Did Harry Potter ACTUALLY Die!? | Harry Potter Film Theory

Подписаться 2,2 млн

Просмотров 86 тыс.

50% 1

Shopify info for description: Go to shopify.com/scb to sign up for a $1 per month trial period.
Today J dives into the Wizarding World of Harry Potter to find out if Harry ACTUALLY died at in the forest when Voldemort hits him with Avada Kedavra or if he only got part of the way there. What do you think?
Through The Griffin Door
RU-vid :: / @throughthegriffindoor
Apple :: podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast...
Spotify :: open.spotify.com/show/062Ypac...
#supercarlinbrothers #HarryPotter
Edited by : Ethan Edghill
Carlin Brothers Coffee & Merch ►► carlinbrothersmercantile.com
J vs Ben ►► bit.ly/2I5xHee
Harry Potter Theories ►► bit.ly/2K2Rtru
Super Carlin Gaming ►► bit.ly/1CRM5Bq
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
BECOME A SUPER CARLIN FRIEND➜ / supercarlinbrothers
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
FOLLOW US:
P A T R E O N ➜ / supercarlinbrothers
J's V L O G➜ / jonathancarlin
I N S T A G R A M➜ / jonkerlin & / scb_ben
F A C E B O O K➜ / supercarlinbrothers
G A M I N G ➜ bit.ly/1CRM5Bq
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Want to send us something?
Super Carlin Brothers
PO Box 4339
Roanoke, Virginia 24015
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Business Inquiries Only: carlinbrosrtp@gmail.com
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Intro Music Created by RKVC
/ @rkvc
Intro Animation Created by J. Cutt Productions
/ @j.cuttproductions
Every time you give us a thumbs up a Narwhal gets its horn! (maybe..)

Кино

Опубликовано:

7 мар 2024

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 385

@pareekravi 3 месяца назад

I also love how Voldemort's brilliant plan of giving Harry the option to come to the forest and meet him there was the cause of sacrificial protection being cast again. He really is the worst planner ever

@GermanCptSlow 3 месяца назад

He should have just killed him like he killed Snape. Would have avoided a lot of trouble from his perspective.

@shilohwehrmacht2947 3 месяца назад

Smart as he is he's really big dumb for plot if I kept being beaten and the only thing that ever beat me before was love I'd experiment against love magic

@sisterjesscah 3 месяца назад

He's an idiot. 🤣

@ginnyjollykidd 3 месяца назад

I was going to say this. It's the one detail he. left out.

@nathancase6485 3 месяца назад

His plan to live forever backfired so bad that his unnaturally long wizard life was cut so much shorter because of his meddling.

@reckless_slowpoke 3 месяца назад

In this death scene there a line that hit me all the time, in books and movies: - Stay close to me (said Harry to his mother) I cannot imagine more sad line in human being life than asking your (ghost) mum to be close to you in time of dying

@jacquelinekenknight9280 3 месяца назад

Thanks for this. I just found out I’m pregnant with my first and you just made me cry with this comment. 😭

@kristanella5859 3 месяца назад

@@jacquelinekenknight9280congrats!!!

@lycanthis9963 3 месяца назад

@@jacquelinekenknight9280 Congratulations. Only advice I can give, cherish every moment you have with your child, whether good or bad. And try to avoid hypocrisy.

@CharlotteFung 3 месяца назад

I cried at that line too 😭

@maddiebeth_o 2 месяца назад

It makes me LIVID that the standout quote from this book is “Always” from Snape and not “Until the very end” from James

@-speedster-101 3 месяца назад

It was so funny when Harry said” is this all just in my head?” and Dumbledore just went.” of course it is.”

@zedchillman2685 3 месяца назад

What's funny about that?

@-speedster-101 3 месяца назад

@@zedchillman2685 imagine if in a series where someone can kill somebody else with a stick the mentor tells the main character yo dude your mental this is all in your head

@moemuxhagi 3 месяца назад

Classic Dumblydoore moment

@lexieboon7852 3 месяца назад

🤣🤣@@moemuxhagi

@amandacarnelison2157 3 месяца назад

Harry had a second chance to live

@emmasmith8098 3 месяца назад

“How’s Wormtail?” 😅😂😂

@catfishin 3 месяца назад

I like to explain the sacrificial protection as "murder double jeopardy"

@thunderflare59 3 месяца назад

And becoming the master of death is final jeopardy.

