No video :(

Donald Trump shot and injured at Pennsylvania rally | Scott Lucas

Подписаться 922 тыс.

Просмотров 26 тыс.

50% 1

Donald Trump has survived with a minor injury to his ear after being shot at during a rally in Pennsylvania, one rally attendee was killed, Scott Lucas Professor of American Studies, Clinton Institute, University College Dublin, gives #timesradio the latest.
📻 Listen to Times Radio - www.thetimes.c...
📍 Subscribe to our channel - / @listentotimesradio
🗞 Subscribe to The Times www.thetimes.c...
📲 Get the free Times Radio app www.thetimes.c...

Опубликовано:

21 авг 2024

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 338

@TheDoctorOfPainAndWeebz Месяц назад

The scary thing is how predictable this was.

@anthonymorris2276 Месяц назад

The second moment that Trump won the 2024 election. (The first was, of course, the televised “debate” with Biden.)

@AthelstanEngland Месяц назад

What a prat this man is! President Trump had just been shot and will be in shock but still reacted superbly. Well said the guy with the headphones and calling him out. How low can you get.

@addeigloriam4844 Месяц назад

My goodness man the gunshots rang as clear as day….we don’t know what it was….please

@zeitgeist5134 Месяц назад

"Someone took a shot at him...apparently." Principles of good journalism applied. Bravo.

@mr.mayhem7402 Месяц назад

And to think that the Times once set the world standard when it came to serious, high quality journalism. We now get this shameful clown show.

@TrickyWookie Месяц назад

The smirk on this guys face is frankly disturbing

@mr.mayhem7402 Месяц назад

What he says is even more so.

@catsnads01 Месяц назад

Yeah. I've got no time at all for Trump but dude... this guy seems like he's coping with the fact Trump came out of this well.

@panzerblitz2140 Месяц назад

Obviously not Jason Bourne... this guy missed

@VideaVice25 Месяц назад

Real life assassin =/= Movie assassin

@mr.mayhem7402 Месяц назад

You must be very upset about that.

@duncanfindlay3227 Месяц назад

Utterly disgraceful reporting, the Times plumbs new depths!

@alexkulka8578 Месяц назад

Why?

@mr.mayhem7402 Месяц назад

Indeed: "I don't think that Trump anticipated this" Really? And try to immediately spin it as a PR opportunity for Trump because they know how this will play out. Neatly overlooking all the poltical violence openly celebrated by the Left (a vast list of examples to chooses from but we can start with Portland and go from there.)

@Shsjier Месяц назад

@@mr.mayhem7402lmao go ahead pretend that the left is more violent 😂you guys are clowns

@pauln6803 Месяц назад

@@mr.mayhem7402 Right... The "left"... The US political establishment keeps what would be considered centre left in any sane country out on the fringe where the lobbyists can drown out their calls for genuine reform. And it wasn't the left who stormed the Capital leaving five dead.

@leifleblanc160 Месяц назад

Guest was probably all smiles . Hes so one sided in his political diatribe its ridiculous.

@user-fz7yp3xk6w Месяц назад

Pro Biden podcast🤥🤥🤥

@Georgieastra Месяц назад

Or as the BBC described it: _The Largely Peaceful Assassination Attempt_

@PeterOZ61 Месяц назад

this bloke talking is such a rabid lefty

@mairhart Месяц назад

The shooter registered as a Republican in 2021, confirmed by Pennsylvania state government records. He remained registered as a Republican until his death.

@urbangypsy4335 Месяц назад

The Times Radio Is disgusting putting on a trump hater!

@user-fz7yp3xk6w Месяц назад

I hope Trump sues both you guys for slander, making all these false insinuations.

@umbertotoni3021 Месяц назад

Ohh Times Radio, whats a piece off shir are you and yours viewers.

@patrioticbrexiteer7935 Месяц назад

Shame on you saying diatribe. He was fking shot it was a bullet hole

@bwilsondomain Месяц назад

Always a possibility in the USA

@18_rabbit Месяц назад

particularly after eight years of that prez/candidate stoking violence & then basic human rights being removed over the past two years by Scotus & the final nail of the brand new presidential immunity (not even vaguely in the Constitution itself), and something was bound to break, yes.

@michaeldoolan7595 Месяц назад

The UK has had two politicians killed in eight years. What's your point?

