Тёмный

Cultural Boycotts of Israel: Explosive Debate on Complexities & Global Impact!!! 

Marc Lamont Hill
Подписаться 143 тыс.
Просмотров 16 тыс.
50% 1

Join an engaging teach-in panel discussion on the appropriateness of cultural boycotts of Israel, featuring prominent voices. Stu Bykofsky, a seasoned journalist and columnist known for his incisive commentary, brings decades of experience to discussions on political and social issues. Chloe Valdery, a passionate advocate for peace and understanding, focuses on cultural and educational initiatives promoting dialogue and mutual respect. Susan Abulhawa, acclaimed author of "Mornings in Jenin" and a Palestinian American activist, contributes her profound commitment to social justice and insights into the Israel-Palestine conflict. Marc Lamont Hill, a renowned academic specializing in African American studies and global social justice issues, offers critical perspectives on the implications of cultural boycotts and their impact on international relations.
Originally broadcast on July 9, 2018, this panel dives deep into the complexities and implications of cultural boycotts, offering diverse perspectives on a highly debated issue.
Like, comment, share, SUBSCRIBE, and JOIN the MLH Membership Program for more engaging discussions: / @marclamonthillofficial
Stream NIGHT SCHOOL with Marc Lamont Hill live Monday-Friday at 9pm EST. Join live viewer Q&A in Marc Lamont Hill's OFFICE HOURS live on Sundays at 9pm EST.
Stay connected with Marc Lamont Hill:
👉🏾 Instagram: / marclamonthill
👉🏾 TikTok: / marclamonthill
👉🏾 X (Twitter): / marclamonthill
👉🏾 Facebook: / marclamont
#CulturalBoycott #IsraelBoycott #StuBykofsky #ChloeValdery #SusanAbulhawa #MarcLamontHill #TeachInPanel #MiddleEastDebate #PoliticalActivism #HumanRights #IsraelPalestineConflict #FreeSpeech #GlobalJustice #AcademicDebate #CurrentEvents #TrendingNow #MustWatchDiscussion #SocialJustice #BoycottDivestmentSanctions #ProtestMovements
#nightschool #officehours #mlh #marclamonthill

Опубликовано:

 

21 июн 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 340   
@dredgalann
@dredgalann 6 дней назад
“An occupied people have a right to resist!”
@CraigTheBrute-yf7no
@CraigTheBrute-yf7no 6 дней назад
Through armed force
@cgm2086
@cgm2086 5 дней назад
@@CraigTheBrute-yf7no exactly. by any means necessary. #natturner #mandela - the jews themselves resisted all over europe
@willneverstop
@willneverstop 5 дней назад
@@CraigTheBrute-yf7no yea and the occupier will resist the resistance by all means...so the occupied should be smart about it.
@CraigTheBrute-yf7no
@CraigTheBrute-yf7no 5 дней назад
@@willneverstop The Taliban were smart & so were the viet cong
@vintagepipesnightmares
@vintagepipesnightmares 5 дней назад
Absolutely 👍
@MathFunandGames
@MathFunandGames 6 дней назад
There is no excuse for starving 2.3 million people
@markymarkymarkymarky
@markymarkymarkymarky 5 дней назад
Blah, blah, blah. No starving Gazans. Period.
@markymarkymarkymarky
@markymarkymarkymarky 5 дней назад
Tell ya what- with 2.3 million people- you should be able to produce pictures of starving Gazans- but you can’t. Why is that? Because there are none. We have been hearing about starving Gazans for 7 months. Newsflash- people won’t last 7 months without food. Gaza is the only place that has an obesity problem that the usual suspects are pushing it as a famine.
@Ahsan2Clutch
@Ahsan2Clutch 5 дней назад
@@markymarkymarkymarky No hostages held in Gaza. Period.
@markymarkymarkymarky
@markymarkymarkymarky 5 дней назад
@@Ahsan2Clutch There are no starving Gazans. That is a fact. This laughable nonsense has been pushed for 7 months. Isn’t it amazing you guys can’t produce a single pic of a starving Gazan?
@jhegre
@jhegre 5 дней назад
@@markymarkymarkymarky I am pretty sure you yourself know exactly how inane your counterarguement is. Period. I case you are not; ask ALL of the worlds aid organizations.
@jdsull
@jdsull 6 дней назад
The "Jew" card is also morally and politically exhausted. BDS is antizionist not anti Jew.
@MathFunandGames
@MathFunandGames 6 дней назад
Free Palestine!!!
