Тёмный

"England Should Apologise To Australia!" Aussie Journalist SLAMS English Cricket 

Piers Morgan Uncensored
Подписаться 3,3 млн
Просмотров 501 тыс.
50% 1

Piers Morgan Uncensored is joined by Australian cricket writer and journalist Peter Lalor to react and discuss the controversial stumping of Jonny Bairstow which led to Australia winning the Ashes over England.
Piers believes Australian captain Pat Cummins is the person at fault as he believes he should have spoken with the umpire to reverse the decision. Peter however believes that Australia are owed an apology by English cricket fans over the way the team has been treated online and more so at Lord's by MCC members who hurled insults at the team as they walked in.
Subscribe to stay up-to-date on all Uncensored content.
Follow Piers Morgan Uncensored on:
Twitter: / piersuncensored
Instagram: / piersmorgan. .
Facebook: / piersmorganu. .
TikTok: / piersmorganun. .
Follow Piers Morgan on:
Twitter: / piersmorgan
Instagram: / piersmorgan
Piers Morgan Uncensored is now available on TalkTV, Fox Nation and Sky News Australia!
#piersmorgan #cricket #ashes #englandcricket #australiacricket #debate #talktv

Опубликовано:

 

2 окт 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 3,7 тыс.   
@Grief_Jerky
@Grief_Jerky Год назад
“It's within the rules of the game and that's how it is,” - Jonny Bairstow 2014
@acerimmeh
@acerimmeh Год назад
Did he say that when he sneakily stumped Patel in a County match?
@MattyGalvin
@MattyGalvin Год назад
​@@acerimmehhis exact words made on tv when interviewed about it 😂 all this old footage coming back to haunt him
@arlencarroll1964
@arlencarroll1964 Год назад
Hahaha yeah,maybe that's why old Jonny boy has been conspicuously quiet on this matter hey haha 😄
@Bellas1717
@Bellas1717 Год назад
@@acerimmeh Yes, he actually stood holding the ball waiting for Patel's foot to clear the crease. Bit of a difference.
@jamesjones-z4u
@jamesjones-z4u Год назад
@@Bellas1717 Stumping players on the edge of their crease overbalancing has always been part of the game. Australians bringing up these false equivalencies, pointing out times Bairstow attempted regulation stumpings to justify their far from regulation ‘stumping’ of a player going for a between overs chat is disingenuous at best.
@petermcculloch4933
@petermcculloch4933 Год назад
Piers, the batsman doesn't rule over, the umpire does.
@michelleclifford7122
@michelleclifford7122 Год назад
Exactly !
@Boolama27
@Boolama27 Год назад
Yes 100%
@addamr2052
@addamr2052 Год назад
One law for the Poms and another law for the others .
@niftynev4779
@niftynev4779 Год назад
Meghan will be glad this has happened, she now gets a break from Morgan's big mouth. 🦘
@concernedcitizen5943
@concernedcitizen5943 Год назад
The English are so used to making the rules they forgot who their cricket rules delegated authority to on the cricket field.
@pablodelfuego6567
@pablodelfuego6567 Год назад
So Bairstow is calling when the over is over? Well we don’t need umpires anymore do we.
@Kingsman-1981
@Kingsman-1981 Год назад
😂
@johnbriggs5379
@johnbriggs5379 Год назад
We could even go back to "Over the fence is 6 & out"
@martinmason5008
@martinmason5008 Год назад
I'm an Englishman, furiously passionate about The Ashes and fair play. I wholeheartedly agree with Peter Lalor. We can't be pointing fingers with a ton of whatabouts out there. I even agree about England apologising, in my view because we've prioritized Bazball over The Ashes, and show respect for the folks who have travelled so far for the contest. We should thank Australia for a timely slap around the face whilst we have a chance to do something about getting a win on the board in Leeds. Sorry to hear about Steve Smith's mum. It's not on that this has happened to her. Finally, the comment about the Englsh writing the laws: Ouch. That hurt, and good one. Proud Pom, no whinger though.
@libertyordeaf
@libertyordeaf Год назад
Australian fan and appreciate your level-headedness. Personally, I don't like these gotcha kinds of wickets - Mankads and sneaky keeper underarms. I'd rather see batsmen dismissed by high quality bowling or fielding. But clearly these dismissals are within the law and they are occasionally needed as as a reminder to batsmen that (a) the creases are there for a reason, and (b) they don't determine whether the ball is live or dead. I can guarantee Bairstow will never take that for granted and get out that way again, and it'll be a wake-up call for a few others too. As for the 'spirit of cricket', it's outlined in the preamble to the Laws of Cricket and says nothing about captains being so generous as to hand dozy opposition batsmen a second chance.
@goodyeoman4534
@goodyeoman4534 Год назад
Fawning submissive.
@Doghead.89
@Doghead.89 Год назад
Dude. He was batting in his crease. He marked his crease. Both umpires where on the move. One umpire unclipping the bowlers cap. Oh but the ball wasn’t dead? It was sneaky and crooked. Was JB gaining an advantage? NO. A batsman batting 3 yards out for his crease would be gaining an advantage. A batsman running down the wicket to a spinner would be gaining an advantage. The batsman at the non strikers end backing up to early before the bowler has released the ball would be gaining an advantage. JB wasn’t the whole thing stinks, same old Aussies always cheating theyve got previous this lot, a disgusting bunch.
@Lucaf_2008
@Lucaf_2008 Год назад
@@Doghead.89 do you have a life to get on with?
@jt1559
@jt1559 Год назад
​@@Doghead.89and yet when England has done it in the past, no one in England said anything.
@filips4972
@filips4972 Год назад
What i've noticed about Piers is, when he is confident that he is absolutely right, he lets his guest speak without interrupting. As soon as the guest starts building a valid argument, he just jumps in and interrupts them every three seconds. Pathetic, really. It's easy to be a bully when you are in command of the mute button. The spirit of the game is to applaud your opponent, even when you'd want to tear his guts out and feed them to the dogs. It is in the spirit of the game to accept the umpires' decision, even when you are 100% certain that they are wrong. Like the day before, re Starc's (non) catch... It is not in the spirit of the game to announce that you won't be having a beer with your opponent any time soon. As if they'd be crying to miss that opportunity (it's most likely they'd be saying DILLIGAF.)
@micksharonlittle1907
@micksharonlittle1907 Год назад
i totally agree. If you want to debate someone then you should allow them to respond freely. Unfortunately Piers Morgan is the epitome of a whinging Pom. As an Aussie I watched Stokes batting and had a terrible feeling that this bloke is going to pull the rabbit from its hiding place again. However as an Australian I also appreciated his display of trying to win the game. This is how England should be.
@robby1816
@robby1816 Год назад
Yup, the umpire is always right, even when they're wrong.
@SvendBosanvovski
@SvendBosanvovski Год назад
Pretty crook when they have to go back to the Trevor Chappell issue, and that was against the Kiwis. The laws have changed since that. And Sandgate, after Smith scored on of the best centuries in recent history?
@wolfe59
@wolfe59 Год назад
Has anyone read his continual tirade on Twitter I blocked him in the end he was whinging for 36 hours 😂😂
@michaelbishop9157
@michaelbishop9157 Год назад
Piers is a horrible person
@nickhand8054
@nickhand8054 Год назад
Actually, as an Australian, my feelings are this: if an Australian batsman got himself out in the same fashion, I reckon I'd be feeling anger towards the batsman for his negligence. I really don't think I'd be blaming the fielding side.
@jamesjones-z4u
@jamesjones-z4u Год назад
Considering the massive Australian over-reaction to the Starc non-catch the day before (crowding the umpires, blaming Duckett for not walking) I highly doubt that your compatriots would feel the same way! Also, Australians were wandering out of their crease throughout both of their innings without positive confirmation the ball was dead, which I guess just means that they all must be negligent also, or was Bairstow only negligent because he did it against Australia, a team known to be unsporting?
@paulpurves484
@paulpurves484 Год назад
Of course you’d say that.
