Тёмный

Do's and Dont's for sharpening stone use and care 

Rough Rooster Knife Sharpening
Подписаться 4,5 тыс.
Просмотров 7 тыс.
50% 1

I have put together a small list of things that I believe to do and to not do when caring for and using sharpening stones one thing that I did not put in the video that I believe is critical is Stone storage wrap them up and keep them safe do not lay them on top of each other I hope you guys enjoy this video please if you have any questions feel free to ask

Опубликовано:

 

11 янв 2017

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 62   
@williams.1130
@williams.1130 5 лет назад
Ive got some stones in route i just bought and I was wondeting the same thing about grit cross contamination watching some of these guys. Just seems logical to keep them out of the same water. Thanks for validating that concern i had man. Your vids are excellent. Ive been binge watching them throughout the day for several days now.
@roughroosterknifesharpenin5531
William Sleight awesome thank you. And I believe this to be accurate
@WhiteSandsMbuna
@WhiteSandsMbuna 9 месяцев назад
I have an inexpensive arkansas combo that is lapped to perfection, that has livved in water miced with simple green for over a decade. That cuts fast and clean. Ballistol emulsified 20:1 also does wonders. I have a norton india stone that has lived in enulsidied ballistol for quite a few years now
@jeffedge4871
@jeffedge4871 4 года назад
Never mind I just came across your video on how to degrease/de-oil an Arkansas stone and that answered the question-thanks for the videos!!!
@roughroosterknifesharpenin5531
@roughroosterknifesharpenin5531 4 года назад
Jeff Edge awesome! How did u like it?
@markprentice1961
@markprentice1961 Год назад
Great Information.
@rickwhitson2804
@rickwhitson2804 2 месяца назад
I took up your idea of dawn and water. I really like it way better than oil. So much cleaner than oil.
@madmike6908
@madmike6908 3 года назад
first time I heard about the dawn with water , i will give it a try. Good vid.
@roughroosterknifesharpenin5531
@roughroosterknifesharpenin5531 3 года назад
This is a old video. I'm still using it today. I'll never look back.
@peetsnort
@peetsnort 7 лет назад
Dishwasher liquid has surfactants im loving using it and am very happy with the results
@roughroosterknifesharpenin5531
Howard Petterson more u use it, the more u will like it
@dfailsthemost
@dfailsthemost 6 лет назад
I hear you about grit contamination. I'm really enjoying the hobby of hand sharpening. But I am currently in a place in which I am broke as broke can be. So I have found myself being hyper vigilant about caring for the few items I have. I've hand built all my strops, but compound ain't free. Same goes for my stones. Maybe it is OCD, but I'm going to keep at it anyway. Just looking into waterstones, so I appreciate the tip regarding soaking in separate containers.
@roughroosterknifesharpenin5531
dfailsthemost Hey man not having alot keeps us somewhat humble. its nice to have hand made things that you have created. I make the majority of mine. I know how being broke is man. Im there now. Glad to hear you are enjoying this. Take care
@jaredtyra6311
@jaredtyra6311 7 лет назад
Cool I use water just cuz I'm cheap but I gotta get into using dawn
@oldlincolnpipewelder
@oldlincolnpipewelder 3 года назад
20:18 Learn something new every day. I never even thought about it in that aspect, but it makes a lot of sense!
@williambrown8372
@williambrown8372 2 года назад
I use dawn ultra as hand soap after coming out of the shop!
@augustwest3575
@augustwest3575 4 года назад
I'm taking the hard Arkansas out of my 313 tri-stone because the India and Crystolon grit is always getting onto the surface of the hard Arkansas. Thinking about trying to get the oil out of the Arkasas and use it with water between the Dan's soft and black. Thanks again.....
@osbaldohernandez9174
@osbaldohernandez9174 3 года назад
It is true guy I renember going camping I had a stone I used water from the river and water will always overcome oil plus water isn’t as messy
@osbaldohernandez9174
@osbaldohernandez9174 4 года назад
I bought a oil stone at the flea market and I used 3 in 1 and this video makes sense the oil does and doesn’t
@roughroosterknifesharpenin5531
@roughroosterknifesharpenin5531 4 года назад
Osbaldo Hernandez don’t really understand what u said.