@mrsroseyp109
@mrsroseyp109 6 дней назад
Who is this young lady representing Israel under the guise that she's taking it upon herself to lift every voice...I would take her seriously after Israel stops committing genocide
@susancoolidge7810
@susancoolidge7810 5 дней назад
Israel's not committing genocide let's not forget what happened on October 7th if you can't stand the heat get out of the kitchen you should have never started anything
@chrisulmer694
@chrisulmer694 5 дней назад
I’d bet anything that AIPAC is paying her. Those are all despicable people and I think they know that their “argument” is untenable.
@jhegre
@jhegre 5 дней назад
She is not the sharpest knife on this drawer that is for sure. Her arguement is basically that since Israelis don't "feel guilty" they should not be held accountable, since Israelis do not agree with BDS that means BDS can not work. She might as well have the letters T O O L tattooed on her forehead.
@Bchic02
@Bchic02 5 дней назад
Chloe is definitely that “one Black friend “
@moniqueglinton7623
@moniqueglinton7623 5 дней назад
She was out of her league
@Peacejusticenow
@Peacejusticenow 6 дней назад
Red shirt guy doesn't know the difference between Ashkenazi, Mizrahi and Sephardic, etc. 🙄
@diallo1347
@diallo1347 6 дней назад
In response to Chloe, in 2014, 17 IDF soldiers were killed. In the next two months, over 1,700 Palestinian civilians were killed in response. 900 of those Palestinians were children.
@hitch4526
@hitch4526 6 дней назад
They keep counting IDF soldiers just because they weren't in uniform, just because they were in their "Civies" (military, for civilian clothes). Others seem to also expect Palestinians to fight like "Gentlemen", like Red Coats, like blue coats, in nice pretty rectangles so that Israelis can tell the difference between babies and soldiers and then the world can pretend that it's all an equal fight... Even while recognizing that we didn't beat the British while standing in ranks expecting bullets and cannon balls.
@sahraluujiyano6
@sahraluujiyano6 6 дней назад
Free Palestine 🇵🇸
@rainfall1drop
@rainfall1drop 5 дней назад
Susan Abulhawa is great. I'm going to follow her on other social media. As far as the history there were Jews outside of Palestine long before the Roman conquest. Jews from Poland are the descendants of communities that are no more Palestinian than Korean Catholics are Italian, or Japanese Buddhists are Indian.
@OH-uo3nq
@OH-uo3nq 6 дней назад
Free Gaza
@sarahadam8334
@sarahadam8334 5 дней назад
FREE PALASTINE
@eye.bull666
@eye.bull666 6 дней назад
The world is united. We support BDS. Free Palestine 🇵🇸
@ileanahernandez1709
@ileanahernandez1709 5 дней назад
I can't keep the memory of an interview I saw of a group of doctors who escaped the bombings of an intensive care wing were they had four newborns babies in incubators and the Israeli soldiers took them out of the incubators and promised they wouldn't hurt them. The next day when the doctors were fleeing the bombs they found the four newborns thrown by the side of the rubble of a street. Of course they were all dead.😢 I'm really trying very hard to have any compassion in my heart for these so called soldiers but I don't know how. Imagine how much forgiveness a Palestinian would have 😢.
@Peacejusticenow
@Peacejusticenow 6 дней назад
Golda Meir => Golda Mabovitch
@bobbyd5167
@bobbyd5167 6 дней назад
Who invited Chloe? Please don’t do that again! She is yet to understand the necessity to provide proof for what facts she proclaims. Embarrassing!
@unreliablenarrator6649
@unreliablenarrator6649 6 дней назад
I suggest she visit Gaza, West Bank and then Israel, look at the reality on the ground and talk to the people who live there. This could be a bit devastating for her but might temper her enthusiasm for Zionism.
@user-ez1eh3ph1j
@user-ez1eh3ph1j 5 дней назад
actually she is right and you are wrong
@David-fq5un
@David-fq5un 5 дней назад
@@user-ez1eh3ph1j wow...are you in third grade?
@bobbyd5167
@bobbyd5167 5 дней назад
@@user-ez1eh3ph1j About?
@deend7824
@deend7824 5 дней назад
Months ago I decided not to listen to zionists bc I've heard how they just lie without any facts - they are morally bankrupted and have failed as humans. So I've Boycotted their talking points too. What's the point of listening to ppl that justify military occupation and ethnic cleansing PPL.