@sansul88
@sansul88 Год назад
Not a chance mate... This will be on the headlines, just as its been portraited in the English newspapers.. They will definitely talk about lack of spirit for the game and they will also be called cheats, BY EVERYBODY IN AUSTRALIA MATE... Lets be honest, nobody talks highly of The Australian spirits for the game.. I can only think of Adam Gilchrist when it comes to Australian spirit of the game. I mean who would thought of sandpaper and how long did that happen before its been caught? How many test matches and odis been played that way? Guess nobody will know that now but yeh.. Australians would react the same way if the tables were turned.
@Reneesillycar74
@Reneesillycar74 Год назад
Yep!
@TheAbabab77
@TheAbabab77 Год назад
​@@jamesjones-z4u😂😂😂😂 you're wanker of a captain has tried it multiple times champ. Get over it your team just aren't good enough.
@nafizimtiaz5680
@nafizimtiaz5680 Год назад
Watching Piers embarrass himself is an amazing thing to see 😂
@Roy3.16
@Roy3.16 Год назад
@nafizimtiaz5680 absolutely😁
@Grant_Ferstat
@Grant_Ferstat Год назад
It's not infrequent...
@bobjames1992
@bobjames1992 Год назад
Not really. It happens quite often.
@mackabee6674
@mackabee6674 Год назад
How so?
@benjaminturkalj4415
@benjaminturkalj4415 Год назад
Hes a walking embarrasment!
@jjeherrera
@jjeherrera Год назад
I like Piers, but Peter Lalor is right here. The players must play by the rules, and this was fair play, regardless of the fans' feelings.
@suzilouden5964
@suzilouden5964 Год назад
Pierce is a whinging Pom. And he's Trump apologist. With his history, how dare Morgan talk about integrity......🤮
@jjeherrera
@jjeherrera Год назад
@@johnnichol9412 Corrected! Mind the lapsus! 😅
@Woodbug-b7t
@Woodbug-b7t Год назад
...or Piers's feelings.
@todddixon1005
@todddixon1005 Год назад
When the ball is in the gloves and both batsmen are in their crease it’s a dead ball, you don’t then make it live again I’ve umpires and I would have laughed at the fielding side if they’d tried this.
@raymckee2450
@raymckee2450 Год назад
I have supported Piers on just about everything argument he puts up, but this interview and a couple of others on this Bairstow stuff up, has me disliking him. I wouldn't be surprised if he has never played cricket at any level, and is just quoting what he has heard. He refuses to listen to the facts and avoids the words of previous English. captains. This just proves, that he is as bad as the average ignorant English members of the Marylebone Cricket Club.
@nathanhowland196
@nathanhowland196 Год назад
I am Englishman, was a wickie for 27 years, and in every form of cricket I played, catching a batsman walking out out of his crease was a 'given' part of the role, actively coached, and I did it about a dozen times. Not one batsman complained it was unsportsman-like conduct, no opposition player ever pulled me to one side about it, and every batsman I caught out was gutted they were mugged for not paying attention. The ball was still live, the over was still live, and the wicketkeeper was aware enough to be proactive and switched on to seize the opportunity. If the ball had missed and gone for 4 overthrows none of you idiots would be whining!? Piers needs to shut-up!!
@justinspagnolo2931
@justinspagnolo2931 Год назад
Thank you dude. Restored my faith in the English!!!.. now please go and spread the word .. Ben stokes nearly pulled off a miracle and everyone's focused on a legitimate piece of cricket play and likening it to sandpaper-gate and cheating.. I'm actually really disappointed in your entire country ATM and I'm honestly looking at this as objectively as possible..
@colin.mall3tt
@colin.mall3tt Год назад
Well said but many suspect that this is not about the 'incident' itself, its about drawing attention away from the failures of 'bazball'.
@michaellincoln3739
@michaellincoln3739 Год назад
Very true. But the answer to this conundrum is that the umpires should be empowered (and educated) to over-rule the laws of cricket on certain rare occasions to 'protect the integrity of the sport'. As an Aussie, I believe Bairstow should have been given a reprieve by the umpires. It's the umpires who have failed not Cummins or Carey who did the right thing. Gutless umpiring has caused this controversy.
@justinspagnolo2931
@justinspagnolo2931 Год назад
@@michaellincoln3739 i actually agree with u here because u can't blame Carey or Cummins and it's a shit way to get someone out or to get out.. I was thinking the exact same way, the umpires have all the angles and all the cameras so it's all up to them.. then I realized that giving him a reprieve here will set a precedent where umpires are now having to decide if a batsmen is being careless or made a mistake.. the rules are the way they are so umpires don't have to make these decisions.. therefore I revert back to it being entirely bairstow's fault and if england want to blame anyone it should be him. After all he's a keeper and all keepers know the rules regarding the crease and gameplay etc.. especially considering he made a similar play in the previous innings and he's got a history of using the same rules to his advantage and then quoting 'its I'm the rules and it's part of the game'..
@BenDover-tb8ek
@BenDover-tb8ek Год назад
And you naturally did this at the end of an over.
@karthiksatyam
@karthiksatyam Год назад
Piers Morgan should let the guest talk. You let Geoff Boycott rant for minutes without interruption. But now you keep talking over peter for every two words he says. Yet you lecture about spirit of cricket. How about the spirit of being a good host and let the guest speak his mind? As an Indian and a cricket fan, I fully support the Aussies. Way to go!
@TheMusingGreg
@TheMusingGreg Год назад
Well said mate. I agree with Piers on most things; I generally disagree with him here although I didn't like the look of the dismissal as Bairstow wasn't trying to get an advantage. But even on causes I agree with Piers on, I wish he would stop interrupting the guest as I'd like to hear and understand their view so I can make my own judgement. That should be the job of the media, to allow both sides of an argument to be aired so the public can make informed decisions.
@shaunstrang6658
@shaunstrang6658 Год назад
agree 100%
@AntzWar
@AntzWar Год назад
As an Englishman, Piers you are an embarrassment and get over it, the ball was not dead and it is not a dead ball when the batsman scrapes his boot or studs to mark the end of the delivery, its up to the umpire, Aussies played within the rules and so why should Cummins have to withdraw the appeal, it is not cheating so no tarnished reputations, MCC members should definitely apologise to the Australians
@felawes
@felawes Год назад
Writing as a MCC member and lifelong cricketer, Piers you would be well served to read the rules of cricket before spouting a stream of inaccurate consciousness.
@todddixon1005
@todddixon1005 Год назад
I’m Australian and I think we are the pathetic ones, to try and justify this shows what and immature and desperate people we are.
@alani3992
@alani3992 Год назад
Nobody believes that the batter was trying to steal a run. Why try to somehow get a wicket that you haven't earned. Even in Mankading, the accusation is that the batter is trying to get an advantage, which is not the case here.
@geralddinkleson4201
@geralddinkleson4201 Год назад
@@todddixon1005 my brother bairstowe attempted the exact same dismissal
@pimp4984
@pimp4984 Год назад
Are you an English Cricket fan, though? It doesn't sound like you are.
@GeoffGordon-e1b
@GeoffGordon-e1b Год назад
When Australia bowled the underarm ball, they took away New Zealand's agency over that moment. In this case, Johnny Bairstow still had agency in that moment and chose not to use it. It was a sad way to lose his wicket, but ultimately, his own fault.
@TheIkaraCult
@TheIkaraCult Год назад
sadly this obvious fact needs to be explained to people like Morgan and others who sympathise with him.
@eyecontrol4900
@eyecontrol4900 6 месяцев назад
The thing I find most sickening is the 'lost opportunity' and 'haven't moved past Sandpapergate' drivel, which Piers Morgan pontificated at the time. Just because Australia did the wrong thing 5 years ago, and egregiously so, doesn't mean that from then on - perhaps forever - they must play to some moral standard higher than everyone else, including their opponents in highest stakes competitive matches. Australia and the relevant players were punished at the time - rightly, and the team has cleaned up its act so that, one thinks, it will never happen again. That's enough, without Australia having to then play on some kind handicap system for 5 years or eternity thereafter.
