Тёмный

Did the Virus Do it Or did We? | Disentangling research to come 

Vinay Prasad MD MPH
Подписаться 188 тыс.
Просмотров 121 тыс.
50% 1

Vinay Prasad, MD MPH; Physician & Associate Professor
Google Scholar: scholar.google...
Substack: vinayprasadmdm...
Podcast: podcasts.apple...
Personal Website: www.vinayakkprasad.com
Laboratory Website: www.vkprasadlab.com
Podcast Website: www.plenarysessionpodcast.com
Academic Publications: www.vinayakkpra...
Follow me on:
Twitter @vprasadmdmph

Опубликовано:

 

5 окт 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 1,7 тыс.   
@katiehollmer5756
@katiehollmer5756 2 года назад
Nailed it!! The refusal to discuss the actual safety signals has contributed massively to vaccine hesitancy. People aren’t stupid & they realize that the message “vaccines are safe & effective, so shut up and don’t ask questions” feels very dismissive and potentially sinister.
@janiekrig5232
@janiekrig5232 2 года назад
Get rid of 'potentially'! The government and cdc response is and has been sinister! It's about greed and money! Not our health.
@jessiferri2922
@jessiferri2922 2 года назад
I agree. Banks are recording record profits for fiscal year 2021 , DURING the pandemic- ?! Massive bond and buy back programs that were supposed to be pandemic aid. I saw it on Russell Brands channel here on RU-vid.
@peachBloom
@peachBloom 2 года назад
@@jessiferri2922 Russell is great. I will have to go watch that video. He is so smart and articulate.
@Acetyl53
@Acetyl53 2 года назад
Vaccines are poison and always have been. Without the pretext of preventing disease the general population never would have accepted arbitrary mystery injections given to their children. They were designed to maim and dumb us down from the start. It looks sinister because it is. You're looking at a drooling penetration fixated bunch of predators.
@ms-jl6dl
@ms-jl6dl 2 года назад
Of course. And the complete denial of something so common and simple as "natural immunity" after the covid infection. People lost their livelihoods because of that. It will take loooong time before that is forgotten. If ever.
@cooperaiken8148
@cooperaiken8148 2 года назад
Thank you Dr. Prasad. For the past 2 years I've hated hearing people say "I can't do 'such and such' because of COVID..." It's not COVID at all. It's the governmental policy.
@UncleJamie
@UncleJamie 2 года назад
The mitigation against covid has done much more damage than the virus ever could have by itself.
@Joseph1NJ
@Joseph1NJ 2 года назад
I say profoundly that's bullshit. When the spillover over hospital patients when put in tractor trailers, and healthcare was in crisis we had no choice but to mitigate things. Now, if you're a fan of Darwinism, and we should just let it have it's way, then I can't talk to you.
@mdrnfinance
@mdrnfinance 2 года назад
@@Joseph1NJ There's a difference between Darwinism and voluntary measures. The problem here has been trying to mandate measures in a one-size-fits-all manner instead of letting individuals decide which strategies are best for them. Public health is about providing guidance not about forcing people to do what you want.
@datruth4766
@datruth4766 2 года назад
@@Joseph1NJ except that the mitigation didn't do anything at all, as evidenced by Sweden! There are many more people dying from SOLVABLE PROBLEMS, like hunger, poverty related disease, war, liberals driving around in SUVs harming people with lung disease and causing lung disease, and destroying the planet which will kill everyone; nobody cares about those dying people and only care about the people dying of the impossible to solve problem which we have been unable to change no matter what we've done. You guys never cared about dying people before... don't pretend now!
@PD-iu9bn
@PD-iu9bn 2 года назад
Broken Window fallacy. Government intervenes to mitigate harm from a perceived threat, claims that the action prevented more severe damage than what would have occurred in the absence of government intervention. Everyone who can’t think critically says “thank you government, please continue to intervene to protect us.”
@Joseph1NJ
@Joseph1NJ 2 года назад
@@mdrnfinance That's a MAGA attitude, and you've completely missed the point.
@jessiejb4684
@jessiejb4684 2 года назад
Thank you for your honest commentary through this craziness. Respect. I just felt like sharing I’m a 36 yr old unvaccinated female. I was originally vax hesitant, unsure of risk vs benefit for myself. But now I find myself principally opposed to getting the jab because of the mandates and demonization coming from every level. Notice the lack of health based considerations (however if I felt at higher risk, that would weigh heavily). Even worse, I’m now question on all vaccines, have zero trust in CDC, FDA, and public health officials, not to mention big pharma. That sounds crazy to say, even to myself, but it’s honestly where I’m at. I can only imagine how many people share these feelings. From the top down, they have created the politicization, demonization, and shown to be untrustworthy time and time again, without any accountability. The damage is vast and ongoing. Our country has some serious reflecting to do but many are not there yet, and I seriously worry we will never get there.
@clownsleftjokersright7027
@clownsleftjokersright7027 2 года назад
Anyone paying attention and delving into this pandemic have the same conclusion! We have all been damaged by the media, medical and political institutions!
@lisag1153
@lisag1153 2 года назад
Here's one who shares your feelings exactly! I was already distrustful of big medicines and big pharma, now I distrust it all, even my own doctor.
@feralgypsy8353
@feralgypsy8353 2 года назад
@@lisag1153 agree. I hope People will now wake up-it is our turn now. Just think if a large majority of people simply did not enter any building, company, restaurant that mandates vaccines how quickly this would be dropped. VAX or UNVAX you know what it doesn’t do. You know it’s not proper to force. You know there’s no benefit to it being forced. Take back human rights make a choice
@Gr8flGrrl
@Gr8flGrrl 2 года назад
You are not alone! What this pandemic has shown us is how deep and wide the corruption really is. It had infiltrated every level of government, academia, science and medicine!
@sara_sofia_1984
@sara_sofia_1984 2 года назад
I lost my faith in the medical system after I got damaged by the tetanus vc. at 21 and I had no idea that could happen, totally confident in it... The fact that people are waking up to the reality of the system is a good thing. It has always been like this, it is just so much more obvious now.
@kathrynann375
@kathrynann375 2 года назад
I didn’t skip the jab because of politics of poor marketing. I don’t consent to participating in an experiment that has no long term data.
@milenalm5288
@milenalm5288 2 года назад
I can honestly say that politics had ZERO to do with my decisions about vaccination. It would be extremely foolish to let poltics dictate people's medical decisions. Those who berate others for refusing to be part of this experiment and claim it's due to politics are just as foolish.
@alexanderb5644
@alexanderb5644 2 года назад
@@milenalm5288 I'd argue that ignoring the political element that has shadowed every step of this bug is very much relevant. Operation Warpspeed is a govt program, quarantines and mandates are politically fueled, pharmaceutical solutions are taxpayer funded.
@davidprice9792
@davidprice9792 2 года назад
My wife and I live in Nicaragua. The schools here never closed and businesses never closed. Public transportation continued as normal. Yes we had more deaths than usual in April,May and June of 2020. But by July of 2020 things seem to go back to normal in the hospital. A friend of my wife's had surgery for cancer right in the hospital that was supposed to be bad. Her surgery could have waited 6 months. Hospital here are free so they are always full because people go there instead of the doctors office because it is free. So if our hospitals are over run in the Last year and a half some one in the states are lying. We have kids not wearing masks and kids have been fine. I have been going to local markets where people are packed in and there isn't a problem. Anyone who ever rode Public transportation in Central America knows what i am talking about. We have been fine but the media still has people here scared.
@TraceyMush
@TraceyMush 2 года назад
That's all good to hear. l often wonder if there are places that go on as normal and how that works for them. lt makes me angry that politicians think they can outwit a virus, and make us all suffer in their moronic efforts. Thank you for the information.
@ashleyhayes7568
@ashleyhayes7568 2 года назад
Thankyou for this. Never hear about your Countries and how you have fared. I suspected the reason "why" could be you were doing a lot better than expected Sounds as though the original virus did its dash amd then subsided. Herd immunity was established. In highly vaccinated Counteies it seems the vaccine has interfered with the natural progression. Allowed new variants to break through and prolong rhe pandemic.
@gigstrail7180
@gigstrail7180 2 года назад
Did they have early diagnosis responses there?
@davidprice9792
@davidprice9792 2 года назад
@@TraceyMush i had posted videos on Facebook in 2020 where the local markets never closed. That is where thousands of people go everyday to buy and sell. A lot of the people get payed daily so if they don't work they don't eat. I went through these markets asking why are these people not getting sick. It is face to face some of it is outside and some is inside. Trust me there is no social distancing. Things are that way today and it always has been. I can go do a video anytime.most of the fear pushing is all a lie.
