Тёмный

Dune: Baron Harkonnen 

Brainstorm Lore
Подписаться 2,3 тыс.
Просмотров 4,6 тыс.
50% 1

website link: studiobrainsto...
Minds link: www.minds.com/...
fan art and music credits, please support them
lukeoram.com
markzug.com
www.deviantart...
www.deviantart...
• The Desert - Backgro...
All copyrighted material is used solely for review purposes.

Опубликовано:

 

6 сен 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 11   
@Kitzishot
@Kitzishot 3 года назад
This is the problem with the Brian Herbert books. They don't stay on the established world building of Frank Herbert. A Bene Gesserit can't be poisoned, paralyzed, sickened etc. They can adjust their body to make such efforts mute. Further, Brian Herbert took the 1984 movie as inspiration and not his father's works. Baron Harkonnen wasn't sickly and red hair isn't established cannon in the books. In fact the only mention of hair was about the nephew in which he is described as having dark hair. There was a reason Frank Herbert simply described the Baron as being grossly obese. He indulged in gross overindulgence in everything he did and had no inclination to restrict himself in any way, shape, or form. The way Frank overtly describes the Baron is a person who is contently in the need of more. It isn't enough to be a ruler of a world or worlds but he is seeking to be a ruler of them all. It isn't enough to have a sexual appetite but must partake in the very extremes of sexual perversion of raping children in fiendish sickening ways. It isn't enough to simply defeat the Atreides but to annihilate them and consume them. Brian never got the intention of the subtilties of the evils. Instead, he seized upon the comedic over the top portrayal of the 1984 movie when in reality the Frank Herbert description is far more frightening for all of us, at least once in our lives, has ran into the Baron and may have never known it.
@Brainstorm-Lore
@Brainstorm-Lore 3 года назад
True, but alas unless Frank's original notes get released this is all we've got to work with.
@ismata3274
@ismata3274 3 года назад
@@Brainstorm-Lore sure, but indeed, there is a very glaring inconsistency about the metabolic powers of bene Gesserit here. Having the ability to contain within their body many a poison and germ, without harming themselves, but can't turn this one specific paralyzer of keeping the victim awake!!!!!! variety to boot. Thus rendering the not really but maaaaaaybe acceptable excuse of, well she was not aware until the deed was done, and by then, since the duty was accomplished, there was no need to turn the paralizer down. She was awake, so unless this specific paralizer is an Achilles s heel for bene Gesserit control, she should have been able to turn it down. Maybe turning a chemical down is time consuming? But then that means bene Gesserit can be poisoned. Just choose a fast acting one. Which water of life is....... And a not yet a reverend mother can convert it...... And become a reverend mother......(admittedly the substance gives a feeling of time dilation, possibly by increasing the speed of neural transmit)..... Doesn't matter. A Reverend mother, especially an experienced one, should be able to do it. and not being concious enough to turn it down would make choosing baby's gender an impossibility. So she must have been awake. Barons sadism demands it. What they should have done was; making her speedily examine the poison, listing effects it will have, turning it down, but mimicking it's effects, for the reason of obeying the bene Gesserit s usual mode of action, which is Never make benegesserit look too capable, and to keep bodily control abilities under wraps. That keeps eyes away from their breeding practices, thus from the breeding program too.............. (point to them is, don't become/look like a nonaging, immortal, captivatingly attractive, mind controlling warmachines that they are capable of becoming if they choose to but don't ever do for the good of the sisterhood and humanity's interests -in their eyes-. Only Alia and at later days of her life Irulan used/disobeyed the capacity to stop aging part of the don't be really seen! general order, which, seeing them such, Jessica promptly despised those two....) Those are franks books plot points, so this would have fit into canon! cannon pretty good I think.
@joshuamarvin7400
@joshuamarvin7400 3 года назад
It wasn't until Ramsay Snow in ASOIAF that I felt the same absolute disgust for a fictional character as I originally had for Ribhan Harkonnen.
@shahansindhi8141
@shahansindhi8141 3 года назад
Harkonen forces are like Nazi, they will fight with "Paul Aterides" (who called this war a "Crusade"). Harkonen has to make his point in the Dune (film), he has to be very explicit in his strategy of war.
@frankmoss5282
@frankmoss5282 2 года назад
HarKOnnen not Harkanenn
@shahansindhi8141
@shahansindhi8141 3 года назад
We have to perfect the identity of Paul Aterides, Harkonen, and "Beni Computer Brains".
@micstonemic696stone
@micstonemic696stone 2 года назад
👍 good
Далее