@roughroosterknifesharpenin5531
@roughroosterknifesharpenin5531 4 года назад
Osbaldo Hernandez but what kind of stone is it?
@osbaldohernandez9174
@osbaldohernandez9174 4 года назад
It looks brown for the rough side and red for the fine side but I told the old man what does he put on his stone and he says he uses 3 in 1 and it works good but I noticed that the oil just sticks on the stone instead of removing metal
@roughroosterknifesharpenin5531
@roughroosterknifesharpenin5531 4 года назад
Osbaldo Hernandez that sounds like a emry stone. Like emry cloth or a emry board/nail file. I’d say that thing needs a good cleaning. Then use mineral oil on it. Water will flow through it cuz it’s very porus
@bharrell521
@bharrell521 5 лет назад
What’s up rooster, love your videos man. I use WD-40 on my stones, it is a light oil that is designed to evaporate. Seems to work pretty damn good. What’s your opinion on using it?
@roughroosterknifesharpenin5531
B Harrell I personally have never used it to sharpen. But it being a lower viscosity than regular oil, I’d say it would probably work good. I still like my dawn and water though 😃 Thanks for the compliment
@mildyproductive9726
@mildyproductive9726 6 лет назад
Hey Rooster, I have a new insight on arks and flatness which I think you and your viewers might like. The first one I ever bought was a Smith hard, and I always thought it was total junk. It glazed over quite fast. Lapping it never really helped, because it glazed, again. Where the belly/tip of the knife drags across the middle of the stone and eventually digs a low spot, the stone would cut very roughly. The edges of the stone would cut very roughly. The rest of the stone wouldn't cut (it would look like a mirror, but with little holes/chips in the surface). So what you would end up with is a stone that aggressively abraded the belly/tip, but it wouldn't work on the flat. So I stopped using it. Fast forward to current. I came across a video of how Dovo sharpens their razors. They use a coticule which is intentionally convexed just slightly. I dug out this old stone (the biggest piece of it, anyway), and I intentionally convexed one side. Whadya know, the stone works, now, and it doesn't glaze, anymore. Anyways, I think glazing of stones is a little misunderstood. I have tried using this stone dry, and it doesn't slow down or glaze, now that it is convexed. Oil, no problem. Water, no problem. I am pretty confident that glazing is not caused by old oil or swarf. In fact, I can get the stone (as well as most soft arks) super glazed in no time by rubbing it against another fine flat stone, whether ark or india or SiC. No oil, no metal. The problem is if/when the stone gets too FLAT. When the surface area of contact gets spread out too much, the pressure just isn't enough to break out the worn particles. The bits of quartz just wear down to match the other points... and then this just magnifies the original problem of too much area of contact. But when the stone is slightly convexed, the area of contact on any given point is enough to prevent this from happening. I have convexed a translucent and a ceramic, as well. And for free hand sharpening of knives, I am convinced my edges are better (and easier) than ever. With the slightly convexed surface, the pressure on any given point on your edge is CONSISTENT, across the entire edge. It doesn't alternate from huge area of contact to point as you transition from straight to belly. It doesn't jump from flat to edge of the stone when sharpening the straight portion. It is just silky smooth, all the time. I'm also convinced that bur formation is reduced, soft, translucent, and even 3k ceramic. Since it's theoretically ALL high spot, there are no flats that get glazed, and perhaps there is less of a burnishing effect on the metal; and perhaps this has something to do with bur formation. The convexing need not be much. It can be essentially undetectable to the eye, and it still works. All it takes is putting pressure on the edge of the stone while lapping it, rotating, and repeating, while observing the pencil marks. The corners of the stone should be the lowest points, and the middle of the stone the highest.
@roughroosterknifesharpenin5531
Kenneth Lee sounds like to me it needed to be flattened and roughly lapped. I dont understand how the stone glazed tho? that takes alotta use. What do u mean by convexing the stone?