@davidprice9792
@davidprice9792 2 года назад
@@gigstrail7180 no
@francischaput2723
@francischaput2723 2 года назад
I 100% believe that our response to the pandemic caused more death and misery than the pandemic itself.
@georgemead6608
@georgemead6608 2 года назад
The pessimist in me feels it is more sinister. I cannot accept that the active suppression of treatments was a good faith attempt to protect people, but rather to protect profits.
@floatingleaf9672
@floatingleaf9672 2 года назад
It has been planned for a very long time. They just didn't know if they'd get away with it. I hope not💫
@sirmoke9646
@sirmoke9646 2 года назад
*so far. Because humanity will pay for this for decades.
@scrout
@scrout 2 года назад
Especially banning alternative treatments....criminal.
@theotheronetoknow5828
@theotheronetoknow5828 2 года назад
The "response" wasn't to a pandemic.
@AdrianagiselaFMS
@AdrianagiselaFMS 2 года назад
What about the “vulnerable” people on their seventies or eighties eating inside restaurants and having a good old time while children can’t take their mask off even out in the school yard? Also, deaf kids who rely on facial expressions to make sense of the world and communicate? It’s just unfair and illogical policies! I’m with you in this one. Keep raising awareness in this 👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽💪🏽
@fredd629
@fredd629 2 года назад
Awesome comment
@-Thunder
@-Thunder 2 года назад
This has completely proven that top down authoritarian Gov't doesn't work and appears to drive a portion of the public totally crazy in their fervor to become agents of the State.
@PS-ek2lw
@PS-ek2lw 2 года назад
I feel exactly the same about that! I just had do move daycares for my 2 year old son, they enforced a mask policy for all ages with the exception of infants. It’s simply terrifying!
@anthonyhiscox
@anthonyhiscox 2 года назад
@@-Thunder Well, that's unfortunate. Considering we just created a large group of people that will be suffering and more than willing to give up their rights and power to the government just to get a scrap of meat thrown their way. Something that I personally have believed was the plan since the beginning.
@ricknash3055
@ricknash3055 2 года назад
The heavyhanded moronic overreach of authoritarian government and health officials defies their supposed pedigreed credentials. Someone needs to run their diplomas through a paper-shredder.
@kevintroxell7571
@kevintroxell7571 2 года назад
This is exactly what my family is living through right now. Both my kids, 4 and 10, have been sent home because of being exposed at school. My youngest is required to stay home for 10 days after exposure. After a week of being back in child care, she got exposed again. So another 2 weeks at home. Meanwhile my wife and I are expected to work and to pay for child care regardless. We are lucky, some of the other kids come from single parent homes. Both my wife and I where happy to get vaccinated and boosted, and to comply two years ago, but that time is over. We will enthusiastically vote out of office everyone who continues to support these COVID measures, from President on down.
@GNpatent
@GNpatent 2 года назад
My 4yo daughter was kept out of daycare "cuz covid" two weeks ago, went back for FOUR days and gets "quarantined" for exposure to a "positive" case again. Two weeks of PTO down the drain and it's not even February. 2022 is shaping up to be yet another rough year. We've been spared from having to downsize so far but at this rate we're going to have to transition to single-income.
@katy9860
@katy9860 2 года назад
@@floatingleaf9672 “Left behind” how? The unvaxxed that make it through, which is like 98% or 99.08% of those under sixty will get Covid, get natural immunity and be better protected than the vaxxed, whose immunity wanes. Yes, please leave the unvaxxed “behind.” Just go on with your life!
@kevintroxell7571
@kevintroxell7571 2 года назад
@@floatingleaf9672 Yes, I do not believe in mandates. Being pro-choice means no one tells me what to do with my body, or inject into my body.
@annapadilla4349
@annapadilla4349 2 года назад
@@floatingleaf9672 yes please! Leave us alone and just continue to get boosted to your hearts content. My entire family has had it twice. My elderly parents are still here
@sarahbreisch4750
@sarahbreisch4750 2 года назад
@@floatingleaf9672 we all want to know, what do you men by that?
@ledpoizn
@ledpoizn 2 года назад
Dr Prasad, your "ramblings" are a thousand times more honest and informative than all the prattle on corporate media combined. You are a brilliant voice of reason amidst the chaos being forced upon us and you are making a difference. Thank you
@sasdear
@sasdear 2 года назад
I cannot agrees more.
@SUPERBRETTASTIC5
@SUPERBRETTASTIC5 2 года назад
I have nothing but respect for all your valuable insight throughout this pandemic but I would love to hear a theory why these mistakes keep on happening in one direction. The concept of corruption seems to be non-factor in any of your videos. Thank you so much for all your work.
@spocksdaughter9641
@spocksdaughter9641 2 года назад
AMEN
@jsoul6647
@jsoul6647 2 года назад
Yes!
@stevendamon7309
@stevendamon7309 2 года назад
I suspect he feels that if he points out the corruption, he will be deplatformed. We have to do this for him in the threads and hope it gets through the algos.
@thankmelater1254
@thankmelater1254 2 года назад
He's a Progressive. That carries a certain amount of inherent dishonesty and self-deluding.
@nicknack9398
@nicknack9398 2 года назад
We all have to pick our battles. Those "corrupt forces" to which you may or may not be referring could still hold great power, if this be the case then one might think it prudent to walk a fine line. Just playing devil's advocate, sometimes a little subtlety is needed to thread the needle.
@agathahofmann6977
@agathahofmann6977 2 года назад
as an ICU nurse I can say I am traumatised by everything that happend at work: my patients lay alone in a room and when I needed help because they took a turn for the worse I had to yell for help through an intercom, but sometimes everybody else was in a room with their patient and they couldnt just run out. And then your other patient had an alarm as well bit you couldnt see them. And all of this with an FFP2 restricting your breathing during stress. And how I was shut out of restaurants and stuff because I didnt have a QR code... And all of this for a virus that is exactly like the flu. Wtf! I am done with most people and certainly not going back to the ICU.
@TheRealHonestInquiry
@TheRealHonestInquiry 2 года назад
Can you confirm the data I have seen that shows the influenza "disappeared" as in cases dropped something like 98% and was "replaced" with C0\/1D?
@harunmusa8693
@harunmusa8693 Год назад
The Koolaid drinkers are a danger to us all... 👀
@qualm43
@qualm43 2 года назад
Having JUST recovered from covid, I can say that being infected was the LEAST inconvenient part of the pandemic... And I'm "unvaccinated".
@skilla69
@skilla69 2 года назад
Agreed. Im unvaccinated. Felt a little crappy while working out for a few days in early January. My fully vaccinated and boosted girlfriend that i live with tested positive 2 weeks ago and was bedridden for 4 days, and continued to test positive for 7 days, while i myself did not
@summerneverends1569
@summerneverends1569 2 года назад
Agree completely everyone’s different but yeah I agree
@johnkline1790
@johnkline1790 2 года назад
my son had it - was fecked for three days - extreme fatigue sweating - 1 week off work - back to work - as a bricklayers labour - very physical - he is at Gym now lol
@sarahbreisch4750
@sarahbreisch4750 2 года назад
@@sassyt1545 But maybe not. I had that one. I'm not super young or super healthy or super smart or super proud. But I'm still super alive and well..
@dwightcarlson7136
@dwightcarlson7136 2 года назад
@@sassyt1545 how do you know it wasn't delta?
@DonnDeVoreMusic
@DonnDeVoreMusic 2 года назад
Nearly the entire population of Portland, Oregon are wearing cloth face panties outside in the sun on a windy day acting like it's March 2020 as if that actually worked, scorning others who don't follow the fashion trend. I guess they didn't see the news update about the ineffectiveness of their face decoration.
@jeanninecanino9452
@jeanninecanino9452 2 года назад
I have a friend who was diagnosed with an early stage breast cancer. They canceled her lumpectomy because she tested positive for COVID. How is this ok??? As a breast cancer survivor, this infuriates me. How is COVID trumping cancer?
@floatingleaf9672
@floatingleaf9672 2 года назад
Cancer money will still be there when the covid money has dried up.
@sora4440
@sora4440 2 года назад
My mom is a two time breast cancer survivor. Once in 2003 and then again in 2015. I was talking to her the other day and said that if she had got it a second time during the pandemic and they postponed her surgery due to her testing positive or due to offices closed or any of our own draconian measures, I would have went John Q on everyone...