@Mr12Relic 3 месяца назад

"I'll take 'Pretty Obvious' for 400"

@Mr.supergamer20 3 месяца назад

I don't think I've watched since Alex Trebek died R.I.P

@doll9340 3 месяца назад

@@Mr.supergamer20same 😭

@DJay157524 3 месяца назад

I'd say in ol Volde's perspective, it was more of a "Whammy".

@cmm07r 3 месяца назад

Harry was only MOSTLY dead.

@jacquelinekenknight9280 3 месяца назад

😂 probably owes you money

@user-en7hz9ko2x 3 месяца назад

There is a difference between mostly dead and all dead. Most dead is slightly alive. With all dead, there's only thing you can do. Go through his clothes and look for loose change.- Miracle max (princess bride)

@red5_skywalker 3 месяца назад

Mostly dead? How can you be mostly dead?

@Dadofer1970 3 месяца назад

He was really dead, just not most sincerely dead.

@DoloresLehmann 2 месяца назад

@@red5_skywalker The same way you can be nearly headless.

@ElysiaWhitemoonOmega 3 месяца назад

i still say we need a show where in each episode voldemort tries to kill harry in stranger ways, like dropping a car on him and it just bounces of harry's head

@gaurav1987pal 3 месяца назад

Sean Bean is the real master at Dying, hence "Master of Death"

@MegaGandalf12 2 месяца назад

One does not simply die on the way to Mordor 😂

@jamescam04 16 дней назад

Sean Bean is the Master of Beanth.

@Ollie.H-2301 3 месяца назад

I always thought he was in a kind of limbo between life and death. He wouldn't die unless he chose to move on and he wouldn't be truly alive again unless he chose to come back. Harry says, "I've got to go back, haven't I?" And Dumbledore says, "That is entirely up to you. You say we are in King's Cross? I think if you so desire, you can board a train." "And where would that take me?" "On."

@ObsessiveGeek 3 месяца назад

Limbo is between Existence and Non-existence, it can only be visited by being disconnected from the mortal realm. It’s not “true death” but it is still part of the experience of dying. Harry wouldn’t have had a choice to move on otherwise. I feel like we just tend to consider “death” in very black and white terms, like life, it is multi faceted and complex, especially in the Wizarding World when we have Ghosts who are neither alive nor truly dead.

@paragon_pa 3 месяца назад

I agree. Aa few times in the books even Dumbledore states that nothing can bring someone back from the dead.

@Ollie.H-2301 3 месяца назад

@@ObsessiveGeek man's out here preaching philosophies to us all

@ked49 3 месяца назад

@@ObsessiveGeekaka those who made the same choice as Harry.

@samstromberg5593 3 месяца назад

@@ObsessiveGeek I feel like it's important to note that IRL death IS very black and white terms It's just in this fictional Wizarding World that there's grey area

@littleblue997 3 месяца назад

I interpreted it as Harry being neither alive nor dead whilst in limbo. That was where he made a choice. Schrodinger's cat was probably there in the background.

@yakirfrankoveig8094 3 месяца назад

Harry:"the reverse schrodingers cat"

@adolfodef 3 месяца назад

Erwin Rudolf Josef Alexander Schrödinger, The First ("Al") was the cameraman.

@pckrichards7980 3 месяца назад

Schrödinger’s Pottah!

@cyberhawkgames 3 месяца назад

Short answer, yes. Long answer, ITS COMPLICATED!

@john_drennon 3 месяца назад

Head cannon: Dumbledore put the ring on specifically so he could talk to his sister.

@thesoftersideofsears 2 месяца назад

That’s not head canon, he literally says that’s why he did it. Also to see his mother and father, something like “i hoped to see my family alive and whole again”

@HpToujoursPur 2 месяца назад

"Head canon" proceeds to describe actual canon

@john_drennon 28 дней назад

@@thesoftersideofsears I seriously don’t remember him saying that. Looks like I need to go back to the books!!! Did he say that in HBP?