@crowbar9566 Месяц назад

It can happen anywhere.

@theloniousm4337 Месяц назад

This is a possibility just going to the store for groceries in the USA.

@JustMe-fv9ug Месяц назад

He said wait wait, I want to get my shoes

@Rob-hy8vb Месяц назад

Its called dignity

@goddam9925 Месяц назад

And your point being !!

@Gopnikawa Месяц назад

@@goddam9925What do you mean? Dude almost got assassinated and he just casually asked for his shoes like it’s Tuesday.

@anthonyd4341 Месяц назад

The NRA thanks candidate Trump for his endorsements.

@crissdizick9403 Месяц назад

This guy is a clown

@YayaaSanogo Месяц назад

You're the clown 🤡

@mr.mayhem7402 Месяц назад

Note how all the poltical violencebof the Left is ignored. It's like the riots in Paris never happened.

@bikergirluk8059 Месяц назад

Does anyone know where Seal Team Six is? Tho I doubt they would’ve missed 🤔

@Dogboy73 Месяц назад

This is a big win for Trump, unfortunately.

@thaksforurip Месяц назад

YOU MEAN BIG LOSS

@danalexanderaudio8506 Месяц назад

oh sure. Now, all the women who were upset at being told to sit down and shut up will vote for The Fatboy King because poo widdoo twumpoo aaaawwwww.....

@Batmandarkknight. Месяц назад

Why unfortunately. Bet ur a gay

@gp2917 Месяц назад

@@thaksforuripno he means big win. The optics on this will play great with the masses.

@tomfurmby88 Месяц назад

@@gp2917 true, I once tried to apply for an airport security job, they said no so I shot myself in the foot and went back to them saying "look I have an additional qualification" - they hired me on the spot.

@TVStuff10 Месяц назад

In one ear and out the other apparently..no damage reported!

@zacharyscott2298 Месяц назад

so funny, he just won the election

@wthomas5697 Месяц назад

Funny!

@Arctic_Dude Месяц назад

His comb over took some damage though...

@charlesmcdonald1973 Месяц назад

😂

@userunknown1030 Месяц назад

it appears joe would be saved in the same way.

@catsnads01 Месяц назад

This guest is apalling. What an awful way to cover this event.

@Sa1985Mr Месяц назад

It's America, it's the national pass time, I believe all you have to do is say "thoughts and prayers".. and everyone moves on.

@richardkrispell7904 Месяц назад

What a lovely professor. Heart of gold.

@VideaVice25 Месяц назад

/sarcasm

@waheex Месяц назад

the guy was on the roof and the shooter is dead

@01bystander Месяц назад

A 100% Trump hating guest. can’t say anything about what a terrible incident this is. Only negative vibes on Trump.

@wthomas5697 Месяц назад

Hey, I hate trump too.

@michasunafish4844 Месяц назад

@@wthomas5697I imagine there are a lot of people that hate you too, just a hunch.

@proselytizingorthodoxpente8304 Месяц назад

@@michasunafish4844 Doubt it. I can't imagine wthomas has instigated any political violence on the streets of his own capitol lately. Same can't be said for Trump.

@user-mz3in7vo5b Месяц назад

Is this real or reallity show? Only Trump knows...

@SashedPotato Месяц назад

I'm concerned for what happens next. We all know how Americans react to most things. There will be January 6th times a billion in the streets.

@userunknown1030 Месяц назад

why shouldn't there be if biden was almost taken out democrats would burn down the usa they have done it before with blm so you act like there shouldn't be any blow back.

@nathanhoffman20000 Месяц назад

Nah

@danielhall-wl4ql Месяц назад

not in Eastern Kentucky, not sure what our problem is really but if it ant in our front yard its not our buisness , maybe thats the way it should be , maybe we just pu$$ies , I dont know , and yes the cousin thang is true , not sure what to say about that other than supply and demand

@valqueenofValhalla Месяц назад

You know nothing

@mr.mayhem7402 Месяц назад

What do you mean?

@MantisEnergy Месяц назад

Surely everyone had their phones out and we'll see how it happened soon.

@cbh2976 Месяц назад

This act will 100% get Trump elected President.

@gror7849 Месяц назад

Sadly ...

