Debate - Trinity vs Tawheed | Adnan Rashid vs Samuel Green | ft. Hashim, Mansur and M.Hijab 

20:18 Subhan Allah. I am shocked and amused hearing Samuel give the example "As-salamu alaykum" as a prayer that is addressing the prophet PBUH". And he said it with so much confidence. Where did he get that translation from? 😲🤣🤣

The question by brother Hashim sums this video up. The confusion Samuel Green had show how absurd the trinity is.

Alhamdulillah for Islam

Trinitarians - If it Looks like a Duck, Qwacks like a Duck then it definitely is an Elephant!!!! 🤦🏽

in the first 20 min i laughed soo hard, the guy made up a complete whole new religion XD

Tawheed is straight forward and hence no confusion in it

Alhamdulillah I am muslin

Oh yeah I remember this debate. Bob the builder in the front row trying to ask silly questions 😂😂

We muslims need to hit the LIKE button man. I see the ratio on all the islam vids...i also tend to forget LIKING the vids, we need to do better ❤️💯✌️

Such a legendary debate that I used to watch it in cuts, now in full form. Jazakallah khair

Good work Adnan, God bless you

It's very amazing that Samuel Green tries to raise objections on Tawheed but no one is confused by Tawhid and ask sincerely questions about it except some of them tried to mock at it but Trinity is objected seriously by Adnan Rashid and also from listeners bcz if you rejected absolutely oneness of God then you will hug your infinity confusion and sleep with it🤣😂😂

Let the Christians debate us more, it's making more and more Christians leave Christianity for Islam.

When Bob asked about kissing the black stone, asked him if he kiss his mom, wife, and kids, is a form of worship?

Brother Mansur capturing Brother Hashim asking question to Samuel, brotherhood moments:)

Hijab on two occasions intervened to spare Green the obvious embarrassment visible on his face. The first is when Hashim asked his question. The second when Ali Dawah asked his question. Hijab, seeing him, ie Green, gibberishing, intervened to spare him the humiliation...... These are Muslim ethics. A Christian wouldn't have done likewise......

Christian Prince and Bob and David wood they’ll need too be here so they could learn, those guys be waffling around the internet

The waffling of Samuel to the last question proved the wrestling one has to do with the concept of Trinity 😮

MashaAllah Good talk by brother Adnan... Speakers corner gang in a civilised debate 😂😂😂

JazakAllah'u khairan

1:06 : Samuel Green said that God is not absolutely one🤣😂, therefore if God isn't absolutely one then you admitted that God is polytheism,so You proved that when Quran said Trinity is blasphemy because it against absolute oneness of God and leads to polytheism

We need more debates like this with EVERYONE there. I really loved how respectful this debate was for the most part and the people we take our information from asking questions is also pretty great except there was some that wasn’t there that I would’ve like to see, especially the more controversial ones like David wood, Sam shamoun or Christian prince. None the less I think it’s good that questions are being answered by both sides to maybe help each other understand the other side.

The trinitarian Christians have deified angel Jibra'il into the 'Holy Spirit' as a co-equal part of the 'godhead', Audhubillah.

1:17:30 THE KNOCK OUT QUESTION, SAMUEL STRUGGLES TO ANSWER.

Masya Allah..good presentation brother Adnan May Allah keep protecting you, and all of us

47:53 Mr. Green quotes Jesus, "Jesus says the Father is the true God", so he left out the key word "ONLY". Subhanallah they twist the words of the bible...

The number of people in churches n this one says it all about the faith that’s dwindling with every passing day . Only truth will prevail .

MashaAllah

God is not spirit, God creates spirit.

Just because they say Jesus is the word of God does not mean he is all the word, the words of God can't be separated from Him, this is a crazy statement Samuel and some Christians say. If Jesus was all the words of God he would know the hour and when praying he would have to answer himself

masha ALLAH

Masha Allah. I was delighted to listen to both speakers. I am a Muslim and I see that Adnan did a perfect job in proving that the trinity was not known in the first century after Jesus. But I also see where Samuel comes from. Definitely, the fact that (1) Jesus is not like other humans in his creation, where he has no father, (2) the miracles that happened in his own hands by God (the father) mislead people about his nature, (3) the fact that he is still alive and will come again. All three issues above added to the confusion about the nature of Jesus for all humans. The truth is that he never claimed to be God and that the doer of miracles is God and not his messenger Jesus, and the return of Jesus is necessary to punish people who did not believe in him or did not believe in the Oneness of God. The return of Jesus is important to close this chapter in human history to get things straight.

