Тёмный

Early Christian Texts & The Making of Hell 

Letters and Politics
Подписаться 24 тыс.
Просмотров 93 тыс.
50% 1

Guest: Bart D. Ehrman is the James A. Gray Distinguished Professor of Religious Studies at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill and the author of Journeys to Heaven and Hell: Tours of the Afterlife in the Early Christian Tradition

Опубликовано:

 

6 июл 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 707   
@WaywardWhiteWalker
@WaywardWhiteWalker 2 года назад
It's simple. I see Bart and I click.
@raydavison4288
@raydavison4288 Год назад
Bart must be in big demand. He's on all the atheist-agnostic podcasts.
@garystanfield2274
@garystanfield2274 Год назад
@@raydavison4288 Because he is trained to deceive. Professors and Dr., beware of.
@jesusdeity2010
@jesusdeity2010 Год назад
One of the reasons people misrepresent God / are confused about God are the horrible translation errors in our bibles made by clerks of "a certain denomination". They had no clue about God's intend, so made it fit their conviction. Luckely the original line is clearly visible. 1: God created us after His own image and likeness. Gen 1:27. 2: Man fell. That is what you see in this world: lust, greed, selfishness, strange philosophies, sicknesses, corruption, terrorism, death, etc, etc. Genesis 3. 3: God, the spirit of life, manifests fully in Christ, pays the debt for mankinds fall so we can be indwelled again by His Spirit and be transformed back to origin. John 14-17. Pure grace, love, power of God for His creation. Hence the divine healing miracles and casting out of demons His first friends, i and many others experience up to this day! Some examples of these idiotic translation errors. Saved, from the Greek "Sozo" actually means: made complete, brought back to origin. Eternal life from the Greek "Zoë" means: life of God, divine life. "You will see Jesus coming on the clouds" actually reads: "You will perceive Jesus from a heavenly perspective"... who He is, what He did, who you are IN Him. "Everyone not found in the book of life will be thrown in the lake of fire" actually reads: "Everything not found in the book of life....". Jesus is the book of life, the word made flesh, the exact image of the invisible God. Through Him every lie we believed about God and ourselves will vanish into thin air. 2 cor 3:18, col 3:10. Etc. Holy Spirit brings forth after His own kind. Wrath from the Greek "Orge" means PASSION. So there is no wrath of God upon mankind. God IS love! Wrath from the Greek "Thumos" also means PASSION. There goes the "bowls of wrath" poured out by God over humanity... it's "bowls of boisterous PASSION through Christ" that are poured outt!!! Kpicic. Translated in to judgement, actually reads: "to put straight, a positive judgement. After all the Father judges no-one and the Son took upon Himself all judgement. For... God is love. Parousia. Tranlated as "second comming", means GODS IMMEDIATE PRESENCE. Etc, etc, etc, look it up in the Kittel Theological Dictionary or in any Greek/Hebrew Strong's app. It's there. So now we have ignorant preachers parotting the lie that we have to be saved from God's wrath by Jesus (who is God....) and "have to repent or go to hell and wait for the bus that gets us to heaven". Utter nonsense. In stead it is: God restores us through Christ by His own atoning blood sacrifice and indwelling Holy Spirit, from mankind's fall, to His own image and likeness (Christlikeness) because of... passion. For God so loved the world.... God cannot be tempted to do evil.... There is no turning or shifting with Him.... If you don't love you don't know God, for God is love.... The goal of all instruction is... love The Father Himself loves you.... Jesus healing all..... love Jesus raising the dead..... love Jesus casting out demons.... love Jesus controlling nature..... love If wrath would be in God, it would be the tenth fruit of the Spirit.... and it is not! So... we're made for God's image and likeness Gen 1:27. Man and woman He made them. That got lost in mankinds fall. Hence all confusion, sicknesses, allien doctrines, egoism, etc, etc. Gen 3. Now God stooped down in Christ to, by His perfect sacrifice and Holy Spirit, transforms us back to.... Gen 1:27. John 14-17. God already came full circle. Yay! For us to embrace His Spirit and be changed back to original created value, by His Spirit.
@herminepursch2470
@herminepursch2470 6 месяцев назад
​@@raydavison4288do you believe in preaching to the choir
@raydavison4288
@raydavison4288 6 месяцев назад
@@herminepursch2470: 🤔
@Philusteen
@Philusteen Год назад
I hope Bart knows how much he's appreciated.
@marionfowler4270
@marionfowler4270 Год назад
I hope so too. He's been very helpful for me deconstructing some fundamental fire and brimstone hell trauma. If I ever see him in person he's getting a big hug.
@Philusteen
@Philusteen Год назад
@@marionfowler4270 me too. Unless he's good with a fist bump. 🤓
@solomonessix6909
@solomonessix6909 2 года назад
I personally think that the idea of the lake of fire is derived from the Egyptian funerary tradition and mythology of the journey though the afterlife. It is said that if the heart weighed more than the feather the soul would experience a second death. The second death included having the souls heart fed to a beast, while the soul is destroyed in the eternal burning lake of fire. If you were lucky enough to have been buried with the scarab beetle figurine which prevents the heart from testifying against the soul, the journey would continue on to the field of reeds where they would live out eternity. To my knowledge, the Greeks were educated in Egypt and borrowed heavily from their teachers.
@MrRezillo
@MrRezillo 2 года назад
This is very interesting; thanks for your comment. Can you give some references where I might read up on this? Thank you.
@solomonessix6909
@solomonessix6909 2 года назад
@@MrRezillo ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-1yv_MXNYbAo.html
@solomonessix6909
@solomonessix6909 2 года назад
@@MrRezillo ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-TpsjDFCbcek.html
@solomonessix6909
@solomonessix6909 2 года назад
@@MrRezillo ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-QWl_D79UmN0.html
@solomonessix6909
@solomonessix6909 2 года назад
@@MrRezillo ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-iGe7jcVQ0no.html
@kenk4269
@kenk4269 2 года назад
Amazing as Always.
@peneloped.wenman4388
@peneloped.wenman4388 2 года назад
... thank you so much for this amazing talk ... I eagerly look forward to purchasing Prof. Ehrman's books ...
@WaywardWhiteWalker
@WaywardWhiteWalker 2 года назад
I have to comment again. This was great. Thank you LaP and Bart.
@wallushungry2383
@wallushungry2383 2 года назад
Wow very interesting, a wonderful interview.
@jenniperkins4260
@jenniperkins4260 2 года назад
I love Bart he understands Christians deconverting
@BandiGetOffTheRoof
@BandiGetOffTheRoof Год назад
Yes! He has more credibility with me since he was a preacher first...he knows what it's like to lose faith....but gain truth
@nativeatheist6422
@nativeatheist6422 2 года назад
Always a pleasure to listen to Bart.❤️
@Bisquick
@Bisquick 2 года назад
Interesting as hell. Literally!
@soslothful
@soslothful Год назад
Perhaps heavenly discussion?
@mikehopkins2625
@mikehopkins2625 2 года назад
Bart, I love your books. My favorite was How Jesus Became God. I read it three times. It really shaped my life. Thank you.
@theartzscientist8012
@theartzscientist8012 Год назад
Bart isn’t right. Proof? He has a worldly degree and God doesn’t require them. He doesn’t hear God alone. Is he right about the scriptures? Yes!
@soslothful
@soslothful Год назад
@@theartzscientist8012 Where do you think Bart has erred?
@theartzscientist8012
@theartzscientist8012 Год назад
@@soslothful in his lack of knowing God at all. He’s in his own understanding. He doesn’t hear God.
@soslothful
@soslothful Год назад
@@theartzscientist8012 In essence he does not affirm your ideas about God. Perhaps your ideas are mistaken? More importantly remember Ehrman's scholarship is as a historian, not a theologian. Finally, your reply only states your opinion Ehrman is wrong. You do not cite any specifics.