@teetee9303 Месяц назад

@@gror7849 nope

@awuma Месяц назад

I suspect that neither Trump nor Biden will be the candidates in November.

@wthomas5697 Месяц назад

Wanna bet?

@Lynnefromlyn Месяц назад

Obviously a false flag then. He got a scratch.

@proselytizingorthodoxpente8304 Месяц назад

Now would be the ideal time for Trump to do a little self reflection. To think about how words have consequences. As they did back in 2021 outside the Capitol building. But we all know Trump is not capable of such a thing. He'll just be whipping his lunatic cult into an ever greater frenzy of paranoia.

@YayaaSanogo Месяц назад

How about no and how about you do some of your own self reflection with your far left woke cult

@mikhaelcouchman8783 Месяц назад

this comment proves you are demented. What a dumb thing to say.

@proselytizingorthodoxpente8304 Месяц назад

@@YayaaSanogo Being against the lunacy of Trump and his lunatic cult following is not 'far left woke'. It's what normal people do.

@YayaaSanogo Месяц назад

@@proselytizingorthodoxpente8304 democrats are a far left woke cult

@adrianbundy3249 Месяц назад

Trump's words like no violence and peaceful assembling? You obviously just hate him you never heard him also denouncing violence in totality did you, even though he did multiple times, then and now? Blame your own ignorant media you married.

@bakersmileyface Месяц назад

If only guns were legal in the US. Trump could have protected himself and his audience could have protected him

@carlthor91 Месяц назад

🤣🤣🤣🤣👍👍

@crowbar9566 Месяц назад

A predictably obvious and dumb comment.

@katrinamackenzie8789 Месяц назад

You could hear the pinging of the bullets

@ianwoodham3676 Месяц назад

Doesn't surprise me trumps a target by the establishment

@nathanhoffman20000 Месяц назад

🙄

@JD-im4wu Месяц назад

if it was the establishment they would not miss and be so sloppy clearly it was some angry american that hated him.

@user-dd7qr5kx8h Месяц назад

who is the "establishment". i always thought it was the gop.?

@ChipmunkRapidsMadMan1869 Месяц назад

@@JD-im4wu Long distance shooting is not a 100% hit.

@adrianbundy3249 Месяц назад

If anyone doesn't believe in the establishment or democrats also being a big part of establishment politics 🙄. But op, we don't know for sure yet. He does have a lot of haters, unfortunately.

@bennytaaffe3205 Месяц назад

This stinks of a set up .. the secret service guys are smiling...this seems staged to me

@18_rabbit Месяц назад

dunno yet, but it is interesting that a month or two ago Tucker Carlson said within a larger sentence something about "if Trump is not killed before the election".... Seems the ultraright wing knows something about either true risks or plans. In any case, after 8 years of plainly openly fascist-adjacent onslaught on my country, this incident is hardly a suprise.

@PaballoKobe-xh9ve Месяц назад

Those dead bodies were planted

@saima307 Месяц назад

@@bennytaaffe3205 yup

@uchennatv533 Месяц назад

They just made him the president😂

@Cbmountain42 Месяц назад

100 percent

@laurawgarts Месяц назад

God bless Trump! FJB!

@wthomas5697 Месяц назад

@@laurawgarts FDT&U2

@michasunafish4844 Месяц назад

😂 have a cry loser @@wthomas5697

@ldbent1956 Месяц назад

Donald Trump is not a sympathetic figure nor will he be. He is a wanna be anarchist who would install loyalist and try to overturn democracy like he tried to overturn a presidential election all for his sick twisted maniacal narcissism.

@paulthomas-hh2kv Месяц назад

1 dead 1 injured in the stand

@danielhall-wl4ql Месяц назад

THE BLOOD CAME FROM HIS MOUTH ! after he caught the bullet with his teeth , did get his gum a bit though ! tough dude

@doghouse6413 Месяц назад

Hate to break it to you all, but this just won Trump the election

@user-dd7qr5kx8h Месяц назад

If and only if he uses the opportunity correctly and with dignity and be humble and call for peace. WHAT AM I THINKING WE ARE TALKING ABOUT TRUMP.

@nexus_of_a_crisis Месяц назад

"Standard diatribe?" You want to score political points from a shooting? That's disgusting.

