Тёмный
No video :(

Eugene Stoner and Mikhail Kalashnikov - Part 2 - Discussing the AK 

Bakelite N Waffles
Подписаться 7 тыс.
Просмотров 136 тыс.
50% 1

This video is part of a series created from footage of Eugene Stoner and Mikhail Kalashnikov meeting in Virginia in 1990. All the footage is courtesy of the Smithsonian Institution Archives. All I have done is cut some of the waiting time between tapes out and tried to fix the audio. Otherwise, what you are seeing is entirely unadulterated.
Feel free to ask any questions about the various topics of the video in the comments. I will do my best to answer them.
All footage is used with permission from the Smithsonian Institution Archives.

Опубликовано:

 

22 авг 2021

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 604   
@TheFaveteLinguis
@TheFaveteLinguis 2 года назад
Transcription of his speech: Ladies and gentlemen. I have a job and I don't have time to brush and correct the translation in declared time. Still, in a week, I will finish this work. 0:53 this piece is also very simple. You should push on the magazine catch and move the magazine out. 1:10 Use your thumb to push the return mechanism and remove the dust cover 1:15 that’s a dust cover, you see. 1:16 after that you (?) pull off the return mechanism. 1:22 movements are simple - doesn’t take a college graduate, you see. 1:36 push the bolt carrier and bolt back 1:44 here, two parts 1:49 very simple by themselves (???) 1:50 you see, they fit like a glove. They cry to fit in the exactly right place 1:58 you can’t do it wrong 2:12 next. We have to pop off the gas tube 2:22 here the injection molding was used, just like in your model 2:23 forend has this plastic as well 2:42 and on the pistol grip 2:51 let’s say you need to fold the buttstock 2:52 God it’s tight! 2:55 you know, so it won’t pop off in accidentally. 3:04 like that 3:07 you can even fold it with a magazine 3:15 like that. With magazine. 3:23 magazine, as we discussed, has a semi-spherical form 3:35 higher curvature comes from the taper angle of the ammunition 3:45 (heard the interpreter) yeah, it’s a conical shape - that’s why we have this steep curvature here. 3:52 let’s put in on place - it’s on its place 4:00 in order to proceed with taking it apart we have to have a tool - 4:04 use the punch to tap out the pin and get it out 4:07 push the second pin (the one of the ejector) 4:14 then we have the firing pin and the ejector taken apart 4:20 I don’t have a punch with me, unfortunately, so I can’t show you 4:25 I’m sure you took it apart yourself, eh 4:45 what we have here - the trigger group 4:51 It’s very simple in its design 4:56 The trigger 5:00 then, we have a special catch and automatic-fire sear 5:08 thus, use the safety selector to switch the firing mode 5:25 let’s open it, shall we 5:39 this fire selector acts as a cover for the opening where the bolt handle goes through 5:50 it prevents dust from falling in this huge gap 5:57 sand, dust and so forth 6:02 we close it and see: no gap 6:08 so, it’s a coupling of functions that, sort of, had to occur necessitated by the mechanism operation 6:17 instead of using multiplicities of mechanism 6:21 so, this shield carries out three functions at once 6:26 covers the gap, switches the gun to single and automatic fire 6:45 you observe not the very first model 6:49 it’s an AKM 6:55 letter “M’ stands for “Modernised” 7:01 it’s a custom to designate models like that 7:07 if in a first model the receiver was made from a solid forging 7:23 here we see sheet metal stamping 7:27 here you can see it 7:29 it’s stamped in a shape of a sink 7:33 there 7:34 we have rails for the recoil mechanism 7:43 oh, for bolt carrier and bolt 7:54 we call this “the shroud” (it’s being stamped from the sheet metal (the flat)) 7:59 we, ugh, pin the trunnion, also made from flat, three from one side and three from the other one 8:15 buttplate is being fixed into the receiver and pinned through 8:35 on the first models even these “pullings” (strips of the folding stock connected to the butt plate) were made out of forgings (blocks of metal) and then slab milled in order to get this shape 8:48 that one is made from the flat. Sheet metal. 8:54 there are reinforcements in there spot welded in place 9:02 yeah 9:10 the butt plate is being pinned by rivets from this and that side but 9:12 in a way to allow for its rotation 9:21 let’s move on to this part’nj rfulf& 9:26 that’s a gas block 9:33 it’s being made from a forging 9:37 then we mill it 9:40 the front sight block 9:43 is also made from a forging with to be continued
@eduardocharlier7560
@eduardocharlier7560 2 года назад
This needs to be pinned
@markdahlia9543
@markdahlia9543 2 года назад
You are the hero we need my friend
@RMosher11
@RMosher11 2 года назад
Thank you
@ampernom
@ampernom 2 года назад
Thank you for your time and effort!
@maksymilian2189
@maksymilian2189 2 года назад
Pin it please, admin!
@ivankrylov6270
@ivankrylov6270 2 года назад
This interpreter was really out of his league... Kalashnikov was so excited to describe all the parts, and he just couldnt keep up...
@lieutenantcoloneltanyavond8273
@lieutenantcoloneltanyavond8273 2 года назад
Yeah. It's honestly difficult job. I was once roped into translating a speech live.... One of the worst experiences of my life.
@ivankrylov6270
@ivankrylov6270 2 года назад
@@lieutenantcoloneltanyavond8273 i agree, I do it pretty regularly for some relatives and it doesnt get as technical or fast as this
@bodyno3158
@bodyno3158 2 года назад
@@lieutenantcoloneltanyavond8273 I'm native Chinese speaker and consider myself pretty proficient in English, and once took translation as a side hustle, but simultaneous interpretation? Nah. The mental stress and required proficiency is unimaginable.
@jojomarujo8704
@jojomarujo8704 2 года назад
He's doing double work of translating English to Russian, and technical terms in English to Russian terms. Probably the guy isn't much of a gun guy too (?)
@swiftblade13s
@swiftblade13s Год назад
@@bodyno3158 I'm trilingal and do simultaneous interpretation regularally and it is definitely a skill that takes time to learn
@luciano12sa
@luciano12sa 2 года назад
Kalashikov just didn't care if the translator could keep up with him, he just wanted to explain everything with such detail and presentation for his fellow gun engineer. And now that's history, which we will translate properly to know every word this legend said. Truly a incredible time to be alive.
@rozkaz661
@rozkaz661 2 года назад
Im from eastern europe but not fluent enough in russian to translate what kalshnikov is saying 100% but good enough to understand way more than the translator is saying. He talks very interestingly full of anecdotes and subtle humour, he sounds and constructs sentences like any eastern european educated old man. He reminds me of some of my engineering proffesors
@shabanov88
@shabanov88 Год назад
Where are you from?
@samdavies3170
@samdavies3170 7 месяцев назад
a poet and inventor..!!!
@Adi_1922
@Adi_1922 6 месяцев назад
He was such a well educated Soviet man.
