Different View of Generosity [mlp animation] 

If it's manipulation of minerals, perhaps she was using her own bones to make more things

This was dark. Especialy realizing it was after Different View of Memories.

Thanks for this explanation

basically shewas too kind

The fact that that's going to scar her for life sure but she's going to have to tell her parents what happened to rarity that's going to be harder for her because she's basically a kid. Poor Sweetie Belle.😢

OMG how does this have no replies

This is a great amount of work being put in to this video, and hey LittleShyFiM!!!

Me too!!! And I love Littleshy!!!

Exactly. When you give everything, you lose everything

While it is meaningful to give to others, you must be cautious to maintain yourself and not give so much that you break. If you break, not only are you broken, but you can no longer give help or meaning to others. Even if you feel like there is always more to give, you must maintain some for yourself. That allows more generosity for both you and others in the long run.

Your song/chant went so well with this indeed man!

Basically.

Though, to be clear, this is what Rarity has always done Just with the less tragic tone, that, she dedicated her life to helping others, asking nothing in return. Interestingly enough, her loneliness is fairly plainly spelled out in the show, and her dying alone is implied. Though neither is emphasized and drawn attention to. A lost friendship lesson, if I do say so myself

That's pretty metal

She looked at the crying child and smiled...

The sudden jump from scenes at the start makes it seem like it was her being overly generous as she planned to kill herself anyways, especially with the eye twitching somewhat after the half way point

Наелась и спит

In a previous part of this story, she had to kill Spikezilla with a ruby sword. -> She could allow herself to be "super-generous" because she was planning on killing herself soon anyways.

@@adolfodef That sound about right but I think suicide won't solve anything plus she still has Sweetie Bell need to take care of

@@NyxRMbrony Does she? (In the "Prime" Timeline) -> Sweetie Belle lives with her parents (she only visits Rarity). Why would it be so much different here? [ it could, but again... if not shown...]

@@adolfodef Take care of isn't the words I was going to type that's my mistake. I was meant to type "plus she still has Sweetie Bell who care a lot about her more than anypony else" for some reason I didn't type it right maybe because I just woke up and my brain is still want to sleep.

I agree.

Was that a pun? Since 4everfreebrony is the artist of the song?

@@denali5965 yes

YTMLP I’m glad then! I love puns!

King Westonian MLP OC that is very true!

I love that verse. And you're not wrong :)

spike is dead, as a result of becoming a giant unrecognizable rampaging monster in a darker world where ponies are stronger fighters and rarity's self-defense capabilities don't end at "annoy your enemies until they start bowing down just to make you stop."

Also, love the quality and the depth of the animation!

Я тоже, кстати, привет русским!)))

Я только не поняла, из-за чего Рарити погибла, об этом говорится в песне?

​@@mby.2391 , В песне не знаю . Но вот тебе моя трактовка анимации . Рерити после убийства Спайка не отвернулась от своего элемента , а скорей наоборот - всё больше и больше начала делать подарки другим . По началу это были лишь драгоценные камушки увеличенные и ограненные её магией . Но когда она сама обеднела , она не удержалась и решила сделать подарок в виде скрипки которую она сотворила из своего хвоста . Этот поступок стал точкой невозврата . Она осознала , что владеет ещё одной гораздо более сильной магией - магией трансформации живой плоти (Очень напоминает историю про магию крови из "Аватар . Легенда об Оанге .") . Будь она злодеем , она бы с легкостью подчинила мир такой силой ... Но она направила эту силу на добро ... Превращая кусочек за кусочком своего тела в новые неразрушимые камни , она помогала всё большим и большим поняшам . Что ей мешало остановиться и использовать эту магию только в самых крайних случаях ? Видимо она тронулась рассудком после убийства и эта магия в сочетании с щедростью стали её своеобразным мазохизмом , приносившим ей удовольствие и успокоение . В итоге она окончательно свихнулась (Том II) , а за сломленным духом сломилась и плоть . Простыми словами , она сама себя убила , но не просто самоубийством , а пожертвовав собой ради других .

Considering that the threat isn't being a part of the characters' lives, it's most likely after

@@nameynamd9212 I wasn't talking about threat. Rarity should have had SOME publicity after the stunt with Nightmare and Sunset. Being sponsored by Celestia for being in Harmony squad? NOTHING to pay the bills? And I... Hate this video. Generosity shouldn't be about giving, and giving, and giving until you die. It should be simply giving the last you have, not your very soul and life in peacful times. paza, can I consider this "non-canon" of your universe? PLEASE?

@@Plusle843 This looks like a sequel to A Different View of Memories, so in that way, this could be seen as her being overly generous simply from deciding to kill herself later, a different view of generousity in the case of doing something before death rather out of the goodness of one's heart

@@nameynamd9212 Hum, you could be right in this one. After she killed Spike she COULD lose her priorities just a little bit.

I actually think this takes place before. Mostly because in a different view of memories wouldn't at least a few of other members of the harmony members go with rarity to help provide back up. Or maybe a few of Celestias guard. Not to mention in this their was no way Rarity's teammates would let her over do it like this. No I think this take place before. Which would explain why Rarity was completely covering her mid section in a different view of reality. Maybe to hide the scars of her now crystalized body. That's my theory.

(\

Привет русским, а я не поняла, о чем в песне говорится?

Я не знаю но прикольно

О щедрости наверное