Doctor Who 12x5 FUGITIVE OF THE JUDOON - Reaction / Review 

Doctor Who 12x5 Full Episode Watch-Along available on our Patreon @ www.patreon.com/posts/33497922 E-Win Gaming Chair Review @ ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-hs6kOcUcY_c.html Doctor Who 12x4 Reaction @ ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-vDl27dC8NQo.html

Well the master did say "everything you know it's a lie" and after this episode... I know nothing at all

Imagine if Captain Jack Harkness met Missy, that would be an interesting scene

Doctor: 'trigger happy police' Americans: 'so just the police'

I had to laugh during the opening credits when you said, "They cut right to the chase"... which at that time Bradley Walsh's name was up on the screen who does the British quiz show called The Chase lol

Wasn’t expecting Captain Jack. Well done to John Barrowman & Dr Who for keeping it quiet

My 3 Theories: She's a version of The Valeyard, before the full fall to villainy. She's an alternative universe version of the Doctor, created if the 4th Doctor DID commit genocide in Genesis of the Daleks. She's the 14th Doctor, having lost her memories of her past.

Chibnall's gone mental, and I love it. So much better than when he was trying to write 'normal' Doctor Who (whatever that is). More of this unhinged stuff, please.

captain jack is looking for the doctor who he now knows is female what if he finds ruth first?

Lovely touch at the start, R.I.P KOBE, great reaction guys, this was a great episode, so many questions, 2 major surprise's, I went a bit mental when Capt Jack appeared and then went a little bit more when the other Doctor was revealed, can't wait to see were we go with this

Me before the episode: aah yes another episode of doctor who woo! Me after the episode: **confused screaming**

anyone notice that when the two "doctors" were in the other tardis together it didn't glitch? when 10 and 11 were in a tardis together the tardis couldn't figure out which look to use so it was glitching back and forth. This tardis just stayed the old look, which means they are not the same doctor. So, is she from another dimension? maybe even Susan or Jenny? or Valeyard? which Valeyard would make sense because she was so willing to use guns and kill but i really don't know and I'm so confused

Great great episode! That line “Did you miss me?” All of us, YES!!! Omg!!

Flabbergasted, speechless, dumbfounded, elated, confused - but all in the good way....just a few words to sum up my reaction

I HAVE NO WORDS! I'm still a bit a taken aback by what I had just experienced! I mean, it's one thing having the Judoon come back, but to have a new unknown version of the Doctor (which A) could be a past version that has existed long before William Hartnell and is possibly an adult Timeless Child before she became reincarnated as the Doctor we know, or B) is perhaps an alternate version of her from a parallel Gallifrey), more possible Gallifreyan history, Captain Jack himself coming back (which was friggin' awesome btw!), and the foreshadowed return of the Cybermen. I don't know if all of these concepts are connected or are two completely different story arcs entirely but it does have me very intrigued in what's in store for the future, although I'm still torn about whether or not this was a truly great standalone story or just a glorified setup episode for future episodes to answer much like with 2011's 'A Good Man Goes to War'. So far, I think this is easily the best Doctor Who story since Capaldi's swansong, but that view could change depending on how well Chibnall can stick the landing. After all, we don't need another Wedding of River Song or Battle of Ranskoor Av Kolos!

The two most likely solutions are that either Doctor Ruth is an alt universe Doctor. Or that the timeless child is a reference to a pre Hartnell cycle of regenerations and shes from there

Ruth is probably the Doctor from a parallel universe!

I feel this is the BEST Chibnall era Doctor Who episode. Thanks for the reaction, review and commentary. Awesome.

Jack’s return is what I’ve been waiting for! 😃 I haven’t seen him since Torchwood: Miracle Day (in 2011)!

The little muffled "what is going oon" is basically me throughout the whole episode

BBC better not mess William aka first doctor timeline up

back in classic who there was en episode in the 4th doctors run called “the brain of morbius” where it shows briefly his previous lives and there were more before the 1st doctor.