@theartzscientist8012
@theartzscientist8012 Год назад
@@soslothful I have a calling or anointing from God himself. Erhman doesn’t. This is the difference.
@Patrick77487
@Patrick77487 Год назад
Thanks for having Bart. Aside from breath-taking scholarship, his humor is hilarious.
@jotunman627
@jotunman627 Год назад
ever heard him laugh
@V_George
@V_George 6 месяцев назад
What exactly is breathtaking about his scholarship? He's an atheist for hire pushing self-debunking pseudo-intellectual nonsense on his gullible amen choir.
@australopithecusafarensis5386
@australopithecusafarensis5386 2 года назад
This was a good interview
@TheLionFarm
@TheLionFarm 2 года назад
Only God is Good
@australopithecusafarensis5386
@australopithecusafarensis5386 2 года назад
@@TheLionFarm cute
@Larry30102
@Larry30102 2 года назад
Mitch, just found your channel. You're an excellent interviewer. Excellent production. I love Dr Ehrman. Really appreciate your interview. Subscribed. What a list of interviews!!
@theunclejesusshow8260
@theunclejesusshow8260 2 года назад
Ahem, same here
@redshiftexperiment
@redshiftexperiment 2 года назад
Bart is one of my favorite writers and speakers. Thank you.
@asmartbajan
@asmartbajan 2 года назад
Just make sure you don't follow him into the abyss, from which there is no return, on Judgment Day. On that day there will be overwhelming joy for some, overwhelming sadness for others, and overwhelming anger (gnashing of teeth) for others.
@redshiftexperiment
@redshiftexperiment 2 года назад
​@@asmartbajan I tend to believe that if there was a God, he would not torture most of his creation for thought crimes. These are scare tactics. I kind of pity you if you still believe in such things.
@asmartbajan
@asmartbajan 2 года назад
@@redshiftexperiment Looks like you will be among the angry on that day. But you won't have any real justification to be angry with Him. We are in the Age of Grace. Take full advantage of that, because the opportunity to do so will not be there in the next age. Our lives in this realm are incredibly short - less than 3 billion seconds for the great majority of us. Conversely, the life to come is eternal. *Choose wisely.*
@redshiftexperiment
@redshiftexperiment Год назад
@@asmartbajan since you believe in hell I would be a bit more careful if I were you. YOU WILDLY CURSE ME TO SAY THAT I WILL BE DAMNED TO HELL! BITE YOUR TONGUE YOU ARROGANT LITTLE MAN! I hope your sure of yourself that I dont have the spirit of God in me. Because for a believer like you, more caution should be taken. "Therefore I tell you, every sin and blasphemy will be forgiven people, but (O)the blasphemy against the Spirit will not be forgiven. 32 And whoever speaks a word (P)against the Son of Man (Q)will be forgiven, but (R)whoever speaks against the Holy Spirit will not be forgiven, either in (S)this age or in the age to come."
@ethio1931
@ethio1931 Год назад
@@asmartbajan prove it lmao
@michaelhenry1763
@michaelhenry1763 2 года назад
I really enjoyed the interview. Bart has such a wonderful way of explaining and crafting a narrative.
@edwardlouisbernays2469
@edwardlouisbernays2469 2 года назад
The implication of this is that someone has fraudulently decided that we are a special creation that has a soul, and eliminated the actual words of what Genesis says. Now all other animals don't have a soul. According to the story, all things that live have a soul. So what happened here? Forgery. That's what happened. Chalk one up for vegetarians. There Was No Continuous Hebrew Monotheistic Culture When Yahveh appeared to Moses in the Burning Bush, and announced himself as "the God of thy fathers," he was a total stranger to Moses. How do I know? Read the account. It doesn't take a scholar to read where Moses ASKS who's taking. No, Moses wasn't merely surprised at the voice…he simply didn't know what was going on. (The fact that Moses is just a rehash of the Egyptian Mises is another essay altogether. But for the purposes of this essay, I'm pretending that Moses was a real person.) Moses did not know this Yahveh, and had never heard of him. So that he asked, "What is thy name?" -so that he could report it to the people back home in Egypt, who had never heard it. After some intermission, the God came directly to the point, and declared-here are the exact words-one of the most notorious falsities in the Hebrew text: "And elohim spake unto Moses, and said unto him., anoki Yahveh -- I am the Lord! "And I appeared unto Abraham, unto Isaac, and unto Jacob, by the name of el-shaddai, but by my name Yahveh (JEHOVAH) was I not known to them." (Ex. 6:2, 8.) The Hebrew God for the first time since the world began, is "revealed" to mankind the "ineffable name" of Yahveh, here first appearing in the Bible translations, and there printed as JEHOVAH in capital letters; for more vivid and awe-inspiring impression. But this is a notorious lie-since we known that Moses did not write the first five books of the Hebrew text. In Genesis 2:4, the name YAHVEH first appears; "in the day that Yahveh-elohim made the earth and the heavens." Its first recorded use as a mystical personage, was when Eve "conceived, and bare Cain, and said, I have gotten a man from Yahveh-the Lord." (Gen. 4:1.) The personal name YAHVEH occurs in the Book of Genesis one hundred and fifty-six times. It's spoken dozens of times by Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob, as any one can read in Genesis. Every single time that the title "the Lord" and "the Lord God" appears, it is a false translation by the priests for the Hebrew personal name YAHVEH. Throughout the Hebrew "scriptures" it occurs thousands of times: "The sacred name occurs in Genesis ~156 times; and is found in the Old Testament approximately 6000 times, either alone or in along with another Divine name." More exactly, the Tetragrammaton (YHVH), appears in the Old Testament 6823 times as the proper name of God as the God of Israel. As such it serves to distinguish him from the gods of the other nations." Thus was the Hebrew tribal god YAHVEH distinguished from Bel, and Chemosh, and Dagon, and Shamash, and the dozens of "gods of the nations". Just as James would distinguish his name from Rudolph, or Cary, this was precisely the Hebrew usage-to distinguish one heathen god from another.
@michaelhenry1763
@michaelhenry1763 2 года назад
@@edwardlouisbernays2469 thank you for your post. Why did you post? What are you trying to say ? Why do you use the letter “V” instead of “W”?
@sebolddaniel
@sebolddaniel Год назад
You have the reality we live in which is shadows on a cave, according to Plato, but Hades is another step lower, where you are a shadow of the shadow of the life you lived. Bart really is a groovy guy.
@BethDiane
@BethDiane 2 года назад
The reason women braid their hair is to keep it from tangling.
@ounkwon6442
@ounkwon6442 2 месяца назад
Hell is where we are (overcrowded); Heaven is where we are not. Choose one
@JoeMmt347
@JoeMmt347 2 года назад
Listened this morning. Always enjoy the program!
@avryptickle
@avryptickle 2 года назад
Wild. I’ve listened to your show on kpfk numerous times over the years. It’s weird seeing you out in the wild.
@MisterJang0
@MisterJang0 Год назад
I like the conversation at the end about the Greek word "ecclesia". I found it fascinating that the word that's commonly translated to "church" in the New Testament isn't a word that means physical buildings, but rather the gathering of people. Some of the earliest churches were modeled on basilicas, which were Roman buildings--usually built near forums--meant for public use and hosted a gathering of citizens for courts and other civic functions. Basilicas were modeled after stoas in the Greek-speaking world, which served a similar purpose since Classical Greece; an inside-area--alongside the agora or marketplace--where people gathered to discuss ideas, engage in religious services, or any number of other functions.
@Isaac5123
@Isaac5123 2 года назад
Thank God for this man
@Isaac5123
@Isaac5123 2 года назад
@@snowymountain9305 what is a bot?
@Isaac5123
@Isaac5123 2 года назад
@@snowymountain9305 and may God Bless you with knowledge. As I think you know and understand Scripture can I ask you what do you make of Isaiah 53 ?