@dianamickelsen9988 3 месяца назад

Harry did have the cloak with him when he went to die. He wore it the whole time in the forest on his way to find Voldemort. As it says in the book.

@danielsantiagourtado3430 3 месяца назад

He was in limbo And as the soul piece of Voldemort inside him was destroyed he had the choice to board the train with his beloved mentor or go back. As the hero he is he chose the latter

@Ranger1812 3 месяца назад

No. He didn’t. You cannot reverse death. He went to Limbo, a place between life and death. Harry was the Horcrux. The Horcrux is the object that contains the soul piece, not the soul piece itself.

@merrymay3758 3 месяца назад

@Ranger1812 quite literally the same thing. He came back to life smh. No matter how many times you split that hair...he came back to life and didn't remain dead! Smh!

@Ranger1812 3 месяца назад

@@merrymay3758 It isn’t splitting hairs. It’s an important distinction. ‘No spell can reawaken the dead.’ Harry didn’t die! That’s specifically why he could return to life. That is a fact. That matters.

@directorofshield96 3 месяца назад

He was in between life and death and he could choose (Limbo) We are in King’s Cross, you say? I think that if you decided not to go back, you would be able to… let’s say… board a train.” “And where would it take me?” “On,” said Dumbledore simply. ( Death, life after death or something like that)

@ObsessiveGeek 3 месяца назад

⁠@@Ranger1812Yet, he could have chosen to move “on” had he so wished. This also is fact and matters. Had he made this choice there would be no debate on if he lived or died. It’s simply that as physical beings we struggle to see death in non-permanent forms, we dismiss it as “didn’t count”, but it absolutely does. Limbo is a transitional point, shifting from existence to non-existence. We only get to this point by dying.

@Intrestingwintergamesandmovies 3 месяца назад

Can you do what if wormtail telling voldemort the potters house location was a setup and when he arrives all of the order members are waiting for him while harry,james and lily are safely escorted to hagrids hut or what if voldemorts wand backfired and killed wormtail when he used it to kill Cedric in the graveyard or what if the characters were in different houses Harry:Slytherin,Ron:Griffindor,Hermoine:Ravenclaw,Neville:Hufflepuff Or What if Harry was in Ravenclaw And Hufflepuff.

@Dayshine_WUCE 3 месяца назад

What a fun story for Harry to tell his kids. “Have U ever told you about the time I *died* ?”

@rhondacrosswhite8048 3 месяца назад

Remember in Order Of The Phoenix when Uncle Vernon had his hands around Harry's neck strangling him when he caught him outside the window listening to the news? Vernon got something like an electrical shock that made him let go. I've always assumed that this was one more way Lily's protection helped Harry. Am I correct tin thinking this? Or was it just more accidental magic like flying to the school rooftop to get away from Dudley? I figured that Harry was past accidental magic once he got to Hogwarts and learned to control it-well, except for blowing up Aunt Marge.

@satsujin-shathewitchkingof6185 3 месяца назад

Harry's a horcrux, horcruxes protect themselves when in danger

@nathancase6485 3 месяца назад

Tje protection charm Lily made protects him against Voldimort, not against others, and certainly, not against an arbitrary non magical source.

@MOE-db8oc 3 месяца назад

@@satsujin-shathewitchkingof6185 That’s a unique aspect I had not pondered but I feel you are correct.

@satsujin-shathewitchkingof6185 3 месяца назад

@@MOE-db8oc Thanks. There's another point where he apparates from a group of bullies onto a school roof that could also be his horcrux protecting him.

@MOE-db8oc 3 месяца назад

@@satsujin-shathewitchkingof6185 Interesting. To me, that goes more towards making something happen that was not fully controlled when his feelings were peaked. If one of the boys had touched him and something happened, I would go with the hocrux part. It’s a bit grey since the necklace did react to strangle Harry before he could reach the sword. Mostly though, it seems the horcrux would react when force was being applied to destroy them.

