Тёмный

Elizabeth I and William Camden: The New Information and Findings in Context 

Reading the Past
Подписаться 126 тыс.
Просмотров 49 тыс.
50% 1

Last month we got news of an historical text discovery that is providing us with new information about the Elizabethan period and its legacy. Today, I want to talk about this text as a whole, to explore it within its historical context - what do we know about the author? What did we think we knew about his work? And how much has this discovery changed our earlier understanding?
Let’s take a look at William Camden and his Annales…
I hope you enjoy this video and find it interesting!
Please subscribe and click the bell icon to be updated about new videos.
Also, if you want to get in touch, please comment down below or find me on social media:
Instagram and Threads: katrina.marchant
Twitter: @kat_marchant
TikTok: @katrina_marchant
Email: readingthepastwithdrkat@gmail.com
Intro / Outro song: Silent Partner, "Greenery" [ • Greenery - Silent Part... ]
SFX from freesfx.co.uk/...
Linked videos and playlists:
End of the first Elizabethan Age: • The End of the First E...
Images (from Wikimedia Commons, unless otherwise stated):
Screenshots for title sequence from:
1) www.theguardia...
2) www.smithsonia...
3) www.finebooksm...
Screenshots from British Library press release from: www.bl.uk/pres...
The title page of William Camden's Britannia (1607 edition).
Portrait of Gabriel Goodman, a copy by George Perfect Harding, after an unknown artist’s watercolour (early 19th century). Held by the National Portrait Gallery.
Map showing the rivers of England only.
Detail from the funeral procession of Elizabeth I of England, 1603. William Camden, Clarenceux King of Arms is shown bearing the Tabard or "coate", between two gentleman ushers (c.1603). From Richard Marks and Anne Payne, eds. “British Heraldry, from its origins to c. 1800”, British Museum Publications, 1978.
Detail from the funeral procession of Elizabeth I of England, 1603 showing "The Helme and Creaste borne by Raffe Brooke Yorke Herald of Armes" (c.1603). From Richard Marks and Anne Payne, eds. “British Heraldry, from its origins to c. 1800”, British Museum Publications, 1978.
Portrait of William Camden by or after Marcus Gheeraerts the Younger (17th century, based on a work of 1609). Held by the National Portrait Gallery.
Frontispiece and titlepage from a 1675 edition of William Camden's biography of Queen Elizabeth I. From the private Collection of S. Whitehead.
Quoted texts:
www.bl.uk/pres...
Wyman H. Herendeen, ODNB entry on William Camden.
Also consulted, were:
Other relevant entries from The Oxford Dictionary of National Biography Online.
openlibrary.or...
www.bl.uk/coll...
#History #ElizabethI #WilliamCamden

Опубликовано:

 

29 сен 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 657   
@KamikazeKatze666
@KamikazeKatze666 Год назад
It is known that the empress Agrippina, Nero's mother, wrote an autobiography but unfortunately it hasn't survived . Even though the chances are slim I still hope that this book is waiting on a dark shelf of an obscure monastery to be discovered by a courageous researcher.
@c.s.7266
@c.s.7266 Год назад
I literally just watched a documentary about Nero's beginnings on Friday and that Agrippina had a sad ending. It would be interesting to know more about her from her own words.
@pamelaoliver8442
@pamelaoliver8442 Год назад
Yes!!
@margaretlovelock7031
@margaretlovelock7031 Год назад
👸🏽🫅🏻🤴🏿⏱️⚰️⚔️💣⛓️⚜️🛡️🌎🌍🌏???
@ScorpionFlower95
@ScorpionFlower95 Год назад
Something tells me that given the time it has passed and the way she fell from grace, the chances of finding that autobiography are very very very slim
@phillipstroll7385
@phillipstroll7385 Год назад
According to the public of that time all we know about Nero today is a lie. The citizens were just as literate them as they are now. In most cases multi lingual. The slaves did all the business of the day so they were very much multi lingual. Anyway, hundreds of thousands of artifacts, letters, etc have been found in garbage heaps, graffiti, etc claiming the people absolutely loved Nero. That he was a true blessing to the citizens and it was the senate who hated him. It was they whom began a propaganda campaign against him. Much like the cia against Trump today. I'd like to know for sure which side is telling the truth. Although I know already the citizens are. Because we don't need monuments built to tell us people are bad. We only do that when they are loved and the state needs to convince the next generation otherwise.