Reverend Samuel Green has made adjustments to his presentation since his early days of rebuttals to Brother Ahmed Deedat. However, no matter how he tries he still comes up short. It's really not his fault, more sagged and learned men than himself have thrown in the towel and declared the Trinity unfathomable and therefore a "mystery" you must accept on faith. And intellectuals like Newton and Jefferson have jumped ship for, as Ustad Rashid has pointed out, Atheism, Deism or Unitarianism doctrines. And for those of you who believe Atheism is not a religion, guess again.

barakkallahulakum

This guy Samuel when Ahmed Deedet used to give literature on the subject of Jesus..he was there in one of Ahmed Deedet video's, Samuel asked a question to Mr Deedet. Nonetheless from the time of Ahmed Deedet time until now he did not got it, they hear yet they can't hear they see yet they can't see SubhanAllah.

Tawheed is utterly logical

Samuel Green should debate Burt Erhman first to prove his Trinity before challenging Adnan Rashid.

As a convert to Christianity, I obviously find the reasoning for Christianity and the christian understanding of the Creator convincing. But anyways, both speakers tried to be do their best and be respectful, so I respect them both, though as a christian individual, I wish everyone see the reality of God the heavenly Father, and come to the Christ, the Word of God - who is God - , and find the one God - the Holy Spirit - in her/his mind and heart. In the name of the Saviour of the World, Amen

Every Orthodox Jewish rabbi who lives by the Torah/Old testament agrees with the Islamic understanding of taweed . So he's going to lie about the Old testament wow 😲

بِسْمِ اللَّهِ الرَّحْمَنِ الرَّحِيمِ قُلْ هُوَ اللَّهُ أَحَدٌ (1) اللَّهُ الصَّمَدُ (2) لَمْ يَلِدْ وَلَمْ يُولَدْ (3) وَلَمْ يَكُنْ لَهُ كُفُوًا أَحَدٌ (4)

Samuel you need to be in a box by yourself because you just made your own religion! May Allah guide you to the right an healthy religion that you were born to be!

Wow 3 can be 1 !! 😃

If glory makes Jesus God, well Jesus says that he gave the glory he received from the Father to the disciles ( I have given them the glory you gave me) . So the disciples must also be God because Jesus shared glory with them

May Allah guide Samuel.

its always the bible who gets attacked on these topics. Islam is crystal clear subanallah

Samuel Green put no effort in learning about Islam. Even he did not bother learning about the meaning of tawheed. The people who debate a topic should have some depth in an area. Adnan has clearly demonstrated his knowledge of the Bible and history of Christianity. I would love to see a more learned debater to face Adnan.

From 1:20:00 the answer from Adnan, would somebody please tell me which vers in the bible speaks about angels having the glory of the Father? Thanks.

Muslim prays to the only one and true God.

As that Christian claimed something like, God both has oneness and distinction which led to the trinity, so my question is, if God is perfect so basically there is nothing that is imperfect about God, and there is distinctions between the persons of the trinity, for example in the bible when it talks about the hour, that only God knows the hour and not the son or the holy spirit, basically no one except God knows the hour, doesn't it automatically mean that clearly God is one and no trinity because God knows everything and if someone claims that this person is God but doesn't know everything doesn't it mean that he is not God. But a trinitarian Christian might say that no Jesus his human essence didn't know the hour but his divine essence does, so wouldn't that mean that there is four persons instead of 3, example God the father, another God the Father, God the holy spirit and Jesus the son of the 3 God's, why because Jesus in his human essence and divine essence are distinct if one knew the hour and the other didn't. Anyway the statement of oneness and distinction (in trinitarian Christian belief) about God is a contradiction because if God is perfect in all his attributes and Jesus being a human but also God, doesn't it mean that Jesus isn't God because a human has clear limits and God doesn't, but a Christian trinitarian might say that God needed to take on a human form so that he can guide people because prophets are humans and can make mistakes and sin. So I would say that can't God create a human that is capable of not sinning just like the angels, (peace of Allah be upon them) and not making mistakes especially in religion because he would have to be a role model for the people. But also for God to become imperfect with limited knowledge is just a lie because he knows everything and he is eternally perfect. Also Allah knows best. And that islam is the correct religion and Allah is one. And there is no other God except Allah. And Isa ( jesus) peace and blessings and mercy of Allah be upon him is a servant of Allah