@kirstenkolkman6758 3 месяца назад

The editor really did the most in this video

@ericrutledge4925 3 месяца назад

I always believed that what happened to him was a purer version of what happened to Voldermort in Godric’s Hollow. So he became ‘less than sprit, less than the meanest ghost…but still [he] was alive’. And the reason he could chose to come back was because it wasn’t his own horcrux keeping himself alive, it was Voldermort’s making his soul remain pure and cause the afterlife to give him a choice. Great video guys! I love your stuff! ❤❤

@justinstewart6507 3 месяца назад

“Eh heh hehhh.”

@53prime 3 месяца назад

I like to imagine Harold had a similar limbo experience when he was a baby and when asked whether he wanted to die or return he just stared blankly because he didn't understand words yet.

@thescholarsjourney661 3 месяца назад

I think that if a horcrux makes you survive as "less than the meanest ghost," then wouldn't a "lovecrux" make you die as.... "less that the meanest.... death"? Like, technically you're dead, but not really, in the same way that a horcrux makes you alive, but not really.

@RillaGorilla420 3 месяца назад

Well now there’s a difference in events between the great hall and the forest. Harry did absolutely nothing in the forest and the Avada Kadavra still knocked out ol Voldy. In the great hall, Harry casts expeliarmus at Voldemort and it disarms him AND sends back the Avada Kadavra curse.

@abenihnatyszcz6687 3 месяца назад

I love that the mtg card for sacrificial protection was a full art

@ObsessiveGeek 3 месяца назад

The piece of Voldermort we see in Limbo **IS** the fragment that was inside Harry, this is how Harry was able to “survive” Death by being fixed to Limbo and being able to then actively make a choice to be resurrected. However it was only a direct attack by Voldermort himself that would result in this specific scenario, I’m not as confident with what death looked like for him though personally I don’t think its as hellish, I like to think he is able to pass on through. His existence was tragic enough without adding eternal punishment.

@MagusAgrippa8 3 месяца назад

I'd like to think he was mostly dead. And mostly dead means slightly alive. Dumbledore just fed him a Miracle Pill before they started chatting.

@jimlittle5769 3 месяца назад

🤣🤣🤣

@justinn8541 3 месяца назад

Harry Potter, master of all 3 Deathly Hallows.

@red5_skywalker 3 месяца назад

I'm growing increasingly more fond of the little text snippets that pop up on screen to share their thoughts 😂 I love it, hope it continues!

@TeachMeBert 3 месяца назад

What if, during the Harry VS Voldemort duel at the end of _Deathly Hallows,_ Harry had simply used "Accio Elder Wand" _before_ Voldemort used Avada Kedavra, thus leaving Voldemort wand-less? What would Voldemort have done then?

@naomi_falk 3 месяца назад

I see you are supporting the Ravenclaw Reds today

@zoewilliams5752 3 месяца назад

So not specifically related to the video but I just thought about something I haven't seen anyone talk about but why didn't the trace alert the ministry when Wormtail killed Cedric and all the other magic that happened in the Graveyard since Harry was still underage when all that happened.

@DrMd-jr3xt 3 месяца назад

Thanks, editor. You made me smile a lot with this video and you contributed a lot

@mjpete27 3 месяца назад

Hullo Brothers and SCB Team! Nicely done! I do enjoy watching your videos and am amazed with your continued excellent content, Thanks!

@medichampion328 3 месяца назад

On that basis, could Ron or Hermione run up to Voldemort and touch his face to kill him (post-Nagini kill)?

@lovelylife-tz4be 3 месяца назад

Thank you guys I was feeling super anxious today but watching a harry potter video of yours always helps me through it❤😊 just thought you want to know

@heyitsltaylor24 3 месяца назад

You guys are my favourite yt channel, Keep it up! 🪄😁

@AdrianChazz 3 месяца назад

To my previous understanding, Harry doesn't die, just get's the option sorta unlocked... He basically get's the equivalent of a videogame *_" C O N T I N U E ? "_* screen... *Y/N*

@mecahhannah 3 месяца назад

Awesome as always thanks guys ❤

@cl8733 3 месяца назад

Could you do a video about the prophecy? Trelawny had it wrong: it’s really “neither shall die while the other lives” because they anchor each other to the world of the living via the Horcrux/Lovecrux.