@mildyproductive9726
@mildyproductive9726 6 лет назад
Re: Rooster, the glazing is sorta like what you see on a shiny, polished trans/black. When you tilt the stone in the light, you can get a bright reflection. It starts in shiny streaks. (Even my flat-lapped ceramics will develop these streaks between lappings). But on this particular hard (and to a lesser extent, some of my soft) arks, these streaks develop almost instantly, and they quickly progress to cover a large percentage of the flat-lapped surface. It doesn't take "a lot" of use. Even flat-lapping this stone against an india stone can leave a glazed surface (on both stones). I have experimented with roughing the surfaces with diamond plates down to 60 grit, and even this is only a temporary and partial improvement. (And the rough lapped surface degrades the keenness of the edge you can make). On a trans/ceramic, one might like this super polished surface; on these stones it might be useful. But on the porous arks, this surface isn't contiguous. There are lots of sharp edged divots which make the stone not so good for burnishing/apexing The convexing is just what it sounds like. I rock the stone against the lapping surface to give the stone a very slightly curved or crowned surface. Because there are no flat spots to glaze, the stone wears evenly. When sharpening a flat/straight bevel, I just rock the blade against the stone, slightly, to frequently change the contact area. And I preferentially use the ends/edges of the stone (and rotate the stone, periodically, to keep it symmetrical). This is an improvement over what I did in the past, which was to round just one edge and primarly focus pressure towards that edge. What happens here is the stone wears very unevenly and starts to 1. slope towards that edge and 2. starts to dish in the middle of that edge. Lapping this out wastes a LOT of stone. Convexing the stone in all directions and rotating it while using it means you only ever have to lap tiny bits off the ends/corners of the surface to keep it in shape. I am consciously doing this now to many of my abrasive stones, of all types: india, SiC, ceramic, ark... whether by actively lapping them or by how I shape them through usage. If you have ever used machinist file stick shaped india stone, you might be familiar with a method for using them. Usually you hold it in your hand and are using primarily one spot on the end. After you dish a spot in the end, instead of lapping the entire surface flat, you might just lap the worn bit at an angle. And then curve that in to meet the rest of the stone. And eventually the entire end gets curved into a banana. This is a bit of the same principle, just applied to 3 dimensions, radially, rather than 2 dimensions. With knife X strokes, in particular, this means the blade and stone contact over a relatively small area, no matter if it's a straight section or a curve. I think this allows room for swarf to form/exit, and allows the stone's abrasives to eventually pop out when worn. And the knife will always find a new path over the stone on every stroke, compared to a perfectly flat stone where the straight portion of the blade is always going to find (and very lightly touch) the flat areas... and cause glazing. The slightly convexed stone wears super evenly, as a result, and you hardly ever have to reshape or resurface it. The huge problem with trying to flatten a stone that glazes easily is that the little dishing that you eventually create in the middle of the stone and/or the middle of the edge(s)? These spots are going to bite like crazy compared to the flats. The LOW spots biting much harder and grinding way more quickly than the high spots makes for a very bad sharpening experience which grows exponentially worse and out of control, over time. A lot of folks just let the stone get completely dished and use it like that. I prefer to use the convex surface over concave. The problem with a concaved surface is that as you sharpen into it, you can get into a situation where as you build up momentum in the stroke, the edge DIGS into the stone. As the angle gets progressively steeper, the edge is cutting into the stone, sharpening itself, and cutting into the stone, again... ad infinitum. This is wastefully eroding stone in a generally (for final sharpening) unproductive manner. Even on my trans arks, when I used to round off one edge and use that side of the stone... when it started to get dished in the middle of the edge, this trans ark would get super grabby in the dished area, destroying edge and stone quite quickly with one errant stroke. Consider the situation with a convexed stone. If you use part of it to lap a flat surface, you could create a low spot. If this flat surface were to have gotten glazed, it will not matter. It would be quickly eroded from the outside in, receding away. It is self-healing. Thus, the slightly convex surface wears much more evenly, bites the same on all spots, and you can maintain the same shape indefinitely with a little care and infrequent maintenance. It's also much easier to resurface and fine tune than a dished surface. If you try this, on say, one of your narrower stones, like say a 4x1 dans pocket stone, I will bet there's a good chance it will change the way you use stones, forever. There's a time and place for flat-lapped stones, but for sharpening knives, extreme flatness is perhaps overrated.
@ronaldthomas3528
@ronaldthomas3528 6 лет назад
Do you have a video on sharpening stones in the wild? Meaning what if I don't have my Arkansas with me. What stones should I be looking for out in Bush? Thanks for the information!