@jeanninecanino9452
@jeanninecanino9452 2 года назад
@@sora4440 Yes, I think I would have lost it too! Glad to hear your mom is 2 time survivor ❤️
@fairwayinc6552
@fairwayinc6552 2 года назад
A man in need of a heart transplant, and next in line, has been denied this life saving measure due to being unvaccinated.
@soulfireonfire6423
@soulfireonfire6423 2 года назад
@@fairwayinc6552 Who ever denied him should lose their license and forbidden to practice for the rest of their lives.
@bizzo1954
@bizzo1954 2 года назад
I am glad you talked about Sweden. I live there. When it started and they decided not to close the schools, Anders Tegnell said that the data does not support it. When people keep pressing on him he said to check back in a year.
@reginaford8575
@reginaford8575 2 года назад
He told the truth!
@cantstandya157
@cantstandya157 2 года назад
Let's just set aside the fact that Sweden's death rate per capita is 7-10 times Norway, I guess it depends on your definition of success. What people seem to be missing here is every country, every city is different, you can't just take Sweden's policy and plop it into New York city and expect the same outcome. Different age demographic. Different co morbidity. Different housing structure. Different psychology. Why not look to some states in Australia like Queensland, South Australia and Western Australia, who have had minimal death, minimal lockdown and almost no school time lost. Why don't we hold them up as the Gold standard pandemic response? Because it's probably not possible for other countries to implement the same policies or to have the same outcome even if the exact same measures were taken. There is nuance here that seems to be overlooked.
@bizzo1954
@bizzo1954 2 года назад
@@cantstandya157 You are right. Every place has different conditions. When I look at the countries around here, what I see is this. Denmark had a school winter break two weeks before Sweden. They went skiing in the Alps and had a great time. Two weeks later Swedes went skiing in the Alps (Just when it was exploding in Italy). They came back sick. I know this because some of my friends got it. Norway has no winter break. Can Sweden's numbers be just bad luck?
@cantstandya157
@cantstandya157 2 года назад
​@@bizzo1954 In my opinion sacrificing a ski holiday in a pandemic is a bit of a first world problem that could have helped limit the spread, on the other hand people will say that it impinges on their freedom. I don't know the intricate detail of how Sweden handled the pandemic, could they have had stronger border control, better quarantine, protected the age care and nursing homes better? I'm from Australia so I know what worked here to minimize death and keep kids in school, in most cases, short strict preventative lockdown (3-4 days to a week in most cases), rigorous contact tracing, strong border control, strong quarantine. I think it's possible Sweden could have used some of these measures early on as I think Sweden and Australia are similar in many ways, but I could be wrong. The states that failed in Australia were Victoria and to a lesser extent New South Wales who waited for it to get out of control then implement long drawn out lockdowns that destroyed business and enforced home school for long periods of time. They also had poor nursing home structure and a leaky quarantine system due to employing the wrong people for the job and incorrect information from the WHO on how COVID is spread - I mean they still thought it was predominantly spread via contact when it was clearly evident it was aerosolized.
@MaxGreis
@MaxGreis 2 года назад
Thank you Dr. Prasad for expressing a voice of sanity, in an era plagued with irrationality & sensationalism.
@ZeeMan84
@ZeeMan84 2 года назад
I'm so happy that Vinay is being red pilled. Thank you for opening your eyes and mind Dr. Prasad.
@jonesfactor9
@jonesfactor9 2 года назад
The media isn’t talking about healthcare, the general poor health of Americans, how we can become healthier to lessen things like we just went through. No one is talking about the studies and data from around the world. The US is pushing shots and shots alone. It’s infuriating.
@dwightcarlson7136
@dwightcarlson7136 2 года назад
Here in Canada in the province of Quebec, they are now forbidding unvaccinated from shopping in big box stores such as Walmart and Costco. The premier of Quebec suggested he would place a special tax on unvaccinated who end up in hospital. He doesn't threaten a similar tax for obese people entering hospital even though it is one of the main cobormidities for COVID patients. This all in the light that vaccinated get infected and spread COVID just like unvaccinated. And likely more because they falsely believe they are invincible.
@Acetyl53
@Acetyl53 2 года назад
By "the US" you mean "God's Chosen". They always do this when they take over. Look at the Soviet purges and Holodomor. They love to maim, kill, and extermiante anything that is not themselves. And they always will because it's genetic. The only non-violent solution is systematic and forced interbreeeding.
@mka6245
@mka6245 2 года назад
@@dwightcarlson7136 Governments are always placing special taxes on stuff like cigarettes and alcohol, and some cities have tried to implement taxes on the junk food that leads to obesity. So this is not totally unprecedented
@-Thunder
@-Thunder 2 года назад
@@dwightcarlson7136 Trudeau is a totalitarian. The jab has nothing to do with health. It has everything to do with control.
@dwightcarlson7136
@dwightcarlson7136 2 года назад
@@mka6245 but not on individual persons based upon health treatment choices
@dragonslayer69420
@dragonslayer69420 2 года назад
Finally a public doctor who does a serious cost benefit analysis and not the faucian prevent virus at all costs method
@asnark7115
@asnark7115 2 года назад
Fauci was NOT about preventing the virus. That would have been cheap and easy to sanction for the CDC. Fauci was about pushing one vaccine as a platform for multiple NIAID patents/royalties and expanding policy into mando adult vaccines of every kind available; attaching those records to financial and licensing eligibility. Go Fish.
@personmcperson5740
@personmcperson5740 2 года назад
Policies have been far more destructive than the virus, especially when we take into account death rates more than 10 times less than advertised, as the UK stats revealed.
@toddr3644
@toddr3644 2 года назад
Interesting study out of New Zealand, which effectively had no COVID, showing all-cause mortality rising immediately after the vaccine went into distribution and mirroring the rollout.
@alicejones9031
@alicejones9031 2 года назад
I agree
@alicejones9031
@alicejones9031 2 года назад
I'm feeling like this conversation is about 18 months late
@yamishogun6501
@yamishogun6501 2 года назад
@@alicejones9031 22 months too late.
@marcstudent7797
@marcstudent7797 2 года назад
@@toddr3644 where can one find this study?
@mtmg3648
@mtmg3648 2 года назад
I have said this from day one. How I, with only a BS degrees in cell biology and organic evolutionary biology, could call this before our nations leading "experts" is beyond me.
@migsmigs87
@migsmigs87 2 года назад
We will all encounter the virus. Mandates aren't working. I had it back in Dec 2020. Vaccinated summer 2021. I just had mild case of Omicron two weeks ago during a lockdown in Ontario, Canada. I've only left the house to go to the grocery store. I completely agree with you Vinay. I plan to not forget and be vocal that it wasn't the virus but the policies for the economic, mental health and education issues we will be facing very soon.
@josephgutschmidt4718
@josephgutschmidt4718 2 года назад
Those of us who were sounding the warnings in April of 2020 are glad people are finally paying attention. While it is tragic that so much unnecessary damage has been done, hopefully we can prevent it from getting worse. Most importantly, we need to make sure this can never happen again. "You can't comply your way out of tyranny"
@natalieroy4849
@natalieroy4849 2 года назад
My husband and I are from Ontario and we haven't seen our family since 2019, including our aging parents. We wanted to visit this summer and attend my niece's wedding but travel Covid restrictions are preventing us. I hope more and more Canadians speak up. I support the trucker convey.
@yunu9439
@yunu9439 2 года назад
I wish I could continuously tap thumbs up. Unfortunately, I could only tap once.
@RubbingElbowsLLC
@RubbingElbowsLLC 2 года назад
We must start acknowledging natural immunity also. It is real. We must also acknowledge the role of comorbidities. I’m in my mid 60s with no comorbidities other than age and had Covid in February 2020 and a bout of omicron recently. I never came close to being hospitalized. Omicron came through in late December, early January. Everyone was sick, including the vaccinated. Many of them were sick for weeks. I don’t know of anyone hospitalized from either camp but of course there were some. I’m from NJ where sick people were put into nursing homes during the Covid outbreak. These people were the most most at risk when there were other options available. We knew that elderly people were most at risk from the data coming from Italy and Spain at the time. We also knew children weren’t as susceptible to it as were adults. We knew this from the Swedish data. We must stop this over reaction and get back to life. We know so much more now.