@miltonthegreat6520
@miltonthegreat6520 6 дней назад
'Never Again' applies to all of us. One World.
@davidnguyen7891
@davidnguyen7891 4 дня назад
Even if you have ancestral ties to a land, that doesn’t give you the right to ethnically cleanse and subjugate the population that is currently living there. There are many black people in America and Europe and Canada who have ancestral ties to Africa, but do they have the right to go to Africa and ethnically cleanse the currently population and take their land and establish it as their own state? No. They have the right to move back to Africa and live there, but they don’t have the right to subjugate the existing population and take their land.
@unreliablenarrator6649
@unreliablenarrator6649 6 дней назад
I hate to be harsh, but Chloe Valdery is unhinged. No one will question her passion, but her argument do not stand to reason or facts. If her goal ie peace and understanding, I suggest she visit Gaza to understand the situation of Palestinians and listen to what they have to say, and then do the same in Israel. I'm afraid the experience would crush her from both directions and temper her passion for Zionism. I'm for truth and reconciliation, but truth has to come first, so let's not put the cart before the horse. Let me close with this: I may think I'm a school bus and that Chloe flying saucer but that does make either true.
@user-ez1eh3ph1j
@user-ez1eh3ph1j 5 дней назад
Chloe was great, but she did say things that don't match your opinions
@jhegre
@jhegre 5 дней назад
@@user-ez1eh3ph1j Naw, she was basically saying that BDS is wrong because Israelis don't agree with it. No matter what your opinion is that is just a meaningless arguement.
@roystonmason9125
@roystonmason9125 4 дня назад
@@jhegre B D S babay
@tonybanks1035
@tonybanks1035 4 дня назад
she's the only one making sense actually
@treid1369
@treid1369 6 дней назад
23:40 I now know why there is chaos in this world and always will be. She stated she was going to take 8 min before she started. She was cleared for that. After 5 min he couldn’t even contain himself because the demons in him were itching when she was simply restating the history as a basis for everyone in the room just because he can’t stand to hear the truth. 😮‍💨 28:30 Are we allowed to bring up Jesus now?! 😂 36:04 This lady is very interesting. I would like to hear her take on the treatment of Ethiopian Jews, specifically with curbing the birth rates of Ethiopian women in Israel against their will. How much is she getting paid?! 😏
@syedsaqibaftab19
@syedsaqibaftab19 6 дней назад
Keep up the good work Marc
@sahraluujiyano6
@sahraluujiyano6 6 дней назад
Thank you Marc it's always educational to listen to you
@TratUsYT
@TratUsYT 4 дня назад
Marc is incredibly smart. Everytime i listen to him I learn something new. Brilliant mind and amazing debater.
@theageofgoddess
@theageofgoddess 6 дней назад
Free 🇵🇸
@jdsull
@jdsull 6 дней назад
No. There is no room for nations founded solely on faith traditions. Israel should have been boycotted with South Africa and Rhodesia and shared their fates, but we decided to hate Islam after the destruction of communism.
@alaaalzubaidi2401
@alaaalzubaidi2401 6 дней назад
Free palestine🎉
@sarahadam8334
@sarahadam8334 5 дней назад
THE LADY WHO SAYS SHE REPRESENT ISREAL AND SAYS SHE IS OBJECTING TO DIVESTMET, AND WANTS TO BRING THE 2 COMUNITIES TOGETHER WITH LOVE !!!!! OK, TAKE OFF ALL THE RULES THAT MAKES THE PALSTENIANS LIFE WORST THAN WHAT BLACK AFRICAN LIFES WERE UNDER APARTIHID
@tyroneglover2290
@tyroneglover2290 6 дней назад
Malcom X asks the question " how can you have a moral solution with immoral people who cling to an immoral position"?
@thembakhumalo-li7bl
@thembakhumalo-li7bl 5 дней назад
It's painful to listen to a person like Chloe.....she's so ignorant
@wandachatman1658
@wandachatman1658 6 дней назад
🤯🙏🏽🙏🏽✌🏽Thank You Professor Hill.🤯😱🙏🏽✌🏽
@JemLeavitt
@JemLeavitt 6 дней назад
Thanks for sharing.
@tyroneglover2290
@tyroneglover2290 6 дней назад
Israel is an Illegal occupation force under international law. What rights do they have as such, furthermore do the Palestine people have the right to self defence also?
@adrianprather6022
@adrianprather6022 6 дней назад
This is what happens young sister, when 🫵🏾 don’t know your history.