@Isaac5123
@Isaac5123 2 года назад
@@snowymountain9305 I thank you for coming back to me but my question is quite simple and would be grateful of a straight answer first please then I would be glad to move on to your questions
@Isaac5123
@Isaac5123 2 года назад
@@snowymountain9305 now I understand you are in my opinion on the wrong path and been misled by people who have made it christialogical and suited to mislead by incorrect translation. Please refer to Rabbi Tovia Singer for a clear simple explanation of the chapter. I take it you do not understand Hebrew then you would understand unless you wanted to deceive others then I would say goodbye. This is where the apostasy in the church will come from people understanding that they have been lied to. I would imagine that you have merely attended Bible studies with no previous experience and been brainwashed. Isiah 53 does not speak of the future at all.
@fretnesbutke3233
@fretnesbutke3233 2 года назад
In reference to the Greek, Homeric concept of the afterlife,what wasn't mentioned was the Elysian Fields, which contrasts with the rather bleak depiction of Hades as a pleasantly blissful afterlife. The Greeks were as fuzzy as the Hebrew concept as to what to expect as well as some clear instructions on how to exercise control over one's final destiny.
@michaelsommers2356
@michaelsommers2356 2 года назад
I think the Elysian fields was a later development.
@martifingers
@martifingers 2 года назад
Very good conducted interview. Prof Ehrman is able to clarify without oversimplifying. Quite the opposite in fact.
@user-yv2bd7qm4p
@user-yv2bd7qm4p 2 года назад
Plato does not get nearly enough credit for his 4th-5th century B.C.E. contribution to Jewish and Christian depictions of Hades, Gehenna, Tartarus and eternal punishment that were written centuries after his dialogues, Phaedo, Gorgias, Republic, etc.🔥🔥🔥🤔
@edwardlouisbernays2469
@edwardlouisbernays2469 2 года назад
Dude! Mastreo V Bart D. Ehrman series on Christianity I have watched Many Many times. Impressive scholar
@orthodoxchristianprayers
@orthodoxchristianprayers 2 года назад
Great interview. Great channel. You should check out NT Wright too
@Tubulous123
@Tubulous123 2 года назад
Yes!!! Thank you!!! 1Nation4Life
@bradleywillis1654
@bradleywillis1654 2 года назад
Really like Bart’s new glasses
@tedgrant2
@tedgrant2 2 года назад
I get the impression that Bart is very happy.
@tedgrant2
@tedgrant2 2 года назад
@The Arduous Sierra Divide Fame and fortune might have something to do with it.
@herminepursch2470
@herminepursch2470 7 месяцев назад
​@@tedgrant2How much fame and fortune do you have
@AB-et6nj
@AB-et6nj Год назад
Mitch was a great interviewer
@invokingvajras
@invokingvajras 2 года назад
The popular Christian conception of heaven and hell is remarkably similar to the Buddhist description of these realms. There are a lot of flipped parallels between the two traditions. The meaning of "醍醐" and "Christ" is one of them.
@AbandonedVoid
@AbandonedVoid 2 года назад
Not really. I mean, the idea of reward for the just and punishment for the unjust in the afterlife has been reinvented by several cultures over the years. Buddhist narakas are actually rather distinct from Christian hells when understood in this broader context. Christian Hell has more in common with Egyptian, Hellenic, and Zoroastrian places of punishment.
@johnnastrom9400
@johnnastrom9400 Год назад
It sounds like you do not know much about Buddhism. It also looks like you do not have the guts to respond when you are challenged on your incorrect information.
@curbroadshow
@curbroadshow 2 года назад
After listening to this interview I read parts of the apocalypse of Peter for the first time. How sick and twisted were they back then to imagine and write passages like these, twisted minds perverted by religious doctrine. It’s took 2000 years to even start recovering from these abhorrent fantasies and we’ve still got a long way to go before we are freed from them.
@chiricahuaapache5132
@chiricahuaapache5132 2 года назад
Tell me more. What did you read that was so sick and twisted? Let me know.
@heyalun
@heyalun 2 года назад
@@chiricahuaapache5132 the way it explicitly describes the eternal suffering of the dead. It’s backwards and perverse
@anonUK
@anonUK 2 года назад
That's nothing. Augustine and subsequent writers described the schadenfreude of the angels watching the torturing of the damned in hell.
@curbroadshow
@curbroadshow 2 года назад
@@chiricahuaapache5132 Read it for yourself.
@chiricahuaapache5132
@chiricahuaapache5132 2 года назад
@@curbroadshow No, I can't be bothered. You're a bit of a curmudgeon, aren't you? Are you a Fundy Xristian full to overflowing with God's love?
@NuisanceMan
@NuisanceMan 16 дней назад
In the thumbnail, Bart looks like he just created Hell and is very proud of himself.
@raydavison4288
@raydavison4288 Год назад
I have read the entire "Commedia"(English translation, of course). "Inferno" is the most interesting by far. "Purgatorio" & "Paradiso" can be tedious at times. 😇
@douglashogg4848
@douglashogg4848 2 года назад
Thank God for the Enlightenment.
@Thagomizer
@Thagomizer 2 года назад
The Holocausts of the 20th century had nothing to do with that, obviously.
@bubbafowpend9943
@bubbafowpend9943 Год назад
Dr Ehrman is the man! We're so lucky to have the access we do to great scholars like Bart.
@user-pj7sq7ce1f
@user-pj7sq7ce1f 8 месяцев назад
As being a western lost in his illusions.
@bubbafowpend9943
@bubbafowpend9943 8 месяцев назад
@@user-pj7sq7ce1f tell me, what illusions do all "westerns" believe? I also can't wait to hear about how you have access to all of these peoples' illusions. Do tell!
@herminepursch2470
@herminepursch2470 7 месяцев назад
​@@user-pj7sq7ce1fWhat about your illusions
@AcesK9AGA
@AcesK9AGA 2 года назад
How can one be joyful in heaven when their loved ones isn’t there but in torment for eternity? I believe that those in heaven would be in hell themselves to see and witness that
@manifold1476
@manifold1476 2 года назад
Let's say all your "loved ones" made it in the door to heaven, but some of their "loved ones" didn't. - - - Would that mean that you could be "joyful" in heaven, but some of your "loved ones" would have their "heaven" ruined for them, by being unable to be "joyful" in heaven? ? ?
@nasishehim
@nasishehim 2 года назад
There's no validity for relationships in afterlife... Each person is responsible for himself only...
@markderksen4130
@markderksen4130 2 года назад
Their mind will be so at one with God's that they will care as much about those people as God does.
@christopherianlister5212
@christopherianlister5212 2 года назад
@@nasishehim must be a sociopath
@ronbanks1541
@ronbanks1541 2 года назад
@@nasishehim there is no validity in relationships in the afterlife? The afterlife is the recreation of the new earth, which is patterned after Eden. Adam and Eve did not have a relationship? God created each of us to have a relationship
@bookmouse2719
@bookmouse2719 2 года назад
"Hell" came from Greek mythology. This isn't mentioned that much in the Torah, barely in psalms, certainly not the way christians talk about it with fire and stuff.
@anonUK
@anonUK 2 года назад
It was originally the "weeping and gnashing of teeth", I think, no doubt accompanied by the rending of garments. The threats of hell were used to stop you coveting your lord's money, his wife or indeed his ass.
@heyalun
@heyalun 2 года назад
The equivalent to hades in the Christian scriptures is sheol. There’s no change. The only weird mention is one of Jesus’ parables where he says that someone that had been rich dies and is suffering and speaking to Abraham. But other than that, Jesus and the apostles taught that the dead were just dead.
