Engineer Explains Why Acura TLX is Better Than Lexus IS: 5 Top Reasons why the TLX is Better 

Hi all, many thanks for comments and feedback. I know that size-wise, the TLX competes more with the Lexus ES, but the data shows that IS buyers cross shop and cross compare to the TLX - which is why I'm comparing the two. They both have strengths and weaknesses, and they both have distinct character - so you can't go wrong with either one. Personally, I will pick the IS 500 launch edition which is what I am trying to get right now.

Thank you everyone for your comments. Some people asked me which model I would buy as my personal car... and even though the TLX is a better car in most respects, I still like the Lexus myself and will likely buy the IS vs the TLX mainly because I love the current Lexus design and engineering. In fact, I'm pretty close to making a decision about putting a deposit for the IS 500 launch edition and trade-in my Supra.

We all know Japanese built cars last longer

Toyota/Lexus isn’t too quick to be the first with new technology. They stay with tried and true, hence their high reliability ratings year after year.

I had an acura tl in the past and it gave me nothing but problems. I have a 2016 lexus IS300 and it has had zero issues since day 1. Toyota is very reliable. Data shows us that you will be visiting the mechanic shop much less frequently with your lexus than you will with an acura.

I love the way you started with background information regarding the philosophical approach of both companies - thank you! It really added meaningful context to your position.

I love them both Acura and Lexus

V6 over turbo 4 any day.

After working at Acura dealerships and also Lexus dealerships, my experiences have created my preferences. I like preferentes, and love Lexus. Acura is a good car while Lexus is truly great in my opinion and really no car compares to the Lexus if you know cars.

Lexus: still made in Japan. I’ll take the Japanese made and assembled over the US assembled Acura

Lexus built and designed in Japan, Honda built and designed in the USA, no brainier Lexus all day long...

We have 4, ES, IS, GS and LS, we traded Honda, Nissan, Porsche and Mercedes-Benz, while not leading edge technology, they out class Honda in ownership satisfaction.

Acura has always had more soul and driver focus. They nailed it with this TLX

Lexus still way better. Don’t even see any Acura TLX on the road

I just traded in my TLX w/ Tech Package for the IS350 F sport....and so far I'm super glad I did! The Acura handled better, but the Lexus felt much more premium.

That Acrua is a very good looking car. It is also a compelling argument. Thank you!

I have a 23 mdx type S, and just picked up a 23 integra A spec with tech package, and love them! Toyota vs Honda, you will be a winner with quality/longevity either way. My engineering question is, why does Honda/Acura continue to use a timing belt instead of chain? I also have reservations about the 1.5 turbo in the integra. Has great acceleration, but how it will hold up over time has yet to be seen.

Good review; however as a consumer Honda and Acura's reliability has gone down hill after the early 2000's due to all the high gadgets it has. Yes, it focus on tech like GM, Ford and all the others, while Toyota and Lexus focus on consumers who wants something reliable for themselves and their family. As a parent, am tired of taking the new Civic to the shop for a transmission repair, while my Lexus is almost at 400k miles. Also, it shouldn't matter where anything is made, as long as it's affordable and built well. I do hope Toyota don't lose focus on their quality in the future.

I wouldn’t worry too much about what you’re saying right now...because in a little bit you’ll be talking about the IS...🤷🏾‍♂️ am just saying...but no matter what am sticking to my Lexus 👍🏾

The newest TLX is great, no doubt about that, yet so is the latest refresh of the IS. Newer isn't always better imo. Neither car is perfect, but the push button transmission and lack of smooth V6 kills the appeal of the TLX for me. The IS (in F Sport trim) simply looks killer imo, and that combined with a silky smooth V6 with 311 HP is enough to make it my choice even if the interior is mostly a rehash. The F sport seats are fantastic, and not just for looks...and most everything in the interior feels solid and well assembled. (Cheesy rear cup holders excepted) The IS looks great from any angle, not so much for the TLX. The front of that car seems a little too conservative for this segment, but of course thats subjective. Oh, and if you have fairly deep pockets you can also get the IS 500 with a very nice 470 hp V8. Nothing even close to that with the Acura.

Hurry and put your order in for a launch edition IS 500 before it’s too late!

I've owned three Acura's before buying my fourth the 2021 TLX A-SPEC SH-AWD, this car is the best one yet' driving this car is so fun and well worth the $$$ there is no other car out there right now that can compare! sorry. Acura #1

You'd have a much better argument for the Type S version of the TLX. But the standard tlx comes nowhere near measuring up to the Lexus IS.

