EXO 2024 Fan Meet: Epic B-Side Medley Reaction! 🎤🔥 - KPop On Lock S3E11 

To be fair, because you're not so familiar with each EXO voices compared to us fans who can distinguished who's singing which part even to the tiniest and deepest of their vocal layering, it's easy for you to get confused especially between Suho and Chen's voices because their tone is similar. However, EXO sings live and great at it too. You can tell there's a very minimal backtrack, I'm no expert but I guess that is used also to guide the singers since live performances are prone to unforeseeable conditions plus some background adlibs from the non present members. Going back to this particular performance, as others have said, Chen was miming while vibing to Suho's part when the camera focused on him. Ironically enough because the very guy you pointed out/suspected of lipsyncing is known for stopping mid performance when a pre recording is playing in the background. A recent technical glitch happened while he was performing in Indonesia very recently, so the staff played a pre recording only for him to stop at the start when he realised there was a problem and when they couldn't fix it, he decided to sing the song in acapella. He even sings live during his MV shoot. Also, few hours before this very fan meeting, I watched Baekhyun live and witnessed his soundcheck in thw Philippines and I can 💯% tell you guys they're even more amazing live👌 Thank you for your EXO reactions and cheers for more!

It's not his (CHEN) part, it was SUHO who is singing at 11:24 and he (CHEN) is just singing along. I mean how can you question their live performance? That's insane! Yes, there's a backtrack but it's so minimal that you can barely hear it. Well, I can't blame you guys if you think that it's pre-recorded because their live performances are too perfect something that I can be proud of as an EXO-L. I can recognize their voices even if I close my eyes. Overall, I do appreciate your reaction to EXO. Thank you. 😊

That is Suho singing while the camera focuses on Chen. You cannot question EXO's vocals esp their live vocals.😊❤

EXO performances are 100% live✨ that's why I'm so proud to be an Exo-L 🙃🔥

Beakhyun lost a game and he could pick someone to wear it with him. He chose D.O. Beakhyun was also real sick but he still put on a show.

Don't be so shocked to witness they look so relaxed in singing. They're THAT GOOD. Even the knetz acknowledge them as great vocalists. Most of the people even loves the live versions more than the recorded one. And they're one (if not the only) of the group that uploaded the concert version of their songs on spotify. And that says a lot. Also these guys, even if they're known as the kpop vocal kings already are still going to a lot of vocal lessons. That's our pride. We can never feel ashamed of their vocals skills bcoz we know they never disappoint. Sorry if a lot of us are like coming at you guys, we just always got so worked up whenever people doubt their live singing lmao

OMG! You guys have been watching and reacting to exo for a while. You should’ve known these guys dont lipsync. This is definitely live. You didnt catch the part where suho missed the beat for “forever”. He started a little early. And chanyeol looked at him. Watch them more. You’ll be able to distinguish their voices. It was suho singing that part. Chen was having so much fun. He was singing along with him.

Actually a lot of time during the performance, camera was pointed to the other member when someone else is singing... That's why you were so confused

For your question about fan meets, they are extremely varied but generally between 1-2 hrs long. EXO did 2 sessions (a little bit different for each show) that day and it was to celebrate 12 years since their debut. Individual idols will hold fan meets and so will groups, often around birthdays or debut dates as a celebration with fans. Music is often not the main part of a fan meet; it will be included to varying degress but fan meets are often like a variety show or party or pretty much whatever the idols and the fans would like. The boys made this medley at fans' request. Many beloved b-sides have rarely ever been done live before just because EXO has such a big discography. The Killing Voice they did was so short and many fans asked for more and EXO delivered. Many of these b-sides are very well known but ones like Butterfly Effect have only been included in like one concert. Pretty much the best gift they could give fans is live singing and they know that.

Excuse me is not pre recorded He singing along with suho 😅 This one is pure vocal live 100%

Touch It was written by CHEN. Gravity and Heaven was written by Chanyeol. Multi talented kings👑!

Chen @ 12:12 ( that member that you think lipsyncing) love that part of Suho so his singing along while suho was singing😌

It’s a sold out Fanmeet and they didnt LIPSync its Live Vocal they look relaxed becoz its a fanmeet not a concert and they dont have to do Hardcore choreography.After this they had some games and cute interactions with fans. Please check out EXO is Family part 1 & EXOL is EXO’s Family part 2 by exoxouniverse ❤. It is little bit sad but you can see the members brotherhood and their care for each other❤

You should watch full fancam of all the members in one video, if you're going to question their live vocals. In fancam, you can see who is singing and even doing harmonies with each other.