@AdamSmith-gs2dv
@AdamSmith-gs2dv 2 года назад
You must be so jealous of those of us who never gave a damn and still never got this thing. Idk why or how, only explanation is asymptomatic infection because I don't see any way that I have avoided exposure for two years with no precautions unless forced
@thomasstapel6824
@thomasstapel6824 2 года назад
You mentioned that policy have caused many life altering changes. For example my wife and I have just both retired in early Jan just before covid started-2019. We have both been waiting and planning on traveling and dreamed of many trips we were to take - the first would be Santorini. Well of course 2 years later and we'll still waiting. I am 74 she is 70 and I was just diagnosed with CKD stage 3. Thank god its looks like it has been not progressing, but this puts a sense of urgency and frustration to are long held dreams together. Its so frustrating see so many people submit to so many life altering restrictions in the name of safety. Do they not see they are throwing these years away. And in our advance age stage of life these constraints amount to a significant percentage of what is left. Its maddening...
@rebeccabenson6922
@rebeccabenson6922 2 года назад
Yes they see
@genieonfirevisionquest8229
@genieonfirevisionquest8229 2 года назад
Stop waiting and live you life right here and now. No matter where you are I'm sure there are beautiful places to see and experience. God Bless You
@alaron5698
@alaron5698 2 года назад
It's people like you that end up being used as the excuse for all this. All done to protect you, or so the story goes. Never mind whether you asked for that protection or not.
@wakemewhenitsover3021
@wakemewhenitsover3021 2 года назад
I don't understand how people continuously say masked faces are no big deal. It is impossible to meet new people, 1/3 of faces covered ...shrouds peoples moods, personalities...our facial expressions play a key roll in deciding to bravely start a conversation with people we do not know. My daughter is a junior in high school now in CA- the only reason she is okay is b/c she still has friends she made in middle school and a couple new ones from first half of freshmen yr of high school. School closed for a year and a half- and while she is back in school in person- no one has made NEW friends like we all normally did...as we ALL evolve during adolescence as we experiment with defining ourselves and our individuating process. THIS normal, healthy development is not happening with everyone's faces covered. Those who are fortunate to have a pre-existing circle of pre-covid friends/ support systems are okay, but STANGANT. My son is a first yr college student who lost his entire last years of high school...pivotal period of time lost. As a late bloomer, he went from 5'4" to 6'3" in his bedroom during zoom school. He never got to experience his sports in his bigger, stronger body- he never got to navigate the needed social development everyone needs to gain confidence and become comfortable in ones own skin...all of these things affect life trajectories and decision making. How is it possible that influential people do not know this?
@rorykahneisenberg5299
@rorykahneisenberg5299 2 года назад
I feel your pain, I have a college junior and a high school junior here in NY which is mandate central. The college kid left for her freshman year, came home for spring break and never went back. She languished in her room for a year and a half doing a joke of zoom classes and eventually transferred to a school closer to home. By the time she had an in-person class she was a junior and decided to dorm just to meet people. Covid didn't steal her college experience, Governors Cuomo and Hochul did. Even now with the ridiculous mandates for the NY state college and school systems the kids are being screwed out of normalcy. My son is an avid musician who missed performing with live bands both inside and outside school and missed 2 summers of elite programs in and around NYC because everything was closed. He finally performed right before Omicron hit with a select group of musicians from around the state, on a stage, masked. These kids that have to blow through the mouthpiece of an instrument for hours really fast, and not pass out, so horrible. My son's window closed for many music programs he waited to be old enough to apply to, either they are virtual, not happening at all, or he has aged out of them. My heart weeps the most for the high school and college kids and all that they lost, not to Covid, but to these Draconian policies that early on labeled them as the age group that needed to save the world from super-spread.
@poodledaddles1091
@poodledaddles1091 2 года назад
N95 masks ARE oppressive, anyone who says otherwise is sitting in front of a box fan in 68 degree climate controlled room.
@jonathanlin66
@jonathanlin66 2 года назад
Many influential people, especially in NY and CA, who decided restrictive policies for the "good" of the people chose to ignore these restrictions in favor of going about their business as usual and deciding the same for their children as well. It's really been a classic case of "rules for thee, but not for me".
@hisservants8003
@hisservants8003 2 года назад
@@poodledaddles1091 Even then you cannot breathe! It just cannot be good for the brain or body, esp with children!
@vladimirofsvalbard9477
@vladimirofsvalbard9477 2 года назад
You're going to have a wave of dysfunctional children that are highly disproportionate in anti-social disorders. Unfortunately, they will probably be known as the 2020 babies. If you're a child that was 2-4 between 2020 and 2021, then there is a disturbing probability that they will suffer from some kind of anti-social personality disorder. Children need to see faces, expressions, and interaction. If they don't between that golden age of 2 to 4, then their socialization is going to be forever maimed. I wish parents understood this before having children. Trying to raise a child in a masked environment and letting them play on a tablet 8 hours a day is absolute child abuse.
@twhdvm
@twhdvm 2 года назад
My 9 year old daughter had COVID last week. Mild headache and fever that lasted 24 hours. Next day she was fine. But she had to stay home 5 days and was allowed to return to school as long as she wears a cloth mask for 5 days (otherwise sh would have to stay home 5 more days). The dumb school policy (based on the nonsense CDC guidelines) has disrupted her life more than COVID has. But here is the real idiocy of our school's policy - had she tested negative she would have been allowed back to school the next day, no mask. If she was unable to get tested then her only requirement would have been to stay home until symptoms resolved and then return to school with no mask. Yes, actual adults wrote that policy. It's lunacy. So, we're just not testing our kids any more.
@ms-jl6dl
@ms-jl6dl 2 года назад
Message : do not test your kids unless realy necessary
@laurakyplain2413
@laurakyplain2413 2 года назад
Does a child who gets sick, have to get tested and show prove to go back to school; doctor visit?
@AdamSmith-gs2dv
@AdamSmith-gs2dv 2 года назад
So just don't get tested then?
@twhdvm
@twhdvm 2 года назад
@@laurakyplain2413 No
@lizkeith1356
@lizkeith1356 2 года назад
have you seen the video on Rumble with Senator Ron Johnson as he holds a conference with physicians from around the country/world to discuss the pandemic and covid ? long, enlightening video that all physicians should see. just saw it last night. wow.
@stevecatlin5609
@stevecatlin5609 2 года назад
There are at least 38- 40 different therapeutics being used around the world by countries that have no access to vaccines or mRNA drugs. We should be discussing this as well as natural immunity and other considerations which vary the severity of the symptoms (ie IgA levels, blood type, genetic variables, blood type, overall health and comorbidities, etc.).
@ms-jl6dl
@ms-jl6dl 2 года назад
Steve,you sound reasonable. There's no place for people like you in today's society.
@stevecatlin5609
@stevecatlin5609 2 года назад
@@ms-jl6dl Thank you, that is the nicest thing anyone has said to me in a long time (I guess my degree in philosophy paid off- finally, lol).
@jbailey1898
@jbailey1898 2 года назад
And discussing what we can do to get the vaccines to those who do not yet have access!! I cannot believe we are this far into the pandemic and we’re STILL not focusing on a world vaccination effort. This is utter foolishness.
@stevecatlin5609
@stevecatlin5609 2 года назад
@@jbailey1898 Fortunately, there are vaccines being made by other countries- Cuba as an example- that are effective and are not being made to make a profit. They will be available for poorer countries, rather the Pfizer drugs, which range from $11- $20 a dose depending on the country. And I do believe that in those contracts, richer Nations cannot donate their doses to poorer ones, but I could be wrong.
@TraceyMush
@TraceyMush 2 года назад
YES, we should be discussing how to treat covid, both at hospital and at home!
@jessehansen9212
@jessehansen9212 2 года назад
Unfortunately, the damage has been done. The fear that was built is now hard to let go of for those that believed in our public health response. Any shift in public policy will now come under fire and doubt by those hardcore believers in the apocalyptic view of this disease.
@floatingleaf9672
@floatingleaf9672 2 года назад
These people need a "slap" back to reality. Tell them they are being propagandized. Tell them they are supporting tyranny. Would you watch someone suffer from a mental health episode or would you help them snap out if it?
@jessiferri2922
@jessiferri2922 2 года назад
That's their problem. Personal paranoia cannot be catered to by policy. Forced vaccines have made been illegal by the Geneva Convention since WW2. its also against The U.S. Constitution, The U.N. Charter etc.