@roughroosterknifesharpenin5531
Ronald Thomas Thats a good question. And no i do not. really its whatever u can find to work with. find a good surface that works for you. Just enough to.get you through what you need.
@dfailsthemost
@dfailsthemost 6 лет назад
Btw, have you seen the "Arkansas Water Stones" now being marketed by RH Preyda? Seem like novaculite re-bonded with some adhesive. Maybe just the thing to vindicate what you've been saying for a long time.
@roughroosterknifesharpenin5531
dfailsthemost i have not seen these. Hmm im going to have to look into this.
@peetsnort
@peetsnort 7 лет назад
What i do is use the d4 diamond side to make a slurry off a 8000 waterstone and then use it to load a strop to attain Mirror finish
@roughroosterknifesharpenin5531
Howard Petterson hmm interesting
@kssaint6290
@kssaint6290 3 года назад
Speaking of Arkansas stones.....most notably the hard black Arkansas stone, one of the biggest problem is the slowness of the stone when sharpening a knife, or a straight razor. However, there is a way to speed up the process....I wonder if you tried this method...mix edge leading strokes with edge trailing strokes usually a 2:1 ratio, where the one stands for edge leading strokes and the 2 which stands for edge trailing strokes. Always start with edge leading strokes first ( I'm talking straight razor honing here, but this is true to knives as well) ....and finish the sharpening with edge trailing strokes. When I did that it was almost the feeling of the edge just "went on steroids" and it was in a short time(2-3 minutes max) on the hard black Arky. I was totally dumbfounded...since then when I use the hard black or the translucent Arky I always use this sharpening method, and I wonder if you ever tried this?
@roughroosterknifesharpenin5531
@roughroosterknifesharpenin5531 3 года назад
No I just sharpen like I do on every other Stone. And it turns out fine every time.
@adamwhiteson6866
@adamwhiteson6866 2 года назад
I like to use a drop of dish soap whenever working with water. It kills the surface tension of the water and allows it to adhere to surfaces better. It makes the water wet :) But some mfrs, like King, do say not to use soap. Don't know what the concern is. I figure a drop or two in the water won't hurt.
@roughroosterknifesharpenin5531
@roughroosterknifesharpenin5531 2 года назад
Thank you.... Finally another recognizes that. And with kings I've never tried that. But I do like kings.
@williambrown8372
@williambrown8372 2 года назад
I use mineral oil from the drug store on my stones. I have never had a problem with them gumming up. I use my stones mostly for chisels and planes and I can't run out of the shop to scrub the hell out of them.
@alexmorris3106
@alexmorris3106 Год назад
I think you are wrong, but that is me I have had a stone for years,1972?, It still works great, Eck usmc
@jeffedge4871
@jeffedge4871 4 года назад
Hey Rooster, I've got a new Arkansas stone and have used it twice with oil thinking that's what I was suppose to use-can you switch to dawn and water after you've already used oil on a stone?
@roughroosterknifesharpenin5531
@roughroosterknifesharpenin5531 4 года назад
Jeff Edge yes you can but you will have to de oil the stone with de greaser and boiling water. I have a video on here showing how I do it
@thewalnutwoodworker6136
@thewalnutwoodworker6136 2 года назад
Is it a bad idea to use mineral oil or other honing oils for honing on Arkansas stones?
@roughroosterknifesharpenin5531
@roughroosterknifesharpenin5531 2 года назад
I don't use oil on my Arks. I get much better results from my dawn and water.
@MrDravous
@MrDravous 6 лет назад
so question: it was my understanding that the chromium in stainless or D2 will form chromium carbides which are harder than quartz or silicates(the cutting medium in Arkansas and Japanese water stones, respectively), and that these carbides will actually be more abrasive to the quartz in the stone than the other way around. aluminum oxide(the softest of the synthetic cutting mediums) is harder than chromium carbides, and as such I've avoiding using natural stones on anything stainless or D2. now, you say you've gotten hair whittling edges using Arkansas stones on D2, but from what I know about the relative hardness of quartz and chromium carbides this shouldn't be possible. do you have any thoughts on how this is happening? and to be clear I'm not calling you a lier or anything of the sort. if you can get those edges on Arkansas then there must be some information I'm missing.