@wwirelesswwizard
@wwirelesswwizard Год назад
Other than the obvious crown emoji, I think that some possible contenders for an Elizabethan-themed emoji include: 1. 🌍 or 🌎 (the globe) - This can obviously be because of the beginnings of globalization and the numerous colonies under Elizabeth I, but also a reference to the Armada Portrait, where she's holding a globe. 2. 💃 (the dancing woman) - Queen Elizabeth I loved dancing, so this one feels like an obvious choice to me. 3. 🧦 (socks) - This choice might seem a bit odd, but as someone who loves knitting-themed history tidbits, there are 2 well-known stories that often make me think of socks whenever I think of Queen Elizabeth I: First, there's that story about how, shortly after she became queen, a lady-in-waiting gifted her her first ever pair of knitted silk stockings. Up until that point in her life, Elizabeth had only worn/owned woven wool stockings. She was so delighted with her new pair that she declared that she would only ever silk knitted stockings for the rest of her life. Second, there was a man named William Lee who invented the first ever knitting machine; when he showed it to Elizabeth I, she refused to grant him a patent, and explained that it was because she did not want to destroy the livelihoods of those who knit stockings for a living.
@adriannegentleman83
@adriannegentleman83 Год назад
🎭🪡 I love how even our understanding of history can change with new data. Love your content Dr Kat, keep it up.
@jillniemczynski5517
@jillniemczynski5517 Год назад
Thank you Dr Kat💜🫅🏰🎪⚔️👑🛡️⚜️🚩🔔🕯️
@dannemcmillen7917
@dannemcmillen7917 Год назад
The English mystery that I wold love to hear new breakthrough evidence about is the “princes in the tower.” 👑 🏰 I enjoy your videos, Dr. Kat!
@debbiev4455
@debbiev4455 9 месяцев назад
You were right!! I am excited to hear more of their findings !
@judiguest8409
@judiguest8409 Год назад
Thanks again for the most interesting facts. ❤😊❤
@JanetBezer
@JanetBezer 11 месяцев назад
Very interesting to find hidden details in documents of Camden. Would great to find a diary of one of Elizabeth's ladies is there one? 🏵🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿
@belwynne1386
@belwynne1386 Год назад
Fascinating! 👸
@srelizabethmaryhermit6450
@srelizabethmaryhermit6450 Год назад
Superb! 🧐
@TheCynthiaRice
@TheCynthiaRice Год назад
I just listened to a podcast about this from Not Just the Tudors. So fascinating.
@chrystalcook3239
@chrystalcook3239 Год назад
This was awesome 👌 thanks really enjoyed it. Watching from New Zealand 🇳🇿. 🏰👑💍🎻🕯📜🇬🇧
@annagail8458
@annagail8458 Год назад
Love your history channel you are 🫶👸👑👸you are wonderful!!!
@victoriaz14
@victoriaz14 Год назад
had to do it ♍
@mlpollard2
@mlpollard2 Год назад
Anyone else wish that, scribbled in a margin, it would reveal that Elizabeth's last words were really "I die a queen but I would rather die the wife of Robert Dudley"?
@evewhite1474
@evewhite1474 Год назад
I would like to find out what happened to The Lost Colony in colonial America.
@moniquehoward1822
@moniquehoward1822 Год назад
I would like to know if there is further information about the death of Amy Robsart or if Elizabeth would have let the son of Catherine Grey become king or information about his legitimacy 🪶
@possumbuddy
@possumbuddy Год назад
I'm an American but I find British history fascinating. Thank you for your videos.
@lesliedupre4357
@lesliedupre4357 Год назад
I totally agree with you!! Fascinating!!❤️
@tergre54
@tergre54 Год назад
Depending on your bloodline, this could be your history too.
@lesliedupre4357
@lesliedupre4357 Год назад
@@tergre54 so true!!
@possumbuddy
@possumbuddy Год назад
@@tergre54 You're right. Most of my family is from the UK so that's probably why I love it.
@ea7383
@ea7383 Год назад
🌹(Wars of the Roses emoji) This American loves Dr. Kat too!
@charlottegrim3542
@charlottegrim3542 Год назад
Thank you, Dr. Kat, for producing such interesting and informative videos! I very much enjoy not only your content, but the manner in which you present it. I live in a rural area in Western Maryland and know very few people who share my interest in English history. I truly appreciate you and your channel.
@sempressfi
@sempressfi Год назад
I've been obsessed with Elizabeth I since I was 7 (and a lot more figures/events as I've gotten older) and it was definitely lonely before finding all the awesome historians and fellow always-students online. It's so nice having ways to always explore and find new content, research, etc
@kellyfrost1052
@kellyfrost1052 Год назад
I am an American listening. I am fascinated by the pilgrims who went to Leiden then onto the new world. The Pilgrims appear to be separatists, not Puritans. I would like to know more about what drove these groups to actually leave Europe w/out them being lumped together.