Green Samuel has invented his new version and creed for the Trinity: "We Prey to the father through the son by the Holy Spirit" Someone else can add to the renovation: ""We Prey to the father through the son by the Holy Spirit with the Mother under the Sky for the Children" then we make a council in Istanbul and add more divine persons to the Godhead. Astaghfiru-Allah

trinity question made me converted to Islam, it never make any sense as much as you explain it...

Hashim's question ✔️ Samuel's answer ❌

S. Green, Jesus doesn't say the Father is the true God, as you put it. Why did you omit the key word ONLY from John 17.3 ?

Bro. How are you so confused. Attributes are a description of a thing, not pieces. For example, an insect vs. a fish. They have attributes, but those attributes on their own are not their own entity. They're simply the description for you to identify that thing,why are you confused ?

Who's the questioner at 1.29.12? looks like a younger version of Adnan

💕💕💕

Ignorant people who doesn't know that God/Jesus of chrstians does command war/ violence 1 samuel 15:3 Now go, attack the Amalekites and totally destroy[a] all that belongs to them. Do not spare them; put to death men and women, children and infants, cattle and sheep, camels and donkeys.’”

Assalamualaikum. May i know when this debate was held ? And if possible, is there any recording for the other 2 debates ? Thank you so much for posting the videos. May Allah bless.

wow it's beyond me how a grown up man can come in front of the world and say we have 3 Gods is we have 3 Creators then what will happen if they disagree with some things as we all know they will fight and if they fight the ( the Sky and the Earth will crash and if that was true we will be gone in one day)

47:19 why he take the word "Only" out of the verse he just read?

I got migraine trying to understand the trinity. surah al- Ikhlas بِسْمِ اللَّهِ الرَّحْمَٰنِ الرَّحِيمِ In the name of Allah, Most Gracious, Most Merciful. 1. قُلْ هُوَ اللَّهُ أَحَدٌ Say: He is Allah, the One and Only; 2. اللَّهُ الصَّمَدُ Allah, the Eternal, Absolute; 3. لَمْ يَلِدْ وَلَمْ يُولَدْ He begetteth not, nor is He begotten; 4. وَلَمْ يَكُنْ لَهُ كُفُوًا أَحَدٌ And there is none like unto Him. Wa La hawla wa la quwwata illa billah (وَلاَ حَوْلَ وَلاَ قُوَّةَ إِلاَّ بِاللَّ) “There is no power, no strength but from Allah”. Inna lillahi wa inna ilayhi raji'un (إِنَّا لِلَّٰهِ وَإِنَّا إِلَيْهِ رَاجِعُونَ) "Surely, we belong to Allah and verily to Him do we return. And alhamdullilah my migraine is gone.

This guy is leaving explicit verses and using ambiguous verses. Not surprised, Christians have been doing this past 2k years. Whereas Quran provides the correct methodology to read the scriptures.

Mr Green is waffling too much here, no making any senses

I can hear the questions more than the speakers. . .

Legs and hands of disbelievers will talk and testify against them in hereafter As Quran says in 36:65 So something speaking doesn’t mean they are devine including black stone

LOOL when adnan went back to his powerpoint samuel knew it was over ... Samuel 5 min was so shaky and just rushing through the questions giving answers without even thinking

Samuel was relieved he didn't have to answer @alidawah saved by @Hijab lol 😂

the brothers in the SC are doing good workz alhamdoullilah wich has enouraged christians to research what their scriptures actually says instead of just swollow whatever the church feeds them as church doesnt want anyone to study christianity not to find out the real truth about it. As GOD will never send confusions and misteries to his creation as the christians try to make us believe as if GOD is not aware of the limitations of his creation rather GOD sent 1 clear message for eternity as GOD does not make mistakes that need any correction so no one on judgement day can hide behind the excuse of "i wanted to follow but it was just to big of a mistery for me to understand or grasp it was just to confusing to obey"

Bob's the only one that showed up?

