Everything Wrong With Wish In 19 Minutes Or Less 

The fact there was NO SIN for the disaster of a line that is "I'm a star, look out world here I are." is a crime against humanity

“ChatGPT, write me a Disney movie.” This whole movie is exactly what you get.

Take Mother Gothel. She is initially deceitful but not outright evil until the end of the movie. But her transition from mean to murderer is believable because she had BEEN evil (kidnapping Rapunzel). But Magnífico never showed any signs of evilness so his transition feels forced

4:16 This scene made me laugh because she's like "I have no parents :( " And he basically responds with "Every single person I knew from my childhood including my family is dead :/ " And we're supposed to feel sorry for Asha while thinking the king is supposed to be evil.

The worst part about this movie is that the concept art tells the story of what could have been a MUCH better movie

Imagine being the biggest entertainment company for 100 years, and for your big anniversary movie, you get upstaged by a funny Adam Sandler movie.

Ahh Magnifico… the first Disney villain to prove how evil he is by fighting to keep his people safe and happy. Doing nothing to them they weren’t completely willing to do and that they understood in its entirety…. Wait… which character was the villain again?

"Wish" is one of those rare Disney films where the Villain wins instead of the Hero. When you think about it, Asha is the TRUE villain of this film, because King Magnifico has a really good point about how it's dangerous when everyone's wishes are granted.

I love that Magnifico is treated as unreasonable for saying that the granddad's wish of wanting to write songs could be dangerous Then at the end, he's defeated by a song, proving he was 100% right.

the movie that said “what if every single character had no development at all”

This movie deserves an extra 5,000 sins just for Asha’s magic wand. After preaching the whole movie that people should make their dreams come true themselves, and that the king was evil for deciding which wishes would get granted, she has the gall to accept a magic wand and take on the role of the kingdom’s fairy godmother. Basically, it’s evil if Magnifico is doing it, but it’s totally fine if she herself is doing it. Asha is a lying piece of ****.

5:32 - I love how everybody.... EVERYBODY... immediately thought of this as soon as they saw the first trailer. "But... not everyone CAN have their wish granted, if only because of simple wish economics." NOBODY thought it was fair to label Magnifico the villain for just being practical with his wish-granting. lol

A missed sin in the villain song was the line "I let you live here for free and I don't even charge you rent". Bro, is literally the same thing

Disney: We promise to give you an old fashioned villain. Also Disney: Gives “villain” reasonable backstory, logical mindset, and then forces him to be evil. Classic Disney 😒

"My Saba is good" girl the king barely knows you or your grandpa! You barely finished the interview and already asked him to change the fabric of reality because the earth spun around the sun one more time since your saba was born.

3:47 Bro I agree. When Belle got her library from the beast at least you got a sweeping shot at how BIG it was and knowing how much Belle loved reading it had a personal connection to it. 4:03 wow as an artist that's insulting

Villager 1: I wish Villager 2's wish not to be granted. Villager 2: I wish Villager 1's wish to be granted. Deal with that, Asha.

If only the Disney executives just simply leave the filmmakers alone, we would've gotten Starboy and Disney's first (feature animated) villain couple.

I believe Starkid said it best in their brilliant piece Twisted: "If you're good and you're attractive, no need to be proactive! Good things will just happen to you!"

My wife and kids dragged me to this movie. As soon as she learned the truth that many wishes would NEVER be granted, including her grandpa's, I immediately turned to my wife and said that if this wasn't a Disney movie, the right decision would be for the King to end her right there and make up some excuse about her "accidental" death before she becomes a problem. But no! He just let's her walk free with dangerous insider knowledge.

I took my kids to the theater to see this movie. I hated how the villain was The hero and the hero was the villain. My kids hated that everything in the film was just an Easter egg. When the four year old can find your plot holes you got a problem

King Magnifico: *refuses to grant wishes that could have consequences and had to be careful with them* Asha: "And I took that personally."

Only 19 minutes? Dude the entire movie's a sin. But thanks for calling out the fact that the King literally has a point by not granting everyone their wish!