@jessemay4277
@jessemay4277 Год назад
"We probably would have been 2-0 up" has me dying hahahahahahah
@arunsrivatsa7155
@arunsrivatsa7155 Год назад
What a stupid thing to say by piers. There's no ifs and buts
@ChatPOPPAT
@ChatPOPPAT Год назад
As much as I dont like Piers, England were in position to win both test matches.. 55 runs needed with 2 wickets to go on the final day with new ball, England were clear favorites.. they dropped too many catches.. and again here, England were chasing down a total with 2 of their best on the crease,, JB run out is more controversial as it robbed us on a great finish, I dont say that England would have won but it would have been an exciting contest.. its clear that JB was not trying to take any advantage (which was the case with Labushane attempt which everyone is citing as he stood out of the crease to negate swing), he clearly marked the crease, his only fault was to assume it was the end of the over, you can call it silly or dumb, but its what every batsmen does... even the leg umpire started moving and facing umpire was taking out the cap to give it to the bowler.. what didnt set with me well that it was not a competitive dismissal and it sets up a wrong precedent to win at any costs.. well the bar has been set, Aussies have opened up the door.. now everything with the laws of cricket will happen, irrespective of the situation..
@flamingfrancis
@flamingfrancis Год назад
@@ChatPOPPAT One could equally state that the patriotic effort by Nathan Lyon to bat, as he did, and contribute to a 21 run partnership could have amounted to a game winning effort.
@mohidfarhan3527
@mohidfarhan3527 Год назад
Coulda shoulda woulda...the perfect response
@mikipiediaelburro7588
@mikipiediaelburro7588 Год назад
The sandpaper boys will always be remembered as the biggest crybabies in history😂😂😂
@tonyblades2800
@tonyblades2800 Год назад
Peter Lalor is such a great journalist, streets ahead of Piers, with his infinitely non existent cricket wisdom.
@longjohn5322
@longjohn5322 Год назад
Morgan can call himself whatever he likes but I think he’s a celebrity.
@clarke1319
@clarke1319 Год назад
Maybe ...don't know the person however what we are watching here is not journalism is it. On the face of it it's two guys with conflicting views about an incident in a cricket match. It could just as easily be you and I having a discussion in a pub. It's not journalism to have an opinion.
@francisjohnston8014
@francisjohnston8014 Год назад
Ironically Piers is streets behind.
@trevorcornwa-zy8sq
@trevorcornwa-zy8sq Год назад
"Both umpires had moved to move away" shows vision where the standing umpire doesn't even take a step out of position.
@williamwelling2210
@williamwelling2210 Год назад
i spotted that too, at most the standing umpire only looked down and Bairstow didn't even look at him before he started off.
@davidgraham8299
@davidgraham8299 Год назад
You watch it from the various angles available, NEITHER umpire had moved.
@paulmerson2023
@paulmerson2023 Год назад
Scraping a boot has no significance whatsoever. Piers lost the plot yet again
@swanny1236
@swanny1236 Год назад
Love how piers invites an Aussie on then doesn’t let them speak 😂
@robertcockerell3640
@robertcockerell3640 Год назад
Exactly. We see and hear too much of him on Australian TV.
@goodyeoman4534
@goodyeoman4534 Год назад
Best way.
@MastersOfTheHeart
@MastersOfTheHeart Год назад
exactly, he just loves the sound if his own voice and his arguments are very thin indeed. love these aussies. cheers from Melbourne.
@geoffwhite5782
@geoffwhite5782 Год назад
poms are bad looses
@MultiDwang
@MultiDwang Год назад
So true.
@saqibakbar2026
@saqibakbar2026 Год назад
"We should have won" is not an argument. Losing and then highlighting a single incident just displays a loser mentality.
@knight2425
@knight2425 Год назад
Yeah they should have won lol, I love the way they say that considering that dismissal is what set Stokes off. How do they know if the Aussies had withdrawn the appeal Stokes would have played like he did? Typical poms that think they know the rules but don’t know this one
@brettallan7417
@brettallan7417 Год назад
@@knight2425 The poms wrote the rules and still don't know them. 🤣🤣🤣
@knight2425
@knight2425 Год назад
@@brettallan7417 Some of them know the rules but don’t want to abide by them when it’s to their detriment
@Johnnysabboy
@Johnnysabboy Год назад
They couldn’t even win on day one…
@jamesjones-z4u
@jamesjones-z4u Год назад
Ridiculous. Had England done to Australia what Australia did to them there’s a reasonably high chance they would have walked off the pitch and flown home. You only had to see their ridiculous response to the Starc grounded catch the day before, where they surrounded the umpire in an attempt to intimidate him.
@steelydan133
@steelydan133 Год назад
Pierce I am neither English nor an Aussie, I am a cricket fan for over 48 years. Bairstow was so amateurish specially in such an important test and had a brain fade. The ball was in play, Carey threw it instinctively and caught him napping. Scraping of the boot was just in Bairstow's mind, that doesn't mean it is the end of the over. England is being a sore loser, they lost and they are taking the anger on one incident, smoke and mirrors buddy. And Pierce you can't be serious when you say if Bairstow was not out Eng would have won? What, Bairstow could have got out very next ball who knows and had Strokes hadn't played the innings of a lifetime it would been Eng losing by over 150 runs. Get some sleep
@aperfectlycromulentusername
Peter Lalor is one of the best cricket writers in the world, his opinion commands respect.
@loganratley6704
@loganratley6704 Год назад
HAHAHA sounds like an uneducated whinger to me.
@Stu-Bo
@Stu-Bo Год назад
One key thing Piers doesn't understand, is that the ball was being returned BEFORE Bairstow scraped his foot. The ball was returned in one swift motion, and had Bairstow looked back to see this would never have occurred.
@davidbrear8642
@davidbrear8642 Год назад
I completely agree with that. That said, if you watch the video carefully, the only valid excuse for Bairstow's failure to look back, is the fact that he looked towards the bowler's end, where the umpire definitely began to react as though the over has ended. However, the umpire hadn't yet called 'over.' From the umpire's initial movement (where he started to look down), I don't think he had yet spotted that Carey had not stopped playing. A full view of Carey would be blocked by Bairstow, and/or (like Bairstow) the umpire made a wrong assumption, because he wasn't paying sufficient attention.
@jamesjones-z4u
@jamesjones-z4u Год назад
@@davidbrear8642 Batsmen on both sides were doing exactly what Bairstow did throughout the game, wandering out of their creases at the end of overs without looking back or positive confirmation the ball was dead. If that’s careless then it’s something many batsmen are guilty of. It hadn’t been a problem before that, though, because before that nobody would have attempted a stumping, however Australia were enraged up by the Starc decision the day before! The most careless thing Bairstow did was thinking he could be complacent around the angered Australians! It’s true that Carey threw the ball immediately, though. So it’s not necessarily that Carey was being unsporting, as much as Cummins was to not withdraw the appeal.
@davidbrear8642
@davidbrear8642 Год назад
@@jamesjones-z4u Yes, you make very good points. This incident was the result of many combined factors not least revenge. The entire England team should have been on their toes after the Starc decision. I previously pointed out on another thread that amongst international players it seems to have become an unspoken 'gentlemen's' agreement that, when the keeper is standing back to pace and the ball is cleanly pouched, if the batter is safe in his crease, both sides have invariably stopped playing and umpires have taken the same approach. Perhaps the laws of cricket will now be modified to deem the ball as automatically dead in these particular circumstances? Currently in these particular circumstances in test matches, during overs (and even at the end of overs) when batsmen leave their crease for a chat or to do a bit of gardening, it's often unclear whether the ball is dead or still in play.
@count23all
@count23all Год назад
Doesn't understand or doesn't care, because he is an outrage factory and needs to be angry about _something_ when Megan and Harry aren't in the news.
@johnbriggs5379
@johnbriggs5379 Год назад
@@davidbrear8642 Why change the rules? when all you need to do is pay attention to the current rules.
@chrisjames5188
@chrisjames5188 Год назад
As an England fan Australia did nothing wrong they took advantage of bairstows mistake. Since when does the batsman decide the over is finished.
@itsfrma6500
@itsfrma6500 Год назад
Absolutely spot on. Bairstow was an idiot!
@maldini3184
@maldini3184 Год назад
Exactly. Australia is the only team i would never cheer for in cricket. But that is out. Carey did nothing wrong
@NemoNiemand497
@NemoNiemand497 Год назад
As a South African I love nothing more than seeing England and Australia going at each other. Having Pierce Morgan getting his own medicine is so much fun! But honestly, this "run out" is not cricket, it's bad sportsmanship. Nuff said.
