Тёмный

Elegoo Mars Mate Review - So, this exists.... 

FauxHammer
Подписаться 75 тыс.
Просмотров 43 тыс.
50% 1

Buy the Elegoo MarsMate here: shareasale.com...
Sandisk USB 5 Pack - amzn.to/3ZxobJr (like all links, this is an affiliate link, and we will earn a commission on any qualifying purchase you make, at no cost to you. Thank you)
Get any printer working easily with the Photonsters XP Range Finder - www.thingivers... (watch my video for full instructions • How to Print Perfect M... )
Join this channel to get access to perks:
/ @fauxhammer
Buy WARGAMER - The best Resin for Miniatures yesthats3dprin...
3D Printer Cleaning Mat: geni.us/3DPrin...
This Video is part of our series looking for the Best 3D printer for Miniatures; www.fauxhammer...
Special thanks to the following Creators who provided models
Rider of Despair - Creature Caster - www.myminifact...
Dredge Marines - Mezgike - mezgike.com/
One Page Rules - www.onepagerul...
Wolverine - Drafnir Studios - cgtrader.sjv.i...
Artis Opus FauxHammer Essentials Set: store.artis-op...
FauxHammer Patreon - / fauxhammerblog
FauxHammer Facebook Group - / painthub
FauxHammer 3D Printing Group - / 3dprintedminiatures
FauxHammer Discord - / discord
Best Airbrush For Miniatures: www.fauxhammer...
Beginner Airbrush: www.fauxhammer...
Affiliate Links to support us.
Element Games - elementgames.c...
Wayland Games - affiliates.way...
Forbidden Planet: forbiddenplane...
Amazon - www.amazon.co....
Website: www.fauxhammer...
Facebook: / fauxhammerblog
Twitter: / fauxhammerblog
Instagram: / fauxhammerblog
Pinterest: www.pinterest....
Video Editing by VidPros: app.vidpros.io...
00:00 - Intro

Опубликовано:

 

30 сен 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 229   
@caiomolinari
@caiomolinari 5 месяцев назад
I'm a chemist and I have a master in chemical engineering with emphasis in materials science. And I've read the SDS of Elegoo resins which are public on their website. And what I can say to you is that under GHS global standards there is a risk of exposure by inhalation to a substance that's volatile and carcinogenic... it's a risk it's not guaranteed... and it's something that may happen after being exposed several times (maybe years) but sometimes depending on the substance, even really small quantities (ppm level) could be already very toxic... every substance will have a different threshold limit for exposure... for some it would need higher quantities to show a risk of toxicity, for other a small quantity is already a risk... meaning that the total VOC doesn't tell the whole story... even if their purifier doesn't remove all the VOCs but completely removes the one that shows a clear carcinogen risk, that would be enough in my humble opinion. However, due to this lack of transparency, the only way I would feel completely safe is by having an exhaust fan system to capture everything and throw it outside of my house and use the proper PPEs (the right mask). But maybe I'm becoming unnecessarily cautious about this... ignorance is a bliss sometimes 😅
@plasticarcade
@plasticarcade Месяц назад
I always print in a sealed box, with a ventilation system that pulls fumes outside, I also have a filter on that as well so that I am at least filtering the air as best I can before throwing it out in the environment. before opening the chamber/print box I also let it evacuate any fumes that may be left after printing, Ill usually wait about 15 minutes or so, this adds time and expense but works well for me. I still wear proper mask while processing prints though and I run the ventilation system to evacuate the air while Im doing that as well.
@goldstick3D
@goldstick3D Месяц назад
I wonder how much "blowing everything out of the window with a fan" is making it a problem for your neighbours if you live in an apartment building?
@benhickey792
@benhickey792 Месяц назад
@@goldstick3D if its not blowing directly in their face, unlikely causing any issues. the earth is pretty large and gasses tend to diffuse quickly. the reason vocs can get stuck in your house is becuase of dead air and poor ventilation. once outside they dissipate very quickly, still probably best to point away from your garden or and public streets ect.
@digitalghosts4599
@digitalghosts4599 Месяц назад
I don't think you are being overly cautious. I know of at least 2 people (friends of my friends) who got very bad contact dermatitis due to ignoring PPE while handling resin prining (one at their dental job) and can't be even anywhere near those resins without getting their allergic reactions back almost instantly. We also know that this is a serious concern from other jobs where people deal with epoxy and other types of resins since decades. What concerns me the most is that you have nowadays "low odor" resins as well as those filters that don't do shit and create a false feeling of safety due to reduced smell. The fact that something smells less doesn't mean that it's any safer at all, but most people who have no training/experience with chemicals often don't realize it and I can't blame them. It's just outrageous that marketing departments take advantage of this!
@aestusvideos6297
@aestusvideos6297 Месяц назад
Do you have suggestions for different type of resins from differen Companies which do not rely on carcinogenic substances?
@iansegobio9334
@iansegobio9334 11 месяцев назад
That last bit of "putting it back in the box again" was pure gold...
@dmurphine
@dmurphine 11 месяцев назад
Activated carbon filters are good for filtering certain VOCs but not all airborne contaminants. Some of those airborne contaminants are going to just go through the filter unaffected. What you got off of the burnt toast was particulate matter, not VOC's. The detector also may have been picking up dust particles from the carbon filter. Also, that detector is suspicious, because formaldehyde (or formalin) is notoriously difficult to detect and most detectors have very short lifespans so I don't see how that is useful or how they expect it to work. Anyway, the compounds coming off of the resin vat are generally pretty benign under the conditions most hobbyists use them. Worry more about getting it on your skin.
@mekko1413
@mekko1413 10 месяцев назад
This is exactly that. So many people on the internet now days freak out over the slightest little thing that they hear all of a sudden its a big deal but when someone does the science behind it and or works in that field and says look this isn't a big deal. They then freak out over that person and forget what they were worried about in the first place. People were complaining about something that really didn't matter. Sure it smells but so do my farts and when people complained Elegoo said lets make money off these people complaining.
@OntarioGuy430
@OntarioGuy430 10 месяцев назад
So using xylene to wash fixative off my fingers when doing histology is a bad idea?? ;)
@Pendragon-dnd
@Pendragon-dnd 10 месяцев назад
I’m a noob but your comment gave me some questions. How long do detectors usually last? The resin fumes are fine to breath in while printing and don’t require a mask?
@dmurphine
@dmurphine 10 месяцев назад
@@Pendragon-dnd It depends on the detector. Some are very difficult to maintain and may degrade under exposure to human breath or water vapor. Some are also use once and done. Again it depends and they can be very finicky. Also they are compound specific - there is no one is good for all (with accuracy) like a Star Trek tricorder. For instance, combustible gas detectors are detecting anything that combusts - but are calibrated to something like methane. So if you have anything other than methane the values may not be totally accurate. As to resin vapors (fumes is a term that only technically applies to heated metal particles - like welding fumes) I'm not saying put your face over the vat, but generally the amount of exposure and the volatile compounds coming off the resin are very minor and a mask is really unnecessary. Yes you can smell it, but think about it this way: can you smell ammonia when you open a bottle? Yes, because it is very volatile and has a very low odor threshold. But it's not harmful at the level or concentration at which you can smell it. In fact, in order to be really sickened by ammonia vapors there has to be so much in the air that you really couldn't stand it. The fact that it stinks is telling you it's in the air, but it readily dissipates before it gets to a concentration that can harm you. Airborne chemical exposures for all things - dusts, vapors and fumes - have a safe use value that is based on concentration in the air, and the amount of time to which you are exposed. An industrial level print farm may need a respirator, but a hobbyist really doesn't as long as the area has good general ventilation or the resin is enclosed (like keep the cover on).
