David De Gea vs Van Der Sar vs Peter Schmeichel best saves ~ Who is the best? Manchester United | HD 

Schmeichel- leadership Van der Sar- positioning De gea- reflexes

Van Der Sar is my favorite keeper of all time as I watched him growing up and is the reason I follow Manchester united but if it wasn't for schmeichel setting the standards for keepers we wouldn't have people like De Gea playing for our squad now

I'm pretty sure schmeichel and van der sar didn't have Chris smalling and Phil Jones in front of them

Peter "The Great Dane" Schmeichel was a beast of a keeper.... He knew how to sort his defence out! After he left United, the defenders knew their roles because he drilled his orders into their heads.... Literally!

De Gea is very impressive technically, but Schmeichel remains the best keeper I've ever seen. He was a massive guy yet he had incredible reflexes and agility, at close range he used his arms more effectively than any other keeper at the time, you can see that at 3:12 for example. He had such a huge presence on the field, constantly shouting at his team mates, he was a nightmare for attackers and defenders alike. He was in my opinion the biggest founder of what is expected of a keeper nowadays

honestly as good as de gea is, peter will forever be the greatest man u keeper

Schmichel is out of this world, wasn't born in his time but the Vids tell it all🙌

Schmeichel was next level. He was my idol as a nipper and nobody in my opinion will ever get close to him.

Peter Schmeichel

when de gea came to utd everyone was like why they bought this kid. now same people are saying he is the best in the world. he earned that.#respect for de gea.

Van de Sar barely had double saves because HIS positioning was always on point❤️🔥👏🏽👑WHAT A GOLIE

Those Manchester united keepers are the best in their time,,,,if you agree give me a like,,,,am not man united fan

Why choose? ... we are blessed to have had 3 of the very best that have ever put gloves on and all 3 have given us countless great memories.

peter and van der sar is a legend. De Gea on his way, definitely !!!

3 best. Schmeichel is a legend.

I think...... Peter Van Der Gea is the best!

They all are very good, but I Think that Peter is a bit better

Schmeichel is arguably the best of all , but tbh I love Van de sar

Comparing Schmeichel to any other gk is sacrilegious to the sport itself. His combination of leadership, intelligence and raw skill is clearly unmatched to this day.

I'm leaning towards Schmeichel from what I've heard. {I was born in 97} So Growing up in the 2000s Van Der Sar was my goalie.

Peter Schmeichel is the best of all.

2 legends and 1 legend in the making

Scmeichel of course. The complete package of world class shot-stopper, leader and a total monster. He was not just about shot stopping and reflexes. He had a huge influence, also with the accuracy of his throws out of defence to launch counter attacks. Greatest of all time.

Schmeichel was in that team that broke through and reclaimed the trone after so many years where United never won the title. That shift in the teams mentality took an immense belief, power, skills and leadership. And in center of that teams quest you found two men who set United above everybody else: Cantona and Schmeichel. One scoring the goals and the other keeping it. Schmeichel would tear up the premier league, letting no-one doubt who was the best keeper in the following years, setting new stadards constantly revolutionising the way keepers should play the modern game. He would plague strikers out of their minds with his almost violent way of coming out of his goal, his almost superhuman power in one v one situations. Unbelievable keeper. Best keeper not only in United but in the leagues history.

I like all of them

Having played as a keeper myself, I would say Schmeichel. Van der sar was an amazing shot stopper (reaction saves and blocking/diving in front of the line), as is De Gea (probably slightly edges Van der sar and Schmeichel on that front), but Scmeichel was the complete goal keeper in terms of shot stopping, closing down angles, intimidating attackers and marshalling the defence. He was like having an extra defender in the team - a defender that could start an attack run as well because of his fantastic distribution of the ball after a save

Schmeichel was the best, no doubt

In United colours, Schmeichel gets my vote. Absolute beast he was! But VdS is my favourite, because he made all those crazy-ass saves for us when he was already past his prime. That being said, de Gea's reflexes is second to none! So yeah, I'm confused! 😂

Schmeichel's Bravery, Van Der Saar's Vision, De Gea's Reflexes.

u know all man utd goalkeepers are great

De Gea no doubt in my mind. He's saved us on countless occasions, unlike the other two who have had real defenders in front of them. Imagine having to make saves like those 10 times a game... Only De Gea can say he can relate.

