The difference between Bandori and Project Sekai covers if bandori ones feel like a live concert and they apply their own style to the instrumental and vocals. The project Sekai ones feel like a cover artist and try their best to sound like the original. Though, both are good in their own way. It all depends on your taste..
Also project Sekai has a set of really unique voices! Like mixing and seeing how it turns out is smth to look out for in project Sekai covers which is fun to listen to
@TenmasAgenda Yeah. The bandori vocalist are the only ones who sing most of the time, with the other characters only getting small lines. Project Sekai uses their characters vocals to the fullest and use mixing methods on the vocals. Bandori their vocals are really good, professional even, but if doesn't have the same teenage like feel to it (which doesn't matter much now since some are in college) but project Sekai has vocals that are seem more fun or have that "I just want to do it for fun" feel, which is expected since they're teenagers. In other words, Bandori vocals sound more professional and crisp, and project Sekai ones sound more authentic and realistic.
@@MayonesaMitchRAS is so bad with this too like we know they're a band and all but i just want to hear lock, masking, and pareo (outside of planet loop),sing at least a small part of a song alone, other bands let the members sing small parts man... (idk aby mygo and morfonica though bc i don't listen to them)
bandori feels very powerfully vocal oriented, its almost like a very insanely talented group decided to cover a song instead of deliver the real vibe of the song
이게 좋다 저게 좋다 같은 각자의 취향이 있는 건 당연한 겁니다 다만 극소수의 사람은 본인이 마음에 안 든다고 정말 기분 나쁜 비하를 하는 사람이 보입니다 그냥 노래를 듣고 즐기면 되는 겁니다 그저 편곡의 방향성이 다를 뿐이지 그 편곡과 차이를 단순히 즐기면 되는 겁니다!! これがいい、あれがいいといった各自の好みがあるのは当然のことです。本当にただ少数の人は本人が気に入らないと本当に気持ち悪い卑下をする人が見えます ただ歌を聞いて楽しめばいいのです。ただ編曲の方向性が違うだけで、その編曲と違いを単純に楽しめばいいのです!!
Both are good but it depends on your preference, I'll say my OWN thoughts Bandori Likes - custom instrumentals - powerful vocals - own style/arrangement - unique and cool Dislikes - most covers are sung by the vocalist (ik that's how it should be but still) - less into emotions Pjsekai Likes - Close to original - Sings with emotions - They all get to sing, with vocaloids - voice mixing, and good quality of harmony Dislikes - mixing and line distribution sometimes ruin the cover - vocaloid tuning - no own band arrangement for leo/need
honestly the vocaloids tuning has always been good, its just people only talk abt the tuning when its bad.... like, I remember when everyone said colpal always does luka dirty when they literally used the og tuning in meteor pulse(or atleast its very close) and for bandori, the unique vocals could be a plus, but its an acquired taste cus its just very nasal, like emu or nene dialed up to 1000x but i can still appreciate it since its recognizable which is what youd want
In my opinion. The contrast between both vocaloid and human singer in the covers just never sounded right to me. At some point it genuinely feels like the vocaloids just exist in the song to tell you "HEY THIS IS A VOCALOID GAME!!" And the VA's they sound really good, just their voices don't contrast well with that of the vocaloids or sometimes other way around. that is if the song has emu in it (screaming her vocals obnoxiously) Again just my silly personal opinion. Knowing the prosekai fandom please don't bash me for it, that's very immature
@@MarxPopstar69 I can see where you come from, but i personally disagree esp because a lot of songs sound good BECAUSE you can tell the difference (someth like Tokugawa cup noodle is an exception cus holy hell the tuning is so human) a song i can say is definitely like this is kitty or dokuzu but I can definitely see why you wouldnt like the vocas and ocs being mixed together cus sometimes its a disaster (im looking at you patchwork staccato....)
뱅드림을 더 오래해서 그런건진 몰라도… 노래를 편곡해서 밴드처럼 해놓은게 너무 좋음… 프세카는 원곡처럼 해놔서 좀 더 깔끔한 느낌이였음 프세카는 멤버 모두가 같이 노랠 부르면서 목소리가 섞이니 좋은데 뱅드림은 보컬이나 두세명이 부르는데 그것도 그거대로 좋음… 난 밴드가 더 좋고 베이스가 잘들려서 너무 좋음… 란 유키나 레이야가 진짜 개잘부름ㄹㅈㄷ임진자로…너므잘불러
I was in utaite fandom and usually search for covers that stay true to the original version, so overall i prefer prsk's version. But i like bandori too, sometimes you just want to listen to a version that is different from the others
i think that, removed from context for the song and story, bandori's covers will usually sound better. but where puroseka really shines is how context makes it more emotional. bandori delivers on the technical side of things, but take the song Charles for example. at least in my understanding of the game, the song doesn't fit yukina's or roselia's story. it does, however, fit mizuki and ena's with the whole keeping secrets/miscommunication thing they've got going on! so, bandori is good for people who like more technical quality and proseka is good for people who like story and diversity in their music (thanks to all the different vocaloid producers they commission and cover). thank you for coming to my TedTalk
그런 애들이 이상한거니까 신경끄고 갈 길 가는게 나아요 자기가 선택한게 더 우월함을 인정받고 싶나보죠 다 잘하니까 굳이 스트레스 받지 마요 둘 다 하는 사람이 워낙 많기도 해서 여기 댓글은 전반적으로 누가 압승이다 뭐다보단 취향 얘기로 깔리기도 했고ㅋㅋ 첫대댓 저건 또 웃기네 이해못할일도 아니면서
nice comparison! thx for your hardwork yet i think choosing 25 instead of mfy as phony's cover may be a better choice. as that version is an alternative cover, the original one is covered by both members of 25.
Overall Bandori's covers are a lot more unique since it's not just the voice that change, but I do want characters that are not the lead singer to sing more, ROKI is a great cover because Moca also sings in it