@dmurphine
@dmurphine 10 месяцев назад
@@OntarioGuy430 Well Xylene isn't great for your skin, like all petroleum distillates it has a defatting effect (skin is mostly fat) and can cause drying and cracking. I'd also worry about the fixative so maybe don't get it on your skin. Similar chemicals like Toluene, Hexane, Methanol and Benzene can be absorbed into you body through your skin, so they can actually cause systemic effects even if you're not breathing the vapors.
@walterstarr1588
@walterstarr1588 11 месяцев назад
I'm just going to set up a grow tent and vent the air outside, wearing PPR when I am opening the printers and working with resin.
@MrGTAmodsgerman
@MrGTAmodsgerman 4 месяца назад
Seems to be so far the best approach. Also if you ever encounter a resin spill. You could throw the whole tent into trash if you really want it. Also you can control the "room temperature" this way, way more efficent while also it's a closed box with no windows in best case which protects from UV light.
@Tratios
@Tratios 4 месяца назад
I just finished ordering the inline fan and carbon filter to do the same thing to the tent I assembled while waiting on saturn 4 ultra
@grindtastic
@grindtastic 11 месяцев назад
great video, it is something I started to take more seriously recently as I have been printing a lot more and I am in a somewhat enclosed room. I am in the process of installing an extraction fan that will lead outside.
@FauxHammer
@FauxHammer 11 месяцев назад
Yeah, seems the best choice. Glad I have my extractir
@seelenschlucht
@seelenschlucht 11 месяцев назад
Could you make the following test? - Put the air quality meter in a big plastic bag or container that would also fit the Elegoo Mars Mate and seal it. - Let the air quality meter run for 30 minutes. - Write down the air quality of the inside of the bag. That is the base level for the next reading. - Now put the Elegoo Mars Mate with the air quality meter inside the bag or container and reseal it. - Let the Elegoo Mars Mate and the air quality meter run for 30 minutes. - Subtract the base level reading from the new reading. Now you see how much VOC the Elegoo Mars Mate spits out on his own. The higher reading in the exhaust of the Elegoo Mars Mate could mean that it sucks everything in from around it, is absolutely useless with just it's carbon filter, filters nothing, and blows out a concentrated, toxic, stream. Or it means that the Elegoo Mars Mate itself is made from the cheapest plastic, doesn't circulate any air inside the room because of the weak fan, and blows out very toxic air on it's own.
@karol30660
@karol30660 16 дней назад
Sooo... It got me genuinely wondering. How is it different to use a carbon filter in a mask from using a similar carbon filter in that device? I get that printer can leak, but is it really such a difference? If so I wonder if it would be hard to seal it with window seals or such. Also yeah, funny that there are people who are close to using hazmat suits to print, and then proceed to smoke cigs or vape :p
@Cordeneaux87
@Cordeneaux87 11 месяцев назад
From the aquatics side, carbon is not all the same. Some carbons are really good at absorbing specific sized particles. As your meter suggests, 2.5 and 10 microns are substantially different. It is hard to see how a singular carbon block is capable of absorbing all of these. It would be good to test a regular certified HEPA filter to see if they absorb more of the compounds we are concerned about. As far as health concerns, the answer lies in the middle of all the hype pieces. Singular (acute) exposure to VOC's are not going to cause anyone real problems. Prolonged (chronic) exposure is what the main concern is with VOC's. Similar to that of smoking, VOC's are inhaled and create problems in lung tissue. They cause inflammation, so people with pre-existing conditions are at an enhanced risk, as well as the increased risk of cancers. Will there be people who both smoke and print with no ill-effects? Of course. Statistically, you are better off venting your printer than leaving it in a confined room. If you use a printer more, you are at more of a risk, but that risk will never be 0% or 100%. Statistics are frustrating that way.
@justinchamberlin4195
@justinchamberlin4195 10 месяцев назад
I work in a foundry, there is nothing my FDM or resin printers can produce that's worse than that. And for non-foundry employees, sitting in front of a bonfire a few hours is again going to expose you to far more airborne pollutants than your printers release, unless maybe you're printing 24/7 and have your printer(s) in your bedroom. That being said, I don't think there's any good option for an in-home purifier/recirculator - it's like the vent hoods for kitchens, the ones that only filter air and blow it back into the room don't work for anything while the ones configured to blow air outside work great. Recirculating purifiers make it smell nicer, but that's it - the best option is to exhaust fumes to the outdoors rather than let them linger inside.
@Snafu00M
@Snafu00M 11 месяцев назад
Ew, screw the filter on the Elegoo trash, change your masks Air Filters, they're black.
@onihensen
@onihensen 10 месяцев назад
That’s not actually the filter itself, it’s a prefilter pad on top of the filter. I always wondered what it was for.
@goldstick3D
@goldstick3D Месяц назад
volatile organic compounds, if the lid is on, and printer is running, then of course the volatility of the organic compounds is reduced eg not flying into the air tester. Some chemist had a really good point that a box around the printer etc without a fan and hose to outside, is most likely worse than without the growth tent etc box, because the hit of VOC-s you get the moment you open up the printer lid, is gonna be excessive due to the concentration of them, so I guess the "useless filter system" is reducing the load so that you won't get an invisible explosion of poison the moment you open up your printer.
@FauxHammer
@FauxHammer Месяц назад
Or…. Wear a mask when you open it. Rather than have anything pumping into your room at all
@Godonstilts
@Godonstilts 9 месяцев назад
"I bought this thing that measures if air is good or bad..." proceeds to take a big ol' lung full of vape, says its "Hazardous" Still vaping?
@FauxHammer
@FauxHammer 9 месяцев назад
yeah...
@msp5616
@msp5616 11 месяцев назад
Tbh i got th same exact same result, and it led me to the same conclusion. Leave a sealed lid on and mask up when removing it. I returned the filter as it did seem pointless, considering the biggest danger was removing the lid, and the filter has no way of helping with that
@FauxHammer
@FauxHammer 11 месяцев назад
Glad it’s not just me
@Lyall4
@Lyall4 10 месяцев назад
Did you test the voc when removing the lid with the filter vs not. My thought is this is just refreshing the air under the lip more consistently. So when be less of a build up (wave) of voc release when you lid.