@sarahadam8334
@sarahadam8334 5 дней назад
OMG, MARK LAMONT, LOVE YOU FOR EVER AND EVER AND EVER YOU BEAUTIFUL HUMAN BEING
@reddy11-11
@reddy11-11 5 дней назад
big ups to Phillly., that was a great discussion. I learned a lot. It was good to hear some new perspectives and history i had not heard before regarding the Zionist perspective on the conflict, however, I'm not down for no genocide and apartheid business. Free Palestine!!
@user-jv8kr4im1t
@user-jv8kr4im1t 5 дней назад
Free it!!! ✊🏾🇵🇸 Y'all know Philly always gon show up.
@angellrainell
@angellrainell 6 дней назад
She just said “it’s like two Native tribes fighting against each other” aaaand I’m about to ready to tap out. My nerves are bad
@user-jv8kr4im1t
@user-jv8kr4im1t 5 дней назад
She said that like it was gon make sense smh. 😅
@Bchic02
@Bchic02 5 дней назад
Chloe, girl, this is embarrassing
@markymarkymarkymarky
@markymarkymarkymarky 5 дней назад
She is the only one that is making sense.
@roystonmason9125
@roystonmason9125 4 дня назад
@@markymarkymarkymarky shesux
@afzanezamjaafar3104
@afzanezamjaafar3104 6 дней назад
The sound system is poor
@tangelaharden5336
@tangelaharden5336 5 дней назад
I wish I was in attendance. This was an excellent panel because ALL sides were represented! #Free Palestine 🇵🇸 NOW
@the.masked.one.studio4899
@the.masked.one.studio4899 6 дней назад
Ngl it was painful hearing the Zionist talking points 🇵🇸
@icecoldyellowredbull
@icecoldyellowredbull 5 дней назад
Thank you Marc
@Officiallyamber-rose
@Officiallyamber-rose 5 дней назад
Chloe‘s eyes darting back-and-forth as she searches for the bad Hasbara talking points to explain away the truth that is being dropped on her. I hope she’s really listening.
@Mamali316
@Mamali316 5 дней назад
A sick cookie perhaps paid by AIPAC
@MinkytheMinkY
@MinkytheMinkY 5 дней назад
32:00 land ownership definitely ignores historicity. Marc is spot on.
@markymarkymarkymarky
@markymarkymarkymarky 5 дней назад
The Jews belong in Israel and history confirms this. Archeology confirms this.
@ahamedalthaf5824
@ahamedalthaf5824 5 дней назад
We are now Boycotting.Euro Dollar and the damn Pound.for Free Palestine.this is what happens when half the Congress have dual citizenship.
@markymarkymarkymarky
@markymarkymarkymarky 5 дней назад
Of course Hamza, whatever you say. We should follow the example of Islam, right? Islam, who hasn’t created or given a thing to mankind in the last 1000 years, is who we should follow. Sorry I’ll pass.
@adamadaamo2514
@adamadaamo2514 5 дней назад
1.coffee 2.surgery 3.algebra (thanks to algebra you had the opportunity to write such an ignorant comment) 4.flying 5.medicine 6.astronomy 7.optics 8.university And many more... Look it up.
@markymarkymarkymarky
@markymarkymarkymarky 5 дней назад
@@adamadaamo2514 I said the last 1000 years- but let’s go thru your list. Coffee? Nope- the Mayans in the Americas have that one. Surgery? Nope. Algebra- OK- you got that one. Flying? Nope (paper airplanes don’t count). Medicine? Nope- the Greeks predate you as do the Egyptians. Astronomy? Yup, you have that one. I don’t know about optics and the advanced school predates Islam. And you have confirmed that nothing in the last 1000 years is accurate.
@roystonmason9125
@roystonmason9125 4 дня назад
@@markymarkymarkymarky what have you given us ww s ?
@dfgt-su9ki
@dfgt-su9ki 6 дней назад
bravo!!!!!🍉🍉🍉🍉🍉🍉🍉🍉🍉🍉🍉🍉🍉🍉🍉🍉🍉
@12nuk
@12nuk 4 дня назад
On Chloe’s argument Jews been in Europe for over 2000 years. So when it benefits them can they say they are indigenous to certain countries in Europe and “create” a Jewish state within Europe?
@southpaw786
@southpaw786 6 дней назад
❤️🖤🤍💚✌️🇵🇸
@DG-or5ui
@DG-or5ui 5 дней назад
Intel halts 25 Billion dollar investmnet in Israel. BDS is working.
