I'm from Mumbai. I would rather the police not take bribes and just demolish all illegal street vendors. It is a nuisance. It blocks paths, and moreover takes business from legal retailers. This is a problem. Allow one illegal shop, it allows multiple shops. I'm personally tired of these thelas blocking the pedestrian traffic. My and everyone else's time is more important.
It is easier said than done. He is making 1.5 lacs a month due to the Service, Taste and Quality which he is providing for the Money he is charging. Not everyone can do that.
@@asaidweeman28 Consistency will automatically come when the same process, recipe is followed day in day out. That's why the taste of all 'famous' products remain same over years, decades. Expertise comes from such excessive practice! ☺️
@@amarkulkarni5992 opening roadside is illegal..occupying footh path is not legal..by giving few 100 bucks he is allowed to do business ..its better then taking a shop on rent..
@@amarkulkarni5992 how can it be legal ? He is blocking foot path. He is making conjecting roads with his customers. His shop is under tree, even birds poo will make a chutneys in his dosa which is unhygienic
@@shresthsrivastava8764 hi sir, myself Chotu best commerce graduate. I am able best to clean bhandi specialist in dosa maker tawa. Please sir i want to job. This is my no 98###### please caal me sir i very hardly working sir. Thanks sir
As per your calculation..and after giving to police also..he is earning above 2 lakhs per month.. He said 5000 expense per day..means 150000 monthly U said sale of items multiply by cost is equal to sale of 24,500 per day..which is 720000 monthly.. Let's assume as per seller..business is good for 3 days..and not good for 3 days..and we exclude 1 day totally.. Then also by half of 720000 is 360000 And we can downsize it to 350000 for Police wale chakka (a wheel which makes your business run) Now profit is total sale minus total expense..which is 350000 - 150000 = 200000 So he is making around 24 lakhs yearly.. Which is more then salary of a Service Delivery Manager and almost 3 times salary of a Manager of companies like HCL, IBM, TCS , Accenture etcetera etcetera... So I think now it's high time...I must also open Pakoda becho types.. Bcoz Ram ka naam lene se job toh kya..bheek bhi nahi milti Jai ho
Bribes are less 5k*4(20k) for 1 month. If you calculate Income Tax it will come to 30k per month. Better government can give permit to roadside shops with some rules and restrictions and bring in some mechanism to collect reduced taxes(if possible/full taxes) from these people
@@sudharshanshyam9162 He won't have to give income tax coz it's a business. He would have to register his business and accordingly GST would be applied on every sale. He can show his personal income less coz technically all the money would of the company (or firm or shop).
@@vinayprakash1687 GST and Income Tax are two different things and I think you are getting confused between both. GST gets added to the items sold and the service tax goes to the central government from which a part of it gets distributed to the state governments. Paying Income Tax is necessary for both Individuals and Businesses for the Income/profit which they make in a year and almost both of them have the same tax slabs like 5%, 20%, and 30% based on the Income Tax Slab which goes to the central government's kitty and this is the root source of Income for the Indian government to run this country and when people ignore this it becomes black money and the government will find it impossible to recover this black money, especially from this kind/group of people. Next time read thoroughly about a topic before you comment/answer something wrong.
@@sudharshanshyam9162 Read my comment carefully before blabbing anything. I didn't say he won't have to pay taxes, I just said that his taxes would be less. Tax on small businesses is very less in India. Go and do your homework.
@@vinayprakash1687 What is there to read in your nonsense comment. It's waste of my time replying to stupids like you who don't want to spend any time gaining knowledge and talking about your kids homework here. Which part of irrespective you didn't understand for Individuals/Business? There are no special tax slabs like small business, large business etc. If they want to go under the business route, these guys will fall under 25% tax slabs(+4% extra cess on the taxed amount) for Income/Profit as business up to 400 crore which is almost similar to Individual slabs. cleartax.in/s/income-tax-slabs
Gotta love the two way relationship. The customers are super happy(even me who regularly eats 30 rupees dosa) and the shopkeeper is happy to earn 1.3 lakh a month without having to pay rent in shops but just a small bribe. Everyone happy including the BMC.
5000rs per week is small bribe vs RENT ? So total of 20000rs per month spent on bribe is less than rent? The problem is goverment can benfit if they make the place legal for road side shops and collect that money as rent instead.
