Deffo dennis for both...phil is all talk when it comes down to it he gets others to do his dirty work while dennis fights his own battles he loves a good scrap...also lets not forget dennis killed dalton and would of left johnny dying too if he hadnt thrown him the phone
Quite honestly their both nutters and both of them have punched one another. Though personal I always prefared Dennis as a character because of how much more complicated he was.
Dennis Rickman made a fool of Minty twice. First time when he grabbed him by the nuts in the cafe and the second time when he knocked him out with one punch in The Vic.
I think Phil is the answer to both! couldnt imagine Dennis going mental at a girl like Phil did to Ronnie and Stella! btw CanadianMaster1 ive got to say that Dennis would definately kill Beppe lol
beppe was not really hard phil would have killed him in a fight it was just that he was a cop so phil never battered him. i think dennis would be phil in a fight
I think the nutter question is a pretty close one, but i'd give Phil Mitchell the edge. His mental aggression is far stronger than Dennis's manipulable nature. Best punch - hands down PHIL.
Phil needed heavies to take on Dennis though. Phil was no match for Dennis at all, ever. Phil does pack a better punch but Dennis can still take him on easy.
@@gh0510 I think when they faced each other it would have been a 50/50 fight. If this was the Phil of 1992-6, I'd say it would be a 75-25 fight in Phil's favour.
@@faisalchaudhry7800 92-96 Phil wasn't as muscular as 2003 Dennis so there's no way Phil would win. Reason why I struggle with Phil being top dog is that he easily, instantly w/out thinking attacks people who he knows can't fight like Ian, Steve, Billy, Jamie, Jay, Nick, Mark etc even when the beef aint that deep. But when it comes to Dennis or Johnny Allen he rarely touches them and ONLY does when he's pissed. Whereas Dennis attacks almost everyone on impulse coz he's pissed off and doesn't care if he wins or loses. Even Andy said to Dennis (30/3/2004) "it was always sucha pleasure to watch you work. When someone doesn't care what happens to them. Gives them the edge."