@andrewpiltenko9432
@andrewpiltenko9432 2 года назад
Let me defend the translator for a second. This was 1990, there were not a lot of good translators out there who would speak both languages very very good. At least they were not easy to find. The guns and gun parts have very specific words for them and terms, which sound totally different in these two languages, so it's pretty much impossible to learn them by association. Many of these words are quite specific and it's difficult to remember them, as there are many and they are tricky. The translator actually asked Kalashnikov to slow down in the very beginning and give him some time to translate, which Kalashnikov simply ignored lol. Most of the things Kalashnikov was saying were something like "then you do this, then do that, then you twist this, then you open here, then you pull that, etc.", so a lot of times there was nothing to translate really. And at the end of the day, he probably was very nervous. That being said, they probably could have found a better translator, but it's not that easy. Partially it is understandable why he had such a difficulty with translation.
@luciano12sa
@luciano12sa 2 года назад
Absolutely, even to learn the name of all the parts, engineering processses, industrial processes they talked about in your own language would take a considerable time, let alone translate to another language that may not have proper words to describe with some level of fidelity what's being said. All on top of a fast speaking guest. What a nightmare 😆.
@Wattfgoogle
@Wattfgoogle 2 года назад
And thats ok but this is a gem of history that we need to work towards giving justice for what it is
@gunrelatedvids
@gunrelatedvids 2 года назад
Technical words dont translate well at all. I have this issue at work translating german to english
@kravchan
@kravchan 2 года назад
You are right. It was old times with no internet to learn actual English for the translator.
@koolaidblack7697
@koolaidblack7697 Год назад
>The translator actually asked Kalashnikov to slow down in the very beginning and give him some time to translate, which Kalashnikov simply ignored Based Kalashnikov
@brasstard7.627
@brasstard7.627 2 года назад
The irony that they brought him a Chinese AK!! He has stated on video elswhere that he wasnt pleased about the Chinese version
@thefirearmschannel3194
@thefirearmschannel3194 2 года назад
At the time this was filmed (1990), the Chinese rifles were the most common. I suppose an Egyptian would’ve been more closer to being correct.
@berryreading4809
@berryreading4809 2 года назад
The only "real" Ak's were hidden away deep in multiple government warehouses after "acquiring" them from Cuba, Vietnam, Afghanistan, Germany, etc. It was a few more years after the wall came down before Soviet imports or even parts kits were available... they used what they could get for this filming without lots of government red tape... however I am disappointed in the translator... maybe someone can eventually add subtitles 🙏😁
@Im_TheSaint
@Im_TheSaint 2 года назад
A so called ray kay.
@moonasha
@moonasha 2 года назад
1990, I don't think we were importing guns from the soviet union yet
@miniaturefarmer464
@miniaturefarmer464 9 месяцев назад
I remember Remington had a deal to get Baikal shotguns by 1994. Izhevsk and Tula guns were a few years later. @@moonasha
@DawidKov
@DawidKov 7 месяцев назад
Since there does not appear to be a full translation in the comments, only partial, I have created my own. For ease of reading, I only put timestamps intermittently, rather than on each single phrase. It did not fit into a single comment, so I broke it up into two parts, the second part is in the replies to this one. 0:15 Just now, my colleague, Eugene Stoner, has graciously showed me his work. Let him have some patience, and listen as I tell him about my first work. This design is just as simple. You just need to press this lever and detach the magazine. Here, press down with your thumb onto the recoil spring assembly, and take off the cover. Here, the cover. Then, take out the recoil spring assembly. The movements are very simple, no need to finish an academy. Pull back the bolt carrier and bolt. Here, two parts. They're simple on their own. And each is almost asking to go to its place, they won't fit otherwise. Then we need to remove the gas tube in its cover. Here, as in your work, we use a plastic mould. Same plastic is on the handguard, and on the pistol grip. 2:47 Well, let's say you need to fold the stock. Oh wow, that's stiff. Well, it's made in such a way that it wouldn't open up accidentally. Like this... by the way, it folds even with the magazine attached. (translator: slower, let me translate, Mikhail Timofeyevich). The magazine, as we discussed, has a curved shape. The steeper curve depends on the cartridge's taper. The cartridge is tapered, so the shape is steeper. Here, let's put that where it belongs. It's right where it belongs. 4:00 To disassemble further, we need the kit - use a punch to take out this pin, then this second one for the extractor, and then we'll have the extractor and the firing pin disassembled. I don't have a punch here, so I can't demonstrate it, but I'm sure you've disassembled it more than once! But as it is, what can we see? Here we see the fire control group. It's very simple in its construction. The trigger, here's a special hook, and the sear for single or automatic fire. So, with this selector, we can go from single to automatic fire. 5:25 Here, let's open this up. This selector serves as well to close up this opening where the bolt handle passes. So this is done to prevent dust from getting inside this large gap. Sand, dust, etc. And when we close it up, we see that dust can't get in. So this combined function comes from a practical necessity. To avoid making some separate little parts for it, but instead make this little shield do pretty much three functions - close up the gap, select single fire, and automatic fire. 6:45 What you're seeing isn't the first model, this is the AKM. The letter M is there, meaning "modernized". This is our convention, M for modernized. Here, in the first model, the receiver was made from a steel block. In this one we see it's stamped, made into a sort of trough out of metal sheets. And we get the guide rails for the bolt carrier. We call it a "shroud", this stamped bit. On the front trunnion, we rivet it with three rivets on one side, and three on the other. On the rear trunnion, on the stock, we do the same, sliding it into the stamped receiver and fixed in place with rivets going all the way through. 8:33 On the first models even these bars were made from a block, milled out into shape. So you can see it's the same, now it's stamped from sheets, there are spot-welded reinforcements. And the butt plate is also on rivets, one on each side, but made to freely rotate. 9:20 Now, let's move on to this area. Here's the gas chamber. It's machined out of a steel block. The front sight post, also machined from a block. Here, we drill an opening, and insert the base of the front sight. This base has a threaded opening, and we screw the front sight in there with a special key, adjusting its height with the thread. Here is the rear sight, a tangent type, so to say. It's marked up to 800 meters. Well, I'll say it plainly, - you know this better than me, - that shooting at such a distance is very difficult. After all, this is an assault weapon. And perhaps this type of sight isn't needed. But the military men, be they ours or yours, will demand - give us this sort of large distance. But really, it'd be enough to have a selection from three distances, you don't need more than that. 11:45 Here, this one's also detachable, you turn this here... it's very stiff still, the cleaning rod should've been removed. Stiff. Then this band is moved away... here, we can use this... and the handguard is taken off. Here it is, stamped. Here, we too, used to put an aluminium heat shield. Because in hot conditions, during sustained fire, it heats up quite a bit, and burns the hand. You can't hold it. But on the latest models we worked this out in such a way that... you see, the handguard used to be made from wood, the upper from veneer, and this one from glued... like a thick plywood. And from that we had this sort of shape. And when we started to switch to plastic, we needed to make it so it didn't heat up any more than the wood. So in the latest models there are special grooves, to increase the cooling surface. 14:15 I'm showing you models that were made, let's just say, many years ago. Right now it's all made from progressive workpieces (note: I've no idea how to translate this term properly). It's casted. This part is cast (pointing at the rear sight block), this one (gas chamber), this one (front sight post), so all the details... and this one (rear trunnion), so all the parts are cast. This too (the hammer) is cast, you can see on this model it was milled from a block, on the new ones it's cast. So the weapon isn't staying still, when the laymen will look and say "the way it was in 1947, its shape hasn't changed since". 15:50 But actually, there was a lot of work done, to switch from the milled blocks to stampings, this wasn't a simple issue. We needed to keep the same durability, as we talked, when throwing, dropping, and so on. But on the outside, the shape is the same. And right now, the latest models in service in our army, they too have the same shape, but there was a lot of changes made. Same as you, I'm not getting off my horse, so to say, in regards to interchangeability and unification of design. See, everything that affects the design's effectiveness remains as is, almost without changes. 17:17 But of course, on the outside they look similar enough that laymen will say it's the same thing. So that's the short explanation of this model of the AK... or rather, an AKM. If you maybe have any questions for me, I'll be ready to answer them. You know, same as you, Eugene, I've had military men say they'd like a weightless weapon, we have the same demands. So in the latest models this cover is thinner material, the receiver is a thinner material. In some ways, we lose out - on durability, the robustness of the weapon, when we try to make it excessively light. 21:30 Right. Now I'll reassemble this weapon, and tell you about the reason I started working on designing firearms. I hold it like this. The bolt connects to the bolt carrier. It must be cocked. Place it in. Insert the recoil spring assembly. Place the dust cover. Like this. Insert the magazine. Right, that happens, that happens. This might not be the right magazine, it's not going in (translator: maybe the release lever is...) Alright, we'll leave this one to the side. So this is the weapon assembled.