@@GowthamV07yes monthly rent comes to a minimum of 60k for a really small building, on top of that they'll have electricity and water charges not to mention all the extra cost for equipment
how irritating it will b for them too to stand all day in sun n serve also take care of besharams collecting bribes. they r doing wat they can at their level n capability we cant tell them to walk off. they hve to cook,serve,wash utensils,take care of money collection, all at same time bearing the heat n wid limited staff n place. its nt easy to run a dosa/pav wada stall. And still we r nt that developed nation yet wer all our people can afford few 100's bucks lunch everyday. ya they work harder then many office going people too. many rich n highly educated people wont b able to stand fr 2 days n run it.
@@jaivora9528 imagine doing all fkn degree with the mental pressure and getting job and working 24 hr a day just to earn 10-12k per month and doing this job with just some bribe amount and earning 24 l per year
Most of the comments :- Iam wasting my time for degree Me bhi idli dos bechuga 😒😂.. Reality :- place - ready Utensils - ready Dosa - ready Customer - error404 ( Taste / presentation / hygiene / perfection /skill / time to settle.... matters ) Note :- sab dukan wale utna nhi kamate jitna tum soch rahe ho 😏🥱
This is not business, its an illegal business. Had this been a proper restaurant then you would need to factor rental costs which itself would had eaten entire profits. Also licenses and compliance. So this is like smuggling, make money without rules.
Hence the bribery. His customers are ok with the service, standing outdoors and they are not bothered by the hygiene standards. As long as people want to buy he will keep selling. He doesn't need a fancy restaurant to attract customers, just tasty food.
@@TheHybridlogic totally agree. Just saying its nothing surprising he earns that well. What gets shown is one side of the coin. People think lets do that instead of studying but its difficult to follow the right path and achieve v/s working on foot'path' and achieving
This is the best business.... A qualified CA working in Industry gets around 6-8 lacs in mumbai as a fresher .... and this Anna gets 16.32 lacs per annum ...and that tooo with limited working hours unlike CAs who have to slog their asses 12 hours a Day ..This proves that education is not the only path to riches ... Be Smart
Why should they? Ppl educate themselves so much and then earn a lakh....but the gov takes 30k frm them as taxes...but these ppl dnt pay ny kinds of taxes nd earn so much
In MP, an MBBS intern gets 14K a month on paper actually it is 8-9K and that too not every month. 😂 I am a PG (med), even right now I am getting 55K/mnth. Workload- 24-36 hour shifts Decide for yourself
Yes bro these not so educated small vendors earn easily 1.5L to 2L monthly. They think we white collers earn 5L monthly but fact is despite with f** master degrees and with 10yrs experience its still 10L ctc yearly and subject to taxes. The samosa vendors earn 3Ls monthly in hard cash. The government employee hardly work and hardly found on job are doing some job or business and earn money in Lacs. I know one guy who makes approx 8Lacs a month while doing government job so he earns goverment pay, bribes on job, do some business or job total 7 to 8Ls. He has taken falt on hard cash downpayment. Actually the hard hit citizen of india are white collar people who rub their asses to get degree and then spent 10 12 hours on job to get 5 10 20L ctc subjext to tax and even work on weekends and unrealistic targets. Goverment dont pay any attention to businesses, agent, farmers etc but its always private workers who are gangra*** by everyone
He was talking about those uneducated/ class 8th/10th passed people. A huge portion of our country is still uneducated and it was for them, not for those students who are studying now.
He seems to be from southern tip of Tamil Nadu. Generally these guys have a good entrepreneurial skills. They come to a developed city, and small start businesses. There are plenty of examples bjust in my colony.
I am quite ignorant about taxes as my dad is in defence so it gets deducted on its own from his salary. Can you enlighten me what a civilian is supposed to do? Are they supposed to pay the taxes themselves and if it is not that strict to do so, why do we still have income tax?
He pays ..50% of his profits to staff. It trickles down to society. He pays bribe multiple govt departments. Corporates usually pay less than 2% of total profits to stff. Wake up.
@@yagesh287 its civilians, army mens and everyones above 18 yearsbof age itsbyheir duty to file income tax returns every year. Even if tax is deducted in salary and no other income..then also all have to file tax every year. Thats the only duty
Option 1: Listen to your Father and get degrees. PERHAPS you will earn more money. PERHAPS you may become your own boss one day. PERHAPS with the accountant's help you will pay lesser taxes. PERHAPS you will spend quality time with your kids & family. Option 2: Don't listen to your Father. Help your Mother in Kitchen and learn culinary skills. DEFINITELY you will earn more money. DEFINITELY you will become your own boss one day. DEFINITELY you will pay zero taxes (as it is mostly a cash based business). DEFINITELY you will spend quality time with your kids & family. Now I understand, why the hierarchy of respect is - Mother, Father, Guru & God.
