Creep - Vintage Postmodern Jukebox Radiohead Cover ft. Haley Reinhart (Reaction) 

Hayley Reinhart is one of the most underrated singers of our time. She really needs more exposure. She's just incredible.

4:55 "Did she just skat her way to my heart?" Yes, yes she did...and take a number ;)

She could sing the Federal tax code deductions book and I'd listen.

Not sure if you know this, but she did this on the FIRST take. There was no dubbing, no retakes. She walked in and laid this down all natural... So talented.

If you close your eyes you can almost feel yourself sitting in a smoky Jazz club in the 1930's or 40's listening to a taut vixen pouring that sultry sound right in your ears like a golden honey.

Haley Reinhart is the Human form of Jessica Rabbit when she sings with PMJ. She is AMAZING.

I’ve been a fan of Haley since her American Idol days. Her rendition of this song really shows off her dynamic vocal abilities.

I love PMJ, all they do is solid. Morgan James is another one to check out.

You should listen to the original. Radiohead: Creep. The song is about a man that is in love with a woman, but too shy to approach her. They said the lead singer wrote it from personal experience...

She brought me tears, goosebumps, and awe all at same time.

It doesn't matter how many times I hear Haley's rendition of Creep, every single time I get major chills and goosebumps!!! Guaranteed!

If you loved her voice in this, you have got to check out her rendition of Seven Nation Army with PMJ

PMJ covers modern songs in the old lounge music style. They do all types of music this way.

the cool part of this was that haley did this on the first take

She has an incredible voice and amazing control. Check out Seven Nation Army and Don't Know How to Love You. She is amazing!

Ella didn't just Skat, she was the queen of skat

That is Haley Reinhart who is an absolutely phenomenal singer! I first heard her on American Idol. She placed third but is arguably one of the best voices ever featured on that show. She's outrageously talented and I totally love her voice. She's not had too much commercial success since the show but I think part of that is just not finding the right material that connects with people.....yet. Commercial success or not, the girl can blow! She has pipes for days. Reminds me a tiny bit of a young Mariah Carey.

Your reaction to Haley is priceless. In a world full of so many over produced voices and is so refreshing to know that that is her voice. Have seen her live twice. She is the real deal. Simply ridiculous in the best possible way. Respect.

Great reaction...she has a very uniquely beautiful voice. Her version of 'Seven Nation Army" and "Oops, I Did It Again" are wonderful as well. She also does a PMJ group video of "All About That Bass" that is amazing!

Wow this girl can sing the dictionary and I would listen. Thanks for the reaction

Yes! She is one of a kind. I too wish I had this kind of soulful gorgeous voice. You should do her with them doing Seven Nation Army!! It will blow you away too!

Yup! A whole lot of us had that exact same "holy shite!" reaction to Haley. Wow. Great reaction, keep 'em coming.

This has been on my play list for a minute - she scatted her way to my heart too lol

if I remember correctly, this was done in a single take, and she was sick on top of that.

Here's a suggestion joe bonamassa and beth hart , I'd rather go blind. Beth has an incredible voice. Your welcome

All about that bass- Post modern juke box.

Post Modern Jukebox is a fun group to listen to. They have multiple singers and take mainstream songs and sing them in a different style. Even Wayne Brady joins the band for a song. Enjoy.

By the way, I discovered a lot of artists who worked and collaborated with PMJ: Morgan James, Robyn Adele Andeson, Miche Braden, Ariana Savalas, Hanah Gill and so many more artist!

She does an amazing "Black Hole Sun"

Loved your reaction! The cover style is late 1930s jazz lounge "torch singing". A torch song is one of unrequited love, failed relationships, being used and abused, feelings of little worth, hurting so bad you want to die. Normally a slow crooning ballad, the jazz aspect allows the singer to show power, range and innovation if they have talent. Thus, the genre choice for the infamous "I'm Shit, I Know, But Can't Stop Wanting You" song, "Creep." NOTE: PMJ had stopped into a small Swedish recording studio on the spur of the moment in Stockholm after eight straight days of live performances all throughout Scandinavia. Haley was totally exhausted by then and not feeling well at all, but agreed to try just two songs. This one was the ONLY taping of Creep and it was famously done from beginning to end in this take with no rehearsal. The band supported her totally by watching her body language from the back and listening to her volume for the crescendos and runs (where you hear them go silent or hold back). The piano and drums were perfect. This video is now legendary for both the performance and the back story. She recorded one other really great "listen to" as the lead in a female trio cover of "It's All About That Bass" that will knock your socks off with the sultry tones and subtle choreography. BTW, the bass solo/duet in that video is both funny and entertaining as two men play the same upright bass fiddle in the middle that they had only come up with THAT morning, and only tried the one time before the performance video was made. It also has several million views. Don't miss it!

Hayley Reinhart got her start on American Idol of all places. I loved her then and I love her now.