Vanessa’s reaction was pure delight as she slowly realizes the owner of the voice! 😂😂😂

That intro to kobe though.

Ha 11:46 both perfectly in sync with the hands. A crazy, mind boggling episode - but SO good! Great reaction!

After the episode aired Chibnall said that Ruth-Doctor is actually the Doctor. Not an alt universe version, not a fake, not a clone or copy, but truly properly one of the Doctors incarnations. Hence the "Introducing Jo Martin as The Doctor" in the end credits. The most popular and convincing theory is that she is the series 6B Doctor. We didn't see the regeneration of 2 into 3. We saw Troughton caught, then we saw Pertwee leaving the Tardis. The theory is that before they force regenerated him they sent him off as an agent for the CIA. Which explains why he and Jamie looked so old in The Two Doctors. Troughton regenerated into Ruth-Doctor which is where we come in. Eventually she regenerates into Pertwee. If the time Lords wiped her memory of her time working for them it wouldn't upset continuity plus it would mean the double Tennant regeneration only counts as one regeneration.

in "Brain of Morbius"with 4th doctor, we see 8 other images of doctors prior to Hartnell.

Beautiful start guys. Amazing reaction 😊

I think she is either a pre-Hartnell Doctor, which ties in with the repressed memories of the timeless child. Or she is the Doctor from a parallel universe. I really want to see how the cybermen come into this story. Whatever the hell it is....I am realllyyy loving it!!

I showed the wife your reaction to Jack Vanessa and she said that’s how you was last night only I was up jumping around a bit more, lol. Doctor Who Lore Time lord CIA*, series 6b. The Doctor work for the CIA between his 2rd and 3rd regeneration, we know that the TimeLords had the ability to gift regenerations and the Looms. So the CIA could have wiped those memories and replaced the used lives to cover their tracks. Ruth’s Tardis is how it looked in then War Games and Spearhead from Space, so that would fit the theory. I still so OMEGA is at play here, from his antimatter universe. * Celestial Intervention Agency

24:44 "We end up after everybody." You are Late to the Party, after all.

Can I say it was a REAL treat watching your reactions! I've been sitting on these spoilers since May and it's refreshing to see how I could have reacted if I didn't know what I did. Keep up the good work!

I think by far Series 12 is the most twisting in the nuwho era.

As I recall, we missed one of the early regenerations 2 to 3, I think - and alternate material implied that the Doctor worked for Time Lord Black Ops in this time. It's totally reasonable that they blanked his/ her memory afterwards, and compensated by giving him another regeneration. It doesn't have to be that, I'm just arguing that Time Lords can and have done some freaky things (the Master and Rassilon being solid examples) Plus, do you remember Missy stating "I know him ever since he was a little girl?"

When I saw the episode I totally freaked out, and what if this is an alternate version of the Doctor. But then again remember what the Master said that, "nothing is what it seems..."

The master,all you think you know is a lie.

She's from the series of regenerations that the valleyard from. Classic Who TARDIS, that looks fresh and brand new, meaning it's off of the assembly line. The other time lord obviously being from before Gallifreyan destroyed and recognizing Ruth implies all of this. The Cartnell Masterplan is engaged. Prepare for timey to get a lot more wibblly, a lot more wobbly and a lot more whimey. The biggest time paradox of the doctor's life, as well as the reason why multiple doctors and masters can exist within the same point in time as other versions simultaneously has been opened. It also revives the question that haunts the doctor through every incarnation. Doctor Who?

"WHAT IS GOING ON?" I think you just summed up EVERYONE's reaction. XD

Had to watch again for Vanessa's brilliant excited reaction and Roberts odd pirate voice when you first see the Judoon! Bloody brilliant!

The guy who baked that "You Can Do Better" cake, wasn't he also in another Doctor Who episode Kerblam!?

That is one of the most amazing genuine reactions I have ever seen from Vanessa.

