4:39: melee in front, archers and siege weapons behind the melee line. I'm just going to say it: this battle makes more sense than the battle of Winterfell from GoT S8.
It's nice to see "sense". You know, close to 20 years ago, I watched the third Lord of the Rings movie, and to this day, I sometimes stop, and just think "Why... Why? Why would you cavalry charge mumaks... Why would you do that..."
@@ArtypNk from a tactical point if the elephants got inside minas tirith where they couldnt easily be flanked it would be GG, and as we saw the cavalry was effective once it was able to not be in front of the mumaks IE Eowen hamstrining them or Eomer Arrowspamming the other.
It needs more trenches. for all its failings, the battle of Winterfell at least had one trench. I would need the full context of the battle but as I see it, unless the defending army had little time to prepare, they should have built a system of trenches to abuse the charging army and force them to run around them. With an ample use of trenches the enemy would fall to traps set by the defenders and make the enemy easy pickings for archers and those oil blankets. By the time the enemy got to the phalanx, a good chunk of their forces would be dead and would be forced to retreat if not attack with a reduced army. Even if the enemy knew of the trenches, its still a no man's land and the defenders can pick at them wile comfortable to rest or even wait for reinforcements. Siege warfare is amazing.
@@ArtypNk Rohan had full momentum behind them. The Orcs were retreating and if the Riders retreated, the tide of battle could change just as fast in the enemies favor. They couldn’t fall back to Minas Tirith as the lower levels were swarming with Orcs. The only sound option was to keep the momentum going and charge on ahead
All the running the Easterlings are doing, I'm surprised they still have the energy to fight! They must be knackered by the time they get to the enemy!
they are like switzerland, they are a peaceful kingdom/country but have a very impressive military ( yeah thats right, switzerlands army is actually pretty OP )
Fergil The Fox a furry shouldnt talk about military power. Switzerlands army is weaker than all of its neighbouring countries except for maybe austria and ofc lichtenstein which isnt a threat either way.
STORM LORD good question my friend.and lucky enough your asking the right man.😀 so how did a small country like Great Britain 🇬🇧 with a vastly smaller population to dominate and completely control an entire sub continent which is now modern day India, Pakistan and Sri Lanka for almost 200 years? Well the answer is quite simple. We were never there to conquer. We were there to trade. The British empire was never one to rape, murder and cause mass genocide. Although if it came to it we could fight like the best of them. We had a much smaller army than the Indians and knew if we wanted to trade we had to get along. We give them Christianity, technology and a good old cup of tea. 😀 Our army is organised and battle ready in case of trouble and was able to call on local tribes when their was trouble. Britain has never fought alone. We kept the local tribes leaders in power almost as a puppet. We policed and made sure tribes kept from attacking each other and causing unrest and generally kept everyone inline. India wasn’t a country like it is now with just one government power. Tribes could be played against each other, thus, easily dividing and conquering the trouble makers allowing companies to continue the trade of silk, opium, tea and spices. Hope this helps. 👍🏻🇬🇧
Padmanava MUKHOPADHYAY hello there. You went a bit sketchy at the end of your statement there my friend. I couldn’t workout what you were trying to interact. But having the ability to speak 2 languages is impressive... well done to you 👍🏻 I did my best to explain why we held power in India for 200 yrs. I hope this helped to educate a few people. If there are any doubts on the facts I gave please look them up. You made a good point on bringing up the border disputes. The border disputes have always been there and always will. With or without the help from Great Britain 🇬🇧 Even today with modern day Pakistan and our intention was to save lives by separating the religions to avoid mass genocide. Especially with the more gentile regions and keep them out of harms way from the evil that is Islam. To summarise if it wasn’t for British technology, engineering and education then India would still be a warlord state, murdering, raping, enslaving and killing neighbouring tribes. Worse of all, God forbid, you wouldn’t have the good old cup of tea. After all. It’s what civilisations are based on. 😀 Glad I could of been of help. 👍🏻
unknown 20 I didn’t mean to offend. But look up India’s tribal belt. You’ll find it on wiki. I’ll try to explain a little from memory. But you’ll find a more accurate representation on wiki... The diversity, the different language and customs. India had many tribes before she became united. Slowly a lot of these tribes become integrated into the main population joining the cities while they looked for work or to trade. so yes, India had tribes😀. I should of explained more in previous comments about how the sovereign rule at the time(Raj) didn’t know the true population count or where some of these tribes were located. Or even that some villages weren’t known to the Raj. It was the British pioneers who mapped the areas extensively. The underlining reason was so these people could be taxed by the ruler and therefore taxed by the British 😉 hope I helped to clear up that misunderstanding. Enjoy the reading. 👍🏻🇬🇧
Except this "Peaceful Kingdom" has an arsenal of engines and troops so ridiculously well-funded that it'd put the economy of even the most war-driven kingdom to shame. Hahaha
I was exactly wondering who is the peaceful kingdom here xD I was under the impression that the advanced guys are the aggressor and the primitive dudes are the defender. Much like in a rome/barbarian scenario.