Each of them has their own strength.. Schmeichel with his bravery, VDS with his intelligence, DDG with his instinctive reflexes.. all of them are world class for sure

I've never witnessed Schmeichel or Van Der Sar because I'm only a teen. I've only ever seen De Gea and I love De Gea. All these goalkeepers are superb and I've seen some of their best highlights. I believe that Manchester United produces the best keepers : )

Been supporting this club since 1988. Been blessed to see absolute legends between the sticks. That said, for me Schmeichel is the greatest GK of all time, not just in United's history but football overall. BUT instead of comparing, I just sat back and enjoyed 3 club legends :) Yes even young DDG has my full respect and is already a "legend". Just a fun video for a supporter overall, thanks for posting :)

You can see over the years how outfield play has improved and play has become faster and more skillful. I followed Schmeichel all his career, he was the best. But, when you see the level of competition Van der sar was up against and the level De gea are in you have to say De Gea. However, and with hindsight of Schmeichel and all of his honours, Schmeichel made the greatest difference to the club. A tough one. All greats.

One on one there was only one. Kahn and other German keepers had some of the ruthlessness too, but only Schmeichel had it all.

Schmeichel is the best keeper man u have had he always came out and put his self in front of the ball like a defender and plus his reflexes and agility

Degea is the reflexes beast smeichel is fearless one and Vander seer is an organize keeper

1. Scheimachel have two big hands 2. VDS have long finger 3. David have good reflect on legs...

My heart always says Van Der Sar because he my childhood HEROES 👍👍 Edit : The one and only who save 4 penalties in row😘👌

peter schmechael THE BRAVE van der sar THE SAVER de gea THE FLYING STAR THE LEGEND MANCHESTER UNITED GOALKEEPER

Van Der sar was so good to see, everytime the opposition had the ball u was so satisfied because Van Der Sar had all over control. He was so smooth and good. So 100p Van Der sar

Schmeichel and it's not even a debate,he had things you can't teach,BRAVERY,LEADERSHIP, PRESENCE (opponents feared him) and was also excellent technically.Not only is he a united legend HE IS A FOOTBALL LEGEND as well.

Better days, those... We miss you, Edwin 🥺

Peter Schmeichel - he had multiple double saves ♥

May I point out that when Schmeichel joined United, it turned the club around. One of the coaches told Fergie after he signed Schmeichel "he will win you trophies" and that is how it turned out. All three are great goalkeepers, but Schmeichel was the game changer and also changed our ideas of what a goalkeeper could be.

Van Der Sar was my favourite goalkeeper.

Schmeichels save against Rapid Vienna at 2:12, is like one of the best saves any keeper ever made.

Who's here after *De Gea's* performance vs tottenham ✋😂🤣

Blessed to be able to witness all three play, Schmeichel was the Messi & Ronaldo of goalkeeper, out of this world class. DDG & VDS are the Zidane & Ronaldinho of goalkeeper, world class.

I love Schmeichel and DeGea. Both are soo talented goalkeepers in different ways. Schmeichel - Fearless DeGea - Reflex & Technical Saves

Peter made me a United fan 🙌🏼

Three great keepers...all great shot-stoppers...always Schmeichel for me though. So much power coming off the line 👍