Aint this TLX (Mid size sedan) to be compared to the Lexus GS?? The IS is a compact sedan so its in class with the ILX.

The Lexus is vastly better looking, I would even call it sexy. The Lexus is vastly more prestigious. Acura really needs to hire all new stylists to revive their dull, stodgy cars.

I've always been a fan of Acura, my family has owned both and currently own a Lexus. Handling is definitely better on Acura's, the stereotype is definitely right about Lexus being an "old man car". Personally I'm Acura all the way, the interior is on par with today's competition. Whereas Lexus is lacking redesigns, starting with the same key fob that's been around in the early 2000's. Tech is way behind their competitors, Lexus needs to step up on that for sure

The problem with Honda/Acura is that they discontinue cars 🚗 like you throw away a pair of shoes 👞. Toyota/Lexus stays with their current vehicle instead of discontinuing vehicles then putting new names on new vehicles further confusing the buyer

Dope review man! I got my first Acura a couple years ago & I love it. I got a 2016 TLX Technology Package (4 cyl). Can’t wait to upgrade to the v6 in the future, whether it’s the A-Spec or just the regular one.

Trying to decide between the two… love the exterior of the Lexus but the interior of the Acura

I'm not sure if it's a fair comparison between IS vs TL. it would make more sense between TLX vs ES350 or TLX vs LS460. But do like both, each has its own pros and cons.

Consumer Reports - Annual Auto Issue - April 2021 1. 2021 Acura TLX - Overall Score 56 2. 2021 Lexus IS - Overall Score 70 3. 2021 Audi A4 - Overall Score 87

You have some really awesome content. Thank you for putting this video together. Really informative.

I live the TLX but its 4,000 plus weight is a huge engineering mishap for an engineering focused car. That IS500 is a beast, and the Acura cannot compare.

The TLX is newer, sure. And it may very well be better than a base IS. But in ever metric (style, V6, optional V8, dynamics, reliability, and dealer service, the Lexus IS and Lexus as a whole is the better brand.

Im my personal opinion any naturally aspirated engine will go longer before having anything needing repair vs any turbo engines. Turbo is squeezing extra power from the engine its connected to but at what expense? Perhaps shorter engine life or maybe just a new turbo every now and then for maintenance. 🤷

TLX Type S > Lexus IS. Easily. Lexus IS500 F Sport Performance > TLX Type S x10^2. And that's just scientifically speaking.

Why is the tlx been compared with IS? Is it not supposed to be a direct rival or to the lexus es ?

This is my 2nd time watching and listening to the engineer's perspective as why the Accra A-spec is preferable over the Lexus IS. Excellent job especially pointing out the philosophical differences between the two auto companies in making and responding to vehicle design and manufacturing. Thank You! ♥ P.S. I wonder though . . . how the 4cyl will handle longevity compared to the 6cyl. we know can go the distance. 😉

The TLX may better statistically better, the subjective factors keep me with the Lexus. I like the looks, naturally aspirated V8 sound, and proven reliability of the IS500. The TLX-Type S vs M340i vs IS500 will be a great comparison.

I thought TLX competed with ES instead of IS.

Turbo V6 type S has me wanting to go back to Acura. I test drove the A-Spec and fell in love. I am awaiting for the Type S to trade in my 2013 Audi S5.

Acura TLX is front bias base.Lexus IS is rear bias. You need to compare the IS with other rear wheel drive like Mercedes or BMW. We know Acura is a newer design so will have better technology

I just bought a 2019 TLX (6 cyl ) last Sept ('22) that only had 10K miles. The only problem I have is that the back seat doesn't seem to have as much room as my 2020 Honda Civic Si sedan. It does have great pick up and drives smooth.

Lexus (RWD) > Acura (FWD-based) Lexus 8 speed > Honda 10 speed (too many gears) 51/49 weight distribution > 57/43 (nose heavy)

Açura #1💯💯👍💪

I purchased my brand new Acura TLX 2021 of November performance red tech pack front wheel drive love the vehicle

While all of the statements may be true, I still prefer the IS 350 to this. I guess "better" doesn't always = more desirable.

The Acura is lower than before, thirstier than before, fatter than before, and smaller inside than a Civic. Add to that a ridiculous price for a Honda product and it's a very easy "no thanks".