@anonUK
@anonUK 2 года назад
@@heyalun Most of it was reversal of the idea of heaven. Heaven was above, so it was bright, airy, offering a clear view of everything and everyone. It was basically inherited from the Greek idea of Mount Olympus. Hell was obviously below ground and magma coming through volcanic eruptions was a clear indication of what was below. It was unbearably hot, crowded with millions of sinners reincarnated for torture, and dark except for the blazing fires of magma. The environment of hell, minus the demons torturing the multitudes of unrepentant sinners, is pretty much the same as the conditions which exist in the mantle layer of the earth.
@heyalun
@heyalun 2 года назад
@@anonUK ok, but that’s not the biblical presentation. That may be a later development, but biblically dead people are dead, not “reincarnated.”
@anonUK
@anonUK 2 года назад
@@heyalun Well, they could feel the pain of the tortures, otherwise there wouldn't be much point having them. Maybe "reincarnated" is the wrong word but certainly, the threat of hell was designed to involve heat and pain.
@TrevorDent
@TrevorDent Год назад
As a christian, i love Bart's work. To me he brings back so much biblical clarity away from 'Church Gospel'. Yes, heaven and Hell are constructs created by later church/pagan fathers, not from the words of Christ nor from the bible forefathers. Again thank you Bart Ehrman.
@lepidoptera9337
@lepidoptera9337 Год назад
You can analyze the work of the "forefathers" just as well and you will discover just as much bullshit in it. The Christ is, of course, an invention. Jesus was real. He was an apocalyptic preacher and an idiot who got himself killed by the Romans. Beyond that it's pretty much all fairytale.
@IsaacNussbaum
@IsaacNussbaum Год назад
*"...heaven and Hell are constructs created by later church/pagan fathers...."* You are absolutely correct. When I try to explain that to church folk they generally look at me like I have a forked tongue and cloven hooves.
@kobe51
@kobe51 2 года назад
Bart is a fresh air for Christianity
@sandormccann2546
@sandormccann2546 Год назад
Bart destroys christ-stain-inanity for intelligent, rational people.
@herminepursch2470
@herminepursch2470 7 месяцев назад
You don't really think you're rational do you
@OddawallWood
@OddawallWood Год назад
Gradation of reward? Like when the priest gets a Ford and the rabbi gets a Lincoln because the rabbi is related to the boss.
@thetruthaboutscienceandgod6921
@thetruthaboutscienceandgod6921 2 года назад
Please share my two brief videos with other people. Thank you!
@c.h.ingate5271
@c.h.ingate5271 2 года назад
Mitch, thanks for presenting Dr. Ehrman. He's a great and articulate scholar.
@TheLionFarm
@TheLionFarm 2 года назад
No he is NOT Matthew 10:28 And fear not them which kill the body, but are not able to kill the soul: but rather fear him which is able to destroy both soul and body in hell.Luke 12:5 But I will forewarn you whom you shall fear: Fear him, which after he has killed has power to cast into hell; yes, I say to you, Fear him. READ EZEKIEL 32
@anonymousjohnson976
@anonymousjohnson976 2 года назад
@@TheLionFarm : Yes, he is! Try reading something other than the mythical and superstitious book.
@alalohwhydee
@alalohwhydee 2 года назад
Constantine/Rome didn’t take over control of the church at the time of the conference at Nicea - but wasn’t it so that at this stage the Christian church had their meeting places provided for by the Roman Empire and from then on they were beholden to the Secular state for funds, favor etc. and thereby made themselves willingly the servants of Rome from that time on into the present?
@mysterious_monolith_
@mysterious_monolith_ 2 года назад
Before watching this I was hoping Bart Ehrman could explain some details that would help me finally conclude that hell is not real, so that if I wanted to I could kill myself. But what happened is 42:20 , I realized hell is definitely not real, but life is more precious than I had acknowledged, because this really is all we have. That makes me want to live until my time is up naturally, rather than take matters into my own hands.
@christianhinojosa848
@christianhinojosa848 2 года назад
That's kinda amazing
@wannabe_scholar82
@wannabe_scholar82 2 года назад
hey man I just wanna say whether u come to the conclusions hell is or isn't real to not take your life man. I'm sure people love and care about you and that's a really heavy thing for people's families or friends when a love one does that. you have alot to live for, don't miss out on it.
@geofromnj7377
@geofromnj7377 2 года назад
Why in the world would you think hell was real? Was it because a few religious fanatics decided to write fiction on papyrus and pass it around?
@theartzscientist8012
@theartzscientist8012 Год назад
Hell is real. There has to be a place for child molesters and sinners.
@theartzscientist8012
@theartzscientist8012 Год назад
Oh, and don’t kill yourself! You are valued by God.
@llt8101
@llt8101 2 года назад
I prefer the tour of "hell" and "heaven" in Vergil's Aeneid. Everyone who is punished or rewarded is just there long enough to forget their old life and then they are reborn on Earth.
@TheLionFarm
@TheLionFarm 2 года назад
30:00 smh Luke 12:5 But I will forewarn you whom you shall fear: Fear him, which after he has killed has power to cast into hell; yes, I say to you, Fear him. Matthew 10:28 And fear not them which kill the body, but are not able to kill the soul: but rather fear him which is able to destroy both soul and body in hell.
@patrickmac2799
@patrickmac2799 Год назад
Who could believe in such an impossibly cruel and sadistic deity? Utter nonsense.
@danielsnyder2288
@danielsnyder2288 2 года назад
How much do the Christian versions of hell rely on Platos story of El?
@SliceySlicer
@SliceySlicer 2 года назад
I'd pay to watch Dr. Erhman debate Christian Prince on Christianity.
@shaunigothictv1003
@shaunigothictv1003 2 года назад
Bart would destroy Christian Prince on New Testament studies. Christian Prince is not fluent in Koine Greek.
@APracticingGamer
@APracticingGamer 18 дней назад
And they shall go forth, and look upon the the carcases of the men that have transgressed against me: for their worm shall not die, neither shall their fire be quenched; and they shall be an abhoring unto all flesh. Old testament
@christopherp.hitchens3902
@christopherp.hitchens3902 2 года назад
Christians will sometimes claim to understand why someone might want to invent heaven but ….WHO, they ask, would ever invent “hell”? The answer is, of course, for all the people you don’t like! “We are the pure and chosen few and all the rest are damned. There’s room enough in hell for you; we don’t want heaven crammed.”
@williamoldaker5348
@williamoldaker5348 2 года назад
What makes religious/spiritual beliefs distinguishable from that of mere make-believe? It's ultimately a matter of make-believe, of individual interpretation.
@alisonpovey1234
@alisonpovey1234 Месяц назад
I've been a Christian all my life 72 years. Hmm. I guess not many Christians are going to get to be saved. I gave it all up 5 years ago when I found so many people in the Bible , thousands were exterminated by God. Even little children and babies. I don't know what I'd call myself now. I love listening to your blogs, and Mythvision. I really enjoy now not having to pretend to believe. This is freedom. Thank you Sir😊
@Ordinal_Yoda
@Ordinal_Yoda Год назад
Amazing how unbelievable the acumulative total of everything equalling one word "All". Whereas naturally within is "All Power" and "All Knowledge". Where as "All Laws" root from. The Laws of Motion. Which necessarily had application prior of material materializing. Exactly Three laws descibing the One Concept. Motion. The Lord of Hosts.
@jesperandersson889
@jesperandersson889 2 года назад
soul-body separation yess a Greek concept - origins of Aristotles' sway over theology as well
@AB-et6nj
@AB-et6nj Год назад
I think it's a pretty big tell that God isn't behind Christianity when Judaism has no conception of an afterlife or heaven and hell in its scriptures. That's pretty central to Christianity and even Islam. Why would that be omitted? Not to mention the peculiar coincidence that the ideas of heaven and hell are related to Zoroastrianism and other beliefs in the mid-5th century BC + time period.