First of I would like to say, all three of them are WORLD CLASS. Shot stopping: I would say they are really close. De Gea is probably a little ahead of the other two, because his reflexes and positioning are out of this world. Ball distribution: Both Van der Sar and Schmeichel were better than De Gea at this. De Gea can be a bit sloppy with the passing sometimes. Schmeichel probably takes #1 spot in this category. Penalties: No discussion here. Van der Sar hands down takes this, with Schmeichel as #2. VdS ability to psyche out the penalty taker was quite fascinating to watch. Dealing with crosses: This is something De Gea struggled a lot with the first couple of seasons, however he has improved a lot over the years, but he's still behind Van der Sar and especially Schmeichel. Schmeichel was a very imposing goalkeeper and I've seen many strikers pull out of a challenge because they've heard the freight train that is Schmeichel come crashing towards them. Leadership: Hands down Schmeichel with Van der Sar behind him. This is probably De Gea's weakest attribute. Both Schmeichel and VdS were a lot better at organizing and communicating with their defense.That being said they also had a better defense in front of them. De Gea is still young and I have no doubt he will improve this a lot in the future. So, based on this I would rank them Schmeichel>VdS>De Gea

Schmeichel without doubt is the best keeper Utd have ever had PERIOD. He's is(was) an absolutely world class goalkeeper and a true leader on the pitch. I can't rate him highly enough and I'm a Liverpool fan so please feel free to argue against this.....

All of them best goalkeepers of their generation. I respect De Gea though He was our main man fr 7 seasons single handedly saved United from relegation. 5 consequative times in the Epl team of the year.

Schmeichel won keeper of the year 5 times... I think he is a level above the two others

Schmeichel the best :)

Interesting to see the different styles. Schmeichel with the sheer bravery, VDS with positioning and DeGea with reflexes.

I like Peter the most he is the legend. Edwin are one of the best. And David is now No.1 of the world in this era. He's gonna be a legend too. 👍👍👍

SCHMEICHEL FOREVER !

This is the journey of glory" united. Everytime united have a brilliant keeper. United will bring the champion league to manchester.

3 goalkeeping Titans. Peter set the bar for modern keepers, everyone else tries to follow but these 3 are all epic in their own rights, the greatest keepers and shot stoppers of their generations for me.

If you grew up in the 90´s then you know that Schmeichel reinvented how goal keeping was supposed to be. He was the first, the best, he was/is The Great Dane that led the danish national football team to their victory in EM 1992. And he is/was the man who Man Utd needed the most in their time of need and he secured every titel possible. Do not bother discuss this issue, the others are great goal keepers no doubt about it. But Schmeichel was the person who invented that style of goalkeeping. The others wouldnt be as great as they are without Schmeichel.

Schmeichel - 1 on 1 master Van der Sar - positioning/long shots master De Gea - reflex semi-pro

Schmeichel = UCL 1999 van der sar = UCL 2008 De Gea = Road to UCL

Schmeichel by far... He had all the qualities of a worldclass goalie, which he was... In my humble opinion, he was the best in the world, in his prime... They way he threw the ball, and hit the intended target everytime... Insane His reflexes was second to none...

Great #daviddegea best goalkeeper ever since I'm on the club at Manchester United #GGMU

Schmeichel without a doubt. He came from brondby when nobody even knows him. He helped united from nothing to becomes 'king of the premier league' on his era. Don't get me wrong..V. Der Sar and De Gea both are fantastic, but they came when united already became one of the biggest club in the world. So yeah..Schmeichel, Sir Alex and 'class of 92' earned every respect for this

Peter Schmeichel absolutly

All three fantastic can't compared them, they are best at there moments

De Gea is all time best goal keeper of man UTD 💯 in history of man UTD 💯

vd Sar was the best keeper Ajax and our Dutch squad ever had, but I still believe Schmeichel was the better keeper because his reflexes were phenomenal. I've never seen a goalkeeper since that had such catlike reflexes as he used to have. I think this video proves this point! Thanks for this great video!

Schmeichel and van de sar and de gea .the difference. Schmeichel and van der sar both had world class players in front of them .de gea has a load of overated overpriced ordinary players in front of him

I've seen these 3 legends and all of them have their own strength....but for me I will choose Peter...he got all the capability of a goalkeeper and the voice at the back...

