This was a bucket list conversation for me! (I do hope I don’t kick the bucket any time soon.) But talking to you, your amazing team, and your brilliant audience was the thrill of a lifetime! I hope to share more with you all someday. For now, keep watching the heavens!
Yeah I asked a flat Earth guy if he believed in microscopes. He said no and like 25 people laughed at him. Good times. These days you have to remind people. Don't cut off your penis. They just might.
i’m not a guy that cries often and i never ever cry in public, but yrs ago i went on a date to the observatory in socal and they had a rep working there that brought me to a huge telescope and told me to look through. i saw jupiter. but then he told me to stay there for a few more moments and i saw movement-like grains of sand move across- and i was like “woah, what was that?” and he explained that i had just witnessed one of the biggest long-standing storms in our near solar system. i was so impacted by that, the most beautiful thing i’ve ever seen in nature. i couldn’t believe it; it made me so teary-eyed just standing there seeing it, impacts me still to this day. such an incredible sight.
Enormous 55" Chihuahua KOCK transplanted onto a man. 98" VEINY WRINKLED KOCK glistening in the moonlight. Beads of sweat drip down the shaft. The shiny tip continues to wave in the midnight air. Suddenly, the 98" KOCK prepares to enter a tight BIT WHOLE. BUT WHOLE DESTROYED. DEMOLISHED BUT WHOLE. BUT WHOLE WRECKED. BLOODY KOCK EXITS THE DEMOLISHED BUT WHOLE
@@AmandaRaeGA Are you an astronomer? Astronomers actually look up to the heavens with a telescope. Reading what's available to you, or watching on RU-vid does not make you one.
Been waiting for this podcast for a long time as a big fan of Dr Brian’s podcast, his sense of humor, and his open mindedness and curiosity that extends to matters of spirit.
Yet his biblical illiteracy is laughable. Funny how he doesnt use the same discretion towards it as he does everything else. all from a so called "jewish" man
Hands down one of the most fascinating, deep-dive interview related to (among other things) physics, cosmology, aliens, and the history and origins of the universe that Joe Rogan has ever done. Dr. Keating is the rare genius who not only makes complex AND complicated ideas accessible, but who also makes it entertaining to really listen, learn, and understand them.
Enormous 55" Chihuahua KOCK transplanted onto a man. 98" VEINY WRINKLED KOCK glistening in the moonlight. Beads of sweat drip down the shaft. The shiny tip continues to wave in the midnight air. Suddenly, the 98" KOCK prepares to enter a tight BIT WHOLE. BUT WHOLE DESTROYED. DEMOLISHED BUT WHOLE. BUT WHOLE WRECKED. BLOODY KOCK EXITS THE DEMOLISHED BUT WHOLE
As a young teen i had a cheap ass telescope, i saw Jupiter up close through the lens not just a light with some moons i mean the tans, yellows, red clouds of Jupiter. For me it was life changing
Every once in a while joe brings on fascinating people to listen to again like the old days. Not his fault, he's talked to nearly everyone worth listening to.
Bring back all the theoretical physicists and other scientists, they are genuine, interesting and fact based. Brian Cox was brilliant but the podcast was 4 years ago.
One of the best episodes I've listened to in a while! Never thought I'd care so much about Galileo, for many years I knew him as "that dude from Bohemian Rhapsody" 😆
THAAAAAAAAAAAAAT'S a bit misleading. Goyum is NOT a neutral word. If YOU hear a jewish person saying that around you, just realize they just called you an animal, that is open for any jewish peson to rip off per the Torah.
I didn't know Brian Keating, so I'm so happy that I stumbled upon this. This was one of the best JRE episodes ever. I'll definitely start listening to Brian's podcast.