@susanfisher606
@susanfisher606 Год назад
Thank you Dr. Kat for another wonderful video! Nice to see hard evidence of censorship in historical documents. 🕯️👑💂🏻
@susanfisher606
@susanfisher606 Год назад
@garyallen8824 no, I did not say or imply that I am pro-censorship. I merely pointed out that it is nice to see the physical evidence that censorship is not a recent invention. One always hears the “history is written by the victors” spiel and now we have proof.
@danielsantiagourtado3430
@danielsantiagourtado3430 Год назад
Love your content girl! Thanks for all your dedication!😊😊😊😊❤❤❤❤
@ReadingthePast
@ReadingthePast Год назад
Thank you for your kind words and encouragement 😊
@danielsantiagourtado3430
@danielsantiagourtado3430 Год назад
@@ReadingthePast ALWAYS
@grtlyblesd
@grtlyblesd Год назад
Would love to see a video on the religious art created during the Tudor era. It was such a tumultuous time, in terms of religion, I would like to see how artists were expressing their beliefs, and what prior time periods they drew inspiration from. (For instance, the way artists of the Dark Ages patterned their Madonna and Child after Egypt’s Isis.) 🖼️ 🎨 👩‍🎨
@ingerfaber3411
@ingerfaber3411 8 месяцев назад
Interesting idea
@michellejenkins5922
@michellejenkins5922 Год назад
Brilliant, it shows that history is not always what were told and even lost or hidden histories are coming to light📜📜✒
@kathrynmast916
@kathrynmast916 Год назад
We must always remember that history is written from someone’s point of view and the facts that are presented are always bias even when when trying our best to be truth and unbiased.🫅👑🌹🏰 Dr. Kat , your presentations always look at not only the historical event, but the background, sources and the attached biases. Your work is excellent and always a joy to behold!
@johannabarkwith3703
@johannabarkwith3703 Год назад
I think that the present is also written from someone else’s point of view. You only have to look at how the various newspapers report the same incident to see that there are biases and points of view that dictate how they report current affairs.
@--enyo--
@--enyo-- Год назад
In high school I took extension history (a subject which looks at history and how it is told) and this was a big part of it, as well as the different lenses History can be viewed through.
@alisade127
@alisade127 Год назад
Yes it and she is a joy to behold.
@Zandain
@Zandain Год назад
Which is why > critical thinking < and analysis are important tools when studying history and present day politics 😉
@JoanFoley-t1y
@JoanFoley-t1y Год назад
🤴
@theclassicso8094
@theclassicso8094 Год назад
It is fascinating what we are learning from the past using modern technology. Thank you for bring this to our attention. ❤❤
@cindygrubbs5856
@cindygrubbs5856 Год назад
❤ Thank you, Dr. Kat! Love the way that you bring history to life!
@1607hannah1
@1607hannah1 Год назад
Really interesting video. When it comes to a history mystery, I've always wished that the two children's skeletons found under the tower of london were DNA tested to confirm whether or not they are the princes of the tower who went missing. I don't really understand why the royal family don't want to have that confirmed, when they were perfectly happy to provide DNA for the murdered Romanovs to confirm those bodies found. It might give us more clues as to what happened to the princes and who is to blame, but for now we just don't know.
@bonniherself
@bonniherself Год назад
🕯🍖 Okay, it's not very "Elizabethan" but a candle and joint of roasted meat is certainly associated with the Tudor court. 😋
@kimberlyperrotis8962
@kimberlyperrotis8962 Год назад
I would love a video on the most important English antiquaries and their famous discoveries and works. In many cases, their records and drawings are all we have of lost places and events. Thanks, Dr. Kat. Love your channel❤
@eshim3961
@eshim3961 Год назад
I can't remember what it was, but I read an intriguing theory where it was posited that Henry the 8th's difficulty with fathering a male heir was due to Rh factor incompatibility or McLeod syndrome, another blood antigen disorder . Being in the medical field, this theory fascinated me, and the way it was presented checked out. I doubt any genetic testing would be allowed, but that would be an interesting thing to find out. Staying within the Tudor family, I think it was mentioned that Elizabeth the first may have had Marfan syndrome (but I don't think this theory is especially likely ). Fascinating video, as always.
