both have tiny ball head, the diameter of the ball are about the same. Gitzo tripod is much more stable, can tolerate much stronger side impact without introducing noticeable vibration. Both exhibit the "nodding head" problem, but PD tripod's problem is much worse. I think the problem comes from both the ball head and the legs. It seems the oval-shaped legs are not as stable as the traditional round-shaped legs.
@PlanItPhoto
@PlanItPhoto Год назад
That Gitzo is the old style travel tripod which is very bulky. I probably will never buy it and carry it for a long hike. PD is a new compact style but with a price of course. It will be less stable but much easier to carry. I mostly don't use the last section of the PD and central column. You just choose the right tripod based on your requirements. I also have no double the Heipi 3 pillar central column will be way more stable than the old single pillar central column. I will another video comparison soon to show the test results of stiffness test of different tripods including RRS.
@skywalkerfeng1734
@skywalkerfeng1734 Год назад
@@PlanItPhoto Based on your personal experience, how does the Heipi tripod compared to PD, in terms of stableness? Does the Heipi ball head shows the same "nodding head" problem as PD does?
@skywalkerfeng1734
@skywalkerfeng1734 Год назад
@@PlanItPhoto I used Gitzo GT1555T for quite some time, before switching to PD, for its compact size. PD has a smaller diameter, but Gitzo is 5cm shorter. However, I have ruined quite a few long-exposure shot, because PD tripod is not stable enough. I think PD tripod sacrificed too much stableness to achieve the compact size. I am hoping Heipi would provide a more balanced solution between compact size and stableness.
@Thetinebroken
@Thetinebroken Год назад
But why can't you buy anywhere
@PlanItPhoto
@PlanItPhoto Год назад
You can buy at heipivision.com. Not sure if they have it in stock but it will be first come first serve.
Далее
Five Travel Tripods Comparison
35:56
Просмотров 29 тыс.
The Best Value Carbon Fiber Travel Tripod
13:05
Просмотров 27 тыс.
Best 5 travel tripods of 2024
21:52
Просмотров 19 тыс.
The Best 2024 Travel Tripod? | HEIPI w/ GFX100s
18:24
Peak Design Travel Tripod Review (BRUTALLY Honest)
8:05
Заварушка на пляже!
1:00
Просмотров 4,7 млн
СВАДЬБА МОЕГО ЛУЧШЕГО ДРУГА
0:24