@DawidKov
@DawidKov 7 месяцев назад
22:50 And now I'll tell you how I began designing. I am a participant of the Great Patriotic war. I know, that you too were a participant of that hated war. I was a tank commander. After I got wounded, I ended up in a hospital. And in the hospital I often heard our soldiers say, 'how come the Germans have an automatic for almost every soldier, while we have a rifle for every two or three men?' (note: Russian "avtomat" has historically been used for both submachine guns and assault rifles, hence the awkward translation). We did have automatics, but they were very rare at that time. So I began thinking, could we create a, - well, at the time it was a submachine gun, with a pistol caliber cartridge, - create a submachine gun so simple in design, that it could be produced at any small workshop. But it's one thing to set such a task, how does one go about solving it? Especially when you're wounded and lying in a hospital? But despite that, I obtained some school notebooks, pencils, rubbers, and began designing my first submachine gun, without any experience in this matter. There was only the necessity to design such a weapon. 25:27 I was not alone in this matter. Every Soviet citizen wanted to do something to quicken the destruction of the hated enemy. So, while in the hospital, I made my first sketches for a submachine gun. Then I was given leave to go home, and it was during this leave I made my first combat capable submachine gun. And by the end of the war, when the military was convinced that the pistol caliber isn't powerful enough, and was not effective at longer distances, there was the question of designing a cartridge that would be more effective. So that's why this cartridge was developed, here it is in my hand, we sometimes call this an 'intermediate' cartridge. Why 'intermediate'? It's more powerful than a pistol caliber cartridge, but isn't as powerful as a full rifle cartridge. That's why we call it intermediate. Alternatively it's known as the cartridge model 1943. 27:35 That's when a competition was announced to create an automatic weapon for this cartridge. (host asks if the cartridge was developed before the weapon) Yes. I was not working alone, several designers were working on their own weapons for this cartridge. There were well-known designers such as Degtyaryov, Simonov, others. And there were beginners, myself among them. The work wasn't easy, when you don't have your own design bureau, or sufficient knowledge in this field. But it seems my youth allowed me to take on such nearly impossible task. The competition trials, when the projects were approved, were held simultaneously, different designs were tested in the same conditions. And so, in 1947 this competition came to an end. After the harshest trials of these designs, it was recommended to adopt into service the design that was given the designation of AK-47. At the time I was a senior sergeant, in active service. And in the Soviet Union, we award a prize to those who design such a weapon. Or rather, to correct myself, not those who design a weapon, but design any new technology, that would be a more correct way to put it. So that's when the people saw in the newspapers how there's a designer with a sergeant's stripes. 32:06 That's how this rifle, designated AK-47, was adopted into service of our army. And then it became widely spread. There were modifications, such as the light machine gun (RPK), then the AKM was designed on the same platform. That was my fate of becoming an arms designer. But when I first got into the army, my attempts at designing and constructing weren't weapons, but devices for combat vehicles. So it is the fault of the Germans, who attacked our country, and forced me to switch from peaceful work to military designs. 34:03 This model is still in service in the armies of many countries worldwide. That is how our fates were intertwined, forcing us to become arms designers, and finally, years later, we have met, and are now telling each other of how we became this way. I think that, perhaps, we will forge our swords into ploughshares. But while there is such a need, we will work. This weapon is not one of offence, but one of defence. Yesterday I have seen your weapon, which was adapted for sports shooting. And I'm thinking, maybe I try that too? So that's the short story of my fate and my career of designing weapons. 37:54 (translator: ...you were unknown at the time, a sergeant, and so it was, so to say, a political decision, you were pushed through) My career path was a thorny one. There was distrust, 'how could a sergeant create something good?'. Yes, it's one thing when it's general Degtyaryov, another when it's some sergeant. There were a lot of difficulties. They had their own design bureaus. But I was, figuratively speaking, a homeless orphan.
@markmark2080
@markmark2080 7 месяцев назад
@@DawidKov Thank you so much.
@MaximRymyantsev
@MaximRymyantsev 7 месяцев назад
@bakelitenwaffles78 please pin this. this is a thorough and close-to-the-script translation
@corbinnelson1323
@corbinnelson1323 14 дней назад
This is great!
@1683clifton
@1683clifton 2 года назад
Stoner gave up on translator and just learned russian.
@scarakus
@scarakus 2 года назад
The secret is to just nod your head, and a short chuckle during the pauses.
@Tadhgyboy36atgmail
@Tadhgyboy36atgmail 2 года назад
Lol
@coochykilla
@coochykilla 2 года назад
Lmao
@Lukusprime
@Lukusprime 2 года назад
Really though, he corrected the translator a couple of times
@dingusthedrunkenhousecat2870
@dingusthedrunkenhousecat2870 2 года назад
"DA, comrade." - Eugene stoner (probably)
@benjaminkeepfer8968
@benjaminkeepfer8968 2 года назад
From the limited words from the translator, and what You Tube can automatically translate, it seems like Kalasnikov was really going into some detail about the major manufacturing differences in the different AK's over time. From the early Type 2 AK-47's all the way up to the AK-100 series. He mentioned the changes in top cover design, the switch from a milled receiver to a stamped one, the original gas block, and front & rear sigh blocks being milled forgings and then later switching to castings, he even mentioned for the stock arms on AKS/AKMS were originally milled, but that the one he was holding (a Type 56-1) had stamped arms with reinforcements welded on the inside, while he points to the spot welds on the stock arms. Great stuff!
@AK47avtomat
@AK47avtomat 2 года назад
He was, I speak Russian fluently and he went very into detail. Sad that the translator couldn’t do a better job because he missed a lot of key points.