@roystonmason9125
@roystonmason9125 4 дня назад
can u dig it ?
@adrianprather6022
@adrianprather6022 6 дней назад
WRONG ISRAEL ❤️🖤💚💛
@vanessamason5314
@vanessamason5314 5 дней назад
And who was the , how much time does everyone have man😅thank you mr.lamont
@Clay-doh-fw9rf
@Clay-doh-fw9rf 4 дня назад
This was a great conversation, I’m also loving the side commentary from the woman in the crowd. 16:34
@Cece-hk8nf
@Cece-hk8nf 3 дня назад
Shoutout to the black woman's commentary next to the video recorder. I love her comments and ad lib lol
@evlstoryteller3567
@evlstoryteller3567 4 дня назад
In response to Chloe's point about whether BDS works or not: I guess we're going to ignore what happened in South Africa? And how that apartheid ended?
@ladama3201
@ladama3201 6 дней назад
Zio version of Candace Owen
@bobbyd5167
@bobbyd5167 6 дней назад
That’s a HUGE compliment to this girl. As bad as Candace has shown to be, this girl brings zero contribution to such an in depth topic which she clearly hasn’t studied hard enough!
@GrayzoneGab
@GrayzoneGab 6 дней назад
When mama says we got Candace Owens at home . Haha
@ladama3201
@ladama3201 6 дней назад
Very disrespectful of her, leave our Blk Natl Anthem outta this.
@danniet4733
@danniet4733 5 дней назад
The Caucasity is strong in this one
@maryjane2965
@maryjane2965 4 дня назад
The lady on the left next to Marc„defending“ the settler colonialists truly has no clue about anything 😂I don’t even understand half of the points she is trying to make! But she sure as hell pissed me off with the nonsense she is talking about! Free Palestine and support BDS🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸
@hitch4526
@hitch4526 5 дней назад
The housewife's defense: All of that work, a housewife does, doesn't come from nowhere out of nothing. The husband, after however many years, doesnt just get to kick her to the curb, as she likely put far more work than he ever did to maintain cleanliness and working order. Palestinians made that land a very valuable land with thousamds of years of understanding that it was their land. If that land actually belongs to someone else who'd been living in europe for many generations; That's thousands of years of work that needs to be paid for, to also take care of the wealth accumulation aspect that's being taken from them, as though they didn't do anything.
@Lisey1
@Lisey1 5 дней назад
The jews could have come and live in Palestine with the Palestinians. They could have shared the land.
@nearby222
@nearby222 5 дней назад
"I have a problem because it targets the issue" is the first guys argument? Am I hearing that right? First 4 minutes in and I have to hear ignorance that heavy? Imagine being mad at non-violent targeted action LMAO, the privilege of never experiencing the alternative is insane. Their is no way he his watching what's happening. Like the bombs are targeting one group of people, the famine is targeting one group of people, is he ok with that?
@MinkytheMinkY
@MinkytheMinkY 5 дней назад
1:26:50 listen to this threat, it's as if Israel's way or no way at all. Sickening, this is why the meter has not moved. Israel will not give an inch, though technically not theirs to give they appropriate, but requires a mile to start any conversation. Disgusting.
@Pou1gie1
@Pou1gie1 4 дня назад
@15:30 So, Chloe wants to acknowledge one groups pain over another's and then talk about needing more love. Also, saying that they have done bad things to each other is the understatement of the century, and fails to acknowledge that one group is taking more hits with less support than the other group.
@nooshinrazani3730
@nooshinrazani3730 День назад
The missing piece is the fact that Palestine was a diverse, multicultural community. That is the difference. Whether a single ethnic state should exist any where on the planet, but especially in a region so important to so many different people.
@natom1385
@natom1385 5 дней назад
Why is Lamont on a panel with 'Chloe' . She is clearly not very informed
@markymarkymarkymarky
@markymarkymarkymarky 5 дней назад
Dear audience- a black man can have a white grandchild. Skin tone can change in 2 generations. Multiply it now by 50. Do you get it now?
@Yo-yo98
@Yo-yo98 4 дня назад
How much 🤑🤑🤑🤑is Chloe getting ???😂😂😂😂
@12nuk
@12nuk 4 дня назад
She wants to bring up the Ethiopian Jews without knowing how the Ethiopian Jews are being treated within Israel.
@SA-sf2cq
@SA-sf2cq 4 дня назад
BDS is working Chloe. Just look at the Starbucks stock today.
