What worked for me: 1. The bass. You can run, but you can't hide from it. The bass was brilliant throughout the entire song. 2. Back Vocals. I was blown away by Sunidhi's energetic take on this song. Simply outstanding. 3. Kabil Mia's trumpet. I am a huge fan, and he didn't disappoint this time as well. 4. Boga's sublime appearance and his khomok. 5. Tashfi and Suchana's powerful singing. Things that didn't work for me: 1. Murshidabadi's voice, like you said. I literally double-checked my headphones to see if the volume was lowered down or if I had gone deaf! I am just relieved now that some other people also felt that it's actually his voice that did not match the power the song required. Nothing to take away from him; I am a huge fan of his other works. It just didn't work for me for this particular song. 2. The lyrics of the melody part where Arnob joins to sing. The melody was beautiful, but the lyrics were pretty ordinary in my opinion. Also, this melody part I would love more if I could hear it as a separate song. But it didn't blend well here, I felt. 3. The way they pronounced অরসিক। everytime It sounded like ও রসিক to me. It was pretty disturbing once I started noticing it. I would say this song, for me, was a mixed bag of some liked and not-so-liked elements. But what I always appreciate is experimentation. I have always felt that Coke Studio Bangla is not afraid of doing experimentation, and I have huge respect for the entire team for this as well. On a side note, You guys looked a bit tired to me. I hope everything is going well in your life. Take care
Lyrics except that was actually good and thought-provoking. That should be noted as well. It was that which neutralized the lack of energy in Murshid's voice
@@king_halcyonIt goes without saying that this is absolutely my personal opinion. Of course, people will have different opinions from their own perspectives. I have nothing against the lyrics of the main song. They are indeed thought-provoking and carry the main spirit of the song. However, the lyrics were also the reason I found the modern part of the lyrics flat and not so appealing.
Very well put indeed! Again, nothing against Murshidabadi but probably more energy was required. Some of viewers also made an interesting observation that his voice might not have been processed in the best way during post-production. Maybe this could be the reason too!
Fuad is the main composer of this song. I would say, He is one of the best composer of this subcontinent. If you listen to his other songs, You will realize what im saying.
Till now the most perfect and on point reaction and review video of this song so far. No wonder why we all keep waiting for your videos. Keep up the good work guys 🔥
Dang maaan.... what a rollercoaster... seemless transitions... the main vocal was buzzing soothingly in the ether... lots of national/international music specialists are talkin about it so positively and want to explore more bangla music... beat boxing was funbeat of heart as a British beatboxer shouted it lit. Philosophyical lyrics, everything was smashing and celebration vibe in music.... it's one of the best of cks across the countries. Shout out to CSB... THEY DID IT ......
I've been waiting for your reaction videos and pretty honest reaction i must say. You should listen to Fuad's compositions album like BONNO, VARIATION 25, VARIATION 25.2.. And yes waiting for "KOTHA KOYO NA" reaction video. 🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩
Exactly on point, I Couldn't agree more with you guys. About the outro, basically they tried to mix it in a bengali way of celebrating weddings and programs during the 90's with trumpet. That's what I think, I might be wrong. Basically thats the essence they tried to project and I appreciate them for the try.
Yo Brothers ! I was eagerly waiting for your reaction on Dewana ! Great to see you two back ! This arrangement is from Fuad Al Muktadir, the guy playing the piano !
Completely agreed on the comments you did about murshidabadi part....it make me realise that how good your review is...how honest they are...amazing I totally agree with you❤❤❤💥💥💥💥lots of love🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩
Welcome back & thanks for your honest review. You guys spot on perfectly & top of that I would say there are too much experimental things! Finally it's very natural that somerhing goes wrong because of the settings of priority! But Yes, it has open up a new door & new way of experiment on Kawali Song.
Completely agree with u guys. This song didn't hit me much when I listened to it first time but it grew on me gradually. Still I think some portions were totally unnecessary which ruined the actual taste of Kawali. Yet again agree with Haris, it was an experiment which is needed!