@nooa69
@nooa69 2 года назад
@@floatingleaf9672 I would like to volunteer to deliver that slap. 😁
@jessiferri2922
@jessiferri2922 2 года назад
@@silentnot4812 completely right. In fact some of the numbers are these ; 'Big pharma like Pfizer, Merck, J & J spent over $62 billion dollars combined in 2020 on lobbyists, twice what they spend on research and development.
@josephgutschmidt4718
@josephgutschmidt4718 2 года назад
The damage has been done, yes, but never underestimate how much more damage can be done if people permit it
@karendelgado7923
@karendelgado7923 2 года назад
One of the things that drives me crazy are rules that do not make sense. My high school son had to have surgery and miss a few days of school but was not allowed to participate in virtual classes. Only kids that had covid are allowed to access virtual classes. That is so stupid.
@ms-jl6dl
@ms-jl6dl 2 года назад
🙈 Sorry!
@deathofpoptart
@deathofpoptart 2 года назад
I wish people thought for themselves instead of listening to whatever the media tells them to do.
@stevendamon7309
@stevendamon7309 2 года назад
That would require courage.
@ck1893
@ck1893 2 года назад
Thanks so much Dr. Prasad for articulating so well what I see and feel in my medical practice in Chicago. I see women who are young and hope they never have to go back to work in person… they’d rather stay home on Zoom because they’re afraid when they don’t need to be. I see women gaining massive amounts of weight because they just stay home.. they gave up their gym membership because of Covid. I see depression, anxiety, faces with no expression behind the masks and wonder if they will ever regain the ability to express. I see lots of senseless anger against the unvaccinated and try my hardest to encourage compassion.. even families are broken apart over differences of opinion on vaccines… in 5 years will it have been worth it for people to have lost touch with their families over a virus that everyone will get? I am very lucky that I have continued to enjoy my life over these 2 years… I travel a lot, I go surfing every chance I get, I laugh a lot. Just wish my patients could find their joy also.
@jsoul6647
@jsoul6647 2 года назад
I work in a hospital that yet again changed their policy to no visitors....I disagree with this policy and for a moment I felt it was going against my own moral and ethical values...I had to see past the policies, hospital ceos, etc and focus on my focus of serving the community as a nurse...We've had no remote, we go in day in day out and serve ...teachers need to show up and focus to teaching children, just like the guy at walmart who shows up to scan your items to get a paycheck to feed their families ... The virus is going nowhere, the public needs to show up for each other and upcoming generations effected...
@margotbw4660
@margotbw4660 2 года назад
Its not even the policies, its the shaming and mental games some are inflicting on their fellow human.
@jlushefski
@jlushefski 2 года назад
When I was living in NY, I could play basketball outside, too. However, I couldn't go in a restaurant, museum, many retail stores, chess club, gym. An establishment could deny me on its own, and perhaps that would be irrational yet acceptable, but don't tell me it's somehow broadly supported, or "democratic," when all of these establishments do it only after a mayor mandates it. A major reason why people are so polarized on these issues is that for many, what they hear is in extreme contrast to what they experience. How many people say something like, "I don't personally know someone who died, but I know someone who know does." So...what is the point? ...that because the virus merely exists anything is justified? Well, I hate to sound insensitive, but I know many people who have died: from brain cancer to heart attack, from car accident to razor scooter accident. Where & why is this absurd vision of the world originating & spreading, where certain people think they are not only entitled to enact any policy regardless of collateral damage, but they think are even capable of eradicating it through their policies? Of course it is the policies that caused us the most harm, not the virus itself, but it isn't as if you can have a reasonable discussion anyway... ...When you actively deceive and hide data (take the somewhat recent CDC/Kaiser paper statistics as an example), my trust is gone. I don't look at your next batch of results, or later-released data from a previous paper, and give you the benefit of the doubt. Even if I don't plan to use Iver*ectin, I know someone is a liar when repeatedly referring to it as a "horse de-wormer." Ignoring, and even suppressing, any discussion on ferritin/iron labs, calcidiol, parathyroid hormone, aspirin, povidone iodine, vaccine induced platelet factor-4 activation, vaccine induced increases in sFAS or IL-6, spike protein binding pocket linoleic acid affinity, etc...is not the behavior of an investigative scientist, but that of a propagandist.
@mka6245
@mka6245 2 года назад
"take the somewhat recent CDC/Kaiser paper statistics as an example" which ones? Can you give a link? I agree that constantly calling the anti-parasite drug "horse dewormer" is bullshit- it is a human medication, and there are many human medications originally studied for one purpose that end up being useful for a different purpose. I.E. asprin is a pain medication also used in low dose for its blood thinning effects, beta blockers are prescribed for both heart conditions and anxiety. If doctors have a good medical reason to think that an off label drug will be helpful, it should be studied in trials, and doctors should have the right to prescribe the drug off-label in the absence of evidence of harm.
@jlushefski
@jlushefski 2 года назад
@@mka6245 It was the paper that compared non-covid mortality between those who had covid vaccine and those who had no covid vaccine but who did get a flu vaccine within the last two years. One, why not release total or even covid mortality data? Two, wtf is that [clearly retroactive] group selection?! Funnily enough, the only [weak] argument the mandate fanatics have left, that of "irresponsible hospital resource consumption" (herd immunity is not acceptable considering symptom variation and transmission of vaccinated), was actually countered by the CDC non-covid mortality data, which supported confounding variables that should already be obvious...unless one thinks covid vaccines are somehow working wonders in non-covid health contexts.
@SasukeUchiha-zu6dw
@SasukeUchiha-zu6dw 2 года назад
It's the safety at all costs folks/the end justify the means. We see the same thing with gun control, the goal posts will always shift they are never satisfied.
@doomsdaybooty1072
@doomsdaybooty1072 2 года назад
Fully agree. I'm starting to see certain doctors look at all cause mortality between the jabbed and unjabbed - this is the ultimate metric by which to ascertain the value of the vaccines. So far, from data based out of the UK, somewhat surprisingly, data suggests higher rates of mortality in the jabbed group. If this is true, and if the world is ultimately a just place, this data will raise serious questions about the safety and efficacy of the vaccines. I'm not holding my breath
@jlushefski
@jlushefski 2 года назад
@@doomsdaybooty1072 A "conspiracy" minded person could interpret that sort of damning data as too obvious & luminous, which is why there is such a strong push for vaccination rates well beyond 90% in many countries or country subgroups. Considering symptom variability and recovery numbers, there is no reason to think "herd immunity" requires some ridiculous 99.5% vaccination rate or something--and of course we're not seeing "immunity" anyway. However, going from 70% to 99+% vaccination rate certainly hides polarized rates of other problems [myocarditis], as there is no longer a control group.
@bastardferret869
@bastardferret869 2 года назад
11:20 "people who are over zealous and don't want to discuss safety signals such as myocarditus in boys in a certain age group... are inadvertently feeding the 'other side' who feel as if information is being suppressed.: You know, there's another way of working this, "there are people who are concerned that information is being suppressed - and they're absolutely right. It is."
@AbyssalManta
@AbyssalManta 2 года назад
The biggest thing about 2020 onwards for me was this: before 2020, I had a pretty high degree of confidence in History. Sure, I always knew History was at best a "Soft Science"; there is no way to independently verify Historical claims to the same extent, the same way you can with the Natural Sciences. But at the same time - call it naivete - I didn't imagine there would be a concerted, malicious, high profile attempt to subvert it. That seemed too far fetched, too "Conspiracy Theory" to me. Imprecision, earnest error, sure; deliberate malfeasance, rare at best, and of course readily countered by the plurality of voices, by the free marketplace of ideas. I will readily say it now. I was a fool. I see today what the status quo will BRAZENLY, in your face lie about; things that I can see myself right before my eyes. I see how - initially to my total perplexity - they can get away with it. I see how they can drown and intimidate and silence dissenting voices - no matter how numerous. I can fully imagine what the historical records will say about the events of today, 50 years into the future. And when I say anything about it, that will be the senility talking, of course. This has been a paradigm shift, as far as social phenomena are concerned, to me. I now realize the time before I was born is a hazy mist. It's IMPOSSIBLE to know anything about it beyond the barest of generalities. And the less you're allowed to discuss a subject, the more likely it is that the official narrative is a deliberate fabrication.
@Salta0monte
@Salta0monte 2 года назад
The time before you were born is a hazy mist... and so is much of the history that happened after you were born. One reason why a lot of issues are readily classified as 'conspiracy theory' is that, to take them seriously, you have to believe that govts and media are willing to collude in telling really big, whopping, gigantic lies about world-changing events. It might be worth going back to some of the really big events in your own lifetime to see if there's another take on it out there, that's been suppressed in part simply through the conspiracy theory label.