@PatrickSamphire
@PatrickSamphire 11 месяцев назад
It kind of makes sense that with a pump you would get more VOCs. With a lid with a good seal, almost nothing should be getting out until you remove the lid. With a filter pumping the air out, even if it removes 95% of the VOCs, that's still 5% that gets into the air and that wouldn't get into the air with a sealed lid. The only thing I would test is the level of VOCs when you remove the lid after using the filter and when you remove the lid without using a filter. That *might* be different, but if it isn't, the filter is doing more harm than good.
@AustinLindstrom
@AustinLindstrom 11 месяцев назад
In looking into air quality / VOC / sensors, it's my understanding that any consumer level hand held do-dad is worthless. You need something industrial level, I saw $1,500 investment mentioned. It just seems like no one, anywhere, knows how dangerous / undangerous it is to 3D print.
@WIBRTyranT
@WIBRTyranT 11 месяцев назад
I think what makes it so misleading is that it's a dry block of charcoal/carbon. The smell can get trapped in it, but most of the vocs in the air won't attach to it. That's done way more reliably with a wet/submerged carbon setup, like in aquarium filters. I'm wonder as well, if the extra vocs coming out of the mate are dry carbon dust particles blowing off the block. Carbon blocks require rinsing in water to remove excess dust particles, because there's a LOT of dust that comes off. *edited for spelling
@keladryel5950
@keladryel5950 11 месяцев назад
Maybe just the fact that it sucks air out of the printer tbh. I have noticed the same with the mini filter of my mars 3 pro. If I leave the printer running after a finished print even just the little fan spreads it into the room, going from good air quality and pushes it to unhealthy. If I let it sit turned off after the print there is no degradation of air quality in the room until I remove the lid.
@RM-hn6ir
@RM-hn6ir 11 месяцев назад
Even then, for wet carbon filters, they get used up pretty quickly. For a lot of small aquariums, they are almost pointless.
@keladryel5950
@keladryel5950 11 месяцев назад
@@RM-hn6ir My point was more that the additional airflow makes the room overall worse. In addition to the carbon filter being pointless.
@WIBRTyranT
@WIBRTyranT 11 месяцев назад
@@RM-hn6ir it depends on what is going into the aquarium. If you're removing excess medicine after dosing/treating fish, then you'd wanna replace the carbon so the meds don't leach back out of the carbon. That said, I stopped using carbon in my aquariums a long time ago.
@WIBRTyranT
@WIBRTyranT 11 месяцев назад
@@keladryel5950 they also don't have actual filter material to capture the voc particles (think furnace filters) so yes it is just blowing the vocs right out into the room. What I'm gonna do when I get the time is to make a sealable cabinet, with a fan (filter between it and cabinet) blowing fresh air in, and an exhaust fan with another filter, blowing air outside, via window venting. The furnace filters will capture a good chunk of vocs and get changed every so often, but keep them from saturating the room/inside of the house
@YourAverage_J0e
@YourAverage_J0e 11 месяцев назад
From the studies i have read, the voc content from the printing process is within tolorable values, however it is the chemical cocktail that has the unknown side effects. Also studies show that the highest concentration happens during washing and curing in part due to the agitation of the IPA. The mars mate is flawed from the start since its only atempting to tackle what is essentially the safest part of printing (printer with sealed hood on. It does nothing when you take off the hood to add resin, remove prints or wash and cure. The best option is to have a well ventilated area you can leave while printing and drying and second best to get a powerfull air purifyer with HEPA filter and actived carbon filter. I still see a lot of people concluding carbon doesnt work but for smell but its inconclusive at worst and works perfectly fine acording to most studies. If carbon doesnt work then we are all screwed. The 3m multi gas filters we are all wearing are carbon (including the ones hammer is using in this video) so we are all going to be part of a lawsuite against 3m otherwise.
@GreySectoid
@GreySectoid 7 месяцев назад
When you open the un-ventilated hood you will get all those VOCs on your face. With a device like this the air inside the hood is somewhat pure and you wont instantly blow out all those VOCs into your room. Air purifiers use the exact same principle of activated carbon, but this design is more effective since it sucks the VOCs out before they even get to the room. Also what it seems this machine has more carbon it in, hence more effective.
@madmanwithaplan1826
@madmanwithaplan1826 6 месяцев назад
Yeah but you'd need like 6 to 12 pounds of activated carbon to properly filter it all. So your best bet is still to just send it all outside as much as possible during the entire process. Grow tent. Inline air fan. Ducts and connections will run abou 60 to 100 depending on your set up. But its inarguably the best way to ensure your long term health. If you're worried about heat get a thermal vat band.
@GreySectoid
@GreySectoid 6 месяцев назад
@@madmanwithaplan1826 Source for your "6 to 12 pounds" claim? If a tiny built-in carbon filter in those elegoo printers can filter out most the smell, surely you won't need that much. (I know there can be some non-smelly VOCs which might be more difficult to filter out but at least it filters out those which you can smell)
@SgtHouse
@SgtHouse 11 месяцев назад
Thank you for another great review! I am glad we got to see this in action. I think with the two carbon filters and keeping the lid close, maybe safer than buying this product. However, that's more of my opinion based on my environment and location that might differ from others. Also, I always get a kick where you reverse the unboxing video as if you are subtly saying, "Na, back you go for a refund!" 😂
@WhiteWulfe
@WhiteWulfe 11 месяцев назад
Oof, that's bad to see. First it's marketed incorrectly (carbon doesn't really do much for VOC's), and secondly there's no replacement filters available. Ouch. But for me, the worst part of it all is that by the sound of things it takes care of some of the smell, but at that cost I might as well just do the grow tent plus massive carbon filter method, as such will more or less keep the fumes in on area, and I can then vent it outside as well if need be (the semi-cautious person in my is tempted to do... both, if I can figure out a way to route hoses in a non-obstructive way)
@FauxHammer
@FauxHammer 11 месяцев назад
Well, you get a little carbon filter inside all Elegoo printers now that deals with the smell, and you can get replacement cartridges for those sooooo.
@WhiteWulfe
@WhiteWulfe 11 месяцев назад
@@FauxHammer Makes sense. Odds are as much as I'd love a Saturn 2 or 3 so it matches my Mars 2 Pro for looks, I'll probably go with the GK Two, because not only is the flip up lid is handy (as well as the drip catcher on the build plate), they also have in chamber carbon and you can buy replacement packs easily. But yeah, it is baffling that they didn't take a two tiered approach, and have it be a large block of carbon plus HEPA filtration. Yes, single pass isn't as effective as recirculating, but it sure beats nothing. Plus, y'know, the whole being able to market it even more (even if they've made things problematic by not having readily available replacement blocks)
@N0a5301
@N0a5301 4 месяца назад
But if you take the mars mate out of the window or on the balcony
@maciejs.5094
@maciejs.5094 8 месяцев назад
Ok, I'm no rocket scientist, but as someone pointed out, I thin the test is skewed. You compare the reading from the meter on running filter and next to a hole. The difference here is that the air from the hole flows naturally, so it's hard to say what is the rate of the airflow - but most probably very, very low. Which doesn't mean that the pollution is not produced; it's just trapped under the lid until you open it. When the filter is running, it's obviously sucking the air from beneath the lid. So it's no surprise that the reading can be the same or even higher - the airflow of polluted air is bigger. However, it doesn't necessarily mean that the filter doesn't do anything - maybe the amount of overall pollution, that would be released when opening the lid, is reduced this way. Basically what I'm trying to say: - I'd put the printer, meter and filter in a sealed grow test, not connecting the hose to the lid. Put the meter somewhere in the middle of the tent (but not too close to a source of "moving air" like directly on the filter or near the printer fan) for both tests 1) run a print with no lid with filter ON, capture the reading from the meter (best to capture how it changes in time, but could be hard, so min/max should suffice) 2)run the same print with no lid and the filter OFF, see the readings and compare results. It should give you a more reliable results with more comparable conditions. Than we will know if it really does anything.