I was kinda sobbing during editing with seeing your genuine excitement at 'a certain scene' amongst other people on edge of their seat. A glorious moment. Shame me pc crashed and i went all Kylo Ren on it after losing all work id done! I hope you avoided all the spoilers (someone posted a video with reveal in their title, before i watched episode!).

If this 'Ruth' Doctor is actually the Doctor and is in this timeline (as opposed to an alternative universe version) then there is one place she could be fitted without disturbing the established canon. That point would be between the Second and Third Doctors. As we did not see the regeneration on screen the extended universe has already long ago written in a (Classic) season 6B where the Doctor was pressed into servicce with the Celestial Intervention Agency (CIA). If we accept that concept (and the BBC has included elements of this on its official website in the past) then it is only a small step further to insert an extra regeneration. The Doctor running away (again) would have harsher consequences if she were in the employ of the CIA and that would indicate that they were the one's who employed the Judoon. This fits the fact that the Judoon were planning to take the fugitive back to Gallifrey where the CIA are based. Gat said that Lee had the same training as her which would indicate that both had been officers of the same agency. When the Doctor was eventually released from the CIA's service he/she would have been memory wiped before regenerating to 3. This does raise an issue with the number of regenerations but we have seen that extra regenerations can be awarded by the Time lords so it is not impossible that the CIA, as a covert arm of the High Council woul also have this in their gift. Alternatively, the change of appearance forced on the Second Doctor may not actually be a regeneration - it was never referred to as such at the trial.Finally, although the Second Doctor had a sonic screwdriver, it was never seen to do much more than unscrew bolts so it wouldn't be unreasonable for her not to recognise the all-purpose magic wand that current Doctors carry. Chibnall is reportedly a super hard-core Who fan from Classic days so this storyline might appeal although I still favour the simpler alternate universe idea.

She could indeed be a clone Doctor, engineered in secret back in the past, who naturally diverged in her regeneration cycle. That’s an intriguing theory. 👍🏻

My first thought was perhaps The doctor has had a whole 12 regeneration cycle before we ever met William Hartnell's 1st doctor. Afterward The Doctor was reborn through LOOM technology into William Hartnell and thats why he/she has no memory of Ruth's Doctor. But that all falls a part when Ruth has a Tardis disguised as a Police call box. Her simply having a Police call box means she has to come after Harnell right? unless she's a doctor from a parallel universe. Starts having a nosebleed

Great reaction, and beautiful tribute in the beginning. Recorded my reaction last night and will be uploading it tonight. Gotta wait until I get home from work.

The mystery of the past has to be more than "I got bored and stole a TARDIS with my granddaughter." He's keeping a huge secret.

It looks like Chignall just made be pulling a master stroke. By the sounds of it we are going into deepest darkest cannon from years gone by from the writings and mentioning is from (old) who, with regards to timelord origins and balloons it looks like Chignall just made be pulling a master stroke. By the sounds of it we are going into deepest darkest cannon from years gone by from the writings and mentioning is from (old) who, with regards to timelord origins and the looms

Doctor Ruth's TARDIS has round things. Love the round things. What are they for? No idea.

Wow best episode for Jodie Whittaker's time: Judoon, Captain Jack, a buried TARDIS, another female doctor! Wow what an episode. This season is great. Worth taken the year off last year. Of course RIP Kobe, Gianni, and all killed in the horrible tragedy in California

I’m calling it right now, Ruth is the daughter of The Doctor and River Song, and they named her after her dad

Well now I know what I looked like when I first heard Jacks voice and then saw him on screen LMAO love it!! 😂😂

Episode 5 = Confusion.

This one caught a lot of fans off guard after the fall from the Master storyline to Orphan 55. What an episode...

I think this episode is hands down the best jodi Whittaker episode to date

Just posted my reaction too. This episode has me, shook. SHOOK!

