Hearing Tenn say, "It's a trick! We can't let her hurt anyone else!" just made something in me snap. This was the woman who shot my friend Doug in Season 1. Whose father tried to murder Lee despite him saving his life. Who killed an unarmed, desperate teenage boy in Season 4, episode 2. Who ran a group of child-conscripting thugs willing to murder their way through anyone who tried to stop them. The woman who CUT LOUIS'S TONGUE OFF. I showed her the same mercy she had proven so willing to dispense: "Do it, AJ."
Yeah, I feel the disconnection from Season 1 for so long has made a lot of people look at Lilly as a new character when in reality shes been this way ever since the beginning, just not as bad, I shot her in a heartbeat.
I must say, I agree. Most will argue that choosing the moral choice and the obviously-not-so-moral decision is black and white, however, like most things, it's not. Killing Lilly is not an "evil" decision, and you won't downpour into a state of dread and depression in choosing such. Regardless of her and the player's past in this series, though VERY much so worth noting, the moral decision here is to put Lilly out of commission, and I will argue this decision with the following point: While it is not technically immoral to be fighting a war unless the point of which is through selfish gain, the tactics of the Delta's specific war is. Child conscription, near fascist movements and mindless torture, which justify the means in fucking decking Lilly as I have chosen. While murder is never okay, it is the lesser evil to prevent Lilly from harming anyone else.
If only aj didn't pull the trigger and realized Marlon wasn't a monster , but he was still learning from Clem and didnt understand. But rip by boi Marlon
@@clementine-princessofsurvi2936 oh yeah clem is the kind of person that wants AJ to become a monster... clem is the kind of the person that would seek out revenge... clem is the kind of person that doesnt care how merciful and kind lee was she would kill anything in her path that wronged her.. clem is also the person who wouldnt listen to her friends... and is ignorant to certain things like walkers.... because that's basically what youre saying right now. you may be that clementine but the clementine I KNOW and the clementine LEE RAISED would never kill out of revenge. ever watch the show? ever read the comics? even rick knows the meaning of mercy... he let negan live... and rick is known for not letting things go easily..
@@K1NG0FW0LV35 Killing Marlon was stupid yes but killing Lilly is the only good choice. If I let her live, she will kill James. Another innocent man will die because of her. And what about Kenny? You think he is a monster because he killed Carver?
@@clementine-princessofsurvi2936 kenny went too far he couldve just stabbed him in the head and been done.... and james basically asked to die so that AJ didnt become a monster. in season 2 I shot kenny because he was a broken man who lost everything.. he was already dead.... he was too far gone from the kenny we ounce knew... he didnt care who he hurt or who was killed unless it was you... he even lashed out at you during one point... and when he did kill he went way too far. you may be merciless but the clem I control and the clem I create will never be... James wants lily to live then he'll learn why that is a mistake and then I will fix his mistake in the next episode. when negan kept killing rick's crew did he kill negan? no he spared him and put him in a cell... even maggie let him live.... lily is not negan but she damn sure is better than him... the only people she killed were the people you made fight the only people she tortured are the people who gave her a hard time..... yeah she killed carley/doug but thats because they pushed her... im not saying you have to forgive her im just saying that you shouldnt let AJ become a monster because of your pain, your anger, your hatred, and your greed... listen to james and kill lily later....
Sorry James, but I'm getting my revenge on Lilly. I'm getting revenge for Doug/Carley, for Mitch and for Louis, whom you traumatised (if you chose Violet). I wonder if James would still insist on being a pacifist if he knew he would die 5 seconds later if you decide to spare her.
honestly he probaly would... but I still gave him his wish... he wants to be stupid enough to get stabbed? thats his problem.. i'll save AJ's sanity and kill her the next episode
@@SonnySanVista but a child monster? do you even know what the whisperers are? having one as an enemy is like shoving a knife into your neck... it will end the same way.. with you dead... seriously.... keeping james alive is just as good as killing him later but only when you kill him later he'll hate you... isnt it predictable that he will become the new bad guy? think about it... if you spared lily youd have to kill her later because she's the main enemy... and if you spare james he'll probaly hate you for letting AJ kill against his wishes...and then try to kill you and take AJ... seriously am I the only one who is thinking about the choices for the future rather than jumping to a decision without thinking about the consequences? I know I already said it but i'll say it again.. if you think about it.. its so predictable... so i'll ask you this.. who would you rather kill... lily or james? because either way they'll both die...