@FauxHammer
@FauxHammer 8 месяцев назад
it was there for the whole print, you only saw a few seconds of the whole scenario
@maciejs.5094
@maciejs.5094 8 месяцев назад
@@FauxHammer ok, you focused on one sentence of my whole rant and ignored everything else. I wanted to focus on testing conditions. To put it in more simple terms, let's try this analogy: Let's assume you're a non-smoker. You stand NEXT TO someone smoking a cigarette without a filter (I don't think they make those anymore but let's say he broke the filter off). And you say it smells a bit but it's not that bad. Then you smoke YOURSELF a cigarette WITH the filter and say it makes you cough. And then come up with conclusion that the filters don't do anything, and it's even worse with them then without. See my point? (Disclosure: I don't know if the cigarette filters actually make the cigs less harmful, I know that the cigs without filters are a lot stronger; cigs are harmful as hell either way so it's best not to smoke at all. Given from me, smoking for 20+ yrs and trying to quit without much success)
@FauxHammer
@FauxHammer 8 месяцев назад
@@maciejs.5094 ok
@SamuraiMujuru
@SamuraiMujuru 11 месяцев назад
Finally, a review of this gizmo. I've been eying it, but a proper HEPA filtered air purifier runs about the same price so I've been trying to figure out which I should go with.
@YourAverage_J0e
@YourAverage_J0e 11 месяцев назад
I ended up getting a winnex 5500-2. Has HEPA and carbon filter. The more dangerous time of the printing cycle isn't during the print it's durung wash and cure. So at least to me it seemed smarter to purify the whole room and try not to be in the room when prints are drying or be wearing a mask.
@ActualSizeTV
@ActualSizeTV 9 месяцев назад
@@YourAverage_J0e I do the same but I use water washable resin because I work with IPA on a daily basis at my job so really dont want to use that much IPA at home hahaha but the Winnex 5500-2 works awesome
@bernardhorowitz4763
@bernardhorowitz4763 Месяц назад
You mentioned something important. The smell. I don't expect a $150 machine to remove VOC's. I mean a real professional MOC filer is quite expensive. I tested using a similar device with a Blue Air 2+2+1 filter running for 24 hours in a room with one active Saturn 4 Ultra running lid down. The Blue Air didn't do much to help with smell or VOC's. I tried the same test hooked up to the Mars Mate - Was the smell reduced? Yes. Was it awesome. No. Problem is the Saturn 4 Ultra is not Hermetically sealed with the lid on and closed. it has a gap and the bad air is going to flood out the printer no matter what. If you repeat the test again with the printer in a sealed bubble does it remove the fumes? Does it remove the VOC?
@nwallace
@nwallace 11 месяцев назад
My entirely unscientific gut feeling is that the higher reading over the mars mate vs next to the vent hole could be because of the higher airflow over the mate. I still have doubts that this thing will work but that could explain your funny numbers.
@FauxHammer
@FauxHammer 11 месяцев назад
Yeah that's possible, but as I said, even sat next to it and below the home. Levels continued to rise
@Desmo904
@Desmo904 11 месяцев назад
Well, if we can take any conclusion from the toast test, it is that you should have a 'wife' standing close to the 3D printer at all times to detect nasty smells. Something my wife is quite good at (it would appear) judging by the amount of times she informs me of it! 😆🤣 In a bit more seriousness, I run a Saturn 8k and with the lid on, it seems to be perfectly non-smelly running elegoo standard 8k resin. As soon as the lid is off, you notice a marked difference. So, I'm going to run it always with the lid on. (As I was anyway) Thanks for the review and for taking the bullet with the detector costs for the test! 👍
@digitalghosts4599
@digitalghosts4599 Месяц назад
You can't compare the harmfullness of fumes solely based on the VOC readout - it obviously depends on the kind of chemicals you're dealing with and what kind of stuff is being emitted. A burning toast likely doesn't emit as much VOC as it does particulate matter and incompletely burnt chemicals, while resin will emit harmful solvent fumes that count as VOC. However, the fact that the filter does not lower the VOC concentration is very concerning and it basically means it's a waste of money to buy it.
@p3rrypm
@p3rrypm 2 месяца назад
I would think it would need hepa purification as well as carbon. One should capture the small micron particles and the other the smells.
@MrAsmodath
@MrAsmodath 2 месяца назад
I feel like I gotta put in my 2 cents here. I've been resin printing since the original Mars days. The smell with the cover on while printing was not that bad and was contained to just the room in the basement it was in. However, we recently upgraded the HVAC system in the house, and now the smell was making it upstairs, very faintly, and only after a 10+ hour print. So I picked up the Mars Mate for my Saturn 4 Ultra. And bingo, no more smell, not even standing right next to it while printing. I'm not saying its filtering everything out that is bad, but the smell is completely gone. And I garuntee that like most people, I'm exposed to far nastier stuff everyday then my couple times a month printing with resin. VOC mask and gloves all they way when I'm working directly with it, but the Mars Mate is doing the job I bought it for while printing as far as I'm concerned. If you don't like the the hazards of working with volitile chemicals and can't vent outside, then just don't do it
@MrGsking12
@MrGsking12 2 месяца назад
Can I make one obviously won’t be as nice and fancy, but can I use a really good strong fan with a carbon filter?
@sl-lin0bi529
@sl-lin0bi529 7 месяцев назад
lost me at calculation formula =p
@FauxHammer
@FauxHammer 7 месяцев назад
rewatch it, it should make sense.
@thediscoman2001
@thediscoman2001 5 месяцев назад
basically then its just a gimmake, it probabley got the award for the design and nothing else, iv built a carbon filter system for my ultra 3 and iv got basically nothing at all smell wise witch is what i mainley wanted to get rido of smell, but i think the little usb filters do agood enough job really
@dkev001
@dkev001 11 месяцев назад
I use a grow tent with a pretty powerful exhaust fan. It exhaust into a carbon canister. Looks like a muffler. Because I run 2 resin printers. It is extremely effective at removing resin odors. The manufacturer claims it removes 90% of contaminants. But I don’t know about VOC’s. The bad part is, The tent isn’t tall enough to use my lids.