@jorgkaufmann6363 Месяц назад

Videos of the Butler campaign can be found on RU-vid, where you can watch it from the beginning. What amazes me is how a presidential candidate and former president can give a speech at such a primitive level and still be cheered by the crowd. Then the shots ...

@janinachambers8257 Месяц назад

Not making excuses. He was shot at.

@YayaaSanogo Месяц назад

@@janinachambers8257 that's big of you to admit

@paoloviti6156 Месяц назад

Someone says that Alec Baldwin claims those where blanks but with one died and at least 2 seriously injured. How can those shots be blanks???

@AthelstanEngland Месяц назад

That picture of Trump with fist up under the US flag will become iconic!

@marylousherman5471 Месяц назад

Iconic as an example of his stubborn stupidity...like that day he looked up at the solar eclipse with no glasses. Duh!

@YayaaSanogo Месяц назад

@@marylousherman5471 cope

@AthelstanEngland Месяц назад

@@YayaaSanogo well said. It's incredible how warped some people are. Probably considers herself caring too!

@veronicaleon8075 Месяц назад

The President was clearly struck! Before he went down he grabbed his right ear. Then he hobbled out! 😮 He needed assistance to walk!

@AlxFitz Месяц назад

He's not the president and it just said on the radio that he was hit on the ear by some flying glass.

@laurawgarts Месяц назад

He did not need assistance, he was surrounded by secret service, holding up his fist in the air!

@Lynnefromlyn Месяц назад

Oh heck! He got a scratch! Wow! Pity the poor guy who died. Get too close to Trump ruins your life.

@Lynnefromlyn Месяц назад

He’s not the President. He’s a convicted felon.

@mr.mayhem7402 Месяц назад

He didn't need assistance to walk. He ain't Biden.

@runrau9275 Месяц назад

Now in Custody the shooter is only asking, "when will Trump pay me?"

@anthonymorris2276 Месяц назад

Unlikely, since the shooter is dead.

@saima307 Месяц назад

@@runrau9275 my thoughts

@mrheimdall Месяц назад

who says "Let me get my shoes" while being shot at? 😆

@rachelcoles9141 Месяц назад

Teflon don.

@pjinkc Месяц назад

Fake blood

@YayaaSanogo Месяц назад

Fake comment

@pjinkc Месяц назад

@@YayaaSanogo did you get up off your knees to make that reply? Just curious

@pjinkc Месяц назад

@@Hexley_Vexley apparently so but probably a false flag

@YayaaSanogo Месяц назад

@@pjinkc it's time to take your tin foil hat off and let your brain get some oxygen

@GravTsport Месяц назад

It sounded like a pneumatic paintball gun in the video. I wouldn't be surprised if this was a false flag to deflect from his legal exposure right before the RNC convention.

@wecandothiswarriors Месяц назад

Simpsons

@suburbanview Месяц назад

He dosent mean this, he already thinks he is the CHOSEN ONE, this is a big difference.

@patriciahansen9438 Месяц назад

PRAY FOR TRUMP. WE ARE NEVER TO HAVE REVENGE ON ANYONE. LEAVE ALL REVENGE TO TOUR LORD. FOR OUR LORD JESUS WILL PAY BACK IN FULL. TRUST IN GOD

@WalterCamp-s9r Месяц назад

Please. Fake News. This was staged for a photo op. No different than his team scripting an episode of the Apprentice. Notice how literally nobody scrambled and ran away. Everything with this guy is a planned sound bite or face show of strength.

@craigshannon6011 Месяц назад

You're actually evil.

@YayaaSanogo Месяц назад

Time to take your tin foil hat off and let your brain get some oxygen

@WalterCamp-s9r Месяц назад

@@YayaaSanogo We'll see, everything about this guy is inflated and fake ... already they're saying he was only hit by some ricochet debris, but of course he saying he was hit by an actual bullet. Oh, and who is this alleged shooter? Be interested to hear the actual truth on this.

@haroldgtv Месяц назад

Land of the free, right...

@valqueenofValhalla Месяц назад

God bless Donald Trump FJB

@XavierBen-kw5zs Месяц назад

2 people now dead along with the shooter

@mr.mayhem7402 Месяц назад

And there are legions of Lefties on RU-vid still saying its staged and faked. The TDS is off the scale.

