@Chelsea_Van_Der_Zee the Miocene is far more underrated, aside from the megalodon, nobody cares about this era despite interesting animals like Livyatan, Thylacosmilus, Platybelodon, and Daeodon being from that era
I wonder how you'd handle proto mammalian sounds. I'm not very familiar with them, nor do I know if they could produce anything like their modern descendants
You be surprised, I say don't leave room of doubt as of recent times, its discovered that humans may have developed technologically, but mentality not really, what do I mean by that? It is discovered that ancient romans have been drawing penises on walls, and believed some ancient people of the copper age, were doing that.
Depends on where on the evolutionary tree they fall. Very early synapsids, like Dimetrodon and its kin, didn’t have external ears. Not even a lil hole like reptiles, no ears at all. What would later become the ear bones hadn’t separated from the back of the jaw yet, so it’s possible that they wouldn’t have vocalised at all. Further research, as always, is necessary, but it might be worth staying away from basal synapsids for now.
@@thatkidwiththehoodietheres a species of toadlet with ears too small to function that still makes calls but they did evolve from bigger frogs with ears that worked so who knows if this is a reasonable comparison
Wow, these are incredible! I think the Triassic period is one of the most underutilized period in paleo media. And you showed me how much potential these strange creatures have just by the sounds you made! I love the Herrerasaurus' clicking sounds, and the Plateosaurus sounds a bit like a lion. The Cymbospondylus sounds incredibly eerie, which I like as well.
Finally! I waited for this for so long. I hope you won't limit your studies to just dinosaur times and make some Paleozoic and Cenozoic sounds as well? It would be really interesting to hear mammoths, sabertooth tigers, dimetrodons and meganeuras in your interpretation.
Saber-toothed cats would vocalize like normal big cats do except deeper, and mammoths would sound close to modern elephants but much deeper. But in all seriousness, getting to hear these sounds for the first time would be something really exciting to think of.
Great to see another video of this series! Loved the second one's clicking. I always like the idea of creatures making clicking noises for some reason. It fits that dinosaur very well.
Top notch content as always! 👍 The cymbospondylus vocalization is chilling! I feature cymbospondylus in chapter 1 and temnodontosaurus in chapter 3 of my novel but have them mute as back then I wasn't sure about the vocal capabilities. Its a shame I can't incorporate the new knowledge as the book's been published! I'll incorporate the vocalizations for future works.
@@local._. Yes. Its titled Carnian Street. The 1st chapter is set in the carnian stage. Its set in a fictional West Yorkshire city called Thewlington, follows the life of a college beauty student who lives in an unpleasant part of town. It has the vibe of an R-rated British soap opera. Chapters jump back to certain points in prehistory including scientifically updated creatures as well as some fictional ones.
@@local._. Its for ages 15 and over. But the prehistoric scenes are fine. They are in chapter 1, chapter 3, chapter 5, chapter 7, chapter 13 and chapter 15 and 16.
you are on a boat, you have a recorder and are looking for sounds in the water. 5:13 a sound is heard, it sounds like a a mix of a reptile and a whale as it bellowed through the water, then *CRASH* your boat flips, your stuck in the water and you can't flip your boat over, the speakers cable is rapped around you, the great noise at full volume. and its the last thing you hear... The End
Thank you for sharing this research! It's amazing how far we've come along since I first learned about dinosaurs in my childhood! Leaps and bounds! Let's hope to more amazing research and discoveries!
I love these videos & have watched every one and loved it! Unfortunately, the reverb & almost obviously created within editing which is perfectly fine just kills it for me sometimes with certain ones. I'd love to HEAR for example, the absolutely stomping sounds of Brontosaurus and the charging sound you'd hear from a Utahraptor before you ever saw it coming. I'd love to see something like that, love these videos! Keep it up. Also, you'd think that most predatory dinos/reptiles would be silent/try to be silent before a kill depending on which of course. Are these "calls" or sounds they make for mating display or something of that sort?
Crazy I switched to newest first comment to see if anyone was going to comment about the excessive reverb and here is the first, newest comment saying just that. Like you said, it's cool and all, but sometimes in my opinion it's too obivious and makes it sound way too much like a synthesizer. It does help to picture it echoing through a canyon or something like that but not always. But I absolutely love this stuff, just found it and am very impressed nonetheless. Cheers.
May I ask how many more videos of dinosaur vocalization studies you will post? And could you perhaps do vocalization studies for other prehistoric animals as well? Like Permian stem-mammals like Dimetrodon and Gorgonopsid? Or Cenezoic era prehistoric mammals like Basiliasaurus, or woolly mammoth or maybe even neanderthals and other hominins lol.
I think that's the first time I've ever seen a reconstruction of a Herrerasaurus with any type of filamentous integument. Makes sense, though, as bouncing a little bit back in the phylogenetic tree to pterosaurs there were also filamentous integuments.
Holy shit the presosuchus gave me chills, I'd shit my pants if I heard that in the bushes behind me. That's the last sound you hear before being eaten alive for sure
I feel like all these sounds are made in the most dramatic way. Like they were recorded in a tunnel. I don't think they would sound like this at all in nature.
Hi, the sound effects you produce are amazing! We are an indie studio creating a horror video game featuring dinosaurs and would like to ask if we can use the dinosaur sounds you produce. Of course you will be credited, let us know and great job!
I don’t know why I ended up listening to all these but my conclusion is we need a survival horror video game focused on realistic dinosaurs with realistic noises It would be horrifying lol
I've heard theories they had protofeathers, but never anything suggesting they were so heavily feathered. Personally, I'm not confident they had feathers in the first place
