I mean he does have some valid points on it but I wouldn't go as far to say that was "painfully mediocre" I thought it was an okay/solid show, but I do agree that it started off pretty rough and ended strong, and they should've answered some of the loose ends we have left
@@vetzmoviesno. It was about how Solider’s go on after that the war they’ve been bred to fight for ends. Hunters Journey is becoming a farther and settling down with Wrecker, Echo’s story is not being able to stop fighting for his brothers, Crosshairs is about misplaced loyalty and redemption and Tech’s was ultimate sacrifice. You clearly didn’t understand what it was about. As a former marine this show really hit home
My list. 9. Kenobi. This series completely disappointed me episode after episode. From Reva’s terrible character arc, to the grand inquisitor being stabbed, to kid Leia, I hated a lot about this series. The stuff between kenobi and vader is good but the rest of the show diminishes the quality so much. 8. BOBF. While yes it’s bad, it didn’t offend me as much as Kenobi did. 7. Ahsoka. I just wanna clarify that I actually really enjoyed this show and there’s a huge gap between this and BOBF. I thought this show had a lot of great stuff to offer but there’s definitely certain things in the series holding it back from being better than these other entries. 6. TOTJ. While an amazing entry, it is rather short. And therefore its runtime holds it back from being better than these other shows. 5. Mando. Yes this is decisive but S3 really brought this show down for me. Season 1 was incredible and standing alone would be up there with Andor. HOWEVER S2 was good but just didn’t live up to the expectations that S1 put out. Not to mention the finale of S2 which was amazing was completely undermined by Mando S2.5 in the BOBF. S3 was just bad. It shows that the writing really fell off in the series and what had once been great had fallen. Now don’t get me wrong I still think this show is great overall I just prefer the ones ranked above it. 4. Bad Batch. Yes ik this also decisive, but I really thought season 1 and 2 were good minus a couple filler episodes but none of the filler episodes bothered me aside from S2 E5. I thought the Bad Batch crew had such a good dynamic and you can really feel the loss of Tech in season 3. I know a lot of people got annoyed by Omega but I was never bothered by her I thought she was a good character. I definitely have to mention Crosshair as he is my favorite clone and has some of the best character development in all of Star Wars. I like that each member got to shine and I thought that there was some fantastic episodes in this series. 3. Star Wars Rebels. It might be decisive putting it this high, but I think this show has some of the best characters Star Wars has to offer. Not only does the ghost crew have an incredible dynamic that grows every season, the show also offers some fantastic antagonists. (The Grand Inquisitor, Kallus and Thrawn Ofc.) Yes it does have some childish episodes early on but you can really see the writing shine in some of the earlier episodes as well. I thought Each character had satisfying character arcs and I’m glad we got to see some of them return in Ahsoka. 2. Andor. Probably the most consistent and best written live action show. Completely outstanding in every department from acting to cinematography to action to writing to pacing everything was near perfect. 1. The Clone Wars. The clear winner here, just so many incredible and emotional arcs and some of the best storytelling Star Wars has to offer.
Forget top three I’m gonna tell you all of em 9. Boba fett It sucked. The mods were cringe, the action was clunky, the acting was mid, and ruining one of the most bad ass bounty hunters was awful. 8. Ahsoka Sabine wren having the force kind of ruins how special that ability is. You can’t just teach someone the force. Also Rosario Dawson doesn’t feel right as ahsoka. Hera bringing her son on a mission is absolute bullshit 7. Kenobi The leia chase scene is hilariously bad, and they kill so many people just to bring em back. But the scenes between obi wan and Vader were great. Now to the ones I like. 6. Rebels. I know I’m putting it low, but it just doesn’t have the clone wars animation, and there is lots of filler. Later seasons are good tho. 5 Bad batch I love the characters besides omega, and the story is really good when it’s not filler. Even if you don’t like it, you must admit that the first episode was a masterpiece. 4. Tales of the Jedi Loved the dooku eps and I guess the ahsoka ones to, but we’ve had so much ahsoka recently that I wish we had someone else, like syfo dias( forgot how to spell it). Great animation 3. Mando It would be two or possibly one if not for season three. I agree with what Vetz said. 2. Andor Slow but solid. Good story and character development. I appreciated how they weren’t afraid to kill of people. I liked it a lot except for the fact that Disney forced a lesbian couple in there. 1. TCW You already know
I like the list but I do think rebels should be higher, it is way more impactful than most other series and season 2, 3 and 4 are really strong especially the end. I agree animation is poor and also goofy humor but I think its better than bad batch.