@toddr3644
@toddr3644 2 года назад
Note how the masses are pacified with electronic widgets like this little phone.
@JuliusSP1
@JuliusSP1 2 года назад
The V. does not E.
@ms-jl6dl
@ms-jl6dl 2 года назад
Same here. Right on,brother.
@doomsdaybooty1072
@doomsdaybooty1072 2 года назад
Well said. I've never in my life experienced such a wholesale loss in public institutions, in 'science,' media, government, public health. Apparently there is nothing so sacred they wouldn't propagandize and lie about it. For me, the denial of early treatment for covid with safe, cheap, antivirals - simply because they are not under patent and not highly profitable - at the expense of hundreds of thousands of lives, was what broke me. They've continuously preached that there is no early treatment and vaccines are the only solution, even while half the bloody world has no access to the vaccines and successfully treats covid with antivirals; I see this happening, I watch how western nations have the highest covid rates in the world, despite our high rates of vaccination... and they still have most people convinced that only right wing idiots would take 'horse dewormer'... it's hard not to lose faith in our leaders and institutions. I've damaged relationships with many dear friends attempting to calmly discuss data and statistics, because of the non stop intensity of these disinformation campaigns
@Caneyhead123
@Caneyhead123 2 года назад
“We can’t let the cure be worse than the disease” I heard someone say once
@whatevergoesforme5129
@whatevergoesforme5129 2 года назад
And it is not even a cure.
@liberteus
@liberteus 2 года назад
Given that I live in Quebec, Canada, I now can't: go to a Costco, Walmart, home Depot, best Buy, staples etc etc etc, I can't travel at all (no boarding planes, train, boat), so no leaving the country for vacations, family visit etc... We still have a rule that says we can't have more than 8 people in the same house, and many other asinine rules all over the place...
@ms-jl6dl
@ms-jl6dl 2 года назад
Go Canada. If you leave the country there'll be some problems though -- nobody speaks canadian. You better prep.
@descendingoncewhile
@descendingoncewhile 2 года назад
Before the pandemic, I was financially stable, had the best friendships and relationships of my life, was physically and mental healthy, loved the place I lived, etc. Now I am broke, mentally and physically unwell (things other than/unrelated to covid), longing for valuable relationships, and hate the place I live. I got covid, and recovered quickly with no issues. Covid didn’t do this to me, the government did by locking down.
@ms-jl6dl
@ms-jl6dl 2 года назад
You are not alone. There are millons of us like you. Try humor,irony and toungue-in-cheek speak. Do not confront people,go with the flow,amplify their positions to absurdity so they start feeling uncomfortable,start "hunting",stop being prey = you might find it amusing. Know what to expect in advance,go with it overzealously in protest,comment cynicaly,praise inappropriately... have fun. You are the creator of your own world. Let fools be fools. Stay strong and good luck!🙃
@potion7410
@potion7410 2 года назад
I’d love to hear your take on the decline of ICU beds since 2018 due to how the people in charge of them see them as a waste. Keep up the videos I’m so glad I found your channel :)
@AdamSmith-gs2dv
@AdamSmith-gs2dv 2 года назад
2018? The decline has been going on for over 50 years we had more ICU bends in the 1970s than we have today
@vm4554
@vm4554 2 года назад
I just sent my state legislatures letters to limit government agencies from imposing draconian "emergency" measures. These failed government overreaches need to be reined in so it never happens again. Hopefully, this becomes a movement across the country. From what I see, people are waking up to these injustices. Top-down mandates have done more harm than anything the virus did.
@leonardpersin9694
@leonardpersin9694 2 года назад
Plz seek out medical leadership for our country, we need doctors like you to regain confidence in our healthcare system
@liquidthens
@liquidthens 2 года назад
Knowing what we know now, was the Barrington Declaration a better choice?
@gooberthoreau
@gooberthoreau 2 года назад
Hate to tell Chris this, but I don't feel that a well-off media personality's life is a fair litmus test for the average American experience. Virus or no virus.
@lindas.1751
@lindas.1751 2 года назад
I have been thinking this often lately; I like Chris but, boy, he's All In now on the policy business of the virus.
@machinethesun9243
@machinethesun9243 2 года назад
The Care Act is the problem. Schools receive federal funding but in order to receive the funding, they have to comply with the stipulations such as contact tracing and sending kids home. So principals now spend their day doing contact tracing instead of doing their job. Counselors are handing out testing kits instead of doing their job. These policies are higher up than individual schools.
@reginaford8575
@reginaford8575 2 года назад
Give the monies back
@machinethesun9243
@machinethesun9243 2 года назад
@@reginaford8575 they can't. Their hands are tied. If they want to stay open they need funding. Local taxes don't cover the costs to run a public school. Hammering teachers, principals and schools only leads towards privatization of all schools and then only the rich will be able to pay for their kids to get educated. Not everyone can afford $20,000 - $60,000 a year tuition per kid.
@stevendamon7309
@stevendamon7309 2 года назад
Fear Uncertainty Doubt FUD These are the three pillars of counterintelligence propaganda. This situation seems to have been custom built to exploit these things.
@terepueblas
@terepueblas 2 года назад
Thank you so much Dr Prasad, you have opened the eyes of so many people that were blindly following the media and gov mandates, all lies are slowly falling apart. Go truckers convoy !
@floatingleaf9672
@floatingleaf9672 2 года назад
The excess deaths report in Canada shows clearly that accidental poisonings (overdoses) is where the excess is. Not covid.
@kathleenkirchoff9223
@kathleenkirchoff9223 2 года назад
Thank you for exploring more side of these issues than the usual media from either side. As a public school teacher Pk -6 I a Title 1 school, I can tell you the insanity of our protocols will be crippling children for years to come.I lost 3 former students to suicide and drugs. I can't say for certain it was pandemic related but the social emotional state of all my students has been tragically different the past 2 years. For those Pk and kindergarten kids that is half their lives without normal socialization. I worry what super bugs we have created with all the sanitizing. I know it spiked my high BP working Ina mask, so what was happening to those oxygen deprived kids who were lethargic instead hyper like usual kids. So sad.
@williamsgang4437
@williamsgang4437 2 года назад
Ignoring the many who are recovered and therefore have powerful protection was a red flag for me...I do not want an injection that does not have a meaningful benefit for me (recovered) + the known and unknown risks is something I must consider.
@sarahsophia4070
@sarahsophia4070 2 года назад
A wonderful commentary; thank you for sharing. I certainly agree that many people are not ready to have a conversation around exactly what evidence supported the enforcement of these highly destructive political policies... However, that conversation is a seminal part of the discourse -- and I worry that we will not be having it in time...
@patrickmace5340
@patrickmace5340 2 года назад
Our response has caused this. But that's what we get for playing God and creating this in a lab, then thinking human interference would go any other way than it has since. We need to stop playing God.
@dwightcarlson7136
@dwightcarlson7136 2 года назад
Here in BC Canada, I find the mask wearing so amusing. Most people still wear the simple cloth or light blue/white 'surgical' masks which are are shown to be zero and 5% effective respectively. Some media reports are actually finally pointing this out. But when I go thru the drive thru at restaurants, who also have inside dining, I see those sitting down eating without the mask in place for obvious reasons but people who walk in for a pickup must and do wear a mask. It would all be hilarious if it wasn't so ridiculous. 😛😛😛😛
@thisisrob8750
@thisisrob8750 2 года назад
That's not true that the blue masks are only 5% effective. Please state reputable sources medical sources such as a CDC that say that. They are definitely not as effective as n95 no doubt. Put your hand 6 in front of your face and cough and you can feel the air pressure on your hand and possibly moisture. Put one of the blue masks on and do the same thing you can't even feel the air on your hand. The cloths masks are the worst no doubt and the n95s are the best and that's what we should all be wearing but it does still help. Omicron unfortunately is so contagious that masks are not a guarantee at all with it but if I had to walk into a room full of people with covid and I had a choice to wear no mask or one of those blue medical masks I'd put it on. Even a better example would be to say put your hand 10 in front of your face and spit on it and compare that to putting the blue medical mask on your hand will be dry. They're not perfect but it's better than nothing
@AdamSmith-gs2dv
@AdamSmith-gs2dv 2 года назад
@@thisisrob8750 The Bangladesh study? It showed 10% effective not 5% still not nearly enough to warrant everyone wear them. Also any mask might as well be no mask if you have poor fit and almost everyone does
@katy9860
@katy9860 2 года назад
Damaging the young to protect a bunch of 80 yos.