@sdlorah6450
@sdlorah6450 Год назад
There are references to the afterlife in the Old Testament. Job said, For I know that my redeemer liveth, and that he shall stand at the latter day upon the earth: And though after my skin worms shall destroy my body, yet in my flesh shall I see God: Whom I shall see for myself, and mine eyes shall behold, and not another; though my reins be consumed within me. (Job 19:25-27) The prophet said, And many of them that sleep in the dust of the earth shall awake, some to everlasting life, and some to shame and everlasting contempt. (Daniel 12:2) The Psalmist wrote, But those that seek my soul, to destroy it, shall go into the lower parts of the earth. (Psalm 63:9) Also we read, For great is thy mercy toward me: and thou hast delivered my soul from the lowest hell. (Psalm 86:13) The words ‘lower parts of the earth’ and ‘lowest hell’ speak of different degrees of punishment as confirmed in the New Testament when Jesus spoke of some people’s judgment as being more tolerable while others would receive the greater damnation (ref. Matthew 10:15, Matthew 23:14). Jesus spoke of hell to the Jews in the account of Lazarus and the rich man as found in Luke 16:19-31. He made many reference to a literal hell on a number of occasions (Matthew 10:28, Matthew 25:41, Matthew 25:46, etc.) God provided a way for us sinners to escape his just wrath in hell by sending his Son, the Lord Jesus Christ, to suffer for our sins, his innocent blood shed, that we might be forgiven (John 3:16, 1 Corinthians 15:3-4). Each person is called to put their faith in Jesus Christ as Savior and thereby receive the gift of eternal life (Romans 6:23).
@AB-et6nj
@AB-et6nj Год назад
@@sdlorah6450 I appreciate all the quotes. But it still seems extremely scant in the Hebrew Bible. The Jewish belief is nothing like what Christians believe, which is mostly apocalyptic
@sdlorah6450
@sdlorah6450 Год назад
@@AB-et6nj Jesus said that salvation is of the Jews (ref. John 4:22) The Son of God was born of the Jews; he was without sin and therefore could be the sacrificial lamb who bore the sins of the whole world (Isaiah 53:4-6). Salvation and all that it means as well as God's wrath in hell are expounded upon in the New Testament. The New Testament makes frequent references to the Old Testament in these explanations.
@AB-et6nj
@AB-et6nj Год назад
@@sdlorah6450 But if there was always original sin (because of Adam and Eve) then why didn't God tell the Jews this? Or that their punishment would result in hellfire? Why was it only in Christianity that this was a problem?
@sdlorah6450
@sdlorah6450 Год назад
@@AB-et6nj Just a sampling of Old Testament verses about God and his wrath are listed above; there are others. Adam and Eve and then Noah and his sons transmitted to their descendants a knowledge of God. God has revealed himself to all in a general sense through creation and men's consciences (see Psalm 19, Romans 2:15). In a special sense, he revealed himself to the Jews, the Old Testament prophets, and writers of scripture to the end of making his plan known to redeem mankind through his Son's sacrificial death. Lastly, he spoke to us through his Son (see Hebrews 1:1-2). Gentile people (non Jews) living before the completion of the New Testament responded to God's revelation of himself. For example, the men of Nineveh repented at the preaching of Jonah. The queen of the south sought out the wisdom of King Solomon (see Jonah, Matthew 12:41-42). We have the whole counsel of God in the completed Bible; we live AFTER the resurrection of Jesus Christ from the dead. We have much more than the men of Nineveh or the queen of the south had; God said that they will testify against those who rejected Jesus Christ in person in the coming judgment. For his purposes, God has chosen to reveal truth over time. He has chosen to expound upon truth over time. We can benefit from the work of Jesus Christ on the cross through simple faith in him, receiving eternal life (see Romans 6:23). Of God, the Bible says, And [he] hath made of one blood all nations of men for to dwell on all the face of the earth, and hath determined the times before appointed, and the bounds of their habitation; That they should seek the Lord, if haply they might feel after him, and find him, though he be not far from every one of us...And the times of this ignorance God winked at; but now commandeth all men every where to repent (Acts 17:26-27, 30). I recommend that you seek God humbly in calling out to his Son for forgiveness, in reading the scriptures for yourself, and in listening to Bible preaching like as can be found in Love Worth Finding with Adrian Rogers.
@Joseph-fw6xx
@Joseph-fw6xx 11 месяцев назад
Bart is just a happy going guy good to see laughter once in a while
@ericjohnson6665
@ericjohnson6665 2 года назад
interestingly enough, no near-death experiences ever report visiting hell. One is inclined to think the only hell there is, is one of our own, or others', making. A universe dominated by love would not have any room for a hell in it.
@commonberus1
@commonberus1 2 года назад
Not quiet there are a minority of NDE's that are bad.
@chiricahuaapache5132
@chiricahuaapache5132 2 года назад
There are loads on You Tube, mostly by people who later write books. Just type the words, I Died and Went to Hell.
@Raiden-the-Goat32
@Raiden-the-Goat32 2 года назад
@@chiricahuaapache5132 But they did not actually die they may of been near death but not actually dead. Also they could of been on certain drug's or medicine that induce vivid dream's as such these experiences are not realable.
@Raiden-the-Goat32
@Raiden-the-Goat32 2 года назад
@@chiricahuaapache5132 Also people can lie with an NDE and what their experience was and people can misunderstand an experience they had.
@lastchance8142
@lastchance8142 Год назад
Actually, there are a fair number of NDEs having a "bad" experience, including "hellish" places. Something like 11%. Like the "good" NDEs reported, there are endless variations on these accounts, so it's hard to take away anything concrete. Also, people may be less likely to report these, for obvious reasons.
@moesypittounikos
@moesypittounikos 2 года назад
Bart should do a dismantling of Swedenborg's writings
@UniDocs_Mahapushpa_Cyavana
@UniDocs_Mahapushpa_Cyavana 2 года назад
Hell is a pretty natural conclusion for what to do with anyone who is undesirable to the Kingdom of Heaven. And of course, the clergy would make the thing more emotional. Although demons only appear on Earth in the Bible, so they are completely unconnected with Hell in the Bible.
@chuzzbot
@chuzzbot 2 года назад
Comic book stories always have some element of truth, they should not be taken too seriously. All religious texts share the same tradition as any superhero story.
@soslothful
@soslothful Год назад
Adolescent ridicule. Well done.
@jetdeleon
@jetdeleon 2 года назад
If there’s a special place in hell for bad christians, what does that say about the doctrine’s effectiveness in influencing people to behave morally? Thanks for giving me another reason to convert to Judaism.
@granadosvm
@granadosvm Год назад
Something they didn't touch on the last segment, is Jesus used to teach in Aramaic, the gospels were written for a Greek speaking audience, so they are supposed to be translations, but in Aramaic the word "rock" is nothing like Simon, nor Peter, so there is slim to none probability that Jesus really said that.
@launareynolds427
@launareynolds427 Год назад
He’s not expounding on the literal power and existence of the Holy Spirit
@soslothful
@soslothful Год назад
I'm made intensely curious about the teasingly out of focus painting behind Bart. And did I hear correctly? Did Bart state Constentine did not make Christianity the official religion of the Empire?
@IsaacNussbaum
@IsaacNussbaum Год назад
Yes. He says that at the 10:39 mark.
@tastyfrzz1
@tastyfrzz1 2 года назад
So in the gospel of Nicodemus did Christ also save those from an infinite number of other worlds going back 13 billion years?
@fluentpiffle
@fluentpiffle 2 года назад
There is one biblical story that intrigues me, and that is the story of Noah. I think this may be a timeless anecdote that we can apply to any 'knower' of today. It then takes on the form of a kind of collective unconscious prediction, as anyone who followed the trail of truth would ultimately find themselves in the same position as the biblical character, and likely HAS done through the ages; Giordano Bruno, for instance.. This would explain why the story retains an air of credibility. The events unfolding in the story WOULD mimic the real life situation in ANY age, given that the underlying nature of Humans remains roughly the same. Behaviour is predictable once it wears itself into a pattern, and that in itself is a perfect example of how nature works, at the fundamental level.. Religion itself has, of course, long since been usurped into a weapon of politics, and thus lost any of its face value. ("We don't talk about Bruno!") - But what has been carried inside the 'vehicle', so to speak, are any timeless aspects remaining, those where any relevance to truth can still be found..