@squidwardo7074
@squidwardo7074 7 месяцев назад
Tbh, I can only assume that Stoner and Kalashnikov have studied each others weapon designs for many hours, and Stoner could probably see what he was pointing at and understand it for the most part, the translation is just for us who don't
@Mustang94c
@Mustang94c 7 месяцев назад
​@squidwardo7074 he did on multiple occasions in this and the previous ones corrected the translator mikhail even laughed a little when he did 😂😂 the amount of respect they have for each other is incredible and many could learn a thing or two on humility from watching them interact
@OddBallPerformance
@OddBallPerformance 2 года назад
I love the energy between these two men. It was probably a highlight of both of their lives being able to talk weapon design with one of the few people they considered a peer and possibly admired. Kalashnikov especially became so animated and excited to discuss his design, his passion is palpable.
@RockyRanger663
@RockyRanger663 2 года назад
That translator had a very hard job to do. To be able to translate from English and to Russian is very taxing on the aspect of mental processing power. Even while being well versed in English and Russian it can still be a very daunting task to translate in such a short amount of time especially when you try to repeat multiple minutes of spoken words from memory and then translate as these weapon designers talked very passionately about their work. At 3:11 he asked Mikhail Timofeevich Kalashnikov to please slow down. Massive amount of respect to the designers and the people who made this priceless moment captured on video. The highest level of thanks to our friend the translator in translating and not giving up to give non Russian and like versa non English speaking people the ability to witness and get a glimpse of these wonderful minds.
@casey6578
@casey6578 2 года назад
finally, somebody understands
@LazzySeal
@LazzySeal 2 года назад
Any Russian who have fluent English would do a better job if he would want to. If you want to be sure the best delivery just ask both of them to speak not more than one sentence before translating. I did some real time translating English To Russian and vice versa with aviation technical terms present in it I could keep up because I've setup people who will talk in a way I can keep up with and it was no problem for me and I never graduated from any language academy, just have constant practice. The desire to do job good is what matters, even with skill that guy had it still could be better. He could have prepare and memorize at least frequently used terms like "bolt carrier" for god's sake. He either did not understand the magnitude of the meeting or just generally not sharp enough to compose himself.
@alientrader9815
@alientrader9815 2 года назад
They should have some respect for Mr. Kalashnikov and Mr. Stoner, at least bring in a better translator. R.I.P. you legends!
@oiitsme2501
@oiitsme2501 2 года назад
That's what best they had at that time.
@patrickancona1193
@patrickancona1193 2 года назад
Run what ya brung, they were good with it so suck it up buttercup
@oiitsme2501
@oiitsme2501 2 года назад
@@patrickancona1193 butter cup, chocolate cup, milk cup, water cup, tea cup or maybe coffee cup.
@user-ir2fu4cx6p
@user-ir2fu4cx6p 2 года назад
there still chance someone re-translate it.
@IBillyMaysI
@IBillyMaysI 2 года назад
Could we get Vladimir Onokoy to do a translation?
@alwolf2325
@alwolf2325 2 года назад
Giving him a chinese rifle and a lazy translator was a fine touch, indeed.
@TheKingOfJordan1
@TheKingOfJordan1 2 года назад
This whole production stinks of amateur, slapdash work.
@MPdude237
@MPdude237 2 года назад
This was filmed in 1990, prior to the collapse of the USSR and as such, Chinese and Finnish AKs were the only AK rifles that were available to the public aside from Vietnam War(BTW, NVA forces used predominantly Chinese rifles, so even amongst them Russian AKs were uncommon) Trophies. The Finnish AKs were modified so the Type 56 was closer to the Russian guns. If they didn't have a lot of money on hand, the Chinese Rifles were the only option. The Translator though, that certainly could have been better.
@Eluderatnight
@Eluderatnight 2 года назад
@@MPdude237 heard the finnish were better than soviet. Wouldnt doubt it.
@Delta92F
@Delta92F 2 года назад
I say this as someone who learned English mainly on the internet. I don't think the translator is lazy, he just doesn't know English at such a technical level. Also Kalashnikov doesn't help by "machine-gun'ing" words without giving him time to think.
@Rudyelf1
@Rudyelf1 2 года назад
@@Delta92F exactly. One thing is conversational translation. Another thing is technical translation.
@Breakfast_and_Bullets
@Breakfast_and_Bullets 2 года назад
I'm reaching out through my network to find a friend that knows fluent Russian, I'm going to get these properly translated and transcribed.
@TheFaveteLinguis
@TheFaveteLinguis 2 года назад
i will do it. give me two days.
@Breakfast_and_Bullets
@Breakfast_and_Bullets 2 года назад
@@TheFaveteLinguis Bless
@kazoolordhd6591
@kazoolordhd6591 2 года назад
@@TheFaveteLinguis I hope to see it
@dudearlo
@dudearlo 2 года назад
Me two :D
@lylesloth1275
@lylesloth1275 2 года назад
@@TheFaveteLinguis you have 35 hours left.
@John..556
@John..556 2 года назад
Seems to me like Eugene already knows exactly how that AK works and this politely listening
@lieutenantcoloneltanyavond8273
@lieutenantcoloneltanyavond8273 2 года назад
Probably. If i was him i would want to study examples of both STG and AK before starting work on my own gun.
@ColterBrog
@ColterBrog 2 года назад
Based on their positions of authority on the subject on two previously adversarial sides, I’m sure both had thoroughly examined examples of each other’s work as soon as a sample was able to be acquired by whatever means. They probably know the other guy’s rifle just as thoroughly as they know their own.
@smokeymcpot9883
@smokeymcpot9883 2 года назад
Anyone who shoots an AK once knows exactly how it works haha
@hoppinggnomethe4154
@hoppinggnomethe4154 2 года назад
I really think he should have known since some AK were brought back to the US after Vietnam War.
@princed8534
@princed8534 2 года назад
Kalashnikov joked multiple times about them both knowing inside out eachothers rifles, he even said I am sure you have dissasembled my ak many times as I have dissasembled your AR. It was a joke but knowing cold war I am sure they both had seen each others designs before and knew all there is to know about it. Sadly the intricate details and clever questions were lost because of piss poor translator. It would be amazing to hear them comment about those things, such as questions about the materials and reasoning behind some small design choices. But alas I guess we will never have that anymore. I think we all need to learn multiple languages so when next meeting of this scale happens we dont get "ahh its too complex for me to translate" any more.
@JoshuaKlein25
@JoshuaKlein25 2 года назад
Wish we had a better translator, hope some one some day does it so we can get English captions.
@xb0xisbetter
@xb0xisbetter 2 года назад
I had the same thought. Max Popenker may be our man. He is a Russian firearms historian and enthusiast. He's had various collaborations with Ian on Forgotten Weapons. If anyone can properly translate the nuance of Kalashnikov's monologue into English, he may be it.
@stefanmolnapor910
@stefanmolnapor910 2 года назад
Vladimir onokoy be perfect!
@cristianarreola8582
@cristianarreola8582 2 года назад
Even the auto-translated english captions reveal a surprising amount of details that the translator left out. I'd really like to see it properly translated.
@warrenrosen2326
@warrenrosen2326 2 года назад
Translator...speak up!