@brianbachmeier34
@brianbachmeier34 2 года назад
Exactly. Can't believe this is happening. The UK released some documents last week I believe and the average age of someone who did from C19 was about 82. That is the average age of death anyways.
@vivienmartin9661
@vivienmartin9661 2 года назад
What I find quite incredible is that no one asked the "anti-vaccers" if they had access to a traditional style vaccine ("dead virus vaccine") would they then get vaccinated. And that none of the big Pharma companies in the OECD (except France and Japan) made any effort to make traditional style vaccines which, if I am correctly informed, would have taken less time to produce than the mRNA vaccines AND without all the side effects which have only come to light AFTER the vaccines were rolled out, never mind the long term side effects which will become evident in the years to come.
@MagnificentDevil
@MagnificentDevil 2 года назад
There has been historically a problem with inactivated virus vaccines with Corona viruses, where the vaccines typically make the disease worse as the antibodies are inferior to natural infection, and thus allow the virus to sneak past the immune system. This is called Antibody Dependent Enhancement. This can be seen in the attempts to make a Zika virus vaccine which went horribly wrong. There is some amount of evidence this happened with the mRNA vaccines as well, which were alleged to not have this problem, but the full truth remains to be seen.
@reginaford8575
@reginaford8575 2 года назад
Biiweapon in pocket if China
@amandabartley8847
@amandabartley8847 2 года назад
You can know about what Would happen if the schools only had the sick child stay out and didn't test or anything... But you would have to check ask the private schools.. In the fall of 2020 we switched to a private school that did just that...and you may say that it's not comparable because private schools are smaller than public school, but I would argue that when public school went back in the fall of 2020 (in our same area), the classroom sizes were comparable because half of the kids remained virtual. Public school had masks, shields, plexiglass around their desks, etc... Our private school stressed cleanliness and communication. If you were sick, stay home. When we heard a kid had come down with covid, we were notified if they were in our classroom, and we all monitored our children to see if they had symptoms. We never had a major outbreak. In each classroom (of roughly 12 children), there were never more than two or three kids out at once for sickness. It wasn't and isn't that this private school didn't or doesn't care about covid or even spreading covid... The school just found a sensible answer. As for the local public school, they had to do completely virtual several times when originally they were scheduled for in-person classes. I can't say that it was because they had more outbreaks or just because of the policy. I can confidently say, my children are not behind in school because of this, but it's very upsetting knowing so many of their friends that couldn't afford to go to private school are.
@stevendamon7309
@stevendamon7309 2 года назад
In a refeudalized world, well educated serfs are not necessary.
@sarahbreisch4750
@sarahbreisch4750 2 года назад
Wow, do your kids go to the same school as mine? Exactly the same. Private school was in person for the entirety of last year while our local public school were hybrid and there was so much back and forth for them, poor kids. I think a huge part of the success of in-person learning for our kids was the proactive parents who were willing and able to keep symptomatic kids home.
@sarahbreisch4750
@sarahbreisch4750 2 года назад
@@stevendamon7309 Terrifying and accurate, thanks
@denisekruczyk6847
@denisekruczyk6847 2 года назад
My greatest regret is that I was unable to pull my kids out of public school. My daughter went from straight A student to depression, on meds and failing
@PD-iu9bn
@PD-iu9bn 2 года назад
While not the same thing, our church opened up shortly after choosing to honor the state’s request to close down. As we consulted legal and medical experts and felt like we understood that the perception of risk was being exaggerated, we opened back up. At first we made sure to limit capacity and encouraged people to CHOOSE FOR THEMSELVES what protective measures they might want to take if coming to an in-person service, but always with the caveat that “we cannot guarantee that you won’t be exposed to a virus.” Two years later, most everyone has gotten Covid at som point (not necessarily at the church. In fact there was never an ‘outbreak’) and we’ve lost I think three or four congregants to Covid (or with Covid). In two years. At a church of (now) over 7,000 people. And all of them caught Covid outside the church building. This is with a HUGE number of kiddos in kids classes. No masks. I see what the schools are doing and it’s difficult not to be very upset.
@steveyjay8657
@steveyjay8657 2 года назад
I've been telling my associates this for the last few years now. The "virus" didn't cause this...the virus doesn't make policy or ill-informed decisions... We humans do.
@Tylervrooman
@Tylervrooman 2 года назад
Watching you go from 45k to over a 100k is good news, thanks for the updates. We appreciate you. I literally share every video you make.
@tallard666
@tallard666 2 года назад
yet the Twitter algorithm is blocking him. His pinned post (where I places all articles) was stuck at 2K for the longest time, then a quick jump to 4K, then back to 3K
@patrickgalligan7770
@patrickgalligan7770 2 года назад
You exactly laid out what was going on around me in minutes 2-4. A friend of mine with 2 kids in high school had 1 kid that had to stay home for 2 weeks because someone in his class got COVID. Her other kid could continue going to school and the administration didn't stop to think he'd have contact with his brother. Stupid.
@theroamingsavage8813
@theroamingsavage8813 2 года назад
Great video sir! All of this in combination are what a lot of us have seen and have protested against. Thank u. When i see ppl outdoors alone at a park with masks on, u can tell its a psychological trauma at this point over anything else
@Starfield_Eclipse
@Starfield_Eclipse 2 года назад
As a parent of a 7 year old with a learning disability, all I have is rage at this point. I'm going to go lift weights till I feel better about it.
@ms-jl6dl
@ms-jl6dl 2 года назад
Tide is changing. Keep it up.
@wishiwasinidaho4780
@wishiwasinidaho4780 2 года назад
Well, when you take into consideration that we funded the virus in the first place, I think you could call all virus effects a result of our own policies.
@GetIntoTheBLACK
@GetIntoTheBLACK 2 года назад
Sad part is policy said we shouldn’t have funded that research.
@agnesp8710
@agnesp8710 2 года назад
You should get Denis Rancourt on. His arguments echo the measures themselves are responsible for the majority of deaths. His arguments are backed by one of the most comprehensive statistical analysis done to date.
@tallard666
@tallard666 2 года назад
In Armstrong, BC, 7 of 300 elementary students were mask-exempt, and TEACHERS doing their fear-porn thing have "stayed home" and caused the school to shut down due to "lack of staffing". Teachers have become a real problem.
@memeticist
@memeticist 2 года назад
Teachers are becoming a problem on multiple fronts. Schools of education have been prioritizing the religion of intersectionality over the actual nuts and bolts of education for many years now. This produces agents of indoctrination instead of educators.
@harryparsons2750
@harryparsons2750 2 года назад
in a lot more ways than just the Covid stuff. Makes me cringe and sick to my stomach just thinking about it
@johnorourke7484
@johnorourke7484 2 года назад
The level-headed approach is the best you are a great source of info you're not taking a side just common sense. Also, you are a Doctor with tons of experience very much appreciate your videos
@stevedolesch9241
@stevedolesch9241 2 года назад
We caused the disruptions.. We create polices that don't make sense. I would go further, policies are destroying lives not the virus per se. Vinay, I agree with you because I see the same.
@georgemead6608
@georgemead6608 2 года назад
And that is without factoring in what the suppression of early treatment has done, (which IMHO will ultimately be found responsible for most of the deaths being attributed to C-19).
@ulrichenevoldsen8371
@ulrichenevoldsen8371 2 года назад
Corrupt and paranoid politicians are to blame.
@wernerboden239
@wernerboden239 2 года назад
"We" did not do any of this. If any average Joe would have a say, the world would be a better place. But we do not have any say in the matter. It's the corrupt, power hungry, greedy who are on top of things. You could call it natural selection in politics.
@matthewneal7011
@matthewneal7011 2 года назад
I really appreciate how respectfully and humbly you approach the data you research and review. Its refreshing and I would hope our society and our politicians would begin to do the same. Cheers!
@ashfield1425
@ashfield1425 2 года назад
Love the energy from this guy.
@jabiblewalker
@jabiblewalker 2 года назад
Loved how you differentiated between what is being blamed on the Virus and what is actually just ‘blind and bad’ policies that people did. The virus is what it is, but we are responsible for how we respond to it. Much can be learned after 2 years and all the various reactions; now fair minded people needed to take ownership of what was just error in judgment. Time to learn and move on. Pity if all this and no one learns anything or is humbled.