This reaction is well over a year ago and this is the first I've come across you, Too Sushi. Loved your reaction of Haley!! She did a cover of No Doubt's "Don't Speak" (with PMJ) which is just as amazing!!! I love her voice and wanted her to win the first time I heard her on American Idol (she came in 3rd). She is a diamond waiting to shine and be given the acknowledgement she so richly deserves!!!! Another singer, just as incredible, is a young lady from the Philippines...Morissette Amon. She's called Asia's Phoenix; the Mariah Carey of the Philippines, and her vocals are OUT OF THIS WORLD!!! Please, if you're still reacting, give Don't Speak a listen and I'd suggest starting out with Morissette's song, AKin Ka Na Lang (her reportoire of covers goes on and on and she has even recently released songs she and her fiance wrote. Morissette does all genres of music...Pop, Rock, R & B, Christian music, Broadway songs (which are incredible). Haley is fantastic and I love her voice soooooo much....it's just that I believe, like millions of others, Morissette is the best singer on this planet today!!!! Morissette is just getting noticed internationally and she's been in the "biz" for 10 years. She's 25 y/0 AND she's never had any professional training. She sings, smiles while singing, tells us a story and becomes the lyrics and pulls you in. (btw, most all of Morissette's covers are in English). Akin Ka Na Lang is in her native language and you WILL love it. Please make sure you don't stop ANY video of hers until the video stops. She sometimes takes pauses before the last couple of lyrics.

SO glad you finally got to this. The one reaction I want ALL reactors to react to! LoL Best version of this song you'll ever hear. I'm hoping you do all of her PMJ covers. They're ALL Phenomenal!! Seven Nation Army, Black Hole Sun and Mad World with Puddles Pitty Party... Those three are my TOP. I'm so excited for the possibility of seeing you react to these!!! ::SQUEEEEEE:: You'll be just as impressed!

"I just know what to say, I'm going to just end this " that's the reaction of all of us. She is sublime.

I would suggest some of my favorite covers by Postmodern Jukebox: Seven Nation Army (Haley Reinhart), Royals (Puddles Pity Party), Mad World (Haley and Puddles), Stacy's Mom (Casey Abrams), and Die Young (Robyn Adele Anderson).

PMJ - Black Hole Sun or 7 Nation Army ... And FYI Haley is a monster on mic. She slayed those as well.

Haley Reinhart - Beauty, Brilliance and Talent. I've been addicted for years. You need more Haley in your life.

Kathy here - Haley was first noticed when she was on American Idol. She didn't win but should have. I just don't think they thought she was "wholesome" enough! but her performances on the show were amazing. If you really like her, I would check some of those out. Loved your reaction when she scatted that last little bit of one line. You fell back into your chair and just about lost it! Each time she revealed another layer to her voice, the expressions on your face told it all. Love it. Thanks for the reaction. Found your channel today!

Sushi, I loved your reaction to one of my favorite singers, Haleys all that ! Some of her best songs are; 1) Don't Know How to Love You, 2) Seven Nation Army, 3) Shook, 4) Deep Water, 5) Habits, 6) Baby Its You & many others! Peace & Love🤗❤😎🥀

I love PMJ. When you do these, you should find and listen to the original first -- it's even more impressive when you experience just how the arrangement was made to fit into the different, retro-classic musical styles. "Dream On," featuring Morgan James (originally performed by Aerosmith) is probably my favorite PMJ cover. Another really fun one is the Cars' "Just What I Needed," with Sara Niemietz.

When your cover is so good that people want to do a cover of your cover

Fun fact: Haley did this entire song in one take. She's on some other level than most singers

I've seen your reaction so many times! "did she just scat her way to my heart?" always gets me 😍

Great performer! Love to follow her music... not a “winner” on a talent show but sure has my vote! I find her recordings whenever I can!

As a Radiohead fan, I'm not a fan of people doing covers of their songs, especially this song, but she absolutely CRUSHED THIS! Phenomenal!

I doubt that any singer would want you to pull down your earnest, amazed and soul-bearing testament to this woman's dazzling vocal range. She's an actress with a diva's 10,000-megawatt range.

I am so in love with Haley's voice. I have watched her so many times.

Post modern is one of my favorites . Watch their version of "It all about the bass" . You will love it .

The more you check into Hailey Reinhart the more you'll love her..

love seeing peoples first reactions to Haley the powerhouse Reinhart. shes crazy crazy talented and has such a distinctive voice, how shes fits those pipes in sucha itty bitty body is a mystery

I've always loved Haley Reinhardt's voice. Can't understand why we don't hear more of it. She's so talented.

Check out PMJ with Morgan James "Dream On" Aerosmith cover. That woman can belt out a note!

Please react more of Haley Reinhart and PMJ! Blackhole sun, Oops I did it again, Seven nation army pleaseeeee!

Haley R is a very special cross genre talent, she blows me away everytime.

She scat her way into all our hearts.