My Exo is complete. They have excellent music, they are very talented their visuals are insane, and their voices heavenly they also have charming personalities, are original, and funny, I always watch them mesmerize. I love to watch more Exo Reactions. Thanks! 12 years of discography baby lots of albums to explore their b sides are soothing 😌

It's Exo so It's live ... That's Easy ❤😂

It was suho's part and that's why chen was singing aling without mic. If you notice the voice is not of chen's but of suho's. Just that chen's face was shown on the screen

Chen was only vibing it's not his part,but the camera love him sooooo

Just like Lay explained in his latest show. Every member should know the song by heart. Even if it is not their part, they can sing along and for the major reason that if something happen to any member, someone or anyone from the group can fill in.

Baekhyunie & D.O wear crocodile costumes because of the penalties of the games.its live performance.when Chen singing without microphone he just singing along because the song line not his singing part.exo members like to singing along even not their part to singing. That's not pre records for sure. Thank you for your reaction❤❤❤

Fan meetings are very different compared to concerts. Its more for the fans and are typically more casual and intimate. It tends to have more talking, answering fan questions, fan interaction and playing games which you don’t get in concerts. They also tend to only sing a few songs as its not a concert. This fan meeting had the most songs compared to past fan meetings. My guess is that fans requested for Exo to have a second part to their Killing Voice as it was quite short hence the medley. Its more fan-centered event rather than performance-centered. If they do dance its only for a few songs. It isn’t supposed to be a very high energy setting although it could be, but its more of a yearly get-together with the fans.

@12:12 Chen was just singing along. if it's his part, you would definitely hear him singing. probably the one you're hearing is a back track/ background vocals. technically, fan meetings are more relaxed than full concerts. it's more interaction w/ the fans. like this performance, it's their version of Killing Voice. since a lot of fans requested to hear more songs. they didn't really prepared any choreography since all of them are in between their individual schedules. i also think since their main dancers (Kai & Sehun) are not there, it feels incomplete without them. just an example, Baekhyun just came back from his concert tour in Manila the day of this fan meeting. he even said that he has to sleep in a hotel near the venue & even taken meds because he's not feeling well same w/ Suho. & they have to do this show twice. this video was part of the 1st show. they did the title tracks on the 2nd show. on the 2nd show, they lost the game & their penalty is to wear panda suit. Sehun & Kai was watching this fan meeting with the fans. they were seated with the audience.

That was not Chen's part, he was just singing along.

Yes,they also did a killing voice version wearing panda suits.❤

Don't worry it's Live. On 11.24 when the camera in Chen, it was Suho who sing. In their EXO vlog also mentioned, what is Lipsync? 😁 Slowly both of you will know EXO members vocals tone.

Thank you for your reactions to EXO. I just wanted to mention that the reason why you may think that there is not that many people is because the camera focuses on just a small section of the arena. Also, many fans tend to hold their light sticks lower as to not block other fans and also put them down sometimes as you do get tired of holding it up. If you want to really hear the fan chants, you should check out the fan cams as they do seem to filter the fans out in official videos. Probably because they would drown out the group’s voices. In regards to their live performances, you are not the first ones to question them, for years many fans of other groups have made it their mission to try and discredit them as it is impossible for them to understand how EXO can have such amazing live vocals. I hope you can continue to learn more about EXO and check out more of their live performances so you can decide for yourselves. I will definitely keep watching your reactions 😊

EXO's best live concert performance, best singer, beautiful harmony, beautiful voice 👍👑

Whenever you have doubts about whether it is pre-recorded or live, go to d.o., d.o. parts. He is always the member who exposes EXO's live vocals, since he always adds his style and makes it clear that they are singing live. For example adding adlibs, growls,etc

It’s great to see them post their live video. Its been a very long long time to see them live. Cuz right now they’re still on hiatus and Kai sehun are still in military 😭 Also their live is always crazy not gonna lie.

Before *"White noise"* it was *"24/7"* the live performance in Japan is 🔥

It's live! Suho made a mistake at 11.06 and Chanyeol swung his head around quickly in surprise to look at Suho.

Maybe because you can't differentiate the voices of each exo member, it's okay if there is a little misunderstanding, hopefully in the future you will get to know more about exo. Even I, who have known Exo for 9 years, still often think they lip sync😂 because Exo's vocals are that good, even their live singing is better than the recorded version. Sometimes if I want to see if it's lipsync or not, I look at the fancam version to compare. Thank you for reacting to Exo's video and looking forward to Exo's next video🤗

You don't know how many grps were criticized after this live performance 😂 ppl started comparing , then you came to say it's lypsinc 😭 man even the Ad-libs are live just see the interaction with the crowd

Part Forever is not really Chen's part, but it is another member's part, namely Suho 😄🙏

It's REALLY HURTS AS AN EXOL WHEN PEOPLE TALKS EXO ABOUT THEIR VOCALS(pre recorded,lipsync?😢

The cameraman never work in a concert before or something. They just zoomed at random people who didn't even sing that part, Really could've just pan to more than one member or the whole group 😂😂

Thanks for the reaction!!!! EXO live is always amazing!!!!