How the fuck will you spend time with your kids and family when all the time you are at the stall or at home preparing for the stall? Do you think with your mind? That definitely doesn't works for everyone. Not every dosa-maker street vendor earns 1.5 lacs a month. And this guys works his ass off probably to make that much money. It's easy to say "Learn culinary skills and you would definitely get a job". Listen to your father. A degree will bring you less money probably but you would have peace of mind and education. This guy doesn't have a degree but he works his ass of equivalently. Your father stresses on degrees because he loves you and doesn't want you to see working as a daily wage worker. This guy is also a daily wage worker but his daily wage is better. But you never know when this business could be disrupted. A degree won't snatch your working area from you. If it does then you probably don't deserve a degree.
The municipal authorities just vanish them from road sides...which results into losses for such vendors.. Why can't they just provide such vendors space...where they can carry their business without any hassle...Even Foreign Countries have street food space..then why can't we Indian have the same? I don't understand...why aren't our govts. helping them by giving materials at subsidised rates? If they do so, the citizens will get good quality food at cheap rate and this would ultimately result into these vendors' prosperity🙃
profit could be more as he didn't disclose everything honestly. On top of that most of the vendors use ration rice which is very cheap so ultra high profits.
Scroll.in after watching your videos on daily economics I have decided to start a Pan/cigarette shop and eatery after graduation. IT engg salary 4-5 Lakhs per year and foodpath eatery 1.15/1.30 Lakhs / month for working half a day. Now I understand why many opt for this profession.
Ummm...your initial profit is going to remain at 20,000 - 30, 000 a month. You would need to build a good relation with your customers. After 5-6 years you can earn about 1 lakh from an IT job and will take you about the same time to up your profit while running a shop.
George Mukkath these are not legal vendors so technically BMC can kick them anytime they want as they are not paying any taxes nor that place belongs to them. You need good contacts to handle these things first
George Mukkath also consider the number of hours you'll be working .....in businesses like these you literally get no rest days if you want to maintain customer base
Wernt you one of those channels that along with rahul gandhi, criticised the PM, when he said ppl could earn well making and selling pakodas etc?? What was that idiotic word: Pakodanomics!!
I am a bengali and absolutely in looooove qith tamilian food, especially idli, which is somewhat uncommon with people i know. I really appreciate these cooks and think they are doing a great job, not only providing food but which is tasty as well as so affordable and healthy. The thing about municipality really annoyed me. Hope to see change soon
There was a lot controversy when our PM said a pakoda seller is self employed. Opposition leaders created much hyped drama on this in the parliament. They must come and ask this guy about job. He would probably laugh at them and tell them about his monthly income. No job in India gonna pay him like this figure if it is believed that he is saying the truth, I hope he is. Pappu should learn from him. Kam se kam dosa khaa ke jaaye gaa aurr kyaa pataa sayad akal bhi aa jaaye.
This is what modiji meant when he said even a pakoda shop counts as a job . Everyone made fun of him at that time . Eveyone starts small,take any example . A small pakoda wala today can work hard and own a large joint tomorrow. But people dont wanna work hard , they feel embarrassed starting small.Just imagine if you are starting small and employing just 2 people, you are not only providing for your family, you are helping those 2 helpers as well. But youngsters today just want to sit idle and make money , that's why they lust for government jobs . They dont lust for private jobs , they know they will have to work hard in a private job to succeed, moreover it takes qualifications to get a private job which more than 80% doesnt have . So , just sit idle , dont work and at the end of day blame govt for not giving them a job.
Thank you for doing business in india Here's subsidies for you 1. Let your income be more then 12 laks a year you don't need to pay a single penny as a tax 2. no need to pay rent for stall 3 . If bmc takes away your stall just do a bit drama for sympathy
When the world was boasting snacks, fast foods in McD, PizzaHut etc. & bluffing public with YUMMY, TASTY tags by girls with short skirts, SCROLL.IN is emphasising our own INDian Food by our own people without discrimination. Bravo! Live long scroll.in.
People commenting on his profit are not looking at the hard work he puts in and the fear of loosing his place/business any day. If he opens at 8 AM he must have started working from 5-6 itself.
Yeah , for past 70 years we never paid taxes. Now it's painful for us if someone asks us to pay taxes. Aren't u shameful ? Out of 130 crores population only few lakhs are paying taxes. And you all complain that India is underdeveloped. That's what British wanted. Instructed Ney.hroo to not collect any taxes and thus India will be an underdeveloped poor nation.