Loved the reaction guys 👍🏽 Music started from both Bengal and spread to other regions which is why some of the best musicians, singers, music directors all have lineage to both parts of Bengal East & West. This track had it all, the variety of music and instruments, the beats, rock, jazz, funk, beatboxing drum & base vibes the whole lot, truly amazing piece of artistry. We’re happy that you are reacting to Bangladeshi music because it’s about time our music is highlighted and it will hit the heights it so deserves, everyone are taking notice. Again many thanks bro 🇧🇩
Regarding South Asia when it comes to certain genres of music and themes which came into Bollywood with the likes of RD Burman and many other Bengali artist and musical directors
Okay so top music directors in Bollywood and India are lying when they said this regarding the likes of RD Burman, Bappi Lihari etc, chill mate it’s not my point of voice I’m merely sharing the POV of others in the music industry
I like your reactions when you guys watch coke studio bangla songs for the first time and discover bits and pieces together. Pre watching takes something away, can’t exactly pin point :). I know you guys are catching up but good work. Thanks
Great review!! Very honestly said. It’s very easy to say some cheesy words rather than being constructively critical. Without pointing out the specifics, I also liked most parts of the songs. But above all, I appreciate the experimentation part.
Spot on with the beatboxing part. It truly felt off and instantly took down the intensity of the track once it came on. But it’s a skill for sure and probably fits better in a different number
At last someone agreed that beatbox wasn't required in this track 😂 the best part of the song , the Jugalbandi of Boga and Murshidabadi, that's it. Season 1 set the bar pretty high with the choice of singers but season 2 kinda pales in comparison.
I am telling those who do not know Fuad. Fuad means something new Fuad means getting something new. Fuad means new flavor Fuad means some exception Fuad means music composer❤you Boss Fuad sir ❤
I agree completely about the lead vocal! It doesn't work for me either. It could be replaced by Rinku, who sang "Kanar Hatbazar." You guys reacted to this song before.
Other than Murshidabadi there are other singers from West Bengal too including Arnob's wife Sunidhi and Madhubanti Bagchi(from Dokhino Hawa) and many more because Arnob focuses more on their capability rather than their nationality.
Appreciated your very honest and unbiased reaction to the song. I just wish, you understand this language little better which could help you to enjoy bengali songs much better.
Thank you Haris and Hammad, you just spoke my mind! You spoke about the exact things I noticed, liked and disliked about the track! The song felt underwhelming to me on first listen as well. Only saving grace was Boga (he smoked Murshidabadi in 5 seconds). On second and third listen, I got the guitar and electronic parts. I am not a fan of beatboxing as well, and the part on this song was not very high quality either, but my God that Dotara chord! The ladies were better than Murshidabadi, but I agree with you guys that it needed the whip like Sumi's. I would also like to hear more of Fuad's electronic work. I expected more of it in the outro, missed that sorely. As I have said it many times, listening to these songs with you guys doubles the fun. Thank you again for that.
@@LetsTalkAboutIt-Reactions I just listened to the original. Wanted to share with you guys. It's traditional, and maybe because of that if just sounds more complete: ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-clqqrL60rO8.html
You guys are giving genuine reactions. I agree with u about Murshidabadi. This song kinda disappointed me. The thing is we are expecting much better songs from them.
I've listened to this particular track for at least 10 times by now. With and without. I felt really good but also like something very crucial was missing. And, then you almost like started to speak my mind. I also liked the beatboxing only because it's been fused with Dotara and Khomok. To me, that was the SPACE which symbolically represented the mating of East and West, old and new, folk and pop. I too think, there ought to be "more appropriate" singers who are able to sing the Qawali part with the "right" strength and passion in their voice. Even Sumi's part in 'Bhober Pagol' was not exactly of my taste. But, I guess, the producers aren't really supposed to focus on our tastes. I could be wrong but the target audience probably are the global listeners. I mean, if Murshodabadi was replaced with someone who's a Baul, with a similar vocal like Aleya Begum from 'Kotha Koiyo Na', the funk might've been not so funky. Just my late realization. Meaning no disrespect to any artists. I believe, 'Constructive criticism' often be a form of love. So, you guys really inspired the honesty in me throughout this reaction, for I too believe "the truth is not always beautiful nor beautiful words the truth". 🙏🏼🤍
When i say that you guys have uploaded a new video i literally went "yes..... After all this time YES thay have uploaded a new video" Whenever a coke studio bangla's song come out i watch their video, then i weit for you guys to upload you reaction to that video. This last month i have missed you guys 😭 thanks for coming back(人*´∀｀)｡*ﾟ+
For this arrangement, Murshidabadis vocal was perfect. Because it has the vibes of celebration. Murshidabadi sung the song with great energy you can say it but the vocals are processed according to the need of the song...
The Bass playing was absolute banger . But overall the mixture of the different genres didn't gel as well as some previous tracks, it felt very disjointed. Just my opinion