Thanks for your reaction. EXO singing ability is too good. They put high standart of singing since 1st day of their career. EXO is perfect in live performance that makes you think that they do lipsync.

Check out their MV's "Let me In" & "Hear Me out". Both are from their latest album Exist.

It's hard to go through in this reaction when they said it's pre recorded,As an EXO L you can definitely tell it's not CHENs part.

I just hope they give Baekhyun a little line, just feel sorry for him with his Asian solo tour of more than 20 countries for his live solo concerts. He just come straight from his concert to this Fan Meeting.

Always here for my EXO ❤

The camera was focusing on one of the guys who was singing along without a mic but the voice actually belongs to someone else, so the camera was focusing on someone else. You’d only recognise it if you’re familiar with their individual voices

Exo live vocal to good so other people say their lipsing😅❤

You forgot that there’s a lot of members. Camera can focus on other members while other members are singing. You did not consider that? And just concluded that it was lipsync? Lol

Lol. EXO lipsyncing is as rare as seeing a white hawk. Camera just focused on another member while the other one was singing.

At minute 11:25 they are recording Chen, but the ones who sing are Suho and D.O, they are singing even though the one who is singing is pointing to someone else...

masih ada aja yang ngira lipsync saking bagusnya,, too perfect sih, sungguh sangat menyayangkan selama ini nge-react kalau masih meragukan vocalnya,, hmmn

EXO really good live voice❤❤ Suho in forever song bit krekk😂😂😂❤❤❤❤

Kamu tau cerita tentang EXO yang dimarahin fandom lain karna terlalu sering tampil live vocal dengan sangat sempurna...?? karna membuat group lain jadi tidak terlihat bagus...😂😂😂

D.O my fave ~ unbothered king😅 Please check he's acting compilations here on youtube🎉

Yeahhh Chanyeol vocal is too good as a rapper

Happy SUHO Day🎉❤!

Thank you …. .

King❤EXO❤

Not prerecorded, he was just singing along, the fault was on the camera man for focusing on the wrong person during singing.

You guys have watched enough EXO live stages to know that they don't need to lip sync 😂

I will not be stanning these guys if they lipsync to their own concert or fanmeeting tbh😂 i stan groups w no heavy backtracks and clear vocals like EXO, BTOB, etc. Im not saying they never lipsync bc its kinda normal for kpop group lipsyncs in like music shows due to heavy performances. But exo is one of a kind group that tried their best to deliver live performances for their fans. ❤

Certain countries have different concert manners (like South Korea or especially Japan), and they typically won't sing or even yell unless they're told to. An exception is the fanchants that go along with the song, BUT not all songs have them! Title track songs usually have them, but not every B-side does~~~ Hence, why this crowd seems quiet, at parts^.^

Don't make a mistake. The part where Chen sang with the microphone apart was Suho's part.

EXO is the king of vocals .. its obviously its all live there's no lipsinc here ..

Do react for exo medley in second part of fanmeet too.. Pliiisssss😊❤❤❤

EXO= VOCAL KINGS 💜💜💜

Check out iu palette, where kuungsoo(D.O.) sings love wins all feat iu live Also check him out on seasons singing spot with zico(jeannie part). Check him on season singing rewrite the stars with akmu. Did u check abt time from his latest album blossom? All his bsides from all his solos albums are good. Give it a try Recommendation-abt time Ordinary days Lost, there are 2 versions

Bサイドメドレーの反応ありがとうございます😊少しづつでもいいですのでEXOの反応をしてくださいね♪待っていますよ❤❤❤

Its Suho s part. Its not pre recorded.excuse me. Its LIVE...

I can't blame you guys tho EXO live vocals are THAT GOOD also chen and suho vocal colors are almost the same

I'm 1 minute in and already have something to say lol. all the fans have their lightsticks there it seem less because of the color changing thingie going on. this fanmeet was in Inspire arena that has 16k people capacity if I remember correctly, and they had two shows in one day. anyway I'll go watch the rest of the reaction now 😅

Each of the Exo boys "represents an animal, for example Chen is the dinosaur, although here Baekhyun loses a game and has to choose another one to penalize them and disguise himself and chooses D.O...