Also,5:45 This is exactly why I thought Asha's plan wouldn't work: plenty of people would be upset that their wish wouldn't be granted and that resentment would build after seeing certain wishes be granted instead of theirs. Therefore a rebellion would happen, possibly destroying Rosas Ya can disagree with King Magnifico all you want,but his methods have worked for years,if not decades.

After watching this movie I told myself “Man, Cinemasins is gonna have a field day with this movie.” Looks like I was right.

I think the worst part for me was how Asha being the main character was the one to get everyone chanting in hailing the queen when the queen herself basically sat on her butt for most of the movie except for complaining about her husband...

"this Scene doesn't contain an" *AH FUCK I DON'T WANNA DIE!!* Killed me

You forgot to mention that in the credits they didn’t even put ALL WDAS properties in it as Rescuers, Black Cauldron & Meet The Robinsons weren’t included in the credits

It's quite hilarious that Disney cancelled Nimona, a 20th Century/Blue Sky movie during production, got picked by Netflix with Disney now releasing Wish as their 100th anniversary event and ended up being Nimona recieving way more acclaim including an Oscar nomination for Best Animated Feature than Wish 😂

Video should have been “this movie exists” and then 1000 sins added

You know, both Magnifico and Amaya were meant to be an evil power couple? If Disney had gone through with this idea than this probably would have been a better movie! Seriously, imagine how great of a twist would have it been if Amaya was the true villain! I think it would have been cool to reveal that she was the great evil that destroyed Magnifico's home and slowly manipulated him to open up the book to become corrupted cause maybe for some reason she lost the ability to open the book and that's why she needs Magnifico to open it instead. I mean through out the whole movie her personality felt too nice and boring to me so I was expecting her to be the twist villain. Many plot holes could have been fixed with her as the villain like the roof having an opening. She could have installed that herself as part of the spell she needed Magnifico to use the wishes on. If this movie was supposed to be dedicated to the 100 years of Disney than Amaya would have been the perfect villain to honor that cause she would honor the modern twist villains but also honor the truly evil ones cause she would had never loved her husband! She would have just wanted power! The fact that I can rewrite just ONE character and have that fix so much of this movies problems, just shows how lazy the writing really was!

C'mon, nobody just wakes up and decides to be evil. Magnifico: "Hold my cookie..."

"Oh, I see they're not even going to attempt democracy." Took me out 😂

Disney after receiving negative reviews the previous few years: “This is the thanks i get”?!

17:14 Are they trying to imply that he was sucked into the staff and now exists as the mirror from Snow White? Pause it and advance one frame at a time.

1:18 Yeah, yeah movie. His LOYAL wife...you know? the one who turns on him in an INSTANT. Also ironically, the tagline on the poster for this movie was "Be careful what you wish for" LMAO What I find hilarious is that Asha, we can assume was BORN in this kingdom and had absolutely no issue with how things were done until it indirectly effected her personal life. Disney made a movie about a protester and anarchist.

"I pay and pay and pay and pay, you'd think they'd be more competent...and THIS IS THE MOVIE I GET?"

Not only does Asha ask for her grandfather’s wish to be granted BEFORE she even gets the job, but would she have even cared if she hadn’t found his wish? Would any of this have happened if she saw some random person’s wish? Nepotism.

6:44 This song is probably better than any song in this dumpster of an anniversary movie. Let just point out that this is what we get for Disney's 100th anniversary movie...

Imagine if they'd run with the idea that the protag is assumed good and turns out to be the evil one so the viewer feels betrayed and starts to side with the antagonist

"A Star Is Bored" I'm sure Honest Trailers will thank you for the assist

10:20, actually, it’s established that he normally grants one wish a month so it would actually would be higher than normal

I find it funny that Asha’s whole plan to steal the wishes was to lure Magnifico far enough away so that he couldn’t get back in time to stop them. But, after it is revealed that Magnifico didn’t fall for her trick Asha steals his horse and makes it back to the kingdom in time to try and stop Magnifico. So, In this way, Asha proves that her own plan wouldn’t have worked even if Magnifico had in fact taken the bait. Because if Asha can get back to the kingdom that fast on Magnifico’s horse, than as an all powerful sorcerer Magnifico would have had no trouble getting back to the kingdom quickly. I’ll say that again. This actually happens in the movie. She proves that her own plan wouldn’t have worked!