@culturedpersonality Месяц назад

He just got shot. You’re hardly showing any concern for his safety. Deplorable Reporting. You’re not Main Stream anymore for a reason.

@bens9275 Месяц назад

His fake blood packet didn't hurt him. What are you smoking?

@marylousherman5471 Месяц назад

Consider how unconcerned he was on Jan 6 for anyone's safety at the capitol bldg

@machidaman Месяц назад

Is he channelling Penny Mordaunt?

@katrinamackenzie8789 Месяц назад

Of course he will say " Fight" is this guy against Trump thats speaking???😮

@michasunafish4844 Месяц назад

Does hilary have an alibi? 😂

@paulthomas-hh2kv Месяц назад

Yes she was watching Trump rally on tv with Obama

@user-db7ee8nl3q Месяц назад

Trump wanted this to happen on January 6th.

@jamesg2382 Месяц назад

Thank you, a level headed analysis. Scary moment for democracy. I wouldn’t rule out a false flag op

@vicgarbutt3310 Месяц назад

the shooter was outside the venue on a roof of a 1 story building

@paulthomas-hh2kv Месяц назад

Public alerted security before shots fired witness on tv said

@paulthomas-hh2kv Месяц назад

Bet he’s sitting there waffling wearing a skirt and heels 👠

@renovatio1257 Месяц назад

Extreme leftist rhetoric caused this attempt.

@Lynnefromlyn Месяц назад

Don’t be ridiculous.

@stalyirmangin6249 Месяц назад

😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

@user-dd7qr5kx8h Месяц назад

"extreme leftist rhetoric".. I guess you have never heard trump speak

@bobs_toys Месяц назад

@@user-dd7qr5kx8hone of the two major contenders has been shot here.

@kingsframingartgalleryyour3487 Месяц назад

I think he staged it because he was losing.

@DanielMcGillis-f3w Месяц назад

Nice trolling right there.

@laurawgarts Месяц назад

He's ahead in the polls, you miserable excuse for a human.

@kingsframingartgalleryyour3487 Месяц назад

@DanielMcGillis-f3w you're entitled to your opinion. But if you know Trump, he can't keep his mouth shut. He said that there would be some sort of ruckus in one hour. Then afterward, inciting more violence. 1+1=b

@vortigern3910 Месяц назад

erase my comments

@felicityjordan6853 Месяц назад

That shot has been photoshopped there is no flag that big behind him on the dias anywhere

@YayaaSanogo Месяц назад

It's time to take the tin foil hat off and let your brain get some oxygen

@be_a_bright_sparkle3687 Месяц назад

You are right…and he wasn’t stood so far up..😢

@tegmatthews1047 Месяц назад

Yes… this one a clearly fake news…

@kbradford2270 Месяц назад

Message. Sent. Now let's see if message was received

@YayaaSanogo Месяц назад

@@kbradford2270 Message failed. You have run out of data. Pay your bill.

@reneemottaz3925 Месяц назад

Broken glass from the message prompter

@phillloyd2519 Месяц назад

Got real for Donnie tonight Bone spurs dodged the draft 5 times suddenly is going to war Maybe he’ll do a JFK …,

@wthomas5697 Месяц назад

Let's see what he thinks about gun control now, heh, heh.

@ZR1107 Месяц назад

Clearly staged and fake.

@affankhan3031 Месяц назад

Ah yes, the expert with no expert knowledge. Take your pills boy

@JustMe-fv9ug Месяц назад

Not fake. People are dead

@YayaaSanogo Месяц назад

Clearly time to take your tin foil hat off and let your brain get some oxygen

@Christian_Princess Месяц назад

Another red flag 😮

@michasunafish4844 Месяц назад

Im a beit, but my god there are so many disillusioned brandon lovers on here tonight.

@patriciahansen9438 Месяц назад

GOD IS IN CONTROL

@gingergann3934 Месяц назад

Trump does Not advocate violence. You're full of hogwash.

@freemantle85 Месяц назад

So January 6th was a peaceful group of people with guns breaking into Congress and calling for the death of Mike Pence?

@user-dd7qr5kx8h Месяц назад

Does jan6th not ring any bells for you? Trump only advocates violence where have you been

@marylousherman5471 Месяц назад

Every time he opens his mouth he spews either lies or threats of retribution against 'perceived' enemies! Are you listening to him at all?!