The ten commandments say there's only one God and thou shalt not worship any other God but me.

I'm unable to understand a single word samuel said. What is he talking about. Is he giving his own interpretation? I'm confused...

By the way, Samuel has been debating with Muslims for a long time (I know, because I have watched him many times), yet his knowledge on Islam is STILL very lacking, it's shocking and embarrassing. If you want to combat someone, you should first know the opponent well, right? With this debate, Samuel has lost his credibility as a professional debater. Won't listen to debates with him anymore.

Sorry Samiul I can you’re confuse and I’m very confused. How can you explain that to children

Stop using word ' what game is god playing?' Astarfirullah

speak about ignorant about something but still want to talk about it and he just make fool of himself... in just about tawhed it self... he should just speak about his believe instead of trying to make assumption about our believe...

I have a question does salah means prayer in Arabic and does it have other meanings and is salawatum plural for prayer?

Too bad there weren't that many people attending

All passive aggressive questions, from both Muslims and Christians, somebody should've asked if jesus was worshipped by his disciples during his life

1:40:00 hahah he knows that doesn't work that way

I wish I was there because I had a question for Samual, because in the Old Testament in Numbers 23:19 and One Samual 15:29 and Hosea 11:9 and in so many other parts of the Bible it clearly says that God is not a human or God is not a son or God is not a man, and then suddenly Christians says that a human being came and that is God, or a man that came is God now and that God is Jesus may peace be upon him who is also a son, so doesn't this all contradict what the old testament says as explained above, especially when Christians believe in the Old Testament and surely God would not be lying in the old testament or Christians simply got it wrong, and what makes it further concerning is that a doctrine in the 5th century came about which Christians still believe in is that Jesus who they claim to be God had two natures, which is that human nature referring to the fact that God always had and will have a human nature, which completely again contradicts what the old testament says, and then saying there is a son in the trinity also contradicts the old testament when it says that God cannot be a son. Literally Christians have created a whole new world where their believe does not make sense and clearly goes against their own scripture, with clear evidence of corruption and changes as well made up stuff. Christianity definitely cannot be the truth.

time time time? whats up with time is not enough?

Christians Jews & Atheists; Are you more knowledgeable in the Christians faith than all the Priests & church members & the Jewish Rabbis who reverted to Islam? Or more intellectual than all the professors & scientists who discovered the miracles of Quran & became Muslims?!

A Walnut has skin, and inside the skin, is a shell, and inside a shell is a nut. Should we change the name Walnut to trinity because it is considered 1 Walnut.

If Jesus’s death was a ransom, who was his blood paid to?

If one still persist with TIME DILATION just because Einstein said so , so does people will keep banging till aakhira... TRINITY... they will keep insisting 1×1×1=1, where each 1 has a subscript.. 1f, 1s, 1h... even though 1f=/1s=/1h, still they make 1×1×1... they aren't homogeneous...

Why will Jesus die to save the world from sins, if God almighty send him as a message to save the world, why will God allow him to suffer and die in such a pain full way.? Yeah but guess what God did not let him die God took him to heaven, Because when God wanted to test Abraham and told him to kill his son and he ober God's others , then God send Abraham a lamb, he saves his son. And that's exactly what he did with Jesus.thank you.

Sam would not last a second at speakers corner 🤣

I have a feeling Jews wrote the new testament as it full of discrepancies and insults Prophet Isa alayhi asalaam.

I see why Sam is running away from adnan

Is this bob say hello to speaker 🔊

will not enter into a sane mind something unreasonable

1:04:12 Gyuhujhukajdaio i dead subanaallah these people contradicting themselves in any way, shape and form

Bob the devil makes an appearance lol.

Is that Samuel's best shot? 😁😁

Brother we can see clearly that you are not telling the truth my Christian brother Allah blesses you

The Oneness of Allah confuses no-one except trinitarian Christians and polythesists of other 'faiths', it's very simple for those who have clear rational thought.. Surah Ikhlas gives the clear test of who Allah is and who Allah is not. Is Samuel Green really trying to define tawheed to learned muslims who understand Arabic..? He must be a Joker.