Probably one of the most amazing female voices EVER! And complete command of the song she sings. Amazing.

That was awesome but have you heard creep by radiohead?

Just a little note this woman was voted off American Idol a few years ago, it shows people don't know talent when they see it.

Your reaction to the music did just bring a tear to my eyes, and brought joy to my heart! It is a damn good day. :-)

Hailey didn't really cut loose on that one. You need to watch more PMJ, you won't be sorry. They're all set in different era styles, 1950-40s, Motown, etc. They do a remake of Silent Whisper that's my favorite. Hailey does one of Seven Nations Army that you would love. However, that's just my opinion. Yours Aye

She took a very dark and brooding song by Radiohead and made it better than it ever was in their original recording. She is an absolutely underrated artist. Her original recording of this with PMJ has more than 78 million views now.

By far one of the best reactions to this song. Pure, true emotion.

Scott Bradlee is the founder of PMJ. He also does the piano and arranged the numbers. The rest of the group rotates through. Loved your reaction. Hayley has an incredible voice.

What a sexy, sultry, version of this song considering it’s title...great'''

Shes incredible, beautiful, sexy, feminine, magical She puts a spell on men...When watching her videos you cant take your eyes off her. World Class.

Her father is a famous guitarist and she grew up singing on stage with her mom and dad. Watch the studio live performance with just her and her dad. I believe it’s the chess studios in Chicago!

Omg it's so amazing to watch all those emotions wash across your face 🥹 this must be one of my favorite reaction videos ever! 🤗

This song got me pregnant. And I'm a dude.

Hi from TEXAS Beautiful, you should listen to the original artist of CREEP.🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹

Did she just scat her way to my heart? Dead. 100%

I've loved this for 5 yrs and am still amazed at the perfection! It's good to see Sushi's also impressed and at a loss for words..

Would you please react to "Fall to Pieces" by Velvet Revolver.

React to Carrie Underwood - Before he cheats

The emotions she expressed thru her voice is hauntingly beautiful. Kinda makes me feel like it would be playing in a serial killer type movie if that makes sense.

You just got Haleyd! This isn’t just a cover, it’s a masterpiece! The musicians are fantastic and she’s the hole package. There are more very, very good songs to check out, both her with PMJ, just her and more...

The original radio head version is great to I think you would like creed with arms wide open video look for the one that has his arms spread out

When it comes to PMJ, Morgan James is the queen! Listen to her rendition of Dream On.

Greatest line ever "did she just skat her way, to my heart?"

You're reaction is so priceless. To be able to watch someone experience this masterpiece is so awesome!!!!

Well this is a female cover of a man’s song....

This just popped into my suggestion videos. Your reaction is the best and so fun to watch.

The range of emotions in her voice makes me tear up

Your reaction is priceless. The song is one of the most authentic conveyance of the feelings one has in the presence of greatness. Like if I was in front of you or Haley but I would take that chance, you are both so beautiful. Would love to hear you sing, too sushi. And scat as well.

Said it before and i'll say again... hands down you are my favorite reaction person to watch because you get so emotionally invested in the songs... absolutely awesome

OMG...I am sooooo happy you love this video. Haley is an amazing underrated performer, ever since Idol!!!!! Also, absolutely DIED during your reaction to her scat!!!

did she just skat her way into my heart ! watching these songs detonate in your heart is “very special”. your channel is special...

Talk about a special performance. Every word oozes sensuality.

Love your channel.. it gives me a break from doing work and watching other reaction videos. Great song.. good stuff!

I've love Hailey since she was my favorite on season 10 of American Idol and came in 3rd(she was robbed)! Lol. Voice like silk and so distinctive. Definitely underrated. Amazing talent, raw and sexy but controlled. Glad you enjoyed, and hilarious that she left you speechless. Take care Sushi!

LOL....I knew this would blow you away. PERFECT REACTION!!! Thanks !

The look on your face says it all. This version pulled on my heartstrings also. It's very powerful.

I sat here and watched the emotions flow across your face. I watched the tears. You had the exact same reaction as I did the first time I heard her sing this. And the fact that she did this in ONE TAKE just blows my mind.

I could never listen to this too many times. LOVE how they covered it and Haley is amazing

Don't stop here, Sushi. Keep listening. She, as well as others on PMJ are fantastic.

The reactions are so priceless and you are so emotional.... That's good. 👍😍 pmj is so awesome.

i was drinking water when "Did she just scat her way to my heart?" i choked. now you got a subscriber.

Haley is a throwback to the old old days. She's been singing that way since her days at Wheeling high school in Chicago. Former american idol runner up, she was the top 3. You have to really be a fan of that type of music.

Did she just skat her way into my heart !!! You are amazing :)

What a voice! This has to be one of my all time favorite vocals..Just a stunning ride

Best reaction to this song I’ve ever seen!! Thank you!!!! And yes, Ella was the queen of scat!