0:00: 🔭 Galileo used a telescope to observe the planets and realize that the sun is the center of the solar system. 2:24: 🌟 Stars twinkle due to scintillation caused by atmospheric conditions, while planets do not twinkle. 5:29: 🔭 Galileo's sketches and writings on his observations of Jupiter and its moons. 7:50: 🔭 Galileo's sketch of the Moon through a telescope emphasized a non-existent crater to convey its appearance and feeling. 10:04: 🌍 Galileo's realization that the Earth is not the center of the universe and his struggle to convey this idea to people with strong religious beliefs. 12:58: 📚 Galileo, a religious scientist, believed that scientific truth and religious beliefs could coexist, but this idea could be threatening to the government. Recap by Tammy AI
Just want to point out how incredibly smart Joe is intuitionally, of course he isn't educated to a phd level etc. But during this podcast he actually correctly pushed back to Brian on probablity of life and Brian did (in conversation) make the Bayesian fallacy whereby he equated probability of conditions creating life, to just our life, and if you understand probablity etc. You'll understand why this is a huge fallacy on the outcome side of the argument. Joe pushed back using intuition alone and rightly noted that it is perhaps the case that many different forms of life could be the outcome and therefore each of those could incorrectly make the same mistake of thinking they are 'the life' outcome. Was just very impressed that Joe without any real education on the matter intuited that!
great comment. Brian was intriguing for most of the interview, but when he was debating aliens, etc, he cant for the life of him speak concisely or convincingly. Brian holds obscure, untested statistical formulas at high regard (probability of life), but dismisses hard evidence ( several first hand accounts from senior level military officials, in addition to video). It becomes clear that he is pessimistic, and then makes the argument that only he and astonomers can verify aliens?? really? Joe was good to point him out
I feel like this guy is elevating Galileo beyond what he deserves credit for. A lot of people knew the universe wasn't geocentric before Galileo. 1000 years before in fact. It just became suppressed during the dark ages of Christianity.
I love the way he is explaining this all so nicely. A 16 year old kid can understand what he's talking about. It is so important to understand the history of science.
I've had that sketch of Jupiter with the 4 moons, from Galileo, tattoo'd on the back of my hand for a couple of years. I have it as a constant reminder that not everything revolves around us, and not everything revolves around me, and to think bigger picture. It blue me away, seeing this small depiction of Jupiter and the Moons, and what it meant for Space as a whole.
Love this whole discussion. Brian's role as an experimentalist, whose job it is to narrow the field of possibilities for certain theories, seems to provide an ideology that's more of a skeptic. This is consistent with his claims regarding intelligent life in the universe (or lack there of) and his skepticism towards UAP's being legitimate. It's good to have an alternative perspective. His role and ideology seem analogous to a debunker.
Perhaps, Brian's perspective is one of the only perspectives we should listen to as it seems he's one of the most qualified to comment around UAP's and its all basically down to elimination by subtraction.
@@josephfischer3789 Why would we listen to only Brian's perspective on this? He's credible and respected, but I'd estimate he's in the single digits, of percentage points, of respected, credible people in his field who believe there is no other life in the universe. Maybe you've sought out the one opinion you are championing because it matches with your own personal ideology....typically, religious?
@@michaelmiller6878 That's all I can base it on. I can't speak for you or anybody else. All I can say is, I've listened to all sides of the arguments around UAP's but considering Dr Brian's field of expertise and what he's researched he is one person I can say who would have a front row seat to view what is out there.
@@josephfischer3789 Fair enough. Like you, I try to evaluate any opinion I have based on a well read examination of viewpoints from people I consider experts in the field. On this particular one, Keating is the only one, of maybe 10-12 people who I follow and have respect for in the field, who espouses this view. Doesn't mean he's wrong, I just didn't find his Mars explanation very compelling, as it's one planet amongst billions of potentials, that would need to be studied to confirm this theory. As we learn more, like there being even more solar systems in the universe than previously thought, from what we imagined were "dead spaces" in our field of vision, that are now illuminated through the Webb Telescope, we see the probabilities for other life only increasing. I appreciate his skepticism but wonder if it's tainted by his non-scientific beliefs, like religion or other.