@sjj39
@sjj39 Год назад
I would love evidence leading to the truth about Amy Robsarts death
@ReadingthePast
@ReadingthePast Год назад
SAME!!!
@leanneburbank
@leanneburbank Год назад
It's always great to hear you present these bits of history
@mariposahorribilis
@mariposahorribilis Год назад
Thank you for simply and clearly describing the background to help us understand these fascinating discoveries. As always, very enlightening.💡
@jenniferlewak3506
@jenniferlewak3506 Год назад
Hello Dr. Kat! I absolutely LOVE your videos-thank you for making them. I tried to leave an emoji, but RU-vid wasn't having it. Instead, and this is not so much a mystery, but I have a question that has been on my mind for a while now, or a possible idea for a future video? How violent was the ‘Pilgrimage of Grace’ of 1536? I hear different versions from different historians. It doesn’t sound like it was a violent protest… or was it? How bad would it have been so bad as to scare Henry VIII? Or was he so indignant that his people would make demands of him, for his violent (and very underhanded) response? Or was he being ignorant, or arrogant, to the demands of his people? Also, were any Reformers involved? I understand that a great deal of a county’s economy often relied on the prosperity of the Abbeys… would the Reformers be concerned about this as well? Thank you- Love from Canada!
@ainekearney9041
@ainekearney9041 Год назад
I would love to find any books that was taken from Ireland. Most where destroyed, but one was found in England a century ago. The Lord that had it thought it was egypian but the Irish professor who saw it knew what it was. He was afraid to say because "he was afraid the Lord would throw it in the fire"It was a book of Brehon law, the Irish law system. Everyone knows one of these laws, it was named after the English gentleman who received its punishment, Boycott. It would be nice if England could look an see if any Irish manuscipts survived. But unfortunately most where destroyed.
@anna_in_aotearoa3166
@anna_in_aotearoa3166 Год назад
I think perhaps a valuable and timely reminder that written historical documents as they come to us are not neutral or necessarily 100% accurate to real life...? Even though they do tend to be relied on so heavily in academic research, and also usually given great weight over oral or pictorial accounts (or even contextual object finds)? Kudos Dr. Kat as always for your clear, fluent & concise narration (presumably from pre-written script?) even in a livestream! Not all RU-vidrs manage such a natural style when transmitting live! Gosh, an Elizabethan emoji... Perhaps this one 💎 Given how invested their monied classes and nobles/royals were in the conspicuous display of wealth at the time?! 😝
@judiguest8409
@judiguest8409 Год назад
It is 2.55am in Aoteara N.Z. And I am in bed waiting for the programme to start. It sounds very interesting! Thanks for sharing it with us ❤
@anna_in_aotearoa3166
@anna_in_aotearoa3166 Год назад
Shout-out from middle-of-the-night Ōtautahi/Chch! 😊
@judiguest8409
@judiguest8409 Год назад
@@anna_in_aotearoa3166 😊I’m in Christchurch also Anna. Have a good night dreaming of Elizabethans 😴
@patriciahill6839
@patriciahill6839 Год назад
thank you so much. would love to know more about the mystery of the death of Amy Robstart Lord Robert Dudleys wife. Did she die by accident or who ordered her death 21:17 21:17
@jenniferwilliamson7533
@jenniferwilliamson7533 Год назад
So who, besides James, could've succeeded Elizabeth??
@marshaprice8226
@marshaprice8226 Год назад
I agree that, having steadfastly refused to name a successor all this time, Elizabeth is not at all likely to have changed her mind at the last minute and signaled her approval of James. I wonder if she really would have approved of him? If she didn’t, that’s all the more reason for her to have said nothing at all!
@bbybella9937
@bbybella9937 Год назад
She did approve of him. She and her advisors were prepping him and she was in contact with him. She simply was never going to name a successor anyways.
@myparceltape1169
@myparceltape1169 Год назад
​@@bbybella9937 Perhaps her advisers did not want a female queen again and that's why they got her cousin killed.