I've been fortunate to have the privilege to watched all of them. Peter, Edwin and David. I'll start of by saying that all 3 were/are brilliant world class keepers. Amongst the best of their generation. I'll go with my heart. On balance, in terms of total goalkeeping skills, I'll go with Edwin as number 1. His positioning and grace was exemplary and he was a fantastic ball distributor and penalty stopper. His positioning in general play was also very good and his organization of defence. I rate him slightly ahead of Our Great Dane and David but not by much. They all have great attributes though.

1- Schmeichel 2- Degea 3- V.D.S. Schmeichel is the greatest I've ever seen. lev Yasin must have been good to win Balin dore. But never seen him.

schmeichel is my idol and I'm a liverpool fan

3:14 the best save that I still remember since I saw the match.

No goalkeeper at all can beat Schmeichel at his peak! Buffon longer on top though...

The song fit ps and vandersar perfectly!absolutely amazing goal keepers!perfect!Da gea has along way to go to reach there level!!!

Asking "Who is the best?" Is like asking which one of your 3 kids do you like the most.

I think van der sar was the best just because he was brilliant during the time where the ball was transitioning from the rock hard balls of the 90's and early 00's to the light floaty ones used in now. not an easy change for a keeper because of the flight patterns of the ball. even with the transition Van Der Sar was able to perform equally as good as the other two

Fantastic video. Peter Schemeichel is a legend!

Schmeichel is one of the most importent reasons Utd made such a blast of the 90`s, While van der Sar was not any less good Scmeichel was just happened to be there at their glory-days. De Gea on the other hand has to deal with a world where money and results counts for everything. It is hard too say who`s better they all played/play in a different Utd-Team, different opponents and players have evolved so much over the last 3 dacades.. In my oppinion Schmeichel where the best in the world, matched only by a few like Buffon/Köpkee/Illgner and Kahn.

Any united fans who doesnt believe that the GREAT DANE is the best Keeper in their history is delusional. The leadership, man management from the back and sheer domination of his 18 yard box was incredible. Those long throws and huge goal kicks were outstanding. For me even as a Chelsea Fan, he will always be my no.1 pick for a keeper.

Edwin will always be my favorite since he inspired me as a child

Peter scheumikail..👌

Schmeichel is the best.. If you re 90s kids, you must know.. Noone even close to schmeichel.. Barthez, Chilavert, Peruzzi not even close The best in 00s era.. Buffon... Others Iker casillas, van der sar, petr cech The best in 10s Neuer Orhers de gea, courtouis

De gea is phenomenal! He’s like that perfect replacement for Smeichel except for the leadership traits. We’ve been blessed with great keepers over the decade.

Peter has made a load of double saves. ♥️

Schmiechel is a legend and he is the best in the history

Peter schmeichel is arguably the best goalkeeper to ever live, nevermind the best out of Manchester United's history. He was unbelievable, anyone who knows goalkeeping knows it's Peter schmeichel

On of my best n favorite keeper David dea gea

I didn't see Peter Schmeichel defending in the time but I see his videos and his a legend for the club (respect), Edwin Van Der Sar as well. But i recognize that David De Gea as the best, he gave us (United Fans) very good moment's in the last full season's (Since 2012).

Schmeichel then De Gea then Van Der Sar! Manchester United are now breeding the next star as well Sergio Romero! Amazing man and amazing talent! United will always have good keepers no matter what!

Pretty much everyone who says De gea on here has only seen him play. He’s right up there today, rightly so and probably second only behind Neuer and already near van der Sars level but Schmeichel was the best. Not only out of these three but the best the premier league has seen.

Peter shimiechal Is best goal geeper

Peter Schmeichel...the best goalkepeer ever...I am ARSENAL FANS....😄😄😄

All 3 are insane keepers that are truly on their own level compared to other keepers but watching all 3 makes me think that De Gea is like a combo of both of them and his foot saves are just amazing. Such a blessing that all 3 play for Manchester United