Can we get a round of applause for Nicki Rapp? Her performance as Lilly was phenomenal in this series, but this scene in particular was something special. The desperation in her voice, "I don't wanna die!". I feel pity for Lilly because of this performance, even after everything she had done.
Super3dBoy lol I was scared AJ would be a cruel killer so I made an lower gun, but that friggin got James killed, so I restarted and choose to shoot lily which was more satisfying
"AJ wait! I give up. I will give up. Put down the gun, I'll let everyone leave. My crew and I will leave, we won't bother you anymore" ... "You weren't down there. You didn't see what she did. She tried to cut us all up". Damn this scene is way too strong. I want to kill Lilly, but I don't want AJ to be the one to do it (And it's not because of James or because AJ will probably becomes a psycopath later), it's mostly because Clem is the one who should do it because of their past, and because Lee would have stayed with Carly if she lived and continued the journey with our group back in Season 1. Not only that, all of this only happened because Lilly holds a grudge with everything that happened before, and she mostly wants to hurt only Clem (You know, after knowing she's alive and with the kids back in the school).
It didn’t feel right to kill Lilly while she was unarmed, she had multiple chances to kill Clementine (especially in episode 2’s last fight), but chose not to since she had parts of her that still liked Clem and considered her as family, so, I repaid the favor and didn’t kill her.
Could you do the theme that plays when you talk to violet in episode 3 about Louis.. (Aka when you find her again if you saved Louis) The theme that plays when you guys are talking about Minnie
I do not know about you but I could not bring myself to kill Lilly. I know that a large majority of Twdg hates her and does not hesitate to choose to kill her for what she did to the twins (When she probably forced Minerva to kill her own sister, Sophie really messed me up, I even cried) and Louis and Violet and I understand perfectly but me, I do not know why but when I chose to let AJ shoot him, I felt bad. Personally I love Lilly, she is one of the characters I prefer and her change in season 4, shocked me a lot and saddened me. That's why I preferred to keep the choice to leave it alive. I have nothing against James, I love this character and his philosophy on the prowlers is interesting and a little fascinating. I would really like to know what happened to Lilly during the other seasons.
Hey! Just wanted to pass on the good news that there is finally an official soundtrack release for all of the seasons of Jared's score to Telltale's Walking Dead games. Streaming now, and available for digital download on basically every platform! www.jaredemersonjohnson.com/news/2019/9/10/official-walking-dead-soundtrack-albums-available-for-sale-on-digital-platforms
TripleKillionare Eh, maybe but I wouldn’t be able to watch AJ do something stupid like murder everyone at the boarding school, especially after his badass scene in the cells
I might sound crazy but I think sparing her is a good idea. I know is a revenge for what Lilly did to Carley/Doug, Mitch and Louis but AJ needs to live his life like a little boy, not like a murder. But if AJ spares her, Tenn will get mad on him but James will be happy (I am not saying that James ideas are good, walkers are monsters, there are not humans anymore). But if AJ shoots, the little boy inside him will die and he will become a murder. People will get more scared of him and he may also kill anyone that doesn't agree with him or he just doesn't like. He won't hesitate. So that's why I think AJ should spare Lilly. (Also because something I learnt about Telltale Games is that the best choice you think you made in last chapters, you are gonna regret it later and you will play again to choose the "bad" choice for having maybe a better ending in the story.
Hey could you upload the theme that plays after Lilly kills James and grabs the gun please, it's pretty similar to Raider Attack but with a creepier tone, or when Violet tells her story