@komlat253
@komlat253 6 дней назад
this girl talkinng about love and being able to synpathize with people when it only seems she can sypathize with jews. our history in the west is so bias .jews are not the only people who have been marginalized by every one . every minority have this history .im tired of people saying that jews have trama from every group when like a white jew has no truama when being in ethiopia, they not even the same . . also yall need to get this stright , jews were hated most in europe and so they left . now the jewish community has the full support of the heads of all important nations which is more than basically every other marginalized group in the world . .not to compare , its good the jews have a land and rights but not at the expense of another group. thats not how that works . only racist people hate jews. most people just want gaza to have what isreal has . what makes me mad when people make it about blood liable . like chill . criticism isnt racism. i support isreal but not the occupation . i dont meen isreal cant exist , they just cant push people out
@SuperKripke
@SuperKripke 4 дня назад
22:32 Wonder if this guy ever found out how much time everyone else had.
@adrianprather6022
@adrianprather6022 6 дней назад
🔥🔥🔥🔥
@chrisperez3614
@chrisperez3614 5 дней назад
The people of Tibet aren’t asking us to boycott China. There are some fringe extremists, but the vast majority see themselves as both Tibetan and Chinese. China isn’t an ethnostate. It’s a multi ethnic nation that has enshrined affirmative action policies into its constitution.
@oliviahammash9131
@oliviahammash9131 6 дней назад
Free Palestine 🇵🇸. We are all individually responsible for what we do. Just because someone was abused doesn’t give them divine right to abuse others. To flee one ppl who abused them, to then abuse those that welcomed you, and then be friends with ppl who hurt you??? And those that welcomed you and gave you shelter are now the villains because it makes it easier for you to visit your trauma onto them. Just mind boggling.
@BlackNewsMonday
@BlackNewsMonday 5 дней назад
👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾
@EyeGotSoul
@EyeGotSoul 4 дня назад
I wonder how much they paid that sista 🤔
@saudiacooper8609
@saudiacooper8609 5 дней назад
Chloe is very passionate but NOT factual.. facts are NOT on her agenda but feelings.. to get this straight she is saying people of Hebrew faith were tied to Palestinian land for thousands of years but lived in Europe and decided to come back to that land and kick people out who were there living their best lives…Really 🤔
@markymarkymarkymarky
@markymarkymarkymarky 5 дней назад
She is correct. Tell me, how many times is Jerusalem mentioned in the Jewish Bible? It’s Jewish land, period.
@MinkytheMinkY
@MinkytheMinkY 5 дней назад
​@@markymarkymarkymarkythe Bible is the most unreliable document to exist. It's constantly revised, there's so many versions and marred by the times in which it was revised.
@Romeloblade
@Romeloblade 5 дней назад
​@markymarkymarkymarky The Bible is a fantasy tale why would we use that as a source of any truth.
@user-jv8kr4im1t
@user-jv8kr4im1t 5 дней назад
You don't have a claim to the lands your people lived on in biblical times. We would be giving the land back to indigenous people worldwide if that was the case. Why doesn't the logic extend to every other people who have been dispossessed of land?
@saudiacooper8609
@saudiacooper8609 5 дней назад
@@markymarkymarkymarky What if I don’t believe in your bible or faith ✌🏽
@reseewatts6770
@reseewatts6770 6 дней назад
To the person that thinks we're reliving the past. I say: name another people besides black was imported to the Europe. Shiped like cargo and forced labor and used to pick cotton and other merchandise that made the countries richer. PLEASE!
@Avrasong
@Avrasong 6 дней назад
Indians were taken to the Caribbean.
@AnthonyMorgan-mu5je
@AnthonyMorgan-mu5je 5 дней назад
Mr. Hill has an uncanny, and disingenuous gift for the art of ambush.
@Loner45ify
@Loner45ify 2 дня назад
28:04 as an atheist I love when people try to bring up Jesus to justify things. The mere fact that people genuinely believe that there was only one person running around back then with that name is mind blowing.
@mogostedla2669
@mogostedla2669 5 дней назад
Professor! Thanks for always being on the right side of history. But I gotta ask fam, why do you upload these quality of videos to your channel? I’d love to see you get a set up like Candace Owens’s Piers Morgan etc. you deserve it brother! Watching this in 480p is crazy 😂
@marclamonthillofficial
@marclamonthillofficial 5 дней назад
This was a community event shot at a church 6 years ago. I’m posting it bc It’s interesting, but it wasn’t produced as web content.