@lieutenantcoloneltanyavond8273
@lieutenantcoloneltanyavond8273 2 года назад
Translating live is not easy. I was once roped into doing it. I'm never, ever doing it again. It's completely different from translating written text, where you have all the text, context and time in the world to get things right. But yeah, i would love to see a version with translator parts cut out completely and subs. Would make for more streamlined experience.
@akm_peasant
@akm_peasant 3 года назад
So amazing to see alive two legends. Thanks for sharing this!
@AK47avtomat
@AK47avtomat 2 года назад
As a Russian speaker, the translator did a really piss poor job translating. When Mikhail starting talking about the story of how he created his rifle it’s very interesting and engaging to listen to, but the translator did a bad job translating and missed a lot of dialogue. I feel sorry for you non Russian speakers because Kalashnikov’s story is very engaging.
@ZaxCal
@ZaxCal 2 года назад
Create subtitles for us
@cognitivedisability9864
@cognitivedisability9864 2 года назад
I so much want to watch all the mikhail videos but i only understand a few words here and there, and with the translation being what it is its reallly sad. The stoner tapes were so good.
@sovietbottle-cap1649
@sovietbottle-cap1649 2 года назад
Pls translate
@terrybrown5402
@terrybrown5402 2 года назад
He did a good enough job for me to understand. I dont need every word to understand what hes talking about.
@Brevnom
@Brevnom 2 года назад
Я не понимаю, что с переводчиком. Не может быть, чтобы в СССР не нашлось адекватного переводчика не для кого-нибудь, а для света оружейного строения Михаила Калашникова. Я предполагаю, что нормальный переводчик тяжело заболел, когда делегация приехала, или что-нибудь в этом роде, потому что это просто позорно.
@garrisonnichols807
@garrisonnichols807 2 года назад
I love how Kalashnikov just takes down and shows everything and to be honest I really didn't need the translator to understand. Kalashnikov was that good a teacher! RIP to both these geniuses.
@Eluderatnight
@Eluderatnight 2 года назад
@4:15 translator: "Oh man, thats too complicated". Lol
@repsajann8199
@repsajann8199 2 года назад
These two legends are soon drinking vodka in heaven. But still on earth their masterpieces are use in good and evil.
@anamarvelo
@anamarvelo 2 года назад
Yet no way the guys who designed the weapons that murdered millions on both sides of the cold war are going to heaven
@user-hi8yx1fd3n
@user-hi8yx1fd3n 2 года назад
Два Человека - легенды!
@BEARAuthority-bf8mt
@BEARAuthority-bf8mt Год назад
@@anamarvelo What kind of twisted logic is that? Cars kill 1.3 million people annually, so does that mean the men that designed cars or founded the companies Toyota, Honda, or Ford are gonna go to hell?
@tarektechmarine8209
@tarektechmarine8209 7 месяцев назад
@@anamarvelo They definitely did more than you and will be remembered far more. These are tools, the engineers behind them are the soul put into the things we have today. Imagine thinking you're right to desrespect someone your far superior.
@releasethekraken5039
@releasethekraken5039 7 месяцев назад
The russian translator was completely hammered already
@stevenlewis6781
@stevenlewis6781 2 года назад
Two of the greatest firearm designs in history. I didn't know that these two gentlemen ever sat down and discussed their respective weapons like that. People will say that they are evil but the exact opposite is true. They are both patriots and both went a long way towards making their country's stronger and safer. The AK and the AR have their enherent strengths and weaknesses, but both have been battle tested and stood the test of time.
@chevrolet355
@chevrolet355 2 года назад
Thank you Mr Stoner and Mr Kalashnikov for building 2 of the best rifles ever made. Rip 🙏
@freedomofspeech2867
@freedomofspeech2867 2 года назад
As I Russian, I feel deep shame and disgrace that the translator failed to translate so much. Especially Mikhails story of creating the AK during the war. I can only hope to God that they got the missed parts explained to them at a later point and that they met again before they died. Just as Mr. Kalashnikov used the simple tools he had; a schools pen, paper, eraser and a lack of any prior knowledge I will use Movie Maker on my pre-2009, barely working excuse of a PC to translate this wonderful conversation, so that at least people now, both Russian and English speaking can understand these talented mens stories like they, in those moments unfortunately failed to do. [Progress: 13% of Part 1]
@carterphillips5547
@carterphillips5547 2 года назад
Link to your upload as a comment on this video, please. I'd like to see a better translation.
@freedomofspeech2867
@freedomofspeech2867 2 года назад
@@carterphillips5547 I'll reply to this comment when they're up on my channel.
@sainttrilby7171
@sainttrilby7171 2 года назад
God bless you for your work. Preserving history is paramount, if we don't wish to repeat it.
@freedomofspeech2867
@freedomofspeech2867 2 года назад
@@sainttrilby7171 Or if we do wish to repeat it. Thank you anyways.
@sainttrilby7171
@sainttrilby7171 2 года назад
@@freedomofspeech2867 lol, fair enough.
@mikeyblades1896
@mikeyblades1896 2 года назад
The pure admiration they have for each other and their designs truly shows.
@masongoodrich3183
@masongoodrich3183 2 года назад
I thought it was hilarious when Kalashnikov would thoroughly elaborate in a thick Russian accent and Soviet dialect and then look Stoner in the eyes like "you understood that, right?"
@TheBarefootedGardener
@TheBarefootedGardener 2 года назад
Exactly!
@bbainter7880
@bbainter7880 2 года назад
The translator wasn't the best. Would love somebody to edit this with subtitles.
@johnfichtner4616
@johnfichtner4616 2 года назад
A good idea, and if you cut the translator out of the videos, they wouldn't be half as long.
@smithnwesson990
@smithnwesson990 2 года назад
Amazing how people can be brought together by passions regardless of country of origin or politics. As an American I admire Russian weapon designs and the Russian people
@jensenzack9666
@jensenzack9666 3 года назад
Dude, you are amazing. Thank you so much for doing this!
@BillBraskyy
@BillBraskyy 2 года назад
I remember reading that MK was a tanker and a mechanic/engineer and combined with his height is how he was assigned into the world of tanks (he eventually became a tank commander on the T-34), although being a tanker you become a mechanic indirectly, and if you already are, well now you have a new vehicle you will learn to keep maintenance on (it's a _never ending_ up hill battle). He was known for another thing (aside from inventing the AK). He was also a writer and a highly educated man. Being a tanker myself, I really thought it was interesting that he spent so much time on tanks bc you don't read or hear a lot about many famous people in history that were tankers (aside from Elvis Presley, Bill Dauterive, and Gen. Patton). This article I was reading (not wikipedia, something else, but idr what it was/the source) said that when he was tasked with creating a new main armament for the military, the way he thought of it/went about it was with the mentality that this will be a small machine (which yeah, obvi all guns are machines, but you know what I mean) as opposed to a gun or killing device or whatever. Oh he also is into poetry.
@ReckerFidelWOLF
@ReckerFidelWOLF 2 года назад
He also was furious he was selected to design the Soviet Union a new firearm. He wanted to make farming equipment instead. His least favorite of his inventions were the AK74
@cognitivedisability9864
@cognitivedisability9864 2 года назад
@@ReckerFidelWOLF seems like a good man, he had enough of war i guess.