@@michaelhead5582 Yea very fair tho, I like how you argue and I appreciate star wars fans who actually value good story telling and not blind nostalgia. Atleast there are some of us left.
Here's my ranking 9. Star Wars Rebels I tried to watch this show but it just wasn't great. 8.Tales of the Jedi I am only two episodes in I have not finished all t yet but its decent. 7.Obi wan Kenobi I mean it was okay, Darth Vader and Obi wan Kenobi were good but the show wasn't great. 6.Bad Batch I agree it was pretty mediocre but it had a couple really good episodes. 5. Book of Boba Fett This show just did Boba dirty. I only liked the Mandalorian episodes. 4.Ashoka I think this one was pretty good. The characters were good the plot was decent. 3.Star wars clone wars It feels weird to have this show in third place but I loved how it. Season 1 wasn't great but the next 6 seasons were epic! 2. Andor This show was a masterpiece the writing, action it was incredible. 1. The mandalorian I love seasons 1 and 2 so much. The plot is great. Season 3 was okay.
Good list, I’d recommend watching some of the higher rated episodes of season 1 of rebels to see if you like those. Cause the first couple episodes of the show are pretty terrible but it gets good
I’d recommend trying to look up some stuff on what the best episodes of rebels are to watch to understand the plot. S3 and S4 are probably some of the best Star Wars you’ll find and S1 and S2 also have some great moments. The show sadly has a lot of filler in season 1 and 2 but like I said if you google some stuff on what is actually important to watch I think you’ll find the show more enjoyable.
First off i completely agree with what you said about Kenobi i think it’s over hated Secondly how dare you say mandalorian and bad batch are mediocre And thirdly Book of Boba fett had some great scenes , and Kenobi is over hated
Thought this was a Disney Star Wars-only list at first so I was confused, Clone Wars as a whole at #1 makes sense but imo it wouldn’t in a Disney Star Wars list since they only did Season 7 where the last four episodes were amazing but the rest were mid.
My ranking: 9. Book of Boba Fett 8. Kenobi 7. Ahsoka 6. Andor 5. Tales of the Jedi 4. Mandalorian 3. Bad Batch (explanation: I really liked characters in this show and although a lot of episodes were fillers I still did enjoy it especially ending of season 2 and whole season 3) 2. Rebels 1. Clone Wars
My ranking 9. Obi Wan Kenobi(This show is mostly bad but it does have some really great moments) 8. The Mandalorian Season 2.5 I mean Book Of Boba Fett(the only two really good episodes were the Mandalorian ones) 7. Ahsoka(Had some mid episodes, had some good ones) 6. Andor(I didn't want this but I still enjoyed it) 5. The Bad Batch(I mostly enjoyed it) 4. Tales Of The Jedi(Loved every episode) 3. The Mandalorian(Season 3 was ok, Season 1 and 2 were amazing) 2. Rebels(Ok I am gonna get hate for puting this so high but Idc, I enjoyed it a lot) 1. The Clone Wars(No explaination needed.)
9. Book of Boba Fett, show was mid nothing else to say but it sucked 8. Kenobi, disappointing, too much filler for a 6 episode series 7. Andor, kinda boring and couldn’t get into it. 6. Ahsoka, Loved Anakin vs Ahsoka, Rosario Dawson made Ahsoka look like trash in every duel. 5. Tales (might be higher after Empire) 4. Bad Batch, loved watching it over the past 3 years, season 1 has great moments but a lot of filler, season 2 was great, season 3 was amazing. The Outpost is the Best animated Star Wars episode of all time. 3. Clone Wars, Highest of highs and lowest of lows, makes the villains actually look strong, love how they make clones individuals, built character into a lot of the characters that were just there in the prequels. 2. Mandalorian, season 1 and 2 was the best live action Star Wars content we’ve gotten. Season 3 did not happen. 1. Rebels, Grew up with this show, Ezra Maul and Kanan really stood out, Ahsoka is op, Inquisitors we’re cool then they all died, first time we really saw Vader just be a menace.