@HortenseMueller
@HortenseMueller 2 года назад
Thanks for articulating this so well!
@isaacwhull
@isaacwhull 2 года назад
I read one of Carl Jung's books years ago where he compared the indulgence of European and American governments in populous protection. He stated Europe treats their populations as if they're rather stupid while (and admirably noting) America enshrines its population with every dignity of intelligence. Gustav Le Bon has already dispelled the notion that a Jury of 'sophisticated' jurors is better than the Rabble, it is not, the Rabble is as capable to make judgements as the self-inflated aristocracy.
@zuzuspetals9281
@zuzuspetals9281 2 года назад
Unfortunately, in the US we now have a ruling aristocracy that thinks just like the European elites and lower-class rabble that indulge them pitted still against the freedom loving independent rebels who resist government control over every aspect of their lives. We’re once again in conflict over the right to chose over government ruling us or citizens ruling themselves through government. We the people will prevail.
@preciousissah7395
@preciousissah7395 2 года назад
GOD bless you Dr VINAY
@Adrian-yi8fl
@Adrian-yi8fl 2 года назад
11:23 yep it turns out, systematically suppressing information makes some people "feel as if" information is being suppressed!
@JamesHuntingtonBed
@JamesHuntingtonBed 2 года назад
Batt Sibrel has been saying this for a year and a half. He uses the metaphor as a car driver saying “I hit those people on the sidewalk because i had to swerve to miss a squirrel, it’s the squirrels fault” or something like that. Bart is a very smart guy
@livingitup9647
@livingitup9647 2 года назад
Excellent points about this spectrum of ever-changing, inconsistent policies -- which seldom are based on data driven, risk vs. benefit ratios. It's stunning that the majority of the US population still believes in most of what the official narratives, from only the sanctioned sources, continue spouting. And this 'follow the leader' persists even after 2 years of witnessing the consequential damage to our economy, and to many lives, wrought by said policies.
@jamesturnbough3695
@jamesturnbough3695 2 года назад
Great video, it's time to move on. Let people govern themselves. If you want to wear a N/K95 mask all day everywhere then do it. Just don't get mad when you see my smile.
@eneveasi
@eneveasi 2 года назад
Dr Vinay Prasad! I believe you might be a perfect person to have a discussion will the likes of Dr Robert Malone and Dr Peter McCullough. There is NOT enough scientific debate between those looking at the science and gaining different viewpoints. They are leaders in their standings and you are a leader in yours. Please please please make it happen because OUR world NEEDS this in long form!!
@joshw6562
@joshw6562 2 года назад
The problem is that if you do anything but witch hunt them, you get lumped in with them. There is no room for actual discussion, debate, or analysis of data - There is THE TRUTH™ brought to you by SCIENCE™ - and all else is heresy and to be shunned.
@morgantaylor517
@morgantaylor517 2 года назад
@@joshw6562 True, I've seen so much hate especially directed towards Dr Malone, what did he say that they find so awful?
@johnz8112
@johnz8112 2 года назад
Vinay dropping that knowledge!
@hollylovepeace
@hollylovepeace 2 года назад
My son was sent home for 5 days due to "potiential exposure" makes the 2nd time this month, it is a struggle to keep up with his classwork. We "potientially" expose ourselves to everything and anything every day. When will we look at these ridiculous policies and realize they are more hurtful than helpful more-so with school-age children?
@amygolds2435
@amygolds2435 2 года назад
Thank you for always being so down to earth and so filled with common sense. I wish more Dr’s were like you. Thank you! ❤️🙏🏼
@chriscrowell6678
@chriscrowell6678 2 года назад
have been following your channel for a while now and in my opinion you have hit the nail square on the head. you pretty much laid it out , this is EXACTLY the point we are at
@Anastasia91000
@Anastasia91000 2 года назад
Thank you for mentioning Sweden. It is being ignored by regular "media", and I'm using that word loosely.
@ImNoclue
@ImNoclue 2 года назад
I think Sweden is a good example. The country reported 10 deaths attributed to COVID in those under 9 during 2021. In those 10-19, that number is 5. I'm struggling to see any evidence that changing their policies would have reduced those numbers, but maybe it's out there.
@feralgypsy8353
@feralgypsy8353 2 года назад
Thank you for this discussion. I have said since day one, covid did not do as much harm as the government policies did. And continue to do. Hoping more will see the difference.
@nickimoto007
@nickimoto007 2 года назад
It’s so nice to see Vinay finally coming around. Seeing him open his eyes to what we’ve been saying from the beginning is like watching your child master a new skill. I think he had the problem of been too intelligent for his own good when this started but the awakening is wonderful to see.
@kieranbrennan7350
@kieranbrennan7350 2 года назад
Huge respect to you, Mr Prasad, you are one of few sane voices in an utterly insane time. You can always say you spoke your truth, which is more than 99% of the 'useful idiots' in academia and corporate medicine...
@davidparkins1808
@davidparkins1808 2 года назад
An elegant analysis. Thank you!
@aime8588
@aime8588 2 года назад
“But when I would be out there alone, by myself on the western ridge, I would ask myself, why am I wearing this 🤣🤣🤣” Thank you Vinay! You are such a sage, intelligent being! It is so extremely comforting listening to your messages
@amyhowell5198
@amyhowell5198 2 года назад
How many Mistakes make a pattern of choices? Allen
@beatgreens9530
@beatgreens9530 2 года назад
LOVED this one! I was trying to make this exact point to people but I obviously don’t say it as well as you do because they just didn’t get the difference. Thanks again for sharing your perspective!
@hammejharris267
@hammejharris267 2 года назад
I soooo love your honesty and transparency. Good luck in everything you do.
@JamesSaine
@JamesSaine 2 года назад
Dr Prasad, thank you. I just discovered your channel. I am an RN who believes many of the things the CDC has done in this pandemic. But I have also been shocked by some recommendations by the CDC. Thank you for non political, critical thinking, evidence based assessment and analysis. We need our thought leaders to be…. Well very good and the best thought leaders. Thank you again.
@brains8305
@brains8305 2 года назад
I got covid the other day, the way I got it is my brother got it so I had to be quarantined because we live together. All I was thinking is why can't I stay somewhere else so I don't get it but the policies are that I have to stay in the house with him thus giving me covid 8 days later
@ArkadyItkin
@ArkadyItkin 2 года назад
Vinay has the patience of an angel taking anything from MSNBC seriuosly and discussing it so respectfully.
@joestergios6557
@joestergios6557 2 года назад
I admire Vinay's equanimity as he tries to articulate his frustration. People who are propelled by their fears have succeeded in foisting their idiotic plans on everyone else. Worse, even though their strategies have clearly backfired, the answer is even more madness. I correct people constantly when they blame disruption on "the virus-" it's our reaction that has done 10x damage.
@wayward-saint
@wayward-saint 2 года назад
Thank you for voicing a nuanced view. I’m in a similar position as a family physician. I also give voice to the benefits of vaccination, while also voicing concern for over reaching, unscientific policies and media spins.
@twinpop8392
@twinpop8392 2 года назад
Thank you Dr. for bringing up policy issues that affected all of america , please research on early treatment suppression . I need clarity on this for my family , thanks a bunch love your content.
@dwightcarlson7136
@dwightcarlson7136 2 года назад
If he even mentions the drug who must not be named, he is liable to get kicked off yt. Sad but true.
@janiekrig5232
@janiekrig5232 2 года назад
Brilliant observation and ability to communicate! It's what we've all been thinking but you put it to voice. Thank you! God bless you and your family!
@kathydouglas8262
@kathydouglas8262 2 года назад
Thanks for your insight! I don’t care what Dr. V’s political views are. I feel he, for the most part, steers away from that. He’s always been upfront of where is political views lie. He also isn’t a liar and seems to give us the truth. I also love how data driven he is. There is truth in data for sure (as long as it’s not corrupt data).
@jasonlambert2226
@jasonlambert2226 2 года назад
I appreciate your insight. I'm not enthusiastic about the vax at all and the safety signals aren't suppressed so much as flat ignored. EUA, therapeutics downplayed, pharmacist not filling scrips, mixed messaging from the political/science class and general overrelyance on one solution was suspect, as well as obvious lying about the data.
Далее
这位大哥以后恐怕都不敢再插队了吧…
00:16
This 1 Thing Can Replace Our Entire Medical System
9:14
Noam Chomsky - Why Does the U.S. Support Israel?
7:41
Abilify Causes Chemical Lobotomy
1:11:19
Просмотров 326 тыс.