@lindawakiyama1603
@lindawakiyama1603 Год назад
Hello from Japan!😊
@joanneCaisley
@joanneCaisley Год назад
another fascinating piece of history brought to light. Historians are among my favourite people and Dr. Kat is one of the most informative - thank you for your content 😊
@evelinharmannfan7191
@evelinharmannfan7191 Год назад
Elizabethan emojis: ⛵ boat for Elizabeth I building the English Navy 🌍going places setting up colonies 🔭telescope for discoveries 🏴‍☠ a pirate´s flag for the privateers filling the queens coffers with gold 💰 from Spanish ships 📚 books for learning and literature that thrived 🏟 the arena resembles the globe theathre - Shakespeare and Marlow as the best playwriters 🧱 brick building becoming popular for Elizabethan manor houses 💍a ring for Elizabeth´s elaborate dress style and jewels ⚠ a warning sign, and a knive 🗡for the constant danger of asassination the queen was in ⚔ swords for her military successes "Gloriana"
@paulaedwards1978
@paulaedwards1978 Год назад
Archbishop John Whitgift was reportedly requested to be by Elizabeth’s side during her final days/hours and has subsequently almost disappeared from written history. His crest is also missing from Canterbury Cathedral. Does this new discovery shed any light on John Whitgift potentially witnessing the lack of communication from Elizabeth in naming her successor? Could this be why he ‘disappeared’ from favour and record soon afterwards?
@manuellubian5709
@manuellubian5709 Год назад
Question: do you think that the Camden document will ever reveal any tidbits about Queen Elizabeth I's personal traits, temperaments, or personality?
@kirstena4001
@kirstena4001 Год назад
historical mystery: was William the Conqueror really promised the English throne??? Or did he just use that as an excuse?
@skwervin1
@skwervin1 Год назад
I just wish there was an unadulterated contemporary account for Richard III and the lost Princes in the Tower. ⚓👑⚔
@Rockieswoobie
@Rockieswoobie Год назад
❤❤❤❤you move inspired me to get my MA in history.✨
@lisakilmer2667
@lisakilmer2667 Год назад
The mind always boggles at the toxicity of the Tudor court. Finding Camden's revisions is very interesting.
@michaelkopala3738
@michaelkopala3738 Год назад
👸 Thank you for another wonderful podcast. And to think that somebody actually edited to historical documents! Who knew? And this is the best Elizabeth Emoji I could find.
@user-mc3wb6mo8r
@user-mc3wb6mo8r Год назад
23:01 The two mysteries that shall, most probably, never be categorically solved in this time period are (1) was the marriage of Arthur and Catherine of Aragon ever consummated, and was Mary Queen of Scots forced to marry Bothwell?😮
@GreatGreebo
@GreatGreebo Год назад
🧱🧱🍗 ⚔️ 🕯️ 👑..A few red bricks for Hampton Court, a swan drum stick, swords, a candle and *THE* crown for Elizabethan England. Ha! I am also feeling a bit smug with this new discovery! I have always doubted *Elizabeth I* would willing designate James as her rightful successor. I have honestly always thought she died without naming anyone. Thank you and cheers!
@janellinger4492
@janellinger4492 Год назад
This is so interesting. Your analysis and the analysis of the doctoral student makes sense. I know that history that I have personally witnessed and experienced isn't necessarily portrayed as I saw it. ❤❤
@gertsgarden
@gertsgarden Год назад
Won’t be able to make the premiere but will be watching as soon as I get home. As always thank you so much Dr Kat!
@lpcherry2324
@lpcherry2324 Год назад
This video is very, very interesting. History is written by the victors…or the successor. Thank you for bringing it to us! 👑🥳
@cindys2617
@cindys2617 Год назад
I am wondering how, when previously unavailable information is uncovered (in this case, literally UNDER canon documents), historians determine which version is closest to the true recording of events? It seems in this case that the BM is interpreting the heretofore hidden information as closer to the truth, so how have they determined that the final drafts were embellishments or simply less accurate? Couldn't the overwrite have been to correct the first draft because that was inaccurate? How in the world do historians decide which version to propound as most factual? As always, I really enjoyed your presentation. 🦁📖
@atarayael
@atarayael Год назад
🦁 lion on England’s crest 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿 🦄 unicorn on Scotland 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁳󠁣󠁴󠁿 Great Britain has both
@f.c.6819
@f.c.6819 Год назад
After seeing records being sealed by the British monarchy recently, I now am very curious about how many secrets will ever come out about the royals of the past. All very intriguing.