@V3ntu97
@V3ntu97 11 месяцев назад
I do the same, but I wouldn't worry about the lid since the printers are already enclosed in the tent. If anything is more harmful to keep the lid on without any proper ventilation system, because once you take off the lid, all the voc will be dispersed in one go. The best thing you can do is activate the extractor fan for 1-2 hours before the printer has finished. This will sensibly decrease the voc amount, it's also worth noting that extracting the fumes outside (even with a carbon filter) is the better choice
@scottiforgot7467
@scottiforgot7467 10 месяцев назад
I'm glad I seen your comment. I'm literally going to do the same thing and was going to start asking if it was a good idea to use a grow tent or not lol 😂😂 I can exhaust everything right out my window and not have to worry about getting this mars mate thing lol
@blorgblorgstein4101
@blorgblorgstein4101 9 месяцев назад
just curious here but why not vent it outside?
@spqrpraetorian
@spqrpraetorian 11 месяцев назад
You should definitely stop vaping. Nearly all studies have pointed to it being every bit as bad if not worse than just smoking.
@davidwaples8758
@davidwaples8758 8 месяцев назад
What struck me when I started using my new Saturn 3 is that when the unit is running, the onboard carbon filter would run and I would not smell anything. But when the printer stopped, the filter stopped and the smell quickly enveloped the area. This Mars Mate works when the printer stops, but replace the filter every two months? And just how good is it? The carbon blocks are like $90 each? I wonder if that's necessary? Most quality air purifiers only require the carbon filter to be replaced every two years? Those hand held air quality testers are pretty worthless. I watched a video from an industry expert holding two of the same devices next to each other and they had drastically different readings. More professional devices are required for accurate readings. I'm thinking about just getting a quality AirPura air cleaner designed for VOC's for the area I'm printing in (basement). I think I trust that more than an Elegoo product. Still trying to decide.
@FauxHammer
@FauxHammer 8 месяцев назад
When the unit is closed, the filter keeps it all inside and circulates the air through the filter multiple times. The mate pumps it directly into your room
@cfaulkingham
@cfaulkingham 11 месяцев назад
I pre-ordered 2 of these, 1 is still in the box. They really are useless and I am surprised they're still for sale. It's the worst 3D printing accessory I have purchased to date.
@benceszabo2286
@benceszabo2286 3 месяца назад
so i dont really care about the air quality, but does it reduce the smell enough to make it worth to buy? 🤔
@wastanley734
@wastanley734 9 месяцев назад
Wouldn't it be better to use the small one inside during operation. And run the air mate for a few minutes before removing the lid? For dissapation of the bulk of them that happened that during curing process. And there's a formula for how much volume of air has to moved for resin printing. Worked in the dental field and the room with the printers had to have the air completely replaced around every 15 minutes. So the low speed of the fan for the tiny volume of the printer enclosure makes sense.
@telleryoutube4458
@telleryoutube4458 11 месяцев назад
yes i am very upset i purchased it when i started 3d printing lo
@ScytheNoire
@ScytheNoire 11 месяцев назад
Should have been named the Elegoo Moon. Would have fit better in their naming scheme. Not having the required filters in stock is an issue, although it not working is the bigger issue.
@acasccseea4434
@acasccseea4434 6 месяцев назад
can you review the USB air filter that comes with the elegoo printers? or just find a better option that you'd recommend to us
@Mani_spielt
@Mani_spielt 6 месяцев назад
So i dont need this one?
@joostrove4440
@joostrove4440 6 месяцев назад
May I ask a stupid question? Did you remove the plastic cover around the filter?
@Lexst1
@Lexst1 2 месяца назад
I used a BR-SMART tester and got similar results. I was told that my testing method was not rigorous and that the machine had "relevant certificates". Asked for a return and was told that I could but will have to pay for shipping. O.K. send me an RMA. It is too big to be an effective paperweight.
@FauxHammer
@FauxHammer 2 месяца назад
Well. I’m glad to see I’m not alone in testing this. Sorry for your experience.
@docroberts1988
@docroberts1988 11 месяцев назад
Probably do just as good taking some large diameter PVC pipe and hose and fittings , drilling holes in the tube . Inside just add 2 or three MK06 MK01 HEPA Replacement Filters and calling it a day . Be about as good as that Elegoo worked . Just need a motor that's strong enough to draw the air through and housing made tight enough to contain the air movement .. Make about anything you want , you just need to replacement filters you can get easily
@emal2170
@emal2170 4 месяца назад
The little usb was a placebo for me. This pulls out. So when pulling out your pulling air in, which pulls out again. That seems dumb and gimmicky. I prefer to just leave the printer running without a filter. If I were to do anything else, it would be to vent outside, but Sunlu doesn't smell that much to me.
@FauxHammer
@FauxHammer 4 месяца назад
At least that worked by refiltering the air inside the chamber
@zackarybrown6752
@zackarybrown6752 9 месяцев назад
I do really wish we could get a professional study on how the VOCs from resin actually affect us and what quantities are bad.
@FauxHammer
@FauxHammer 9 месяцев назад
so do I
@SomoneTookMyName
@SomoneTookMyName 11 месяцев назад
With little or no reliable info on the vocs that come out of resin printing I just run a standing fan, a celling fan, as well as a small air purifier located behind the printers. I currently have 3 printers. I honestly feel that this helps a great deal with keeping the air well circulated within the room. I wish I had a dedicated location for just my printers but they reside within my man cave. I would love to put them in my garage but here in AZ the temps get so hot I would not want to run them during the summer months where the garage gets upwards to 100 degrees. Personally I think my current setup is fine. I should be more concerned about the resin that I touch with my bare hands at times.
@3dpathfinder
@3dpathfinder 11 месяцев назад
My Creality Halot Mage 8k comes with a built in carbon filter and hose that i just run to a window fan on exhaust . No issues
@FauxHammer
@FauxHammer 11 месяцев назад
Yeah the pro does too, that’s pretty good
@nicholassmith5206
@nicholassmith5206 11 месяцев назад
Nice outro. 😅
@FauxHammer
@FauxHammer 11 месяцев назад
Lol, thanks
@ausfoodgarden
@ausfoodgarden 11 месяцев назад
Yeah, carbon filters trap smells but the volatiles just tend to blow through. Way better to use that hose with an extractor fan and push the air out the window. That's what I do and it seems to work well. It's cheaper too. 😊
@sodakupop
@sodakupop 9 месяцев назад
Do you have anything you'd recommend for this setup?
@sggee
@sggee 11 месяцев назад
Would you recommend having a system to suck the air out using the rear lid hole and exhausting out of a dryer vent or window like in your window? Would that disperse the VOCs faster?
@FauxHammer
@FauxHammer 11 месяцев назад
Yes
@jasonc212
@jasonc212 11 месяцев назад
I bought one of these, and before I did, I had some of the same concerns that most share. It's just a large charcoal filter, so is it really going to do anything? Will it only get rid of just the smell (which is at least something I guess)? I'm glad you did this review, because I now know I should've gone with my initial gut and not ordered it. I have my printers set up in a converted bathroom that still has a very powerful ceiling vent that sucks up steam, and air particles. it doesn't clean the air, just takes what's in there, and blows it out a vent. I don't know if that helps much either, but I don't seem to have that smell nearly as strong when I have that fan running, and it seems to at least be moving the air out of the house, so perhaps that was all I needed all along.