@itsfrma6500
@itsfrma6500 Год назад
@@NemoNiemand497 You see as an England supporter I do still disagree! It really wasn't hard to just stay in another second or two. I feel like people use the likes of MS Dhoni as a reference to how "good sportsmanship" should be displayed, but even that circumstance in my opinion was totally different to this! Bairstow (WHO MIGHT I ADD IS A WICKET KEEPER?! 😆) Doesn't even look back to see if Carey caught it or fumbled or whatever... (I appreciate it isn't village cricket) but it doesn't take a lot to just turn a head and see / check everything is ok!
@thatsbollox
@thatsbollox Год назад
@@NemoNiemand497 Its not even a run out. He was stumped. Nothing weird, and quite common even off a seamer. They saw their hopes and dreams dashed thats all.
@lsimmo78
@lsimmo78 Год назад
Piers is conflating 'Sandpaper Gate' with what happened to Jonny Bairstow. The two are not linked. Jonny was lazy and not paying attention.
@bendavidjohn
@bendavidjohn Год назад
I’d have done exactly the same thing if I were Australia tbh. Australia aren’t making these same silly mistakes, so why are England? This is professional cricket at the highest level. Silly mistakes should be punished at this level - fair game.
@anishjagannathan1576
@anishjagannathan1576 Год назад
Mitch Starc made the silly mistake of letting the ball scrape against the ground for a catch, and as a result, it was ruled not-out.
@mickm6309
@mickm6309 Год назад
Bairstow would have done the exact same thing and Stokes would never have called the batsman back.
@flch95
@flch95 Год назад
@@mickm6309lol 100% believe that lol.
@faniegreyling7949
@faniegreyling7949 Год назад
I am no Australian fan but they played the game within the rules. Piers and the poms should have another glass of vinegar and carry on with their lives.
@iajanus
@iajanus Год назад
"if we hadn't lost the two games we would have won them" Top shelf analysis right here
@billymorris8764
@billymorris8764 Год назад
As a English fan, Australia did nothing wrong . Schoolboy error blown out of proportion.
@johnnysoccer1983
@johnnysoccer1983 Год назад
If Bairstow was out of his crease at any point from the start of the bowlers run up to the ball entering the keeper's gloves, I would agree. But the fact that he tried to deliberately time it for the moment he left his crease after all of that was said and done, AND did so on the last ball of an over, makes it entirely unacceptable..... And I'm and Aussie.
@jakkaxn5513
@jakkaxn5513 Год назад
@@johnnysoccer1983it was an instant throw. It was a schoolboy error
@uskumarmate
@uskumarmate Год назад
​@@johnnysoccer1983well said mate
@uskumarmate
@uskumarmate Год назад
​​@@jakkaxn5513he instant throw, was, based on what Cummins said, related to what Carey had observed Bairstow doing earlier. Let's not pretend Carey was just being instinctive.. It was pre planned
@johnnysoccer1983
@johnnysoccer1983 Год назад
@@jakkaxn5513 Choosing to go for an instant throw when the batter was never out of their crease in the hopes of timing it for when they leave AFTER they believe the ball dead and on the last ball of the over is a dog act to try and buy a wicket you couldn't get legitimately.
@E1sun
@E1sun Год назад
3 things: 1. Baistow should have checked the over was over . 2. The ball was released by the keeper before he left the crease. 3. Bairstow has a bad habit of leaving his crease early constantly and the Ozzies noticed. That is his and the English coaching staffs fault for not resolving .
@anubhav111196
@anubhav111196 Год назад
so piers doesn't like it when others don't let him talk but it's okay when he does it
@megahedgehog8649
@megahedgehog8649 Год назад
Conveniently cutting off Lalor trying to tell how Steve Smith's mum left the ground in tears. Well done England, you absolute twatwaffles.
@SA-nv5tc
@SA-nv5tc Год назад
Having now read what “the spirit of cricket” is as written in the laws of the game, it turns out that the only team and country that has not behaved in the “spirit of cricket” is ENGLAND!
@willforbes6373
@willforbes6373 Год назад
Well said. Glad you said Laws, not Rules.
@falaramal3979
@falaramal3979 Год назад
Yea what happened to respecting the decision of the umpire?
@SA-nv5tc
@SA-nv5tc Год назад
@@falaramal3979 that ended at the same time as saying “crease leave”! 🤣🤣🤣🙊
@flamingfrancis
@flamingfrancis Год назад
For the record. The Spirit of the game is NOT written into the actual Laws. It appears as a preamble to those Laws. Such as a preface would in a book.
@samwheaton8591
@samwheaton8591 Год назад
Ah yes what a spirited debate where piers talked for about 7 and a half minutes and peter got about 30 seconds and then shoved off screen
@flamingfrancis
@flamingfrancis Год назад
That, my friend, is very typical of the way these "shock jocks" operate. They have their hand on the "kill" switch.
@daniellehirschausen8908
@daniellehirschausen8908 Год назад
Thank you to all the Englishman and ladies ,who agree about the aussies not cheating ,and thank you for being fair !😊
@lindsaybaker9480
@lindsaybaker9480 Год назад
Totally different incidents piers. Sandpaper was pure cheating but Bairstow has been caught out doing what he’s done to others.
@DaveWhoa
@DaveWhoa Год назад
it was also pure cheating when England used mints to shine the ball for the entire 2005 Ashes series
@melodychest9020
@melodychest9020 Год назад
Sandpaper happened cos the Aussies and the South Africans had bad blood outside the field as well, and both were at each others' throats. No excuse, but it was a very turbulent tour and emotions were out of control.
@user-hi5dd5qh9n
@user-hi5dd5qh9n 6 месяцев назад
Was a dark day for Aussie cricket. We love to win. But not at any cost. And not by cheating.
@solreaver83
@solreaver83 Год назад
I saw footage today of Bairstow holding his gloves by the stumps for a few seconds before stumping someone doing the same thing. Our guy throws the ball immediately. In real time its about 2 seconds between the ball passing and the stumps coming off.
@murph7421
@murph7421 Год назад
Yes, and the English commentary team called it ‘very clever wicket keeping’. When asked about it after the match he said ‘it’s within the rules’.
@Toomaletoopaletoostale
@Toomaletoopaletoostale Год назад
As soon as the game finished The headline in Australia on news corp online was “let the whinging commence”. The English didn’t let us down.
@noumangujjar3159
@noumangujjar3159 Год назад
As a neutral person i believe it was right decision from umpire and cummins , however stokes and english captain should have given back 5 overthrow runs to NZ for the spirit of the game but they prefered WC.😏
@thatsbollox
@thatsbollox Год назад
You could not write this script if you tried. One simple fair stumping and the players meltdown, the coach goes full hypocrite, the crowd meltsdown, the commentators meltdown, and even the old toffs in the long room turn feral. All their hopes and dreams shattered and thrown to the wind. It is such classical English whinging. Historically embarassing. Historically funny as hell.
@M1dnightRunner
@M1dnightRunner Год назад
Smokescreen is what he said and how true haha.
@flch95
@flch95 Год назад
And it’s why I always cheer for whoever England is playing lol.
@Jack-r2v9b
@Jack-r2v9b Год назад
Yes if the ball missed and went to the boundary the poms wouldn't of run a couple more runs,you know this because of the spirit of cricket thing they claim for themselves
@dermotquinn
@dermotquinn Год назад
And the Aussies acted true to form. It's the expectation that the Aussies may be committed to fair play that makes the English look stupid.
@RolandEHay
@RolandEHay Год назад
We Australians have a inferiority complex and will do anything to win……I’m afraid!!!
@nitlover8319
@nitlover8319 Год назад
Comparing it to the underarm incident is just taking stupidity to a different level 😂😂
@brianwilson49
@brianwilson49 Год назад
He was equating the Australian attitude to cricket not the laws of the game.
@BlakeLawler
@BlakeLawler 9 месяцев назад
@brianwilson49 Remember the game with England and West Indies where the keeper waited the batter to slide his foot out of his crease and stumped him. Not to mention Bairstow tried the same f***ing thing in the same match so what does England know about the spirit of the game.
@kha58
@kha58 Год назад
The English should learn the rules and accept the umpire decision as out. They are acting unsportsmanlike.
@pablojescobar3400
@pablojescobar3400 Год назад
They wrote them too
@madam9736
@madam9736 Год назад
You sound clueless son.