EXO =- VOCAL KINGS 🔥

When camera focus on chen, it was part of suho not chen. But i don't know why the camera still focus on chen instead of suho. Maybe the cameramen love chen so much Exo live performance it's really amazing you should attend to exo concert and feels the atmosphere how amazing exo performance live.

around 8:40 about the crowd. that's the footage from Beyond Live. there, for better experience of ones that are watching concerts from home the crowd sounds are reduced so we can hear artists properly. I'm seeing you also reacted to the fancam of second show with title songs so you probably saw the difference of the sound already

Oh you guys will never catch Thee EXO lipsyncing 😭😭 cause the member themself will complaint right away on the stage if they hear AR (all-recorded) and not MR (music-only-recorded) version while performing those songs.

Pleeeease react to Barkhyun’s solo like called Lonsdaleite😭 He is doing Asia tour right now. He is too good at breath control and dancing while singing really difficult songs😭😭😭!!

EXO FOREVER

In the second part they all used panda's costume because they all lost the game..

If D.O almost never looks directly at the camera, it will be because of his part as an actor or because he is also very shy...

Thanks guys 🥰, they are vocal kings for a reason. They do have Killing voice part 2 at the fan meeting 😮, it’s practically all the songs y’all have reacted to, sending the link. Hopefully y’all can do a part 2 of the fan meeting ♥️, please 🥰? ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-jYRE6RrRRgM.htmlsi=NbXAOmBpvJ44XkhI

THIS ISN'T PRE-RECORDED! EXO are excellent vocalists and sound even better LIVE that newer or casual listeners could mistakenly think they are doing lip sync.

Exo themselves said that the thing they hate the most is *NOT* singing live 😂

The camera showed CHEN, but it was SUHO who was singing.

Yesss EXO ❤❤❤

EXO eats CD’s for every meal! 😊😊

El problema fue que no enfocaron en el tiempo correcto desde el comienzo a cada miembro que cantaba, así que debe ser confuso reconocer sus voces hasta para las nuevas personas que están conociendo a Exo.

Forever that part was Suho sang at that time

I like you guys but to say there is not a lot of people in that full arena is ridiculous also they are singing live 100% thank you for your reaction ❤

El camarógrafo enfoca a Chen pero el que está cantando es Suho. Canción Forever. Minuto 7:57

I know its kinda hard for u guys to believe that this was live performance bc i am too. I've been stanning these guys since 2013 and i'm still shook eveytime they sing live bc they just get better and better. Btw, if u can maybe u can react to their acoustic medley in Seoul. For me, their Seoul concert got more good and clear vocals than Japan concert so u guys can see how relax they can be singing while doing all the harmonization ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-IgT_CxUuFK8.htmlfeature=shared

You should recognize their voice😅😅 we all know that who is singing and who is showing on screen cuz of camera angel 🤗😂😂

Its not lipsync.. they are just too good..

Just going thru some comments and i felt i should not continue watching. I was excited to watch but sorry. Thanks for the reaction anyway

they also did title song medley, can you do react to that??

Это не заранее записанная песня,просто в это время пел Сухо.

idk if you will read all this or not but i just want to explain something! they are using a low backing track in the background that they are singing over, this is not new and most singers do this in their concerts. on 14:36 D.O. didn’t use the mic and we hear the low backing track with his voice play, then on 14:41 we see him placing the mic up to his mouth again at the end there and actually sings. note the difference, his actual live vocals are much louder than the backing track. the part where you said some parts sound "too perfect" may be because you hear the backing track come through. however, the part at 11:23 is just Chen vibing and mouthing the lyrics to Suho’s part, so no that’s not his voice and it’s not the same thing D.O. did. in my opinion the cameraman should’ve filmed Suho there and not Chen, cause i get how that became confusing 😭 in conclusion, no this is not a pre-recorded performance! hope this made sense LOL i just wanted to help and let you guys know 😄💓 thank you for your reaction, this performance always gets meeeeeee!! 🙌

😅 it was suho singing not chen , he was just having fan ❤

Saya bisa membedakan suara mereka bahkan dengan memejamkan mata.

Hi again Ku and Aus. What's up. I think it's a bit hot here ehehee... it's okay

It's until you guys know how to differentiate their voces, of the members precisely Chen and Suho are the ones whose voice tones are most similar. At first it was difficult to differentiate them, but. Over time both have developed their singing styles and it is easy to know which is which.

Itu part nya suho..chen hanya meniru. Suara suho memang hampir sama dengan chen. Lebih baik kalian kenali dulu suara setiap members exo.. karena exol akan tau setiap suara members exo yang bernyanyi tanpa harus di liat. Tak kenal maka tak sayang....

12:12ไม่ใช่ท่อนของ chen