@edwardlouisbernays2469
@edwardlouisbernays2469 2 года назад
A Few Translations These translations, while only three in number, will change your whole way of thinking about what is being presented in your Bible. Son of Man: In all three major Semitic languages (Aramaic, Hebrew, and Arabic) the term barnasha means "human being". Jesus often referred to himself as a human being (28 times in the Gospels). Barnasha comes from bar (son) and nasha (man). The meaning of barnasha has created a lot of confusion in the Gospels. It is impossible to translate the Aramaic term of barnasha literally as "son of man" - and yet most biblical translators have and still do just that to this day. In the Aramaic language the word bar is combined with many other words to create different meanings - most specifically is means a "likeness." For example barabba means "resembles his father". Barhila translated literally would mean "son of power" but in reality it means "soldier". So when we read in the Gospels the phrase "son of man" it should be read correctly as "human being". Son of God: The word bar means a likeness or resemblance to the suffix word. The Aramaic term that Son of God comes from is bardalaha. Translated literally as "son of God" it does not mean this. Bardalaha in reality means "like God" or "God-like". So when Jesus is referred to as the "Son of God" we should read this correctly as "God-like" or "like God". So what does that tell you about the translation we read in today's Bibles? It tells you that Jesus was not the Son of God - but that he was "God-like". There is a big difference. Jesus himself repeatedly referred to himself as a "human being". The Aramaic reference does not mean one is physically divine - it means there is an important spiritual relationship between God and the man whom is bestowed that phraseology. In addition, don't forget that the Council of Nicea in 325 CE voted to change the human Jesus to a supernatural being. It wasn't until that time that any church thought of Jesus as such. Only Begotten Son: The world ehedaya is Aramaic. It is very important to understand its meaning when hearing that phrase being bantered about. When we read that Jesus was God's "only begotten son" - it is an incorrect translation of the Aramaic word. The term is found exclusively in the Gospel of John. The phrase we read in English was translated from a Greek word, monogenes. Monos means "single" or "one" and genos means "kind". So the Greek translation originally was with "one-of-a-kind". So where does 'begotten' come from? The Greek word genos is distantly related to the verb gennan which means "to beget". Thus, to translate monogenes as "only begotten" is improper and incorrect--which is an indication of an ill-trained translator being involved with the text. The actual translation should be "unique son" or "one-of-a-kind". The Aramaic word ehedaya means "sole heir" and "the beloved". So when we combine monogenes ehedaya we get "one-of-a-kind, beloved son". That's considerably different from 'only begotten son'.
@fluentpiffle
@fluentpiffle 2 года назад
@@edwardlouisbernays2469 Thanks for the info. The same is occurring everywhere today. The term 'Big Bang' was first used by Sir Fred Hoyle as a rather sarcastic retort to the idea that all of existence could magically appear from 'nothing', as physicists suggest! (The quality of understanding seems to be going backwards!). Then the pope of the time, and with great delight, found it necessary to endorse the idea.. "In fact, it seems that present-day science, with one sweeping step back across millions of centuries, has succeeded in bearing witness to that primordial 'Fiat lux' (Let there be light) uttered at the moment when, along with matter, there burst forth from nothing a sea of light and radiation, while the particles of the chemical elements split and formed into millions of galaxies ... Hence, creation took place in time, therefore, there is a Creator, God exists!" (Pope Pius XII, 1951) Yippee!
@mirando100
@mirando100 2 года назад
The term "Christians" were given by gentiles in Antioch to Jesus followers, not even Paul used that term, Peter used it just once to relate it to persecution. But I don't think neither any apostle developed a theology of "hell", but the had an idea of the underworld where disembodied souls go after death and they are conscious. This idea could have given birth to the idea of hell as punishment for those who reject Jesus Christ. John apostle speaks about Lake of 🔥 fire..this idea is more close to the doctrine of hell.
@sdlorah6450
@sdlorah6450 Год назад
There are references to the afterlife in the Old Testament. Job said, For I know that my redeemer liveth, and that he shall stand at the latter day upon the earth: And though after my skin worms shall destroy my body, yet in my flesh shall I see God: Whom I shall see for myself, and mine eyes shall behold, and not another; though my reins be consumed within me. (Job 19:25-27) The prophet said, And many of them that sleep in the dust of the earth shall awake, some to everlasting life, and some to shame and everlasting contempt. (Daniel 12:2) The Psalmist wrote, But those that seek my soul, to destroy it, shall go into the lower parts of the earth. (Psalm 63:9) Also we read, For great is thy mercy toward me: and thou hast delivered my soul from the lowest hell. (Psalm 86:13) The words ‘lower parts of the earth’ and ‘lowest hell’ speak of different degrees of punishment as confirmed in the New Testament when Jesus spoke of some people’s judgment as being more tolerable while others would receive the greater damnation (ref. Matthew 10:15, Matthew 23:14). Jesus spoke of hell to the Jews in the account of Lazarus and the rich man as found in Luke 16:19-31. He made many reference to a literal hell on a number of occasions (Matthew 10:28, Matthew 25:41, Matthew 25:46, etc.) God provided a way for us sinners to escape his just wrath in hell by sending his Son, the Lord Jesus Christ, to suffer for our sins, his innocent blood shed, that we might be forgiven (John 3:16, 1 Corinthians 15:3-4). Each person is called to put their faith in Jesus Christ as Savior and thereby receive the gift of eternal life (Romans 6:23).
@RomanPaganChurch
@RomanPaganChurch Год назад
Mostly true, but you're confusing the translation of hell with what was actually said in Hebrew and Greek.
@chinering23
@chinering23 Год назад
The traditional view of hell as a fiery cauldron of punishment has been taught for centuries. Perhaps one of the earliest to expound this view among Christians was the Catholic theologian Tertullian, who lived around A.D. 160-225 Hades. The KJV translates ᾅδης (hades) and Γέεννα (Gehenna) both as "hell", unlike modern versions of the bible which transliterate ᾅδης as 'Hades'. KJV onlyists criticize that the idea of Hades being separate from hell is an idea from Paganism and not biblical.
@matthewdowns9507
@matthewdowns9507 2 года назад
you're like the ronnie james dio of religious scholar book writing.
@RichWoods23
@RichWoods23 2 года назад
Holy Diver?
@matthewdowns9507
@matthewdowns9507 2 года назад
@@RichWoods23 😆
@cynthiaharvey6155
@cynthiaharvey6155 2 года назад
If Jesus died for our sins, why would there be a judging of sinful people.....I know some people are evil and or wicked so I'm not speaking of those ones, but for ones who just simply sin and err, why would they be judged and tormented FOREVER... Also I learned that there's no literal burning flames that's meant for people to burn forever rather that, there will be an eternal distructiion for the wicked ones, after all Adam and Eve didn't even burn nor were they tormented FOREVER, but ETERNALLY DESTROYED. If we were born in sin how would it be justfied for us to be eternally tormented for sinning a short while here on Earth, that would NOT make any sense at all, let's say we live 100 years, burning or being tormented FOREVER, would never be in any way a fair punishment at all. One hundred years is by no means a comparison to FOREVER. This is my understanding from a personal study of the Bible, I know NOTHING FOR CERTAIN, as none of us do.
@MrRezillo
@MrRezillo 2 года назад
Good points. Yes, if we all have "original sin" beyond our control, why be tortured eternally for it?
@scambammer6102
@scambammer6102 2 года назад
@@MrRezillo why be punished for it at all?