@hollywalker3726 3 месяца назад

I have a slightly different twist on the love crux idea being the reason it wasn't binding. It is only partially binding, however Lily's protection on Harry only was removed by the caster, in the case of the Cruciatus Curses used on him. What if the reason that the spells Voldemort used was neither binding or ineffective on the battlers of Hogwarts is because he returned from the dead? So they received only partial protection from the love crux?

@thegamedevcave 3 месяца назад

yeah, i really don't think so... the fact that with harry and Voldemort are in kings cross to me it indication that wherever they are is not death because voldemort can't get to death, not in that moment, but not even after he "dies" in the end, that is the price for ripping his soul, not being able to properly die and endure feeling weak and suffering for eternity. Harry also gets to choose if he wants to go back or move "on", which seems much more like they're in some sort of limbo than in a proper afterlife to me. one that Dumbledore can reach from death and one that harry, at this time can freely move in either direction in. Harry casting sacrificial protection is easily explained by him meaning to die, voldemort even says "but you didn't die!" and harry responds with "but I meant to!" indicating that he didn't in fact die and that actual death isn't a requirement for the charm... not entirely sure how you guys missed that since it's probably on the same page as a quote that was used in this video... those bits of dialogue are very close to each other.

@MrLuke7131 3 месяца назад

Harry did not die, of course. Dumbledore says: "On the whole my dear boy, I think not." In the final battle Voldemort says: "But you did not(die)!", Harry: "I meant to and thats what did it." Actually dying is not a requirement for sacraficial love.

@ComilitoEqvinus 3 месяца назад

im glad you toned back on intro now channel is fun

@nathans9764 3 месяца назад

As many others have said, i viewed this as a Limbo state or sort of "pre-death.". I don't think that the flayed soul there was the bit from Voldy prime, but rather all of the fragments from his horcruxes trying-and failing- to reconnect. They are stuck there, no vessel to go back to, but unable to move on due to the other fragments anchoring them to the living world.

@thepomfrit 3 месяца назад

I had a thought when you said "Quirrel was a horcrux". Would just holding Nagini kill the snake? Does the protection only work against living things? For example the locket didn't melt away when Harry touched it. Is the protection against that piece of Voldemort's soul in particular?

@1SlateS314 3 месяца назад

I think that the king’s cross is the place where you choose to pass on or return as a ghost so Harry isn’t really dead but in limbo Harry also is able to return alive because if the sacrificial love and hallow stuff

@sunshine34567890 3 месяца назад

1:52 I love that this is an actual card in MTG!!!

@osmosisjones4912 3 месяца назад

Do cars have souls. Did the ending to ratatouille create beautiful ones

@jacquelinedeservebeauty 3 месяца назад

Love your videos!!! You guys should do What if Barty crouch jnr died in ascaban instead of his mother?

@danielwemyss9354 3 месяца назад

I don't think Harry was quite the Master of the Elder Wand at the forest as he hasn't used Malfoy's wand against Voldemort. Its only when this happens that the wand recognizes that Harry defeated Draco and he is now its new master.

@saklee1777 2 месяца назад

I’ve always just thought that Harry did die. But since Harry was Voldemort’s horcrux, I figured that since Harry wasn’t an item and is a human, Harry and Voldemort shared the horcrux. As in Harry also had a horcrux. It was himself or his scar. And both Voldemort and Harry had it as a horcrux. So when Harry died, it was both Harry’s and Voldemort’s extra life that was made through the horcrux that was destroyed.

@IronKnuckleKO 3 месяца назад

"You know, it is really unclear." -- Sokka

@Dadofer1970 3 месяца назад

No, the Voldybaby in Kings Cross is the piece that was in Harry. Dumbledore explains that. There were still two other live pieces of Voldemort's soul when you include Nigini. Harry had to actually die to kill the piece of Voldemort's soul within him. That is fully explained by Dumbledore. However, Harry could choose to either go on and continue being dead or return to life because he had just held the resurrection stone. That is what gives him the power to choose, which Dumbledore also set up.

@HannahEvansOfficial 3 месяца назад

Love your videos

@cyt3633 3 месяца назад

This was a good one, Brothers!