@shakeelahanif5398
@shakeelahanif5398 16 часов назад
@@marclamonthillofficial damn I had no idea this was from 6 years ago. It breaks my heart that everything said is still so unfortunately relevant today.
@tonybanks1035
@tonybanks1035 4 дня назад
BDS was called a bunch of lunatics by Norman Finkelstein
@lamarholmes4573
@lamarholmes4573 4 дня назад
I wish they would have a discussion on what is and isn't "indigenous" because the pro-Israel debate side is treating it to mean some of your ancestors solely being from a place at some point with no limit on the distance of time away from said place. Under this kind of logic everyone would considered indigenous to Africa. I treat indigeneity as a social state of having an established multi-generational culture in a place where you currently reside and is then invaded/conquered by a foreign group of people. Meaning you have to be invaded/conquered and have a previously established culture to be considered indigenous. Im a multi-generational Black/African American and my ancestors come from West African lands such as Nigeria, but that doesn't mean I'm in indigenous to West Africa, I have ancestry from there. If some random country invades the USA tomorrow I will be consider indigenous to America because my culture/ethnicity has been established as Black/African American. When Germany invaded and conquered Poland in WW2 Jewish people residing there would be considered indigenous to Poland at the time.
@MinkytheMinkY
@MinkytheMinkY 5 дней назад
40:10 the moderator is commendable for trying to keep focus on the topic, it's a tough crowd, a disruptive one, at that. I don't know if anyone could've done better.
@NumTecho
@NumTecho 6 дней назад
I may not agree with some of the panel, but I find it rude to interrupt them
@MinkytheMinkY
@MinkytheMinkY 5 дней назад
49:27 the problem is the way in which the entity was born, and has insisted on subjugation of Palestinians. The problem is in which zionism insists it exists, the expelling and extermination of the indigenous who've been there the whole time. Israel's governance is based on apartheid, genocide, and theft, in no way is it about equal rights, or coexisting, or reparations. So why would you eat at a place whose cooking is unethical to you? BDS is not about targeting Jewish businesses, but rather businesses that uphold the genocidal project?
@MathFunandGames
@MathFunandGames 6 дней назад
If you go far enough back, every person has ancestors who were oppressed sometime in the past. Where does reliving the past stop?
@hitch4526
@hitch4526 6 дней назад
All the way back to and through "Out of Africa", where only a select few have access to technology to trace lineages closer and closer to life's origins, with convenient incomplete truths and lies by omission.
@MathFunandGames
@MathFunandGames 5 дней назад
@@hitch4526 it all comes back to 2.3 million people being starved to death right now, on purpose. And a generation of children who will suffer from the trauma they are undergoing for the rest of their lives. This ends all arguments for me. It needs to stop and humanity needs to start these people in the road to recovery. Then , and only then, can we figure out what’s what.
@hitch4526
@hitch4526 5 дней назад
@@MathFunandGames I would go even further in stating that the existence of Israel requires genocide, ethnic cleansing to maintain the ethnostate. The apartheid and the famine seem to be just byproducts of trying to ethnically cleanse while everyone is watching in disgust. The famine, water, and electricity situations create the facade where people can more easily blame an invisible monster (i.e a God showing their blessing).
@hitch4526
@hitch4526 5 дней назад
@@MathFunandGames I would go even further in stating that the existence of Israel requires genocide, ethnic cleansing to maintain the ethnostate. The apartheid and the famine seem to be just byproducts of trying to ethnically cleanse while everyone is watching in disgust. The famine, water, and electricity situations create the facade where people can more easily blame an invisible monster (i.e a God showing their blessing).
@BellyLaugher
@BellyLaugher 4 дня назад
Self defense is the accurate paradigm. I understand Chloe is wanting both sides to find a commonality, and before that can happen, those who literally forced the indigenous people out of their houses & as they did so, moved their own belongings into them...& who to this day target bomb &/ bulldoze the indigenous peoples' homes, sometimes w/whole families inside➡that those traumatized zionists should know better than to do. The indigenous people who lived there before & while the zionists returned never harmed the new arrivals UNTIL they were harmed in such ways. They also had a system of shared land ownership, called Commons➡they did not fence/wall-off land➡they did not want to change the system of shared-communal land use. There is a youtube interview of a Professor who discovered thru looking at documents more of the story (he acknowledged up front he's not a historian; simply a curious academic who wanted to understand/ answer some questions he had). The paper he wrote abt it is listed under the yt video, but I will try to locate it & insert it in reply section under this comment, in case anyone would like to read it.