Behold. The ONLY CinemaSins Video that everyone will agree with. Mostly because Disney literally wrote themselves into a corner with this one.

The real problem with this movie: someone should’ve told Disney “There’s celebrating your centennial and there’s advertising your worst movies.” They did the latter

16:02 [missed audio outtake]: "It doesn't matter. You're too late..." "A wizard is never late ... nor is he early..."

7:00 when y’all dropping a parody album because you just rocked that 🎉

I have to say that as a biracial person, I was so excited when I saw the trailer. When I was little, I desperately wanted a Disney Princess that looked like me, so when I saw the trailer and realized she was biracial, I was nearly in tears. I finally had my biracial “Disney Princess.” But then I saw the movie, and I cannot express how much my heart broke. I finally got that representation my child self dreamed of, but it was delivered to me in a broken package. Seeing the concept art felt like a slap in the face for good measure. It could’ve been so good.

I disagree with one sin: "this goat is a dick and a liability". He is, but that means he's a very realistic goat, and I appreciate that.

I feel like we need an extended edition to properly sin this movie 😂 What about the fact they sing a full-blown romantic love song to the wishes? The bunny says the answers to Asha’s questions are simple - and then they sing a whole song that doesn’t answer anything. Actually all the songs need more sins. And we need a bonus round for every time they say “wish.” XD

Notice how everything that happens is slapped on the screen, dead-center? It looks like a cooking show.

“I hope one of these bubbles has Planes in it.” I hope Jeremy’s sense of humor never changes. 😂

It's really the fact that Trolls Band Together is more well recieved than Disney's Wish (a movie that was supposed to be celebrating Disney's 100th year anniversary that's failed miserably) and the songs in Trolls Band Together are way better than Wish despite the fact that most of it were cover songs is hilarious to me 😂😂

Nowadays everyone is worried about AI ruining art. This movie is what you get when a focus group writes a script. That's what people should be worried about. No passion, no vision, nothing offensive.

1:03 LOL! As a DnD fanatic myself, this very thing irked me and I was like, "Wouldn't it be nice if CS mentioned this in their video?" Thankyou for granting my Wish!!! (Pun very much intended)

4:43 Her deepest desire was to fly? That's the wish from her heart? The only thing she wanted in life? I wonder why he doesn't think it's important to grant everyone's wish...

13:21 Considering he’s studied magic for so long, it would make sense for him to have read about a magical island full of fairies and hand craving crocodiles

This movie smells like a sloppy rewrite. It sure seems like they intended to make Magnifico a sympathetic villain by giving him more backstory and motivation. But that probably tested poorly. It sure seems like they were hinting his village was destroyed by magic related to wishes. Like you could split the interview scene into two parts. End after Magnifico's good guy song about protecting wishes and end wish him giving Asha the apprenticeship. Skip forward time to Asha asking about her grandfather's wish, Magnifico not freaking out, but instead expositioning how a greedy wish destroyed his village. Have her disillusioned without going super villain, have her sing her song. Have the star come down, and have Magnifico freak out and start his decent to evil from there. And yes, "you can't really take away someone's wish" makes a lot more sense of a theme than "we're all made of stars"

5:57 What's worse in this case is that Asha says "People of Rosas are good" but girl, have you forgotten that not all the people are from Rosas or were born in Rosas? most of them are immigrants from far away lands who might not always have good intentions or wishes

13:56 *Kick back intensifies*

the Once Upon A Studio short did a way better job of commemorating 100 years of Disney than this

If Asha says that all wishes must be granted, then I wish Disney be back to the way it used to be before in the past.

why did 10:52 unironically make me burst out laughing😭the way she SHOVES the shelf down

you know this is gonna be good when there's already 144 sins and i'm only 7:33 seconds in

DnD reference was top tier

Me and my sister could NOT WAIT for this episode, so we did it at home! We got 185

18:25 This whole recap was better than the entire movie.

15:15 put your fucking back into it, star thing

Why could I not stop thinking about Wonder Woman 1984 and the patent stupidity of granting all wishes. Just show her one vile, selfish, greedy, hurtful, foolish wish ... then reveal that most of the wishes he's got caged up in the musty old wish attic look like a 15 year old's browser history. Walk her down to the basement full of the skulls and broken toys of villainous wishers that almost got what they wanted. Show her that deciding this sort of thing is a burden. Hell, he could reveal that he actually has granted all of the good, loving and selfless wishes and only captured and held the wicked ones.