@jpesicka
@jpesicka 7 месяцев назад
"Someday we'll turn the swords into plows, but until then there will be a need for our work" -best quote I've ever heard.
@Appalachia_Ape
@Appalachia_Ape 2 года назад
Bro, you're a legend for posting this series.
@sumvs5992
@sumvs5992 2 года назад
I mean this in the most sincere way, but Mikhail seems like a kid here. While Eugene simply explained features, history and problems he had with the AR15, Mikhail seems really energetic in trying to physically display his point.
@Andy-sy9yl
@Andy-sy9yl 2 года назад
It's really amazing how passionate he was about his creation after all those years.
@McShaggswell
@McShaggswell Год назад
He's sharing his special onterest and got pretty excited
@kauboy9816
@kauboy9816 2 года назад
I love getting this perspective straight from Mikhail. He wanted to work on peaceful things, but was chosen to build weapons after the German invasion. His comment about beating swords into plowshares was very telling... he wants peace, but understands the need for violence in order to get there. "Si vis pacem, para bellum"
@0926001
@0926001 2 года назад
see that lenin pin? Mikhail was a revolutionary, by his work, education and ideals, ince you become versed in Marx, you understand if theres peace for some while not for other, there are still revolutions to fight.
@upinacorner9227
@upinacorner9227 2 года назад
@@0926001 i actually don't see a lenin pin. at 15:28 you can see the pin on his right breast is a soviet flag crossed with an american flag. is there another?
@0926001
@0926001 2 года назад
@@upinacorner9227 ohh very true, my bad, i thought it was 1986 XXVII Congress of the Communist Party of the Soviet Union comemoration pin , very common with soviet tecnicians and college graduates. Again ma bad
@upinacorner9227
@upinacorner9227 2 года назад
@@0926001 No worries brother
@madstan8948
@madstan8948 2 года назад
Wish we would have gotten to see their combined invention
@voler_1925
@voler_1925 2 года назад
you mean the mutant? that thing is an abomination
@roadhouse6999
@roadhouse6999 2 года назад
Have you heard of the SIG 556 SWAT?
@madstan8948
@madstan8948 2 года назад
@@voler_1925 this is why I said “their combined invention” not someone else’s
@voler_1925
@voler_1925 2 года назад
@@madstan8948 what would that be then, there are some others I guess.
@voler_1925
@voler_1925 2 года назад
@@roadhouse6999 I have, it's honestly more of its own thing than an ar15 and AK mix, it has a short stroke gas piston and not a long stroke gas piston like the ak, and although it does share the same ammo as the ar15 and have a rotating bolt, the ak does too. that's about as similar to the ar15 as it gets. Would you call an hk416 an ar AK mix?
@TheMuro22
@TheMuro22 2 года назад
Well, it looks like Stoner himself understands Kalashnikov better than the translator does...
@gregorsamsomeone1184
@gregorsamsomeone1184 2 года назад
*click CC for closed captions, go to settings, go to closed cap settings, if auto translate is there choose your language, if not click Russian, then click auto translate* The translator sitting in with them couldn't order Vodka in a Russian bar let alone translate this excited inventor. You can tell he's SOOOO Plssed at the chinese AKM lmao. Mischa keeps muttering "Chinese trash" under his breath 😅
@TheKingOfJordan1
@TheKingOfJordan1 2 года назад
Very frustrating that the "translator" simply chooses not to translate what Mr. Kalashnikov says at times.
@meee2014
@meee2014 2 года назад
no he just sucks as a translator
@scottmcdivitt2187
@scottmcdivitt2187 2 года назад
@@meee2014 ether that, or his skill with the language isn't up to the rapid-fire deluge of technical terms Kalasnakov is launching. Either way, they should have had a better translator in place for a meeting like this.
@Alex462047
@Alex462047 2 года назад
The translator couldn't keep up. I am able to understand 90% of what Mr Kalashnikov is saying, but this translator is at about 50% or less. I feel sorry for him, trying to interpret detailed technical information at this speed is a massive job. I couldn't do it.
@bodyno3158
@bodyno3158 2 года назад
@@Alex462047 You have to know both languages' technical jargon to do the job, find a Russian-English interpreter is hard enough, find a Russian-English interpreter who has engineering background and loves firearms is next to impossible, also in the era that video was filmed in, internet weren't a thing for the most of the population, nowadays they could just post it on twitter or other platform then a fuckload of Russian-English gun-nut interpreter would show up and do a excellent job, probably for free.
@user-ir2fu4cx6p
@user-ir2fu4cx6p 2 года назад
@@Alex462047 that's unprofessional from his he should stayed before the interview with Mr Kalashnikov and chat with earch other, it's ironic with these long cold war they didn't found decent translator in America ?
@pauleggington
@pauleggington 2 года назад
This is pure gold - thank for posting!
@MavHunter20XX
@MavHunter20XX 2 года назад
interesting thing about Mr Kalashnikov, he had spiritual struggle concerning his guns, causing so much death and suffering. Wish i can tell him, that he cannot control the actions of others and the government. If he hadn't made his gun, they would have just upgraded the SKS or something.
@LoadinMosin
@LoadinMosin Год назад
I like how it's a Chinese AK. If you look at the rivet pattern on the receiver, it is the triangle pattern only used by the Chinese. And a hooded front sight, also a Chinese thing.
@chitownbangin
@chitownbangin 2 года назад
I truly hope Mikhail had a good time while in the U.S.
@MOAONAABE
@MOAONAABE 2 года назад
my dad was a engine oiler on a merchant ship on the murmansk run and we had a sub mariner from the uboats that were sinking the ships, working in our local deli in the 60s. my dad introduced me to him and made sure i knew that they are soldiers and sailors, not politicians and there was only mutual respect. i did my time during the viet nam days, and our enemy, right in the threat assessment was the sino-soviets. politicians. m60 was shock and awe and almost useless on full auto. i never fired my M-16 on full auto, ever, not even at the range. i was surgical with it squeezing them off. you cant have optics that with go out of zero if you fall, or drop it, or the weather changes. and testing at the range even 2000 rounds wont be the same as that carbon build up left to rest in the high humidity and then reconstitute it with more hot vapors, its becomes goo. like the shellac the russians use to water proof the rounds, wont work on close tolerances for long. and i was taught to clear a jam by smacking the butt on a tree, didnt have no forward assist, or training wheels.
@joeminer1947
@joeminer1947 2 года назад
I love watching these videos every time. Such magnificent engineering feats by such amazing men. I will add Russian to my languages to learn so I can truly appreciate what Mr. Kalashnikov was saying. It's the only way to best watch this video.
@GunSperg
@GunSperg 6 месяцев назад
It’s very frustrating that whoever set up this once in a lifetime very historical meeting seems to have either not shown the proper respect to Mr. kalashnikov by not supplying him with a proper translator and Russian built rifle or they bit off more than they could chew. Nevertheless I’m very thankful for this content, more than I can put in to words. Mikhail Kalashnikov invented my favorite rifle of all time and I’m blessed enough to own a few, the collection will continue until my last day I suspect. God bless Eugene Stoner & Mikhail Kalashnikov, their legacies will forever live on, their work still influences history even today and will continue to into the foreseeable future.