@TaliesinMyrddin 3 месяца назад

Never really twigged that he cast the protection on the whole of Hogwarts

@marielacristina762 3 месяца назад

Greatings from the other side of the world from Buenos Aires Argentina 😊

@DoloresLehmann 2 месяца назад

Saludos de una argentina exilada en Alemania!

@ironpheonix5937 2 месяца назад

another great video guys

@SweetSlytherinGirl-Jennifer 3 месяца назад

My new favorite pasttime is trying to catch the snarky comments the editor slips in. Bravo. Especially the "I don't feel so good Mr. Stark" comment, that was hilarious!

@ramonbetzler7786 2 месяца назад

12:44 This line should never have been cut from the movie

@robinsmith5442 3 месяца назад

Kind of like the Easter story but Harry didn't have to wait 3 days to come back.

@Knowledge.to_Come 3 месяца назад

Harry used the horcrux inside himself to come back. Funny, voldemort never got to use one, but harry did.

@daketora 3 месяца назад

With the new Eragon series in the early stages of development for Disney+ you guys should start doing Eragon theories! You would be the first channel I’ve seen to dive into it.

@Ignis930 3 месяца назад

Dumbledore in this chapter was literally just trolling Harry the whole time

@darkkey19 3 месяца назад

A problem with this theory is that Dumbledore explicitly states that Voldemort failed to kill Harry, that Harry is not dead. I always figured he was halfway between life and death, and that was why he cast sacrificial protection that was less powerful than his mother's. Voldemort even state's that Harry didn't die, and Harry basically agrees with him.

@nathanscudder1303 2 месяца назад

What if instead of dying Marvolo goes looking for Slytherins locket and the ring and finds a baby/very small Tom Riddle and raises him? How does that impact the wizarding world? Is it better or worse?

@charlottehardy822 3 месяца назад

Today’s memes are top tier 😂❤😂

@Nicktonyous 3 месяца назад

Theory: Did Dumbledore perform sacrificial protection?

@northrendicecrown631 3 месяца назад

Harry tried to save them at the end. What if Voldemort repentant?

@bencm92 3 месяца назад

His soul would've been restored but the effort of it would have killed him (Hermione explains that it's a painful process at the beginning of DH). A preferable fate given he then would've been able to move on past limbo with an intact soul, but still dead nonetheless.

@RillaGorilla420 3 месяца назад

It’s so poetic. Voldemort, in his quest to become master of death and kill Harry, gives Harry everything he needs and even helps him to become master of death.

@FatRonaldo1 3 месяца назад

8:15 Harry had the cloak on him in the Forrest but he took it off when facing Voldemort so it was present even if he wasn’t using it

@sargentrowell81 3 месяца назад

Love how they just come up with good ideas for their "What If" series and seemingly don't realize it right away! I mean, I really want to see an epilogue to the recent "What If" but now I want to see a "What If Harry didn't get to the graveyard in The Goblet of Fire?" Just like he said, maybe he's just told to immediately quit at the start of each task or something like that. If not that, well what if Harry just ended up not going to the graveyard? How would Voldemort proceed from that point?

@laylabeth22 2 месяца назад

Ahhh thank you! I have been saying for years that Harry was the master of death at that point! I also think that the reason he could come back was because he was master of death, that being master of death doesn't mean you conquer death but rather have the option to choose it (which is why Harry having the option to choose in kings cross is so special and rare). If being master of death didn't actually do anything then why would Dumbledore bother to leave clues in his will for the trio to find the hallows, it was all part of his big plan for Harry to choose to die and be able to come back. Dumbledore was even preparing him for this back in book 2 when he says to Harry 'it is not our abilities that show who we truly are, it is our choices' 🤯

@joasegoans3709 3 месяца назад

Ok, I might be overthinking this a little bit, but I just got to a conclussion that I'm not sure how fits in Dumbledore's plan -You always talk about how the Lovecruxe anchors Harry to life, but it seems to me that, when Voldemort dies, that Lovecruxe doesn't exist anymore because Lilly's protection doesn't live in Voldemort. -It also feels like the only reason Voldemort doesn't die in the Forbidden Forest is because he still has a horrocruxe. If not for that, he would have died there. So, let's imagine Harry fulfills Dumbledore's plan and destroy all the Horrocruxes before meeting Voldemort in the Forbidden Forest. When Voldemort attacks him, would both had died? Like, Voldemort would have been destroying his last Horrocrux, and, with his death, the Lovecruxe would be destroyed too and Harry wouldn't be anchored to life. So none of them would be able to come back. Is this right? What do you think? Did Harry only lived because he hadn't fulfill what Dumbledore told him to do?