Last year I got a telescope and when I first saw Jupiter and especially Saturn it was really mind blowing but for beauty , the moon and it’s craters had me out every clear night for weeks.
@@andresil8330 I got mine off marketplace for $100 Australian dollars. There were lots on there. Saxon 76/700 reflector was the one I had (I sold it as I needed the money) but I think they’re cheap new too. I could see Saturns’ rings clearly.
Am I the only person who thinks this guy is super close minded? He immediately shut down any speculation of life in the universe and thinks that the ufo footage is most likely a misunderstanding by experienced pilots..
Ugh, "I'm Jewish" instantly caused me to pause the video, write this comment, and scram. They always say Jewish doesn't define them, but they bring it up every chance they get.
The Orthodox Jews built and maintain a wire around NYC just to bend God's rules that they're so determined to follow to the T. Jews and Amish turn to God when it benefits them.
The Koine Greek word for "tripod" is τρίποδον (tripodon). In ancient Greece, a tripod referred to a three-legged stand or support often used to hold sacred objects, offering containers, or even as prizes for athletic or artistic competitions.
Love hearing smart people talk on this show that have a great deal of experience and are passionate in what it is they are talking about. Much more intriguing, well done.
Didn't Copernicus propose the Sun as the center of the Solar Sytem? I think Galileo confirmed it with his observations. It's some mind expanding stuff anyway and then Newton came along and blew everyone outta the water!
Yep, also there were societies and religions claiming this same thing 5 thousand years ago, doesn't mean they had any kind of proof, but there has been many people that have proposed this for thousands of years
The heliocentric model was known since antiquity, and right up to Galileo's time. The problem was that there wasn't any system to explain the movement of the planets. See Aristarcus.
Kepler was a contemporary of Galileo. His heliocentric model made more accurate predictions. It had deeper insights - Kepler’s laws paved the way for Isaac Newton. But Galileo gets the press. That is because his story better fits a popular anti-theist narrative.
Joe sounds like he is definitely hooked on this. And going to buy an observers tower telescope station. With a comfortable chair so he can relax and gaze at planets and maybe the stars. Have at it, this is good stuff.
When Stephen meyer was a guest Joe made sure to vigorously interrogate the ways in which his religious views influenced his scientific thinking and his general philosophy. That is what was missing with this episode. It is evident that Keating’s religious views play a role in his views. Especially around the topic of non-human intelligences that may or may not exist beyond our solar system. Also Joe elected to barely push back against the somewhat shocking views of Keating when it comes to whether we should colonize our solar system and beyond, his questioning of why it is important to preserve humanity into the future, etc.
Jupiter has a LOT more than 4 moons. Io, Europa, Ganymede and Callisto were the first to be seen and discovered by Galileo but today we know there are many more. I think it’s somewhere around 90-100 moons now.
The reason why people believed the Earth was the center of everything is because being in the center is relative. If you asked an ancient person to picture "Earth" they would look around. Modern people picturing earth imagine an image from outer space of looking down on earth.
So cool to see Brian Keating on Rogan. His podcast is one of my favorites as he has excellent guests and discusses all sorts of science. He too, apparently, makes a great guest and it's excellent that he got this exposure. Dude deserves it!
I love the way he described the relationship between religious beliefs and science. I’ve always felt this way. The truth science uncovers is God’s signature.
Keating is a good experiment as far as physics goes and he gets great guests aswell. I do enjoy his podcast. Good to see Joe getting into these fields 👍. Now if we can get Joe to help get these wars over we can get our arses into the vacuum for good. Peace ✌️
Naw... It was a dude chiefed the F out lost on a dead end road asking how to get back to the main road with the Google Maps logo covering his entire vehicle.
He was born Catholic and converted to Judaism. Pretty cringe to bring up being Jewish despite not being one by blood. Just goes to show you that being Jewish makes people listen to you and take you seriously
@@josephkrohl7357 I saw an old dictionary definition of Jew and it said something about knowledge. I guess it was originally a title for men, not a race or religion.
