Severus, purple is a mix of 2 colours, and we have 3 colour receptors in our eyes(normally) which detect magenta, yellow, and cyan. Therefore without the red, we will see things without the reddish element
Hagrid didnt watched Lily death that was Sirius he take Harry out of the House but he give Harry to Hagrid, when he tall him that Albus said that he should take Harry
I remembered I saw a meme on this, it was before Lily died m, she said “Can you give me a minute to change into my fav blue shirt? Please, I want to wear that when I die” and then there’s the scene of her dead “thanks”
Dude when Hagrid was explaining to Harry he was telling him the thing it was from Hagrid's mind that lily might have wored purple sweater and in snape's scene then lily was actually wearing blue sweater Moral of the comment: Hagrid was just telling to Harry how his mother died and Snape was actually present there 🙂
I'm sorry but thats not a mistake, its a brilliant detail. Hagrids memorys are based on things he has been told, so things like a shirts colour could not be accurate. Snapes memorys details are correct coz he was there, so everything in his memory is exactly how it was.
Hagrid wasn't there and when he got there the house was destroyed and she was dead, so his memories are likely made using some of his final times seeing them alive whereas Snape actually saw her and the home. We don't even know if haggrid had been to the house before their deaths or not. So he could be filling in the blanks of the home. There will be a reason behind it.
And how its a different type of sweater (the blue one is more like a smock/dress with leggings) , she's aged 10 years between scenes (obviously due to films being made so far apart but come on! Lily was 21 when she died and Geraldine Somerville was in her thirties in the first film anyway!) , the nursery is different and the house itself is also different 🙄 Some things I love so much about the films, like Alan Rickman's acting and the gorgeous Hogwarts castle sets, but others just had no love or attention to detail. Like the new director went "sod continuity from film one, let's dress Lily differently and put her in a different house I doubt anyone will notice or care"
@@qwuack hi, yeah I get he'd remember her differently (no problem there really) but it's a bit of a stretch that he'd remember the house and surrounding area so differently! :)
Another mistake when Lily died she had wavy hair, maybe shoulder length, but in Delphi hallows part two ghost head, curly side, part neck length hair lifted curled to the side did she get her hair done ?
When hagrid explains , it his version of the story ad Harry just imagines the story. But snape's memory i something like a recording. Harry just imagines her wearing a blue sweater 😊
Baby Harry also appears to be wearing different clothes too. In TPS his clothes are light blue and have stripes. In TDH his clothes don’t have stripes.
I think maybe the clothes didn't fit anymore or went missing since you must remember this was filmed years later in 2011 while the one she was wearing was a different thing in the first movie was made in 2001. So either the clothes didn't fit and were out of stock or the clothes went missing over the years
Something that also doesn’t make sense with this scene is where she is at the door with Harry in her arms, she shuts the door infront of Voldemort, goes over to the crib still with Harry in her arms as Voldemort breaks down the door. But there is a scene where she talks with Harry in the crib about being “safe and strong” then Voldemort kills her in 2 different ways, when she is near Harry’s crib, and then when she is near the doorway.
“Wait, Voldemort, just one moment, I don’t want this outfit to be my death outfit. Can I just change real quick? Oh, and by the way, don’t hurt Harry!”
Snape knew what happened because he was there, but Hagrid wasn't. Hagrid only told Harry a recount of the well-known incident, but he obviously wasn't present during it.
Hagrid wasn't there at the time of Potters demise. We are seeing his version of the events. Also the duration between both the films is roughly 10 years and hence expecting the makers to mind such minute details is truly mind-boggling.
Hagrid probably recalled the sweater wrong as it wasn't important compared to what else was going on that night But Snapes memory shows the truth because he could never forget a single detail about lilly she was his only love he never got to be with.
It’s possible Slughorn explained it. The Fish Lily gave Slughorn disappeared when she died. Is it possible that her Clothes can change color when she’s dead?
Did you not notice the hair? When Hagrid was explaining how Harry’s parents died we can see that lily’s hair is straight but in the deathly hollows/snapes memories her hair is curly
Voldemort- “Step aside you silly girl!” Lily- “Wait i must get a change of clothing first, i hate this shirt, oh and please don’t hurt my son” Voldemort to himself- “Seriously Severus, you want me to let her live!”
Plus they kept saying harry had his mother's eyes. But harry and his mother didnt have same eye color. Harry and his father had same eye color. His mother has a child had brown eyes.
I mean.. Hagrid was just telling a story about it. He wasn't personally there. Snape was. So it's not necessarily a mistake. Plus I doubt Hagrid would tell Harry details like what color was his mother's shirt when she was dying.. the scene was basically just how he imagined it.. but Snape was actually there, he saw her and held her in his arms.. it was his memory..
This is because this was there conversation Lily: Wait Voldy I just bought this new blue sweater can I change quick Voldy: Of course gotta look good! Lily: Thanks