@shalom5214 3 месяца назад

There's a theory that I think would be a good explanation as to why he didn't really die. It goes something like "Avada Kedavra" is a curse that rips the soul from the body, where the body is left as a hollow shell on its own. As Harry was a horcrux, having part of Voldemort's soul inside him with his own soul still present, due to his mother's sacrificial protection, his soul was shielded from the curse, instead ripping out the Voldemort soul from his body instead.

@baruchgoldberg6280 16 дней назад

hmmmmm king's cross chapter in DH: Harry: "Am i dead?" Albus: "I think NOT!" BOOOOOOM!

@gracekim25 3 месяца назад

Great question 😅 I love the mystery of it all

@DdKk-uc4ek 3 месяца назад

I am currious how you mention in that relm you say it is showing voldemort's body. What about in the first movie when he drank the unicorn blood and was subject to "a half life/a cursed life" if that is coming into play.

@ShriyaditaSS 3 месяца назад

I’ve never understood the concept of sacrificial love. Cause when Lily does it for Harry, it is active till he turns 17. This was also something debated on the Alohomora podcast. Would the protection have been just as powerful if Voldemort had attacked the Potters when Harry was say 10? And why is it that when Lily sacrifices herself for Harry, the protection is active only till he turns 17, but when Harry sacrifices himself for Hogwarts, everyone including adults are protected from Voldemort?

@torquin1720 3 месяца назад

next what if idea. what if harry potter decided to go on at kings cross afterlife

@rebekah4761 2 месяца назад

I tried to find out if the shirt was on a clearance sale and it isn't available in the shop.

@General12th 3 месяца назад

Hi J! Do you get a set bonus if you carry all three Hallows at once? Maybe a 10% bonus to movement speed?

@ginnyjollykidd 3 месяца назад

Besides Voldemort giving Harry the opportunity to _choose_ death or not, which is the activator of sacrificial love, I'd also like to bring up remorse Hermione said, when she discovered about horcruxes, that there is only one way to reunite a person's rent soul: remorse. Remorse for all the murders he committed. Harry said, "I've seen what you'll become." does that mean when Voldemort's horcruxes have been destroyed? Or is that the form his soul pieces take and the rest of him-the two left-will join the rest and share limbo or purgatory or in between world he's in? Harry does tell Riddle the remedy of remorse. I hope Riddle remembers it to start working on his return to wholeness. Maybe he'll learn a bit of love in the process. That in a way Harry loved even Voldemort by offering him the remedy. Even a relationship of such giving is a form of love. It's love thy neighbor. Voldemort rejected it, fired at Harry, and Harry defended himself. Even so, a gift of love is never wasted.

@Erobazai 3 месяца назад

Could you do a theory, if harry really is the master of the elder wand. Because it looks to me that Draco should still be the master. Harry was never in the presence of the elder wand when he disarms Draco. The hawthorn wand gets disarmed and that wand should change team to Potter. But the elder wand is still in a tomb in Hogwarts. If you have 2 wands and 1 gets disarmed, will the other change team too?

@crawdaddy2004 3 месяца назад

0:28 We’ve never done a “dead-icated” video on it. 😂

@brianabc83 3 месяца назад

I don't understand the last part of the video about giving Hogwarts protectors the protection by dying for them, same as his mother did for Harry. I thought it was a "love" sacrifice that gave him magical protection. I'm a little confused at that part. He certainly didn't love everyone at Hogwarts, did he?