@cynthiaharvey6155
@cynthiaharvey6155 2 года назад
It's in the Bible so it can't be denied. I am a former J W so we HAD to study the Bible, supposedly daily but at least very regularly and I did just that. This is confusing, and I've been saying something was wrong for a few years now, even when I disassociated myself from the J W's. How can we get the TRUTH when there are so many different views about the SCRIPTURES. None of this is making too much sense. I know what I desire to believe and all I can do is hope in that. I can say that I do believe that, there's a CREATOR, and after that I'm pretty much lost.
@DocZom
@DocZom 2 года назад
Hold on. You are trying to make logical sense out of myth and superstition. Good luck with that.
@DocZom
@DocZom 2 года назад
@@cynthiaharvey6155 "It's in the Bible so it can't be denied" Do you really think that? Why?
@tryme3969
@tryme3969 Год назад
Is the Bible more of a manual for creating Heaven on earth or Hell on earth?
@emp-ty-g
@emp-ty-g 2 года назад
funny how much people have written about things we dont know anything about. is it fear of dead and the unknown? or is it the prise of human intelligence. we can see what we dont know and make up histories
@APracticingGamer
@APracticingGamer 18 дней назад
Hell predates the new testament, the apostles take the wordage from the prophetic books that they grew up reading and studying. Bart got caught up in contradictions in the gospels, he is a seed that fell by the way side.
@BandiGetOffTheRoof
@BandiGetOffTheRoof Год назад
I've never heard any reasoning as to what keeps people in heaven from ever sinning while there. For billions and trillions of years...not one slip up of sin. Do they not have free will once in heaven? How it is different from the Earthly paradise God created, that produced sin immediately with Adam and Eve.
@RomanPaganChurch
@RomanPaganChurch Год назад
This is the inherent nature of flesh verses the desire to follow the Will of God. If we have a natural desire to follow the Will of God then when all temptation is removed, it should come naturally.
@lepidoptera9337
@lepidoptera9337 Год назад
If you can trust a Catholic priest on the matter then, no, we can't sin in heaven. He described heaven to me as a place where we are all gathered around god's glory in eternal bliss. I was eight years old at a time. Guess what happens if you tell an eight year old kid with ADHD that heaven is the place where he has to sit still and look at a giant lightbulb all day long? You make an eight year old hard atheist in an instant. :-)
@lepidoptera9337
@lepidoptera9337 Год назад
@@RomanPaganChurch And there is the person who doesn't know how the bible defines "sin". Don't worry, none of you have ever found the passage. It's too obvious to be visible to the religious. ;-)
@IsaacNussbaum
@IsaacNussbaum Год назад
@@lepidoptera9337 ✴ _Therefore, to him who knows to do good and does not do it, to him it is sin._ (James 4: 17; KJV)
@lepidoptera9337
@lepidoptera9337 Год назад
@@IsaacNussbaum You just made a fool of yourself, kid. Good job! ;-) Having said that, at least you made one of the more interesting entries in this contest. Most people didn't get even that far.
@APracticingGamer
@APracticingGamer 18 дней назад
And the sea gave up the dead which were in it: and death and hell delivered up the dead which were in them: and they were judged everyman according to his works. And death and hell were cast into the lake of fire. This is the second death. Your not just going to hell Bart, your not worried about hell alone people, eternal damnation is not in hell. It's much worse than that. And whosoever was not found written in the book of life was cast into the lake of fire.
@mrandersong1
@mrandersong1 2 года назад
I’m just worried that what if it really exists? Where do all the bad people go? Stalin and hitler or sinners etc?
@shaunigothictv1003
@shaunigothictv1003 2 года назад
Good point John.
@mrandersong1
@mrandersong1 2 года назад
@@shaunigothictv1003 thanks
@herminepursch2470
@herminepursch2470 7 месяцев назад
Don't be worried. Enjoy your life. Love God and be kind to others.
@herminepursch2470
@herminepursch2470 7 месяцев назад
Where bad people go is. Not your problem
@faridaali8758
@faridaali8758 Год назад
When we died we didn’t go straightaway to heaven or hell.Our spirit are stored in a special place above the Earth in heavenly realms.If you are someone who denies the existence of your creator or attributed partner with Him then your soul will stay in the Earth until resurrection day
@user-lj9zq4dr5t
@user-lj9zq4dr5t Год назад
Liar
@herminepursch2470
@herminepursch2470 7 месяцев назад
That's not what I believe.
@herminepursch2470
@herminepursch2470 7 месяцев назад
There's a difference Between. Lying and expressing your opinion.
@rockitbitz
@rockitbitz 2 года назад
I had to switch off, got fed up with Ehrman laughing at his own commentary. I've watched a great many of his presentations, have lost the ability to switch off when he does it, I guess it's a nervous thing but it comes across as condescending, even when what he is saying is absolutely right.
@DRSulik
@DRSulik 2 года назад
Shameful bigotry of not giving the fiery Hell of the Egyptians who were the rulers of the Canaanite lands far longer than the Greeks, any recognition. Nor the book of Enoch.
@shaunigothictv1003
@shaunigothictv1003 2 года назад
Agreed.
@marceloorellana5726
@marceloorellana5726 2 года назад
Best friend? That was Achilles' lover. 🤦🏼 We're adults and educated. Don't patronize.
@carlchapman-iz1dk
@carlchapman-iz1dk 2 месяца назад
Great man and info, 'but a little less laughing and a little more knowledge, please' most of his interview is taken up with his laughter 😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂 I bought his book , very expensive , but it's fantastic well worth the price .
@ericjohnson6665
@ericjohnson6665 2 года назад
Of course, all writings about hell by the authors of the Bible are pure speculation and supposition. None of them were ever there. What Paul thought he saw may or may not be reliable. But Jesus always wanted his listeners to focus on the positive, love, truth, beauty, and goodness.
@tastyfrzz1
@tastyfrzz1 2 года назад
So if all of these books were just fiction why pay any attention to any of them?
@martifingers
@martifingers 2 года назад
I guess there are several main reasons: 1. Like it or not, they are a significant influence (albeit indirect and now highly mediated) on our cultural life and political and legal structures etc. 2. Myths like these are often very good guides to the desires and repressions of the human psyche. (They are often just interesting stories too!) 3. It is useful to be aware when encountering apologetics.
@r0ky_M
@r0ky_M 2 года назад
Great segment with Bart, but way too much educational information for Sunday school simpleton Xtians.
@soslothful
@soslothful Год назад
Why do you think Christians are simpletons?
@r0ky_M
@r0ky_M Год назад
@@soslothful I don't think, I know for certain.
@soslothful
@soslothful Год назад
@@r0ky_M Well, that is bold, but you duck posting examples.
@r0ky_M
@r0ky_M Год назад
@@soslothful It encounter such Xtian simpletons on a regular basis and their blatant dishonesty is another problem they display.
@harryhagman6063
@harryhagman6063 2 года назад
EVER SEEN ESTUS PIRKLE AND RON ORMAN'S 1974'S "THE BURNING HELL "?.
@herminepursch2470
@herminepursch2470 7 месяцев назад
No
@guarddog318
@guarddog318 2 года назад
Jesus goes to Hades? So he just decided to visit his old buddy the Greek god of the underworld? Interesting. Also, anybody else notice the similarities between "Hell" and the Germanic goddess of the dead, Hel/Hella? Personally, I'm of the opinion that the whole idea of "Hell" stems from the Germanic tribes that were giving the Romans such fits - and who ultimately finished off the Roman Empire. I mean, really... does it seem like so far-fetched a notion that when the bible was being put together, that the Roman Catholic Church would say something like "A place of punishment? Hmm... how 'bout we 'borrow' that bit about the underworld from those damned barbarians that we never managed to conquer?"
