Dune live Q&A with Quinn 

Man i was looking for something to Fall asleep and your thing Just pop up i love both Channels so Helllll yeaaah

Alt schwift x would be furious

But that’s another RU-vidr isn’t?

Nah you’re thinking of alt Schwift x, this is a different bloke

I love how this is the top comment

True

They’re probs not going to have him in the film. Would love to be proven wrong though!

@@user-ru9ig2ed9y Tim Blake Nelson has been cast in an undisclosed role. Lady Margot is confirmed to be in the movie, played by Lea Seydoux. Nelson HAS to be playing Fenring

@@Ryuk45he did a podcast episode of WTF with Marc Maron and he mentions he’s has a role in Dune Part Two but he describes it nothing more than a cameo. I’m fairness, both Fenring’s roles in Dune were small, so Tim could very well be the Count, but I guess we’ll see

FURTHERMORE Tim Blake Nelson yodels and fenring and his wife have that sing songy secret language that just seems perfect

Feelings character was so inconsequential he can easily be left out of the movie

fentanyl much?

Just did the same thing! So grateful my whole living room is spotless now tysm for the content

Adapting Messiah would definitely be a challange given that barely anything happens in the books other than people talking or thinking. But I do admit: I would loooove to see the stone burner scene realized on the big screen.

Couldn’t agree more. Absolutely love Messiah, it’s my favorite book of the series.

love his scifi book reviews, esp into Three Body. Wish he'd do Macroscope by Piers Anthony; he'd love it.

Quinn is so flippin smart - love his channel and how he explains everything in detail I enjoy without feeling talked down to. He wouldn't criticize me for ending that sentence in a preposition. ha!

Couldn’t agree more, he understands how the movie must be different from the book in some ways to be great. What makes the book perfect cannot be translated to film and so that’s not what denis should focus on.

Quinn does quite a bit of complaining about other franchises especially when he’s berating them against Dune. His Dune knowledge is very good but when he talks about other franchises it’s very clear he doesn’t understand them at all nor is he very knowledgeable.

The irony of Dune fans gravitating towards one influencer over another is delightful.

Interesting.. which series in particular do you mean?

I have heard the same thing, that he's bright, fun to talk to, a good speaker, as you say a really nice guy....It's sort of unfortunate, the guy knows a lot about his dad's work, obviously cares deeply about it, and he just can't write very well. He doesn't have that spark. It must be awful to have all the ideas, all the desire, all the love for the stories and simply not be able to make it work. It doesn't help that the poor guy's dad is a writer and storyteller so skilled that he manages to make Dune, a complete disaster that should NRVER have worked, turgid, slow, often silly, and yet Frank Herbert's genius fills it and turns it into one of the greatest works of sf ever written. There aren't many people in history that could have 'taken over' the story from Frank Herbert, and I won't hate on Brian Herbert for failing where almost nobody could ever have succeeded.

Also a fan of all 3 channels

Nice!@@barryhercules7588 I'll definitely say hi if I see you on any of their live streams - fun!

No, this is RU-vid.

This is such a nice and refreshing attitude to see, as opposed to all of the people who keep saying stuff like "they RUINED DUNE by making Kynes a woman / showing Jessica crying / changing Shaddam's hair color / etc." It's like dude, the books will always be there, part of the fun of an adaptation is seeing a fresh spin on things. So many people have made up their minds and hate a film that's not even out yet, just because it doesn't conform to their idea of what it should be like (exactly like the books). IMO the changes are what make the films interesting, and it'd be quite boring if nothing was changed in adaptation.

ikr i loved the crazy costumes including the hats in that adaptation just because it was scifi and who cares they let the costume dept go nuts@@claris108

That’s going to be an extremely difficult movie to make well. Unfortunately I think that messiah would be last film made. Beyond that I’m not sure if mainstream audiences would necessarily understand or enjoy god emperor as well as the rest of the books. I love dune but it gets weird as hell and pretty damn morbid.

It's based on the description of Edrik in messiah

Westworlds soundtrack was Ramin Djawadi (same bloke who did GoT) Hard agree it was incredible

@@jw9485 Well then Reznor did some of the music then. I definitely recognized his piano playing. Maybe they did some collab? Have you heard WW sound track... Oh God it's so good.

There is one cover of a NIN song in Westworld S4's soundtrack, but otherwise I'm unaware of Reznor being involved in the composition of the series

Idk they both seem like different characters to me

@@neutral_10 to me they're similar in the fact they both have visions of the future that they kinda act upon on, without really understanding then or the consequences that much and doing bad things in the name of a greater good. The rumble on AOT and the Jihad on Dune

@@ReegSkywalker I see the similarities but there are key differences. I feel Eren was more about exploring free will while Paul was about the dangers of blindly following a charismatic leader.

Eren is much closer to Leto II imo. They both see and act upon a horrible future of genocide, planning to be seen as a villain and (willingly) getting assassinated to unify the world/universe

Lol found the feminist

lol found the arsehole@@bennygerow you do realize feminism means equality, right? why do women (or other minorities) being equal to men scare you?