@Roy3.16
@Roy3.16 Год назад
@@pablojescobar3400 that's the most funniest thing that the writers of cricket rules and laws forget about them😆
@steventhomson8387
@steventhomson8387 Год назад
Piers as is perfectly demonstrated here in this unilateral one-sided interview and by his lack of knowledge of cricket laws, is the perfect example of an unadulterated winging pom. Australia did nothing wrong and England are just plain sore losers and deserve to the series 5 - 0.
@grennyfell97
@grennyfell97 Год назад
By not acknowledging that Carey had received the ball and was ready to consider it dead, Bairstow has shown a level of disrespect to his Australian counterpart.
@patrickreade6119
@patrickreade6119 Год назад
Morgan, if England had took more catches or scored more runs they would have won both tests 😂😂😂😂 if smith hadn't dropped Stokes England would have been beaten more easily.
@SilentHotdog28
@SilentHotdog28 Год назад
If Australia had of won both tosses and had the favourable conditions instead of England, Australia would have won more comfortably.
@shannonnaicker4040
@shannonnaicker4040 Год назад
If englnd scored 700 and got aussies out for 50 they would have won. 2nil down and 3 more to lose. Come on aussies. From a South African 🇿🇦
@pleasantville4529
@pleasantville4529 Год назад
If my gran had wheels, she'd have been a bicycle.
@pleasantville4529
@pleasantville4529 Год назад
@@runawaypuppet Your kind of rewriting the joke there, but good on you.
@pleasantville4529
@pleasantville4529 Год назад
@@runawaypuppet I have to say, I'd be laughing like a mad man, if the tables were turned.
@jasoncommon4795
@jasoncommon4795 Год назад
Was bowling bouncers to the injured Nathan Lyon in the " spirit of the game"
@PigeonPair
@PigeonPair Год назад
exactly, and was refusing him a runner also 'in the spirit of the game'? Hmmm
@ajmalmeeran6864
@ajmalmeeran6864 Год назад
We all saw England's spirit of the game during the world cup match against NZ 🤣
@shaneharrison8648
@shaneharrison8648 Год назад
That was ruff 😮
@janebond819
@janebond819 Год назад
The problem with P Morgan is that if the guests doesn't agree with him, he doesn't let them talk. And sometimes, he talks alot of shite.
@thennavandakshinamoorthy7494
According to the law England won the 2019 World Cup but to Save the spirit of cricket they should give it back to new zealand 😅😂
@tahmasp6624
@tahmasp6624 Год назад
😂 😂
@martinmason5008
@martinmason5008 Год назад
It crossed my mind at the time it could be shared.
@ADNAN-l5g
@ADNAN-l5g Год назад
Yeah according to spirit of game they should have given the trophy to new Zealand 😂
@margaretreid2153
@margaretreid2153 Год назад
By the way Piers, the disgusting underarm incident was in 1981,not 1991.
@johnfisher9692
@johnfisher9692 Год назад
@@margaretreid2153 And he got things wrong, Trevor Chappel argued with his brother over doing that, you can see he clearly didn't want to do it but in the end he did as his captain ordered him to do. In my view the only thing Trevor is guilty of is obeying his Captain.
@adventurebushflyers985
@adventurebushflyers985 Год назад
"The Batsman doesn't get to decide when the over is done....That's the Umpires job."
@henzelbitzi859
@henzelbitzi859 Год назад
Sandpaper gate has nothing to do with this! This just Piers and English way of trying to cry 😂😂
@DaveWhoa
@DaveWhoa Год назад
and he conveniently never mentioned England used mints to shine the ball for the entire 2005 Ashes series
@acerimmeh
@acerimmeh Год назад
@@DaveWhoa We would have flogged England that series had they not cheated. At the time, I had my suspicions they were cheating when watching that series, because they were getting the ball to revers swing within 20 overs. I find sandpaper gate disgusting as all Aussies do, but England have no moral high ground when it comes to cheating.
@johnavery3941
@johnavery3941 Год назад
As a Cricket Umpire myself he is out, the Umpire did not call Over. Even schoolboys/girls know are taught to stay in their crease until Over is called. It was his own fault. The spirit of the game does not come into it. The ball was not dead.
@dhimantchovatia
@dhimantchovatia Год назад
Not once has Piers Morgan and the show's producers shown the angle from behind where both wicketkeeper and batsman are visible. If one sees that, it is clear as daylight, that Carey threw the ball much before Bairstow stepped out. Yes, he had been routinely stepping out immediately after the ball was bowled which the Aussies noticed. However, on that occasion, Carey did not see him step out. He just threw the ball, almost predicting that he may step out and he foolishly did the same. If the camera behind the keeper is shown, all the arguments die instantly. As for the Captain to withdraw the appeal, I think soon the English will ask to withdraw clean bowled while shouldering arms appeals because the batsman misjudged the ball. If you doze off you get out. This is TEST cricket for goodness sake.
@vivekpokhriyal5303
@vivekpokhriyal5303 Год назад
Why would Johnny scrapping his boot mark the end of the over. Thats a decision that umpires make. Next time Warner nicks one to the slip, he should quickly scrap his boot before the catch is taken. Oh no over finished, ball dead, catch cannot be claimed. Absurd explanations from the English
@Roy3.16
@Roy3.16 Год назад
@vivekpokhriyal5303 best comment lmfao🤣🤣😆😆
@vicdantel2145
@vicdantel2145 Год назад
Saying “we should have won at Edgebaston” is like I should have won lotto even though I didn’t buy a ticket 😂
@XaviRonaldo0
@XaviRonaldo0 Год назад
They certainly shouldn't have lost. That stupid declaration made me laugh so hard
@Shandyboy8612
@Shandyboy8612 Год назад
We were the better side at Edgbaston throughout the 5 days and made stupid decisions and crucial times which made it too close and you won a game you didn’t deserve! Happens all the time in any sport. You deserved to win at Lords regardless of Bairstow but I just think you didn’t need to revert to those tactics
@XaviRonaldo0
@XaviRonaldo0 Год назад
@@Shandyboy8612 I was on your side til you had a bitch about the stumping
@MaKar372
@MaKar372 11 месяцев назад
Here after England's performance in WC...man its good to see Poms cry
@kelstra1997
@kelstra1997 Год назад
We have a few bad commentators here in Australia but thank God we don't have Piers Morgan.
@williamwelling2210
@williamwelling2210 Год назад
He doesn't really care , he just takes the opposite view to get air time
@Nofurtherquestions
@Nofurtherquestions Год назад
Thank god Australia is where the UK sent all its prisoners. Racist sexist backward hell hole
@nsh1772
@nsh1772 Год назад
Man I love Aussie commentary. Can you give me an example for a bad Australian commentator?
@patterdale4332
@patterdale4332 Год назад
And get here you are
@kelstra1997
@kelstra1997 Год назад
@@nsh1772 Most of the faces on Sky News would fit the bill as well as out famous Alan Jones
@DaveWhoa
@DaveWhoa Год назад
Piers keeps mentioning sandpapergate but conveniently never mentions England using mints to shine the ball for an entire 2005 Ashes series. As for cheaters, who is the only person convicted of cheating in this Ashes series? England's Moeen Ali.
@Reneesillycar74
@Reneesillycar74 Год назад
Or that pocket full of dirt. How convenient!
@loganratley6704
@loganratley6704 Год назад
Or the player that got pinned this series
@oleggorky906
@oleggorky906 Год назад
No. Smith and Warner are convicted cheats if we’re going that way. Myopic Aussies. Never sinning but always sinned against.
