Тёмный

Do Needed Services Devalue Guitars? 

Guitar Quackery
Подписаться 3,5 тыс.
Просмотров 418
50% 1

Sometimes, service that are needed to make guitars playable, will require some alterations. This gets collectors all worked up. But what's more important? To maintain playability, or to worry about perceived resale value?
Don't forget to visit the @GuitarDepartment RU-vid channel.
To support this scientific research you can...
Buy me a Coffee - www.buymeacoff...
Become a Patron - / guitarquackery
Buy Merch - merch.guitarqu...

Опубликовано:

 

6 окт 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 35   
@208414
@208414 13 дней назад
I'm pretty sure you can replace the fretboard if it gets too thin. I know that further deviates from originality, but that means you can maintain the functionality of the instrument past the lifetime of the fretboard itself.
@GuitarQuackery
@GuitarQuackery 13 дней назад
For sure. Interestingly, on violins it is much easier to remove the fingerboard. They are built with the removal in mind.
@randykalish7558
@randykalish7558 14 дней назад
There is nothing like the smell of the old wood being sanded down to an absolutely crisp, level fingerboard with new frets well set and polished in anticipation of uber perfect string action and the total shred dance to come, leaving with the feel of now having a potent tool.
@GuitarQuackery
@GuitarQuackery 14 дней назад
The way you put your thoughts into words, really sounds like poetry.
@stevesmithers7901
@stevesmithers7901 14 дней назад
Good stuff, Great point of view.
@GuitarQuackery
@GuitarQuackery 14 дней назад
Thanks for dropping by.
@Nick051967
@Nick051967 14 дней назад
Another great video. Please keep going; your channel is unique and brilliant
@GuitarQuackery
@GuitarQuackery 14 дней назад
That’s the spirit. Keep an eye on the channel, because soon I will be announcing live streams. I’m just not 100% mentally ready yet.
@jarodreddig63
@jarodreddig63 13 дней назад
Great episode. I just wanna play and work on my guitars too man, it’s weird to think what will become of them in 100-300 years.
@GuitarQuackery
@GuitarQuackery 13 дней назад
Future generations will no doubt come up with new music and new types of instruments. Guitars will undoubtedly drop in value. There are simply too many of them around.
@jarodreddig63
@jarodreddig63 13 дней назад
@@GuitarQuackery Indeed
@GuitarQuackery
@GuitarQuackery 13 дней назад
@@jarodreddig63 I guess it will be a great buyers' market for those who will wan to play old fashioned music on nearly forgotten instruments. And I guess guitar repair techs will be what typewrite repair techs are today.
@carpathus
@carpathus 14 дней назад
"I just want to play it". Spoken like a true guitarist. ✌🎸
@GuitarQuackery
@GuitarQuackery 14 дней назад
I just want to play it. Then I want to fix it. And then I want to play it again. Then fix it again. Then play it again and so on.
@guythetechguy
@guythetechguy 14 дней назад
You shouldn't need to keep resurfacing the fretboard. If it's a little uneven due to movement of the wood then it'll just move again after you resurface it. If it wasn't flat when it left the factory then I guess leveling it won't hurt. It's unlikely that some slightly out of flat fretboard surface will impact your ability to level the frets and get the instrument to play very well. Scalloped fretboards are not flat, also please don't flatten those either.
@GuitarQuackery
@GuitarQuackery 13 дней назад
You make very good points. I think there are many different reasons why techs might decide to level the boards. Let's say one tech levels it on the first refret, after finding that the board is not trued. Decades later the board has dimples from the fingers and at that time one tech might decide to fill them. After filling, the leveling should take place. So, leveling should touch the entire board. Another tech might decide to level the dimples with the board, instead of filling. But in either case, leveling took place. There might also be a scenario when yet another tech decides to use a short leveling beam to touch up just one area of the board. That might lead to another tech discovering that the board is is kicking upwards over the fingerboard extension, so leveling the entire board (again) might be what that tech recommends. There could be also a scenario where the truss rod is maxed out and a tech decides to level the board at the two extreme ends, to reduce the up-bow. I can think of many scenarios where multiple tech work on the fretboards, each having a different idea on how to tackle a refret, for different owners, with different budgets. I really don't think there is a fretboard that will stay true over the course of decades and that will never again have to be leveled. For example, if we look at an old granite stairway, all the stairs are worn down from all the foot traffic. It does take many decades, or even a few centuries of constant foot traffic, but eventually they do wear down. Again, I do think you are making really good points and I am simply presenting all these other possible scenarios. In a more ideal hypothetical scenario the guitar would only be worked on by the same tech, over many decades, but that is of course not possible. Even in that case, again, I don't think the board would stay true forever.
@markpell8979
@markpell8979 14 дней назад
Right, Doc. (My shortest comment ever.)
@GuitarQuackery
@GuitarQuackery 14 дней назад
Right on.
@susanandjasonstaal3778
@susanandjasonstaal3778 14 дней назад
Super vido! Excellent points! How about a middle path, do as little as possible to maintain playability. When I need to refret I go to Guitar Quackery! And I ask for the fret board to be perserved never to be planed, cause it makes a difference on the feel of the neck and if one is prone to injury can cause strain, trigger tendonitis.
@randykalish7558
@randykalish7558 13 дней назад
Sports Injury or repetitive motion injury is most often due to muscle adhesion that goes unaddressed before and after activity. Pro guitar hand/arm stretches involving myofacial release have spared me from being palsied by the fury of my guitar playing. I'm 72.