Being prepared for war was the only guarantee of being at peace. Fun fact: Switzerland waq the least agressive nation of europe in the last few centuries. Yet the most military ready in both WW. They were so ready for invasion, the guys that planned bridges, roads and tunnels had to include the self destruction charges in the *design* phase. They did not later ship in explosives to take down the stuff - they literally had self destruct buttons for them!
The human culture whose language was the basis of Quenya was the Finns. Back when Tolkien wrote TLOTR the Finns were classified as an Asiatic culture but they have more in common with the Japanese than with the people of the Indian subcontinent. Their language is interesting but very hard to learn.
For a peaceful kingdom they sure do have a lot of advance weaponary and tactics edit: LMAO why did this comment blow up i was half joking when i wrote this
Even till now, India never attacked someone first and tries to maintain peace still it is the 4th strongest military, second largest importers of arms and weaponry from all across the globe.
Gee Romans were really Peaceful. Makedons too. I love how peaceful the Ottomans were. British were masters of Naval warfare and peace. Remember Napoleon tried to sue for peace the whole continent of Europe? I mean there is peace in it, right? I love Prussian military they were great at peace. Germany made two great peaceful parties in whole world. Remind me if there is another peaceful nation.
Oh how could I forget USA, as they had the one of the best military in the 20th century. The US Has Been at war 225 out of 243 years since 1776. They are in four wars at this time. Well after wars people have to sign peace, right? Then USA is 89 times peaceful. They even used a peace potion called Agent Orange on children in 'Nam. Spain? Well, there were several Civil Peaces, Re-Peacista and the Spanish Peacesition were the times of great peace. They had the strongest military for a time too. For keeping the peace of course. Ok there was peace of Nanking. And peace camps in China at this moment. Russia is enforcing military peace in Ukraine too. They have (or had) strong military force right?
This is Not aBoollywood Film .It is a Telugu Film of India south Boollywood Hindi has no Releation to this Film All Actors Are South Telugu Tamil No Boollywood.. Can Call Telugu film Toollywood
That is the difference. Prince Bhallaladeva just focuses on destroying the enemy, while Prince Amarendra Baahubai not only fights but also protects the people. Queen Mother Sivagami tells this later in the movie. :)
If anyone wanted background info, there are 2 brothers in the good side and one of them will be the new king. This battle was used to see the skill base of the 2 brothers in combat and strategy. You will see that one of them make poor choices and the other does it a better way. The father roots for the “evil brother” and the mother roots for the “good brother”.
@@benjaminkasongo7018 in Netflix. The Movie is in two parts. BAAHUBALI THE BEGINING & BAAHUBALI THE CONCLUSION. I ASSURE YOU IT IS A FANTASTIC MOVIE YOU WILL LOVE IT.