@roughroosterknifesharpenin5531
Dravous Wild great question. And im very sorry for the late response. i just now seen this comment. People say you cant sharpen anything other than carbon steel on Arkansas. This is not true. I always use my dmts first to to the hard work and set the initial bevel and sharpness. Then use the Arkansas for honing. The novaculite is much harder than people think. Now if you were to try to do the entire sharpening process on Arkansas you would fail miserably. No way possible. I hope this answers your question.
@default186
@default186 6 лет назад
When I'm finished using my stones my knife feels sharp and when I carfuly drag my finger down the edge I can feel it grab and slightly cut with little to no pressure but after I'm finished stropping the bite has gone and doesn't feel as sharp and there is no burr. What is going on ?
@roughroosterknifesharpenin5531
aidan wyman well you dont want a burr on the finished edge. Sounds to me like your stropping to hard and rolling the edge. The burr don't make it sharp its a process to make it sharp.
@default186
@default186 6 лет назад
Ok thank you
@roughroosterknifesharpenin5531
aidan wyman keep working at it. You'll figure it out 😀
@olgadachdecker7754
@olgadachdecker7754 7 лет назад
Did you somehow degrease your oil stones before you switched to using that soap water as a lubricant?
@roughroosterknifesharpenin5531
Olga Dachdecker no, none of my current stones were ever used with oil. I will however be doing a video on de-greasing stones. also just because there called "oil stones" by some don't necessarily make them oil stones.
@wilsonline90
@wilsonline90 7 лет назад
I beleave oil is need in some situations because of low temperatures. I mean, if you have a stone with water and the temperature goes below 32 F, the ice will crack the stone. And there are some situations that people don't pay atetion. Like in the lugage in the airplane. And then, you have a very expensive stone all cracked.
@roughroosterknifesharpenin5531
Wilson Miranda I see what your saying, but if I'm in that kind of situation I'll have my gear and I'll just use it dry if I have to. if it's that cold I don't think I'm gonna worry about my edge until I get onto a warmer situation. Unless I'm field dressing game.
@default186
@default186 6 лет назад
I'm glad I don't live in a place with that temperature
@williambrown8372
@williambrown8372 2 года назад
I am having issues with my stones. Where can I contact you?
@roughroosterknifesharpenin5531
@roughroosterknifesharpenin5531 2 года назад
southerntrader124@gmail.com
@aktrapper6126
@aktrapper6126 4 года назад
Somebody should at some time make a video on how to flatten a rock with another roch in a survival situation to make a bushcraft sharpening stone.
@roughroosterknifesharpenin5531
@roughroosterknifesharpenin5531 4 года назад
AKTrapper idk about you, but I’d just be worried about survival. I’d find some sort of abrasive surface and use that
@aktrapper6126
@aktrapper6126 4 года назад
@@roughroosterknifesharpenin5531 Mitch at Native Survival has one I just found. He just uses a untouched rock with good results. ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-5cnk1A-PsgQ.html
@williambrown8372
@williambrown8372 2 года назад
"Soak a new Arkansas stone in oil overnight before use" -Norton.
@roughroosterknifesharpenin5531
@roughroosterknifesharpenin5531 2 года назад
Ok awesome. I don't give a shit. You have commented this repeatedly. Do what you want get inferior edges. Don't care
Далее
Inadequate bevell's and why you should perfect them
30:20
Arkansas stone lapping!  Vid 2  Very important.
32:24
Просмотров 18 тыс.
Она Может Остановить Дождь 😱
00:20
What Do "Knife Sharpening" Honing Steels Actually Do?
14:57
Why Arkansas Sharpening stones are America's best
38:53
Freehand sharpening the mistakes most beginners make
23:37
The soft Arkansas sharpening stone vid 1 of 4
20:16
Просмотров 16 тыс.
How to Flatten a Whetstone - Easiest/ Cheapest Method
6:03
Precious Metal From Catalytic Converter
20:53
Просмотров 4,1 млн
We NOW know what's happening at Victorinox (SAK)
22:47
Просмотров 234 тыс.
How Japanese Masters Turn Sand Into Swords
25:27
Просмотров 10 млн