30 kg rice = 1200😮 15 kg urad Dal= 1500🤔 Totally wrong stats..... Idly rice is parboiled broken rice which when brought in bulk will cost not more than rs 20-25 /kg. Similarly urad Dal purchased in bulk will not cost more than rs 80/kg Kindly recheck the figures....
Monthly revenue 3.64 lakh.. and x 12 = 43.68 and doesn't have any income tax.. complete tax free no fucking 30% tax slab no bullshit business.. peaceful with good saving/profit of 1.5 lakh per month x 12 = 18 lakhs.. he retire in 5-6 years (18x6=1 crore+) no need to work like a govt/software employee till 45-55 years.. I hardly savings per month is 9k.. Dosa Anna you are super.. 👌
Don't get carried away with figures...he is selling 350 dosas, 500 idlis, 200 vadas...its very big number..his location is very busy street near station and hence sales is high..location is the key here
@@DeepakYadav-ev6lw yeah really good for you ... And do remember when you start selling Dossa on Road, atleast you pay tax as the salaried employees do by default....
U can't c the kitchen of the hotel..but u have ppl from the muncipal corporations keeping a check on u and giving u ur food license accordingly...u may c him prepare the dosa in front of u...but do u know how he made his batter or sambhar or chutney
If our goverment can allocate dedicated spots for these road side business to thrive and instead of paying bribe collect rent for goverment and then use that rent to give subsidy to these people to improve their business. It will be a great economy booster. And also must put in strict legal rule for not getting bribe if that place is registered and rented out by the goverment itself. Like they can file a complain and next day action can be taken on the person asking bribe. This will reduce bribe and black money as well.
For people saying I'll do this after engineering, I like your sense of humour. But for people who feel he is earning so much more than us, you can see the struggle in that. Having a white collar job and getting salary is way different from what he is doing. He might have gone through so many hardships and you can see he is still working so hard. Facing all those municipal officers and bribes on a daily basis. A single day if he shuts because of sick, he losses a big chunk of his revenue and most importantly customers. Unlike us who have sick leaves, weekends and paid leaves.
Remember one thing these people don't know how tp make it more big but if a engineering or i say educated person is gonna do it then definitely it will be a startup and he definitely find a way and make it big and more profitable then there will be a day when he will be a owner of 4 5 shops and thats it you are end up here seted up good food business with big profit and now its up to you if you wanna pull it more further or you are just satisfied here.
You even don't add the other spices needed to cook chutney and sambar and vada and effort and maintenance of vehicle and water and plates and losses at weak days you should be more accurate
Great and congratulations to Anna 🎉 however makes me wonder why do salaried taxpayers always have to contribute to the Indian economy by paying taxes year on year? So we pay taxes so that people like Anna can continue to earn tax free income year on year....and perhaps enjoy all govt benefits side by side...
This is the truth everywhere. Salaried people, including bank employees and government workers, pay taxes. Most business owners and employees, and self employed people evade taxes.
GST forced many business to pay taxes which they were previously not paying and enjoying the cheaper prices ,then suddenly comes GST and smaller businesses couldn't compete with others due to raised price . I Dont know whom to blame. Plus such kind of local vendors pay bribes to police ( which is obivously lot cheaper than the actual taxes thats why they do it ) and many also enjoy BPL previledges n other schemes.
Placement chal rahe hain. Lag nahi raha acchi nokri milegi. Mera bhi eak fast food ka stall kholne ka man kar raha hai. Partners ki talash me hu. If interested tell me I'll give you the link to my LinkedIn profile.
There is a dosa stall in Pune..they sell set dosa in leaf plates and use leaf cups for 2 chutneys and sambar too.. Dosa are just 30 a plate..3 set dosa. That stall is always crowded..we have to wait for 5-10 min to get second round of dosas. Missing that😭
I don't understand why there's no easy subscription fee for roadside vendors instead of confiscating their business or stopping them from running their business! We need to give them more opportunities or else how will we develop as a nation?
there is a major mistake in calculation if you listen him care he said first 3 days buisness is good next 3 days its not that good maybe he is making 50-60% sale only on next 3 days and as he is serving mainly office going people so sunday is a off so if we calculate his income considering the above points it comes down to around 50000
While calculating everything and found my self in Mumbai he earning atleast 2k to 2.5k per day it means he earning 60k to 80k per month. Well he also mention that he spent bribe means 20k for months Instead we can invest money into rent. But hopefully there is something way to earn money more than any graduate holder salary. Hope after graduation every degree holder start there own business.