@AbandonedVoid
@AbandonedVoid 2 года назад
The New Testament was written in Greek. The Greek word "Hades" was used when referring to underworlds in general by the ancient Greeks, not just the Greek underworld, sort of in the same way that they called Thoth "Hermes." The Aramaic (and Hebrew) word that gets translated to Greek as "Hades" is "Sheol," which was more of a poetic term for the land of the dead that is more accurately translated as "the grave," since ancient Jews believed that the soul died with the body. "Hell" was the Germanic word for the underworld, and English is a Germanic language. So you're actually completely on the mark about where the name comes from, but it's due to translation and not intentionally copying the mythology of other cultures. That said, other words were later erroneously translated as Hell, too, like Gehenna, which was a real, physical place where the bodies of criminals were burned in a massive pit because they were unworthy of having a decent burial. This is actually where the idea of Hell being a place of fire comes from, and it's genuinely a part of Jewish tradition rather than a syncretic element from any other culture. But when Paul redesigned Heaven to be an afterlife, rather than the resurrection in New Jerusalem that Jesus promised, it also made the metaphorical destruction of the wicked in Gehenna into an afterlife, too, because the souls said to burn in Gehenna were no longer seen as mortal. This ended up implying that Gehenna was a kind of underworld, which is why it ended up being translated as such and being conflated with other references to Sheol.
@guarddog318
@guarddog318 2 года назад
@@AbandonedVoid - Hades is the ruler of the Greek version of the underworld, Tartarus. The same is true for Hel and Helheim, which is a realm in Niflheim ( Norse/Germanic underworld. ) And do keep in mind the connection between the Romans and Greece... A connection close enough that mistranslations between Greek, Latin, and the Germanic/Scandinavian languages should have been a rare thing. Those were the common languages of the day in Rome, back when the Roman Catholic Church was being formed. Anyway, the fact is that Christianity borrows or steals quite heavily from earlier religions, and has done its best to either "Christianise" or outright eradicate the earlier belief systems that were still in place when it was adopted by the Romans. That last is the reason the neopagan movement of the past 20-25 years is so wrong about so many old practices; there's just not much information left concerning the druids, or the Germanic religions. And what little we do have is written by people already converted to the Christian way of thinking.
@darfcrow
@darfcrow 2 года назад
I heard "Damned forever". I thought Christians believed in redemption and forgiveness?
@timproffit7861
@timproffit7861 2 года назад
Same here. I was under the impression that God heard Jesus' prayer, Father forgive them (us, sinners) for they know not what they do (sin). And as he said it it finished, that mankind was finally redeemed. Giving the accounts of how many Christians were in hell, and that some of them simply because of doctrinal error, such as seeing Jesus as more of Divine than human. Wow, not sure if I can buy that. My hat is off to him for his research and and study of Patristics. But not all of the Church fathers held to this view of hell.
@DocZom
@DocZom 2 года назад
The redemption and forgiveness come before you die. Once you are dead, it is too late to repent. That is when the eternal damnation begins. Telling this story to children is child abuse, regularly practiced by all Christians.
@darfcrow
@darfcrow 2 года назад
@@timproffit7861 If Jesus is the father the son and the holy Spirit, why did he need to "pray" to God? He's literally just talking to himself btw, Billions of people are doing the same thing today
@timproffit7861
@timproffit7861 2 года назад
@@darfcrow He is not the Father, nor is he the Holy Spirit, so of course he dialogs with the Father. They are one but not the same. Look at John17
@darfcrow
@darfcrow 2 года назад
@@timproffit7861I come from the Catholic faith. They DEF believe in the Trinity. Even though it was conceived of in the 14th century. They don't let facts get in the way of a good story!
@RonJohn63
@RonJohn63 Год назад
49:22 The... Assembly of God? (I wonder if that's where the denomination got it's name.)
@edwardlouisbernays2469
@edwardlouisbernays2469 2 года назад
Most Hate Filled is Romans Chapter 1, second part. Paul is the most Antisemitic Person in history. Read the 1611 King James Version where Paul is explicit.
@heyalun
@heyalun 2 года назад
“For I am not ashamed of the good news; it is, in fact, God’s power for salvation to everyone having faith, to the Jew first and also to the Greek.” (Romans 1:16) Wow, good news of salvation for everyone faithful, but first the Jews. How hate-filled and antisemetic!
@chrissonofpear1384
@chrissonofpear1384 2 года назад
And then it goes into that clunky, specious business in the next few verses, about how everything has been 'clearly seen and understood', despite being invisible, plus interwoven with a 'fallen' nature.
@igaluitchannel6644
@igaluitchannel6644 5 месяцев назад
Didn't the Zoroastrians also have concepts of resurrection, judgement, heaven and hell? Could have come into Judaism even before the Hellenization.
@rogerwood6893
@rogerwood6893 Год назад
Explain Isaha 45:7
@rogerwood6893
@rogerwood6893 Год назад
it proves that jahova made evil not satan
@chainedmindsasylum
@chainedmindsasylum 2 года назад
These extra biblical books demonstrate what lies people will tell in the name of religion. The NT is no different than the rest of them. Lies everywhere
@dnkhosro4861
@dnkhosro4861 2 года назад
bart heaven and hell came from zeorestrian.. paradise??? you use the word but you do not know its an Iranian word pardis??
@spirituallevelofbeing7308
@spirituallevelofbeing7308 2 года назад
Bart d ehrman is good at his translations he dosent understand gnosticism very well but he's a great translater same with Marvin meyer alot of the translations I use for ancient scriptures I read for my channel are mostly from these two
@latjolajban81
@latjolajban81 2 года назад
Doesn't understand gnostisicm?
@spirituallevelofbeing7308
@spirituallevelofbeing7308 2 года назад
@@latjolajban81 there were many forms of gnosticism and their writing's are full of deeper meanings thus secret teaching gnosticism is not a religion but an alternative to religion the gnostic are mind worshippers they didn't worship a god rather we all make up the cosmic mind of the mother father (energy) itself and that we are the gods living a human experience and that the mother father mind is evolving through us to discover itself before returning home the pleroma (energy or the mother father)
@herminepursch2470
@herminepursch2470 7 месяцев назад
None of us understand completely
@bernardfinucane2061
@bernardfinucane2061 2 года назад
Jesus called Simon Peter (Kepha in Aramaic) as a joke. Simon means clever, and kepha means rock or clod, or stupid person. It's a joke in not very good taste. Matthew is embarrassed by it, but can't just cut it like he did other embarrassing incidents like the fig tree story, or Mary calling Jesus crazy. Peter's name was too well established. So he cooked up the story about Peter being the foundation of the church.
@deewesthill1213
@deewesthill1213 2 года назад
In my opinion, the reason that the two major Christian apostles Simon Peter and Saul/Paul have the same initials is from the influences of Buddhist scripture on the gospel writers, since the principal disciple of Buddha was Sari Putra. I also think the initials of Jesus Christ (Iesu Christos) are from Julius Caesar (Iulius Caesar).
@mariaandreaspashi1931
@mariaandreaspashi1931 Год назад
It may be that Jesus predicted that Peter would be strong as rock, and have strength of faith to painfully disown himself and deny Jesus 3 times, to do exactly as Jesus told him, to return and strengthen the others, Luke 22: 31,32. Zechariah 13:7,8. And for them all to keep following Jesus in ministering to save lives and souls. And when Jesus confirmed to Peter the true expression of Love to Jesus is not a verbal self expression but "feed my lambs, take care of my sheep, feed my sheep, follow me." I think the name rock to Peter and also the term Peter having the key is significant in the lesson of painfully disowning self as Peter did to save one's existence in order to continue following Jesus in Saving, and possibly the key is knowing the difference of Love through self/ego and Love through Jesus.
@Chris-op7yt
@Chris-op7yt 2 года назад
religion is politics, period.
Далее
The Hardest Challenge!
00:37
Просмотров 4,6 млн
Did Jesus Even Claim to be God? Bart Ehrman Says No...
1:31:12
Lost Christianities
1:31:56
Просмотров 173 тыс.
Life after Death in the Bible and Beyond with OUP
1:01:31