@DigiMax1337 3 месяца назад

I’m actual of the belief that harry didn’t master the stone the stone was made by death to tempt mortals into killing them selves to be reunited with their loved ones, which is exactly what happens. I think to master the stone you have to use it and know that it’s empty and that you’ll meet them when you die a natural death, harry let Voldemort kill him because that was the only way to defeat him and he was able to do because of the encouragement from his dead loved ones. Even if death didn’t make the hallows and the brothers were just very powerful, this applies as all the hallows have an issue, the elder wand tempts all those hungry for power to kill you, the stone drives you to death, and the invisibility cloak forced the creator into hiding for the rest of his life it took multiple generations for the cloak to become myth to stop people looking for it, as presumably the hiding part of the three brothers tale has to have some truth to it so who was the third brother hiding from if not death. Anyway that was just a rant which doesn’t have much to do with the video mostly just saying harry is not master of death.

@ChosenGemInEye 2 месяца назад

5:19 Remember when Voldemort looked just like that when Peter dropped him in the cauldron and he did a blood sacrifice?

@TheDMan2003 2 месяца назад

8:20 Harry uses the cloak to enter the camp and uses the stone to get there.

@ugly-duckling123 3 месяца назад

(without watching) Well... as he went to face Voldemort, he was the owner of all 3 Deathly Hallows supposedly making him the 'Master of Death' so I would say no... Also that 'Kings Cross Station' was Limbo, neither the land of the Living or the land of the Dead, and instead of going to the latter, he went back to the land og the Living.

@sofaking6961 3 месяца назад

I'm pretty sure even if Harry didn't have the other two hallows, that just the invisibility cloak is the hallow that saves him. Since the owner of the cloak is the only one that can pass it on so that he can then welcome death as an old friend.

@crawdaddy2004 3 месяца назад

0:03 Yes

@imbincibleboss 3 месяца назад

Loved the deep dive. I think if Harry had attacked in the forest and Voldemort's wand had backfired, it would have ripped his soul from the body constructed using Harry's blood- removing Harry's tether to life. I wonder if Harry did seemingly kill him like he does in the great hall how the death eaters would have reacted? Tom Riddle dropping a mundane death to the boy he begged them all to find so he could fight one on one would be great!

@brianhill7715 Месяц назад

I do think the spectrums of Harry's family should have been with him all the way up to avada kedavra it would have made it more emotional and dynamic for the enemies to not be able to see with Harry could see

@heyfling 2 месяца назад

I always took it as Harry ends up in limbo because Avada Kedavra worked but Harry doesn't technically die because the soul of Voldemort takes the brunt of the attack. That said, like how Harry loses the piece of Voldemort, Voldemort loses the piece of Harry that he took from his blood. Which is why both ended up in Limbo but neither actually died from that attack. Which is also why the wand doesn't respond to Voldemort, because they no longer share any connections.

@mikkihesson3509 3 месяца назад

ive got a question you guys might ponder, could Voldemort have even mended his soul if he WANTED to after the first piece was destroyed? it takes feeling remorse to put the pieces back together, but even if he felt remorse when harry gave him the last chance was there anything left to be mended or was he out of luck from the moment the first one was destroyed?

@Morgyborgyblob 3 месяца назад

The Cloak *was* present at the moment in the clearing. Harry isn't wearing it, but he has it tucked under his robes. 'His hands were sweating as he pulled off the Invisibility Cloak and stuffed it beneath his robes, with his wand. He did not want to be tempted to fight' Deathly Hallows - Chapter 34 - The Forest Again

@flappi2232 3 месяца назад

I've always thought that in the forest Voldemort kills the only part of Harry he can actually kill: the horcrux he never wanted to make. So he kills the horcrux, and without Lily's protection he would have kill the whole Harry too. But Harry, being the master of the death (and the wand) and being still protected by Lily (thanks Voldy for always making the best plans), and without the horcrux part that's being destroyed, has a choice: in this limbo, he can choose the ultimate death or he can go back to life, and he bravely choose life, despite all he has ensured and all the fighting still ahead of him.

@modestasrimkus7279 3 месяца назад

pls make video about felix felicis (liquid luck). Snape have gotten his liquid luck in 6th year from Prof. Slughorn. He says himself "only one student ever brew poison of the living drought to win this award. I'd like to hear what was the situation in which Snape used his felix felicis to get his 12h of best day in his life.