@miguellopez3392
@miguellopez3392 9 месяцев назад
Yes i use the outake fan of my small paint station to clear the fumes of alcohol and resin out of my room in winter. It is probably the best way as the air in the room is replaced entirely every couple of hours with no smell with 2 printers running, just sucks that im blowing all the heat out of my house as well.
@darkhighwayman1757
@darkhighwayman1757 11 месяцев назад
I swear I wanna start building hoods or enclosures for Printers.
@FauxHammer
@FauxHammer 11 месяцев назад
Do it, I'd love one
@TigraZ
@TigraZ 3 месяца назад
that detector sucks shjould have used a better one
@FauxHammer
@FauxHammer 3 месяца назад
Personally I feel whether it is accurate or not, is irrelevant as it still detected more/less. that's enough to temll me what i need to know.
@esbenrasmussen4289
@esbenrasmussen4289 8 месяцев назад
I read some stuff on the Ikea air measurement device. And one commented that it was a good design choice to only have an indication on stable/rising/lowering of VOC, since "measuring VOC in air is very difficult" Also VOC can be many things. I don't think it is possible to test this with only common knowledge and a handheld device. It would take an educated person with the right testing equipment....
@kurtlazarus5975
@kurtlazarus5975 2 месяца назад
Just buy a large Samsung one they are 1000 bucks but they work.
@FauxHammer
@FauxHammer 2 месяца назад
What? An air purifier or do they make a specific printer one?
@kurtlazarus5975
@kurtlazarus5975 2 месяца назад
A air purifier is an air purifier as long as it has a HEPA filter and active carbon. The 3d printer company’s should stick to making 3d printers and leave filtration to the company’s that know what they are doing. A small unit like that would do nothing.
@Gregatron13
@Gregatron13 11 месяцев назад
Can you say "Matching mount on the Mars Mate" three times fast?
@FauxHammer
@FauxHammer 11 месяцев назад
I just tried No, I can’t
@stephankleen556
@stephankleen556 11 месяцев назад
I just tried. I can.
@therealjonaswp602
@therealjonaswp602 6 месяцев назад
So I guess you should just wear a good mask. Any suggestions on a good low budget extraction fan/setup for fumes?
@MBaadsgaard
@MBaadsgaard 10 месяцев назад
You are using a PM2.5 sensor for particulates (smoke and from printers) that are more in the 0.1-0.5um range. Basically, it's the wrong sensor. If the filter doesn't do fine particulate filtration, then of course, that's not important, but you do dwell on this alot.
@basilmemories
@basilmemories 10 месяцев назад
why are you telling this to an alot? tell that to the maker of the video
@FauxHammer
@FauxHammer 10 месяцев назад
Actually PM2.5 PM10 HCHO AQI So what is the right sensor?
@FauxHammer
@FauxHammer 10 месяцев назад
Eh?
@MBaadsgaard
@MBaadsgaard 10 месяцев назад
@@FauxHammer A PM10 measures 10um and below with decreasing accuracy, a PM2.5 measures below 2.5um and a PM1 below 1um. Some sources also list "ultra fine particles" as the main issue with 3d printing, which is
@FauxHammer
@FauxHammer 10 месяцев назад
Ok, so what can I use to measure if this does anything at all? Because it doesn’t seem to do anything useful
@TheFacelid
@TheFacelid 11 месяцев назад
I have no opinion on whether you should stop vaping or not, but I would suggest changing the filters in your mask
@enricobononi8655
@enricobononi8655 11 месяцев назад
doesnt do anyting like all the filters provided by elegoo...just a gimmiick
@erik3205
@erik3205 11 месяцев назад
Has anyone attempted to use grow tent carbon filters with 3d printers?
@antongunther3977
@antongunther3977 11 месяцев назад
Yes, they don't do much. You are better off venting the exhaust outside. Just get a grow tent and inline fan to create a negative pressure room around your printer
@erik3205
@erik3205 11 месяцев назад
I see, my garage doesn't have windows in it and its about to winter time, I'll have to come up with another solution. @@antongunther3977
@FauxHammer
@FauxHammer 11 месяцев назад
Inpaud a plumber mate to drill me a vent hole. £30. Then I bought a £15 extractor pipe kit from screwfix
@Ninjastar202
@Ninjastar202 11 месяцев назад
Great vid. doesn't need stock gesture footage.
@FauxHammer
@FauxHammer 11 месяцев назад
Trust me, its better than repeat filler footage and until I get a room big enough to do talking head footage. It's staying as it is. Sorry
@JohnVanderbeck
@JohnVanderbeck 10 месяцев назад
Spoiler alert yeah it does nothing but strip smells. Note their testing methodology says to let it sit for 6 hours then test again. Well you could turn the Mate off for 6b hours and the levels would drop about the same. Its 6 HOURS!
@scottyboy6269
@scottyboy6269 9 месяцев назад
3 Stage filter probably better by a lot, I have a Honeywell one with a massive carbon pad on it, the activated carbon blocks I swear have far less surface area.
@lozovoymax1941
@lozovoymax1941 11 месяцев назад
Interesting. Thanks. Seems like it does not work the way it is promoted. Seems like you still need enclosure and put printer with mate inside. Then it would do something useful. Instead of spreading less odor but not odor-less inside your room. But for that purpose, duct fan with 4" carbon filter exists. And, ha-ha, you can buy it. Can't understand why nobody offers some solution with vented/recirculated/heated enclosure. Feel lack of completed solution on the market. I understand that this video is not about enclosures, but this product tries to solve odor problem while it not clear whether it actually solves it. If you want to buy it - you want to recirculate inside your room. Also, that means that option with exhaust out of your house is not your choice. If you want to recirculate - keep it in small, enclosed area. People often go with grow tents, but they're huge. Smallest that you can get for decent price is 100x60x60 but often they're 120 or 140 tall. For 1-2 printers they're just too big. Would love to see something more suitable for resin printers rather than plants.
@defdaz
@defdaz 11 месяцев назад
Glad people are taking this seriously. You have to think total 'pollution' per day from all sources. Your body can only deal with so much per day and any more than this results in ill health. Dietary pollutants are very high for most people on the western diet (and causes serious ill health - all the modern western metabolic diseases like alzheimers, diabetes, obesity, heart disease etc.) and so most people can't deal with any additional pollution - think about how smoking tips most people over the edge even quicker than a bad diet alone. Stress, atmospheric pollution, diet, smoking all add up and if it's too high - you get ill / die (30,000 people die per year in the UK from air pollution).