@theloverlyladylo9158
@theloverlyladylo9158 Год назад
It’s always good to remember that primary documents were written by people, with all the biases and influences that implies. 👑
@Kristine709
@Kristine709 Год назад
I need to read Camden to gain a greater understanding on this topic. Unlike other books I haven’t read yet (Suetonius is giving me a glare from the bookshelf), I didn’t know Camden existed. 📕 📖 📚 👑👑🕯️⏳⌛️
@gonefishing167
@gonefishing167 Год назад
Hi Dr Kat, really enjoyable ! Did Philip 11 die in the manner that was written, didn’t like him much ( how can you say that about someone you’ve never met. Seems wrong doesn’t it?) but that death sounds gross. I think many have always wondered about Elizabeth naming James on her deathbed. Many people who are busy dying don’t have time for chitchat. Though, in truth, Elizabeth should have had the succession written in stone ages before she passed. Very remiss. Yes , James was a good candidate but , when I thought she had named him, I wondered how much of his naming came from a guilty conscience toward his mother . Who else do you think she would have had in mind? There were plenty of candidates to choose from. I’d say the council took it upon themselves ( or 1 man did) to choose who he thought would best serve. James was a Protestant ( and England had always wanted Scotland) , married and, most importantly, already had sons for the succession. Thank you 🙏🙏👵🇦🇺
@gracefuller9981
@gracefuller9981 Год назад
Thank you Dr Kat, you have a wonderful speaking voice, an amazing way explaining. I have always be fascinated by history and religions. How they enter twine and how they have shaped our world. I’ve enjoyed every one of the subjects you’ve brought to life for us. So, thank you
@cmcg9035
@cmcg9035 Год назад
Thanks so much! I'd like to see a video on some of those who lived a long life and prospered, despite being in Henry VIII's court. And what was the likelihood of surviving his court? ⛵
@elizabethhubble5296
@elizabethhubble5296 Год назад
Mystery for which new documentary evidence would be amazing: Princes in the tower. Death of Amy Robsart, to second commenters below.
@MissSiobahnMaebh
@MissSiobahnMaebh Год назад
I have always thought it quite off the Elizabeth I would designate the son of her rival (Mary, Queen of Scots) as her successor.
@bendrui
@bendrui Год назад
⛵For the privateers Elizabeth sent to rob the Spanish treasure ships of the valuables Conquistadors were stealing from the Americas.
@saralittle18
@saralittle18 Год назад
The mystery of whether Elizabeth I knowingly signed for and allowed the death of Mary Queen of Scots
@michaelablair4689
@michaelablair4689 Год назад
Things that happen when you follow multiple history creators on multiple platform is hearing about recent discoveries from multiple view points
@MelindaWalker-p4x
@MelindaWalker-p4x Год назад
I had read of this discovery but found your discussion of the context and probable reasons for the changes fascinating. I’d like to hear more about the roles in court, and how people used the savages gained by these appointments. ❤
@LaceyGordon-i1x
@LaceyGordon-i1x Год назад
📖👑🏵 Love a good discovery story. Thank you.
@j7333nnn
@j7333nnn Год назад
Thanks !! Festinating as always. Jeffrey Newcomb
@ginalou5774
@ginalou5774 Год назад
🍖🍺🎾meat, beer and tennis….very ‘Tudor’ I think!
@myparceltape1169
@myparceltape1169 Год назад
👽☠🙉👀🧠🧚🏵 Foreigners. At least they 🍺
@diannaholiday9086
@diannaholiday9086 Год назад
This is absolutely fascinating! It is much more true to character that Elizabeth I did not - under any circumstances! - designate a successor.
@bennylawrence6221
@bennylawrence6221 Год назад
The princes in the tower and the consummation of Arthur and Catherine’s marriage
@Olivia-io9sb
@Olivia-io9sb Год назад
Politics and religion...... bases on which to be 'cancelled then, and now.
@lynnedelacy2841
@lynnedelacy2841 Год назад
More what ifs please ❤Also a friend of mine has just been accepted to join the Charterhouse community Given it is such an historic establishment an investigation by you of its history would be of great interest
@ataraxisbuildsthings429
@ataraxisbuildsthings429 Год назад
🍬 this is supposed to represent those little bon bons that Elizabeth loved so much!
@moonloon5859
@moonloon5859 Год назад
Hello from South Africa, Dr Kat. I would like to thank you for your fabulous videos and for the way you teach history so that the persons become so very human. I have always found history fascinating and you definitely feed my appetite for it! ❤❤❤
@EmoBearRights
@EmoBearRights Год назад
I've always been interested in the Princes in the Tower. 🎭
@erinrising2799
@erinrising2799 Год назад
I was just wondering if you know anything about John's ascension to the thrown. He had nephews by two of his older brothers. How did he become king?
@beth7935
@beth7935 Год назад
I'm pretty sure John only had one nephew from an older brother: Arthur of Brittany, his brother Geoffrey's son. He'd been Richard I's heir, but Richard changed his mind when he was dying & named John instead, as Arthur was only ~12. When he was ~15, he allied with the French king & rebelled against John, & John had him imprisoned. He was never seen again, & it's most likely John had him killed. And since John doesn't have a society full of obsessive fans like Richard III has, nobody really argues with this extremely reasonable conclusion...