Mr Green can't explain well the trinity status of his 3 Gods...☝️☝️☝️❤️❤️❤️👍👍👍🧔🧔🧔🇵🇭🇵🇭🇵🇭

Согласно основополагающему положению христианства, бог сам себя зачал в чреве своей будущей матери, а после рождения стал собственным сыном. Уважаемые христиане, каким разумом это можно понять, и что это, если не дьявольщина? Сам Иисус говорит (от Иоанна 5:19): «Истинно вам говорю, что Сын ничего не может совершить по Своей воле, Он делает лишь то, что, как Он видит, делает Отец. То есть, воля Иисуса зависит от Отца (Бога) и не имеет собственной силы. Если Иисус не обладал собственной волей, то как он может быть богом? Христиане говорят о трех ипостасях бога - Троице, а по сути, о структуре или составе его. Во-первых, кто (какой философ, поп, агностик, физик…) достиг такого уровня знаний о природе бога, что осмелится говорить из каких и скольких частей бог состоит - 3, 5, 50 или 1000? Во-вторых, разве измерения, какие бы они ни были не является атрибутом физического мира и обладает ли бог физической природой, чтобы можно было говорить о его каких-то физических параметрах, не является ли сама эта идея большой глупостью невежд? Догмат о божественности Иисуса был принят на Никейском соборе в 325 году решением 318 священнослужителей, проголосовавших за божественность его. Но разве качества объектов (вещей предметов, людей, растений, насекомых) зависит от результатов голосования или чьих-то убеждений? Не открывает ли такой подход путь к обожествлению не только человека, но и мыльницы, табуретки или, скажем, крокодила или помойного ведра? Согласно От Матфея 5:17-18, Иисус пришел соблюсти иудейский закон. Он (Иисус) говорит: "Не думайте, что Я пришел нарушить закон или пророков: не нарушить пришел Я, но исполнить. Ибо истинно говорю вам: доколе не прейдет небо и земля, ни одна иота или ни одна черта не прейдет из закона, пока не исполнится все". А как известно, никакой Троицы, никаких крестов, никаких ритуалов каннибализма с "плотью и кровью Христа", никаких кукол из папье-маше или картин, которым поклоняются язычники, в "Законе" не было и нет. Тогда какой дьявол прицепил к имени Иисуса всю эту галиматью и две тысячи лет носятся с программой, которая компрометирует великого пророка? Иисус говорит (От Матфея 15:24-26): «Я послан только к заблудшим овцам народа Израиля». Тогда женщина подошла к Иисусу и, склонившись перед Ним, сказала: «Господи, помоги мне!» Он возразил ей: «Нехорошо отнимать у детей еду и бросать её собакам». Мы здесь видим непреклонность Иисуса даже когда женщина пытается найти лазейку, чтобы приблизиться к нему. Если придерживаться слов самого Иисуса, то вывод, отсюда следующий: никто кроме евреев не могут быть последователями его. Но апологеты христианской доктрины ссылаются на другие стихи евангелиста Матфея - 28 стих 18,19, которые гласят: «Отдана Мне всякая власть на небе и на земле. Итак идите, научите все народы, крестя их во имя Отца и Сына и Святого Дух", согласно которым Иисус вроде как дает своим ученикам другую установку «научить все народа». Однако, если принят это положение, то получается, что Иисус-бог в первый раз как бы соврал. Но разве бог может врать? Если нет, то стихи Матфея 28 стих 18,19 должны быть признаны домыслом. В этом случае, как и говорил Иисус, никто кроме евреев быть его последователями не может, в том числе те, кто считают себя христианами. Логика тут очень простая: или Иисус соврал, или вторая группа стихов - домысел, с вытекающими отсюда последствиями. В целом вопрос следующий: уважаемые «христиане», зачем в течение 2 тыс. лет вы занимаетесь самообманом, когда вся эта ваша вымышленная доктрина трещит по всем швам?

1:03:00 eh ehe he em em em em my G be stuttering