Being that it’s a fwd accord based car wouldn’t the ES be a better comparison ? I know it’s not sporty but the F sport tries to be

David, That was excellent. I am particularly supportive of Reason 5, consumers ought to be aware of where cars are built. On the subject of the IS V6 engine, I am absolutely confounded by the meagre 260 hp rating of the low powered version. Can you please explain in detail how Lexus managed to get 40 fewer hp from a 3.5 V6 engine running on Premium than Toyota gets from their 3.5 V6 running on Regular? In terms of the two specific cars in this comparison, I am too tall to fit in a Lexus IS and may be too tall to fit in the new TLX .

I think I'd prefer a car that was engineered and manufactured in Japan. The Japanese dont play when it comes to quality

Acura does not have the same refinement as Lexus does. It will also not last or depreciate like the IS. Lexus is a far better vehicle

I feel like it would make more sense to compare the TLK with the Lexus ES...

But which one is more reliable? 👀

turbo's are expensive to maintain, they do not last beyond 70-75K miles, if they need t be replaced or rebuild you have to consider how long you will keep the car. I owned turbo's from Mazda and once the turbo was out, I did not bother to have it rebuilt as a lot of the engine components also need to be replaced and or adjusted, I do have a Acura MDX 2011 with SH-AWD and that car has 100K miles and I only change fluids, brakes and tires so far. SO if reliability and longevity are an issue, stay away from turbos! I can attest to that because I owned a CX-7 AWD GT, awesome car but expensive to maintain!

The Acura isn’t as dependable as the Lexus though.

I just don’t like the way the new tlx Looks. Yes the IS interior is dated but the IS just looks better to me.

Excellent comparative review from an engineer standpoint, thank you! 👌🏼 Since purchasing a Type-R in 2017, I'm very much looking forward to welcoming the Type-S in the near future. Indeed a heavier TLX frame chassis and less engaging (or neutral) on the road, but I'm looking for comfort, AWD with a sporty feeling and the TLX Type-S caught my attention.

IS 350 F Sport has superb looks, I doubt the Type-S can beat that. Also having RWD bias system but yea SH-AWD is better and AWD on IS means 6 Speed instead of faster 8 Speed. The other issue on IS is lack of wood and leather. TLX has them both. TLX rear has some more space than IS 350. But now the NA V6 in the IS 350 is much smooth, linear with zero lag. Then the bulletproof nature of those Lexus cars vs TLX, finally the whole Made in Japan package seals the deal to be fair. Acura looks fine but it is no Lexus, also looking at Acurazine, I see a lot of issues in the modern Acuras, I do not know if Honda dropped the ball or whatever there's no spirit of pride in Acura I think vs Japanese Tahara made Lexus. The last of it's kind, the IS 350 since GS is dead which was superior and ES is FWD and made in US gets more smooth ride and premium interior but the FWD is a mega bummer for the price. Then the GX is also dead by 2024. LS is long gone since a decade+ finally RC is another one left with the NA V6 powertrain from Japan.

Just being built in Japan is worth the price.

I drive an Acura TL Type-S 2007 since 2014. Car runs flawlessly. Only spent money on maintenance and minor things like exhaust repair and other parts that wear off over time. For my next car was looking at these 2 cars. TLX Type-S or IS 350. After many hours of research I'm leaning heavily towards the TLX Type-S. Savagegeese have some amazing reviews of all these cars.

Nah, Lexus all day because Acura has that cluttered infotainment system. Lexus is just smooth all around

I was clever enough to buy a new Japan built 2004 TSX manual. Has been nothing short of amazing with 92,000 mi. 2 air filters, 1 alignment and rear brakes. I will keep the TSX but will definitely stay with the Acura brand for my next ride.

I feel like the better comparison would be the Lexus ES

Acura’s motto is Precision Crafted PERFORMANCE. They give us performance and unrelenting reliability compared to all other manufacturers. Go ahead and pay 30k or more than my Honda. Economically, I’ll save much more money on maintenance and fuel.

I owned a 2015 TLV 3.5 L and recently bought an IS350. Although on paper the IS350 is more powerful, Id say performance wise they are very similar. I personally feel the IS is a little easier to handle and faster. Just my 2 cents.

Lexus is better quality and reliability. Acura can't match Lexus quality and reliability. I use to own Acura and i would NEVER buy another Acura. Very expensive to repairs my Acura. I can drive Lexus for 10 years and trouble FREE. Can't said the same about Acura.