@RomanCatholic001
@RomanCatholic001 2 года назад
Bruh, this translator is sleeping on the job...
@CertifiedSunset
@CertifiedSunset 2 года назад
Bruh, you clearly don't know anything about how live translation is like. Russian doesn't have a 1:1 translation to English.
@RomanCatholic001
@RomanCatholic001 2 года назад
@@CertifiedSunset it might not have a 1:1 translation but there's plenty of times shit is said and he just remains quiet.
@jspirmann
@jspirmann 2 года назад
@@RomanCatholic001 It's impossible to translate when the person you are trying to translate for keeps talking over you. Imagine trying to just keep a straight thought, let alone translate into another language. It was said that one of the translators for Muammar Gaddafi actually fainted during a speech because of how hard translating is.
@astragreen
@astragreen 8 месяцев назад
The translation guy is ok he is doing his best because the old guy is nervous and in panic mode and it’s super hot that doesn’t help the old guy is wanting another drink, he looks like he’s had quite a lot last night, gene is ok with everything so that’s ok isn’t it
@daviddiffenderfer6963
@daviddiffenderfer6963 2 года назад
The two best arms men r gone now im glad this is up on here still thanks.
@bhoward9378
@bhoward9378 Год назад
Thank you for these Stoner/Kalashnikov videos!
@dustingrohman7487
@dustingrohman7487 2 года назад
Imagine standing in front of the man who designed the rifle and attempting to put the heat shield/hand guard on incorrectly.
@notsam9528
@notsam9528 2 года назад
Anyone who knows russian, please make a full translation and add the subtitles. You'll be a hero of all mankind.
@somebb
@somebb 7 месяцев назад
youtube does it
@calebsone1630
@calebsone1630 2 года назад
You can see him getting frustrated at the fact that he finally has somebody who can understand what he is built and there's a language barrier between the two of them
@jimburnsjr.
@jimburnsjr. 6 месяцев назад
What an incredibly beautiful day, to see two historic icons side by side talking of their work.
@actually_a_circle
@actually_a_circle 2 года назад
MK: the translator just mumbled 3 words in english... he's probably done. "Пдлщшыимбячждзщхцйуадвдвлтвьалажыдвьаьаьадабмьвдудьудаьпьпдаьвьалптададпщадыьж да ад" Translator: "uhh..." MK: ...done. *inhales* "Фывпрджжузызфдвтатвдсдвьвжсьс..."
@johnnyjoestar2391
@johnnyjoestar2391 2 года назад
О да моё любимое ошалдщцьузажьащьпьпщплпщп А ещё в России любят шаталузыудтузыьвщвщувлоу
@shootem5568
@shootem5568 2 года назад
Thanks for posting these. Really great videos.
@lukevanordstrand4997
@lukevanordstrand4997 2 года назад
I love both Eugene Stoner and Mikhail Kalashnikov
@douglasturner6153
@douglasturner6153 2 года назад
I wish we could get a full transcript of Kalashnikovs comments. He was very passionate about his work. Translation not very good.
@Yiots
@Yiots 2 года назад
Kalashnikov: I consider it is not an offensive weapon but a defensive weapon. Straight from the man himself... the gun-grabbers have no idea.
@sygos
@sygos 2 года назад
4:17 me when i get a new job
@RsTesters
@RsTesters 2 года назад
I speak russian and ukrainian and the amount of missing information that the translator missed is bad.
@felixraithel9055
@felixraithel9055 2 года назад
So nice to see both legendary rifle designers talking about their rifles. Absolut treasure!
@thebestian
@thebestian 2 года назад
brandon hererra needs to see this if he hasn't already.
@BrandonHerrera
@BrandonHerrera 2 года назад
Oh trust me, I’m here watching 😂
@fishinforfun3359
@fishinforfun3359 2 года назад
@@BrandonHerrera I have to say it. Let’s go Brandon.
@Breakfast_and_Bullets
@Breakfast_and_Bullets 2 года назад
@@BrandonHerrera Bro. It makes me so happy that you're here watching within hours of me.
@Matthew-np9fk
@Matthew-np9fk 2 года назад
@@BrandonHerrera let’s go Brandon!
@bamesjond7495
@bamesjond7495 2 года назад
@@BrandonHerrera There you are! Kinda sad that the translator isn't the best. I will hand it to you, I have gotten 99% of my AK knowledge from your videos which makes watching this video even better. I'm not sure what the analytics are for your deep dive history videos, but they were def my favorite ones as well as the whiteboard of knowledge.
@Tobashadow
@Tobashadow 2 года назад
18:58 assemble a AK wrong in front of the master lol
@SpartanB88
@SpartanB88 2 года назад
I wish they’d put subtitles and just cut the translator out
@diplexnormal3353
@diplexnormal3353 4 месяца назад
The part that bugs me about the debate (not just talking this video) between which firearm is more sophisticated when disassembling or reassembling, But the AR15/M16 isn’t that bad. If anything, there are parts of the M16 that you *dont* have to bother disassembling because they don’t take much fouling at all. With the AK47, the amount of necessary parts that you need to remove is the dust cover, recoil spring, bolt carrier, bolt and gas tube. With the M16, the amount of necessary parts that you need to remove is the Bolt carrier, charging handle, Firing pin retainer, firing pin, Bolt retainer, bolt and *maybe* the buffertube/recoil spring if it’s that bad (I’m not gonna count them separately, they’re not easy to pull apart and it’s hardly ever necessary to disassemble it anyway). The point that I’m getting at is that the amount of parts for disassembly are similar and the only argument that people have (AK47 fangirls obviously) against the M16 is that some of the parts for disassembly are significantly smaller and hard to find if lost, but I would argue that a man shouldn’t field strip his weapon and place parts willy nilly in the first place. Just so we’re clear, I own both a Colt AR15 and a M70 AK and love them both, I bought the M70 recently and unfortunately for over a thousand dollars, which should show my dedication and respect to the rifle on its own but I know that people aren’t gonna listen to that. I see the AK47 as what it is and nothing more, a crucial chapter in firearms technology and we all know that any military weapon can’t be cutting edge or best the winner forever, something has to give and something is going to incentivize things to change. I know that one day, my AR will one day be looked at as piece of history or as a vintage weapon rather than a modern one because that’s just how the cookie crumbles which I don’t mind at all. Nobody’s a winner in this argument because to be honest, both weapons are starting to be looked at as pieces of history rather than being new or cutting edge. For Christ sake, even the M16A4 was replaced in the Marine’s for reasons that I can’t understand till this day but again, it was bound to happen sooner or later because standards change even when they’re strange.
@BobyourUncle
@BobyourUncle 7 месяцев назад
The saddest part of this entire clip is the thought that of what these two great nations might have achieved had they combined their creativity in the pursuit of a better world :(
@shades2.183
@shades2.183 6 месяцев назад
Russia and communism has nothing to contribute with to the free world, you would know if you had did your research.