@emmanjacobsdad
@emmanjacobsdad 4 дня назад
That lady on the audience needed to be redirected or asked to leave. I may agree with every word she says, but it’s very disruptive. This entire debate was a bit chaotic d/t the audience being out of control. I enjoyed the panel, however the moderator needs to do a better job.
@Yo-yo98
@Yo-yo98 4 дня назад
Did y’all think Zionist were the first colonialist settlers? Many early colonizers …that spread all through the America’s were some of Jewish religion from Spaniards to Germans .
@Officiallyamber-rose
@Officiallyamber-rose 5 дней назад
The woman at 24 minutes using his repeat your message tactic on him❤
@reemhabboushe5465
@reemhabboushe5465 4 дня назад
Valdary sounds like a cult leader. Is she a theater major? It's hard to take this kind of histrionic victim - centering seriously. Valdary seems to expect that Palestinians' safety can be sacrificed for that of Zionists, a spiritually bereft hypothesis. She suggests that this intergenerational trauma can be dumped on Palestinians, as if Palestinians only exist as tools and vehicles to relieve and carry Jewish intergenerational trauma. The suggestion is so absent basic human morality that it's hard to listen to her. The panacea for trauma is therapy, not thieving others' land: this merely smears the trauma on others.
@theasim3757
@theasim3757 5 дней назад
That speaker at 54:00 lol bet she’s changed her mind about that billion dollar investment in Gaza
@eucapsiolatina
@eucapsiolatina 6 дней назад
Chloe Valderyis is very aggressive and promotes the propaganda talking points with no shreds of evidence whatsoever.
@andreskorge1828
@andreskorge1828 6 дней назад
the Breach at the Fence was allowed - could have been thwarted - too much blood, pain, hostages and destruction subsequently - proof abounds even this week - unsettling big time - more exposure desperately needed
@BehindTheCurtain_Truth
@BehindTheCurtain_Truth 5 дней назад
Dang, Marc… scandalous! :-)
@MinkytheMinkY
@MinkytheMinkY 5 дней назад
1:11:07 here is exactly why people boycott.
@markymarkymarkymarky
@markymarkymarkymarky 5 дней назад
BDS has been a total abysmal failure. All this woman has proven is that she is a professional victim
@MinkytheMinkY
@MinkytheMinkY 5 дней назад
​@@markymarkymarkymarkyfailure, how?
@markymarkymarkymarky
@markymarkymarkymarky 5 дней назад
@@MinkytheMinkY The professional victim act is old. Here are the facts- there was never, ever an independent country called Palestine. It was never owned by them. Never. They went to war and lost multiple times. If you are American then you can’t say a thing.
@MinkytheMinkY
@MinkytheMinkY 5 дней назад
53:35 solar field for whom? and over whose demolished homes will those will those panels be installed? And who will be installing them, whose economy will it benefit? And who will actually get to participate, is this what Palestinians want? Why does the Kenneset get do decide what happens in Palestine?
@markymarkymarkymarky
@markymarkymarkymarky 5 дней назад
Blah, blah, blah
@nooshinrazani3730
@nooshinrazani3730 День назад
Why do they give Chloe so much time. She is wrong and it is tiring.
@rockmusic175
@rockmusic175 4 дня назад
Typical European colonial attitude.
@herOhface
@herOhface 5 дней назад
Hey sound guy- you sort it out bro?
@MinkytheMinkY
@MinkytheMinkY 5 дней назад
33:47 what about the Ashkenazi? They converted to Judaism.
@markymarkymarkymarky
@markymarkymarkymarky 5 дней назад
Wrong. Learn about DNA.
@MinkytheMinkY
@MinkytheMinkY 5 дней назад
Right, are DNA tests legal for the zio residents?​@@markymarkymarkymarky
@jhegre
@jhegre 5 дней назад
I call BS on Stu Bykofsky! His arguement falls flat within 30 seconds!
@DG-or5ui
@DG-or5ui 5 дней назад
Red shirt guy is a liar
Далее
Самоприкорм с сестрой 😂
00:19
Просмотров 264 тыс.
Time to boycott Israel? | Head to Head
47:30
Просмотров 1,4 млн
Glenn Greenwald and Alan Dershowitz Debate Bombing Iran
1:51:13
BDS Movement Debate | Oxford Union
1:23:02
Просмотров 321 тыс.
Palestine Talks | John Mearsheimer discusses Gaza
30:14