I test drive a base model tlx with the turbo 4 cylinder. Then a camary xle V6. The Acura felt much better. Ended up buying it.

The Acura TLX is more of a competitive comparison to the Lexus ES not IS. I hear what you are saying about cross shoppers in the comment below, however IS is RWD and a small sedan, ES is FWD and is a mid size which more like the TLX. You might say that the TLX also comes in AWD however if you consider the way the motors/transmissions are set up in the cars (IS vs TLX) it is a very different configuration.

I have a 2021 IS 350 and TLX is just like a Honda Accord a like which is i own 2021 touring right now. For me i take Lexus .. all day 100% JP quality is superb

TLX for the undeniable superiority of its suspension geometry and AWD system. Then Turbo tuning potential, and that brilliant 10 speed. Type-S is about to make its stock numbers at the tires, just wait.

everyone skip to 6 min mark. everything before that is just rambling

Still take is f 350 just my choice Lexus is king to me

There’s no comparison between American built and Japanese. The RDX and Accord have lot problems. I own a 2022 IS 350 F no issues at all well built. Design and made in the U.S Is gonna fall apart within 4 years.

lexus is better, very reliable

The small interior space in the TLX ruined this car for me. It's a boat yet the inside is smaller than a Honda Civic

The reason Honda doesn’t grow and compete at the same level as Toyota is due to Honda‘s lack of developing a V8 engine. A V8 engine should have gone into the NSX, Ridgeline, pilot, passport, RL, and maybe the TLX. I’m pretty sure that is why the RL and the NSX failed.

Do you trust that the Acura turbo will be reliable of the long run?

Great video bro when you doing one on ES F Lexus ?

just bought a 2018 TLX V6, I love it so much, always have had hondas but this is my first Acura :)

This car seems closer in comparison to the Lexus ES than the Lexus IS. Am I wrong?

TLX anyday!

Only a Lexus mother could love the Lexus spindle grill.

I have a 2012 tsx and thought I was going to get a tlx. Used 92 accord, new 98 civic, new 12 tsx. I did not enjoy my test drive of the tlx. So disappointed in the powertrain and the acceleration lag. The IS powertrain actually drives more like my previous Hondas. I hated the piped in sound of the tlx too. I actually waited for the 2nd gen tlx before car shopping. I will be getting an is350 this July.

Do you think the fact that the Acura TLX is a fwd platform as opposed to the rwd platform on the Lexus IS or other European luxury sedans in this segment is a slight handicap that is keeping the TLX from handling extremely good?

First argument is fail lolzzz made in Japan > made in US. Sorry but that is facts

All that and…I’m still buying Lexus at the end of the day. Has an “it” factor for me, very personal & subjective I know. TLX may objectively be the better car, but still lol

Drive a Is350 and if you still go to with TLX then- there’s no help for you.

Toyota has a big advantage over Honda. They are much larger which allows them to offer 2 models in certain segments vs Honda’s one vehicle to satisfy the segment. Pilot vs Highlander/ 4Runner TLX vs IS / ES

Good try but no

You are comparing an apple to an orange! FWD vs RWD, no comparison! What Lexus does extremely well is fit and finish combined with reliability and resale. For this reason Lexus is seen as more a direct European competitor.

Good Review, But what is a IES?

I would love to hear your thoughts on the Genesis g70

That panel gap should not be on a luxury car. Still I would take TLX over IS. I think if Lexus brings in ES with AWD and a turbo it would better compete with TLX.

Lexus is always the answer. Period

Front reminds me of a Ford Mustang, makes sense because it was designed and built in America.

I'm wondering why he didn't mention the fact that the Acura has the battery in the trunk and no spare tire😳 wtf is up w/that!! i guess if u get a flat better call for a flatbed tow tk, bcuz thats the only way you getting home! as far as which veh i'd take, the Acura looks to be the better buy!

I'l take the V6 over the 4 cylinder turbo junk, that's a weak engine.

Lexus should up its game and offer more vehicles with torque vectoring. Right now only RCF has it since the GSF is dead.

I agree with Acura being ahead in technology to the Lexus. Back in 2018, my TLX V6 TECHNOLOGY, had features that the IS did not have. Also the features in the IS that were in expensive packages which put it over nearly $10K over the TLX. My concern is the longevity of the new turbo push in Honda/Acura engines. I don't believe they will last more than 150K miles without having serious expensive turbo repairs. I wished they would have kept the 3.5 V6 and modified the Intake/exhaust/cams, to squeeze out 325 HP.