@oleggorky906
@oleggorky906 Год назад
That’s odd, myopic Dave. I thought that the convicted cheats were Smith, Warner and young Bancroft, etc. The saliva from the Murray Mints was so game changing that you only complained after your boys got caught and the amino acids in the mints were obviously doing more damage than the abrasive sandpaper! There was also the case when Mark Waugh and Shane Warne got caught, taking money off of a bookie in Sri Lanka in 1994. CA didn’t give either of them a ban. Incredible to think that they covered it up for four years when you remember that Hanse Cronje forfeited his career for something similar. Then there was Warney getting sent home from the World Cup in 1999, after falling a drugs test. Did CA give him a ban? No, of course not. They’re in a different position to anyone else. Oh wait ... all of the above was the poms fault ... they forced those incidents onto poor old Australia! 🤣👍🤣👍🤣👍
@theflyingdropbear2009
@theflyingdropbear2009 Год назад
the ball was live when Bairstow got stumped, it isn't the Australians' responsibility to remind an experienced player to keep his bat grounded until the ball is deemed dead at the end of the over by the bowler's end umpire, that is the first thing we are taught when we pick up a cricket bat for the first time. Bairstow never looked back to Carey to get the all the clear, he just walked away from the crease in a daze. The non-existent controversy brought up by a bunch of sore losers isn't going to change the fact that Bairstow made a beginner's mistake, even though he is an experienced player, and he is also a wicket-keeper, he should have known better than that. He simply had a significant lapse in concentration, which denied him of having any amount of situational awareness. I find it very amusing that the people complaining about it the most, are the ones who wrote the laws of the game, the very same laws that rightly denied Starc of a catch when he grounded the ball, and the very same laws that got Bairstow out, in short, the Australians did nothing wrong, and the only in the wrong, is Bairstow himself.
@doctorsocrates4413
@doctorsocrates4413 Год назад
I do wish morgan would allow his guests to finish a sentence..I am very surprised anyone appears on that show.
@murph7421
@murph7421 Год назад
Well, like Piers said, no one else would.
@bc3397
@bc3397 Год назад
​@@murph7421 Shocking that no-one would want to spend 7 and a half minutes of an 8 minute interview being bullied and berated by the host, then interrupted and muted whenever they get a chance to counter Piers' logical fallacies and whataboutism.
@eugenebong9414
@eugenebong9414 Год назад
The more times they run the Bairstow stumping, the more comical he looks!🤣
@Jivvi
@Jivvi 11 месяцев назад
Where did Piers get the crazy idea that the batsman can "mark the end of the over"? That's not a thing. It's never been a thing. The umpire says when the over ends. Johnny Bairstow had brain fart. Plain and simple. He'd do exactly the same thing, and _has_ done exactly the same thing to a batsman when he's the one fielding the ball.
@Quincycle
@Quincycle Год назад
Part of the spirit of cricket is accepting the umpire's decision
@rogerreverence4737
@rogerreverence4737 Год назад
In 2023 England has now begun a new state of the art training teaching batsmen how to stay in their crease....
@Sippajo1
@Sippajo1 Год назад
The fact that piers for the most part can't tell that for the most part Peter is actually taking the piss out of him
@maldini3184
@maldini3184 Год назад
Lack of consentration from Bairstow. That is out all day long.
@omieyadav638
@omieyadav638 Год назад
It was Bairstow's mistake. Carey took advantage of it. No need to create more mess.😅
@TylerDurden-cu6iz
@TylerDurden-cu6iz Год назад
It's not that simple. It involves the spirit of the game
@andrewmiller6051
@andrewmiller6051 Год назад
I’m Australian and I’m glad we won in this way, because now we get a hilarious show of England proving to the world what sore losers they are. Much more entertaining than a regular win 😂 And if the roles were reversed, I would defend England. I’ve never believed in the Holy Spirit of Cricket that the Lords and Sirs made up but refuse to codify and even refuse to explain.
@garystrahan4601
@garystrahan4601 Год назад
They're only crying because no matter how many times Bairstow has tried doing this very same thing he lacks Carey’s far superior skills and keeps missing.
@jamesjones-z4u
@jamesjones-z4u Год назад
Aussies keep saying Bairstow has tried doing this, can’t provide any examples. Almost like it’s a lie.
@thesupplantor
@thesupplantor Год назад
@@jamesjones-z4u if you actually open the other eye and check media outside of that idiot Piers Morgan there's plenty of evidence of Pommy sneakiness and hypocrisy. You wankers just can't handle that Australia always win fair and square.
@theearthrexden
@theearthrexden Год назад
@@jamesjones-z4ugo back and watch the second test. He tired it against Warner and also in the second innings against Marnus
@Roy3.16
@Roy3.16 Год назад
@@theearthrexden also tried against Head at Edgbaston
@uskumarmate
@uskumarmate Год назад
​@@theearthrexdenplease go back and learn the rules of the game. Bairstow did that to them when they took guard outside the crease not when they were going to talk to their mate at the end of an over. Different scenarios
@ST-hr4xv
@ST-hr4xv Год назад
Stokes said that he wouldn't want to win a test in that manner...yet hes perfectly fine with winning a World Cup final like that?
@Roy3.16
@Roy3.16 Год назад
@ST-hr4xv hypocrisy at it's finest
@jeffmackie547
@jeffmackie547 Год назад
Bullshit
@maxsmum3561
@maxsmum3561 Год назад
I think the umpire calls ‘over’, not the player. The play was clearly not over, the keeper in one movement caught the ball and threw it at the stumps. Let us take every incident on its own merit, rather than trying to right wrongs from previous matches. Piers, I really think you have lost this round fella…
@rondunn4336
@rondunn4336 Год назад
How can anyone complain, rules are rules, simple.
@taylorlibby7642
@taylorlibby7642 Год назад
As an American with absolutely no knowledge of cricket I find this whole tempest highly amusing.
@sirsillybilly
@sirsillybilly Год назад
Tune in for tomorrows next Test at Leeds…. They’ll be more fireworks than July 4th
@simonjones4941
@simonjones4941 Год назад
I hear Dave Portnoy is our resident cricket expert across the pond 😅
@alexjason9086
@alexjason9086 Год назад
You like English defeat??
@salttea8926
@salttea8926 Год назад
In Cricket there are 3 formats in which 5 days cricket is the longest format and in which a player need more skill, more patience both physically and mentally... And other two one day and T20 are just for entertainment which last 7 hours and 2.5 hours respectively.... In 5 days cricket there are lot of minor things which can be sought out by both teams by themselves and they also have laws for it, as these minor things can be a loopholes in laws of cricket on which a team can take advantage... In this particular case Australian wicket keeper stumped (out) English cricketer by that minor thing on which English cricketer doesn't want to take any advantage and which costs England the match... And also Cricket is known as Gentlemen's game not because only mens play it (women's also play it) but all players are supposed to play it within spirit of game...
@mtsardar
@mtsardar Год назад
Cricket 🏏 is religion Matches between Australia 🇦🇺 - England 🏴󠁧󠁢󠁥󠁮󠁧󠁿 , India 🇮🇳-pakistan are serious business . You get over billion people watching the game .
@alfalders3020
@alfalders3020 Год назад
This is the side of Piers that is so difficult to love.
@analogpixel
@analogpixel Год назад
There’s a side that’s easy to love?
@donuttttttt
@donuttttttt Год назад
@@analogpixellmao that’s funny but I do like the way he handles some things (note that I said some)
@thatsbollox
@thatsbollox Год назад
Piers wants to introduce Woke Cricket. It starts with a few rule changes. it is now the batsman that tells the umpire when a ball is dead, and when the over is finished. Also, scratching the ground with your spriggs becomes the universal signal that you now cannot be dismissed. Another new rule is to let all batsmen get offered a second chance in case they feel poorly or offended about anything. My niece thinks that Bairstow fella looks exactly like a gingerbread man she made for chirstmas.
@Bellas1717
@Bellas1717 Год назад
I like your point, but woke actually means aware and accepting of a need to redress discrimination, particularly racial discrimination. It is unfortunate that you used the American bastardisation of the word, a tactic used to keep groups of people subjugated and to protect the power and position of old white men. (But then, isn’t that the composition of the group in the Long Room who showed us what the spirit of the gentleman's game should look like?)
@thatsbollox
@thatsbollox Год назад
@@Bellas1717 Grow up and tell the story to someone in your victim group that might care.
@Bellas1717
@Bellas1717 Год назад
@@thatsbollox it is actually quite grown up to be able to accept another point of view. It is quite the opposite to be dismissive and insulting. I belong to no group. I am not a victim. I simply bring a little discernment to what I read and hear, especially the spin coming out of America. Let’s get back to enjoying the cricket.
@thatsbollox
@thatsbollox Год назад
@@Bellas1717 Thats wonderful. Truly it is. However i didnt come here for anyone else's "point of view", for your discernment, definitions of woke, nor your naive evangelical political advice. In fact just take a hike bozo.