Ladies and gentlemen Captain Jack is back ❤

Ruth could be an alternate version of the Doctor or Rassilon or Rani or a Cyberman version or Dalek version or The Valeyard.

when she realised whose voice was on that ship and he didn't, that "late to the party" sign was soo on point :DD

As I woke this morning, an idea popped into my head regarding the lone Cyberman mentioned in Doctor Who. Maybe what it wants from the Doctor is some of her regeneration power so it can become flesh again. Out of compassion, she gives it what it wants and it regenerates...into the Master. Because the body of Missy had been left on the Cyberman ship, and we all know what happens when the Cybermen get there hands on a body.

I'm pretty sure Ruth is The Doctor, since the sonic screwdriver said that they were the same person. That, plus a TARDIS, makes it very hard to create a fake. It's possible Ruth is a Zeroth iteration, or somewhere between Seven and Nine. She might have had her mind wiped during the Time War.

Wow thank you, for activating my brain. It could be the ValleyYard. If you don't know who the ValleyYard is then you need to watch the trail of a Time Lord. Old Doctor #6 Colin Baker's run.

Your reaction to Jack's return was exactly how I felt but I kinda yelled his name out loud to... myself 😂😂

Ok, I never made the Jackson Lake Doctor connection with the Cybermen. I like that Theory.🤔

11.42 open mouths, 'catching flies' as we say here in the UK!. Nice reaction. I liked the set up of the story but am just a wee bit worried the explanation will be an obvious cop-out such as parallel universe etc. Maybe the universe Rose lives in?.

Chibnal confirmed that she is not an alternate or fake Doctor. She is legit the Doctor. Now, we still don’t know how... but they were both the Doctor.

I'm going with pre-Hartnell. Lemme put it this way: purportedly, throughout the entire universe, the concept of "healer" and "wise man (woman/person)" originating from the Doctor has, in some ways seemed strange. The Doctor is now over 2000 years old, and yes, she's a time traveler, but the Time Lords are one of the older species in the universe, not the oldest--there are canonically older ones--but they're pretty up there. Their species has been around, according to Timothy Dalton Rassilon's words, at least a billion years, or on that order of that many years since they've had time travel technology, and all up until the Doctor's birth, there was never any figure even like him/her? That's seemed a tad strange to me. When 11 became 12, and the Doctor had been through all 12 regenerations, the Time Lords somehow granted a new cycle of regenerations. What if that wasn't the first time? What if it was just the first time where he remembered his previous lives? I think there's been some Who content (uncertain about canonicity) where the 12 regeneration limit is said to be artificially imposed, either by Rassilon or some other founder of Time Lord society. I also remember reading something about how, when Time Lords die, the experiences or knowledge or personalities of who they are just sorta get scrambled back into "genetic material" that itself gets recycled back into new Time Lords again. So what if "the Doctor" actually existed prior to the 13 incarnations and something happens that recreates The Doctor such that the Doctor believes these familiar 13 incarnations are all the ones she's ever known?

Incredible episode! Definitely has me excited to see what's coming. I think that it has to be an alternate time line that both Ruth (doctor) and the new master have come from. It was fantastic to see Jack again but I think that it was deliberate that he didn't see the doctor but found out she is a female. I think that Jack will meet Ruth before he meets Jodie's doctor.

The new doctor's shirt and collar are an echo of the 6th doctor. You can see the chaotic color combination that was 6's trademark! You can also see an echo of Jon Pertwee....all you have to do is to look at the ruffles on her wrist. first Colin.. www.timeshifterspodcast.com/doctor-who-colin-baker/ AND Pertwee culturalgutter.com/2013/11/28/the-dandy-doctor/

I had to pause when I first heard Jack's voice too, :-D Best Episode in a long long time! I like Doctor Ruth but unless it's an alternate universe situation I have no clue what's going on. It's worth noting she had a Gallifreyan companion, which we haven't seen in Nu Who so that was cool. The lack of a Sonic is probably stranger to people who have only seen the later Doctors. as not all of them have used sonics. I think one of them even said that they were too smart to need it so Dr Ruth's comment seemed plausible, but it was strange that she didn't at least recognise it, though her brains were still unscrambling so maybe that's it. I didn't think it was the Master behind it I immediately thought it was Rassilon and maybe the Master & The Doctor will team up against him. Last thought, We met the Judoon with 10 and Martha who also introduced the Chameleon Arch now we see the Arch again and the Judoon are also back, was anyone else thinking of Martha?