@Romancelanguagespassion
@Romancelanguagespassion 7 месяцев назад
Sounds great, I am excited if you can compare different filter in the market to see which one is best, for instance Elegoo filter vs AlveoPro😅
@cidercreekranch
@cidercreekranch 8 месяцев назад
A well fitted printer lid will keep VOCs and particulate matter in the air surrounding the printer to a minimum. Though at the end of the print the contained VOCs and particulates will be release into the air and that is when having an effective means of venting these is key. I chose to build a fume hood measuring 44" wide x 20" deep x 44" that is vented to the outside, in the garage. Both the resin printer and the wash & cure station, resins and other chemical substances live in the hood. When printing, with the lid securely closed, I set the fan speed to the lowest value that is still effective at ensuring frequent air changes. At the end of the print, I set the fan speed to full before removing the printer's lid and cannot detect any odors, unless I shove my head into the hood. Even then there a a barely perceptible chemical odor. The hood encloses a volume of ~22.5 cubic feet and the vent fan is rate at 200 cubic feet per minute (CFM). Though I doubt that it moves more that 100 CFM. Even at the lower CFM, the air within the hood is exchanged at least 4 time per minute. Air changes per minute is more important than filtering capacity since the types of filters like the Elegoo and similar types of filter are not effective at moving air since they operated within a larger enclosed volume. Namely the room where it's located. Chemistry labs contain banks of fume hoods and not table top air cleaners. From The National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH): "Make sure that the space where you will be using the printer is well ventilated with lots of fresh, uncontaminated air to dilute and remove particles and gases. For example, the space has vented exhaust located near the 3D printer or windows and doors that can be opened to let fresh air into the room." And: "Isolate the 3D printer from persons in the room. For example, consider placing it in a working fume hood in a workplace setting or in a well-ventilated garage in a home setting." NIOSH recommends the above for FDM printers but it also applies to resin printers as well. I would not put much stock into the detector you used to measure formaldehyde concentration, since as other have indicated such low-cost devices are grossly inaccurate. To get accurate results requires capturing periodic air samples while the printer is operating and having the samples analyzed using gas chromatography coupled to a mass spectrometer. A study conducted by NIOSH, Evaluation of 3-D Printer Emissions and Personal Exposures at a Manufacturing Workplace, conclude, w.r.t. PPE that (emphasis added): "Personal protective equipment is the effective means for controlling hazardous exposures." and "Personal protective equipment be the sole method for controlling hazardous exposures. Rather, personal protective equipment should be used until effective engineering and administrative controls are in place."
@Volgan16666
@Volgan16666 11 месяцев назад
Hmmmm interesting - and there was me smoking my 3d printed resin cigars thinking they were better for me. Suggest you take the little meter and pop it in the bin. The less you know the better. What I do wonder is what sort of results you would get when you are using iso to clean the prints.
@fredrick_leicht
@fredrick_leicht 10 месяцев назад
There are two schools of thought when it comes to dealing with 3D Resin printers and the smell. One pump as mush air as you can OUT of the room. This works well but as I have noticed you end up making more smell the more air you pump out of the printer. so low air speed is the key. Two trapping the air inside the device. This is most likely best as you are not creating a bunch of gas by blowing on it and pumping it just just outside of where you are working. How ever that is until you take the lid off device. Once you take the lid off then you have to deal with the smell which is normal not a lot. So there you have it in a nut shell as they say. Do with it what you will.
@kielhawkins9529
@kielhawkins9529 8 месяцев назад
I kicked around the idea of a grow tent or cabinet with a fan venting to the outside. But adding some of those gloves to the side that you can reach through to interact with objects inside. It's obviously overkill, but you can work with the Resin and IPA without having to wear PPE or open the enclosure. For me in a little basement office that the kids are often in, it might be a way to work without having to kick everyone out and put on PPE.
@peternoob
@peternoob 11 месяцев назад
I also returned mine. It's slow/super slow settings are annoying as is the missing option to hook up multiple printers with these low speed settings. I also wouldn't say its small, compared with other available room air purifiers it's on the bigger side. Even more so if you take into account that the Mate will ever only work in a single printer setup. Good thing you had the hose laying on the desk, as the pressure fit of the hose is just as weak as it's fan. If it hangs loose in the air or connects the Mate to a printer on another shelf level, the hose slides out in a matter of hours.
@justinsomers8578
@justinsomers8578 11 месяцев назад
Haven't finished the video, but could you try testing the air filter with the usb-stick elegoo air purifiers? I'm also curious what it might look like if we have an air purifier running in a small room that's connected to the 3d printer?
@pablofiasco2
@pablofiasco2 11 месяцев назад
yeah, i think it would probably be easier, and safer, to just rig a tube with a fan drawing air out a window
@GuthanSlayer
@GuthanSlayer 11 месяцев назад
anyway you could test the air quality with an actual HEPA or other highly rated air filters really interested to see how those do with resin fumes etc
@Starfury0042
@Starfury0042 11 месяцев назад
I run mine in the garage and will have both doors open and it gets a nice breeze through and blows the smell out.
@ao-b2774
@ao-b2774 3 месяца назад
Just on the vape comment: vapes aren't 'safe', they're just less unsafe than cigarettes. People seem to confuse the later with the former.
@FauxHammer
@FauxHammer 3 месяца назад
Yeah, that was my point…
@samsimpson3071
@samsimpson3071 9 месяцев назад
I might be wrong but from what elegoo sent you it seems they tested it in an enclosed chamber for six hours which would mean that it is constantly recycling the air in that chamber over and over again which is obviously not what it’s doing when it’s sucking the fumes out of the machine and spitting them out into your room as the air now can’t get back into the machine. Plus the uncurled resin in the machine will constantly be producing the VOC vapours where as they seem to have started with a fixed amount of pollutant. The way they have tested it would be more applicable to the internal USB filters working solely within the case but technically you would have to cover the resin without removing the lid when you were finished printing and then wait six hours before you opened the case. This is my understanding of what’s been sent over.
@FauxHammer
@FauxHammer 9 месяцев назад
yep, that makes sense actually!
@olgriz8474
@olgriz8474 7 месяцев назад
The way you tested it went from active to passive. For instance active was you blowing the vape directly on the sensor, sticking it in the burnt toast smoke, & setting it on top of the purifiers exhaust. Passive is setting the sensor next to the machine & toaster. The sensor is meant to detect ppm in the surrounding air. With active testing the concentration/ppm the sensor is detecting is vastly higher than with passive. A better way to test would be to put the sensor in a small room or closet with the printer. Collect samples without the purifier then with the purifier and compare the results.
@FauxHammer
@FauxHammer 7 месяцев назад
I think the test that matters really, whether active or passive is that with the lid on, the printer doesn't let out many VOC's.. plug in the mate and turn it on and it throws tem into your room. is that what anyone wants?
@johnrobertson9333
@johnrobertson9333 10 месяцев назад
Where can we buy the correct attachment to run an exhaust from the Saturn 3!?
@KevinG9012
@KevinG9012 11 месяцев назад
I bought one. Now seems like a complete waste.
@mikedunning265
@mikedunning265 4 месяца назад
Amazing reboxing mate. Very efficient.....
@tek9058
@tek9058 11 месяцев назад
Just make something to put the printer into, make a filter yourself with loose active carbon and leave it inside. Done, a self heating box and filter. In winter it only needs initial heating and will maintain 25-30°C if properly isolated, the UV lights are awesome heaters. No fire risk having heaters permanently on. Tip: don't use Ikea stuff, get dense wood.