@erinrising2799
@erinrising2799 Год назад
@@beth7935 I thought I'd read that Richard had a son with Baringaria (sp?)
@beth7935
@beth7935 Год назад
@@erinrising2799 That would be major news to me! To the best of my knowledge, Richard & Berengaria had no children at all, & certainly not a son who was alive at Richard's death: I can't imagine Richard disinheriting his own legitimate son for John, or people not wanting a legitimate son of the great Richard the Lionheart, or many people seriously preferring John. Richard did have one illegitimate son, but I'm not aware of anyone suggesting him as a successor- only John & Arthur.
@Green4CloveR
@Green4CloveR Год назад
It’s always exciting to hear about what is new in the discovery of history. 🎉
@steelerbear
@steelerbear Год назад
Thank you for covering this great topic, Dr Kat! 💗👑
@Funnybriton
@Funnybriton Год назад
How did James VI co-opt Elizabeth’s government. After all first he turned Essex and Cecil sensing an opportunity leaped at James VI so as soon as Elizabeth died the King of Scots was declared King of England.
@Tuppence1
@Tuppence1 Год назад
This is a very interesting issue. I hope Dr Kat speaks on this for us
@kaybrown4010
@kaybrown4010 Год назад
I, for one, confess to feeling a tad smug when I’m vindicated. 😄 Your videos are amazing. Many thanks! 🪶📜🌹
@lbakemeyer
@lbakemeyer Год назад
If not James, who do you think would have been the most likely candidate. According to King Henry VIII" s will, he excluded Margaret's successors from the English throne. So why James and not Mary's succesors? A desire to unify Scotland and England by Elizabeth's advisors? You raise some very interesting points or should I say Camden.
@ReadingthePast
@ReadingthePast Год назад
Mary Tudor (Brandon) had a great grandson and a great great granddaughter who was still living when Elizabeth died - both of who had a recognised claim to the throne in law. I think Arbella Stuart might have had a shot too. Although descended from Margaret, she was born in England, which might have sweetened the pot.
@ccsullivan9164
@ccsullivan9164 Год назад
Think of all the discoveries to come! 💀💕
@cmlaporte62
@cmlaporte62 Год назад
Such a prescient example of history being written by the victors, or as in this case, those in power.
@dhoward8816
@dhoward8816 Год назад
I wish they could solve the mystery of what happened to the two princes in the Tower (Edward V and Richard). If they were murdered, are the bones of the two boys found in the Tower really them?👑
@lel7841
@lel7841 Год назад
It's entirely possible they didn't die from murder but merely illness. There were rumors at the time the boys had a long illness and children were shockingly likely to die before adulthood back then by things are easily survived of now. Given that they were locked up and getting very little in the way of fresh air, sunlight, and exercise they probably were quite weak anyway.
@BethDiane
@BethDiane Год назад
I wanted to add one of a ruff, but it doesn't exist yet.
@susuelisa7134
@susuelisa7134 Год назад
I'd love some information about the collection of relics held by the Elector "Friedrich der Weise" during the German Reformation... I always wondered if they were given away, put in storage, destroyed....
@johnguglmini
@johnguglmini Год назад
the mystery of what Queen Vtctorias writing real said as they were heavily edited by her daughter john guglielmini
@ReadingthePast
@ReadingthePast Год назад
I would also appreciate this info
@kimberlykirkpatrick5954
@kimberlykirkpatrick5954 Год назад
I love your videos - from the US!