12. Young Jedi Adventures 11. Resistance 10. BOBF 9. Kenobi 8. TOTE 7. TOTJ 6. Mandalorian (sorry but that’s how I’m feeling. S3 let me down so much) 5. Ahsoka 4. Bad Batch 3. Rebels 2. Clone Wars 1. Andor (the writing and the storylines kept me way too involved into this show especially the Mon Mothma scenes. Such a bigger masterpiece than Clone Wars and we are still getting a second season.)
For me it’s: Clone Wars - I just hate anthalogy, it’s just me. Obi-Wan Kenobi - mediocre. Ahsoka - nice. Bobf - I really enjoyed it. Mando and Andor - peak LA Star Wars. Bad Batch - Peak Star Wars. I haven’t watched rest yet.
My ranking: 1. THE CLONE WARS 2. REBELS 3. ANDOR 4. THE MANDALORIAN 5. TALES OF THE JEDI 6. THE BAD BATCH 7. AHSOKA 8. OBI-WAN KENOBI 9. THE BOOK OF BOBA FETT
My ranking 1.Clone wars 2.Mandalorian 3.Rebels 4.Tales of the Jedi 5.Bad Batch 6.Kenobi 7.Ahsoka 8.Book of boba Fett 9.Andor I’m really glad everyone loved Andor but it just didn’t really click with me to be honest, maybe season 2 will win me over
My Ranking: 10.Andor 2/10 (I cant get into it, please dont hate me) 9.Book of Boba Fett 3/10 (complete mess) 8.Visions 5/10(Some great episodes but also painfully mid at some points) 7.KenobI 6/10(Bad execution but has some good moments) 6.Bad Batch 7/10(Has my favorite moment in star wars when crosshair kills nolan, but 60% of the show is filler) 5.Ahsoka 7.5/10(Underrated but too slow at times) 4.Tales of Jedi 8/10(Peak Star Wars but I need more of it) 3.Mando 8.5(Love first 2 seasons but 3rd season is pure garbage) 2.Rebels 9/10 (Great follow up to clone wars, gets better as it progresses.) 1.Clone Wars 10/10(No explanation needed)
@@DarthEqualizer bro either you didn’t pay attention to anything or you’re 5 years old because although it’s not the most traditional Star Wars show the characters are great the show is suspenseful and the worlds are great looking
I dont get what people think is so good about andor? It definitely doesnt beat rebels and mando, the story, lore and characters made it perfect while andor was bland as hell and everyone in it was mid
Character drama, meticulous worldbuilding, political intrigue... it's not for everyone, but it makes for a more complex and nuanced experience than any other Star Wars to me. You got to see a lot different perspectives from the little people of the Galaxy and the inner workings of the world. You'd probably find shows like The Sopranos or Game of Thrones to be boring too.
This is my beef with andor. People say they love it “because it dove deeper into stuff, it was more R.” That’s not what Star Wars was created for. It was created for a fun galaxy, with good characters, and good fights. My list is: 9 kenobi 8 book of (everyone but) boba fett 7 andor 6 the bad batch 5 ahsoka 4 tales of the Jedi 3 rebels 2 the mandalorian 1 the clone wars
“A special effect is a tool, a means of telling a story. People have a tendency to confuse them as an end to themselves. A special effect without a story is a pretty boring thing.” - George Lucas
My list for shows that I’ve watched 8:bobf(was basically just mandolorian and others featuring boba fett and they wasted cad bane) 7:kenobi(would have been 8th if not for the Vader and kenobi scenes,reva sucked) 6:rebels(not a bad show but not that great either the returning characters were great though) 5:andor(thought it was good but not amazing) 4:totj(I liked the Ashoka stuff but the dooku episodes were great) 3:bad batch(started off kinda weak but ended amazing I liked the bad batch crew and the other clones arcs) 2:mandolorian(first two seasons are great season 3 not as much but still great) 1:clone wars(remarkable simply remarkable)