@FauxHammer
@FauxHammer 11 месяцев назад
I mean, I'm nktvthe mkst DIY person, but the point of the video was to reviewthis
@stevekay6895
@stevekay6895 11 месяцев назад
GREAT VIDEO !! The last thing I need is more useless junk on my workbench! 👍
@FauxHammer
@FauxHammer 11 месяцев назад
You and me both!
@axelrodriguez9967
@axelrodriguez9967 11 месяцев назад
I returned mine it doesnt work I use now some inline fan some adapters that are in printables and all goes outside
@FauxHammer
@FauxHammer 11 месяцев назад
Smart
@flojoairflojoair3369
@flojoairflojoair3369 11 месяцев назад
i know your love heated 3dprinters wudent it be a easy thing to confurt a heater to blow warm air tru that removebel vent hole ?
@FauxHammer
@FauxHammer 11 месяцев назад
It might be actually
@off-grideverything533
@off-grideverything533 11 месяцев назад
Think I'd rather just print an adapter, and buy some hose + a fan to pump it outside 😂
@FauxHammer
@FauxHammer 11 месяцев назад
Same
@kevinrodriguez4090
@kevinrodriguez4090 11 месяцев назад
Have you gotten a chance to test out uniformation gk2 12k lcd upgrade
@FauxHammer
@FauxHammer 11 месяцев назад
not got it yet
@vhoo7210
@vhoo7210 11 месяцев назад
Do you think the Mars Mate combined with 2 usb filters would make a difference?
@FauxHammer
@FauxHammer 11 месяцев назад
no
@antongunther3977
@antongunther3977 11 месяцев назад
Exhausting>>>>>>>filtration for smells and VOCs
@FauxHammer
@FauxHammer 11 месяцев назад
Damn that would have been a good thumbnail title
@ghostrangerp.8819
@ghostrangerp.8819 11 месяцев назад
Same here i use a grow tent for the small to mid size printers but fotr larger printers like the jupiter and higher these printers are not well thought out by the manufacters at all...if they actually took the time and listened to users like myself and others that have a functioning brain and took us to the manufacturer we could collaborate to create something so much better than the garbage being sold out there...its sad that these printers are just being recycled with the same parts over and over
@FauxHammer
@FauxHammer 11 месяцев назад
Some are listening
@ghostrangerp.8819
@ghostrangerp.8819 11 месяцев назад
@@FauxHammer The problem is by the time they listen most likely they dont care.. or lost interest...ive noticed that companies like elegoo and others dont care about their customers at all...its just about the cash in the end customer service has diminished so much entirely to a point where we hardly exist
@AndroidA258
@AndroidA258 10 месяцев назад
just do what i do, plug an air extraction fan to outside, its just the best way no matter what
@FauxHammer
@FauxHammer 10 месяцев назад
That’s why I usually do
@AndroidA258
@AndroidA258 10 месяцев назад
@@FauxHammer im really glad you made this video, i was literally just shopping for active air filters to put in my workplace and i was looking at this thing, it doesnt look that great from what it seems
@Hero1117a
@Hero1117a 11 месяцев назад
At least you're honest
@TimWatts
@TimWatts 11 месяцев назад
Did you try a test outside of the printer case with and without an internal carbon filter running? I'd love to know if they're actually doing anything.
@FauxHammer
@FauxHammer 11 месяцев назад
If the big carbon block isn't doing anything, I'd be very surprised to see the little one doing anything.
@TimWatts
@TimWatts 11 месяцев назад
@@FauxHammer Yeah i just wondered as they'd be cycling the same air over and over which would give the carbon more chance to absorb VOC's.
@npccx
@npccx 11 месяцев назад
How is Uniformation reading?
@FauxHammer
@FauxHammer 11 месяцев назад
not tested it, my filter ran out months ago - never bothered replacing it.
@Gateseleven
@Gateseleven 11 месяцев назад
vor from most or vor from plastic like buddy, thats not the same. And yes you're wrong, aint ther a fan even with the lid on you ll get air out. this devise idk is your wrong on that, I would just take the air outside no need to have it in the room.
@FauxHammer
@FauxHammer 11 месяцев назад
eh?
@OOTheBlueAir
@OOTheBlueAir 11 месяцев назад
@@FauxHammer should be Voc spelled wrong. yea the 3d printer have a fan that blows air in, some of that natural go up top, and out under the lid.?_
@RocktracksSC
@RocktracksSC 11 месяцев назад
​@@FauxHammerI think hes saying VOCs from toast and from plastics arent comparable in terms of posed danger, and why worrie about filtering efficacy when throwing the fumes outside is more effective anyway
@FauxHammer
@FauxHammer 11 месяцев назад
@@RocktracksSC ah thanks, Well in that case, yeah i know, that is why I said I'm no scientist. but also, the reason why I'm talking about it when blowing outside is better is because the point is to review this product. and this isn't a blowing outside machine.
@MemelordSupreme
@MemelordSupreme 11 месяцев назад
For the price you can get a pretty decent air cleaner built for workshops (like woodworking) that's going to do a lot more air circulation than this little guy. Granted, it's not feasible to put one of those in a bed room but if you're printing in a garage it would probably be fairly beneficial. I really hope more companies come out with similar solutions as the mars mate, but maybe thye could actually work haha!
@alexabel1841
@alexabel1841 11 месяцев назад
Could you give an example for such air cleaners?
@ROKKIT44
@ROKKIT44 10 месяцев назад
Thank you so much for this review. I messaged you over a month ago about this machine to see if it was worth it. You replied right away to say you were in the process of reviewing. Thank you for taking the time to try this out. Sad to learn it’s worthless, but glad I learned before buying. The fact they still don’t have replacement filters available, is just icing on the garbage cake.
@FauxHammer
@FauxHammer 10 месяцев назад
Glad I could help!
@GreySectoid
@GreySectoid 7 месяцев назад
It's not worthless. I think the testing procedure is flawed somehow - or he has reversed the laws of physics. Industrial fume extractors use the exact same principle e.g. when filtering out air from laser engravers, and it works.
@enricobononi8655
@enricobononi8655 11 месяцев назад
correct...adding the filter (even the one they provide) it is just moving the air and making more VOC coming out form the lid. Keeping the lid close is the best solution
Далее
Real World 3D Printing with the Elegoo Mars 4 Ultra 9k
23:38
THE BEST Elegoo Saturn 4 Ultra Review on The Internet
21:00
pumpkins #shorts
00:39
Просмотров 21 млн
I was DEAD WRONG about air quality
20:24
Просмотров 162 тыс.
Elegoo Saturn 4 Ultra (HONEST review) 3D resin printer
15:37
Can I 3D Print AND Paint A GIANT Knight In 24 hours?
13:24
Elegoo Mars 5 Ultra, Worth it for YOUR shop? Well..
9:39
Resin 3D Printers don't NEED inbuilt heaters (TESTED)
13:55