@octavianpopescu4776
@octavianpopescu4776 Год назад
So, now... I'm confused about how succession actually worked. Because as far as I can tell, it was nothing more than a might makes right system, with no real rules, only a veneer of law to make it look legitimate. So, Henry VIII writes a will which is made law by Parliament in which he establishes an order of succession, but that will and law contradict an older law that bastards can't inherit (Mary and Elizabeth being bastards according to him). Then comes Edward VI, ok, fine, he's king, so it makes sense that if the previous king can change the succession, so can he? Right? He's just as king as Henry was. And he decides Queen Jane I is the Queen. But then Queen Jane I is removed via a coup led by a usurping Queen Mary I and killed, based on Henry's will... so people were still trying to follow Henry's will, ok, so far so good... but then after Queen Mary I comes Queen Elizabeth I who straight up ignores her father's will and law and just does... whatever. So, Henry's will WASN'T law after all or what? Elizabeth gets her successor Katherine Grey killed by playing ping pong with her for the horrible crime of getting married and having children... the horror and then... plays with the idea of naming the Scottish King as her heir, which was absolutely against the law and her dad's will. And then the Council just brings the Scottish King. How is that NOT a coup? So it seems to me it's all random and there is no actual principle applied here. Let's listen to Henry VIII's shady will, but only while it's convenient and just pretend Edward VI doesn't exist, because... reasons, he's a child (the Device for Succession was signed by his council and the Great Seal applied to it, so it wasn't just a piece of paper, it was law, yes, contradicting other laws... because why not? Henry's will did, by allowing bastards to inherit the crown). Oh, and because Elizabeth is loved by everyone she gets to just do whatever with the succession and at the end the council breaks all laws and does a coup. So... what gives? Because, all I see are contradictory laws which may or may not be valid and even those are applied as it suits some people, when it suits them. If this is the case, let's also acknowledge Queen Jane I, she had her 9 (or 13) days as a Queen and whoever may have just held power throughout history, regardless of legality. In this case, there are no usurpers or traitors, just monarchs with varying degrees of control and reign durations who took over not because they had some right, but because they were better at violence than everyone else. Might made right.
@dominaevillae28
@dominaevillae28 Год назад
Edward VI was a minor and could not make a will on his own; it would have had to be approved by parliament, which it was not, so Henry VIII’s will stands and Mary is the legitimate Queen.
@octavianpopescu4776
@octavianpopescu4776 Год назад
@@dominaevillae28 As far as I know, he did have the right, but with the Council's approval as a minor. But Elizabeth could do it just by waving her finger on her death bed? And even Henry's will went against another law banning bastards from inheriting, since Henry as usual had to make a mess... instead of legitimizing Mary and Elizabeth,, as he should have, he just left things like that. And then if Henry's will is the law, why was it later ignored? Why does someone like Arundel say Mary is a bastard and supports Jane, then he says the will is law to put Mary on the throne, but then objects to the exact same piece of paper later, because Henry didn't sign it by hand and a stamp was used? One guy changing his views as the wind blows... so it seems to me, the only criterion was who was in control of the capital. To this day, bastards are not allowed to inherit the throne, but they just ignored that for Mary and Elizabeth. I guess it's only fitting as the whole Tudor dynasty was established "by right of conquest" that it ended with a coup, the Council doing whatever it wanted. At least Henry VII was honest about it, he basically said: I have the bigger army, whatcha gonna do about it?
@shirleykathan-sayess5764
@shirleykathan-sayess5764 Год назад
Very interesting! What a lucky discovery to shed light on the truth vs PR. 🍷
@AinsleyCarson
@AinsleyCarson Год назад
It's always great to hear you present these bits of history. Love your content girl! Thanks for all your dedication!.
@alexandravladmets8206
@alexandravladmets8206 Год назад
💃She was a dancing queen!
@maryannchaisson6742
@maryannchaisson6742 Год назад
I love history - so really enjoy your vlogs!! 🇨🇦👑
@AAD2698
@AAD2698 Год назад
📖♍(the virgin queen)
@peterromeo4379
@peterromeo4379 Год назад
NEW HISTORY JUST DROPPED! I REPEAT! NEW HISTORY HAS JUST DROPPED! This is very exciting!
@evaapple255
@evaapple255 Год назад
really ? YT likes emojies ? well then :😏😋😛😁😁😁😁😁😁😁😁😁😁😁😁😁😁😁😁
Далее
The End of the First Elizabethan Era
32:09
Просмотров 55 тыс.
11 ming dollarlik uzum
00:43
Просмотров 681 тыс.
BUSTING HISTORY MYTHS
32:47
Просмотров 24 тыс.
Lady Arbella Stuart: England's Lost Queen?
22:06
Просмотров 157 тыс.
Taking the Throne: By Right or by Might?
38:52
Просмотров 58 тыс.
'Beau" Brummell: Chief of the Fashion Police?
22:58
Просмотров 15 тыс.
The Winter Queen and the House of Hanover
27:47
Просмотров 57 тыс.
Kat Astley: Elizabeth I's Favourite
21:40
Просмотров 54 тыс.
Dr Kat and The Virgin Queen
17:52
Просмотров 96 тыс.
Charles Brandon: How to Survive in Tudor England
26:26
Просмотров 139 тыс.
King Henry VIII: Randy Royal or Prudish Prince
37:48
Просмотров 57 тыс.
Famous Last Words: Investigating Scaffold Speeches
29:27
11 ming dollarlik uzum
00:43
Просмотров 681 тыс.