I have a theory! This "new" Doctor is the Doctor from before everything - the very original. She and the rest of the Timelords discovered the "Timeless Child", an entity that was the incarnation of the Universe itself, that took the form of a child. Back then they weren't called the Timelords, but something else entirely. The Timelords imprisoned the Timeless Child and used her to gain control over time and space. This is when they changed their name to the "Timelords". They then had their memories wiped - either by their own volition because they were ashamed at what they did, or the Timeless Child did it.

So they never share a scene.

She is me when I heard jack talk. I flipped out soooooo hard!!!

my belief, alternate timeline doctor. being alternate timeline, "same hardware, different case" regeneration is random

2 Theories of Ruth!Doctor. A: She, and by extension Gat[?] & Lee, are from some Alternate Universe. Though the question is why don't they know there from some AU? Better yet, Our Doctor knows about AUs and was in one last season so why didn't they bring it up? B: Ruth!Doc is a future Doctor and something happened with there memory that they don't remember Thirteen and whatnot. And, unless it was Retconned or something, 12 was on Gallifrey a billion or so years in the future in HS/HB. And the Gallifrey that O destroyed is just one further in the timeline. Of course, quick and easy way to solve this would be to have 13 and Ruth mind meld to see what the last thing Ruth remembers is/what her previous face was. But, that is to simple so prob won't happen.

After Series 11 I didn't know that I would say this: but this is now in my Top 10

Love your reaction! Happy Captain Jack is back!

I was looking foward to this reaction! and rip kobe bryant

Ok I think one of 3 things are happening 1 the timelord high council wanted to ascend to higher form of life so maybe they went to the cybermen to help them up grade . 2 the high council made the master and the Dr as scouts to explore and conquer other planets but the Dr found out and left 3. Peter capaldi's Dr changed the cybermen base code to allow them to upgrade timelords and we know that john Simms master got to the lift maybe he got upgraded and then went on to destroy gallifrey

Ruth is the doctor 1.5 (2 Actually) but the memory of her existence is whipped from Jodi and the other 11 regenerations minds by the timelords, she is either the timeless child or found out the timelords were doing something shady making them force her to regenerate and whipping their minds of ruth's regeneration. The Master said Everything you think you know is a lie. You can figure out where she fits in time because 2 was the first doctor to use a sonic which she did not recognize and 1 stole the tardis with Susan making it a police box, and she still calls it a ship.

When I watched the episode on Sunday I thought, I know that voice!

She should have said, "That is enigmatic. That is textbook enigmatic."

There is still so much love for Captain Jack. Gotta love him!

Possible theory: When the Timelords gave the Matt Smith Doctor a new set of Regenerations they could have manipulated things to create an alternative Doctor that they controlled, except that by the time we get the version we see she has broken away, which would explain the whole 'working with/for the Timelords'? Can't be pre-Hartnell, Hartnell stole the Tardis, any pre-Hartnell wouldn't have the Tardis, would also still be on Galifrey

It is worth noting that Hartnell to Matt Smith is a complete set of regenerations. There are no spaces along that line. If it's pre-Hartnell, then it has to be another regen-cycle that's been wiped from Doc's memory. If Ruth is post-Jodie, then again memory loss has to be involved. My money's on parallel because it explains so many inconsistencies with the world as a whole and not just the ones with The Master and Doctor.