@durbo7087
@durbo7087 Год назад
The only thing unsporting is Bairstow not walking once out. Cricket is a gentleman's game. He should have walked once he realised his mistake.
@jeffmackie547
@jeffmackie547 Год назад
Yes it's a gentleman's so why is it played by Aussie's
@Bellas1717
@Bellas1717 Год назад
@@jeffmackie547 England have proven that cricket is no longer played just by gentlemen. While we Australians have our fair share of gentlemen, the term "gentlemen's game" is anachronistic.
@CH-yp5by
@CH-yp5by Год назад
@@Bellas1717 Yep bodyline
@durbo7087
@durbo7087 Год назад
@@jeffmackie547 because England burnt the stumps after losing.
@jeffmackie547
@jeffmackie547 Год назад
@@Bellas1717 Oh there's nowt like a good laugh
@samb8744
@samb8744 Год назад
I love how every clip of Piers Morgan is just him getting horribly embarrassed on his own show. It’s so funny that he calls his show “uncensored” when he’s the most milquetoast, safe, conservative puppet in media. He tries so hard to be transgressive, and then gets horribly offended and cries when people call him out for being an idiot
@tccandler
@tccandler Год назад
Absolutely 100%... and I am English.
@balancinggargoyle
@balancinggargoyle Год назад
Consider this hypothetical. Bairstow walks out of his crease in the exact same way, but instead stops and realizes that he's out of his crease while the ball is live. Bairstow immediately tries to get his bat behind the crease but just fails and is stumped. This would be considered by anyone to be an uncontroversial stumping. Bairstow's obliviousness can't dictate whether a dismissal is fair or not. Piers Morgan's argument is reductio ad absurdum.
@wrongtracksuit
@wrongtracksuit Год назад
@@Eric_Cartman______yet your own team did the same act in New Zealand. Hypocrite much? Loser.
@williamwelling2210
@williamwelling2210 Год назад
This is a brilliant , i wish someone in the media picks up on this. There is absolutely NO argument after this. WELL SAID
@0Fallacy
@0Fallacy Год назад
Good argument and I don't even follow cricket, well done
@billwhite9703
@billwhite9703 Год назад
"Consider this hypothetical. Bairstow walks out of his crease in the exact same way, but instead stops and realizes that he's out of his crease while the ball is live. Bairstow immediately tries to get his bat behind the crease but just fails and is stumped. This would be considered by anyone to be an uncontroversial stumping. Bairstow's obliviousness can't dictate whether a dismissal is fair or not. Piers Morgan's argument is reductio ad absurdum." That's a great comment.
@sanjicook08
@sanjicook08 Год назад
I don't think you know what reductio ad absurdum means
@jehanariyaratnam2874
@jehanariyaratnam2874 Год назад
It's funny how 90% of the comments completely disagree with Piers Morgan whether English, Australian or neutral
@billschild3371
@billschild3371 Год назад
Jehan. I see you everywhere and I await your input next on CFA Nation 😊.
@quicksquiz
@quicksquiz Год назад
England have backed themselves into a corner on this. Most neutrals agree it was fair play. I'm noticing quite a few English posters on social media saying it was fair play. Then add the likes of Vaughan, Strauss, Atherton, Hussain and Butcher all saying it was fair play. Bad losing is bad cricket and this will tarnish Englnd for a long time.
@heretichello8253
@heretichello8253 Год назад
Indian here. I supported Australia the moment I saw Bairstow dismissal. My first thought was intelligent work by Carrey. Even though I hated Australian teams over the years. I support them on this issue. That was out.
@Roy3.16
@Roy3.16 Год назад
@quicksquiz even England's only odi world cup winner Captain Morgan supported Carey
@johnjames6620
@johnjames6620 Год назад
Surely, the umpire's decision (if it is indeed within the law) is final. Nothing more to be said.
@paramtageja6891
@paramtageja6891 Год назад
Cricket is a bit weird in this perspective because in various aspects for alot of people spirit of the game overrides the laws of the game in cases like Mankad etc. In footballing terms if a team puts the ball out for a throw in because there players is injured then the other team takes the throw in and scores. It's legal and in the rules of football but is it in the spirit of the game?
@johnjames6620
@johnjames6620 Год назад
@@paramtageja6891 Then a new set of rules should be drawn up so that everyone is aware of what the rules (spirit) of the game are and then there can be no disagreement on the matter and the umpires can enforce it. As an aside, is it also in the spirit of cricket for the bowling side to heckle the batsman (who is all alone on the field)? This happens all the time! So, to my mind, gamesmanship forms a big part of the "spirit of the game" as you referred to it.
@damonclarke3741
@damonclarke3741 Год назад
These umpires have been shit. Neither were looking at the crease when Bairstow had his stumps hit.
@aawe1
@aawe1 Год назад
@@paramtageja6891 But it _is_ the in the spirit of the game according to the English. And according Bairstow himself. See his comments about his own delayed stumping of Patel in 2014.
@aawe1
@aawe1 Год назад
@@paramtageja6891 Just rampant hypocrisy and bad sportsmanship from the English.
@brucehicks3786
@brucehicks3786 Год назад
Piers refers to a time when he did a lunch break filler/stunt for tv by padding up to face Brett Lee in the nets. He put on every bit of protective gear available. What was going to be a 'gentlemans' arrangement with Brett bowling at a moderate pace changed when Piers big mouth got in the way and started mouthing off to the point of being rude. Brett didnt take too kindly to the comments and suddenly cranked his pace up. Piers got continually hit to the point where i thought he could have been hurt. It was serious at the time but then Piers and his big mouth got what he deserved.
@beachboy13600
@beachboy13600 Год назад
the umpire was right
@SilverZankarne
@SilverZankarne Год назад
England fan here - Aus fully entitled to run Bairstow out and I probably would have done the same thing in Cummins' shoes. It's not Australia's job to teach Bairstow when he can leave his crease just as it's not England's job to teach Mitchell Starc how to catch.
@gtaveteran
@gtaveteran Год назад
Spot on mate ! i also find it to be a ridiculous argument that because of what happened in Cape Town YEARS ago that Australia/Pat Cummins was supposed to withdraw the appeal & give Bairstow a free pass
@pimp4984
@pimp4984 Год назад
Have you been to Lord's Cricket Ground mate?
@gtaveteran
@gtaveteran Год назад
@@pimp4984 No, but i bet the tears of lords & sirs from the long room taste pretty sweet though.
@abdulsamadzakria9912
@abdulsamadzakria9912 Год назад
The fact that Australia went through scandal doesn't mean they stop winning games and giving the opposition chances to win in tricky situations. Its a really foul way of shaming, no reason whatsover to relate the 2 incidents.
@michaellear6904
@michaellear6904 Год назад
The 'Spirit ' of cricket is behaviour that is best manifest when events go against you and you gracefully and manfully accept it.
@nickrad6966
@nickrad6966 Год назад
Like the under arm ball or the Mankad
@michaellear6904
@michaellear6904 Год назад
@nickrad6966 I have no problem with the Mankad but yeah, that underarm caper was shameful.
@alexclark3473
@alexclark3473 Год назад
Football equivalent of “play to the whistle”. Why is everyone complaining over a legal play?
@georgejung5429
@georgejung5429 Год назад
It’s actually nowhere near the same. 😂 Cricket is a gentleman’s sport, it’s etiquette to play it as it should be played, but….the ozzys have just played dirty to get a W, and as an English man, I’d like to congratulate them on their success. England I hope would do the same thing and take advantage of a dirty play if it arose.
@ohmyfungus5810
@ohmyfungus5810 Год назад
Because it’s scummy and this Aussie team is most famous for sandpaper gate (they were found cheating)
@itsmeprasad1987
@itsmeprasad1987 Год назад
Cricket is a gentleman’s game
@trevaudio
@trevaudio Год назад
@@georgejung5429 A gentleman’s sport 😂😂😂😂
@davidbrear8642
@davidbrear8642 Год назад
You are correct, according to the laws of cricket, the bowler's end umpire can only rule that the ball is dead when all the players on the field (the two batters and the fielders) come to regard it as dead. In other words, the ball becomes dead when both sides have stopped playing. Bairstow stopped playing, but Carey didn't, because he wasn't obliged to. The ball was, therefore, still in play. It has to be said that when a keeper takes a ball cleanly whilst standing back to pace in a test match, and the striking batsman is safely anchored in his crease, invariably everyone has stopped playing. It's almost as though this has become an unspoken agreement amongst international players, and this explains all the furor. Bairstow is a good bloke, but he was far too careless in the moment, particularly since this was an Ashes test where traditionally no holds are barred. He didn't even look round to see if Carey had pouched the ball, let alone to verify that he'd stopped playing. Bairstow must have heard the ball slam into his keeper's gloves so he signalled his intention to leave his crease not realising that the ball was on its way to the stumps Carey and Cummins are good blokes, but they have too much pressure on them to win.