@@mady4196 you guys also have an average wage of 616$ a year, a redicuolously uncontrollable population, one of the most crime ridden countries in the world, no economy whatsoever, a large military but shit military, the rest of the world has had many more people like the ones that you mentioned than in india, india is a shithole, india is a third world country, 50% of kids go to school, you guys have a literacy rate of 65% and the people who do go to school get an education not even worth being called an education. Before you insult us westerners look at yourself you piece of shit
@@VictorL8 if we have shit military thn how we kicked ass britishers and throw out of our country in 1947 if we have shit army why alexander was unable to conquer india Remember it was past or it is present or in future no other countries can win battles against india If we have worst education how indian people became ceo of google and microsoft If we had bad education how we had stepped on moon Why we have isro and drdo Now jaguar and land rover is under "Ratan tata" Watever u r learning today it is origin of india Zero"0" invented by brahmagupta Our sanskrit word 'bhratra' becomes brother and matra becomes mother Gometry becomes geometry and trigonmiti becomes trigonometric The world's tallest statue is 'statue of unity' in our country Taj mahal in 7 wonders of world The biggest hub of the diamond is india If u dont believe all the things i said u can google bloody creepy foreigners Bt u so kind of blind people who can see only negatives everywhere cant see good anywhere And now i can see the black smoke coming out of ur asshole with burning smell😂😂😂 If u dont like why u whites and black people are coming to visit india and after coming here thinking to dominion over india Get lost 😂😂😂
@@mady4196 hey brother don't reply to this culture less people.. They are fool not we are, just chill because we are cool people and peacemaker....... Be calm brother... Kutte hai Kab tak bhokenge..... 😂
@Jose Ojeda For some historians, you can find a lot of cultural similarities in the West and the East (monomyth, indo-european culture, and so on). So, maybe, why not ? =)
@Groot Nope. That's a myth. Both used common source material. And anyone who has ever read the edits in of LOTR knows that the changes were too organic to be considered a copy of.
This is a clip from 'Bahuballi' a Telugu film where, in this battle, 100,000 barbarians are attacking Mahashmati, a kingdom in confusion as of who should be king.
I must admit, I had fun watching that. Very fresh. Shows a lot of creativity, dedication, and effort; rather than funds, choking out the audience with dazzling spfx. I won’t complain about the realism since in 300 the Spartans were wearing diapers, and this one isn’t trying to be realistic in the first place. It’s fantasy.
Title: *Easterlings* Me: *Expecting the Rhûnish, Balchots or Wainriders from Lord of The Rings Video: *Shows this instead Me: *,,D I S S A P O I N T E E E D..''*
Mehul Verma We’re supposed to assume that humans had Superhuman strength as well as brilliant eyesight, don’t look for realism it’s a historical fantasy!
I didn’t think I would like this movie as much as I did.”Bahubali” is fantastic and it really gave a shot in the arm for those into the “Baliwood”genre.
It's actually not a bollywood movie.Bollywood as we know it is based out of Mumbai which produces Hindi language films.Indiq has other movie industries so in other languages like Telugu,Tamil,Malayalam etc.This particular move is a producer d by the Telugu movie industry
*This was one of the BEST movies coming from INDIA that has been watched internationally.* Baahubali: the Beginning and Baahubali 2: the conclusion. I loved this movie and i watched it so many times!!! 😍😍
This clip is actually from an Indian film called Bahubali, from the director of RRR. Unfortunately this channel tried to make it fit in with the LOTR lore somehow. It's a pretty damn good film which caused quite the stir in India. Over the top, and gloriously so ♥
This battle sequence was one of the craziest things I've ever seen. Bad CGI aside, it was exciting, expansive and ridiculous all at the same time. My big question is how did that Prince get so many weapons, every scene it looked like he had some new weapon in his hand. Also the Helicopter Chariot was wonderfully ludicrous, historical accuracy be gone.
Peaceful kingdom: *Burns hundreads alive under a giant fabric* Surely that scares theme! Barbarians: HEY BOYS WE GET BARBECUE AFTER THIS! Peaceful kingdom: *Suprised pikachu face*
@Darshan Kumara Yeah like killing a rhinoceros with just 1 spear...and leonidus ringing bells of greek temple located on a mountain just by banging his spear in the ground.....physics got mad in 300...
Some context: The "peaceful kingdom" was set up just a few decades before and of course was filled with battle hardened veterans. They had not messed with anyone since though. The two princes are competing to see who would be a better king and that is why they are highlighted separately, and the nice one is the mc of course. The two brothers have superstrenght(like Heracles) and the film is good but physics make zero sense(search for the scene where they catapult people using trees)