I can only think Ruth is a different timeline Doctor, a potential version, not an actual one. Similar to how the Master died as Missy, the master is an alternate. The regulation of the timelines is collapsing & bleeding into others. The reversal of that allows Gallifrey to return. I can’t see it as pre-hartnel, as how would Ruth have a Police box “stolen” type 40- more likely she’s from Hartnells timeline but is an alternate regeneration to a canon Doctor (maybe 5 based on shirt loudness 😂) I think it all links to a timeless child- an immortal who is at the heart of the untempered schism & effectively regulates the timelines/perhaps is the source of regeneration energy (and most likely a trapped prisoner suffering eternally), but is breaking free and it’s all time is collapsing as a result. Also think the comment Jack made about the alliance sending a device back through time to stop the cyber men could be the root of it. That clips gonna get replayed in a future realisation montage, similar to spymaster.

I freaking loved this episode . I have been enjoying Jodi’s Doctor but this episode blew me way and got me all excited about Doctor Who again . IFirst the return of Capitan Jack I was jumping around my apartment with Joy. Second I read an article that thought this was a future incarnation of the Doctor I believe that is wrong . I think this is not a future doctor but this is the Doctor before the War Doctor (John Hurt) you can tell by (1) Ruth’s TARDIS interior looks like the first Doctors [ William Hartnell] (2) Gallifrey is alive and well plus you get a sense this is before the War with the Dalek’s so its not time locked like the Great Time War. (3) It’s already cannon that the Doctor can wipe out and not remember a lifetime for example The War Doctor. This Dr. Ruth (lol wonder if she gives Sex advice) is obviously a past incarnation of the Doctor Who did something so bad she was wiped from the Doctors memories like the War Doctor , could also elude to the lost child that was hinted at in last season.

They did mention the alliance sending 'something' back to deal with the Cyberman situation. What would be the perfect thing to send? But then how does that tie in with anything else said in the episode? Confused? You will be, in next week's edition of...

Two words: Timeless Child Our current Doctor used telepathy to communicate about Gallifrey. Why was The Master so angry ? Question: how did the Timelords explore all (most) of Time and Space?

I´m getting season 6B vibes from this. An explanation; some fans have speculated that the Time Lords used the Second Doctor as an agent after the events of The War Games (1969), and that he did not in fact immediately regenerate and enter his exile on Earth. This theory of continuity is described as "Season 6B.

I think the Ruth Doctor is Chibnall introducing "the other" into TV canon. you should check out who "the other" is on different who wikis. "the other" is kinda ... sorta ... the Doctor

All i want is one reunite kiss of doctor and jack it's been yeas ,😭😭😭😭

The judoon were hired by a high ranking time lord who wanted Doctor Ruth to come back to the fold, Gat told us that

And FYI the cybermen didn't create the Morrisey doctor. He was created completely by accident with the data things, no cyber interference

The words that come to my mind are confused, intrigued and worried. All rumours have been true so far, so I'm worried about the direct pre-Hartnell route. But I'm still loving the bold direction so far. I'm not sure what is the route here but I agree with Robert, I feel it has to be a parallel universe Doctor or a biologically cloned one. Or... the Valeyard. No writer ever changed the Valeyard's premise upside down, apart from Big Finish, but the sort of dream-like premises the Valeyard is famous for never changed since "Trial of a Timelord", maybe we've been led to believe our Doctor would turn evil at some point, but what if there were 2 Doctors after all? That Doctor even removed the Judoon horn like it was nothing (how would a pre-Hartnell incarnation do that?). And it was the Master (another funny coincidence) who told the Doctor would turn into the Valeyard. But... what if he was never meant to be the Valeyard in the first place? All these prophecies are getting crazier for sure.

I'm with the idea of a parallel universe Doctor Ruth (just thought about that...Dr.Ruth... should have put that together earlier lol!)..also, anyone notice the hexagon mirror Ruth looked into at the beginning of the episode... like the TARDIS hexagon interior design? 😁

Loved the reactions for this episode.🤩

Glad Chibnall has bought Captain Jack back and has written him right. Moffat was a disaster and I am glad Jack didn't get ruined by Moffat

Personally hope they don't go the Pre-Hartnell thing or the whole regen between 2 and 3. I like the alternate reality theory

How did they get him De-Aged, he looked like shit on Arrow!