@jeffmcmahon3278
@jeffmcmahon3278 Год назад
Bairstow is supposed to be a Test cricket wicket-keeper - could have fooled me.
@abyss7049
@abyss7049 Год назад
Give it a bloody rest Piers. Not every member of the public says it was wrong. Infact its more 50/50 with English folk, and given that, it just shows you it's not as bad as you think. Absolute waffle!
@knight2425
@knight2425 Год назад
Most of the past England players including captains have come out and supported Australia over this, it’s just the sore losers that are looking for a way to blame everyone else that are whinging at the moment
@shaunstrang6658
@shaunstrang6658 Год назад
couldnt agree more. A painful listen. Like so many of the other interviews he does.
@AdamDermody
@AdamDermody Год назад
Bairstow marked his crease before the ball reached Carey. Therefore it’s not the end of the over he should have looked behind him
@acerimmeh
@acerimmeh Год назад
Agreed. I timed Bairstow ducking the ball (ball above his head), to the moment he started to move out of his crease at 1.8 seconds. Who walks out the crease in 1.8 seconds of ducking a bouncer and does not expect to be stumped.
@AdamDermody
@AdamDermody Год назад
@@acerimmeh haha exactly and thats fast if the ball goes through to the keeper on the full let alone bouncing on the way to the keeper
@matt.2708
@matt.2708 Год назад
We don’t need to apologise to the English, and we don’t need to seek apologies because Aussies couldn’t care less about them crying and harping on cause they always have
@deepu14693
@deepu14693 Год назад
Piers spoke like he looked up what cricket is and looked at some short hand notes on the incident 30 mins before going on air 😂😂
@Roy3.16
@Roy3.16 Год назад
@deepu14693 exactly😀😀😆😆
@jehanariyaratnam2874
@jehanariyaratnam2874 Год назад
Nah he's an experienced cricketer, he thinks he demolished Brett Lee in the nets
@dasadman
@dasadman Год назад
That's summarizing his sports knowledge in general
@Roy3.16
@Roy3.16 Год назад
@@jehanariyaratnam2874 hahahaha best comment😆😆😂😂
@Katrinagaming-en1os
@Katrinagaming-en1os Год назад
I love how they never show the whole picture/clip. Carey was standing deep and immediately after he received the ball he threw it back at the stumps. I repeat … immediately. An instinctive reaction from a wicket keeper that is doing his job. What the English keep showing is this long lag from swing to stumping. Carey - again doing his job - threw the ball slowly from a long distance. This would ensure if he missed the stumps the ball wouldn’t go for four. Incidentally if that did happen, England would have gladly taken their four. Here is the whole truth at 2.25 ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-lkAHxxL4kSc.html Piers I like your passion across most topics but you know you have set this interview up as a lie. Get over it England and stop dragging up the past!
@leeleeson5947
@leeleeson5947 Год назад
You’re telling an Englishmen to stop dragging up the past hahahahahahahahaha if any nationality had th e past brought up the most it’s the English ! You clown!
@CR-gr4bx
@CR-gr4bx Год назад
Not instinctive. Carey knew Bairstow would walk to the middle at the end of the over. Bairstow wasn't dozy, he assumed some level of professional understanding among players by saying 'I'm in' with his foot scrape.
@Roy3.16
@Roy3.16 Год назад
@@CR-gr4bx where was this professionalism when Bairstow did that exact same thing to Marnus and Warner at Lord's and to Head at Edgbaston? Bairstow also didn't warned them before threw the ball to the stamps direction but all 3 times he missed and all 3 times Aussie batsmen were care enough to look back and since when batsman earned this facility to mark the crease with shoe and then get out of the crease? there's no rule or nothing like that kind of facility given to batsman atleast till now, an over will only end when 1 of the 2 on field umpires call it "Over" until then the ball and the over is alive and batsman is obliged to stay inside his crease
@seaofghosts
@seaofghosts Год назад
@@CR-gr4bx "Professional understanding" is knowing the rules of the game. The over isn't finished until the umpire says it is.
@johnfisher9692
@johnfisher9692 Год назад
@@CR-gr4bx The truth is Bairstow was an idiot who made a mistake a rookie wouldn't have, and is too embarrassed or cowardly to admit it. Scraping your shoe only means something if you are playing Bairstow Rules and this isn't. Otherwise the opposition team wouldn't be allowed bats, according to Bairstow rules 🤪
@justintime1307
@justintime1307 Год назад
Australians should apologise to the British for the abuse they have given to English as a language. Absolutely brutalised our vocabulary every single time they open their mouth. Prime example is "snag" a problem or difficulty, in Australian a sausage. WTF are Australians doing to our language.
@stevebird7265
@stevebird7265 Год назад
I 100% agree with the Aussie! Surely the over is not finished with until the play is ended. The wicket keeper did what he did in one continuous move, so play was not over and the batsman should have waited!
@jehanariyaratnam2874
@jehanariyaratnam2874 Год назад
It's over when the batsman scratches the crease with his foot once.....lol
@jimmyjames7667
@jimmyjames7667 Год назад
@@jehanariyaratnam2874 No, it's over when the batsman adjusts his cup. 🤪
@umairmudassar3152
@umairmudassar3152 Год назад
As a Pakistani fan of cricket I am enjoying this from day one 😂😂
@shounakchatterjee4461
@shounakchatterjee4461 Год назад
Me too...guess what I am an Indian🤓🤓
@miloblackmetalhate
@miloblackmetalhate Год назад
Bhaisaab as an Indian this is like Diwali came early. Maybe Bakrid ki khushi mei yeh tohfa diya hai goron ne 😂
@sven_86
@sven_86 Год назад
as indian fan, me too lol
@safebrad423
@safebrad423 Год назад
@@miloblackmetalhate fjijewroijfioejofijweoifjoi i can speak gibberish too djweojfimeovimv[oew c
@aussieme-mt7vr
@aussieme-mt7vr Год назад
English kidnapped Indigenous children in the guise of educating them but actually using them to do hard labour to make their beds and homes comfortable. Have they apologise then? No, so how do you think England will apologise to Australia especially now even the families are being put in danger because ill-mannered fans are scaring them off as if it is in the spirit of the game too. those members at the Lords being suspended is not enough what they should do is to keep the families of the Australian players safe and comfortable because it is making the image of England bad being Not a Safe place to watch any sports if England is losing because they do not like England losing.
@ST-hr4xv
@ST-hr4xv Год назад
I was on England's side of the argument until I saw previous clips of Bairstow doing the exact same thing and saying that its perfectly within the rules. Completely stand with the aussies now.
@anthonywebster7722
@anthonywebster7722 Год назад
He spoke so many words, but all I heard was "Waaaah."
@YD-uq5fi
@YD-uq5fi Год назад
An umpiring error is the reason England won the last World Cup instead of New Zealand. Does Piers want to trade that for this?
@MultiDwang
@MultiDwang Год назад
The interesting thing here was about Steve Smith's mum crying, and Piers talked over that !!! That's not cricket Piers.
@SriGutta
@SriGutta Год назад
If Carey missed the ball and it went to the boundary, would it be called a dead ball because Bairstow marked his crease and signalled end of over. Bairstow was just dopey.. He had no idea where the ball was.
@JoeMicroscope
@JoeMicroscope Год назад
Yes of course it would. England would not have taken the runs.
Далее
НОВАЯ "БУХАНКА" 2024. ФИНАЛ
1:39:04
Просмотров 360 тыс.
When Australia faced a HOSTILE crowd at Lord's 😲
3:53
Piers shown no mercy from Lee
5:49
Просмотров 1,7 млн