@javel114
@javel114 12 дней назад
This is actually very interresting. My countrys defence forces have its own AK variant, inside is exactly the same, just some production differences in looks and the rear sight is on the back plate. I understand Kalashnikovs explenation just by looking and some simularities in techical speach!
@moonasha
@moonasha 2 года назад
oh man I feel bad for that translator, because Mikhail is just in the zone describing everything, the translator has no time to really translate. Plus gun speak between the two languages is hard to translate. я умею понимать немного русских языка, но тут михал говорил очень быстро и использовал много редких слов я ещё не знаю. Если бы кто-то мог добавить субтитры на этом видео, будет отлично!
@celmer6
@celmer6 2 года назад
Translation directly from Mr. Kalashnikov "Fucking Norinco"!
@perfectblue9038
@perfectblue9038 2 года назад
Lol they translator said this is too complicated for me to say.
@holeeshi9959
@holeeshi9959 Год назад
the really cool part is Stoner and Kalashnikov kind of get the firearm technologies before the translator comes up with the words. I do understand and translators will struggle with technical languages used, especially without google and modern techs, but the gun designers really figured out the terms themselves
@mitchellgaston2043
@mitchellgaston2043 7 месяцев назад
I love how passionate kalashnikov is about his design, didn’t care if the translator could keep up lmao
@sik59rt
@sik59rt 2 года назад
i wish i knew what he was really saying and im sure Stoner did too
@goddepersonno3782
@goddepersonno3782 24 дня назад
while he was quite optimistic, as many Russians were before the horrible financial meltdown in Russia during the 90s, I was still touched by Mikhail Kalashnikov's words at the end there. He clearly isn't a man who simply became an arms designer because it was cool or for the money - it was a morally weighed decision. His desire to see a more peaceful and positive use for the AK is a good one, and I hope that Kalashnikov has made much progress in this pursuit since 1990.
@drewsirry9118
@drewsirry9118 7 месяцев назад
How can the two most notorious weapon designers who enabled so many conflicts and deaths through their design provide such a wholesome conversation
@stevejenkins9984
@stevejenkins9984 Год назад
Great videos love the interviews
@trxcummins7388
@trxcummins7388 6 месяцев назад
It's 2024 can we please get someone to translate Mr Kalashnikov in better english?... I am dying to understand every word he said because he seems super passionate.
@prosto_bog
@prosto_bog 2 месяца назад
Почитав комменты, я рад, что много англоязычных ребят, смогли перевести текст на английский лучше чем переводчик на видео. Т.к переводчик упускает самое интересное, а именно его мелкие детали в речи, которые показывают насколько добрый Калашников и причину по которой он решил создать оружие. Передает его опыт жизни и т д.
@Erreul
@Erreul 2 года назад
This is pretty excellent but I wish these two could have communicated a little better, it actually seems to me Mr. Kalashnikov wanted to legitimately have a real conversation with Stoner.
@gaijinblow
@gaijinblow 2 года назад
Ha should have done a collab rifle. Would be legendary.
@rayramirez8776
@rayramirez8776 2 года назад
❤️ both 👏
@willrumbold8050
@willrumbold8050 7 месяцев назад
The ak used in the video a chinese AKS, the commercial export version of the type 56-1, the plastic furniture means it was probably imported by Clayco
@brienmauer8134
@brienmauer8134 2 года назад
Very educational and entertaining! Now bring on Paul Maurer and JM Browning!
@brienmauer8134
@brienmauer8134 2 года назад
*MAUSER*!! useless spellchek😣
@darek4488
@darek4488 2 года назад
Was it really that difficult to get a real Russian AK in the 90's or at least a version from Yugoslavia, Bulgaria, Poland, Romania? Was a Chinese clone really the best they could got?
@andreymalone9631
@andreymalone9631 2 года назад
I'm really glad that I speak Russian and English so this gem of a video is just amazing to see. But I do feel bad for Eugene stoner but them again the two men know both guns inside and out .
@moldovanpotato
@moldovanpotato 6 месяцев назад
Guys don’t blame the translator, Kalashnikov speaks fast and in a lot of specific gun terms, it seems the translator simply doesn’t know them in English, from around the 19 minute mark he also tells Kalashnikov something about disassembling the gun "…like in the army" so I assume he does know the parts (at least in the ak) just not how to translate them well and quickly
@user-ko2gg9eh4p
@user-ko2gg9eh4p 2 года назад
6:20 "деталюшки"))))))
@CAKEwasTRUE
@CAKEwasTRUE 7 месяцев назад
Eugene didn't speak Russian, Mikhail didn't speak English, But they both spoke gun so they understood each other.
@Im_TheSaint
@Im_TheSaint 2 года назад
Translator of the year.
@walker6296
@walker6296 2 года назад
Perhaps someone fluent in Russian and familiar with AKs could properly translate everything Mikhail says. Max Popenker or Anastasia Gorbunova?
@robertchalk8884
@robertchalk8884 2 года назад
2:12 either he had thumbs that could kill or that gas tube retainer removed itself because it knew who was touching it. I always have to use the cleaning kit to pry that damn thing open
@wastelander89
@wastelander89 6 месяцев назад
Thank u for translation
@richardhamilton2344
@richardhamilton2344 2 года назад
ушла эпоха, ушли люди, остались только черти, значит заслужили
@jimmymcjimmyvich9052
@jimmymcjimmyvich9052 2 года назад
It's like the Aliens landed and met up with some disinterested people instead of the learned folk that were supposed to be there to get all we needed to know from them before departure.
@McGovern1981
@McGovern1981 Месяц назад
I highly doubt this is the first time either of them have seen these rifles and thought about them.
@AA-or4dt
@AA-or4dt 6 месяцев назад
After watching this I am now confident I too can have a career as a translator :)
@Manaritzis88
@Manaritzis88 7 месяцев назад
Very nice, thank you!
@qui-gonjinn3322
@qui-gonjinn3322 Год назад
Feels good to be fluent in Russian and English at the same time.
@ComfortsSpecter
@ComfortsSpecter Месяц назад
Such Immensely Incredibly Humanistic History Amazing Wonderful event Two of the Greatest Engineers in Modern Small Arms History Just Vibing in 1990 Virginia, America Nerdily explaining Gun Trivia to Eachother The Freedom Of Man Know’s No Bounds The Comfort Of Man Know’s No Bounds
@ajsnell6256
@ajsnell6256 7 месяцев назад
Dude, if I was Kalashnikov and I ended with a question like that, just for everything to be cut off I would have been PISSED
@Yetified_Mayhem
@Yetified_Mayhem 7 месяцев назад
Vodkas on the house! What a special treat!
Далее
The Eugene Stoner Tapes - Part 1: Designing the AR-15
1:02:42
Gun Builder Reacts to Red Dawn (1984)
11:41
Просмотров 858 тыс.
The Kalashnikov Tapes - Part 1: Life Before the AK
46:36
QA 32
50:24
Просмотров 32 тыс.
How did Ukraine Attack Russia? Kursk
10:41
Просмотров 179 тыс.
Does Russia’s Newest Combat Rifle Kinda Suck?
18:02