Hey y’all, imma put a tie breaker video out some time. Depending on the comments in this video will determine the winner of the tie breaker. However, you must bring relevant facts(feats etc..) on why Edward or Jacob should win.
I know Jacob will win because he is a wolf and he can actually kill Edward, he is so cute and handsome i might have a crush on him 😬, he protects bella like real protect, he is really nice, he likes bella, and he is so super sooo special, serious,and calm.
I would say Edward is the stronger of the two. I mean when Jacob is turned they’re on pretty level ground, but I think Edward has a better mind for battle and doesnt let himself get as consumed by his emotions like Jacob. Jacob is extremely emotion driven, whereas Edward can (sometimes) think more logically.
That might work in Jacob's favor though because Edward HEAVILY relies on his telepathy to beat people in fights, if your overcome with rage your mind isnt gonna be very stable to read. Emmett is basically the vampire versipn of Jacob seeing as how strength is his expertise. And he's confident he can beat Edward without telepathy. Felix bodied Edward with ease and no, being starved played no part on Edward losing because that doesnt affect your physicality, just your mental state. Either way Edward wasn't beating Felix who is the strongest vampire and one of the best fighters Demetri was winning until he turned his back on Edward in the vision battle. He was pretty much losing against Victoria and Riley and I know we can agree those two would get wrecked by Jacob even 2v1, in the vision battle Leah shook off 3 Volturi with ease to go help Esme and she's not nearly as strong as Jacob. Sam is weaker than Jacob and 1v1 he overpowered Edward. Really the only fight Edward won fairly was against James in the 1st movie, and James wasn't impressive at all yet he still put hands on Edward. Jacob doesn't have as many showings, granted. But that's because he's not the focus of the story and he was done dirty with the stupid Renesmee storyline. But it is still heavily implied that once he became Alpha, very few if any characters can challenge him 1v1 and personally, I don’t see Edward being one of those beings. Emmett, Jasper, & Felix are the only vampires I can see giving Jake a fight. And none of the wolves can.
@@thewhitespectreYou got a source to show that starving doesn’t cause loss of physicality because I’ve never once heard that. Also if you’re going down the books and not just the films as people are so often to do James was far more impressive, he was known to hunt OTHER vampires, he was one of the best trackers outside of Dmitri. Plus there’s also no proof that Edward couldn’t use his telepathy against Jacob just because he had a “wild mind” that’s pure speculation with nothing to back it up
@@xaoc6084 I don't have an exact source but it was in an article regarding an interview with Stephanie Meyer and she said that herself. I know the characters were more impressive in the books but they also didn't fight as much as they did in the movies, Edward and Felix for example didn't fight in New Moon and obviously there were no blows thrown in Breaking Dawn. But my main reasoning and logic in this particular case is the fact that, yes in the movies, Edward wasn't all that. He got pinned and was about to be killed by Sam in Breaking Dawn Part 1, who while obviously is very powerful was still stated to be 2nd to Jacob in size and strength when Jake became alpha.
Dont forget that Edward is emotionally driven when it comes to Bella and I think he may would hesitate to kill Jacob because he knows Bella wouldn't forgive him but tbh I don't think Jacob would hesitate and that may would be the reason Jacob would win even tho Edward is stronger
Edward gets strength durability and combat speed, bro was literally contesting Felix and was effortlessly tanking Felix's hits. He's also the fastest vampire in the movies and is able to react to aros attacks which just naturally puts him above Jacob in terms of combat speed. Jacob got low diffed by a literal newborn, newborns
@@dashawyu12bruh vampires are stronger then werewolves. Edward is arguably the weakest of all the male vampires in the Cullen family and he easily stopped a moving van with 1 hand. Jacob got crushed by an unnamed newborn😭 Stop fanboying him Edward negs and u know it
OK first of all that’s unacceptable. Jacob could climb up a tree he is they He’s a werewolf get that in your mind because he does not know he didn’t know that at first you can’t blame him for that he thought he figured it out he was him. Jacob is faster and so are all the wolves and you cannot compete. You cannot say anything about that , this is just unacceptable
Actually Edward is in fact not faster bcuz it is stated the that the wolves are faster than vampires and Jacob is the strongest and second fastest wolf behind Leah
honestly, since edward literally CANNOT DIE unless you perform specific things, i'd say he's got the upper hand in durability. for combat speed, edward would DEFINITELY beat jacob. we dont really get the specifics on the werewolves' speed in the series, but edward is the fastest cullen, and we see how fast he can run in breaking dawn, whereas we see none of that with jacob. it's the same case with the senses, from bella's perspective, we can see how strong her enhanced senses are as a vampire, where they dont even talk about jacob's senses AT ALL. and the alpha thing doesn't make sense since jacob's 'alpha powers' won't work on edward ANYWAYS, since he isn't a werewolf or part of jacob's pack. overall, i think edward would win with some difficulty.
Edward definitely wins for senses since he's a vampire, and also vampires are legit built to be the best predators in the world sooooo Jacob is still pretty good tho
I am team Jacob, so I would have to choose Jacob on that one if anybody doesn’t like TJ I’m OK with that. Just remember that I like Team Jacob.Love the way he talks about Bella. He has a crush on her like that’s. Period like literally that’s all you have to say that’s literally all the amount of surprise that gave me the first time I watched it. It wasn’t too bad. I’ve watched it. It’s my favorite show I love how Jacob is there for herthat just him he’s a sweetheart Jacob is a sweetheart no one could say he’s not. He is the most kind person I’ve ever seen in twilight he gave us more hope definitely Jacobs lifesaver you know he’s a lifesaver.
Excuse me. Did u see how many wolfs it took to kill Laurent in new moon lol. And did u see how Emmett was slapping the shit out of the wolfs in breaking dawn part 1
edward ofc , he always protected bella .he even left bella bc he thought he wasnt safe enough for bella , bc of what hapened at his home when he and the other cullens celebrating bella 's birthday. edward really loved bella , jacob actually had toxic love for bella . team edward forever
I feel that healing should have went to Jacob because if u read the eclipse book it says that he crushes the kitchen knife with his bare hands and heal in a very little bit of time less than a minute