@GuitarQuackery
@GuitarQuackery 13 дней назад
I think if you have a 1 inch thick neck, it is less likely that the fretboard would need to be planed. On thinner necks (the so-called fast necks) there is a higher possibility that planning the fretboard will be required, due to the possible twisting and/or bending of the neck. I have had situations when I was leveling the frets, only to discover that some of the frets were losing a lot of height, on one end, because the board was uneven. In act, the guitar in this video had this problem. I was initially doing a fret Level, Crown & Polish and discovered that some of the frets would have to end up quite thin. After I discussed with the customer, he decided to have me do a refret.
@randykalish7558
@randykalish7558 12 дней назад
The thought of some new instrument displacing the Guitar just makes me crawl, inside.
@GuitarQuackery
@GuitarQuackery 12 дней назад
Its going to be some AI powered instrument, made out of plastic and a microprocessor, and a built-in battery. No skill required to play. Which will also mark the end of music lessons. Welcome to the future.
@onlyusernameleft2
@onlyusernameleft2 6 дней назад
It takes far less time than 50 years for something to be considered "vintage." I have a Russian Big Muff that that goes for ten times what I paid. I was broke from going to the bar too much and it cost less than the US made equivalent. I'm only 40 years old! What happened?! 😭
@GuitarQuackery
@GuitarQuackery 6 дней назад
I even heard that guitars are considered to be vintage if they are older than 25 years.
@onlyusernameleft2
@onlyusernameleft2 6 дней назад
@@GuitarQuackery that means I would have a vintage stratocaster if my parents hadn't sold it as a punishment for disassembling it to see how it worked! On the other hand, I gained a much more valuable, intangible skill so I think it was worth it.
@brooklynsoundgarage
@brooklynsoundgarage 14 дней назад
But will anyone notice it was slightly sanded to perfection or will we assume it was made well at the start, and after one sanding will it ever need to be sanded again?
@GuitarQuackery
@GuitarQuackery 12 дней назад
This seems to be the most frequent comment on this video. Not surprisingly, actually. As it makes sense. I already wrote a long reply to one of the comments, so I think I can just do a copy and paste here. "I think there are many different reasons why techs might decide to level the boards. Let's say one tech levels it on the first refret, after finding that the board is not trued. Decades later the board has dimples from the fingers and at that time one tech might decide to fill them. After filling, the leveling should take place. So, leveling should touch the entire board. Another tech might decide to level the dimples with the board, instead of filling. But in either case, leveling took place. There might also be a scenario when yet another tech decides to use a short leveling beam to touch up just one area of the board. That might lead to another tech discovering that the board is is kicking upwards over the fingerboard extension, so leveling the entire board (again) might be what that tech recommends. There could be also a scenario where the truss rod is maxed out and a tech decides to level the board at the two extreme ends, to reduce the up-bow. I can think of many scenarios where multiple tech work on the fretboards, each having a different idea on how to tackle a refret, for different owners, with different budgets. I really don't think there is a fretboard that will stay true over the course of decades and that will never again have to be leveled. For example, if we look at an old granite stairway, all the stairs are worn down from all the foot traffic. It does take many decades, or even a few centuries of constant foot traffic, but eventually they do wear down. Again, I do think you are making really good points and I am simply presenting all these other possible scenarios. In a more ideal hypothetical scenario the guitar would only be worked on by the same tech, over many decades, but that is of course not possible. Even in that case, again, I don't think the board would stay true forever."
@brooklynsoundgarage
@brooklynsoundgarage 12 дней назад
@@GuitarQuackerythank you for the detailed response! I had no idea other people had the same questions.
@tobbebergman7583
@tobbebergman7583 14 дней назад
Just put Stainless Steel frets on and be done with it !
@GuitarQuackery
@GuitarQuackery 14 дней назад
I’ve refretted guitars that had stainless steel frets on them.
@tobbebergman7583
@tobbebergman7583 14 дней назад
@@GuitarQuackery Sure but they'll last a lot longer than standard frets for sure ! I've had a strat with Stainless since 2005 and I can barely see any wear at all ! Keep Rockin and Fixing Instruments !
@GuitarQuackery
@GuitarQuackery 13 дней назад
@@tobbebergman7583 They will definitely last longer than standard frets. For sure most of them will never be refretted.
@Argentuza
@Argentuza 14 дней назад
Guitars are wearable instruments. When the fretboard becomes worn, it needs to be replaced. Traditional "nickel-silver" fretwire material is a joke; frets need to be leveled every six months.
@GuitarQuackery
@GuitarQuackery 14 дней назад
Interestingly, different people wear through the frets at different rates. My current hypothesis is that it must have something to do with skin type. it also has to do with the condition of the strings. Some people let their strings develop rust, which is more abrasive to the frets.
Далее
The Acoustic Guitar Setup that Can't be Done
14:41
Просмотров 1 тыс.
The Gibson SJ200 - Still The King of Flat Top Guitars?
12:30
Dissection of Gibson Robot Tuners Under the Microscope
29:26
Impossible Setup on Epiphone ES-335 Guitar
21:31
Просмотров 12 тыс.
Top Secret Guitar Warranty Service
26:20
Просмотров 2 тыс.
Why Did LEGENDARY Guitarists Do This?
15:48
Просмотров 28 тыс.
Guitar Summit Day 1 - Europe's Biggest Guitar Show!
43:22
I Thew my Gibson Les Paul R8 Under the Microscope
52:55