@bennytaaffe3205 Месяц назад

Does anybody

@saima307 Месяц назад

Publicity stunt !

@mr.mayhem7402 Месяц назад

And the people who died?

@saima307 Месяц назад

@@mr.mayhem7402 do you really think these politicians care about what happens to people in there gain

@deecee1522 Месяц назад

Such a small crowd lol

@Sivispacemparabellum-ym9cu Месяц назад

Quia ventum seminabunt, et turbinem metent).

@patriciahansen9438 Месяц назад

WE ARE TO FEAR NO ONE ONLY OUR LORD JESUS. OUR LORD

@wthomas5697 Месяц назад

Oh jeezus christ. You people are ridiculous.

@jonm7272 Месяц назад

WHY ARE YOU SHOUTING?

@omaramoo1509 Месяц назад

Lots of shots fired at IT but only 1 land's exactly in the area it has pierced

@garrybaldy327 Месяц назад

Trump watched the movie Bob Roberts.

@peacesempare7585 Месяц назад

God's hands on u

@LabyrinthLaughs Месяц назад

Wouldn’t surprised if this was staged. Just ear damage, Elon backing plus the shooter is dead? Cmon

@user-sm9jy2jm1i Месяц назад

Remove Islam and remove the problem.

@ChipmunkRapidsMadMan1869 Месяц назад

This was not likely islamic extremists.

@fgameshunter1782 Месяц назад

It may be Russia you now what they are like with assassination attempts

@WtfWhy-tl2zl Месяц назад

You think Islam has anything to do with anything at all? You sir are brainwashed by programming and tell a vision.

@user-sm9jy2jm1i Месяц назад

@ChipmunkRapidsMadMan1869 Don't give a fk who it was. My comment still stands. One day, you're going to realise it.

@ChipmunkRapidsMadMan1869 Месяц назад

@@user-sm9jy2jm1i This was domestic.

@chipious9736 Месяц назад

It’s fake, like Jan 6th

@user-dd7qr5kx8h Месяц назад

are you really trying to make this and jan6th equal??? no comparison!!!

@chipious9736 Месяц назад

@@user-dd7qr5kx8h You can believe whatever you want? So can i

@GetToDaChoppa-k5r Месяц назад

😶

@jeromedamian5740 Месяц назад

It's a bit fishy. The Ear bleeds in seconds you notice when he went down he touched his ear and then he took his hand off there was no blood only when he got back up After he huddled , there was their blood. I'm shocked if people got killed.

@ReallyJustAnotherDay Месяц назад

Columbo over here

@anonone8954 Месяц назад

@@ReallyJustAnotherDay apparently watches too much television.

@peteryyz43 Месяц назад

@@ReallyJustAnotherDay; Yeah, I'm surprised the commenter didn't preface his comment, with the classic Columbo line "....Oh, just one more thing..."

@YayaaSanogo Месяц назад

It's time to take your tin foil hat off and let your brain get some oxygen

@jeromedamian5740 Месяц назад

@@YayaaSanogo 😝

@tracygargel216 Месяц назад

You saw that in the video they saw the woman in blue behind Trump give me sign in with signs to something

@waheex Месяц назад

@yotest3697 Месяц назад

@@waheexthis is staged for voters to forget project 2025

@davidmcnamara8024 Месяц назад

the 2nd amendment is a form of the 1st.

@YayaaSanogo Месяц назад

Dumbest statement I ever read

@davidmcnamara8024 Месяц назад

@@YayaaSanogo oh well.

@carolyndaniels386 Месяц назад

Mercy.

@patriciahansen9438 Месяц назад

GOD IS ALWAYS IN CONTROL OF EVERYTHING

@HardLineElektron Месяц назад

There is no god. Would be helpful if people would act accordingly and stop falling in prayers like in the Stone Age.

@matt6984 Месяц назад

It is 2024 for the love of God buy a mic

@DU47ITY Месяц назад

Yo the picture goes hard tho 🥶

@paulrose1785 Месяц назад

What an opportunity to create some form . Just imagine the possibility, Of a staged situation, where someone fires same blank shots, sounds like they were distant? Then brush your ear with stage paint, pump your fish, against the background of the flag, just imagine

@patriciahansen9438 Месяц назад

DO NOT JUDGE