8:31, exactly. If it were otherwise then they should have at least given some indication that Magnifico specifically required them to give up their wishes instead of seemingly giving them up out of their own volition

8:56 I love that song btw.

6:38 10/10 would recommend 8:19 Thank you for pointing this out. My older sister is convinced Magnifico is still evil. When I pointed out the fact that Asha was Breaking and Entering/Stealing she said that they didn't belong to him. She ignored me when I said if there gifted they legally belong to him :/

We couldn't have love story with a star boy😭😭WE WERE ROBBED😭😭

“Throw Caution to every warning sign” The phrase is “throw caution to the wind” throwing caution to a warning sign implies that you’re being cautious when you see the warning sign. The exact opposite of the original phrase - Schafrillas

For some reason this was way funnier to me than it should 9:20

That Bambi and Little John name drop reference was SO CRINGY

8:46 THANK YOU! that is the best line!

“This reads like a recipe book for the foul and the savage.” Handbook for Disney execs makes it into the script (Sin!)

11:33 no you didn't? As far as we know he did it himself.

Fans: There's no way Disney can get worse than it has in the last decade. Disney: Hold my beer. Watch this!

The saddest part is. This could have been a good concept for a movie for a grey area for morals Sorcerer Tyrant who takes power from the Wishes, and only grants a select few that won't disrupt anything. But keeping people compliant since if they misbehave they never get their wish. And defeating him, could be a peaceful revolution of no longer giving the wishes to him so he loses his powers. And instead of relying on some other figure to grant the wish, they take it on themselves to make their dreams reality. Instead.... its this, which doesn't even know what its own moral is

There is a good reason why granting all wishes without knowing the consequences they would result is a terrible idea. Remember Wishmaster films?

Am i tripping or is 6:51 just a sing frim tangled reskinned (i know disney does this to skip corners but god damn cant help but feel angry)

I like how they show other disney characters in the credits like "dont you wish you'd watched these movies instead?"

Gets sneezed on. Wipes hand on clothes, both spreading germs and covering hands in dust/fuzz. Then uses same hand to eat another cookie.

Surprised this video didn't go on forever.

If you don’t mind me idea dumping: -Asha’s wish is to bring her father back, and Magnifico doesn’t grant it because he doesn’t want to upset the balance of the universe -Instead of bees, the book is guarded by a spell that manifests a character’s trauma -It shows Asha a vision of her father, which flows into her and Magnifico’s conversation about him, and later Magnifico his village when he goes to retrieve it -Amaya makes a wish for Magnifico to be saved from the book’s influence

7:26 in all fairness about the nuke or supernova it is mideval times

100 sins for when that deer says “Watch out world, here I are!” in the “I’m a Star” song.

I will ALWAYS be frustrated with the potential of this movie. You can see the ghost of what this movie tried and failed to be. Julia Michaels talked about the direction she was given for the songs in this movie during her songwriters round table; and it was SO VAGUE. She wrote pretty good songs, but she literally didn't know what the plot of the movie was. And obviously the writers didn't know either.

When I saw the title all I thought of was one word EVERYTHING

15:23 look at his face he is evil change my mind

Man, I miss hand-drawn animation.

The songs in this movie are so bland and forgettable, even Phineas and Ferb had better and memorable original songs than this movie especially coming from Doofenshmirtz. Doofenshmirtz telling his backstory through songs way better than whoever this movie's villain did 😂

It's a nice tribute towards Disney's history but definitely needed more

17:41 that would be dreamworks’ 100 anniversary

17:09 so no one's going to notice Disney buried the Sorcerer inside the staff with the not-so-subliminal image of the face from the Magic Mirror in Snow White? So the Queen is really the Evil Queen of the same movie?! I have so many more questions. Damn you CinemaSins!!

Huh. I'm surprised this video isn't the entire length of the movie itself

Why was Simon the only one who got depressed after giving up his wish? Everyone else seamed fine

16:08 immediately thought the same thing